The Durban World Congress Ethics Round Table Conference Report: I. Differences between withholding and withdrawing life-sustaining treatments

Journal of Critical Care

Volumn 29, Issue 6, 2014, Pages 890-895

  Sprung, Charles L ^a   Paruk, Fathima ^b   Kissoon, Niranjan ^c   Hartog, Christiane S ^d   Lipman, Jeffrey ^e   Du, Bin ^f   Argent, Andrew ^g   Hodgson, R Eric ^h   Guidet, Bertrand ⁱ   Groeneveld, A B Johan ^j   Feldman, Charles ^b  

^a HADASSAH HEBREW UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER   (Israel)

^b UNIVERSITY OF THE WITWATERSRAND   (South Africa)

^c UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA   (Canada)

^d Center for Sepsis Control and Care   (Germany)

^e ROYAL BRISBANE AND WOMEN'S HOSPITAL   (Australia)

^f PEKING UNION MEDICAL COLLEGE HOSPITAL   (China)

^g RED CROSS WAR MEMORIAL CHILDREN S HOSPITAL   (South Africa)

^h UNIVERSITY OF KWAZULU NATAL   (South Africa)

ⁱ HÔPITAL SAINT ANTOINE   (France)

^j ERASMUS MEDICAL CENTER   (Netherlands)

more..

Author keywords

Ethics; Law; Life sustaining treatments; Withdrawing; Withholding

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; ARTIFICIAL VENTILATION; CONSENSUS DEVELOPMENT; HEALTH CARE ORGANIZATION; HEALTH CARE PRACTICE; HUMAN; LIFE SUSTAINING TREATMENT; MEDICAL ETHICS; MEDICOLEGAL ASPECT; MORALITY; PRACTICE GUIDELINE; TREATMENT WITHDRAWAL; BIOETHICS; ETHICS; HEALTH PERSONNEL ATTITUDE; INTENSIVE CARE; LONG TERM CARE; ORGANIZATION;

ATTITUDE OF HEALTH PERSONNEL; BIOETHICAL ISSUES; CONGRESSES AS TOPIC; CRITICAL CARE; HUMANS; INTENSIVE CARE; LIFE SUPPORT CARE; MORALS; RESPIRATION, ARTIFICIAL; WITHHOLDING TREATMENT;

EID: 84908142627     PISSN: 08839441     EISSN: 15578615     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jcrc.2014.06.022     Document Type: Article

References (81)

