Comparison of a culture-based and a PCR-based methods for estimating bacterial abundance on eggshells, with comments on statistical analyses

Journal of Field Ornithology

Volumn 84, Issue 3, 2013, Pages 304-315

  Lee, Won Young ^a   Lee, Ki hyun ^a   Chun, Jongsik ^a   Choe, Jae Chun ^b   Jablonski, Piotr G ^a,c   Lee, Sang im ^a,d  

^a Seoul National University   (South Korea)

^b Ewha Womans University   (South Korea)

^c CENTRE FOR ECOLOGICAL RESEARCH   (Poland)

^d Seoul National University   (South Korea)

Author keywords

Censored data; Culture method; Eggshell microbe; Escherichia coli; Pica pica; Real time PCR

Indexed keywords

BACTERIA (MICROORGANISMS); CORVIDAE; ESCHERICHIA COLI; PICA PICA;

EID: 84882995709     PISSN: 02738570     EISSN: 15579263     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/jofo.12031     Document Type: Article

References (84)

1. Amit-Romach, E., D. Sklan, and Z. Uni. 2004. Microflora ecology of the chicken intestine using 16S ribosomal DNA primers. Poultry Science 83: 1093-1098.
2. Antweiler, R. C., and H. E. Taylor. 2008. Evaluation of statistical treatments of left-censored environmental data using coincident uncensored data sets: I. Summary statistics. Environmental Science and Technology 42: 3732-3738.
3. Barrow, P. A. 1994. The microflora of the alimentary tract and avian pathogens: translocation and vertical transmission. In: Microbiology of avian eggs (R. G. Board and R. Fuller, eds.), pp. 117-136. Chapman and Hall, London, UK.
4. Bruce, J., and E. M. Drysdale. 1994. Trans-shell transmission. In: Microbiology of avian eggs (R. G. Board and R. Fuller, eds.), pp. 63-91. Chapman and Hall, London, UK.
5. Burgos, J. S., C. Ramirez, R. Tenorio, I. Sastre, and M. J. Bullido. 2002. Influence of reagents formulation on real-time PCR parameters. Molecular and Cellular Probes 16: 257-260.
6. Burtt, E. h., Jr., and J. M. Ichida. 1999. Occurrence of feather-degrading bacilli in plumage of birds. Auk 116: 364-372.
7. Burtt, E. h., Jr., and J. M. Ichida. 2009. A future with feather-degrading bacteria. Journal of Avian Biology 40: 349-351.
8. Chang, B., T. Taguri, K. Sugiyama, J. Amemura-Maekawa, F. Kura, and H. Wanatabe. 2010. Comparison of ethidium monoazide and propidium monoazide for the selective detection of viable Legionella cells. Japanese Journal of Infectious Diseases 63: 119-123.
9. Conover, W. J., and R. L. Iman. 1981. Rank transformations as a bridge between parametric and nonparamentric statistics. American Statistician 35: 124-133.
10. Cook, M. I., S. R. Beissinger, G. A. Toranzos, and W. J. Arendt. 2005a. Incubation reduces microbial growth on eggshells and the opportunity for trans-shell infection. Ecology Letters 8: 532-537.
11. Cook, M. I., S. R. Beissinger, G. A. Toranzos, and W. J. Arendt. 2005b. Microbial infection affects egg viability and incubation behavior in a tropical passerine. Behavioral Ecology 16: 30-36.
12. Cook, M. I., S. R. Beissinger, G. A. Toranzos, R. A. Rodriguez, and W. J. Arendt. 2003. Trans-shell infection by pathogenic micro-organisms reduces the shelf life of non-incubated bird's eggs: a constraint on the onset of incubation? Proceedings of the Royal Society B 270: 2233-2240.
13. Czirják, G. A., A. P. Møller, T. A. Mousseau, and P. Heeb. 2010. Microorganisms associated with feathers of Barn Swallows in radioactively contaminated areas around Chernobyl. Microbial Ecology 60: 373-380.
14. D'Alba, L., A. Oborn, and M. D. Shawkey. 2010. Experimental evidence that keeping eggs dry is a mechanism for the antimicrobial effects of avian incubation. Naturwissenschaften 97: 1089-1095.
