Genes and politics: A new explanation and evaluation of twin study results and association studies in political science

Political Analysis

Volumn 21, Issue 3, 2013, Pages 350-367

  Shultziner, Doron ^a  

^a TEL AVIV UNIVERSITY   (Israel)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84880670742     PISSN: 10471987     EISSN: 14764989     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/pan/mps035     Document Type: Article

References (101)

1. Alford, John, Carolyn Funk, and John Hibbing. 2005. Are political orientations genetically transmitted? American Political Science Review 99(2):153-67.
2. Alford, John R., and John R. Hibbing. 2008. The new empirical biopolitics. Annual Review of Political Science 11:183-203.
3. Alford, John, and John Hibbing. 2004. The origin of politics: An evolutionary theory of political behavior. Perspectives on Politics 2(4):707-23.
4. Alford, John R., Carolyn L. Funk, and John R. Hibbing. 2008. Beyond liberals and conservatives to political genotypes and phenotypes. Perspectives on Politics 6(2):321-8.
5. Bateson, Patrick. 1998. Genes, environment, and the development of behaviour. In The limits of reductionism in biology. Chichester, UK: Novartis Foundation.
6. Bateson, P., D. Barker, T. Clutton-Brock, D. Deb, B. D'udine, R. A. Foley, P. Gluckman, K. Godfrey, T. Kirkwood, M. M. Lahr, J. McNamara, N. B. Metcalfe, P. Monaghan, H. G. Spencer, and S. E. Sultan. 2004. Developmental plasticity and human health. Nature 430(6998):419-21.
7. Beckwith, Jon, and Corey A. Morris. 2008. Twin studies of political behavior: Untenable assumptions? Perspectives on Politics 6(4):785-91.
8. Benjamin, Daniel. 2011. A white paper by Daniel Benjamin. In Genes, cognition, and social behavior: Next steps for foundations and researchers, ed. A. Lupia, 66-77. Arlington, VA: National Science Foundation.
9. Biuso, Emily. 2008. Genopolitics. Times Magazine. December 12. http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/14/magazine/14Ideas- Section2-B-t-007.html (accessed on November 6, 2012).
10. Bouchard, T. J., D. T. Lykken, M. Mcgue, N. L. Segal, and A. Tellegen. 1990. Sources of human psychological differences-the Minnesota study of twins reared apart. Science 250(4978):223-8.
11. Bouchard, T. J., and M. McGue. 2003. Genetic and environmental influences on human psychological differences. Journal of Neurobiology 54(1):4-45.
12. Bouchard, T. J., N. L. Segal, A. Tellegen, M. McGue, M. Keyes, and R. Krueger. 2003. Evidence for the construct validity and heritability of the Wilson-Patterson conservatism scale: A reared-apart twins study of social attitudes. Personality and Individual Differences 34(6):959-69.
13. Brewer, M. B., and K. P. Pierce. 2005. Social identity complexity and outgroup tolerance. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 31(3):428-37.
14. Brown, Donald E. 1991. Human universals. New York; London: McGraw-Hill.
15. Brown, Donald E. 1999. Human Universals. In The MIT encyclopedia of the cognitive sciences, eds. R. A. Wilson and F. C. Keil. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
16. Brown, Donald E. 2004. Human universals, human nature, and human culture. Daedalus 4:47-54.
17. Caspi, A., J. McClay, T. E. Moffitt, J. Mill, J. Martin, I. W. Craig, A. Taylor, and R. Poulton. 2002. Role of genotype in the cycle of violence in maltreated children. Science 297(5582):851-4.
18. Caspi, A., K. Sugden, T. E. Moffitt, A. Taylor, I. W. Craig, H. Harrington, J. McClay, J. Mill, J. Martin, A. Braithwaite, and R. Poulton. 2003. Influence of life stress on depression: Moderation by a polymorphism in the 5-HTT gene. Science 301(5631):386-9.
