Sense and nonsense in conservation agriculture: Principles, pragmatism and productivity in Australian mixed farming systems

Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment

Volumn 187, Issue , 2014, Pages 133-145

  Kirkegaard, John A ^a   Conyers, Mark K ^b   Hunt, James R ^a   Kirkby, Clive A ^a   Watt, Michelle ^a   Rebetzke, Greg J ^a  

^a CSIRO   (Australia)

^b E H Graham Centre for Agricultural Innovation   (Australia)

Author keywords

Crop sequence; Farming system; Mixed farming; No till; Stubble retention

Indexed keywords

BIOPHYSICS; CROP PRODUCTION; FARMING SYSTEM; MIXED FARMING; SOCIOECONOMIC SURVEY; STUBBLE; ZERO TILLAGE;

AUSTRALIA;

EID: 84898807703     PISSN: 01678809     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.agee.2013.08.011     Document Type: Article

References (88)

1. ABS (Australian Bureau of Statistics) Agricultural Commodities, Australia 2009-10 2011, Commonwealth of Australia.
2. Andersson J.A., d'Souza From adoption claims to understanding farming contexts: a literature review of conservation agriculture (CA) adoption among smallholder farmers in southern Africa. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 2013, 10.1016/j.agee.2013.08.008.
3. Andersson J.A., Giller K.E. On heretics and God's blanket salesmen: contested claims for conservation agriculture the politics of its promotion in African smallholder farming. Contested Agronomy: Agricultural Research in a Changing World 2012, Earthscan, London. J. Sumberg, J. Thompson (Eds.).
4. Angus J.A. Nitrogen supply and demand in Australian agriculture. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 2001, 41:277-288.
5. Baan C.D., Grevers N.C.J., Schoenau J.J. Effects of a single tillage on long-term no-till prairie soils. Canadian Journal of Soil Science 2009, 89:521-530.
6. Baker J.M., Ochsner T.E., Venterea R.T., Griffis T.J. Tillage and soil carbon sequestration-what do we really know?. Agriculture, Ecosystem and Environment 2007, 118:1-5.
7. Baudron F., Tittonell P., Corbeels M., Letourmy P., Giller K.E. Comparative performance of conservation agriculture and current smallholder farming practices in semi-arid Zimbabwe. Field Crops Research 2012, 132:117-128.
8. Bell L.W., Moore A.D., Kirkegaard J.A. Evolution of crop-livestock integration systems that improve farm productivity and environmental performance in Australia. European Journal of Agronomy 2013, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.eja.2013.04.007, published online April 2013.
9. Bell L.W., Kirkegaard J.A., Swan A., Hunt J.R., Huth H.I., Fettell N.A. Impact of soil damage by grazing livestock on crop productivity. Soil and Tillage Research 2011, 113:19-29.
10. Bissett A., Richardson A.E., Baker G., Kirkegaard J.A., Thrall P.H. Bacterial community response to tillage and nutrient additions in a long-term wheat cropping experiment. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 2013, 58:281-292.
11. Bolliger A., Magid J., Jorge T., Amado C., Neto F.S., Ribeiro M., Calegari A., Ralisch R., Neergaard A. Taking stock of the Brazilian "zero-till revolution": a review of landmark research and farmer practice. Advances in Agronomy 2006, 91:47-110.
12. Carsky R.J., Singh B.B., Oyewole B. Contribution of early season cowpea to late season maize in the savanna zone of West Africa. Biological Agriculture and Horticulture 2001, 18:303-315.
13. Chan K.Y., Conyers M.K., Li G.D., Helyar K.R., Poile G., Oats A., Barchia I.M. Soil carbon dynamics under different cropping and pasture management in temperature Australia: results of three long-term experiments. Australian Journal of Soil Research 2011, 49:320-328.
