A critical analysis of paddlewheel-driven raceway ponds for algal biofuel production at commercial scales

Algal Research

Volumn 4, Issue 1, 2014, Pages 76-88

  Rogers, Jonathan N ^a   Rosenberg, Julian N ^a,b   Guzman, Bernardo J ^a   Oh, Victor H ^a   Mimbela, Luz Elena ^c   Ghassemi, Abbas ^c   Betenbaugh, Michael J ^a   Oyler, George A ^a,b,d   Donohue, Marc D ^a,b,e  

^a Johns Hopkins University   (United States)

^b SYNAPTIC RESEARCH LLC   (United States)

^c NEW MEXICO STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^d UNIVERSITY OF NEBRASKA LINCOLN   (United States)

^e JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Algae; Biofuel; Raceway ponds; Sustainability; Technoeconomic analysis

Indexed keywords

EID: 84899105862     PISSN: 22119264     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.algal.2013.11.007     Document Type: Article

References (107)

1. Chamie J., et al. World Population to 2300. Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division, ST/ESA/SER.A/236 2004, United Nations, New York, NY.
2. Annual Energy Outlook U.S. Energy Information Administration. DOE/EIA-0383(2012) June 25, 2012 2012, (www.eia.gov/forecasts/aeo).
3. Richmond A. Handbook of Microalgal Culture: Biotechnology and Applied Phycology 2008, Wiley-Blackwell.
4. Sheehan J., et al. A Look Back at the US Department of Energy's Aquatic Species Program: Biodiesel from Algae. TP-580-24190 1998, National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Golden, CO.
5. Frank E.D., et al. "Life-Cycle Analysis of Algal Lipid Fuels with the GREET Model." ANL/ESD/11-5 2011, Center for Transportation Research, Energy Systems Division, Argonne National Laboratory, Oak Ridge.
6. Davis R., Fishman D., Frank E.D., Wigmosta M.S., et al. Renewable Diesel from Algal Lipids: An Integrated Baseline for Cost, Emissions, and Resource Potential from a Harmonized Model. Argonne National Laboratory, Technical Report: ANL/ESD/12-4, NREL/TP-5100-55431, PNNL-21437 2012, (www.nrel.gov/docs/fy12osti/55431.pdf).
7. Burlew John S. Algal culture. From Laboratory to Pilot Plant 1953, 1. Carnegie Inst. WashingtonPubl 600.
8. Oswald W.J., Golueke C.G. Biological transformation of solar energy. Adv. Appl. Microbiol. 1960, 11:223-242.
9. Lee R.E. Phycology 1980, Cambridge University Press, New York.
10. Bilanovic Dragoljub, et al. Freshwater and marine microalgae sequestering of CO2 at different C and N concentrations-Response surface methodology analysis. Energy Convers. Manag. 2009, 50(2):262-267.
11. Chiu Sheng-Yi, et al. Lipid accumulation and CO2 utilization of Nanochloropsis oculata in response to CO2 aeration. Bioresour. Technol. 2009, 100(2):833-838.
12. Wang Bei, et al. CO2 bio-mitigation using microalgae. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 2008, 79(5):707-718.
13. Redfield A.C. On the proportions of organic derivatives in sea water and their relation to the composition of plankton. James Johnstone Memorial Volume 1934, 177-192. University Press of Liverpool. R.J. Daniel (Ed.).
14. Redfield A.C. The biological control of chemical factors in the environment. Am. Sci. 1958, 46:205-221.
15. Martiny Adam C., et al. Strong latitudinal patterns in the elemental ratios of marine plankton and organic matter. Nat. Geosci. 2013, 6(4):279-283.
16. Welsh David T., et al. Denitrification, nitrogen fixation, community primary productivity and inorganic-N and oxygen fluxes in an intertidal Zostera noltii meadow. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 2000, 208:65-77.
17. Moreno José, et al. Outdoor cultivation of a nitrogen-fixing marine cyanobacterium, Anabaena sp. ATCC 33047. Biomol. Eng. 2003, 20(4):191-197.
18. Berman Tom, Chava Sara Algal growth on organic compounds as nitrogen sources. J. Plankton Res. 1999, 21(8):1423-1437.