19. Charney, Evan. 2008a. Genes and ideologies. Perspectives on Politics 6(2):299-319.
20. Charney, Evan. 2008b. Politics, genetics, and "greedy reductionism." Perspectives on Politics 6(2):337-43.
21. Charney, Evan. 2009. Physiology may not be (political) destiny. PsyCrit. February 25.
22. Charney, Evan, and William English. 2012. Candidate genes and political behavior. American Political Science Review 106(1):1-34.
23. Dawes, Christopher T., and James H. Fowler. 2009. Partisanship, voting, and the dopamine D2 receptor gene. Journal of Politics 71(3):1157-71.
24. Easton, David. 1976. The relevance of biopolitics to political theory. In Biology and politics, ed. A. Somit. Paris: Mouton.
25. Falconer, Douglas S., and Trudy F. C. Mackay. 1996. Introduction to quantitative genetics, 4th ed. Essex, UK: Longmans Green, Harlow.
26. Feldman, M. W., and S. P. Otto. 1997. Twin studies, heritability, and intelligence. Science 278(5342):1383-4.
27. Fergusson, D. M., J. M. Boden, L. J. Horwood, A. L. Miller, and M. A. Kennedy. 2011. MAOA, abuse exposure, and antisocial behavior: 30-year longitudinal study. British Journal of Psychiatry 198(6):457-63.
28. Fowler, James H., Laura A. Baker, and Christopher T. Dawes. 2008. Genetic variation in political participation. American Political Science Review 102(2):233-48.
29. Fowler, James H., and Christopher T. Dawes. 2008. Two genes predict voter turnout. Journal of Politics 70(3):579-94.
30. Fowler, James H., and Darren Schreiber. 2008. Biology, politics, and the emerging science of human nature. Science 322(5903):912-4.
31. Gerber, A. S., G. A. Huber, D. Doherty, C. M. Dowling, and S. E. Ha. 2010. Personality and political attitudes: Relationships across issue domains and political contexts. American Political Science Review 104(1):111-33.
32. Gilbert, S. F. 2001. Ecological developmental biology: Developmental biology meets the real world. Developmental Biology 233(1):1-12.
33. Gottlieb, G. 2003. On making behavioral genetics truly developmental. Human Development 46(6):337-55.
34. Greenstein, Fred I. 1992. Can personality be studied systematically?. Political Psychology 13(1):105-28.
35. Hatemi, Peter K., Enda Byrne, and Rose McDermott. Forthcoming. What is a "gene" and why does it matter for political science? Journal of Theoretical Politics.
36. Hatemi, P. K., C. T. Dawes, A. Frost-Keller, J. E. Settle, and B. Verhulst. 2011. Integrating social science and genetics: News from the political front. Biodemography and Social Biology 57(1):67-87.
37. Hatemi, P. K., N. A. Gillespie, L. J. Eaves, B. S. Maher, B. T. Webb, A. C. Heath, S. E. Medland, D. C. Smyth, H. N. Beeby, S. D. Gordon, G. W. Montgomery, G. Zhu, E. M. Byrne, and N. G. Martin. 2011. A genome-wide analysis of liberal and conservative political attitudes. Journal of Politics 73(1):271-85.
38. Hatemi, P. K., J. R. Hibbing, S. E. Medland, M. C. Keller, J. R. Alford, K. B. Smith, N. G. Martin, and L. J. Eaves. 2010. Not by twins alone: Using the extended family design to investigate genetic influence on political beliefs. American Journal of Political Science 54(3):798-814.
39. Hatemi, P. K., J. R. Alford, J. R. Hibbing, N. G. Martin, and L. J. Eaves. 2009. Is there a "party" in your genes? Political Research Quarterly 62(3):584-600.
40. Hatemi, P. K., C. L. Funk, S. E. Medland, H. M. Maes, J. L. Silberg, N. G. Martin, and L. J. Eaves. 2009. Genetic and environmental transmission of political attitudes over a lifetime. Journal of Politics 71(3):1141-56.