1. Sprung C.L., Eidelman L.A. Worldwide similarities and differences in the forgoing of life-sustaining treatments. Intensive Care Med 1996, 22:1003-1005.
2. Prendergast T.J., Claessens M.T., Luce J.M. A national survey of end-of-life care for critically ill patients. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1998, 158:1163-1167.
3. Eidelman L.A., Jakobson D.J., Pizov R., Geber D., Leibovitz L., Sprung C.L. Forgoing life-sustaining treatment in an Israeli ICU. Intensive Care Med 1998, 24:162-166.
4. Ferrand E., Robert R., Ingrand P., Lemaire F. Withdrawal of life support in intensive-care units in France: a prospective survey. Lancet 2001, 357:9-14. French LATAREA Group.
5. Esteban A., Gordo F., Solsona J.F., Alía I., Caballero J., Bouza C., et al. Withdrawing and withholding life support in the intensive care unit: a Spanish prospective multi-centre observational study. Intensive Care Med 2001, 27:1744-1749.
6. Sprung C.L., Cohen S.L., Sjokvist P., Baras M., Bulow H.H., Hovilehto S., et al. End-of-life practices in European Intensive Care Units. The Ethicus Study. JAMA 2003, 290:790-797.
7. Nolin T., Andersson R. Withdrawal of medical treatment in the ICU. A cohort study of 318 cases during 1994-2000. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 2003, 47:501-507.
8. Wunsch H., Harrison D.A., Harvey S., Rowan K. End-of-life decisions: a cohort study of the withdrawal of all active treatment in intensive care units in the United Kingdom. Intensive Care Med 2005, 31:823-831.
9. Yazigi A., Riachi M., Dabbar G. Withholding and withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment in a Lebanese intensive care unit: a prospective observational study. Intensive Care Med 2005, 31:562-567.
10. Lewis J.P., Ho K.M., Webb S.A. Outcome of patients who have therapy withheld or withdrawn in ICU. Anaesth Intensive Care 2007, 35:387-392.
11. Azoulay E., Metnitz B., Sprung C.L., Timsit J.F., Lemaire F., Bauer P., et al. End-of-life practices in 282 intensive care units: data from the SAPS 3 database. Intensive Care Med 2009, 35:623-630.
12. Turner J.S., Michell W.L., Morgan C.J., Benatar S.R. Limitation of life support: frequency and practice in a London and a Cape Town intensive care unit. Intensive Care Med 1996, 22:1020-1025.
13. Prendergast T.J., Luce J.M. Increasing incidence of withholding and withdrawal of life support from the critically ill. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1997, 155:15-20.
14. Van der Heide A., Deliens L., Faisst K., Nilstun T., Norup M., Paci E., et al. End-of-life decision-making in six European countries: descriptive study. Lancet 2003, 362:345-350.
15. Buckley T.A., Joynt G.M., Tan P.Y.H., Cheng C.A., Yap F.H. Limitation of life support: frequency and practice in a Hong Kong intensive care unit. Crit Care Med 2004, 32:415-420.
16. Mani R.J., Mandal A.K., Bal S., Javeri Y., Kumar R., Nama D.K., et al. End-of-life decisions in an Indian intensive care unit. Intensive Care Med 2009, 35:1713-1719.
17. Spronk P.E., Kuiper A.V., Rommes J.H., Korevaar J.C., Schultz M.J. The practice of and documentation on withholding and withdrawing life support: a retrospective study in two Dutch intensive care units. Anesth Analg 2009, 109:841-846.
18. Brieva J.L., Cooray P., Rowley M. Withholding and withdrawal of life-sustaining therapies in intensive care: an Australian experience. Crit Care Resusc 2009, 11:266-268.
19. Kranidiotis G., Gerovasili V., Tasoulis A., Tripodaki E., Vasileiadis I., Magira E., et al. End-of-life decisions in Greek intensive care units: a multicenter cohort study. Crit Care 2010, 14:R228.
20. Devictor D.J., Latour J.M., EURYDICE 11 study group Forgoing life support: how the decision is made in European pediatric intensive care units. Intensive Care Med 2011, 37:1881-1887.
21. Moore P., Kerridge I., Gillis J., Jacobe S., Isaacs D. Withdrawal and limitation of life-sustaining treatments in a paediatric intensive care unit and review of the literature. J Paediatr Child Health 2008, 44:404-408.
22. Albersheim S.G., Lavoie P.M., Keidar Y. Do neonatologists limit parental decision-making authority? A Canadian perspective. Early Hum Dev 2010, 86:801-805.
23. de Vos M.A., van der Heide A., Maurice-Stam H., Brouwer O.F., Plotz F.B., Schouten-van Meeteren A.Y.N., et al. The process of end-of-life decision-making in pediatrics: a national survey in the Netherlands. Pediatrics 2011, 127:e1004-e1012.
24. Lago P.M., Piva J., Garcia P.C., Troster E., Bousso A., Sarno M.O., et al. End-of-life practices in seven Brazilian pediatric intensive care units. Pediatr Crit Care Med 2008, 9:26-31.
25. Althabe M., Cardigni G., Vassallo J.C., Allende D., Berrueta M., Codermatz M., et al. Dying in the intensive care unit: collaborative multicenter study about forgoing life-sustaining treatment in Argentine pediatric intensive care units. Pediatr Crit Care Med 2003, 4:164-169.
26. Verhagen A.A.E., de Vos M., Dorscheidt J.H.H.M., Engels B., Hubben J.H., Sauer P.J. Conflicts about end-of-life decisions in NICUs in the Netherlands. Pediatrics 2009, 124:e112-e119.
