Constrained Delegation: Limiting Subsidiaries' Decision Rights and Resources in Firms That Compete across Multiple Industries

Administrative Science Quarterly

Volumn 58, Issue 3, 2013, Pages 420-471

  Sengul, Metin ^a   Gimeno, Javier ^b  

^a BOSTON COLLEGE   (United States)

^b INSEAD   (France)

Author keywords

competitive spillovers; constrained delegation; internal capital markets; managerial discretion; multimarket competition; subsidiary autonomy

Indexed keywords

EID: 84887269564     PISSN: 00018392     EISSN: 19303815     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0001839213500272     Document Type: Article

References (160)

1. Acemoglu D.,Aghion P.,Lelarge C.,Van Reenen J.,Zilibotti F.Technology, information and the decentralization of the firm.Quarterly Journal of Economics. 2007;122:1759-1799.
2. Ackerman R. W.Influence of integration and diversity on the investment process.Administrative Science Quarterly. 1970;15:341-351.
3. Adams W. J.Market structure and corporate power: The horizontal dominance hypothesis reconsidered.Columbia Law Review. 1974;74:1276-1297.
4. Aghion P.,Tirole J.Formal and real authority in organizations.Journal of Political Economy. 1997;105:1-27.
5. Ahn S.,Denis D. J.,Denis D. K.Leverage and investment in diversified firms.Journal of Financial Economics. 2006;79:317-337.
6. Alexander D. L.An empirical test of the mutual forbearance hypothesis: The case of bank holding companies.Southern Economic Journal. 1985;52:122-140.
7. Alles M.,Datar S.Strategic transfer pricing.Management Science. 1998;44:451-461.
8. Alonso R.,Dessein W.,Matouschek N.When does coordination require centralization?.American Economic Review. 2008;98:145-179.
9. Anand J.,Mesquita L. F.,Vassolo R. S.The dynamics of multimarket competition in exploration and exploitation activities.Academy of Management Journal. 2009;52:802-821.
10. Areeda P.,Turner D.Conglomerate mergers: Extended interdependence and effects on interindustry competition as grounds on condemnation.University of Pennsylvania Law Review. 1979;127:1082-1103.
11. Baltagi B.Econometric Analysis of Panel Data. New York: Wiley; 2001:.
12. Baum J. A. C.,Greve H. R.Advances in Strategic Management, vol. 18: Multiunit Organization and Multimarket Strategy: 1-28. Baum J. A. C.Greve H. R., ed. New York: Elsevier; 2001:.
13. Baum J. A. C.,Korn H. J.Competitive dynamics of interfirm rivalry.Academy of Management Journal. 1996;39:255-255.
14. Baumier J.Les Grandes Affaires Françaises: Des 200 Familles aux 200 Managers. Paris: Julliard; 1967:.
15. Berger P. G.,Hann R.The impact of SFAS No. 131 on information and monitoring.Journal of Accounting Research. 2003;41:163-223.
16. Bernheim B. D.,Whinston M. D.Multimarket contact and collusive behavior.RAND Journal of Economics. 1990;21:1-26.
17. Bernheim B. D.,Whinston M. D.Incomplete contracts and strategic ambiguity.American Economic Review. 1998;88:902-932.
18. Billett M. T.,Mauer D. C.Cross-subsidies, external financing constraints, and the contribution of the internal capital markets to firm value.Review of Financial Studies. 2003;16:1167-1201.
19. Birkinshaw J.,Lingblad M.Intrafirm competition and charter evolution in the multibusiness firm.Organization Science. 2005;16:674-686.
20. Bloom N.,Sadun R.,Van Reenen J.Does product market competition lead firms to decentralize?.American Economic Review. 2010;100:434-438.
21. Bower J. L.Managing the Resource Allocation Process. Boston: Harvard University Press; 1970a:.
22. Bower J. L.Planning within the firm.American Economic Review. 1970b;60:186-195.
23. Bower J. L.,Doz Y. L.Strategic Management: A New View of Business Policy and Planning: 152-165. Schendel D.Hofer C. W., ed. Boston: Little, Brown; 1979:.
