Tine De Moor's 'Silent Revolution'. Reconsidering her theoretical framework for explaining the emergence of institutions for the collective management of resources

International Journal of the Commons

Volumn 7, Issue 1, 2013, Pages 209-229

  Curtis, Daniel Robert ^a  

^a UTRECHT UNIVERSITY   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Commons; De Moor; Silent Revolution; Socio political structures

Indexed keywords

EID: 84874588522     PISSN: 18750281     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.18352/ijc.354     Document Type: Review

References (129)

1. Abatantuono, M. 2004. Statuti, ordinamenti, leggi municipali e provvisioni di Bruscoli del 1404. In Dal Medioevo alla Repubblica, eds. E. Stefanini and M. Abatantuono. Bruscoli.
2. Alfani, G. 2011. Le partecipanze: il caso di Nonantola. In La gestione delle risorse collettive nell'Italia settentrionale (secoli XII-XVIII), eds. G. Alfani and R. Rao. Milan.
3. Allen, R. 1992. Enclosure and the Yeoman. Oxford.
4. Arizkun Cela, A. 1985. Crecimento agropecuario y retroceso de aprovechamientos comunales en la Montana navarra durante el siglo XVI: el caso del valle de Baztán. In Industrializacíon y nacionalismo: análisis comparativo. Barcelona.
5. Ault, W. 1972. Open-Field Farming in Medieval England. A Study of Village by-Laws. London.
6. Bailey, M. 2010. Beyond the Midland Field System: The Determinants of Common Rights Over the Arable in Medieval England. Agricultural History Review 58(2):153-171.
7. Balestracci, M. 1999. The Renaissance in the Fields: Family Memoirs of a Fifteenth-Century Tuscan Peasant, trans. P. Squatriti and B. Merideth. University Park PA.
8. Barreiro Mallón, B. 1997. Los montes comunales y la coyuntura socio-económica en el occidente de Asturias en los siglos XVI a XVIII. In Homenaje a Juan Uría Ríu, vol.1. Oviedo.
9. Bernal Rodríguez, A. 1997. La tierra comunal en Andalucía durante la Edad Moderna. Studia Historica. Historia Moderna 16:101-128.
10. Bicchierai, M. 2007. La lunga durata dei beni comuni in una comunità Toscana: il caso di Raggiolo in Casentino. In Comunità e beni comuni dal medioevo ad oggi. Pistoia.
11. Biller, P. 1982. Birth-Control in the West in the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Centuries. Past and Present 94:3-26.
12. Blickle, P. 1998. From the Communal Reformation to the Revolution of the Common Man. Leiden.
13. Boserup, E. 1965. The Conditions of Agricultural Growth: The Economics of Agrarian Change Under Population Pressure. London.
14. Bulgarelli, L. 2011. La gestione delle risorse collettive nel Regno di Napoli in età moderna: un percorso comparativo. In La gestione delle risorse collettive nell'Italia settentrionale (secoli XII-XVIII), eds. G. Alfani and R. Rao. Milan.
15. Campbell, B. 1995. Ecology versus economics in late thirteenth and early fourteenth century English agriculture. In Agriculture in the Middle Ages: Technology, practice, and representation, ed. D. Sweeney. Philadelphia.
16. Campbell, B. and M. Overton. 1993. A New Perspective on Medieval and Early Modern Agriculture: Six Centuries of Norfolk Farming. Past and Present 141:38-105.
17. Cascella, B. 1991. I magistri forestarii e la gestione delle foreste. In Castelli, foreste, masserie: potere centrale e funzionari periferici nella Puglia del secolo XIII, ed. R. Licinio. Bari.
18. Chiappa Mauri, L. 1985. Riflessioni sulle campagne lombarde del Quattro-Cinquecento. Nuova Rivista Storica 69:123-130.
19. Chittolini, G. 1978. Alle origini delle 'grandi aziende' della bassa lombarda: l'agricoltura dell'irriguo fra XV e XVI secolo. Quaderni Storici 39:828-844.
20. Cohn, S. 2007. After the Black Death: Labour Legislation and Attitudes Towards Labour in Late-Medieval Western Europe. Economic History Review 60:457-485.