14. Chhokar R.S., Sharma R.K. Multiple herbicide resistance in little seed canary grass (Phalaris minor): a threat to wheat production in India. Weed Biology and Management 2008, 8:112-123.
15. CSIRO Soil Carbon Sequestration Potential: A Review for Australian Agriculture 2010, www.csiro.au/files/files/pwiv.pdf.
16. Conyers M.K., Heenan D.P., McGhie W.J., Poile G.J. Amelioration of acidity with time by limestone under contrasting tillage. Soil and Tillage Research 2003, 72:85-94.
17. Corbeels M., de Graaff J., Ndah T.H., Penot E., Baudron F., Naudin K., Andrieu A., Chirat G., Schuler J., Nyagumbo I., Rusinamhodzi L., Traore K., Mzoba H.D., Adalwa I.S. Understanding the impact and adoption of conservation agriculture in Africa: a multi-scale analysis. Agriculture, Ecosystem and Environment 2013, (in press, this Edition).
18. Cornish P.S., Pratley J.E. Tillage-New Directions in Australian Agriculture 1987, Inkata Press, Melbourne.
19. Donald C.A. The progress of Australian agriculture and the role of pastures in environmental change. Australian Journal of Science 1965, 27:187-198.
20. Donald C.A., Williams C.H. Fertility and productivity of a podzolic soil as influenced by subterranean clover T. Subterraneum and superphosphate. Australian Journal Agricultural Research 1954, 5:664-687.
21. Erenstein O. Crops residue mulching in tropical and semi-tropical countries: an evaluation of residue availability and other technological implications. Soil and Tillage Research 2002, 67:115-133.
22. Eyre J.X., Routley R.A., Rodriguez D., Dimes J.P. Intercropping maize and mungbean to intensify summer cropping systems in Queensland, Australia. Fifth World Congress on Conservation Agriculture and Farming Systems Design, Brisbane, Australia, 26-29 September 2011 2011, 1-3.
23. FAO The Main Principles of Conservation Agriculture 2013, http://www.fao.org/ag/ca/1b.html#1a-1.
24. Farooq M., Flower K.C., Jabran K., Wahid A., Siddique K.H.M. Crop yield and weed management in rainfed conservation agriculture. Soil and Tillage Research 2011, 117:172-183.
25. Fisher J., Tozer P., Abrecht D. Livestock in no-till cropping systems-a story of trade-offs. Animal Production Science 2012, 52:197-214.
26. Franzluebbers A.J. Soil organic carbon sequestration and agricultural greenhouse gas emissions in southeastern USA. Soil and Tillage Research 2005, 83:120-147.
27. Giller K.E., Eitter E., Corbeels M., Tittonell P. Conservation agriculture and smallholder farming in Africa: the heretics view. Field Crops Research 2009, 114:23-34.
28. Giller K.E., Corbeels M., Nyamangara J., Triomphe B., Affholder F., Scopel E., Tittonell P. A research agenda to explore the role of conservation agriculture in African smallholder farming systems. Field Crops Research 2011, 124:468-472.
29. Govaerts B., Sayre K.D., Deckers J. Stable high yields with zero tillage and permanent bed planting?. Field Crops Research 2005, 94:33-42.
30. Govaerts B., Verhulst N., Castellanos-Navarrete A., Sayre K.D., Dixon J., Dendooven L. Conservation agriculture and soil carbon sequestration: between myth and farmer reality. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences 2009, 28:97-122.
31. Grandy A.S., Robertson G.P., Thelen K.D. Do productivity and environmental trade-offs justify periodically cultivating no-till cropping systems?. Agronomy Journal 2006, 98:1377-1383.
32. GRDC GRDC Farm Practices Survey Report 2010, http://www.grdc.com.au/director/events/grdcpublications/grdcfarmpracticessurvey.
33. GRDC GRDC Farm Practices Survey Report 2012, http://www.grdc.com.au/~/media/1A94FC21CA514CF2A9222991418C17F7.pdf.
34. Gupta V., Rovira A., Roget D. Principles and management of soil biological factors for sustainable farming systems. Rainfed Farming Systems 2011, 149-184. Springer Dordrecht, Netherlands, (Chapter 6). P. Tow, I. Cooper, I. Partridge, C. Birch (Eds.).