19. Benemann John R., Oswald William J. Systems and economic analysis of microalgae ponds for conversion of CO2 to biomass. Final Report. No. DOE/PC/93204-T5 1996, California Univ, Berkeley, CA (United States), (Dept. of Civil Engineering).
20. Craggs Rupert, Sutherland Donna, Campbell Helena Hectare-scale demonstration of high rate algal ponds for enhanced wastewater treatment and biofuel production. J. Appl. Phycol. 2012, 24(3):329-337.
21. Vasudevan Venkatesh, et al. Environmental performance of algal biofuel technology options. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2012, 46(4):2451-2459.
22. Jensen M., Andersen A.H. Biofuels: a contested response to climate change. Sustainability Sci. Pract. Policy 2013, 9(1):42-56.
23. Williams B.J.L.B., Laurens L.M.L. Microalgae as biodiesel & biomass feedstocks: review & analysis of the biochemistry, energetics & economics. Energy Environ. Sci. 2010, 3:554-590.
24. Huntley M.E., Redalje D.G. CO2 mitigation and renewable oil from photosynthetic microbes: a new appraisal. Mitig. Adapt. Strateg. Glob. Chang. 2007, 12(4):573-608.
25. NationalResearch Council Sustainable Development of Algal Biofuels 2012, National Academies Press, (Available at: http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=13437).
26. Kendall A., Yuan J. Comparing life cycle assessments of different biofuel options. Curr. Opin. Chem. Biol. 2013.
27. Maintenance Estimate Retrieved December 13, 2012 from. http://www.reliableplant.com/Read/7050/cost-replacement-value.
28. EISA Mandates Renewable Fuel Standard Retrieved April 10th, 2013 from. http://www.epa.gov/otag/fuels/renewablefuels/.
29. Monroe Environmental Retrieved December 13, 2012 from. http://www.monroeenvironmental.com/PDF/ME_Circular_Clarifiers.pdf.
30. WEF Clarifier Design. WEF Manual of Practice No. FD-8 2005, McGraw-Hill. 2nd ed.
31. Peters Max S., et al. Plant Design and Economics for Chemical Engineers 2002, 793. McGraw-Hill. 5th ed.
32. Sangam Henri P., Kerry Rowe R. Effects of exposure conditions on the depletion of antioxidants from high-density polyethylene (HDPE) geomembranes. Can. Geotech. J. 2002, 39(6):1221-1230.
33. EPA East Helena Capital Costs for Lands to be Developed Retrieved December 13, 2012 from. http://www.epa.gov/region8/superfund/mt/easthelena/03_CostTables.pdf.
34. Rosenberg J.N., Mathias A., Korth K., Betenbaugh M.J., Oyler G.A. Microalgal biomass production and CO2 sequestration from an integrated ethanol biorefinery in Iowa: a technical appraisal and economic feasibility evaluation. Biomass Bioenergy 2011, 35:3865-3876.
35. Good Mike Railroad Construction Cost Estimates 2008, Henry Country Library, (Retrieved December 13, 2012 from, http://tacnet.missouri.org/history/railroads/rrcosts.html).
36. Generic Cost Per Mile Models Retrieved December 13, 2012 from. http://citizensforsouthernillinois.org/?page_id=72.
37. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach. "Biodiesel Profitability". Unpublished result retrieved December 13, 2012 from, http://www.extension.iastate.edu/agdm/energy/xls/d1-15biodieselprofitability.xlsx.
38. Harrison Machine & Plastic Co. Retrieved December 13, 2012 from. http://www.harrisonplastic.com/aboutpvc.html.
39. Mueller Industries Wholesale Pipe Price Lists Retrieved December 13, 2013 from. http://www.muellerindustries.com/catalogs/wholesale-price-lists.
40. Lands of New Mexico Retrieved May 5, 2013 from. http://www.landsofnewmexico.com/new_mexico/index.cfm.
41. Lansford R., Hernandez J., Enis P.J., Truby D., Mapel C. Evaluation of available saline water resources in New Mexico for the production of microalgae. Report, Solar Energy Research Institute, Golden, Colorado, SERI/TP 232-3597 1990, (83 pp.).