41. Hatemi, P. K., S. E. Medland, and L. J. Eaves. 2009. Do genes contribute to the "gender gap"? Journal of Politics 71(1):262-76.
42. Hines, Samuel M. 1982. Politics and the evolution of inquiry in political science. Politics and the Life Sciences 1(1):5-37.
43. Huang, S. Y., M. T. Lin, W. W. Lin, C. C. Huang, M. J. Shy, and R. B. Lu. 2009. Association of monoamine oxidase A (MAOA) polymorphisms and clinical subgroups of major depressive disorders in the Han Chinese population. World Journal of Biological Psychiatry 10(4):544-51.
44. Johnson, W., E. Turkheimer, I. I. Gottesman, and T. J. Bouchard. 2009. Beyond heritability: Twin studies in behavioral research. Current Directions in Psychological Science 18(4):217-20.
45. Joseph, Jay. 2010. The genetics of political attitudes and behavior: Claims and refutations. Ethical Human Psychology and Psychiatry 12(3):200-17.
46. Keller, M. C., S. E. Medland, and L. E. Duncan. 2010. Are extended twin family designs worth the trouble? A comparison of the bias, precision, and accuracy of parameters estimated in four twin family models. Behavior Genetics 40(3):377-93.
47. Kendler, Kenneth S. 2005. "A gene for . . . ": The nature of gene action in psychiatric disorders. American Journal of Psychiatry 162(7):1243-52.
48. Lewontin, R. C. 1974. Analysis of variance and analysis of causes. American Journal of Human Genetics 26(3):400-11.
49. Lieberman, M. D., D. Schreiber, and K. N. Ochsner. 2003. Is political cognition like riding a bicycle? How cognitive neuroscience can inform research on political thinking. Political Psychology 24(4):681-704.
50. Losco, Joseph. 1982. Biopolitics: On evolution in the inquiry into political science-a response to Hines 1982. Politics and the Life Sciences 1(1):18-9.
51. Lupia, Arthur, ed. 2011. Genes, cognition, and social behavior: Next steps for foundations and researchers. In National Science Foundation's Political Science Program. Arlington, VA: National Science Foundation.
52. Lykken, D., and A. Tellegen. 1996. Happiness is a stochastic phenomenon. Psychological Science 7(3):186-9.
53. Maher, B. 2008. Personal genomes: The case of the missing heritability. Nature 456(7218):18-21.
54. Maher, B. 2010. Hiding place for missing heritability uncovered. Nature. Published online 26 January, doi:10.1038/ news.2010.33.
55. Mahoney, J. 2001. Beyond correlational analysis: Recent innovations in theory and method. Sociological Forum 16(3):575-93.
56. Mameli, M., and P. Bateson. 2006. Innateness and the sciences. Biology & Philosophy 21(2):155-88.
57. Manolio, T. A. 2010. Genome-wide association studies and assessment of the risk of disease. New England Journal of Medicine 363(2):166-76.
58. Manolio, T. A., F. S. Collins, N. J. Cox, D. B. Goldstein, L. A. Hindorff, D. J. Hunter, M. I. McCarthy, E. M. Ramos, L. R. Cardon, A. Chakravarti, J. H. Cho, A. E. Guttmacher, A. Kong, L. Kruglyak, E. Mardis, C. N. Rotimi, M. Slatkin, D. Valle, A. S. Whittemore, M. Boehnke, A. G. Clark, E. E. Eichler, G. Gibson, J. L. Haines, T. F. C. Mackay, S. A. McCarroll, and P. M. Visscher. 2009. Finding the missing heritability of complex diseases. Nature 461(7265):747-53.
59. Martin, N., D. Boomsma, and G. Machin. 1997. A twin-pronged attack on complex traits. Nature Genetics 17(4):387-92.
60. Martin, N. G., L. J. Eaves, A. C. Heath, R. Jardine, L. M. Feingold, and H. J. Eysenck. 1986. Transmission of social attitudes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 83(12):4364-8.
