The translation and sedimentation of accounting reforms. A comparison of the UK, Austrian and Italian experiences

Critical Perspectives on Accounting

Volumn 25, Issue 4-5, 2014, Pages 388-408

  Hyndman, Noel ^a   Liguori, Mariannunziata ^a   Meyer, Renate E ^b,c   Polzer, Tobias ^b   Rota, Silvia ^d   Seiwald, Johann ^b  

^a QUEEN'S UNIVERSITY BELFAST   (United Kingdom)

^b VIENNA UNIVERSITY OF ECONOMICS AND BUSINESS   (Austria)

^c Department of International Economics and Management   (Denmark)

^d UNIVERSITY OF BERGAMO   (Italy)

Author keywords

Accounting reforms; New public management; Public sector; Sedimentation; Translation

Indexed keywords

EID: 84902253691     PISSN: 10452354     EISSN: 10959955     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.cpa.2013.05.008     Document Type: Article

References (146)

1. Anessi-Pessina E., Steccolini I. Effects of budgetary and accruals accounting coexistence: evidence from Italian local governments. Financial Accountability and Management 2007, 23:113-131.
2. Bardach E. The implementation game: what happens after a bill becomes a law 1977, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
3. Barzelay M., Jacobson A.S. Theorizing implementation of public management policy reforms: a case study of strategic planning and programming in the European Commission. Governance 2009, 22:319-334.
4. Bauer G., Pasterniak A., Seiwald J. Österreich und die IPSAS. Die inhaltliche Fundierung des Rechnungswesens des Bundes. Das öffentliche Haushaltswesen in Österreich 2011, 52:5-13.
5. Becker S.D., Jagalla T., Skærbæk P. The translation of accrual accounting and budgeting and the reconfiguration of public sector accountants' identities. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 2013, 24(No).
6. Behn R. Rethinking democratic accountability 2001, Brookings Institution Press, Washington, DC.
7. Benington J., Moore M.H. Public value. Theory and practice 2011, Houndmills, Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan.
8. Bergmann A. Public sector financial management 2009, Pearson, Harlow.
9. Blöndal J.R., Bergvall D. Budgeting in Austria. OECD Journal on Budgeting 2007, 7:1-37.
10. Bouckaert G. Cultural characteristics from Public Management reforms worldwide. Cultural aspects of Public Management reform 2007, 29-64. Elsevier, Amsterdam. K. Schedler, I. Proeller (Eds.).
11. Bovens M. Analysing and assessing accountability: a conceptual framework. European Law Journal 2007, 13:447-468.
12. Broadbent J., Guthrie J. Changes in the public sector: a review of recent "alternative" accounting research. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 1992, 5:3-31.
13. Bruns H.J. Accounting change and value creation in public services - do relational archetypes make a difference in improving public service performance?. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 2013, 24(No.).
14. Brunsson N. The organization of hypocrisy: talk, decisions, and actions in organizations 1989, John Wiley & Sons, New York.
15. Brunsson N., Olsen J.P. The reforming organization 1993, Routledge, London.
16. Campbell J.L. Institutional change and globalization 2004, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
17. Carabba M. La nuova disciplina dei controlli nella riforma amministrativa. Rivista trimestrale di diritto pubblico 1994, 4:955-1006.
18. Carruthers B., Espeland W. Accounting for rationality: double-entry bookkeeping and the rhetoric of economic rationality. The American Journal of Sociology 1991, 97:31-69.
19. Chan J. Government accounting: an assessment of theory, purposes and standards. Public Money & Management 2003, 23:13-20.
20. Chow D.S.L., Humphrey C., Moll J. Developing whole of government accounting in the UK: grand claims, practical complexities and a suggested future research agenda. Financial Accountability & Management 2007, 23:27-54.
21. Christensen M., Parker L.D. Using ideas to advance professions: public sector accrual accounting. Financial Accountability & Management 2010, 26:246-266.
22. Christensen T., Lægreid P. New public management: design, resistance, or transformation? A study of how modern reforms are received in a civil service system. Public Productivity & Management Review 1999, 23:169-193.
23. Christensen T., Lægreid P. Transcending new public management. The transformation of public sector reforms 2007, Ashgate, Aldershot.
24. Christensen T., Lægreid P. Complexity and hybrid public administration: theoretical and empirical challenges. Public Organization Review 2011, 11:407-423.
25. Christiaens J. Financial accounting reform in Flemish municipalities: an empirical investigation. Financial Accountability & Management 1999, 15:21-40.