24. Bower J. L.,Doz Y. L.,Gilbert C. G.From Resource Allocation to Strategy: 3-25. Bower J. L.Gilbert C. G., ed. New York: Oxford University Press.; 2005:.
25. Brandenburger A. M.,Stuart H. W.Value-based business strategy.Journal of Economics and Management Strategy. 1996;5:5-24.
26. Brynjolfsson E.Information assets, technology, and organization.Management Science. 1994;40:1645-1662.
27. Burgelman R. A.A process model of internal corporate venturing in the diversified major firm.Administrative Science Quarterly. 1983;28:223-244.
28. Burgelman R. A.From Resource Allocation to Strategy: 38-70. Bower J. L.Gilbert C. G., ed. New York: Oxford University Press.; 2005:.
29. Cameron A. C.,Trivedi P. K.Microeconometrics: Methods and Applications. New York: Cambridge University Press; 2005:.
30. Carney M.,Gedajlovic E. R.,Heugens P. P. M. A. R.,van Essen M.,van Oosterhout J.Business group affiliation, performance, context, and strategy: A meta-analysis.Academy of Management Journal. 2011;54:437-460.
31. Chandler A. D.Strategy and Structure: Chapters in the History of the American Industrial Enterprise. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press; 1962:.
32. Chandler A. D.The Visible Hand: The Managerial Revolution in American Business. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University; 1977:.
33. Chandler A. D.Fundamental Issues in Strategy: A Research Agenda: 323-360. Rumelt R. R.Schendel D. E.Teece D. J., ed. Boston: Harvard Business School Press; 1991:.
34. Chatain O.,Zemsky P.Value creation and value capture with frictions.Strategic Management Journal. 2011;32:1206-1231.
35. Chaudhuri A.,Mukerjee R.Randomized Response: Theory and Techniques. New York: Marcel Dekker; 1988:.
36. Chen M.-J.,Venkataraman S.,Black S.,MacMillan I.The role of irreversibilities in competitive interaction: Behavioral considerations from organization theory.Managerial and Decision Economics. 2002;23:187-207.
37. Child J.Organization: A Guide to Problems and Practice, 2d ed. New York: Harper & Row; 1984:.
38. Collis D.,Montgomery C. A.Corporate Strategy: A Resource-based Approach. 2005Corporate Strategy: A Resource-based Approach, 2d ed.Boston: McGraw-Hill.Boston: McGraw-Hill; 2005:.
39. Collis D.,Young D.,Goold M.The size, structure, and performance of corporate headquarters.Strategic Management Journal. 2007;28:383-405.
40. Colombo M. G.,Delmastro M.The Economics of Organization Design: Theoretical Insights and Empirical Evidence. New York: Palgrave Macmillan; 2008:.
41. Cool K.,Henderson J.Power and firm profitability in supply chains: French manufacturing industry in 1993.Strategic Management Journal. 1998;19:909-926.
42. Cowling K.,Sugden R.Transnational Monopoly Capitalism. Brighton, UK: Wheatsheaf Books; 1987:.
43. Cremers K. J. M.,Huang R.,Sautner Z.Internal capital markets and corporate politics in a banking group.Review of Financial Studies. 2011;24:358-401.
44. Desai M.,Foley C. F.,Hines J. R.A multinational perspective on capital structure choice and internal capital markets.Journal of Finance. 2004;59:2451-2488.
45. Dess G. G.,Beard D. W.Dimension of organizational task environments.Administrative Science Quarterly. 1984;29:52-73.
46. Dessein W.,Garicano L.,Gertner R.Organizing for synergies.American Economic Journal: Microeconomics. 2010;2:77-114.
47. Dixit A.The role of investment in entry-deterrence.Economic Journal. 1980;90:95-106.
48. Dray D. M.,Fielding M.Head-to-head: GE vs Siemens.Citi Research, Research Report. 2013;:11.
49. Dyas G. R.,Thanheiser H.The Emerging European Enterprise. London: Macmillan; 1976:.
50. Edwards C. D.Conglomerate bigness as a source of power. National Bureau Committee for Economic Research Conference Report, Business Concentration and Price Policy: 331-352; 1955Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press; 1955.