15. Delucchi, K. L., and A. Bostrom. 2004. Methods for analysis of skewed data distributions in psychiatric clinical studies: working with many zero values. American Journal of Psychiatry 161: 1159-1168.
16. Dragsted, D. M., B. Dohn, J. Madsen, and J. S. Jensen. 2004. Comparison of culture and PCR for detection of Bordetella pertussis and Bordatella parapertussis under routine laboratory conditions. Journal of Medical Microbiology 53: 749-754.
17. Dufour, A. P., E. R. Strickland, and V. J. Cabelli. 1981. Membrane filter method for enumerating Escherichia coli. Applied and Environmental Microbiology 41: 1152-1158.
18. Ehrlich, G. D., P. DeMeo, M. Palmer, T. J. Sauber, D. Altman, G. Altman, N. Sotereanos, S. Conti, M. Baratz, G. Maale, F. Z. Hu, J. Christopher Post, L. Nistico, R. Kreft, L. Hall-Stoodley, J. W. Costerton, and P. Stoodley. 2012. Culture-negative infections in orthopedic surgery. In: Culture negative orthopedic biofilm infections (G. D. Ehrlich, P. J. Demeo, J. W. Costerton, and H. Winkler, eds.), pp. 17-27. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Germany.
19. Espy, M. J., J. R. Uhl, L. M. Sloan, S. P. Buckwalter, M. F. Jones, E. A. Vetter, J. D. C. Yao, N. L. Wengenack, J. E. Rosenblatt, F. R. Cockerill III, and T. F. Smith. 2006. Real-time PCR in clinical microbiology: applications for routine laboratory testing. Clinical Microbiology Reviews 19: 165-256.
20. Farnleitner, A. h., N. Kreuzinger, G. G. Kavka, S. Grillenberger, J. Rath, and R. L. Mach. 2000. Simultaneous detection and differentiation of Escherichia coli populations from environmental freshwaters by means of sequence variations in a fragment of the β-glucuronidase gene. Applied and Environmental Microbiology 66: 1340-1346.
21. Fittipaldi, M., F. Codony, B. Adrados, A. K. Camper, and J. Morato. 2011. Viable real-time PCR in environmental samples: can all data be interpreted directly? Microbial Ecology 61: 7-12.
22. Flynn, M. R. 2010. Analysis of censored exposure data by constrained maximization of the Shapiro-Wilcox W statistics. Annals of Occupational Hygiene 54: 263-271.
23. Gentleman, R., and A. Vandal. 2013. Icens: NPMLE for censored and truncated data. R package version 1.30.0.
24. Goodwin, K. D., M. McNay, Y. Cao, D. Ebentier, M. Madison, and J. F. Griffith. 2012. A multi-beach study of Saphylococcus aureus, MRSA, and enterococci in seawater and beach sand. Water Research 46: 4195-4207.
25. Grys, T. E., L. M. Sloan, J. E. Rosenblatt, and R. Patel. 2009. Rapid and sensitive detection of Shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli from nonenriched stool specimens by real-time PCR in comparison to enzyme immunoassay and culture. Journal of Clinical Microbiology 47: 2008-2012.
26. Gunderson, A. R. 2008. Feather-degrading bacteria: a new frontier in avian and host-parasite research? Auk 125: 972-979.
27. Heid, C. A., J. Stevens, K. J. Livak, and P. M. Williams. 1996. Real time quantitative PCR. Genome Research 6: 986-994.
28. Heijnen, L., and G. Medema. 2006. Quantitative detection of E. coli, E. coli O157 and other Shiga toxin producing E. coli in water samples using a culture method combined with real-time PCR. Journal of Water Health 4: 487-498.
29. Helsel, D. R. 2005. Nondetects and data analysis: statistics for censored environmental data. Wiley and Sons, Hoboken, NY.
30. Helsel, D. R. 2010. Much ado about next to nothing: incorporating nondetects in science. Annals of Occupational Hygiene 54: 257-262.
31. Helsel, D. R. 2012. Statistics for censored environmental data using Minitab and R. Wiley and Sons, New York, NY.