61. Masters, Roger D. 1990. Evolutionary biology and political theory. American Political Science Review 84(1):195-210.
62. McGue, M., and D. T. Lykken. 1992. Genetic influence on risk of divorce. Psychological Science 3(6):368-73.
63. McGuffin, Peter, Brien Riley, and Robert Plomin. 2001. Genomics and behavior - toward behavioral genomics.. Science 291(5507):1232-3.
64. Meaney, Michael J. 2001. Nature, nurture, and the disunity of knowledge. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 935:50-61.
65. Medland, S. E., and P. K. Hatemi. 2009. Political science, biometric theory, and twin studies: A methodological introduction. Political Analysis 17:191-214.
66. Molenaar, P. C. M., and C. G. Campbell. 2009. The new person-specific paradigm in psychology. Current Directions in Psychological Science 18(2):112-7.
67. Mondak, J. J., M. V. Hibbing, D. Canache, M. A. Seligson, and M. R. Anderson. 2010. Personality and civic engagement: An integrative framework for the study of trait effects on political behavior. American Political Science Review 104(1):85-110.
68. Munafo, M. R., C. Durrant, G. Lewis, and J. Flint. 2009. Gene x environment interactions at the serotonin transporter locus. Biological Psychiatry 65(3):211-9.
69. Munafo, M. R., and J. Flint. 2009. Replication and heterogeneity in gene x environment interaction studies. International Journal of Neuropsychopharmacology 12(6):727-9.
70. Oxley, D. R., K. B. Smith, J. R. Alford, M. V. Hibbing, J. L. Miller, M. Scalora, P. K. Hatemi, and J. R. Hibbing. 2008. Political attitudes vary with physiological traits. Science 321(5896):1667-70.
71. Pinker, Steven. 2003. The blank slate: The modern denial of human nature. London: Penguin.
72. Plomin, R. 1989. Environment and genes-determinants of behavior. American Psychologist 44(2):105-11.
73. Plomin, R., M. J. Owen, and P. McGuffin. 1994. The genetic basis of complex human behaviors. Science 264(5166):1733-9.
74. Price, T. D., A. Qvarnstrom, and D. E. Irwin. 2003. The role of phenotypic plasticity in driving genetic evolution. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series B-Biological Sciences 270(1523):1433-40.
75. Prichard, Z., A. Mackinnon, A. F. Jorm, and S. Easteal. 2008. No evidence for interaction between MAOA and childhood adversity for antisocial behavior. American Journal of Medical Genetics Part B-Neuropsychiatric Genetics 147B(2):228-32.
76. Risch, N., R. Herrell, T. Lehner, K. Y. Liang, L. Eaves, J. Hoh, A. Griem, M. Kovacs, J. Ott, and K. R. Merikangas. 2009. Interaction between the serotonin transporter gene (5-HTTLPR), stressful life events, and risk of depression: A meta-analysis. JAMA-Journal of the American Medical Association 301(23):2462-71.
77. Rose, Steven P. R. 2006. Commentary: Heritability Estimates-long past their sell-by date. International Journal of Epidemiology 35(3):525-7.
78. Rustow, Dankwark. A. 1970. Transitions to democracy-toward a dynamic model. Comparative Politics 2(3):337-63.
79. Sarkar, Sahotra. 1999. From the reaktionsnorm to the adaptive norm: The norm of reaction, 1909-1960. Biology & Philosophy 14(2):235-52.
80. Schonemann, P. H. 1997. On models and muddles of heritability. Genetica 99(2-3):97-108.
81. Settle, J. E., C. T. Dawes, N. A. Christakis, and J. H. Fowler. 2010. Friendships moderate an association between a dopamine gene variant and political ideology. Journal of Politics 72(4):1189-98.
82. Shultziner, Doron. 2010. Struggling for recognition: The psychological impetus for democratic progress. New York: Continuum Press.
