Back to the Future: Small Modular Reactors, Nuclear Fantasies, and Symbolic Convergence

Science Technology and Human Values

Volumn 40, Issue 1, 2015, Pages 96-125

  Sovacool, Benjamin K ^a,b   Ramana, M V ^c  

^a VERMONT LAW SCHOOL   (United States)

^b AARHUS UNIVERSITY   (Denmark)

^c PRINCETON UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

energy policy; environmental practices; governance; nuclear power; politics; power

Indexed keywords

EID: 84904669661     PISSN: 01622439     EISSN: 15528251     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0162243914542350     Document Type: Article

References (84)

1. BBMB (Bhakra Beas Management Board). n.d. “Developmental History of Bhakra – Nangal Dam Project.”Bhakra Beas Management Board. Accessed June 23, 2014. http://bbmb.gov.in/english/history_nangal_dam.asp.
2. Berkhout Frans.“Normative Expectations in Systems Innovation.”.Technology Analysis & Strategic Management. 2006;18 ((3-4)): 299-311
3. BockingStephen. 2009. “Dams as Development.”Globalization Monitor, Accessed June 23, 2014. http://www.globalmon.org.hk/content/dams-development.
4. Bormann Ernest G.“Fantasy and Rhetorical Vision: The Rhetorical Criticism of Social Reality.”.Quarterly Journal of Speech. 1972;58 ((4)): 396-407
5. Bormann Ernest G.“Fantasy and Rhetorical Vision: Ten Years Later.”.Quarterly Journal of Speech. 1982a;68 ((3)): 288-305
6. Bormann Ernest G.“The Symbolic Convergence Theory of Communication: Applications and Implications for Teachers and Consultants.”.Journal of Applied Communication Research. 1982b;10 ((1)): 50-61
7. Bormann Ernest G.,Cragan John F.,Shields Donald C.“In Defense of Symbolic Convergence Theory: A Look at the Theory and Its Criticisms After Two Decades.”.Communication Theory. 1994;4 ((4)): 259-94
8. Bormann Ernest G.,Cragan John F.,Shields Donald C.“An Expansion of the Rhetorical Vision Component of the Symbolic Convergence Theory: The Cold War Paradigm Case.”.Communication Monographs. 1996;63 ((1)): 1-28
9. Bormann Ernest G.,Cragan John F.,Shields Donald C.Communication Yearbook 25. Gudykunst William B., ed. East Sussex, UK: Psychology Press; 2001:271-313.
10. Bortot S.,Moisseytsev A.,Sienicki J. J.,Artioli Carlo.“Core Design Investigation for a SUPERSTAR Small Modular Lead-cooled Fast Reactor Demonstrator.”.Nuclear Engineering and Design. 2011;241 ((8)): 3021-31
11. Borup Mads,Brown Nik,Konrad Kornelia,Lente Harro Van.“The Sociology of Expectations in Science and Technology.”.Technology Analysis & Strategic Management. 2006;18 ((3-4)): 285-98
12. Brown Nik,Rappert Brian,Webster AndrewContested Futures: A Sociology of Prospective Techno-science. Burlington, VT: Ashgate; 2000:
13. Byrne John,Hoffman Steven M.Governing the Atom: The Politics of Risk. Byrne JohnHoffman Steven M., ed. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction; 1996:11-46.
14. Carelli Mario,Garrone P.,Locatelli G.,Mancini M.,Mycoff C.,Trucco P.,Ricotti M. E.“Economic Features of Integral, Modular, Small-to-medium Size Reactors.”.Progress in Nuclear Energy. 2010;52 ((4)): 403-14
15. Choi Sungyeol,Cho Jae-Hyun,Bae Moo-Hoon,Lim Jun,Puspitarini Dina,Hoon Jeun Ji,Joo Han-Gyu,Soon Hwang Il.“PASCAR: Long Burning Small Modular Reactor Based on Natural Circulation.”.Nuclear Engineering and Design. 2011;241 ((5)): 1486-99
16. Corn Joseph J.Imagining Tomorrow: History, Technology, and the American Future. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press; 1988:
17. Cragan John F.,Shields Donald C.“The Use of Symbolic Convergence Theory in Corporate Strategic Planning: A Case Study.”.Journal of Applied Communication Research. 1992;20 ((2)): 199-218
18. Cragan John F.,Shields Donald C.Symbolic Theories in Applied Communication Research: Bormann, Burke and Fisher. Creskill, NJ: Hampton Press; 1995:
19. Nuclear energy cost database: A reference database for nuclear and coal-fired power plant power generation cost analysis. Office of Program Support, U. S. Department of Energy; 1988:
20. Drami Dror,Yacobi Yosef Z.,Stambler Noga,Kress Nurit.“Seawater Quality and Microbial Communities at a Desalination Plant Marine Outfall. A Field Study at the Israeli Mediterranean Coast.”.Water Research. 2011;45 ((17)): 5449-62
21. Eames Malcolm,Mcdowall William,Hodson Mike,Marvin Simon.“Negotiating Contested Visions and Place-specific Expectations of the Hydrogen Economy.”.Technology Analysis & Strategic Management. 2006;18 ((3-4)): 361-74
22. El-Genk Mohamed S.,Tournier Jean-Michel P.“AMTEC/TE Static Converters for High Energy Utilization, Small Nuclear Power Plants.”.Energy Conversion and Management. 2004;45 ((4)): 511-35
23. Ertör-Akyazı Pınar,Adaman Fikret,Özkaynak Begüm,Zenginobuz Ünal.“Citizens’ Preferences on Nuclear and Renewable Energy Sources: Evidence from Turkey.”.Energy Policy. 2012;47 ((August)): 309-20
24. Filho Gonçalves Orlando João Agostinho.“INPRO Economic Assessment of the IRIS Nuclear Reactor for Deployment in Brazil.”.Nuclear Engineering and Design. 2011;241 ((6)): 2329-38
25. Fujimura JoanGenetic Nature/Culture: Anthropology and Science beyond the Two-Culture Divide. Goodman Alan H.Heath DeborahSusan Lindee M., ed. Berkeley: University of California Press; 2003:176-99.
26. Geels Frank W.,Smit Wim A.“Failed Technology Futures: Pitfalls and Lessons from a Historical Survey.”.Futures. 2000;32 ((9-10)): 867-85
27. Glaser Alexander,Hopkins Laura Berzak,Ramana M. V.“Resource Requirements and Proliferation Risks Associated with Small Modular Reactors.”.Nuclear Technology. 2013;184 ((1)): 121-29
28. Gunn Joshua.“Refiguring Fantasy: Imagination and Its Decline in U. S. Rhetorical Studies.”.Quarterly Journal of Speech. 2003;89 ((1)): 41-59
29. Hatton Steven A.,El-Genk Mohamed S.“Sectored Compact Space Reactor (SCoRe) Concepts with a Supplementary Lunar Regolith Reflector.”.Progress in Nuclear Energy. 2009;51 ((1)): 93-108
30. Hibi Koki,Ono Hitoi,Kanagawa Takashi.“Integrated Modular Water Reactor (IMR) Design.”.Nuclear Engineering and Design. 2004;230 ((1-3)): 253-66
31. Small and Medium Power Reactors, Project Initiation Study, Phase 1. Vienna, Austria: International Atomic Energy Agency; 1985:
32. Innovative Small and Medium Sized Reactors: Design Features, Safety Approaches and R&D Trends. Vienna, Austria: International Atomic Energy Agency; 2005:
33. Advanced Nuclear Power Plant Design Options to Cope with External Events. Vienna, Austria: International Atomic Energy Agency; 2006a:
34. Status of Innovative Small and Medium Sized Reactor Designs 2005: Reactors with Conventional Refuelling Schemes. Vienna, Austria: International Atomic Energy Agency; 2006b:
35. Nuclear Technology Review 2007. Vienna, Austria: International Atomic Energy Agency; 2007a:
36. Status of Small Reactor Designs Without On-site Refuelling. Nuclear Energy Series. Vienna, Austria: International Atomic Energy Agency; 2007b:
37. Advanced Applications of Water Cooled Nuclear Power Plants. Vienna, Austria: International Atomic Energy Agency; 2007c:
38. Non-electric Applications of Nuclear Power: Seawater Desalination, Hydrogen Production, and Other Industrial Applications. Vienna, Austria: International Atomic Energy Agency; 2009:
39. Small Reactors Without On-site Refueling: Neutronic Characteristics, Emergency Planning and Development Scenarios. Vienna, Austria: International Atomic Energy Agency; 2010:
40. Advances in Nuclear Power Process Heat Applications. Vienna, Austria: International Atomic Energy Agency; 2012:
41. Ingersoll D. T.“Deliberately Small Reactors and the Second Nuclear Era.”.Progress in Nuclear Energy. 2009;51 ((4-5)): 589-603