32. Helsel, D. R., and T. A. Cohn. 1988. Estimation of descriptive statistics for multiply censored water quality data. Water Resources Research 24: 1997-2004.
33. Hettmansperger, T. P., and J. W. McKean. 2011. Robust nonparametric statistical methods, 2nd ed. Chapman-Hall, New York, NY.
34. Hewett, P., and G. h. Ganser. 2007. A comparison of several methods for analyzing censored data. Annals of Occupational Hygiene 51: 611-632.
35. Houston, S., J. R. Saunders, and R. D. Crawford. 1997. Aerobic bacterial flora of addled raptor eggs in Saskatchewan. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 33: 328-331.
36. Hubálek, Z. 1978. Coincidence of fungal species associated with birds. Ecology 59: 438-442.
37. Hughes, J. P. 1999. Mixed effects models with censored data with application to HIV RNA levels. Biometrics 55: 625-629.
38. Ishimaru, C., K. M. Eskridge, and A. K. Vidaver. 1991. Distribution analyses of naturally occurring epiphytic populations of Xanthomonas campestris pv. Phaseoli on dry beans. Phytopathology 81: 262-268.
39. Jin, Y., M. J. Hein, J. A. Deddens, and C. J. Hines. 2011. Analysis of lognormally distributed exposure data with repeated measures and values below the limit of detection using SAS. Annals of Occupational Hygiene 55: 97-112.
40. Kayhanian, M., A. Singh, and S. Meyer. 2002. Impact of non-detects in water quality data on estimation of constituent mass loading. Water Science and Technology 45: 219-225.
41. Khan, I. U. h., V. Gannon, R. Kent, W. Koning, D. R. Lapen, J. Miller, N. Neumann, R. Phillips, W. Robertson, E. Topp, E. van Bochove, and T. A. Edge. 2007. Development of a rapid quantitative PCR assay for direct detection and quantification of culturable and non-culturable Escherichia coli from agriculture watersheds. Journal of Microbiological Methods 69: 480-488.
42. Klein, D. 2002. Quantification using real-time PCR technology: applications and limitations. Trends in Molecular Medicine 8: 257-260.
43. Kloke, J. D., and J. W. McKean. 2012. Rfit: Rank-based estimation for linear models. The R Journal 4: 57-64.
44. Kralik, P., V. Beran, and I. Pavlik. 2012. Enumeration of Mycobacterium avium subsp. paratuberculosis by quantitative real-time PCR, culture on solid media and optical densitometry. BMC Research Notes 5:114.
45. Leblanc-Maridor, M., F. Bedudeau, H. Seegers, M. Denis, and C. Belloc. 2011. Rapid identification and quantification of Campylobacter coli and Campylobacter jejuni by real-time PCR in pure cultures and in complex samples. BMC Microbiology 11: 113.
46. Lee, C., J. Kim, S. G. Shin, and S. Hwang. 2006. Absolute and relative qPCR quantification of plasmid copy number in Escherichia coli. Journal of Biotechnology 123: 273-280.
47. Møller, A. P., G. A. Czirják, and P. Heeb. 2009. Feather micro-organisms and uropygial antimicrobial defences in a colonial passerine bird. Functional Ecology 23: 1097-1102.
48. Møller, A. P., G. A. Czirják, and P. Heeb, J. M. Peralta-Sanchez, J. T. Nielsen, E. Lopez-Hernandez, and J. J. Soler. 2012. Goshawk prey have more bacteria than non-prey. Journal of Animal Ecology 81: 403-410.
49. Monday, S. R., T. S. Whittam, and P. C. h. Feng. 2001. Genetic and evolutionary analysis of mutations in the gusA gene that cause the absence of β-glucuronidase activity in Escherichia coli O157:H7. Journal of Infectious Diseases 184: 918-921.
50. Narushin, V. G. 1997. The avian egg: geometrical description and calculation of parameters. Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research 68: 201-205.
51. Peralta-Sánchez, J. M., M. Martín-Vivaldi, A. M. Martín-Platero, M. Martínez-Bueno, M. Onate, M. Ruiz-Rodrígez, and J. J. Soler. 2012. Avian life history traits influence eggshell bacterial loads: a comparative analysis. Ibis 154: 725-737.
