Genetic fallout in bio-cultural landscapes: Molecular imperialism and the cultural politics of (not) seeing transgenes in Mexico

Social Studies of Science

Volumn 44, Issue 6, 2014, Pages 901-929

  Bonneuil, Christophe ^a   Foyer, Jean ^b   Wynne, Brian ^c  

^a CNRS   (France)

^b SORBONNE UNIVERSITÉ   (France)

^c LANCASTER UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

co production; epistemic cultures; genetically modified organisms; laboratory field relations; legibility illegibility; maize biocultures; Mexico s indigenous landraces; normalization

Indexed keywords

CULTURAL ANTHROPOLOGY; GENE FLOW; GENETICS; MAIZE; MEXICO; POLITICS; TRANSGENE; TRANSGENIC PLANT;

CULTURE; GENE FLOW; MEXICO; PLANTS, GENETICALLY MODIFIED; POLITICS; TRANSGENES; ZEA MAYS;

EID: 84911909811     PISSN: 03063127     EISSN: 14603659     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0306312714548258     Document Type: Article

References (75)

1. Alvarez-Morales A.Transgenes in maize landraces in Oaxaca: Official report on the extent and implications.The 7th international symposium on the biosafety of genetically modified organisms; 2002ISBGMO, Beijing, China; 2002. 78.
2. Aquino P,Carrión F,Calvo R,Flores DCIMMYT 1999–2000 World Maize Facts and Trends. Meeting World Maize Needs: Technological Opportunities and Priorities for the Public Sector. Pingali P, ed. Mexico City: CIMMYT; 2001:45-57.
3. Bellon MR.The dynamics of crop infraspecific diversity: A conceptual framework at the farmer level.Economic Botany. 1996;50 (1): 26-39
4. Bellon MR,Berthaud J.Transgenic maize and the evolution of landrace diversity in Mexico: The importance of farmers’ behavior.Plant Physiology. 2004;134 (3): 883-888
5. Bonneuil C.Cultures épistémiques et engagement des chercheurs dans la controverse OGM.Natures Sciences Société. 2006;14 (3): 257-268
6. Bonneuil CHeredity Explored: Between Public Domain and Experimental Science, 1850–1930. Brandt CMüller-Wille SRheinberger H-J, ed. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press; in press:
7. Bonneuil C,Fenzi M.Des ressources génétiques à la biodiversité cultivée. La carrière d’un problème public mondial (An English version of this article is available from the authors).Revue d’Anthropologie des Connaissances. 2011;5 (2): 206-233
8. Böschen S.Hybrid regimes of knowledge? Challenges for constructing scientific evidence in the context of the GMO Debate.Environmental Science and Pollution Research International. 2009;16 (5): 508-520
9. Böschen S,Kastenhofer K,Marschall L,Rust I,Soentgen J,Wehling P.Scientific cultures of non-knowledge in the controversy over Genetically Modified Organisms (GMO): The cases of molecular biology and ecology.GAIA – Ecological Perspectives for Science and Society. 2006;15 (4): 294-301
10. Genes in the Field: On-Farm Conservation of Crop Diversity. Brush SB, ed. Rome: IPGRI-IDRC; 2000:
11. Busch LStandards: Recipes for Reality. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press; 2011:
12. Callon M,Lascoumes P,Barthe YActing in an Uncertain World: An Essay on Technical Democracy. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press; 2009:
13. CECCAM, CENAMI, Grupo ETC, CASIFOP, UNOSJO and AJAGI (2003) La contaminación transgénica del maíz campesino en México. Article by the Documento colectivo de comunidades indígenas y campesinas de Oaxaca, Puebla, Chihuahua, Veracruz. Available at: http://www.biodiversidadla.org/layout/set/print/Principal/Secciones/Documentos/Transgenicos/La_contaminacion_transgenica_del_maiz_campesino_en_Mexico (accessed on 15 September 2014).
14. Christou P.No Credible Scientific Evidence is Presented to Support Claims that Transgenic DNA was Introgressed into Traditional Maize Landraces in Oaxaca, Mexico.Transgenic Research. 2002; (11): iii-v
15. Cleveland DA,Soleri D,Aragón-Cuevas F,Crossa J,Gepts P.Detecting (trans)gene flow to landraces in centers of crop origin: Lessons from the case of maize in Mexico.Environmental Biosafety Research. 2005;4 (4): 197-208
16. Comisión Intersecretarial de Bioseguridad de los Organismos Genéticamente Modificados (CIBIOGEM) (2004) Reporte técnico acerca de la presencia de maíz transgénico en México. Unpublished official document by CIBIOGEM, Mexico.
17. Cotter JTroubled Harvest: Agronomy and Revolution in Mexico, 1880–2002. Westport, CT: Praeger; 2003:
18. Dalton R.Modified genes spread to local maize.Nature. 2008;456 (7219): 149
19. Delborne JA.Transgenes and transgressions: Scientific dissent as heterogeneous practice.Social Studies of Science. 2008;38 (4): 509-541
