Ignoring the data and endangering children: Why the mature minor standard for medical decision making must be abandoned

Journal of Medicine and Philosophy (United Kingdom)

Volumn 38, Issue 3, 2013, Pages 315-331

  Cherry, Mark J ^a  

^a ST EDWARD'S UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Graham v. Florida; informed consent; mature minor; medical decision making; Miller v. Alabama; Roper v. Simmons

Indexed keywords

ADOLESCENT; ADOLESCENT DEVELOPMENT; BRAIN; CANADA; COGNITION; DECISION MAKING; ETHICS; GROWTH, DEVELOPMENT AND AGING; HUMAN; INFORMED CONSENT; JURISPRUDENCE; LEGISLATION AND JURISPRUDENCE; MENTAL CAPACITY; MINOR (PERSON); PSYCHOLOGY; UNITED STATES; ARTICLE; GRAHAM V. FLORIDA; LEGAL ASPECT; MATURE MINOR; MEDICAL DECISION MAKING; MILLER V. ALABAMA; PSYCHOLOGICAL ASPECT; ROPER V. SIMMONS;

ADOLESCENT; ADOLESCENT DEVELOPMENT; BRAIN; CANADA; COGNITION; DECISION MAKING; HUMANS; INFORMED CONSENT; MENTAL COMPETENCY; MINORS; SUPREME COURT DECISIONS; UNITED STATES;

GRAHAM V. FLORIDA; INFORMED CONSENT; MATURE MINOR; MEDICAL DECISION MAKING; MILLER V. ALABAMA; ROPER V. SIMMONS;

EID: 84878091593     PISSN: 03605310     EISSN: 17445019     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/jmp/jht014     Document Type: Article

References (57)