26. Christiaens J., Peteghem V.V. Governmental accounting reform: evolution of the implementation in Flemish municipalities. Financial Accountability & Management 2007, 23:375-399.
27. Clemente F. La riforma del bilancio in Parlamento: strumenti e procedure 1992, Edizioni Scientifiche Italiane, Naples.
28. Collevecchio M. Governare la città con il bilancio 2004, Maggiole Editore, Rimini.
29. Collier P.M. The power of accounting: a field study of local financial management in police force. Management Accounting Research 2001, 12.
30. Connolly C., Hyndman N. The actual implementation of accruals accounting: caveats from a case within the UK public sector. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 2006, 19:272-290.
31. Connolly C., Hyndman N. The impact of resource accounting and budgeting in the Northern Ireland public sector. Association of Chartered Certified Accountants' Research Report (No. 87) 2006, Certified Accountants Educational Trust, London.
32. Cooper D.J., Hinings B., Greenwood R., Brown J.L. Sedimentation and transformation in organizational change: the case of Canadian law firms. Organization Studies 1996, 17:623-647.
33. Covaleski M.A., Dirsmith M.W. An institutional perspective on the rise, social transformation and fall of a university budget category. Administrative Science Quarterly 1988, 33:562-587.
34. Czarniawska B. Operational risk, translation, and glocalization. GRI-rapport 2011:8 2011, University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg.
35. Czarniawska B., Joerges B. Travel of ideas. Translating organizational change 1996, 13-48. de Gruyter, Berlin. B. Czarniawska, G. Sevón (Eds.).
36. Demmke C., Moilanen T. Civil services in the EU of 27. Reform outcomes and the future of the civil service 2010, Peter Lang, Frankfurt/M.
37. Drechsler W. The rise and demise of the new public management. Post-Autistic Economics Review 2005, 33:17-28.
38. Global themes and local variations in organization and management. Perspectives on globalization 2013, Routledge, New York, (forthcoming). G.S. Drori, M.A. Höllerer, P. Walgenbach (Eds.).
39. Dunleavy P., Margetts H., Bastow S., Tinkler J. New public management is dead. Long live digital-era governance. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 2006, 16:467-494.
40. Dunleavy P.J. Democracy, bureaucracy and public choice: economic explanations in political science 1991, Harvester Wheatsheaf, New York.
41. Dunleavy P.J., Hood C. From old public administration to new public management. Public Money and Management 1994, 14:9-16.
42. Efficiency Unit Improving management in government: the next steps. Report to the Prime Minister 1988, The Stationery Office, London.
43. Elsbach K.D., Sutton R.I., Principe K.E. Averting expected challenges through anticipatory impression management: a study of hospital billing. Organization Science 1998, 9:68-86.
44. Etherington L.D., Richardson A.J. Institutional pressures on university accounting education in Canada. Contemporary Accounting Research 1994, 10:141-162.
45. European Commission Governance in the European Union: a White Paper 2001, European Commission, Brussels.
46. Ezzamel M., Robson K., Stapleton P., McLean C. Discourse and institutional change: giving accounts and accountability. Management Accounting Research 2007, 18:150-171.
47. Ferlie E., Ashburner L., Fitzgerald L., Pettigrew A. The new public management in action 1996, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
48. Ferri P., Zan L. Ten years after: the rise and fall of managerial autonomy in Pompeii. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 2013, 24(No).
49. Fischer F. Reframing Public Policy: discursive politics and deliberative practices 2003, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
50. Flynn N., Strehl F. Public sector management in Europe 1996, Prentice Hall, London.
51. Gamson W.A. The social psychology of collective action. Frontiers in social movement theory 1992, 53-76. Yale University Press, New Haven, CT. A.D. Morris, C.M. Mueller (Eds.).
52. Gamson W.A., Modigliani A. Media discourse and public opinion on nuclear power: a constructionist approach. American Journal of Sociology 1989, 95:1-37.
53. Green S.E. A rhetorical theory of diffusion. Academy of Management Review 2004, 29:653-669.
54. Gualmini E. Restructuring Weberian bureaucracy: comparing managerial reforms in Europe and the United States. Public Administration 2008, 86:75-94.
55. Guthrie J. Application of accrual accounting in the Australian public sector - rhetoric or reality. Financial Accountability & Management 1998, 14:1-19.