35. Hatfield J., Sauer T., Prueger J. Managing soil to achieve greater water use efficiency: a review. Agronomy Journal 2001, 93:271-280.
36. Helyar K. Nitrogen cycle and soil acidification. Journal of Australian Institute of Agricultural Science 1976, 42:217-221.
37. Herrero M., Thornton P.K., Notenbaert A.M., Wood S., Msangi S., Freeman H.A., Bossio D., Dixon J., Peters M., van de Steeg J., Lynam J., Parthasarathy Rao P., MacMillan S., Gerard B., McDermott J., Sere C., Rosegrant M. Smart investments in sustainable food production: revisiting mixed crop-livestock systems. Science 2010, 327:822-825.
38. Hughes N., Lawson K., David A., Jackson T., Sheng Y. Productivity pathways: climate-adjusted production frontiers for the Australian broad-acre cropping industry 2011, http://purl.umn.edu//100563, Feb 8-11, 2011.
39. Hunt J.R., Kirkegaard J.A. Re-evaluating the contribution of summer fallow rain to wheat yield in southern Australia. Crop and Pasture Science 2012, 62:915-929.
40. Hunt J.R., Swan A., Kirkegaard J.A., Breust P., Peoples M.B. Do livestock reduce crop yields in conservation farming systems? 2011, 382-383.
41. Kirkegaard J.A. A review of trends in wheat yield responses to conservation cropping in Australia. Australian Journal Experimental Agriculture 1995, 35:835-848.
42. Kirkegaard J.A., Angus J.F., Gardner P.A., Muller W. Reduced growth and yield of wheat with conservation cropping: field studies in the first year of the cropping phase. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 1994, 45:511-528.
43. Kirkegaard J.A., Christen O., Krupinsky J., Layzell D. Break crop benefits in temperate wheat production. Field Crops Research 2008, 107:185-195.
44. Kirkegaard J.A., Hunt J. Increased productivity by matching farming system management and genotypes in water-limited environments. Journal of Experimental Botany 2010, 61:4129-4143.
45. Kirkegaard J.A., Sprague S.J., Dove H., Kelman W. Dual-purpose canola-a new opportunity in mixed farming systems. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 2008, 59:291-302.
46. Kirkegaard J.A., Peoples M.B., Angus J.F., Unkovitch M.J. Diversity and evolution of rainfed farming systems in southern Australia. Rainfed Farming Systems 2011, 715-754. Springer, Dordrecht Netherlands, (Chapter 26). P. Tow, I. Cooper, I. Partridge, C. Birch (Eds.).
47. Kirkby C.A., Kirkegaard J.A., Richardson A.E., Wade L.J., Blanchard C., Batten G. Stable soil organic matter: a comparison of C:N:P:S ratios in Australian and other world soils. Geoderma 2011, 163:197-208.
48. Kirkby C.A., Richardson A.E., Wade L.J., Batten G.D., Blanchard C., Kirkegaard J.A. Carbon-nutrient stoichiometry to increase soil carbon sequestration. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 2013, (in press).
49. Lahmar R., Bationo B.A., Lamso N.D., Guero Y., Tittonell P. Tailoring conservation agriculture technologies to West Africa semi-arid zones: building on traditional local practices for soil restoration. Field Crops Research 2012, 132:158-167.
50. Lal R. Constraints to adopting no-till farming in developing countries. Soil and Tillage Research 2007, 94:1-3.
51. Lilley J.M., Moore A.D. Trade-offs between productivity and ground cover in mixed farming systems in the Murrumbidgee catchment of New South Wales. Animal Production Science 2009, 49:837-851.
52. Lithourgidis A.S., Dordas C.A., Damalas C.A., Vlachostergios D.N. Annual intercrop: an alternative pathway for sustainable agriculture. Australian Journal of Crop Science 2011, 5:396-410.
53. Llewellyn R.S., D'Emden F.H., Kuehne G. Extensive use of no-tillage in grain-growing regions of Australia. Field Crops Research 2012, 132:204-212.