51. Encaoua D.,Jacquemin A.Organizational efficiency and monopoly power: The case of French industrial groups.European Economic Review. 1982;19:25-51.
52. Faccio M.,Lang L. H. P.The ultimate ownership of Western European corporations.Journal of Financial Economics. 2002;65:365-395.
53. Fauli-Oller R.,Giralt M.Competition and cooperation within a multidivisional firm.Journal of Industrial Economics. 1995;43:77-99.
54. Feinberg R. M.Sales-at-risk: A test of the mutual forbearance theory of conglomerate behavior.Journal of Business. 1985;58:225-241.
55. Fershtman C.,Judd K. L.Equilibrium incentives in oligopoly.American Economic Review. 1987;77:927-940.
56. Finkel S. E.Causal Analysis with Panel Data. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage; 1995:.
57. Finkelstein S.,Hambrick D. C.,Cannella A. A.Strategic Leadership: Theory and Research on Executives, Top Management Teams, and Boards. New York: Oxford University Press; 2008:.
58. Foster L.,Haltiwanger J. C.,Syverson C.Reallocation, firm turnover, and efficiency: Selection on productivity or profitability?.American Economic Review. 2008;98:394-425.
59. Fox J. A.,Tracy P. E.Randomized Response: A Method for Sensitive Surveys. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage; 1986:.
60. FrancoF.UrcanO.VasvariF. P.2010 "The value of diversification: A debt market perspective." Working paper, London Business School.
61. Galbraith J. R.Organization Design. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley; 1977:.
62. Galunic D. C.,Eisenhardt K. M.The evolution of intracorporate domains: Divisional charter losses in high-technology, multidivisional corporations.Organization Science. 1996;7:255-282.
63. Gaspar J. M.,Massa M.The role of commonality between CEO and divisional managers in internal capital markets.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis. 2011;46:841-869.
64. Geweke J.,Meese R.,Dent W.Comparing alternative tests of causality in temporal systems.Journal of Econometrics. 1983;21:161-194.
65. Ghoshal S.,Nohria N.Internal differentiation within multinational corporations.Strategic Management Journal. 1989;10:323-337.
66. Gimeno J.Reciprocal threats in multimarket rivalry: Staking out 'spheres of influence' in the U.S. airline industry.Strategic Management Journal. 1999;20:101-128.
67. Gimeno J.,Woo C. Y.Multimarket contact, economics of scope, and firm performance.Academy of Management Journal. 1999;43:239-259.
68. Golden B. R.,Ma H.Mutual forbearance: The role of intrafirm integration and rewards.Academy of Management Review. 2003;28:479-493.
69. GrahamJ. R.HarveyC. R.PuriM.2011 "Capital allocation and delegation of decision-making authority within firms." NBER Working Paper, 17370.
70. Greve H. R.Multimarket contact and sales growth: Evidence from insurance.Strategic Management Journal. 2008;29:229-249.
71. Guadalupe M.,Wulf J.Flattening firm and product market competition: The effect of trade liberalization on corporate hierarchies.American Economic Journal: Applied Economics. 2010;2:105-127.
72. Guillén M. F.Business groups in emerging economies: A resource-based view.Academy of Management Journal. 2000;43:362-380.
73. Gupta A. K.,Govindarajan V.Subsidiary strategy, managerial characteristics, and subsidiary effectiveness at strategy implementation.Academy of Management Journal. 1984;27:25-41.
74. Gupta A. K.,Govindarajan V.Knowledge flows and the structure of control within multinational corporations.Academy of Management Review. 1991;16:768-792.
75. Hambrick D. C.,Abrahamson E.Assessing managerial discretion across industries: A multimethod approach.Academy of Management Journal. 1995;38:1427-1441.
76. Hambrick D. C.,Finkelstein S.Research in Organizational Behavior. Cummings L. L.Staw B. M., ed. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.; 1987:369-406.