42. All Cost Data Turbine Pumps, Cast Iron Retrieved December 13, 2013 from. http://www.allcostdata.info/browse.html/152901000.
43. Pentair Co. Propeller Pumps Retrieved December 13, 2013 from. http://www.fairbanksnijhuis.com/EngineeredProduct_N_Propeller.aspx.
44. Oakland County Water and Wastewater Masterplan. Alternative Analysis Sept 2007, vol. 4. (URS Project No. 13647263).
45. Blankenship Robert E., et al. Comparing photosynthetic and photovoltaic efficiencies and recognizing the potential for improvement. Science 2011, 805-809. (332.6031).
46. Sun A., Davis R., Starbuck M., Ben-Amotz A., Pate R., Pienkos P.T. Comparative cost analysis of algal oil production for biofuels. Energy 2011, 36(8):5169-5179.
47. Index Mundi DAP Fertilizer vs Urea Retrieved December 13, 2012 from. http://www.indexmundi.com/commodities/?commodity=dap-fertilizer&commodity=urea.
48. Behnke Craig, Sapphire Energy, Inc. Development of Value-Added Products from Residual Algae Biomass. DOE EERE Biomass Peer Review (May 20-23, 2013, Alexandria, VA), Slide 7 May 20-23, 2013, Accessed September 11, 2013. Available from: https://www2.eere.energy.gov/biomass/peer_review2013/Portal/.
49. Office of EERE Bioenergy Technologies At-a-Glance Retrieved May 23, 2013 from. http://www1.eere.energy.gov/office_eere/bo_budget_fy14.html.
50. Schlagermann Pascal, et al. Composition of Algal Oil and Its Potential as Biofuel. J. Combust. 2012, (Article ID 285185) (http://www.hindawi.com/journals/jc/2012/285185/abs/).
51. Chisti Yusuf Biodiesel from microalgae. Biotechnol. Adv. 2007, 25(3):294-306.
52. Barbosa Maria J., et al. Optimization of biomass, vitamins, and carotenoid yield on light energy in a flat-panel reactor using the A-stat technique. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2005, 89(2):233-242.
53. Pulz Otto, Scheibenbogen Karl Photobioreactors: design and performance with respect to light energy input. Bioprocess and Algae Reactor Technology, Apoptosis 1998, 123-152. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg.
54. Gordon Jeffrey M., Polle Juergen E.W. Ultrahigh bioproductivity from algae. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 2007, 76(5):969-975.
55. Janssen M., Slenders P., Tramper J., Mur L.R., Wijffels R.H. Photosynthetic efficiency of Dunaliella tertiolecta under short light/dark cycles. Enzyme Microb. Technol. 2001, 29(4-5):298-305.
56. Lundquist T.J., et al. A Realistic Technology and Engineering Assessment of Algae Biofuel Production 2010, 1. Energy Biosciences Institute.
57. DARPA Defense Sciences Office. Biofuels Retrieved April 30, 2013 from. http://www.darpa.mil/Our_Work/DSO/Programs/Biofuels.aspx.
58. Craggs Rupert J., McAuley Paul J., Smith Valerie J. Wastewater nutrient removal by marine microalgae grown on a corrugated raceway. Water Res. 1997, 31(7):1701-1707.
59. Ben-Amotz Ami Large scale open algae ponds. Technical report 2008, The National Institute of Oceanograpy, Israel.
60. Hellwig S., Drossard J., Twyman R.M., Fischer R. Plant cell cultures for the production of recombinant proteins. Nat. Biotechnol. 2004, 22:1415-1422.
61. Mann N.R., Herbst R.S., Hess J.R., Kochergin V. Enhanced flux, erosion resistant membranes for biomass separations-Part II. Membr. Technol. 2004, 2004:5-9.
62. Schlesinger A., Eisenstadt D., Bar-Gil A., Carmely H., Einbinder S., Gressel J. Inexpensive non-toxic flocculation of microalgae contradicts theories; overcoming a major hurdle to bulk algal production. Biotechnol. Adv. 2012, 30:1023-1030.
63. Ghernaouta B., Ghernaoutb D., Saibabpages A. Algae and cyanotoxins removal by coagulation/flocculation: a review. Desalin. Water Treat. 2010, 20:133-143.