27. Provoost V., Cools F., Bilsen J., Ramet J., Deconinck P., Vander Stichele R., et al. The use of drugs with a life-shortening effect in end-of-life care in neonates and infants. Intensive Care Med 2006, 32:133-139.
28. Burns J.P., Mitchell C., Outwater K.M., Geller M., Griffith J.L., Todres I.D., et al. End-of-life care in the pediatric intensive care unit after the forgoing of life-sustaining treatment. Crit Care Med 2000, 28:3060-3066.
29. Chaudhary R., Silwal A., Gupta A., Kelsall W. Drugs used for comfort care after withdrawal of intensive treatment in tertiary neonatal units in the UK. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 2012, 97:F487.
30. Lee K.J., Tieves K., Scanlon M.C. Alterations in end-of-life support in the pediatric intensive care unit. Pediatrics 2010, 126:e859.
31. Frost D.W., Cook D.J., Heyland D.K., Fowler R.A. Patient and healthcare professional factors influencing end-of-life decision-making during critical illness: a systematic review. Crit Care Med 2011, 39:1174-1189.
32. Nguyen Y.-L.C., Nguyen, Mayr F.B., Angus D.C. End-of-life care in the ICU: commonalities and differences between North America and Europe. Intensive Care Medicine Annual Update 2010, 560-568. Springer, New York. J.-L. Vincent (Ed.).
33. Wilson M.E., Rhudy L.M., Ballinger B.A., Tescher A.N., Pickering B.W., Gajic O. Factors that contribute to physician variability in decisions to limit life support in the ICU: a qualitative study. Intensive Care Med 2013, 39:1009-1018.
34. Wilkinson D.J.C., Truog R.D. The luck of the draw: physician-related variability in end-of-life decision-making in intensive care. Intensive Care Med 2013, 39:1128-1132.
35. Muni S., Engelberg R.A., Treece P.D., Dotolo D., Curtis J.R. The influence of race/ethnicity and socioeconomic status on end-of-life care in the ICU. Chest 2011, 139:1025-1033.
36. Bulow H.-H., Sprung C.L., Baras M., Carmel S., Svantesson M., Benbenishty J., et al. Are religion and religiosity important to end-of-life decisions and patient autonomy in the ICU? The Ethicatt Study. Intensive Care Med 2012, 38:1126-1133.
37. Ford D.W. Religion and end-of-life decisions in critical care: where the word meets deed. Intensive Care Med 2012, 38:1089-1091.
38. Weng L., Joynt G.M., Lee A., Du B., Leung P., Peng J., et al. Attitudes towards ethical problems in critical care medicine: the Chinese perspective. Intensive Care Med 2011, 37:655-664.
39. Kross E.K., Engelberg R.A., Downey L., Cuschieri J., Hallman M.R., Longstreth W.T., et al. Differences in end-of-life care in the ICU across patients cared for by medicine, surgery, neurology and neurosurgery physicians. Chest 2013, [Epub ahead of print]. 10.1378/chest.13-1351.
40. Statement on withholding and withdrawing treatment 2010, Australian and New Zealand Intensive Care Society, ABN: 16 134 292 103. ANZICS Website: www.anzics.com.au - last accessed 18 December 2013.
41. Valentin A., Druml W., Steltzer H., Wiedermann C.J. Recommendations on therapy limitation and therapy discontinuation in intensive care units: consensus paper of the Austrian Associations of Intensive Care Medicine. Intensive Care Med 2008, 34:771-776.
42. Janssens U., Burchardi H., Duttge G., Erchinger R., Gretenkort P., Mohr M., et al. Therapiezieländerung und Therapiebegrenzung in der Intensivmedizin. Positionspapier der Sektion Ethik der DIVI http://www.diviorg.de/fileadmin/pdfs/sektionen/Ethik/Positionspapier_Ethik_2012.pdf.
43. End-of-life care in der Intensivmedizin 2013, Springer, Berlin Heidelberg. A. Michalsen, C.S. Hartog (Eds.).
44. Ferdinande P., Berre J., Colardyn P., Damas P., de Marre F., Devlieger H., et al. End of life in intensive care [in French]. Reanimation 2001, 10:340-341.
45. Rocker G., Dunbar S. Withholding or withdrawal of life support: the Canadian Critical Care Society position paper. J Palliat Care 2000, 16:S53-S62. [Suppl].
46. Huang Y.C., Huang S.J., Ko W.J. Going home to die from surgical intensive care units. Intensive Care Med 2009, 35:810-815.
47. La loi dite loi Léonetti, N° 2005-370 du 22 avril 2005, relative aux droits des malades et à la fin de la vie http://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/affichTexte.do?cidTexte=JORFTEXT000000446240.
48. Withholding and withdrawing of life support in intensive care unit. Current recommendations of the Société de reanimation de Langue Française. Reanimation 2010, 19:679-698.
49. Steinberg A., Sprung C.L. The dying patient: new Israeli legislation. Intensive Care Med 2006, 32:1234-1237.
50. Ravitsky V. Timers on ventilators. BMJ 2005, 330:415-417.
51. Landman W.A. End-of-Life decisions, ethics and the law. A case for statutory legal clarity and reform in South Africa 2012, Globethics.net, Geneva, [Focus 9, (www.globethics.net-last accessed 7 January, 2014].
52. Clarke v Hurst NO and others (1992 (4) SA 630 (D).
53. Soobramoney v Minister of Health, Kwazulu-Natal 1998 (1) SA 765 (CC).
54. Bhagwanee S., Scribante J. National audit of critical care resources in South Africa-unit and bed distribution. South Afr Med J 2007, 97:1311-1314.