54. Llewellyn R.S., D'Emden F.H. Adoption of No-till Cropping Practices in Australian Grain Growing Regions. CSIRO Report for GRDC, SA No-till Farmers Association and CAAANZ 2010, 32. http://www.msfp.org.au/docs/media_260.pdf.
55. Luo Z., Wang E., Sun O.J. Can no-tillage stimulate carbon sequestration in agricultural soils?. A meta-analysis of paired experiments. Agriculture, Ecosystem and Environment 2010, 139:224-231.
56. Maraseni T.N., Cockfield G. Does the adoption of zero tillage reduce greenhouse gas emissions? An assessment for the grains industry in Australia. Agricultural Systems 2011, 104:451-458.
57. Moran K.K., Six J., Horwath W.R. Role of mineral-nitrogen in residue decomposition and stable soil organic matter formation. Soil Science Society of America Journal 2005, 69:1730-1736.
58. Moreno M.M., Lacasta C., Meco R., Moreno C. Rainfed crop energy balance of different farming systems and crop rotations in a semi-arid environment: results of a long-term trial. Soil and Tillage Research 2011, 114:18-27.
59. Musa A.M., Harris D., Johansen C., Kumar J.V.D.K. Short duration chickpea to replace fallow after a man rice: the role of on-farm seed priming in the High Barind Tract of Bangladesh. Experimental Agriculture 2001, 37:509-522.
60. Newman P. Moulboard Ploughing of Sandplain Soils-More Gain, Fewer Weeds GRDC Agribusiness Crop Updates. Perth 2011, pp. 143-146, http://www.agric.wa.gov.au/objtwr/imported_assets/content/amt/agb/crop_updates_proceedings_february2011.pdf?noicon.
61. Nyamangara J., Mashingaidze N., Nyengerai K., Kunzekweguta M., Masvaya E.N., Tirivavi R., Mazvimavi K. Weed growth and labour demand under hand-hoe based reduced tillage in smallholder fields in Zimbabwe. Agriculture Ecosystems and Environment 2013, (in press, this Edition).
62. Palm C.A., Blanco-Canqui H., DeClerck F., Gatere L., Grace P. Conservation agriculture and ecosystem services: and overview. Agriculture, Ecosystem and Environment 2013, (in press).
63. Pannell D.J., Llewellyn R.S., Corbeels M. The farm-level economics of conservation agriculture for resource-poor farmers. Agriculture, Ecosystem and Environment 2013, (in press, this Edition).
64. Paul K.I., Black A.S., Conyers M.K. Development of acidic subsurface layers of soil under various management systems. Advances in Agronomy 2003, 78:187-214.
65. Peoples M., Hunt J., Swan T., Watson L., Li G., Lowrie R., Breust P., Browne C., Craig S. Doing the numbers: the role and contributions of break crops in cropping systems 2013, 51-74.
66. Preston C. Australian Glyphosate Resistance Register. Australian Glyphosate Sustainability Working Group 2013, http://glyphosateresistance.org.au (viewed 30/7/2013).
67. Purakayastha T.J., Huggins D.R., Smith J.L. Carbon sequestration in native prairie, perennial grass, no-till and cultivated Palouse silt loam. Soil Science Society of America Journal 2008, 72:534-540.
68. Rainbow R., Derpsch R. Advances in no-till farming technologies and soil compaction management in rainfed farming systems. Rainfed Farming Systems 2011, 991-1014. Springer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands, (Chapter 39). P. Tow, I. Cooper, I. Partridge, C. Birch (Eds.).
69. Rebetzke G.J., Ellis M.H., Bonnett D.G., Richards R.A. Molecular mapping of genes for coleoptile growth in bread wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). Theoretical and Applied Genetics 2007, 114:1173-1183.
70. Rebetzke G.J., Chapman S.C., McIntyre L., Condon A.G., Richards R.A., Watt M., van Herwaarden A. Grain yield improvement in water-limited environments. Wheat: Science and Trade 2009, 215-249. Wiley-Blackwell, Ames, IA. B.F. Carver (Ed.).