52. Peralta-Sánchez, J. M., A. P. Møller, A. M. Martín-Platero, and J. J. Soler. 2009. Number and colour composition of nest lining feathers predict eggshell bacterial community in Barn Swallow nests: an experimental study. Functional Ecology 24: 426-433.
53. Pinowski, J., M. Barkowska, A. h. Kruszewicz, and A. G. Kruszewicz. 1994. The causes of the mortality of eggs and nestlings of Passer spp. Journal of Biosciences 19: 441-451.
54. Pommepuy, M., M. Butin, A. Derrien, M. Gourmelon, R. R. Colwell, and M. Cormier. 1996. Retention of enteropathogenicity by viable but nonculturable Escherichia coli exposed to seawater and sunlight. Applied and Environmental Microbiology 62: 4621-4626.
55. Quiroz, J., J. R. Wilson, and S. Roychoudhury. 2012. Statistical analysis of data from dilution assays with censored correlated counts. Pharmaceutical Statistics 11: 63-73.
56. Ruiz-de-Castañeda, R., A. I. Vela, E. Lobato, V. Briones, and J. Moreno. 2011a. Bacterial loads on eggshell of the Pied Flycatcher: environmental and maternal factors. Condor 113: 200-208.
57. Ruiz-de-Castañeda, R., A. I. Vela, S. González-Braojos, V. Briones, and J. Moreno. 2011b. Drying eggs to inhibit bacteria: incubation during laying in a cavity nesting passerine. Behavioural Processes 88: 142-148.
58. Ruiz-de-Castañeda, R., A. I. Vela, E. Lobato, V. Briones, and J. Moreno. 2012. Early onset of incubation and eggshell bacterial loads in a temperate-zone cavity-nesting passerine. Condor 114: 203-211.
59. Saag, P., K. Priit, M. Marko, T. Vallo, and M. Raivo. 2012. Inter-annual and body topographic consistency in the plumage bacterial load of Great Tits. Journal of Field Ornithology 83: 94-100.
60. Salter, K. C., and R. F. Fawcett. 1993. The ART test of interaction: a robust and powerful rank test of interaction in factorial models. Communications in Statistics - Simulation and Computation 22: 137-153.
61. Sauer, N., M. Eklund, E. Bauer, M. G. Gänzle, C. J. Field, R. T. Zijlstra, and R. Mosenthin. 2012. The effects of pure nucleotides on performance, humoral immunity, gut structure and numbers of intestinal bacteria of newly weaned pigs. Journal of Animal Science 9: 3126-3134.
62. Seaman, J. W., Jr., S. C. Walls, S. E. Wide, and R. G. Jaeger. 1994. Caveat emptor: rank transform methods and interactions. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 9: 261-263.
63. Sedgley, C., A. Nagel, C. E. Shelburne, D. B. Clewell, O. Appelbe, and A. Molander. 2005. Quantitative real-time PCR detection of oral Enterococcus faecalis in humans. Archives of Oral Biology 50: 575-583.
64. Shadix, L. C., M. E. Dunnigan, and E. W. Rice. 1993. Detection of Escherichia coli by the nutrient agar plus 4-methylumbelliferyl β-D-glucuronide (MUG) membrane filter method. Canadian Journal of Microbiology 39: 1066-1070.
65. Shawkey, M. D., M. K. Firestone, E. L. Brodie, and S. R. Beissinger. 2009. Avian incubation inhibits growth and diversification of bacterial assemblages on eggs. PLoS ONE 4: e4522.
66. Shawkey, M. D., K. L. Mills, C. Dale, and G. E. Hill. 2005. Microbial diversity of wild bird feathers revealed through culture-based and culture-independent techniques. Microbial Ecology 50: 40-47.
67. Shellenbarger, G. G., N. D, Athearn, J. Y. Takekawa, and A. B. Boehm. 2008. Fecal indicator bacteria and Salmonella in ponds managed as bird habitat, San Francisco Bay, California, USA. Water Research 42: 2921-2930.
