Convective versus diffusive dialysis therapies for chronic kidney failure: An updated systematic review of randomized controlled trials

American Journal of Kidney Diseases

Volumn 63, Issue 6, 2014, Pages 954-967

  Nistor, Ionut ^a,b   Palmer, Suetonia C ^c   Craig, Jonathan C ^d   Saglimbene, Valeria ^e   Vecchio, Mariacristina ^f   Covic, Adrian ^a   Strippoli, Giovanni F M ^d,e,f  

^a GRIGORE T POPA UNIVERSITY OF MEDICINE AND PHARMACY   (Romania)

^b GHENT UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL   (Belgium)

^c UNIVERSITY OF OTAGO   (New Zealand)

^d UNIVERSITY OF SYDNEY   (Australia)

^e Diaverum Medical Scientific Office   (Sweden)

^f Laboratorio Angela Valenti dei Fattori Genetici e Ambientali di Rischio Trombotico   (Italy)

Author keywords

dialysis; End stage kidney disease; hemodiafiltration; meta analysis; systematic review

Indexed keywords

BETA 2 MICROGLOBULIN; UREA;

ACETATE FREE BIOFILTRATION; BIOFILTRATION; BLOOD PRESSURE; CARDIOVASCULAR MORTALITY; CLEARANCE; END STAGE RENAL DISEASE; HEMODIAFILTRATION; HEMODIALYSIS; HEMOFILTRATION; HOSPITALIZATION; HUMAN; HYPOTENSION; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; META ANALYSIS; MORTALITY; QUALITY OF LIFE; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL (TOPIC); REVIEW; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; VASCULAR ACCESS;

DIALYSIS; END-STAGE KIDNEY DISEASE; HEMODIAFILTRATION; META-ANALYSIS; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW;

BETA 2-MICROGLOBULIN; HEMODIAFILTRATION; HEMOFILTRATION; HOSPITALIZATION; HUMANS; KIDNEY FAILURE, CHRONIC; QUALITY OF LIFE; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS AS TOPIC; RENAL DIALYSIS; TREATMENT OUTCOME; UREA;

EID: 84901502434     PISSN: 02726386     EISSN: 15236838     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1053/j.ajkd.2013.12.004     Document Type: Article

References (59)

