Recommended practices for exposing pilot-induced oscillations or tendencies in the development process

USAF Developmental Test and Evaluation Summit

Volumn , Issue , 2004, Pages

  Mitchell, David G ^a   Klyde, David H ^b  

^a Hoh Aeronautics Inc   (United States)

^b SYSTEMS TECHNOLOGY INC   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

CATASTROPHIC EVENT; COMMERCIAL AIRCRAFT; DEVELOPMENT PROCESS; FLY-BY-WIRE DESIGNS; INHERENT INSTABILITY; OPERATIONAL FLIGHTS; PILOT-INDUCED OSCILLATIONS; RECOMMENDED PRACTICE;

AIRCRAFT CONTROL; CONTROL SURFACES; TESTING;

AIRCRAFT;

EID: 84896693217     PISSN: None     EISSN: None     Source Type: Conference Proceeding    
DOI: None     Document Type: Conference Paper

References (52)

1. Matranga, G. J., Analysis of X-15 Landing Approach and Flare Characteristics Determined from the First 30 Flights, NASA TN-D-1057, July 1961.
2. Klyde, D. H., D. T. McRuer, T. T. Myers, "Pilot-Induced Oscillation Analysis and Prediction with Actuator Rate Limiting," Journal of Guidance, Control, and Dynamics, Volume 20, Number 1, Jan.-Feb. 1997, pp. 81-89.
3. Klyde, D. H., and D. G. Mitchell, "Investigating the Role of Rate Limiting in Pilot-Induced Oscillations," Journal of Guidance, Control, and Dynamics, Volume 27, Number 5, Sep.-Oct. 2004, pp. 804-813.
4. Ashkenas I. L., H. R. Jex, and D. T. McRuer, Pilot-Induced Oscillations: Their Causes and Analysis, Northrop-Norair Rept., NOR 64-143, June 1964.
5. McPherson, T. M., and LT E. J. Hogan, Jr., Low Altitude High Speed Flight Evaluation of the F-4A/B (F4H 1F/-1) Airplane, NATC-RAD32-103, 2 April 1963.
6. Smith, J. W., Analysis of a Lateral Pilot-Induced Oscillation Experienced on the First Flight of the YF-16 Aircraft, NASA TM-72867, September 1979.
7. Teper, G. L., R. J. DiMarco, I. L. Ashkenas, and R. H. Hoh, Analysis of Shuttle Orbiter Approach and Landing Conditions, NASA CR-163108, July 1981.
8. Berry, D. T., B. G. Powers, K. J. Szalai, and R. J. Wilson, "In-Flight Evaluation of Control System Pure Time Delays," J. Aircraft, Vol. 19, No. 4, Apr. 1982, pp. 318-323.
9. Klyde, D. H., D. T. McRuer, and T. T. Myers, Unified Pilot-Induced Oscillation Theory Volume I: PIO Analysis with Linear and Nonlinear Vehicle Characteristics, Including Rate Limiting, WL-TR-96-3028, Dec. 1995.
10. Preston, J. D., J. Hodgkinson, J. Buckley, K. Citurs, D. G. Mitchell, and R. H. Hoh, Unified Pilot-Induced Oscillation Theory, Volume II: Pilot-Induced Oscillation Criteria Applied to Several McDonnell Douglas Aircraft, WL-TR-96-3029, Dec. 1995.
11. Anderson, M. R., and A. B. Page, Unified Pilot-Induced Oscillation Theory, Volume III: PIO Analysis Using Multivariable Methods, WL-TR-96-3030, Dec. 1995.
12. Bailey, R. E., and T. J. Bidlack, Unified Pilot-Induced Oscillation Theory Volume IV: Time-Domain Neal Smith Criterion, WL-TR-96-3031, Dec. 1995.
13. Efremov, A.V., et al., "Analysis of Reasons for Pilot Induced Oscillation Tendency and Development of Criteria for its Prediction," Investigation of Pilot Induced Oscillation Tendency and Prediction Criteria Development, WL-TR-96-3109, May 1996.
14. Mitchell, D. G., and R. H. Hoh, Development of Methods and Devices to Predict and Prevent Pilot-Induced Oscillations, AFRL-VA-WP-TR-2000-3046, Dec. 2000.