21. Comino, G. 1992. Sfruttamento e ridistribuzione di risorse collettive: il caso della confraria del S. Spirito nel Monregalese dei secoli XIII-XVIII. In Risorse collettive, eds. D. Moreno and O. Raggio, in Quaderni Storici 81:687-702.
22. Corrao, P. 1988. Per una storia del bosco e dell'incolto in Sicilia fra XI e XIII secolo. In Il bosco nel Medioevo, eds. M. Montanari and B. Andreolli. Bologna.
23. Cremonini, P. 1987. Dispute tra il monastero di Nonantola e la comunità rurali sulla proprietà e l'utilizzazione delle terre incolte. In I beni comuni nell'Italia comunale: fonti e studi, in Mélanges de l'École Francaise de Rome. Moyen Age-Temps Modernes 99:585-614.
24. Curtis, D. 2012. Florence and its Hinterlands in the Late Middle Ages: Contrasting Fortunes in the Tuscan Countryside, 1300-1500. Journal of Medieval History 38(4):472-499.
25. Curtis, D. and M. Campopiano. 2012. Into the Frontier: Medieval Land Reclamation and the Creation of New Societies. Comparing Holland and the Po Valley, 800-1500. World Economic History Congress Paper, Stellenbosch, South Africa, 2012.
26. Dahlman, C. 1980. The Open Field System and Beyond. Cambridge.
27. De Angelis Cappabianca, L. 1988. Le cassine tra il XII ed il XIV secolo: l'esempio di Milano. In Paesaggi urbani dell'Italia padana nei secoli VIII-XIV. Bologna.
28. de Boer, D. 1978. Graaf en grafiek: sociale en economische ontwikkelingen in het middeleeuwse 'Noordholland' tussen c. 1345 en c.1415. Leiden.
29. De Keyzer, M. 2012. Tenant Farmers and Commons: Friends or Foes? The Function and Transformation of the Commons in a Traditional Peasant Society; The Campine Area within the Low Countries (1500-1600). World Economic History Congress Paper, Stellenbosch, South Africa, 2012.
30. de la Roncière, C. 1997. Rentabilité, bien commun, écologie. La foret communale de San Gimignano. In Milieux naturels, espaces sociaux. Études offertes à Robert Delort. Paris.
31. De Moor, T. 2008. The Silent Revolution: A New Perspective on the Emergence of Commons, Guilds, and Other Forms of Corporate Collective Action in Western Europe. International Review of Social History 53:179-212.
32. De Moor, T. 2009. Avoiding Tragedies: A Flemish Common and its Commoners Under the Pressure of Social and Economic Change during the Eighteenth Century. Economic History Review 62(1):1-22.
33. De Moor, T. 2011. From Common Pastures to Global Commons: A Historical Perspective on Interdisciplinary Approaches on Commons. Natures, Sciences, Sociétés 19(4):54-63.
34. De Moor, T. 2012. What Do We Have in Common? A Comparative Framework for Old and New Literature on the Commons'. International Review of Social History 57:269-290.
35. De Moor, T. and J. L. van Zanden. 2010. Girlpower: The European Marriage Pattern (EMP) and Labour Markets in the North Sea Region in the Late Medieval and Early Modern Period. Economic History Review 63(1):1-33.
36. De Moor, T., L. Shaw-Taylor, and P. Warde. 2002. Comparing the historical commons of north-west Europe. An introduction. In The management of common land in North West Europe, c. 1500-1850. Turnhout.
37. Debbia, M. 1992. Il territorio di Nonantola durante il medioevo: partecipanza o beni comuni? Il significato dei beni comuni nella storia della comunità locale. In Terre e comunità nell'Italia padana. Il caso delle partecipanze agrarie emiliane: da beni comuni a beni collettivi. Mantova.
38. Dowd, D. 1961. The Economic Expansion of Lombardy, 1300-1500: A Study in Political Stimuli to Economic Change. Journal of Economic History 21:143-160.
39. Emigh, R. 1996. Loans and Livestock: Comparing Landlords' and Tenants' Declarations from the Catasto of 1427. Journal of European Economic History 25(3):705-723.
40. Endres, R. 1989. Absolutistische Entwicklungen in fränkischen Territorien im Spiegel der Dorfordnungen. Jahrbuch für Regionalgeschichte 16(2):81-93.
41. Epstein, S. 2001. Introduction. In Town and country in Europe, 1300-1800. New York.