77. Hambrick D. C.,Mason P. A.Upper echelons: The organization as a reflection of its top managers.Academy of Management Review. 1984;9:193-206.
78. Hansmann H.The Ownership of Enterprise. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University; 2000:.
79. Harris M.,Raviv A.Allocation of decision-making authority.Review of Finance. 2005;9:353-383.
80. Haspeslagh P.Portfolio planning: Use and limits.Harvard Business Review. 1982;60 (1): 58-73.
81. Haveman H. A.,Nonnemaker L.Competition in multiple geographic markets: The impact on growth and market entry.Administrative Science Quarterly. 2000;45:232-267.
82. Henderson B. D.The Strategy Process: Concepts, Contexts, Cases: 678-680. Mintzberg H.Quinn J. B., ed. Essex, UK: Pearson; 1979:.
83. Hill C. W. L.,Hitt M. A.,Hoskisson R. E.Cooperative versus competitive structures in related and unrelated diversified firms.Organization Science. 1992;3:501-521.
84. Hirshleifer J.Economics of the divisionalized firm.Journal of Business. 1957;30 (2): 96-108.
85. Holmstrom B.,Ricart i Costa J.Managerial incentives and capital management.Quarterly Journal of Economics. 1986;101:835-860.
86. Hoopes D. G.,Madsen T. L.,Walker G.Why is there a resource-based view? Toward a theory of competitive heterogeneity.Strategic Management Journal. 2003;24:889-902.
87. Hughes K.,Oughton C.Diversification, multi-market contact and profitability.Economica. 1993;60:203-224.
88. Inderst R.,Laux C.Incentives in internal capital markets: Capital constraints, competition, and investment opportunities.RAND Journal of Economics. 2005;36:215-228.
89. Jacquemin A.,Berry C. H.Entropy measure of diversification and corporate growth.Journal of Industrial Economics. 1979;27:359-369.
90. Jayachandran S.,Gimeno J.,Varadarajan P. R.Theory of multimarket competition: A synthesis and implications for marketing strategy.Journal of Marketing. 1999;63:49-66.
91. Jennergren L. P.Handbook of Organizational Design. Nystrom P.Starbuck W., ed. New York: Oxford University Press.; 1981:39-59.
92. Jensen M. C.,Meckling W. H.Main Currents in Contract Economies: 251-274. Werin L.Wijkander H., ed. London: Basil Blackwell.; 1991:.
93. Karnani A.,Wernerfelt B.Multiple point competition.Strategic Management Journal. 1985;6:87-96.
94. Khanna T.,Yafeh Y.Business groups in emerging markets: Paragons or parasites?.Journal of Economic Literature. 2007;45:331-372.
95. Kim H.,Hoskisson R. E.,Wan W. P.Power dependence, diversification strategy and performance in keiretsu affiliated firms.Strategic Management Journal. 2004;25:613-636.
96. Korn H. J.,Rock T. T.Advances in Strategic Management, vol. 18: Multiunit Organization and Multimarket Strategy: 53-74. Baum J. A. C.Greve H. R., ed. New York: Elsevier; 2001:.
97. Lee J.-R.,Tang M.-J. Urbana-Champaign: University of Illinois; 1994:.
98. Lelogeais L.Un score sur variables qualitatives pour la détection précoce des défaillances d'entreprises.Bulletin de la Banque de France. 2003;114:.
99. Lemelin A.Relatedness in the patterns of interindustry diversification.Review of Economics and Statistics. 1982;64:646-657.
100. Low G. S.,Fullerton R. A.Brands, brand management, and the brand manager system: A critical-historical evaluation.Journal of Marketing Research. 1994;31:173-190.
101. Maddala G. S.Limited-dependent and Qualitative Dependent Variables in Econometrics. New York: Cambridge University Press; 1983:.
102. Maksimovic V.,Phillips G.Handbook of Corporate Finance. Eckbo E., ed. New York: Elsevier.; 2007:423-479.
103. Mercadal B.,Janin P.,Charvériat A.,Couret A.Droit des Affaires: Sociétés Commerciales, 2004. Levallois: Éditions Francis Lefebvre; 2004:.
104. Mintzberg H.The Structuring of Organizations. Englewood Cliff, NJ: Prentice-Hall; 1979:.