1. S.S. Hedayati, A.T. Minhajuddin, M. Afshar, R.D. Toto, M.H. Trivedi, and A.J. Rush Association between major depressive episodes in patients with chronic kidney disease and initiation of dialysis, hospitalization, or death JAMA 303 19 2010 1946 1953
2. F.E. Murtagh, J. Addington-Hall, and I.J. Higginson The prevalence of symptoms in end-stage renal disease: a systematic review Adv Chronic Kidney Dis 14 1 2007 82 99
3. A.J. Collins, R.N. Foley, and B. Chavers United States Renal Data System 2011 annual data report: atlas of chronic kidney disease and end-stage renal disease in the United States Am J Kidney Dis 59 1 suppl 1 2012 e1 e420
4. A.P. Guérin, G.M. London, S.J. Marchais, and F. Metivier Arterial stiffening and vascular calcifications in end-stage renal disease Nephrol Dial Transplant 15 7 2000 1014 1021
5. S. Liabeuf, A. Lenglet, and L. Desjardins et al. Plasma beta-2 microglobulin is associated with cardiovascular disease in uremic patients Kidney Int 82 12 2012 1297 1303
6. A.K. Cheung, T. Greene, and J.K. Leypoldt et al. Association between serum 2-microglobulin level and infectious mortality in hemodialysis patients Clin J Am Soc Nephrol 3 1 2008 69 77
7. J.K. Leypoldt, A.K. Cheung, and C.E. Carroll et al. Effect of dialysis membranes and middle molecule removal on chronic hemodialysis patient survival Am J Kidney Dis 33 2 1999 349 355
8. F. Locatelli, D. Marcelli, F. Conte, A. Limido, F. Malberti, and D. Spotti Comparison of mortality in ESRD patients on convective and diffusive extracorporeal treatments. The Registro Lombardo Dialisi E Trapianto Kidney Int 55 1 1999 286 293
9. E. Vilar, A.C. Fry, D. Wellsted, J.E. Tattersall, R.N. Greenwood, and K. Farrington Long-term outcomes in online hemodiafiltration and high-flux hemodialysis: a comparative analysis Clin J Am Soc Nephrol 4 12 2009 1944 1953
10. B. Canaud, J.L. Bragg-Gresham, and M.R. Marshall et al. Mortality risk for patients receiving hemodiafiltration versus hemodialysis: European results from the DOPPS Kidney Int 69 11 2006 2087 2093
11. K. Arizono, K. Nomura, and T. Motoyama et al. Use of ultrapure dialysate in reduction of chronic inflammation during hemodialysis Blood Purif 22 suppl 2 2004 26 29
12. L.A. Calo, A. Naso, and G. Carraro et al. Effect of haemodiafiltration with online regeneration of ultrafiltrate on oxidative stress in dialysis patients Nephrol Dial Transplant 22 5 2007 1413 1419
13. K.S. Rabindranath, G.F. Strippoli, C. Daly, P.J. Roderick, S. Wallace, and A.M. MacLeod Haemodiafiltration, haemofiltration and haemodialysis for end-stage kidney disease Cochrane Database Syst Rev 4 2006 CD006258
14. ERA-EDTA Registry ERA-EDTA Registry Annual Report 2010 2010 Academic Medical Centre, Department of Medical Informatics Amsterdam, the Netherlands http://www.era-edta-reg.org/files/annualreports/pdf/AnnRep2010.pdf Accessed July 10, 2013
15. Australia and New Zealand Dialysis and Transplant Registry. Chapter 5. Haemodialysis (including home haemodialysis). In: 35th Annual Report 2012. http://www.anzdata.org.au/anzdata/AnzdataReport/35thReport/2012c05- haemodialysis-v2.11.pdf. Accessed August 7, 2013.
16. J. Tattersall, A. Martin-Malo, and L. Pedrini et al. EBPG guideline on dialysis strategies Nephrol Dial Transplant 22 suppl 2 2007 ii5 ii21
17. K.S. Rabindranath, G.F.M. Strippoli, C. Daly, P.J. Roderick, S.A. Wallace, and A.M. MacLeod Haemodiafiltration, haemofiltration and haemodialysis for end-stage kidney disease Cochrane Database Syst Rev 4 2006 CD006258
18. A. Liberati, D.G. Altman, and J. Tetzlaff et al. The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: explanation and elaboration J Clin Epidemiol 62 10 2009 e1 e34
19. Higgins JPT, Green S, eds. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions. Version 5.1.0 [updated March 2011]. The Cochrane Collaboration, 2011. www.cochrane-handbook.org. Accessed January 8, 2014.
20. G. Knapp, and J. Hartung Improved tests for a random effects meta-regression with a single covariate Stat Med 22 17 2003 2693 2710