42. Fox, H. 1984. Some ecological dimensions of medieval field systems. In Archaeological approaches to medieval Europe, ed. K. Biddick. Kalamazoo.
43. Genuardi, L. 1911. Terre comuni ed usi civici in Sicilia prima dell'abolizione della feudalità: studi e documenti. Palermo.
44. Greif, A. 2006. Institutions and the Path to the Modern Economy: Lessons from Medieval Trade. Cambridge.
45. Grillo, P. 2001. Il Comune di Milano e il problema dei beni pubblici fra XII e XIII secolo: da un processo del 1207. Mélanges de l'École Francaise de Rome. Moyen Age-Temps Modernes 113:433-451.
46. Gualteri, R., ed. 1992. Gli statute di Vernio. Prato.
47. Gunawardana, R. 1971. Irrigation and Hydraulic Society in Early Medieval Ceylon. Past and Present 53:3-27.
48. Hajnal, J. 1965. European marriage pattern in historical perspective. In Population in history, eds. D. Glass and D. Eversley. London.
49. Hardin, G. 1968. The Tragedy of the Commons. Science 162:1243-1248.
50. Hayhoe, J. 2002. Litigation and the Policing of Communal Farming in Northern Burgundy, 1750-1790. Agricultural History Review 50(1):51-68.
51. Henderikx, P. 1989. Die mittelalterliche Kultivierung der Moore im Rhein-Maas-Delta (10-13. Jahrhundert). Siedlungsforschung 7:67-87.
52. Hoffmann, R. 1975. Medieval origins of the common fields. In European Peasants and Their Markets, eds. W. Parker and E. Jones. Princeton.
53. Hoffmann, R. 1996. Economic Development and Aquatic Ecosystems in Medieval Europe. American Historical Review 101:631-669.
54. Hoppenbrouwers, P. 1993. Een meent en haar mythen: de vroegste geschiedenis van het Wijkerzand (15de-16de eeuw). In Historische reeks Land van Heusden en Altena, vol.3. Wijk & Aalburg.
55. Hoppenbrouwers, R. 2002. The use and management of commons in the Netherlands. An overview. In The management of common land in North West Europe, c. 1500-1850. Turnhout.
56. Isaacs, A. 1979. Le campagne senesi fra Quattro e Cinquecento: regime fondiario e governo signorile. In Contadini e proprietari nella Toscana moderna, ed. G. Giorgetti. vol.1. Florence.
57. Jones, P. 1983. Common rights and agrarian individualism in the Southern Massif Central, 1750-1880. In Beyond the terror: Essays in French regional and social history, 1794-1815. Cambridge.
58. Kirch, P. 1982. Tikopia: The History and Ecology of a Polynesian Outlier. Honolulu.
59. Klemp, M. and J. Weisdorf. 2011. The Child Quantity-Quality Trade-Off in England During the Industrial Revolution. .
60. Koch, A. and A. Maris. 1949. Meentgenootschappen in Land van Buren. BMGelre 49:163-204.
61. Kos, A. 2011. Van meenten tot marken. Een onderzoek naar de oorsprong van de Gooise marken en de gebruikrechten op de gemene gronden van de Gooise markgenoten (1280-1568). Hilversum.
62. Langdon, J. 1986. Horses, Oxen and Technological Innovation. The Use of Draught Animals in English Farming From 1066-1500. Cambridge.
63. Licciardello, P. and G. Scharf. 2007. Statuto di Moggiona e documenti annessi (fine 1268-inizi 1269). Archivio Storico Italiano 165(1):121-144.
64. Lomas, K. 1993. Rome and the Western Greeks, 350BC-AD200. Conquest and Acculturation in Southern Italy. London.
65. Malvolti, A. 2003. I proventi dell'incolto. Note sull'amministrazione delle risorse naturali del comune di Fucecchio nel tardo Medioevo. In Incolti, fiumi, paludi. Utilizzazione delle risorse naturali nella Toscana medievale e moderna, eds. A. Malvolti and G. Pinto. Florence.
66. Marino, J. 1988. Pastoral Economics in the Kingdom of Naples. Baltimore.
67. Marks, R. 1998. Tigers, Rice, Silk, and Silt. Environment and Economy in Late Imperial Southern China. Cambridge.
68. McCloskey, D. 1976. English Open Fields as Behaviour Toward Risk. Research in Economic History 1:124-170.
69. McCloskey, D. 1991. The Prudent Peasant: New Findings on Open Fields. Journal of Economic History 51:343-355.
70. Meibeyer, W. 1972. Der Rundling-eine koloniale Siedlungsform des hohen Mittelalters. Niedersachsiches Jahrbuch für Landesgeschichte 44:27-49.