64. Wyatt N.B., Gloe L.M., Brady P.V., Hewson J.C., Grillet A.M., Hankins M.G., Pohl P.I. Critical conditions for ferric chloride-induced flocculation of freshwater algae. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2012, 109(2):493-501.
65. Gutzeit G., Lorch D., Weber A., Engels M., Neis U. Bioflocculent algal-bacterial biomass improves low-cost wastewater treatment. Water Sci. Technol. 2005, 52(12):9-18.
66. Salim S., Bosma R., Vermuë M.H., Wijffels R.H. Harvesting of microalgae by bio-flocculation. J. Appl. Phycol. 2010, 23(5):849-855.
67. Salim S., Vermuë M.H., Wijffels R.H. Ratio between autoflocculating and target microalgae affects the energy-efficient harvesting by bio-flocculation. Bioresour. Technol. 2012, 118:49-55.
68. Method and System for Efficient Harvesting of Microalgae and Cyanobacteria WIPO Patent No. 2011040955 8 Apr. 2011.
69. Oyler G.A., Rosenberg J.N., Weeks D.P. Single Chain Antibodies for Photosynthetic Microorganisms and Method of Use, US 2012/032662 2012.
70. Lundquist T.J., Hammond D., Green F.B., Oswald W.J. Tertiary Pilot Study Report, Recycled Wastewater Facilities Plan 2004, 70. Oswald Engineering Associates, Inc., City of St. Helena, California.
71. Rosenberg J.N., Oyler G.A., Wilkinson L., Betenbaugh M.J. A green light for engineered algae: redirecting metabolism to fuel a biotechnology revolution. Curr. Opin. Biotechnol. 2008, 19:430-436.
72. Flynn K.J., Mitra A., Greenwell H.C., Sui J. Monster potential meets potential monster: pros and cons of deploying genetically modified microalgae for biofuels production. J. R. Soc. Interface 2013, 3.1. (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/issues/222341/).
73. Flynn K.J., Greenwell H.C., Lovitt R.W., Shields R.J. Selection for fitness at the individual or population levels: modeling effects of genetic modifications in microalgae on productivity and environmental safety. J. Theor. Biol. 2010, 263(3):269-280.
74. Gressel J., van der Vlugt C.J.B., Bergmans H.E.N. Environmental risks of large scale cultivation of microalgae: mitigation of spills. Algal Res. 2013, 2:286-298.
75. Henley W.J., Litaker R.W., Novoveská L., Duke C.S., Quemada H.D., Sayre R.T. Initial risk assessment of genetically modified (GM) microalgae for commodity-scale biofuel cultivation. Algal Res. 2013, 2(1):66-77.
76. Savage P.E., Levine R.B., Huessman C.M. Hydrothermal processing of biomass. Thermochemical conversion of biomass to liquid fuels and chemicals 2010, 192-221.
77. Miao Xiaoling, Qingyu Wu., Yang Changyan Fast pyrolysis of microalgae to produce renewable fuels. J. Anal. Appl. Pyrol. 2004, 71(2):855-863.
78. Dhargalkar V.K., Verlecar X.N. Southern Ocean seaweeds: a resource for exploration in food and drugs. Aquaculture 2009, 287:229-242.
79. Renaud Susan M., et al. Effect of temperature on growth, chemical composition and fatty acid composition of tropical Australian microalgae grown in batch cultures. Aquaculture 2002, 211(1):195-214.
80. Brown M.R., et al. The vitamin content of microalgae used in aquaculture. J. Appl. Phycol. 1999, 11(3):247-255.
81. Singh Jasvinder, Sai Gu. Commercialization potential of microalgae for biofuels production. Renew. Sust. Energ. Rev. 2010, 14(9):2596-2610.
82. Olivares Jose A. Challenges and opportunities in algal biodiesel development. No. LA-UR-11-00834; LA-UR-11-834 2011, Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL).
83. EPA CO2 Emissions Estimates Retrieved April 26th, 2013 from. http://www.epa.gov/greenpower/pubs/calcmeth.htm.
84. Kadam K.L. Power plant flue gas as a source of CO2 for Microalgae cultivation: economic impact of different process options. Energy Convers. Manag. 1997, 38:505-510. (Suppl.).
85. Huang W. Impact of Rising Natural Gas Prices on U.S. Ammonia Supply. USDA WRS-0702 August 2007.
86. U.S.Geological Survey Mineral Commodity Summaries January 2013.