56. Guthrie J., Humphrey C., Jones L., Olson O. Debating public sector management and financial management reforms: an international study 2005, Information Age Publishers, Greenwich, CT.
57. Hajer M.A. Policy without polity? Policy analysis and the institutional void. Policy Sciences 2003, 36:175-195.
58. Hajnal G. Diversity convergence. A quantitative analysis of European public administration education programs. Journal of Public Affairs Education 2003, 9:245-258.
59. Hammerschmid G., Egger-Peitler I., Höllerer M.A. Evaluierung des Instruments der Flexibilisierungsklausel 2008, Austrian Federal Chancellery and Vienna University of Economics and Business, Vienna.
60. Hammerschmid G., Meyer R.E. New public management in Austria: local variation on a global theme?. Public Administration 2005, 83:709-733.
61. Heald D., Georgiou G. Whole of government accounts developments in the UK: conceptual, technical and timetable issues. Public Money & Management 2009, 29:219-227.
62. Heald D., Georgiou G. The macro-fiscal role of the U.K. Whole of Government Account. Abacus 2011, 47:446-476.
63. Hill M., Hupe P.L. Implementing public policy 2002, Sage, London.
64. Hill M., Hupe P.L. Street-level bureaucracy and public accountability. Public Administration 2007, 85:279-299.
65. Hinings C.R., Greenwood R. The dynamics of strategic change 1988, Basil Blackwell, Oxford.
66. HM Government Efficiency and effectiveness in the civil service (Cmnd 8616) 1982, The Stationery Office, London.
67. Government H.M. Progress since the July 1999 memorandum and further proposals for a resource based system of supply and reporting to Parliament. Select Committee on Treasury (minutes of evidence) 2000, Available online at: http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm199900/cmselect/cmtreasy/308/0030703.htm, last access: 5 June 2012.
68. Treasury H.M. Accounting for taxpayer's money: resource accounting and budgeting in government, a consultation paper (Cmnd 2626) 1994, The Stationery Office, London.
69. Treasury H.M. Better accounting for taxpayer's money (Cmnd 2929) 1995, The Stationery Office, London.
70. Hood C. A Public Management for all seasons?. Public Administration 1991, 69:3-19.
71. Hood C. The "new public management" in the 1980s: variations on a theme. Accounting, Organizations and Society 1995, 20:93-109.
72. Hughes O.E. Public Management and Administration. An introduction 1994, Macmillan, Basingstoke.
73. Hupe P.L., Meijs L.C.P.M., Vorthoren M.H. Hybrid Governance: the impact of the nonprofit sector in the Netherlands 2000, Social and Cultural Planning Office, The Hague.
74. Kettl D. The global revolution in public management: driving themes, missing links. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 1997, 16:446-462.
75. Kickert W.J.M Distinctiveness in the study of Public Management in Europe. The study of Public Management in Europe and the US. A comparative analysis of national distinctiveness 2008, 1-13. Routledge, London. W.J.M. Kickert (Ed.).
76. Kickert W.J.M. The study of public management in Europe and the US. A comparative analysis of national distinctiveness 2011, Routledge, London.
77. Knill C. The Europeanisation of national administrations 2001, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
78. Knill C., Balint T. Explaining variation in organizational change: the reform of human resource management in the European Commission and the OECD. Journal of European Public Policy 2008, 15:669-690.
79. Kurunmäki L., Lapsley I., Miller P. Accounting within and beyond the state. Management Accounting Research 2010, 22:1-5.
80. Lapsley I. Accounting and the new public management: instruments of substantive efficiency or a rationalising modernity?. Financial Accountability and Management 1999, 10:201-208.
81. Lapsley I. The NPM agenda: back to the future. Financial Accountability & Management 2008, 24:77-96.
82. Liguori M. Radical change, accounting and public sector reforms: a comparison of Italian and Canadian municipalities. Financial Accountability & Management 2012, 28:437-463.
83. Liguori M. The supremacy of the sequence: key elements and dimensions in the process of change. Organization Studies 2012, 33:507-539.
84. Liguori M., Sicilia M., Steccolini I. Some like it non-financial. Politicians' and managers' views on the importance of accounting information. Public Management Review 2012, 14:903-922.
85. Liguori M., Steccolini I. Accounting change: explaining the outcomes, interpreting the process. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 2012, 25:27-70.
86. Likierman A. Resource Accounting and Budgeting: where are we now?. Public Money & Management 1998, 18:17-20.