71. Richards R.A., Rebetzke G.J., Watt M., Condon A.G., Spielmeyer W., Dolferus R. Breeding for improved water-productivity in temperate cereals: phenotyping, quantitative trait loci, markers and the selection environment. Functional Plant Biology 2010, 37:1-13.
72. Robertson M.J., Lawes R.A., Bathgate A., Bryne F., White P., Sands R. Determinants of the proportion of break crops on Western Australian broad-acre farms. Crop and Pasture Science 2010, 61:203-213.
73. Robertson M.J., Llewellyn R.S., Mandel R., Lawes R., Bramely R.G.V., Swift L., Metz N., O'Callaghan C. Adoption of variable rate fertiliser application in the Australian grains industry: status, issues and prospects. Precision Agriculture 2012, 13:181-199.
74. Rumpel C. Does burning of harvesting residues increase soil carbon storage. Journal of Soil Science and Plant Nutrition 2008, 8:44-51.
75. Sanchez P.A. Tripling crop yields in tropical Africa. Nature Geoscience 2010, 3:299-300.
76. Scott B.J., Eberbach P.L., Evans J., Wade L.J. Stubble Retention in Cropping Systems in Southern Australia: Benefits and Challenges. EH Graham Centre Monograph No. 1 2010, http://www.csu.edu.au/research/grahamcentre.
77. Seymour M., Kirkegaard J.A., Peoples M.B., White P.F., French R.J. Break-crop benefits to wheat in Western Australia-insight from over three decades of research. Crop and Pasture Science 2012, 63:1-16.
78. Simpfendorfer S., Kirkegaard J.A., Heenan D.P., Wong P.T.W. Reduced early growth of direct-drilled wheat in southern New South Wales-role of root inhibitory pseudomonads. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 2002, 53:323-331.
79. Simpson R.J., Oberson A., Culvenor R.A., Ryan M.H., Veneklaas E.J., Lambers H., Lynch J.P., Ryan P.R., Delhaize E., Smith F.A., Smith S.E., Harvey P.R., Richardson A.E. Strategies and agronomic interventions to improve the phosphorus-use efficiency of farming systems. Plant and Soil 2011, 349:89-120.
80. Soetedjo.F N.P., Martin L.D., Janes A.J.V. Intercropping with canola improves the productivity and sustainability of field pea. 11th Australian Agronomy Conference 2003, www.regional.org.au/au/asa/2003/c/4/martin.htm.
81. Thierfelder C., Cheesman S., Rusinamhodzi L. Benefits and challenges of crop rotations in maize-based conservation agriculture (CA) cropping systems of southern Africa. International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability 2012, 1-17. 10.1080/14735903.2012.703894.
82. Thomas G.A., Titmarsh G.W., Freebairn D.M., Radford B.J. No-tillage and conservation farming practices in grain growing areas of Queensland-a review of 40 years of development. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 2007, 47:887-898.
83. Tittonell P., Van Wijk M.T., Herrero M., Rufino M.C., de Ridder N., Giller K.E. Beyond resource constraints-exploring the biophysical feasibility of options for the intensification of smallholder crop-livestock systems in Vihiga district, Kenya. Agricultural Systems 2009, 101:1-19.
84. Virgona J.M., Gummer F.A.J., Angus J.F. Effects of grazing on wheat growth, yield, development water use and nitrogen use. Australian Journal Agricultural Research 2006, 57:1307-1319.
85. Von UexkÜll H.R., Mutert E. Global extent, development and economic impact of acid soils. Plant and Soil 1995, 171:1-15.
86. Watt M., McCully M.E., Kirkegaard J.A. Soil strength and rate of root elongation alter the accumulation of Pseudomonas spp. and other bacteria in the rhizosphere of wheat. Functional Plant Biology 2003, 30:483-491.
87. Watt M., Kirkegaard J.A., Passioura J.B. Rhizosphere biology and crop productivity. Australian Journal of Soil Research 2006, 44:299-317.
88. Wortmann C.S., Drijber R.A., Franti T.G. One-time tillage of no-till crop land five years post-tillage. Agronomy Journal 2010, 102:1302-1307.