105. Mueller W. F.Firm conglomeration as a market structure variable.American Journal of Agricultural Economics. 1969;51:1488-1494.
106. Nadler D. A.,Tushman M. L.Competing by Design. New York: Oxford University Press; 1997:.
107. Neubauer S.Multimarket Contact and Organizational Design. Wiesbaden: Deutscher Universitats-Verlag; 2001:.
108. Noda T.,Bower J. L.Strategy making as iterated processes of resource allocation.Strategic Management Journal. 1996;17:159-192.
109. Nohria N.,Ghoshal S.Differentiated fit and shared values: Alternatives for managing headquarters-subsidiary relations.Strategic Management Journal. 1994;15:491-502.
110. Ocasio W.,Joseph J.Advances in Strategic Management, vol. 22: Strategy Process: 39-61. Szulanski G.Porac J.Doz Y., ed. New York: Elsevier; 2005:.
111. Ouchi W. G.The transmission of control through organizational hierarchy.Academy of Management Journal. 1978;21:173-192.
112. Ouchi W. G.A conceptual framework for the design of organizational control mechanisms.Management Science. 1979;25:833-848.
113. Ouchi W. G.Markets, bureaucracies, and clans.Administrative Science Quarterly. 1980;25:129-141.
114. Ouchi W. G.,Maguire M. A.Organizational control: Two functions.Administrative Science Quarterly. 1975;20:559-569.
115. Ozbas O.,Scharfstein D. S.Evidence on the dark side of internal capital markets.Review of Financial Studies. 2010;23:581-599.
116. ParussiniG.2005 "Orange, SFR, Bouygues fined EU534 Mln for collusion."http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=newsarchive&sid=af.O1nOGcOmA.
117. Penrose E.The Theory of the Growth of the Firm. New York: Wiley; 1959:.
118. Pitts R. A.Toward a contingency theory of multibusiness organization design.Academy of Management Review. 1980;5:203-210.
119. Poppo L.Influence activities and strategic coordination: Two distinctions of internal and external markets.Management Science. 1995;41:1845-1859.
120. Porter M. E.Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors. New York: Free Press; 1980:.
121. Porter M. E.Competitive Strategic Management: 415-445. Lamb R. B., ed. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.; 1984:.
122. Porter M. E.From competitive advantage to corporate strategy.Harvard Business Review. 1987;65 (3): 43-59.
123. Porter M. E.Strategy and the Internet.Harvard Business Review. 2001;79 (3): 62-78.
124. Prahalad C. K.,Doz Y. L.The Multinational Mission: Balancing Local Demands and Global Vision. New York: Free Press; 1987:.
125. Rajan R.,Servaes H.,Zingales L.The cost of diversity: The diversification discount and inefficient investment.Journal of Finance. 2000;55:35-80.
126. Rangan S.,Sengul M.Information technology and transnational integration: Theory and evidence on the evolution of modern multinational enterprise.Journal of International Business Studies. 2009;40:1496-1514.
127. Rantakari H.Governing adaptation.Review of Economic Studies. 2008;75:1257-1285.
128. Raynor M. E.,Bower J. L.Lead from the center: How to manage divisions dynamically.Harvard Business Review. 2001;79 (5): 93-100.
129. Rivkin J. W.,Siggelkow N.Balancing search and stability: Interdependencies among elements of organizational design.Management Science. 2003;49:290-311.
130. Rhoades S. A.The effect of diversification on industry profit performance in 241 manufacturing industries: 1963.Review of Economics and Statistics. 1973;55:146-155.
131. Scharfstein D. S.,Stein J. C.The dark side of internal capital markets: Divisional rent-seeking and inefficient investment.Journal of Finance. 2000;55:2537-2564.
132. Schelling T. C.The Strategy of Conflict. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press; 1960:.
133. Scott J. T.Multimarket contact and economic performance.Review of Economics and Statistics. 1982;64:368-375.