21. G. Guyatt, A.D. Oxman, and E.A. Akl et al. GRADE guidelines: 1. Introduction - GRADE evidence profiles and summary of findings tables J Clin Epidemiol 64 2011 383 394
22. R.M. Harbord, M. Egger, and J.A. Sterne A modified test for small-study effects in meta-analyses of controlled trials with binary endpoints Stat Med 25 20 2006 3443 3457
23. L. Vernaglione, C. Cristofano, S. Chimienti, and C. Cystatin (CYS), β2-microglobulin (MIC) and C-reactive protein (CRP) behaviours during hemodiafiltration with online endogenous liquid reinfusion (HFR) and low-flux polysulphone bicarbonate dialysis (BD) [abstract no. SA-PO702] J Am Soc Nephrol 17 Abstracts 2006 722A
24. F. Locatelli, P. Altieri, and S. Andrulli et al. Hemofiltration and hemodiafiltration reduce intradialytic hypotension in ESRD J Am Soc Nephrol 21 10 2010 1798 1807
25. A. Santoro, E. Mancini, and R. Bolzani et al. The effect of on-line high-flux hemofiltration versus low-flux hemodialysis on mortality in chronic kidney failure: a small randomized controlled trial Am J Kidney Dis 52 3 2008 507 518
26. S. Mandolfo, S. Borlandelli, and E. Imbasciati et al. Pilot study to assess increased dialysis efficiency in patients with limited blood flow rates due to vascular access problems Hemodial Int 12 1 2008 55 61
27. L.A. Pedrini, V. De Cristofaro, and M. Comelli et al. Long-term effects of high-efficiency on-line haemodiafiltration on uraemic toxicity. A multicentre prospective randomized study Nephrol Dial Transplant 26 8 2011 2617 2624
28. M. Righetti, O. Filiberti, and A. Ranghino et al. Internal hemodiafiltration versus low-flux bicarbonate dialysis: results from a long-term prospective study Int J Artif Organs 33 11 2010 796 802
29. N.M. Selby, R.J. Fluck, M.W. Taal, and C.W. McIntyre Effects of acetate-free double-chamber hemodiafiltration and standard dialysis on systemic hemodynamics and troponin T levels ASAIO J 52 1 2006 62 69
30. B.V. Stefansson, M. Abramson, U. Nilsson, and B. Haraldsson Hemodiafiltration improves plasma 25-hepcidin levels: a prospective, randomized, blinded, cross-over study comparing hemodialysis and hemodiafiltration Nephron Extra 2 1 2012 55 65
31. N. Tessitore, A. Santoro, and G.O. Panzetta et al. Acetate-free biofiltration reduces intradialytic hypotension: a European multicenter randomized controlled trial Blood Purif 34 3-4 2012 354 363
32. E. Ok, G. Asci, and H. Toz et al. Mortality and cardiovascular events in online haemodiafiltration (OL-HDF) compared with high-flux dialysis: results from the Turkish OL-HDF Study Nephrol Dial Transplant 28 1 2013 192 202
33. C.H. Beerenhout, A.J. Luik, and S.G. Jeuken-Mertens et al. Pre-dilution on-line haemofiltration vs low-flux haemodialysis: a randomized prospective study Nephrol Dial Transplant 20 6 2005 1155 1163
34. M.P. Grooteman, M.A. van den Dorpel, and M.L. Bots et al. Effect of online hemodiafiltration on all-cause mortality and cardiovascular outcomes J Am Soc Nephrol 23 6 2012 1087 1096
35. J. Eiselt, J. Racek, and K. Opatrny Jr. The effect of hemodialysis and acetate-free biofiltration on anemia Int J Artif Organs 23 3 2000 173 180
36. F. Maduell, F. Moreso, and M. Pons et al. High-efficiency postdilution online hemodiafiltration reduces all-cause mortality in hemodialysis patients J Am Soc Nephrol 24 3 2013 487 497
37. K. Kantartzi, S. Panagoutsos, and E. Mourvati et al. Can dialysis modality influence quality of life in chronic hemodialysis patients? Low-flux hemodialysis versus high-flux hemodiafiltration: a cross-over study Ren Fail 35 2 2013 216 221
38. C.L. Lin, C.C. Huang, and C.T. Chang et al. Clinical improvement by increased frequency of on-line hemodialfiltration Ren Fail 23 2 2001 193 206
39. F. Locatelli, F. Mastrangelo, and B. Redaelli et al. Effects of different membranes and dialysis technologies on patient treatment tolerance and nutritional parameters. The Italian Cooperative Dialysis Study Group Kidney Int 50 4 1996 1293 1302