83. Shultziner, Doron, Thomas Stevens, Martin Stevens, Brian A. Stewart, Rebbeca J. Hannagan, and Giulia Saltini- Semerari. 2010. The causes and scope of political egalitarianism during the last glacial: A multi-disciplinary perspective. Biology & Philosophy 25(3):319-46.
84. Smith, K. B., J. R. Alford, P. K. Hatemi, L. Eaves, C. L. Funk, and J. R. Hibbing. 2012. Biology, ideology, and epistemology: How do we know political attitudes are inherited and why should we care? American Journal of Political Science 56(1):17-33.
85. Somit, Albert. 1976. Biology and politics: Recent explorations. The Hague: Mouton.
86. Somit, Albert, and Steven Peterson. 1998. Biopolitics after three decades-a balanced sheet. British Journal of Political Science 28(3):559-71.
87. Suhay, Elizabeth, Nathan Kalmoe, and Christa McDermott. 2007. Why twin studies are problematic for the study of political ideology: Rethinking "are political orientations genetically transmitted?" Presented at the annual meeting of the International Society of Political Psychology, Portland, OR.
88. Sultan, S. E. 2003. Commentary: The promise of ecological developmental biology. Journal of Experimental Zoology 296(1):1-7.
89. Tajfel, Henri, and John C. Turner 1979. An integrative theory of intergroup conflict. In The social psychology of intergroup relations, eds. W. G. Austin and S. Worchel. Monterey, CA: Brooks-Cole.
90. Todd, J. A. 2006. Statistical false positive or true disease pathway? Nature Genetics 38(7):731-3.
91. Tooby, John, and Leda Cosmides. 1992. The psychological foundations of culture. In The adapted mind: Evolutionary psychology and the generation of culture, eds. J. H. Barkow, L. Cosmides, and J. Tooby. New York: Oxford University Press.
92. Turkheimer, Eric. 2004. Spinach and ice cream: Why social science is so difficult. In Behavioral genetics principles: Perspectives in development, personality, and psychopathology, ed. L. DiLalla. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
93. Turkheimer, Eric. 2000. Three laws of behavior genetics and what they mean. Current Directions in Psychological Science 9(5):160-4.
94. Turkheimer, E., A. Haley, M. Waldron, B. D'Onofrio, and I. I. Gottesman. 2003. Socioeconomic status modifies heritability of IQ in young children. Psychological Science 14(6):623-8.
95. Turner, John C. 1982. Toward a cognitive definition of the social group. In Social identity and intergroup relations, ed. H. Tajfel. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
96. Verhulst, Brad, Lindon J. Eaves, and Peter K. Hatemi. 2012. Correlation not causation: The relationship between personality traits and political ideologies. American Journal of Political Science 56(1):34-51.
97. Visscher, P. M., W. G. Hill, and N. R. Wray. 2008. Heritability in the genomics era-concepts and misconceptions. Nature Reviews Genetics 9(4):255-66.
98. Visscher, P. M., S. E. Medland, M. A. R. Ferreira, K. I. Morley, G. Zhu, B. K. Cornes, G. W. Montgomery, and N. G. Martin. 2006. Assumption-free estimation of heritability from genome-wide identity-by-descent sharing between full siblings. Plos Genetics 2(3):316-25.
99. Waller, N. G., B. A. Kojetin, T. J. Bouchard, D. T. Lykken, and A. Tellegen. 1990. Genetic and environmental influences on religious interests, attitudes, and values-a study of twins reared apart and together. Psychological Science 1(2):138-42.
100. Weder, N., B. Z. Yang, H. Douglas-Palumberi, J. Massey, J. H. Krystal, J. Gelernter, and J. Kaufman. 2009. MAOA genotype, maltreatment, and aggressive behavior: The changing impact of genotype at varying levels of trauma. Biological Psychiatry 65(5):417-24.
101. Winter, David. 2003. Personality and political behavior. In Oxford handbook of political psychology, ed. D. O. Sears, L. Huddy, and R. Jervis. New York: Oxford University Press.