Risk-based review of California's water-recycling criteria for agricultural irrigation

Journal of Environmental Engineering (United States)

Volumn 140, Issue 6, 2014, Pages

  Olivieri, Adam W ^a   Seto, Edmund ^b   Cooper, Robert C ^b   Cahn, Michael D ^c   Colford, John ^b   Crook, James ^d   Debroux, Jean François ^e   Mandrell, Robert ^f   Suslow, Trevor ^g   Tchobanoglous, George ^g   Hultquist, Robert A ^h   Spath, David P ^h   Mosher, Jeffrey J ⁱ  

^a EOA Inc   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^c UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA COOPERATIVE EXTENSION   (United States)

^d Crook Consulting   (United States)

^e KENNEDY JENKS CONSULTANTS   (United States)

^f WESTERN REGIONAL RESEARCH CENTER   (United States)

^g UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^h CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH   (United States)

ⁱ NWRI   (United States)

Author keywords

Assessment; Microbial; Recycling; Risk; Water

Indexed keywords

AGRICULTURE; ESCHERICHIA COLI; HEALTH RISKS; LAWS AND LEGISLATION; PUBLIC HEALTH; RECYCLING; RISK ASSESSMENT; RISK PERCEPTION; RISKS; VIRUSES; WASTEWATER RECLAMATION; WASTEWATER TREATMENT; WATER; WATER ANALYSIS;

AGRICULTURAL IRRIGATION; AGRICULTURAL PURPOSE; ASSESSMENT; CRYPTOSPORIDIUM PARVUM; ESCHERICHIA COLI O157:H7; HUMAN ENTERIC VIRUS; MICROBIAL; QUANTITATIVE MICROBIAL RISK ASSESSMENT (QMRA);

WATER RECYCLING;

IRRIGATION; PUBLIC HEALTH; RECYCLING; RISK ASSESSMENT; WASTEWATER; WATER TREATMENT;

CALIFORNIA; UNITED STATES;

EID: 84901037082     PISSN: 07339372     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1061/(ASCE)EE.1943-7870.0000833     Document Type: Review

References (65)