1. ACLU 2005. Your Health, Your Rights [On-line]. Available www.teensource.org/ts/sites/default/files/your-health-your-rights.pdf (accessed March 13 2013).
2. Arnett, J. 1992. Reckless behavior in adolescence: A developmental perspective. Developmental Review 12:339-73.
3. Canadian Pediatric Society. 2004. Treatment decisions regarding infants, children and adolescents. Paediatric Child Health 9:99-103.
4. Carpenter-Hyland, E. P. and L. J. Chandler. 2007. Adaptive plasticity of NMDA receptors and dendritic spines: Implications for enhanced vulnerability of the adolescent brain to alcohol addiction. Pharmacology, Biochemistry and Behavior 86:200-8. (Pubitemid 46282059)
5. Casey, B. J., A. Galvan, and T. A. Hare. 2005. Changes in cerebral functional organization during cognitive development. Current Opinion in Neurobiology 15:239-44. (Pubitemid 41569275)
6. Casey, B. J., S. Getz, and A. Galvan. 2008. The adolescent brain. Developmental Review 28:62-77.
7. Casey, B. J., J. N. Giedd, and K. M. Thomas. 2000. Structural and functional brain development and its relation to cognitive development. Biological Psychology 54:241-57.
8. Casey, B. J., R. M. Jones, and T. A. Hare. 2008. The adolescent brain. Annals of the New York Academy of Science 1124:111-26. (Pubitemid 351506787)
9. Cauffman, E., E. P. Shulman, L. Steinberg, E. Claus, M. T. Banich, S. Graham, and J. Woolard. 2010. Age differences in affective decision making as indexed by performance on the Iowa gambling task. Developmental Psychology 46:193-207.
10. Chan, R. C. K., D. Shum, T. Toulopoulou, and E. Y. H. Chen. 2008. Assessment of executive functions: Review of instruments and identification of critical issues. Archives of Clinical Neurophysiology 23:201-16.
11. Clark, L., R. Cools, and T. W. Robbins. 2004. The neuropsychology of ventral prefrontal cortex: Decision-making and reversal learning. Brain and Cognition 55:41-53. (Pubitemid 38591429)
12. Cook, R. J., J. N. Erdman, and B. M. Dickens. 2007. Respecting adolescents' confidentiality and reproductive and sexual choices. International Journal of Gynaecology and Obstetrics 98:182-87. (Pubitemid 47042737)
13. De Lourdes-Levy, M., V. Larcher, and R. Kurz; Ethics Working Group of the CESP. 2003. Informed consent/assent in children. Statement of the ethics working group of the Confederation of European Specialists in Paediatrics (CESP). European Journal of Pediatrics 162:629-33. (Pubitemid 37100627)
14. Dickens, B. M. and R. J. Cook. 2005. Adolescents and consent to treatment. International Journal of Gynaecology and Obstetrics 89:179-84. (Pubitemid 40585628)
15. Downie, R. S. and F. Randall. 1997. Parenting and the best interests of minors. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 22:219-31.
16. Eaton, D. K., L. Kann, S. Kinchen, J. Ross, J. Hawkins, W. A. Harris, R. Lowry, et al. 2006. Youth risk behavior surveillance-United States, 2005, surveillance summaries. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 55:1-108.
17. Eaton, D. K., L. K ann, S. K inchen, S. Shanklin, J. R oss, J. H awkins, W. A. H arris, et al.; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). 2008. Youth risk behavior surveillance-United States, 2007, surveillance summaries. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 57:1-131.
18. Erikson, E. 1968. Identity: Youth and Crisis. New York: W.W. Norton & Company, Inc.
19. Ernst, M., E. E. Nelson, S. Jazbec, E. B. McClure, C. S. Monk, E. Leibenluft, J. Blair, and D. S. Pine. 2005. Amygdala and nucleus accumbens in response to receipt and omission of gains in adults and adolescents. Neuroimage 25:1279-91. (Pubitemid 40591669)
20. Galvan, A., T. Hare, H. Voss, G. Glover, and B. J. Casey. 2007. Risk-taking and the adolescent brain: Who is at risk? Developmental Science 10:F8-14.
21. Geidd, J. N., J. Blumenthal, and N. Jeffries. 1999. Brain development during childhood and adolescence: A longitudinal MRI study. Nature Neuroscience 2:861-63. (Pubitemid 30602596)
22. Gilbert, S. J. and P. W. Burgess. 2008. Executive function. Current Biology 18:R110-14. (Pubitemid 351192314)
23. Gogtay, N., J. N. Giedd, L. Lusk, K. M. Hayashi, D. Greenstein, A. C. Vaituzis, T. F. Nugent, et al. 2004. Dynamic mapping of human cortical development during childhood through early adulthood. Proceeding of the National Academy of Sciences 101:8174-79. (Pubitemid 38698073)
24. Happaney, K., P. D. Zelazo, and D. T. Stuss. 2004. Development of orbitofrontal function: Current themes and future directions. Brain and Cognition 55:1-10. (Pubitemid 38591426)
25. Hasan, K. M., C. Halphen, A. Sankar, T. J. Eluvathingal, L. Kramer, K. K. Stuebing, L. Ewing-Cobbs, and J. M. Fletcher. 2007. Diffusion tensor imaging-based tissue segmentation: Validation and application to the developing child and adolescent brain. NeuroImage 34:1497-505. (Pubitemid 46201906)
26. Hickey, K. 2007. Minors' rights in medical decision-making. Journal of Nursing Administration: Healthcare Law, Ethics, and Regulation 9:100-4.
27. Hikosaka, K. and M. Watanabe. 2000. Delay activity of orbital and lateral prefrontal neurons of the monkey varying with different rewards. Cereb Cortex 10:263-71. (Pubitemid 30159293)
28. Jernigan, T. L., D. A. Trauner, J. R. Hesselink, and P. A. Tallal. 1991. Maturation of human cerebrum observed in vivo during adolescence. Brain 114:2037-49.
29. KOMO Staff. 2010, Mar. 24. Mother furious after in-school clinic sets up teen's abortion. KOMO News-Seattle Washington. www.komonews.com/news/local/ 88971742.html (accessed March 24, 2010).