68. Singh, K., K. A. Mangold, K. Wyant, D. M. Schora, B. Voss, M. K. Hayden, V. Chundi, and L. R. Peterson. 2012. Rectal screening for Klebsiella pneumoniae carbapenemases: comparison of real-time PCR and culture using two selective screening agar plates. Journal of Clinical Microbiology 50: 2596-2600.
69. Sloan, L. M., B. J. Duresko, D. R. Gustafson, and J. E. Rosenblatt. 2008. Comparison of real-time PCR for detection of the tcdC gene with four toxin immunoassays and culture in diagnosis of Clostridium difficile infection. Journal of Clinical Microbiology 46: 1996-2001.
70. Smith, C. J., and A. M. Osborne. 2009. Advantages and limitations of quantitative PCR (Q-PCR)-based approaches in microbial ecology. FEMS Microbiology Ecology 67: 6-20.
71. Soler, J. J., J. M. Peralta-Sánchez, M. Martínez-Bueno, M. Martín-Vivaldi, D. Martín-Gálvez, A. I. Vela, V. Briones, and T. Pérez-Contreras. 2011. Brood parasitism is associated with increased bacterial contamination of host eggs: bacterial loads of host and parasitic eggs. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 103: 836-848.
72. Soler, J. J., J. M. Peralta-Sánchez, M. Martín-Vivaldi, A. M. Martín-Platero, E. Flensted-Jensen, and A. P. Møller. 2012a. Cognitive skills and bacterial load: comparative evidence of costs of cognitive proficiency in birds. Naturwissenschaften 99: 111-122.
73. Soler, J. J., J. M. Peralta-Sánchez, A. M. Martín-Platero, M. Martín-Vivaldi, M. Martínez-Bueno, and A. P. Møller. 2012b. The evolution of size of the uropygial gland: mutualistic feather mites and uropygial secretion reduce bacterial loads of eggshells and hatching failures of European birds. Journal of Evolutionary Biology 25: 1779-1791.
74. Taskin, B., A. G. Gozen, and M. Duran. 2011. Selective quantification of viable Escherichia coli bacteria in biosolids by quantitative PCR with propidium monoazide modification. Applied and Environmental Microbiology 77: 4329-4335.
75. Tooze, J. A., G. K. Grunwald, and J. h. Jones. 2002. Analysis of repeated measure data with clumping at zero. Statistical Methods in Medical Research 11: 341-355.
76. USEPA. 1985. Test methods for Escherichia coli and enterococci in water by the membrane filter procedure. Publication EPA-600/4-85-076, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Cincinnati, OH.
77. USEPA. 2010. ProUCL Software. http://www.epa.gov/osp/hstl/tsc/software.htm#about (12 July 2013).
78. Valasek, M. A., and J. J. Repa. 2005. The power of real-time PCR. Advances in Physiology Education 29: 151-159.
79. Walls, J. G., G. R. Hepp, and L. G. Eckhardt. 2011. Effects of incubation delay on viability and microbial growth of Wood Duck (Aix sponsa) eggs. Auk 128: 663-670.
80. Wang, J. M., M. K. Firestone, and S. R. Beissinger. 2011. Microbial and environmental effects on avian egg viability: do tropical mechanisms act in a temperate environment? Ecology 92: 1137-1145.
81. Wendelberger, J., and K. Campbell. 1994. Non-detect data in environmental investigations. Los Alamos National Laboratory Report, LA-UR-94-1856, Los Alamos, NM.
82. Whelan, J. A., N. B. Russel, and M. A. Whelan. 2003. A method for the absolute quantification of cDNA using real time PCR. Journal of Immunology Methods 278: 261-269.
83. Wobbrock, J. O., L. Findlater, D. Gergle, and J. J. Higgins. 2011. The aligned rank transform for nonparametric factorial analyses using only ANOVA procedures. In: Proceedings of the ACM Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI '11), pp. 143-146. ACM Press, New York, NY.
84. Wu, S. B., N. Rodgers, and M. Choct. 2011. Real-time PCR assay for Clostridium perfringens in broiler chickens in a challenge model of necrotic enteritis. Applied and Environmental Microbiology 77: 1135-1139.