40. T. Ohtake, M. Oka, and K. Ishioka et al. Cardiovascular protective effects of on-line hemodiafiltration: comparison with conventional hemodialysis Ther Apher Dial 16 2 2012 181 188
41. A. Alvestrand, I. Ledebo, and I. Hagerman et al. Left ventricular hypertrophy in incident dialysis patients randomized to treatment with hemofiltration or hemodialysis: results from the ProFil study Blood Purif 32 1 2011 21 29
42. H. Schiffl Prospective randomized cross-over long-term comparison of online haemodiafiltration and ultrapure high-flux haemodialysis Eur J Med Res 12 1 2007 26 33
43. A.M. Schrander-vd Meer, P.M. ter Wee, G. Kan, A.J. Donker, and W.T. van Dorp Improved cardiovascular variables during acetate free biofiltration Clin Nephrol 51 5 1999 304 309
44. L. Vaslaki, L. Major, and K. Berta et al. On-line haemodiafiltration versus haemodialysis: stable haematocrit with less erythropoietin and improvement of other relevant blood parameters Blood Purif 24 2 2006 163 173
45. R.A. Ward, B. Schmidt, J. Hullin, G.F. Hillebrand, and W. Samtleben A comparison of on-line hemodiafiltration and high-flux hemodialysis: a prospective clinical study J Am Soc Nephrol 11 12 2000 2344 2350
46. V. Wizemann, C. Lotz, F. Techert, and S. Uthoff On-line haemodiafiltration versus low-flux haemodialysis. A prospective randomized study Nephrol Dial Transplant 15 suppl 1 2000 43 48
47. B. Bammens, P. Evenepoel, K. Verbeke, and Y. Vanrenterghem Removal of the protein-bound solute p-cresol by convective transport: a randomized crossover study Am J Kidney Dis 44 2 2004 278 285
48. N. Karamperis, D. Jensen, E. Sloth, and J.D. Jensen Comparison of predilution hemodiafiltration and low-flux hemodialysis at temperature- controlled conditions using high calcium-ion concentration in the replacement and dialysis fluid Clin Nephrol 67 4 2007 230 239
49. W. Lornoy, I. Becaus, J.M. Billiouw, L. Sierens, P. Van Malderen, and P. D'Haenens On-line haemodiafiltration. Remarkable removal of beta2-microglobulin. Long-term clinical observations Nephrol Dial Transplant 15 suppl 1 2000 49 54
50. K.K. Teo, C. Basile, R.A. Ulan, M.D. Hetherington, and T. Kappagoda Effects of hemodialysis and hypertonic hemodiafiltration on cardiac function compared Kidney Int 32 3 1987 399 407
51. S. Tuccillo, V. Bellizzi, and F. Catapano et al. Acute and chronic effects of standard hemodialysis and soft hemodiafiltration on interdialytic serum phosphate levels G Ital Nefrol 49 4 2002 439 445
52. S.D. Fox, and L.W. Henderson Cardiovascular response during hemodialysis and hemofiltration: thermal, membrane and catecholamine influences Blood Purif 11 4 1993 224 236
53. H. Schiffl, B. D'Agostini, and E. Held Removal of beta-2 microglobulin by hemodialysis and hemofiltration: a four year follow-up Biomater Artif Cells Immobilization Biotechnol 20 5 1992 1223 1232
54. C. Basile, R. Giordano, and A. Montanaro et al. Effect of acetate-free biofiltration on the anaemia of haemodialysis patients: a prospective cross-over study Nephrol Dial Transplant 16 9 2001 1914 1919
55. M. Noris, M. Todeschini, and F. Casiraghi et al. Effect of acetate, bicarbonate dialysis and acetate free biofiltration on nitric oxide synthesis: implications for dialysis hypotension Am J Kidney Dis 32 1 1998 115 124
56. M. Todeschini, D. Macconi, and N.G. Fernandez et al. Effect of acetate-free biofiltration and bicarbonate hemodialysis on neutrophil activation Am J Kidney Dis 40 4 2002 783 793
57. G. Verzetti, C. Navino, R. Bolzani, G. Galli, and G. Panzetta Acetate-free biofiltration versus bicarbonate haemodialysis in the treatment of patients with diabetic nephropathy: a cross-over multicentric study Nephrol Dial Transplant 13 4 1998 955 961
58. M. Allon, J. Daugirdas, T.A. Depner, T. Greene, D. Ornt, and S.J. Schwab Effect of change in vascular access on patient mortality in hemodialysis patients Am J Kidney Dis 47 3 2006 469 477
59. P. Roy-Chaudhury, V.P. Sukhatme, and A.K. Cheung Hemodialysis vascular access dysfunction: a cellular and molecular viewpoint J Am Soc Nephrol 17 4 2006 1112 1127