30. Kuther, T. L. 2003. Medical decision-making and minors: Issues of consent and assent. Adolescence 38:343-58. (Pubitemid 37469598)
31. Lemmens, C. 2009. End-of-life decisions and minors: Do minors have the right to refuse life preserving medical treatment? A comparative study. Medicine and Law 28:479-97.
32. Luna, B., A. Padmanabhan, and K. O'Hearn. 2010. What has fMRI told us about the development of cognitive control through adolescence? Brain and Cognition. 72:101-13.
33. Matthews, S. C., A. N. Simmons, S. D. Lane, and M. P. Paulus. 2004. Selective activation of the nucleus accumbens during risk-taking decision-making. Neuroreport 15:2123-27. (Pubitemid 39281759)
34. Monk, C. S., E. B. McClure, E. E. Nelson, E. Zarahn, R. M. Bilder, E. Leibenluft, D. S. Charney, M. Ernst, and D. S. Pine. 2003. Adolescent immaturity in attention-related brain engagement to emotional facial expressions. Neuroimage 20:420-28. (Pubitemid 37188530)
35. Ondrusek, N., R. Abramovitch, P. Pencharz, and G. Koren. 1998. Empirical examination of the ability of children to consent to clinical research. Journal of Medical Ethics 24:158-65. (Pubitemid 28274480)
36. Planned Parenthood. 2009. Parental Consent and Notification Laws [On-line]. Available: http://www.plannedparenthood.org/health-topics/abortion/ parental-consent-notificationlaws-25268.htm?-utma=1.451122628.1362642910. 1362642910.1362642910.1&-utmb=1.19.10.1362642910&-utmc=1&-utmx= -&-utmz=1.1362642910.1.1.utmcsr=%28direct%29|utmccn=%28direct%29|utmcmd= %28none%29&-utmv=-&-utmk=216182550 (accessed March 13, 2012).
37. Ridderinkhof, K. R., W. P. M. Van den Wildenberg, S. J. Segalowitz, and C. S. Carter. 2004. Neurocognitive mechanisms of cognitive control: The role of prefrontal cortex in action selection, response inhibition, performance monitoring, and reward-based learning. Brain and Cognition 56:129-40. (Pubitemid 39423876)
38. Ringheim, K. 2007. Ethical and human rights perspectives on providers' obligation to ensure adolescents' rights to privacy. Studies in Family Planning 38:245-52. (Pubitemid 350238608)
39. Schultz, W. 2006. Behavioral theories and the neurophysiology of reward. Annual Reviews of Psychology 57:87-115. (Pubitemid 43237228)
40. Schwarz, S. W. 2009. Adolescent Violence and Unintended Injury in the United States [On-line]. National Center for Children in Poverty. Available: http://www.nccp.org/publications/pdf/text-890.pdf (accessed November 29, 2012).
41. Segalowitz, S. J. and P. L. Davis. 2004. Charting the maturation of the frontal lobe: An electrophysiological strategy. Brain and Cognition 55:116-33. (Pubitemid 38591434)
42. Sinclair, S. J. 2009. Involvement of adolescents in decision making for heart transplants. The American Journal of Maternal Child Nursing 34:276-81.
43. Somerville, L. H., R. M. Jones, and B. J. Casey. 2010. A time of change: Behavioral and neural correlates of adolescent sensitivity to appetitive and averse environmental cues. Brain and Cognition 72:124-33.
44. Sowell, E. R., B. S. Peterson, P. M. Thompson, S. E. Welcome, A. L. Henkenius, and A. W. Toga. 2003. Mapping cortical change across the human life span. Nature Neuroscience 6:309-15. (Pubitemid 36278290)
45. Sowell, E. R., P. M. Thompson, C. J. Holmes, T. L. Jernigan, and A. W. Toga. 1999. In vivo evidence for post-adolescent brain maturation in frontal and striatal regions. Nature Neuroscience 2:859-61. (Pubitemid 30602595)
46. Sowell, E. R., P. M. Thompson, C. M. Leonard, S. E. Welcome, E. Kan, and A. W. Toga. 2004. Longitudinal mapping of cortical thickness and brain growth in normal children. The Journal of Neuroscience 24:8223-31. (Pubitemid 39280801)
47. Spear, L. 2000. Neurobehavioural changes in adolescence. Current Directions in Psychological Science 9:111-14.
48. Steinberg, L. 2004. Risk taking in adolescence: What changes, and why? Annals of the New York Academy of Science 1021:51-58. (Pubitemid 38879609)
49. -. 2005. Cognitive and affective development in adolescence. Trends in Cognitive Science 9:69-74. (Pubitemid 40173919)
50. Steinberg, L. and E. S. Scott. 2003. Less guilty by reason of adolescence: Developmental immaturity, diminished responsibility, and the juvenile death penalty. American Psychologist 58:1009-18. (Pubitemid 38023979)
51. Thompson, P. M., J. N. Giedd, R. P. Woods, D. MacDonald, A. C. Evans, and A. W. Toga. 2000. Growth patterns in the developing brain detected by using continuum mechanical tensor maps. Nature 404:190-93. (Pubitemid 30154487)
52. Unguru, Y., N. J. Coppes, and N. Kamani. 2008. Rethinking pediatric assent: From requirement to ideal. Pediatric Clinics of North America 55:211-22. (Pubitemid 351187778)
53. Unguru, Y., A. M. Sill, and N. Kamani. 2010. The experiences of children enrolled in pediatric oncology research: Implications for assent. Pediatrics 125:e876-83.
54. Whitty-Rogers, J., M. Alex, C. MacDonald, D. Pierrynowski Gallant, and W. Austin. 2009. Working with children in end-of-life decision-making. Nursing Ethics 16:743-58.
55. Wright, B., J. Aldridge, K. Wurr, T. Sloper, H. Tomlinson, and M. Mill. 2009. Clinical dilemmas in children with life-limiting illnesses: Decision making and the law. Palliative Medicine 23:238-47.
56. Zawistowski, C. A. and J. E. Frader. 2003. Ethical problems in pediatric critical care: Consent. Critical Care Medicine 31(Suppl. 5):s407-10. (Pubitemid 36583833)
57. Ziner, S. E. 1995. The elusive goal of informed consent by adolescents. Theoretical Medicine 16:323-31.