1. Asano, T., Leong, L. Y. C., Rigby, M. G., and, Sakaji, R. H. (1992). " Evaluation of the California Wastewater Reclamation Criteria using enteric virus monitoring data." Water Sci. Technol., 26 (7-8), 1513-1524. WSTED4 0273-1223
2. Bambic, D., McBride, G., Miller, W., Stott, R., and, Wuertz, S. (2011). " Quantification of pathogens and sources of microbial indicators for QMRA in recreational waters." PATH2R08, Water Environment Research Foundation, Alexandria, VA.
3. Cabelli, V. J. (1983). " Public health and water quality significance of viral diseases transmitted by drinking water and recreational water." Water Sci. Technol., 15 (5), 1-15. WSTED4 0273-1223
4. Cabelli, V. J., Dufour, A. P., Levin, M. A., McCabe, L. J., and, Harberman, P. W. (1979). " Relationship of microbial indicators to health effects at marine bathing beaches." Am. J. Public Health, 69 (7), 690-696. AJHEAA 0090-0036 10.2105/AJPH.69.7.690
5. Cabelli, V. J., Dufour, A. P., McCabe, L. J., and, Levin, M. A. (1982). " Swimming-associated gastroenteritis and water quality." Am. J. Epidemiol., 115 (4), 606-616. AJEPAS 0002-9262
6. California Dept. of Health Services. (1991). " Excerpts from environmental management branch, draft statement of reasons relating to risk of exposure to reclaimed water used other than for groundwater recharge." « http://cdph.ca.gov/certlic/drinkingwater/Pages/recycledwater.aspx ».
7. California Dept. of Public Health, Executive Summary. (1987). " Wastewater disinfection for health protection." « http://cdph.ca.gov/certlic/drinkingwater/Pages/recycledwater.aspx ».
8. California State Water Resources Control Board. (2012). " Municipal wastewater recycling survey." « http://www.waterboards.ca.gov/water- issues/programs/grants-loans/water-recycling/munirec.shtml » (May 10, 2012).
9. Colford, J. M., Eisenberg, D. M., Eisenberg, J. N., Scott, J., and, Soller, J. A. (2003). " A dynamic model to assess microbial health risks associated with beneficial uses of biosolids-Phase 1." Water Environment Research Foundation Rep., Project 98-REM-1, Water Environment Research Foundation, Alexandria, VA.
10. Cooper, R. C. (1991). " Public health concerns in wastewater reuse." Water Sci. Technol., 4 (9), 55-65. WSTED4 0273-1223
11. Cooper, R. C., et al. (2012). " Review of California's water recycling criteria for agricultural irrigation, recommendations of an NWRI independent advisory panel." National Water Research Institute, Fountain Valley, CA.
12. Cooper, R. C., Olivieri, A. W., Danielson, R. E., Badger, P. G., Spear, R. C., and, Selvin, S. (1986). " Evaluation of military field-water quality, volume 5: infectious organisms of military concern associated with consumption: assessment of health risks and recommendations for establishing related standards." UCRL-21008, Lawrence Livermore Laboratory, Environmental Sciences Division, Livermore, CA.
13. Couch, R. B., Cate, T. R., Dougla, R. G., Gerone, P. J., and, Knight, V. (1966). " Effect of route of inoculation on experimental respiratory viral disease in volunteers and evidence for airborne transmission." Bateriol. Rev., 30 (3), 517-529.
14. County Sanitation Districts of Los Angeles County (CSDLAC). (1977). Pomona virus study, final report, California State Water Resources Control Board, Sacramento, CA.
15. Crabtree, K. D., Gerba, C. P., Rose, J. B., and, Haas, C. N. (1997). " Waterborne adenovirus: A risk assessment." Water Sci. Technol., 35 (11-12), 1-6. WSTED4 0273-1223 10.1016/S0273-1223(97)00225-4
16. Dryden, F. D., Chen, C. L., and, Selna, M. W. (1979). " Virus removal in advanced wastewater treatment systems." J. Water Pollut. Control Fed., 51 (8), 2098-2109. JWPFA5 0043-1303
17. Fankhauser, R. L., Noel, J. S., Monroe, S. S., Ando, T., and, Glass, R. I. (1998). " Molecular epidemiology of 'Norwalk -like viruses' in outbreaks of gastroenteritis in the United States." J. Infect. Dis., 178 (6), 1571-1578.
18. Farber, J. M., Ross, W. H., and, Harwig, J. (1996). " Health risk assessment of Listeria monocytogenes in Canada." Int. J. Food Microbiol., 30 (1-2), 145-156. IJFMDD 0168-1605 10.1016/0168-1605(96)01107-5
19. Garcia-Aljaro, C., Bonjoch, X., and, Blanch, A. R. (2005). " Combined use of an immunomagnetic separation method and immunoblotting for the enumeration and isolation of Escherichia coli O157 in wastewaters." J. Appl. Microbiol., 98 (3), 589-597. JAMIFK 1364-5072 10.1111/jam.2005.98.issue-3
20. Haas, C. N. (1983). " Effect of effluent disinfection on risks of viral disease transmission via recreational exposure." J. Water Pollut. Control Fed., 55, 1111-1116. JWPFA5 0043-1303