20. Delborne JA.Constructing audiences in scientific controversy.Social Epistemology. 2011;25 (1): 67-95
21. Doebley J.Molecular evidence for gene flow among Zea species.BioScience. 1990;40 (6): 443-448
22. Dyer GA,Taylor JE.A crop population perspective on maize seed systems in Mexico.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 2008;105 (2): 470-475
23. Dyer GA,Serratos-Hernández JA,Hugo Perales R,Gepts P,Piñeyro-Nelson A,Chávez A, et al.Dispersal of transgenes through maize seed systems in Mexico.PLoS One. 2009;4 (5): e5734
24. Ezcurra E,Ortiz-García S,Soberón Mainero J.Evidence of gene flow from transgenic maize to local varieties in Mexico.LMOs and the environment: Proceedings of an international conference; 2002Raleigh-Durham, NC; 2002. 289.
25. Fagan J,Schoel B,Haegert A,Moore J,Beeby J.Performance assessment under field conditions of a rapid immunological test for transgenic soybeans.International Journal of Food Science and Technology. 2001;36 (4): 357-367
26. Fitting EThe Struggle for Maize: Campesinos, Workers, and Transgenic Corn in the Mexican Countryside. Durham, NC and London: Duke University Press; 2011:
27. Fox-Keller EThe Century of the Gene. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press; 2000:
28. Foyer JIl Était une Fois la Bio-Révolution: Nature et Savoirs dans la Modernité Globale. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France; 2010:
29. Agroecosistemas de México. Hernández Xolocotzi E, ed. Chapingo, Mexico: Colegio de Postgraduados, Universidad Autónama Chapingo; 1977:
30. Herrera LA,Joffrey GA,Álvarez MA,Huerta E,Arriaga L,Soberón J, et alPrimer informe sobre el análisis de la presencia de máiz transgénico en Oaxaca y Puebla. Report for the Secretaría de Agricultura. Mexico: Ganadería, Desarrollo Rural, Pesca y Ailmentación/Dirección General de Sanidad Vegetal/Comité Intersecretarial de Bioseguridad de Organismos Genéticamente modificados; 2002:
31. Hugo Perales R,Brush SB,Qualset CO.Dynamic management of maize landraces in central Mexico.Economic Botany. 2003;57 (1): 21-34
32. States of Knowledge: The Co-Production of Science and Social Order. Jasanoff S, ed. London and New York: Routledge; 2004:
33. Jasanoff S.Biotechnology and empire: The global power of seeds and science.Osiris. 2006;21:273-293
34. Jasanoff S.Constitutional Moments in Governing Science and Technology.Science and Engineering Ethics. 2011;17 (4): 621-638
35. Kaiser J.Calming fears, no foreign genes found in Mexican maize.Science. 2005 1000;309 (5737):
36. Kaplinsky N,Braun D,Lisch D,Hay A,Hake S,Freeling M.Biodiversity (Communications arising): Maize transgene results in Mexico are artefacts.Nature. 2002;416 (6881): 601-602
37. Kinchy ASeeds, Science, and Struggle: The Global Politics of Transgenic Crops. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press; 2012:
38. Kleinman DL,Suryanarayanan S.Dying bees and the social production of ignorance.Science, Technology & Human Values. 2013;38 (4): 492-517
39. Knorr-Cetina KEpistemic Cultures: How the Sciences Make Knowledge. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press; 1999:
40. Landavazo Gamboa DA,Guadalupe Calvillo Alba K,Espinosa Huerta E,González Morelos L,Aragón-Cuevas F,Torres Pacheco I, et al.Caracterización molecular y biológica de genes recombinantes en maíz criollo de Oaxaca.Agricultura Técnica en México. 2006;32 (3): 267-279
41. Latour B.The ‘pedofil’ of Boa Vista: A photo-philosophical montage.Common Knowledge. 1995;4 (1): 144-187
42. LezaunJ (2003) Policing purity: Testing, traceability, and the governance of genetically modified organisms. PhD Thesis, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY.
43. MacKenzie A,Waterton C,Ellis R,Frow EK,McNally R,Busch L, et al.Classifying, constructing, and identifying life: Standards as transformations of ‘the biological.Science, Technology & Human Values. 2013;38 (5): 701-722
44. Marris E.Four years on, no transgenes found in Mexican Maize.Nature. 2005;436 (7052): 760
45. Martinez-Soriano JPR,Leal-Klevezas DS.Transgenic maize in Mexico: No need for concern.Science. 2000;287 (5457): 1399
46. Matsuoka T,Kuribara H,Takubo K,Akiyama H,Miura H,Goda Y, et al.Detection of recombinant DNA segments introduced to genetically modified maize (Zea mays).Journal of Agriculture and Food Chemistry. 2002;50 (7): 2100-2109
47. Environmental Effects of Transgenic Plants: The Scope and Adequacy of Regulation. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press; 2002:
48. O’Connell J.Metrology: The creation of universality by the circulation of particulars.Social Studies of Science. 1993;23 (1): 129-173
49. Ortega-PaczkaRA (1973) Variación en maíz y cambios socioeconómicos en Chiapas, Méx. 1946–1971. MS Thesis, Universidad Autónama Chapingo, Colegio de Postgraduados, Chapingo, Mexico.
50. Ortiz-García S,Ezcurra E,Schoel B,Acevedo F,Soberón J,Snow AA.Absence of detectable transgenes in local landraces of maize in Oaxaca, Mexico (2003–2004).Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 2005;102 (35): 12338-12343
51. Piñeyro-Nelson A,Van Heerwaarden J,Hugo Perales R,Serratos-Hernández JA,Rangel A,Hufford MB, et al.Resolution of the Mexican transgene detection controversy: Error sources and scientific practice in commercial and ecological contexts.Molecular Ecology. 2009a;18 (20): 4145-4150
52. Piñeyro-Nelson A,Van Heerwaarden J,Perales R,Serratos-Hernández JA,Rangel A,Hufford MB, et al.Transgenes in Mexican maize: Molecular evidence and methodological considerations for GMO detection in landrace populations.Molecular Ecology. 2009b;18 (4): 750-761
53. PrakashCS (2005) Duh … No GM genes in Mexican Corn. AgBioWorld Newsletter. Available at: http://www.agbioworld.org/newsletter_wm/index.php?caseid=archive&newsid=2398 (accessed 20 October 2011).
54. Pressoir G,Berthaud J.Population structure and strong divergent selection shape phenotypic diversification in Maize landraces.Heredity. 2004;92 (2): 95-101
55. Agnotology: The Making and Unmaking of Ignorance. Proctor RNSchiebinger L, ed. Palo Alto, CA: Stanford University Press; 2008:
56. Quist D,Chapela IH.Transgenic DNA introgressed into traditional maize landraces in Oaxaca, Mexico.Nature. 2001;414 (6863): 541-543
57. Rabinow PMaking PCR: A Story of Biotechnology. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press; 1996:
58. Schoel B,Fagan J.Insufficient evidence for the discovery of transgenes in Mexican Landraces.Molecular Ecology. 2009;18 (20): 4143-4144
59. Scott JCDomination and the Arts of Resistance: Hidden Transcripts. New Haven CT: Yale University Press; 1990:
60. Scott JCSeeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press; 1998:
61. Scott JCThe Art of Not Being Governed: An Anarchist History of Upland Southeast Asia. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press; 2009:
62. Maize and Biodiversity: The Effects of Transgenic Maize in Mexico. Montréal, QC, Canada: Report for the CEC; 2004:
63. Serratos JA,Gómez-Olivares J-L,Salinas-Arreortua N,Buendía-Rodríguez E,Islas-Gutiérrez F,de-Ita A.Transgenic proteins in maize in the soil conservation area of federal district, Mexico.Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment. 2007;5 (5): 247-252
64. Taller de maíz transgénico.Proceedings from meeting with the North American Plant Protection Organization (NAPPO), General Directorate on Plant Health (DGSV) and Comité Nacional de Bioseguridad Agrícola CNBA; 2000Mexico; 2000.
65. Gene flow among maize landraces, improved maize and teosinte: Implications for transgenic maize.Proceedings from the International Maize and Wheat Improvement Centre (CIMMYT) forum; 1997El Batan, Mexico; 1997.
66. Shapin SL.The invisible technician.American Scientist. 1989;77 (6): 554-563
67. Star SA Sociology of Monsters: Essays on Power, Technology, and Domination. Law J, ed. London: Routledge; 1991:26-56.
68. Van der Ploeg JDAnthropological Critique of Development: The Generation of Ignorance. Hobart M, ed. London: Routledge; 1993:177-234.
69. Van Heerwaarden J,Ortega del Vecchyo D,Alvarez-Buylla E,Bellon MR.New genes in traditional seed systems: Diffusion, detectability and persistence of transgenes in a maize metapopulation.PLos One. 2012;7 (10): e46123
70. Wainwright J,Mercer KLGlobal Political Ecology. Peet RRobbins PWatts MJ, ed. London and New York: Routledge; 2011:412-430.
71. Walbot V.Maize genome in motion.Genome Biology. 2008;9 (4): 303.1 303
72. Wynne BEnvironmental Threats: Analysis, Perception, Management. Brown J, ed. London: Frances Pinter; 1989:33-47.
73. Wynne B.Uncertainty and environmental learning: Reconceiving science and policy in the preventive paradigm.Global Environmental Change. 1992;2 (2): 111-127
74. Wynne BRisk, Environment and Modernity: Towards a New Ecology. Lash SSzerszynski BWynne B, ed. London and Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE; 1996:44-83.
75. Wynne B.Creating public alienation: Expert cultures of risk and ethics on GMOs.Science as Culture. 2001;10 (4): 445-481