15. Department of Defense Handbook, Flying Qualities of Piloted Aircraft, MIL-HDBK-1797, United States Air Force, ASC/ENSI, Wright-Patterson AFB, OH, Dec. 1997.
16. Aviation Safety and Pilot Control, prepared by the National Research Council Committee on the Effects of Aircraft-Pilot Coupling and Flight Safety, National Academy Press, Washington, D.C., 1997.
17. Mitchell, D. G., A. J. Arencibia, and S. Munoz, "Real-Time Detection of Pilot-Induced Oscillations," AIAA-04 4700 presented at the Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, Providence, RI, 16-19 August 2004.
18. Chalk, C. R., "Calspan Presentation of PIO and the Effects of Rate Limiting," Flight Vehicle Integration Panel Workshop on Pilot Induced Oscillations, Advisory Group for Aerospace Research and Development, AGARD AR-335, Feb. 1995, pp. 12-1-12-12.
19. McRuer, D. T., Pilot-Induced Oscillations and Human Dynamic Behavior, NASA CR-4683, Dec. 1994.
20. McRuer, D. T., and E. S. Krendel, Mathematical Models of Human Pilot Behavior, AGARDograph No. 188, Jan. 1974.
21. Mitchell, D. G., and D. H. Klyde, "A Critical Examination of PIO Prediction Criteria," AIAA-98-4335 presented at the Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, Boston, MA, August 1998.
22. Neal, T. P., and R. E. Smith, An In-Flight Investigation to Develop Control System Design Criteria for Fighter Airplanes, AFFDL-TR-70-74, Volume 1, Dec. 1970.
23. Smith, R. H., "The Smith-Geddes Criteria," Presented at the SAE Aerospace Control and Guidance Systems Committee Meeting, Reno, NV, Mar. 1993.
24. Gibson, J. C., "The Prevention of PIO by Design," Active Control Technology: Applications and Lessons Learned, AGARD-CP-560, Jan. 1995, pp. 2-1-2-12.
25. Mitchell, D. G., and R. H. Hoh, "Development of a Unified Method to Predict PIO," Presented at the AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, San Diego, CA, 29-31 July 1996, pp. 611-622.
26. Kish, B. A., Capt, USAF, et al., A Limited Flight Test Investigation of Pilot-Induced Oscillation due to Elevator Rate Limiting (HAVE LIMITS), AFFTC-TR-97-12, June 1997.
27. th AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit, Reno, NV, Jan. 1999.
28. Duda, H., "Prediction of Pilot-in-the-Loop Oscillations due to Rate Saturation," J. Guidance, Control and Dynamics, Vol. 20, No. 3, May-June 1997, pp. 581-587.
29. Duus, G., and H. Duda, "Analysis of the HAVE LIMITS Database using the OLOP Criterion," AIAA 99-4007, presented at the AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, Portland, OR, Aug. 1999.
30. Zeyada, Y., R. A. Hess, and W. Siwakosit, "Analysis of Aircraft Handling Qualities and Pilot-Induced Oscillation Tendencies with Actuator Saturation," AIAA-98-4334, presented at the AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference and Exhibit, Boston, MA, Aug. 1998, pp. 401-414.
31. Foringer, L.A., and D.B. Leggett, "An Analysis of the Time-Domain Neal-Smith Criterion," AIAA-98-4250 presented at the AIAA Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference and Exhibit, Boston, MA, Aug. 1998, pp. 154-162.
32. Smith, J. W., and J. W. Edwards, Design of a Nonlinear Adaptive Filter for Suppression of Shuttle PilotInduced Oscillation Tendencies, NASA TM-81349, 1980.
33. Teper, G. L., R. J. DiMarco, I. L. Ashkenas, and R. H. Hoh, Analyses of Shuttle Orbiter Approach and Landing Conditions, NASA CR-163108, July 1981.