21. Haas, C. N., Rose, J. B., and, Gerba, C. P. (1999). Quantitative microbial risk assessment, Wiley, New York.
22. Hamilton, A. J., Stagnitti, F., Premier, R., Boland, A. M., and, Hale, G. (2006). " Quantitative microbial risk assessment models for consumption of raw vegetables irrigated with reclaimed water." Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 72 (5), 3284-3290. AEMIDF 0099-2240 10.1128/AEM.72.5.3284-3290.2006
23. Heijnen, L., and, Medema, G. (2006). " Quantitative detection of E. coli, E. coli O157 and other shiga toxin producing E. coli in water samples using a culture method combined with real-time PCR." J. Water Health, 4 (4), 487-498. JWHOBR 1477-8920
24. Imhoff, B., et al. (2004). " Burden of self-reported acute diarrheal illness in FoodNet surveillance areas, 1998-1999." Clin. Infect. Dis., 38 (Suppl. 3), S219-S226. CIDIEL 1058-4838 10.1086/cid.2004.38.issue-s3
25. Khan, S. (2008). " Quantitative risk assessment for recycled water." WRC08/23, UNSW Water Research Centre, Univ. of New South Wales, Kensington, Australia.
26. Levine, W. C., and, Stephenson, W. T. (1990). " Waterborne disease outbreaks, 1986-1988." Morb. Mort. Wkly. Rpt., 39 (SS-1), 1-9.
27. Los Angeles County Sanitation Districts. (1977). " Pomona virus study: Final report for the California State Water Resources Control Board and United States Environmental Protection Agency." Whittier, CA.
28. Macler, B. A., and, Regli, S. (1993). " Use of microbial risk assessment in setting United-States drinking-water standards." Int. J. Food Microbiol., 18 (4), 245-256. IJFMDD 0168-1605 10.1016/0168-1605(93)90148-A
29. Mara, D. D., Sleigh, P. A., Blumenthal, U. J., and, Carr, R. M. (2007). " Health risks in wastewater irrigation: Comparing estimates from quantitative microbial risk analyses and epidemiological studies." J. Water Health, 05 (1), 39-50. JWHOBR 1477-8920 10.2166/wh.2006.055
30. Mathers, C. D., et al. (2002). Global burden of disease 2000: Version 2 Methods and results, World Health Organization, Geneva.
31. Mead, P. S., et al. (1999). " Food related illness and death in the United States." Emerg. Infect. Dis., 5 (5), 607-625. 1080-6059 10.3201/eid0505.990502
32. Muniesa, M., Jofre, J., Garcia-Aljaro, C., and, Blanch, A. R. (2006). " Occurrence of Escherichia coli O157:H7 and other enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli in the environment." Environ. Sci. Technol., 40 (23), 7141-7149. ESTHAG 0013-936X 10.1021/es060927k
33. National Research Council. (1983). Risk assessment in the federal government: Managing the process, National Academy Press, Washington, DC.
34. Olivieri, A. W., Seto, E., and, Soller, J. (2007). Application of microbial risk assessment techniques to estimate risk due to exposure to reclaimed waters (WRF-04-001), WateReuse Research Foundation, Alexandria, VA.
35. Ott, W. R. (1995). Environmental statistics and data analysis, Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, FL.
36. Palmateer, G. A., Dutka, B. J., Janzen, E. M., Meissner, S. M., and, Sakellaris, M. G. (1991). " Coliphage and bacteriophage as indicators of recreational water quality." Water Res., 25 (3), 355-357. WATRAG 0043-1354 10.1016/0043-1354(91)90017-K
37. Parkin, R. T., Soller, J. S., and, Olivieri, A. W. (2003). " Incorporating susceptible subpopulations in microbial risk assessment: pediatric exposures to enterovirus in river water." J. Exposure Anal. Environ. Epidemiol., 13 (2), 161-168. JEAEE9 1053-4245 10.1038/sj.jea.7500265
38. Petterson, S. R., Ashbolt, N. J., Sharma, A. (2001). " Microbial risks from wastewater irrigation of salad crops: A screening-level risk assessment." Water Environ. Res., 73 (6), 667-672. WAERED 1061-4303 10.2175/106143001X143402
39. Pipes, W. O. (1978). Water quality and health significance of bacterial indicators of pollution, Drexel Univ., Philadelphia.
40. Regli, S., Amirtharajah, A., Borup, B., Hibler, C., Hoff, J., and, Tobin, R. (1988). " Panel discussion on the implication of regulatory changes for water treatment in the United States." Advances in Giardia research, P. M. Walls, et al., eds., University of Calgary Press, Alberta, Canada.
41. Regli, S., Rose, J. B., Haas, C. N., and, Gerba, C. P. (1991). " Modeling the risk from Giardia and viruses in drinking-water." J. Am. Water Works Assoc., 83 (11), 76-84. JAWWA5 0003-150X
42. Rose, J. B., et al. (2004). " Reduction of pathogens, indicator bacteria, and alternative indicators by wastewater treatment and reclamation processes." Water Environment Research Foundation Rep. 00-PUM2T, Water Environment Research Foundation, Alexandria, VA.