134. Scott J. T.Multimarket contact among diversified oligopolists.International Journal of Industrial Organization. 1991;9:225-238.
135. Sengul M.,Gimeno J.,Dial J.Strategic delegation: A review, theoretical integration, and research agenda.Journal of Management. 2012;38:375-414.
136. Shen W.,Cho T. S.Exploring involuntary executive turnover through a managerial discretion framework.Academy of Management Review. 2005;30:843-854.
137. Shin H.,Stulz R. M.Are internal capital markets efficient?.Quarterly Journal of Economics. 1998;113:531-552.
138. Smith K.,Grimm C. M.,Gannon M. J.Dynamics of Competitive Strategy. Newbury Park, CA: Sage; 1992:.
139. Sohn M.-W.Distance and cosine measures of niche overlap.Social Networks. 2001;23:141-165.
140. Stein J. C.Internal capital markets and the competition for corporate resources.Journal of Finance. 1997;52:111-133.
141. Stein J. C.Handbook of the Economics of Finance: 109-163. Constantinides G. M.Harris M.Stulz R., ed. New York: Elsevier.; 2003:.
142. Stinchcombe A. L.When Formality Works: Authority and Abstraction in Law and Organizations. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 2001:.
143. Strickland A. D.Firm Diversification, Mutual Forbearance Behavior and Price-cost Margins. New York: Garland Publishing; 1984:.
144. Strickland A. D.Conglomerate mergers, mutual forbearance behavior and price competition.Managerial Decision and Economics. 1985;6:153-159.
145. Sull D. N.From Resource Allocation to Strategy: 135-175. Bower J. L.Gilbert C. G., ed. New York: Oxford University Press.; 2005:.
146. Van de Ven A. H.,Leung R.,Bechara J. P.,Sun K.Changing organizational designs and performance frontiers.Organization Science. 2012;23:1055-1076.
147. Veendorp E. C. H.Entry deterrence, divisionalization, and investment decisions.Quarterly Journal of Economics. 1991;106:297-307.
148. Verboven F.Localized competition, multimarket operation and collusive behavior.International Economic Review. 1998;39:371-398.
149. Vickers J.Delegation and the theory of the firm.Economic Journal. 1985;95:138-147.
150. Warner S. L.Randomized response: A survey technique for eliminating evasive answer bias.Journal of the American Statistical Association. 1965;60:63-69.
151. Williamson O. E.The Economic Institutions of Capitalism. New York: Free Press; 1985:.
152. Williamson O. E.,Bhargava N.Market Structure and Corporate Behavior: Theory and Empirical Analysis of the Firm: 127-160. Cowling K., ed. London: Grey-Mills; 1972:.
153. World Bank2005World Development Report. http://www-wds.worldbank.org/servlet/WDSContentServer/WDSP/IB/2005/09/20/000112742_20050920110826/Rendered/PDF/322040World0Development0Report02006.pdf.
154. Wulf J.Internal capital markets and firm-level compensation incentives for division managers.Journal of Labor Economics. 2002;20:5219-5262.
155. Wulf J.Influence and inefficiency in the internal capital market.Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization. 2009;72:305-321.
156. Yu T.,Cannella A. A.A comprehensive review of multimarket competition research.Journal of Management. 2013;39:76-109.
157. Zenger T. R.,Hesterly W. S.The disaggregation of corporations: Selective intervention, high-powered incentives, and molecular units.Organization Science. 1997;8:209-222.
158. Zey M.,Swenson T.Corporate tax laws, corporate restructuring and subsidiarization of corporate form, 1981-1995.Sociological Quarterly. 1998;39:555-581.
159. Zhang Y.,Gimeno J.Earnings pressure and competitive behavior: Evidence from the U.S. electricity industry.Academy of Management Journal. 2010;53:743-768.
160. ZysmanS. J.1973 "Top management and decentralized investment planning in diversified firms: A comparative study." Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Harvard University.