34. Shafer, M. F., R. E. Smith, J. F. Stewart, and R. E. Bailey, "Flight Test Experience with Pilot-Induced Oscillation Suppression Filters," NASA TM-86028, Jan. 1984.
35. Donley, S. T., G. L. Gross, J. L. Koper, "Actuator Rate Saturation Compensator," United States Patent Number 4, 866.361, 12 September 1989.
36. Deppe, P. R., C. R. Chalk, M. F. Shafer, Flight Evaluation of an Aircraft with Side and Center Stick Controllers and Rate-Limited Ailerons, NASA CR-198055, Nov. 1996.
37. Rundqwist, L., and R. Hillgren, "Phase Compensation of Rate Limiters in JAS 39 Gripen," AIAA-96-3368 presented at the Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, San Diego, CA, 29-31 July 1996.
38. Hanke, D., Phase Compensation: A means of Preventing Aircraft-Pilot Coupling Caused by Rate Limitation, DLR-Forschungsbericht 98-15, 1998.
39. Hanke, D., "Handling Qualities Analysis on Rate Limiting Elements in Flight Control Systems," Flight Vehicle Integration Panel Workshop on Pilot Induced Oscillations, AGARD-AR-335, Feb. 1995.
40. rd Edition, Wiley Series in Probability and Statistics, New York, 2000.
41. Thompson, P. M., D. H. Klyde, E. N. Bachelder, and T. J. Rosenthal, "Development of Wavelet-Based Techniques for Detecting Loss of Control," AIAA Paper No. 2004-5064 to be presented at Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, Providence, RI, 16-18 August, 2004.
42. Thompson, P. M., D. H. Klyde, and M. Brenner, "Wavelet-Based Time-Varying Human Operator Models," AIAA Paper 2001-4009, presented at Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, Montreal, Canada, August 2001.
43. Klyde, D. H., P. M. Thompson, E. N. Bachelder, and T. J. Rosenthal, "Evaluation of Wavelet-Based Techniques for Detecting Loss of Control," AIAA Paper No. 2004-4072 presented at Atmospheric Flight Mechanics Conference, Providence, RI, 16-18 August, 2004.
44. Flight Test Guide for Certification of Transport Category Airplanes, Federal Aviation Administration Advisory Circular, AC 25-7A, Mar. 1998.
45. Aeronautical Design Standard, Performance Specification: Handling Qualities Requirements for Military Rotorcraft, US Army Aviation and Missile Command, Redstone Arsenal, AL, ADS-33E-PRF, Mar. 2000.
46. Klyde, D. H., B. L. Aponso, and D. G. Mitchell, Handling Qualities Demonstration Maneuvers for Fixed Wing Aircraft Vol. I: Maneuver Development Process, WL-TR-97-3099, Oct. 1997.
47. Klyde, D. H., and D. G. Mitchell, Handling Qualities Demonstration Maneuvers for Fixed Wing Aircraft Vol. 2: Maneuver Catalog, WL-TR-97-3100, Oct. 1997.
48. Mitchell, D. G., R. H. Hoh, B. L. Aponso, and D. H. Klyde, Proposed Incorporation of Mission-Oriented Flying Qualities into MIL-STD-1797A, WL-TR-94-3162, Oct. 1994.
49. Twisdale, T. R., and M. K. Nelson, "A Method for the Flight Test Evaluation of PIO Susceptibility," NASA Dryden PIO Workshop, NASA DFRC, Edwards AFB, CA, 6-8 April 1999, pp. 487-492.
50. Prosser, K.E., MAJ USAF, and A.J. Thurling, MAJ USAF, "Handling Qualities Stress Testing," Forty-Fourth Symposium Proceedings, Society of Experimental Test Pilots, September 2000, pp. 43-60.
51. Angner, J., C. Jensen, M. Seidl, "JAS 39 Gripen EFCS: How to Deal with Rate Limiting," Fortieth Symposium Proceedings, Society of Experimental Test Pilots, September 1996, pp. 220-233.
52. th Symposium and Banquet, Los Angeles, CA, 15-18 Sept. 2004.