43. Rose, J. B., and, Gerba, C. P. (1991). " Assessing potential health risks from viruses and parasites in reclaimed water in Arizona and Florida, USA." Water Sci. Technol., 23 (10-12), 2091-2098. WSTED4 0273-1223
44. Rose, J. B., Haas, C. N., and, Regli, S. (1991). " Risk assessment and control of waterborne giardiasis." Am. J. Public Health, 81 (6), 709-713. AJHEAA 0090-0036 10.2105/AJPH.81.6.709
45. Roy, S. L., Scallan, E., and, Beach, M. J. (2006). " The rate of acute gastrointestinal illness in developed countries." J. Water Health, 4 (2), 31-69. JWHOBR 1477-8920 10.2166/wh.2006.017
46. Sanaa, M., Bemrah, N., Meyer, S., Cerf, O., and, Mohammed, H. (2000). " Quantitative risk assessment related to microbial food contamination." Revue D' Epidemiologie et De Sante Publique, 48 (2s), 11-24.
47. Sobsey, M., Battigelli, D., Handzel, T., and, Schwab, K. (1995). Male-specific coliphages as indicators of viral contamination of drinking water, AWWA Research Foundation, Denver, CO.
48. Soller, J., Olivieri, A., Eisenberg, J. N. S., Sakaji, R., and, Danielson, R. (2004). " Evaluation of microbial risk assessment techniques and applications." Project 00-PUM-3, Final Project Rep., Water Environment Research Foundation, Alexandria, VA.
49. Tanaka, H., Asano, T., Schroeder, E. D., and, Tchobanoglous, G. (1998). " Estimating the safety of wastewater reclamation and reuse using enteric virus monitoring data." Water Environ. Res., 70 (1), 39-51. WAERED 1061-4303 10.2175/106143098X126874
50. Teunis, P., Takumi, K., and, Shinagawa, K. (2004). " Dose response for infection by Escherichia coli O157:H7 from outbreak data." Risk Anal., 24 (2), 401-407. RIANDF 0272-4332 10.1111/risk.2004.24.issue-2
51. Teunis, P. F., and, Havelaar, A. H. (2000). " The beta poisson dose-response model is not a single-hit model." Risk Anal., 20 (4), 513-521. RIANDF 0272-4332 10.1111/risk.2000.20.issue-4
52. Teunis, P. F. M., et al. (2008). " Norwalk virus: How infectious is it? " J. Med. Virol., 80 (8), 1468-1476. JMVIDB 1096-9071 10.1002/(ISSN)1096-9071
53. Teunis, P. F. M., van der Heijden, O. G., van der Giessen, J. W. B., and, Havelaar, A. H. (1996). " The dose-response relation in human volunteers for gastro-intestinal pathogens." RIVM Rep., National Institute of Public Health in the Environment, The Netherlands.
54. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA). (1986). " Ambient water quality criteria for bacteria." EPA440/5-84-002, Washington, DC.
55. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA). (1991). " Technical support document water quality-based toxics control." Vol. EPA/505/2-90-001.1991, Office of Water, Washington, DC.
56. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA). (1997). Exposure factors handbook, Office of Research and Development, NCEA.
57. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA). (2003). " CSFII analysis of food intake distributions." EPA-600-R-03-029, Washington, DC.
58. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA). (2004). " Guidelines for water reuse." EPA-265/R-03/108, U.S. Agency for International Development, Cincinnati, Ohio.
59. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA). (2006). " National primary drinking water regulations: Long term 2 enhanced surface water treatment rule (LT2ESWTR); final rule., Vol. 40CFR Parts 9, 141 and 142, volume 71, Number 654." Washington, DC.
60. van Ginneken, M., and, Oron, G. (2000). " Risk assessment of consuming agricultural products irrigated with reclaimed wastewater: An exposure model." Water Resour. Res., 36 (9), 2691-2699. WRERAQ 0043-1397 10.1029/2000WR900106
61. Voysey, P. A., and, Brown, M. (2000). " Microbiological risk assessment: A new approach to food safety control." Int. J. Food Microbiol., 58 (3), 173-179. IJFMDD 0168-1605 10.1016/S0168-1605(00)00271-3
62. Wade, T. J., Pai, N., Eisenberg, J. N. S., and, Colford, J. M. (2003). " Do US EPA water quality guidelines for recreational waters prevent gastrointestinal illness? A systematic review and meta-analysis." Environ. Health Perspect., 111 (8), 1102-1109.
63. Ward, R. L., Bernstein, D. I., Young, E. C., Sherwood, J. R., Knowlton, D. R., and, Schiff, G. M. (1986). " Human rotavirus studies in volunteers: determination of infectious dose and serological response to infection." J. Infect. Dis., 154 (5), 871-880.
64. World Health Organization (WHO). (1999). " Health based monitoring of recreational waters: The feasibility of a new approach (The 'Annapolis Protocol')." WHO/SDE/WSH/99.1, Geneva.
65. World Health Organization (WHO). (2004). Guidelines for drinking water quality, 3rd Ed., Geneva.