87. Jasinski S.M. Phosphate Rock, Statistics and Information 2006, US Geological Survey.
88. U.S.Geological Survey Mineral Commodity Summaries January 2006.
89. Bohutskyi P., Bouwer E. Biogas production from algae and cyanobacteria through anaerobic digestion: a review, analysis, and research needs. Adv. Biofuels Bioprod. 2013, 873-975.
90. Aslan S., Kapdan I.K. Batch kinetics of nitrogen and phosphorus removal from synthetic wastewater by algae. Ecol. Eng. 2006, 28(1):64-70.
91. 2 capture, wastewater treatment and biofuel production by microalgae culturing-a review. Renew. Sust. Energy Rev. 2013, 27:622-653.
92. Orfield Nolan, Keoleian Greg, Love Nancy A GIS based national assessment of algal biofuel production potential through flue-gas and wastewater coutilization. 6th International Conference of the International Society for Industrial Ecology (ISIE) Proceedings. Berkeley, CA, June 7-10 2011, Abstract #591 2011.
93. Cantrell Keri B., et al. Livestock waste-to-bioenergy generation opportunities. Bioresour. Technol. 2008, 99(17):7941-7953.
94. Venteris E.R., Skaggs R., Coleman A.M., Wigmosta M.S. A GIS cost model to assess the availability of freshwater, seawater, and saline groundwater for algal biofuel production in the United States. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2013, 47(9):4840-4849.
95. Lee Yuan-Kun Microalgal mass culture systems and methods: their limitation and potential. J. Appl. Phycol. 2001, 13(4):307-315.
96. Waller Peter, et al. The algae raceway integrated design for optimal temperature management. Biomass Bioenergy 2012, 46:702-709.
97. Longworth John New Mexico water use by categories 2005. New Mexico Office of the state Engineer Technical Report 52 2005, (http://www.ose.state.nm.us/PDF/Publications/Library/TechnicalReports/TechReport-052.pdf).
98. Kenny J.F., Barber N.L., Hutson S.S., Linsey K.S., Lovelace J.K., Maupin M.A. Estimated Use of Water in the United States in 2005: U.S. Geological Survey Circular 2009, 1344. (52 pp.).
99. Lansford R., Hernandez J., Enis P.J. Evaluation of available saline water resources in New Mexico for the production of microalgae. FY 1986 Aquatic Species Program Annual Report 1987, 227-248. Solar Energy Research Institute, Golden, Colorado, (SERI/SP-231-3071).
100. Ketheesan B., Nirmalakhandan N. Feasibility of microalgal cultivation in a pilot-scale airlift-driven raceway reactor. Bioresour. Technol. 2012, 108:196-202.
101. Christenson L.B., Sims R.C. Rotating algal biofilm reactor and spool harvester for wastewater treatment with biofuels by-products. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2012, 109:1674-1684.
102. Ozkana A., Kinneya K., Katza L., Berberoglub H. Reduction of water and energy requirement of algae cultivation using an algae biofilm photobioreactor. Bioresour. Technol. 2012, 114:542-548.
103. Greenwell H.C., Laurens L.M.L., Shields R.J., Lovitt R.W., Flynn K.J. Placing microalgae on the biofuels priority list: a review of the technological challenges. J. R. Soc. Interface 2010, 7:703-726.
104. USGS NWIS Groundwater Levels for New Mexico Retrieved April 23, 2013 from. http://nwis.waterdata.usgs.gov/nm/nwis/gwlevels.
105. The Engineering Toolbox Retrieved May 10, 2013 from. http://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/specific-heat-fluids-d_151.html.
106. OSHA Hexane Boiling Point Retrieved May 10, 2013 from. https://www.osha.gov/SLTC/healthguidelines/n-hexane/recognition.html.
107. Zhu Tingju, Ringler Claudia, Cai Ximing Energy Price and Groundwater Extraction for Agriculture: Exploring the Energy-Water-Food Nexus at the Global and Basin Levels. International Conference of Linkages Between Energy and Water Management for Agriculture in Developing Countries, Hyderabad, India 2007.