87. Likierman A. Planning and controlling UK public expenditure on a resource basis. Public Money & Management 2003, 23:45-50.
88. Loughlin J., Peters B.G. State traditions, administrative reform and regionalization. The political economy of regionalism 1997, Frank Cass, London. M. Keating, J. Loughlin (Eds.).
89. Lounsbury M. Institutional sources of practice variation: staffing college and university recycling programs. Administrative Science Quarterly 2001, 46:29-56.
90. Lüder K. A contingency model governmental accounting innovations in the political-administrative environment. Research in Governmental and Nonprofit Accounting 1992, 7:99-127.
91. Lüder K., Jones R. Reforming governmental accounting and budgeting in Europe 2003, Fachverlag Moderne Wirtschaft, Frankfurt/M.
92. Lynn L., Heinrich C., Hill C. Improving governance. A new logic for empirical research 2001, Georgetown University Press, Washington, DC.
93. Mahoney J., Thelen K. Explaining institutional change. Ambiguity, agency and power 2010, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
94. Malhotra M., Hinings C.R. Processes of radical organizational change: transformation though sedimentation. First Organization Studies Summer Workshop on Theorizing Process in Organizational Research 2005, Organization Studies, Santorini.
95. Mayntz R. Über Governance 2009, Campus, Frankfurt/M.
96. Mazmanian D.A., Sabatier P.A. Effective policy implementation. With a new postscript 1989, University Press of America, Lanham, MD.
97. Meszarits V., Seiwald J. Budgetary Reform in Austria: towards tighter coupling within the financial and management system 2008, Federal Ministry of Finance, Vienna.
98. Meyer J. Foreword Global warning! Debating international developments in New Public Financial Management 1998, 7-13. Cappelen Akademisk Forlag, Oslo. O. Olson, J. Guthrie, C. Humphrey (Eds.).
99. Meyer R.E., Hammerschmid G. Changing institutional logics and executive identities. A managerial challenge to Public Administration in Austria. American Behavioral Scientist 2006, 49:1000-1014.
100. Meyer R.E., Hammerschmid G. The degree of decentralization and individual decision making in central government human resource management: a European comparative perspective. Public Administration 2010, 88:455-478.
101. Meyer R.E., Höllerer M.A. Meaning structures in a contested issue field: a topographic map of shareholder value in Austria. Academy of Management Journal 2010, 53:1241-1262.
102. Mills C.W. Situated actions and vocabularies of motive. American Sociological Review 1940, 5:904-913.
103. Mulgan R. 'Accountability': an ever-expanding concept?. Public Administration 2000, 53:555-573.
104. Nor-Aziah A.K., Scapens R.W. Corporatization and accounting change. The role of accounting and accountants in a Malaysian public utility. Management Accounting Research 2007, 18:209-247.
105. OECD Participatory development and good governance 1995, OECD, Paris.
106. Olsen J.P. Maybe it is time to rediscover bureaucracy. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 2006, 16:1-24.
107. Olsen J.P. Change and continuity: an institutional approach to institutions of democratic government. European Political Science Review 2009, 1:3-32.
108. Olson O., Guthrie J., Humphrey C. Global warning: debating international developments in New Public Financial Management 1998, Cappelen Akademisk Forlag, Oslo.
109. Ongaro E. Public management reform and modernization: trajectories of administrative change in Italy, France, Greece, Portugal and Spain 2009, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham.
110. Ongaro E. The role of politics and institutions in the Italian administrative reform trajectory. Public Administration 2011, 89:738-755.
111. Ongaro E., Valotti G. Public management reform in Italy: explaining the implementation gap. International Journal of Public Sector Management 2008, 32:174-204.
112. Osborne S.P. The new public governance?. Public Management Review 2006, 8:377-387.
113. Osborne S.P. Introduction. The (new) public governance: a suitable case for treatment?. The New Public Governance? Emerging perspectives on the theory and practice of public governance 2010, Routledge, London and New York. S.P. Osborne (Ed.).
114. Painter M., Peters B.G. Tradition and public administration 2010, Palgrave Macmillan, Houndmills, Basingstoke.
115. Parrado S. Failed policies but institutional innovation through "layering" and "diffusion" in Spanish central administration. International Journal of Public Sector Management 2008, 21:230-252.