55. Scribante J., Bhagwanjee S. National audit of critical care resources in South Africa-open versus closed intensive and high care units. South Afr Med J 2007, 97(12):1319-1322.
56. Health Professions Council of South Africa ethical guideline booklet 12, 2008 at. http://www.hpcsa.co.za/downloads/conduct_ethics/rules/generic_ethical_rules/booklet_12_guidelines_withholding_and_withdrawing_treatment.pdf.
57. Commissie ethiek NVIC mede namens de commissie richtlijnontwikkeling NVIC. Richtlijn nalaten en staken van behandeling en palliatieve zorg na het staken van behandeling bij volwassen IC patiënten 2009.
58. Task Force on Ethics of the Society of Critical Care Medicine Consensus report on the ethics of foregoing life-sustaining treatments in the critically ill. Crit Care Med 1990, 18:1435-1439.
59. Bone R.C., Rackow E.C., Weg J.G. Ethical and moral guidelines for the initiation, continuation and withdrawal of intensive care. Chest 1990, 97:949-958. ACCP/SCCM Consensus Panel.
60. Anonymous Withholding and withdrawing life-sustaining therapy. This Official Statement of the American Thoracic Society was adopted by the ATS Board of Directors. Am Rev Respir Dis 1991, 144:726-731.
61. Truog R.D., Campbell M.L., Curtis J.R., Haas C.E., Luce J.M., Rubenfeld G.D., et al. Recommendations for end-of-life care in the intensive care unit: a consensus statement by the American College of Critical Care Medicine. Crit Care Med 2008, 36:953-963.
62. American Medical Association H-140.966 Decisions near the end of life [last accessed 17 February 2005]. http://www.amaassn.org/apps/pf_new/pf_online?f_n=browse&doc=policyfiles/HnE/H-140.966.HTM.
63. General Medical Council Withholding and withdrawing life prolonging treatments: good practice in decision-making. Withholding and withdrawing life-prolonging medical treatment: guidance for decision making 2006, GMC, London, [Malden, MA & Oxford: Blackwell (BMA edn. 2007)]. 3rd ed.
64. President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research. Deciding to forego life-sustaining treatment: a report on the ethical, medical, and legal issues in treatment decisions 1983, 73-77. US Government Printing Office, Washington DC.
65. Giacomini M., Cook D., DeJean D., Shaw R., Gedge E. Decision tools for life support: a review and policy analysis. Crit Care Med 2006, 34:864-870.
66. Wilkinson D., Savulescu J. A costly separation between withdrawing and withholding treatment in intensive care. Bioethics 2014, 28:127-137. 10.1111/j.1467-8519.2012.01981.
67. The Society of Critical Care Medicine Ethics Committee Attitudes of critical care medicine professionals concerning forgoing life-sustaining treatments. Crit Care Med 1992, 20:320-326.
68. Vincent J.L. Forgoing life support in western European intensive care units: the results of an ethical questionnaire. Crit Care Med 1999, 27:1626-1633.
69. Solomon M.Z., O'Donnell L., Jennings B., Guilfoy V., Wolf S.M., Nolan K., et al. Decisions near the end of life: professional views on life-sustaining treatments. Am J Public Health 1993, 83:14-23.
70. Giannini A., Pessina A., Tacchi E.M. End-of-life decisions in intensive care units: attitudes of physicians in an Italian urban setting. Intensive Care Med 2003, 29:1902-1910.
71. Bulow H.H., Sprung C.L., Reinhart K., Prayag S., Du B., Armaganidis A., et al. The world's major religions' point of view on end-of-life decisions in the intensive care unit. Intensive Care Med 2008, 34:423-430.
72. Vincent J.L. Withdrawing may be preferable to withholding. Crit Care 1989, 17:827-833.
73. Poses R.M., Bekes C., Copare F.J., Scott W.E. The answer to "What are my chances, doctor?" depends on whom is asked: prognostic disagreement and inaccuracy for critically ill patients. Crit Care Med 1989, 17:827-833.
74. Vincent J.L., Schetz M., De Waele J.J., et al. "Piece" of mind: end of life in the intensive care unit. Statement of the Belgian Society of Intensive Care Medicine. J Crit Care 2014, 29:174-175. on behalf of the Belgian Society of Intensive Care Medicine.
75. Levin P.D., Sprung C.L. Withdrawing and withholding life sustaining therapies are not the same. Crit Care 2005, 9:230-232.
76. Sulmasy D.P., Sugarman J. Are withholding and withdrawing therapy always morally equivalent?. J Med Ethics 1994, 20:218-222.
77. Nozick R. Anarchy, state, and utopia 1975, 150-155. Basic Books, New York.
78. Sprung C.L., Maia P., Bulow H.H., Ricou B., Armaganidis A., Baras M., et al. The importance of religious affiliation and culture on end-of-life decisions in European intensive care units. Intensive Care Med 2007, 33:1732-1739.
79. Carlet J., Thijs L.G., Antonelli M., Cassell J., Cox P., Hill N., et al. Challenges in end-of-life care in the ICU. Statement of the 5th International Consensus Conference in Critical Care: Brussels, Belgium, April 2003. Intensive Care Med 2004, 30:770-784.
80. Meltorp G., Nilstun T. The difference between withholding and withdrawing life-sustaining treatment. Intensive Care Med 1997, 23:1264-1267.
81. Curtis J.R., Sprung C.L., Azoulay E. The importance of word choice in the care of critically ill patients and their families. Intensive Care Med 2014, 40:606-608.