42. Jasanoff Sheila,Kim Sang-Hyun.“Containing the Atom: Sociotechnical Imaginaries and Nuclear Power in the United States and South Korea.”.Minerva. 2009;47 ((2)): 119-46
43. Kessides Ioannis N.“The Future of the Nuclear Industry Reconsidered: Risks, Uncertainties, and Continued Promise.”.Energy Policy. 2012;48:185-208
44. Khagram SanjeevBeyond Temples and Tombs: Towards Effective Governance for Sustainable Development through the World Commission on Dams. Cambridge, MA: Center for International Development and Hauser Center for Non-Profit Organizations, The John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University; 2005:
45. Konstantinov L. V.,Kupitz J.“The Status of Development of Small and Medium Sized Reactors.”.Nuclear Engineering and Design. 1988;109 ((1-2)): 5-9
46. Kuznetsov V.19th International Conference on Structural Mechanics in Reactor Technology (SMiRT 19). Canada: Toronto; 2007:1-8.
47. Kuznetsov V.16th International Conference on Nuclear Engineering. Orlando, FL: ; 2008:
48. Lilienthal David EliChange, Hope, and the Bomb. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press; 1963:
49. Lim Seungho,Choi Youngin,Ha Kyungrok,Park Kyoung-Su,Park No-Cheol,Park Young-Pil,Jeong Kyeong-Hoon,Park Jin-Seok.“Dynamic Characteristics of a Perforated Cylindrical Shell for Flow Distribution in SMART.”.Nuclear Engineering and Design. 2011;241 ((10)): 4079-88
50. Locatelli Giorgio,Mancini Mauro.“The Role of the Reactor Size for an Investment in the Nuclear Sector: An Evaluation of Not-financial Parameters.”.Progress in Nuclear Energy. 2011;53 (2): 212-22
51. Mahaffey JamesAtomic Awakening: A New Look at the History and Future of Nuclear Power. New York: Pegasus; 2010:
52. Marvin CarolynWhen Old Technologies Were New: Thinking about Communications in the Late Nineteenth Century. New York: Oxford University Press; 1988:
53. McDowall William,Eames Malcolm.“Forecasts, Scenarios, Visions, Backcasts and Roadmaps to the Hydrogen Economy: A Review of the Hydrogen Futures Literature.”.Energy Policy. 2006;34 ((11)): 1236-50
54. Meerganz von Medeazza G. L.““Direct” and Socially-induced Environmental Impacts of Desalination.”.Desalination. 2005;185 ((1-3)): 57-70
55. Mourogov V.,Fukuda K.,Kagramanian V.“The Need for Innovative Nuclear Reactor and Fuel Cycle Systems: Strategy for Development and Future Prospects.”.Progress in Nuclear Energy. 2002;40 ((3-4)): 285-99
56. Nuclear Wastes: Technologies for Separations and Transmutation. Washington, DC: National Academy Press; 1996:
57. Nye David E.American Technological Sublime. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press; 1994:
58. OberthR. C.LeeC. F. 1980. “Underground Siting of a CANDU Nuclear Power Station.” In Rockstore 80, 701–711. Stockholm, Sweden: Pergamon Press. Accessed June 23, 2014. http://www.onepetro.org/mslib/servlet/onepetropreview?id=ISRM-Rockstore-1980-091.
59. Peterson Tarla RaiSharing the Earth: The Rhetoric of Sustainable Development. Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina Press; 1997:
60. Pidgeon Nick F.,Lorenzoni Irene,Poortinga Wouter.“Climate Change or Nuclear Power--No Thanks! A Quantitative Study of Public Perceptions and Risk Framing in Britain.”.Global Environmental Change. 2008;18 ((1)): 69-85
61. Ramana M. V.“Nuclear Power: Economic, Safety, Health, and Environmental Issues of Near-term Technologies.”.Annual Review of Environment and Resources. 2009;34:127-52
62. Ramana M. V.,Mian Zia.“One Size Doesn’t Fit All: Social Priorities and Technical Conflicts for Small Modular Reactors.”.Energy Research & Social Science. 2014;2:115-124
63. Saint-Exupéry Antoine de.The Wisdom of the Sands. New York: Harcourt, Brace; 1950:
64. Sambuu Odmaa,Obara Toru.“Conceptual Design for a Small Modular District Heating Reactor for Mongolia.”.Annals of Nuclear Energy. 2012;47:210-215
65. Segal Howard P.Future Imperfect: The Mixed Blessings of Technology in America. Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press; 1994:
66. Segal Howard P.Technological Utopianism in American Culture. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press; 2005:
67. Selin Cynthia.“Expectations and the Emergence of Nanotechnology.”.Science, Technology, & Human Values. 2007;32 ((2)): 196-220
68. Shields Donald C.“Symbolic Convergence and Special Communication Theories: Sensing and Examining Dis/enchantment with the Theoretical Robustness of Critical Auto Ethnography.”.Communication Monographs. 2000;67 ((4)): 392-421
69. Shropshire David.“Economic Viability of Small to Medium-sized Reactors Deployed in Future European Energy Markets.”.Progress in Nuclear Energy. 2011;53 ((4)): 299-307
70. Slessarev Igor.“Intrinsically Secure Fast Reactors with Dense Cores.”.Annals of Nuclear Energy. 2007;34 ((11)): 883-95
71. Slessarev Igor.“Intrinsically Secure Fast Reactors for Long-lived Waste Free and Proliferation Resistant Nuclear Power.”.Annals of Nuclear Energy. 2008;35 ((4)): 636-46
72. Sovacool Benjamin,Brossmann Brent.“Symbolic Convergence and the Hydrogen Economy.”.Energy Policy. 2010;38 ((4)): 1999-2012
73. Sovacool B. K.,Brossmann B.“Fantastic Futures and Three American Energy Transitions,”.Science as Culture. 2013;22 ((2)): 204-212
74. Sovacool B. K.,Brossmann B.“The Rhetorical Fantasy of Energy Transitions: Implications for Energy Policy and Analysis,”.Technology Analysis & Strategic Management. 2014;:
75. SubkiM. Hadid. 2012. “Global Trends, Prospects and Challenges for Innovative SMRs Deployment presented at the Long-term Prospects for Nuclear Energy in the Post-Fukushima Era.” August 29, Seoul (Korea). Accessed June 23, 2014. http://www.iaea.org/INPRO/5th_Dialogue_Forum/Wednesday,_29.08.2012/Session_IV_Nuclear_Safety_and_Innovation/2._Hadid_Subki_IAEA_0829_no_distribute.pdf.
76. Top Climate Change Scientists’ Letter to Policy Influencers. 2013. CNN. Accessed June 23, 2014. http://www.cnn.com/2013/11/03/world/nuclear-energy-climate-change-scientists-letter/index.html.
77. Van Lente HarroPromising Technologies: The Dynamics of Expectations in Technological Developments. Enschede, NL: Twente University; 1993:
78. Vasquez Gabriel M.“A Homo Narrans Paradigm for Public Relations: Combining Bormann’s Symbolic Convergence Theory and Grunig’s Situational Theory of Publics.”.Journal of Public Relations Research. 1993;5 ((3)): 201-16
79. Vujić Jasmina,Bergmann Ryan M.,Škoda Radek,Miletić Marija.“Small Modular Reactors: Simpler, Safer, Cheaper?”.Energy. 2012;45 ((1)): 288-95
80. Wallace Edward,Matzie Regis,Heiderd Roger,Maddalena John.“From Field to Factory—Taking Advantage of Shop Manufacturing for the Pebble Bed Modular Reactor.”.Nuclear Engineering and Design. 2006;236 ((5-6)): 445-53
81. Wrage Ernest.“Public Address: A Study in Social and Intellectual History.”.Quarterly Journal of Speech. 1947;47:451-57
82. Zhang Zuoyi,Sun Yuliang.“Economic Potential of Modular Reactor Nuclear Power Plants Based on the Chinese HTR-PM Project.”.Nuclear Engineering and Design. 2007;237 ((23)): 2265-74
83. Zrodnikov A. V.,Toshinsky G. I.,Komlev O. G.,G. Dragunov Yu,Stepanov V. S.,Klimov N. N.,Generalov V. N.,Kopytov I. I.,Krushelnitsky V. N.“Innovative Nuclear Technology Based on Modular Multi-Purpose Lead–bismuth Cooled Fast Reactors.”.Progress in Nuclear Energy. 2008;50 ((2-6)): 170-178
84. Zrodnikov A. V.,Toshinsky G. I.,Komlev O. G.,Stepanov V. S.,Klimov N. N.“SVBR-100 Module-type Fast Reactor of the IV Generation for Regional Power Industry.”.Journal of Nuclear Materials. 2011;415 ((3)): 237-44