116. Peters B.G. The two futures of governing: decentering and recentering processes in governing 2008, University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh.
117. Pettersen I.J. Implementing management accounting reforms in the public sector: the difficult journey from intentions to effects. European Accounting Review 2001, 10:561-581.
118. Pierre J. Bureaucracy in the modern state. An introduction to comparative public administration 1995, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham.
119. Pierre J., Peters B.G. Governance, politics and the state 2000, Palgrave Macmillan, Houndmills, Basingstoke.
120. Pollitt C. Convergence. The useful myth?. Public Administration 2001, 79:933-947.
121. Pollitt C., Bouckaert G. Public sector reform. A comparative analysis 2004, Oxford University Press, Oxford. 2nd ed.
122. Pollitt C., Bouckaert G. Public sector reform. A comparative analysis: new public management, governance, and the Neo-Weberian state 2011, Oxford University Press, Oxford. 3rd ed.
123. Rao H., Monin P., Durand R. Institutional change in Toque Ville: Nouvelle cuisine as an identity movement in French gastronomy. American Journal of Sociology 2003, 108:795-843.
124. Rhodes R.A.W. Understanding governance. Policy networks, governance, reflexivity and accountability 1997, Open University Press, Buckingham.
125. Ribeiro J.A., Scapens R.W. Institutional theories in management accounting change. Qualitative Research in Accounting and Management 2006, 3:91-111.
126. Romanelli E., Tushman M.L. Organizational transformation as punctuated equilibrium: an emprical test. Academy of Management Journal 1994, 37:1141-1166.
127. Sahlin K., Wedlin L. Circulating ideas: imitation, translation and editing. The SAGE handbook of organizational institutionalism 2008, 218-241. Sage, London. R. Greenwood, C. Oliver, K. Sahlin, R. Suddaby (Eds.).
128. Sahlin-Andersson K. Imitating by editing success. The construction of organizational fields and identities. Translating organizational change 1996, 69-92. De Gruyter, Berlin. B. Czarniawska, G. Sevón (Eds.).
129. Schnapp K.-U. Ministerialbürokratien in westlichen Demokratien 2004, Leske & Budrich, Opladen.
130. Schneiberg M. What's on the path? Path dependence, organizational diversity and the problem of institutional change in the US economy, 1900-1950. Socio-Economic Review 2007, 5:47-80.
131. Schwab W. Die Haushaltsrechtsreform des Bundes. Ein verbessertes Instrumentarium für Budgetpolitik und -kontrolle. Das öffentliche Haushaltswesen in Österreich 1986, 27:1-15.
132. Sinclair A. The chameleon of accountability: forms and discourses. Accounting, Organizations and Society 1995, 20:219-237.
133. Skelcher C., Mathur N., Smith M. The Public Governance of collaborative spaces: discourse, design and democracy. Public Administration 2005, 83:573-596.
134. Steccolini I. Is the annual report an accountability medium? An empirical investigation into Italian local governments. Financial Accountability & Management 2004, 20:327-350.
135. Steger G. Austria's budget reform: how to create consensus for a decisive change of fiscal rules. OECD Journal on Budgeting 2010, 10:7-20.
136. Strang D., Soule S.A. Diffusion in organizations and social movements: from hybrid corn to poison pills. Annual Review of Sociology 1998, 24:265-290.
137. Streeck W., Thelen K. Beyond continuity 2005, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
138. Suddaby R., Greenwood R. Rhetorical strategies of legitimacy. Administrative Science Quarterly 2005, 50:35-67.
139. ter Bogt H.J. Performance evaluation styles in governmental organizations: how do profesional managers facilitate politicians' work?. Management Accounting Research 2003, 14:311-332.
140. Thornton P.H., Ocasio W. Institutional logics and the historical contingency of power on organizations: executive succession in the higher education publishing industry, 1958-1990. American Journal of Sociology 1999, 105:801-843.
141. Torres L. Trajectories in public administration reforms in European continental countries. Australian Journal of Public Administration 2004, 63:99-112.
142. Trochim W., Donnelly J.P. The research methods knowledge base 2006, Atomic Dog Publishing, Cincinnati, OH.
143. Vogel R. Framing and counter-framing new public management: the case of Germany. Public Administration 2011, 90:1-23.
144. Wanna J., Jensen L., de Vries J. The reality of budgetary reform in OECD nations. Trajectories and consequences 2010, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham and Northampton, MA.
145. Wildavsky A.B. The politics of the budgetary process 1964, Little, Brown and Co, Boston.
146. World Bank Governance: the World Bank's experience 1994, The World Bank, Washington, DC.