71. Menant, F. 1993. Campagnes lombardes du moyen age: l'économie et la société rurales dans la région de Bergame, de Crémone et de Brescia du Xe au XIIIe siècle. Rome.
72. Mitterauer, M. 2003. Warum Europa? Mittelalterliche Grundlagen eines Sonderwegs. Munich.
73. Nardella, M. 1989. Produzione mercantile e intervento dello Stato nella seconda metà del Cinquecento: le terre a cerealicoltura estensiva della Dogana delle pecore di Foggia. In Undicesimo convegno sulla preistoria, protostoria e storia della Daunia. San Severo.
74. Neeson, J. 1996. Commoners: Common Right, Enclosure and Social Change in England, 1700-1820. Cambridge.
75. Nicolet, J. 1977. Rome et la conquête du monde méditerranéen. Les structures de l'italie romaine. vol.1. Paris.
76. Occhipinti, E. 1989. L'economia agraria in territorio milanese fra continuità e spinte innovative. In Milano ed il suo territorio in età comunale. Spoleto.
77. Oosthuizen, S. 2006. Landscapes Decoded: The History of Cambridgeshire's Medieval Fields. Hatfield.
78. Osborne, A. 1994. The Local Politics of Land Reclamation in the Lower Yangzi Highlands. Late Imperial China 15(1):1-46.
79. Osheim, D. 2004. Rural Italy. In Italy in the central Middle Ages, ed. D. Abulafia. Oxford.
80. Overton, M. 1996. Agricultural Revolution in England: The Transformation of the Agrarian Economy, 1500-1850. Cambridge.
81. Panaitescu, P. 1964. The peasant Obştea in Wallachia and Moldavia during the Middle Ages [Obştea t, ǎrǎneascǎ în Tara Româneascǎ şi Moldova. Orânduirea feudalǎ]. Bucharest.
82. Panjek, A. 2011. Not Demesne But Money: Lord and Peasant Economies in Early Modern Western Slovenia. Agricultural History Review 59(2):293-311.
83. Panjek, G. 1981. Beni comunali: note storiche e proposte di ricerca. In Venezia e la Terraferma attraverso le relazioni dei Rettori, ed. A. Tagliaferri. Milan.
84. Pascua Echegaray, E. 2011. Communties and Sustainability in Medieval and Early Modern Aragon, 1200-1600. International Journal of the Commons 5(2):535-556.
85. Pastor de Togneri, L. 1974. La lana en Castilla y Léon antes de la organización de la Mesta. In La lana come material prima. I fenomeni della sua produzione e circolazione nei secoli XIII-XVII, ed. M. Spallanzani. Florence.
86. Perdue, P. 1987. Exhausting the Earth: State and Peasant in Hunan, 1500-1850. Cambridge MA.
87. Poteete, A., M. Janssen, and E. Ostrom. 2010. Working Together. Collective Action, the Commons, and Multiple Methods in Practice. Princeton.
88. Pretty, J. 1990. Sustainable Agriculture in the Middle Ages on the English Manor. Agricultural History Review 38(1):1-19.
89. Rao, R. 2005. Risorse collettive e tensioni giurisdizionali nella pianura vercellese e novarese (XII-XIII secolo). Quaderni Storici 120:753-776.
90. Rao, R. 2006. Lo spazio del conflitto. I beni comunali nel Piemonte del basso Medioevo. Zapruder 11:8-25.
91. Reynolds, S. 1997. Kingdoms and Communities in Western Europe, 900-1300. Oxford.
92. Rodgers, C., E. Straughton, and A. Winchester. 2011. Contested Common Land. Environmental governance, past and present. London.
93. Rösener, W. 1985. Bauern im Mittelalter. Munich.
94. Saito, O. 2009. Forest History and the Great Divergence: China, Japan, and the West Compared. Journal of Global History 4:379-404.
95. Schofield, P. and T. Lambrecht, eds. 2009. Credit and the Rural Economy in North-Western Europe, c. 1200-c.1850. Turnhout.
96. Schütte, L. 2004. Markenrecht und Markengerichtsbarkeit in Nordwestdeutschland. In Allmenden und Marken vom Mittelalter bis zur Neuzeit, eds. U. Meiners and W. Rösener. Cloppenburg.
97. Sella, D. 1987. Household, Land Tenure and Occupation in North Italy in the Late Sixteenth Century. Journal of European Economic History 16:487-509.
98. Soens, T. 2006a. Explaining Deficiencies of Water Management in the Late Medieval Flemish Coastal Plain (13th-16th Centuries). In Waterbeheer, gemeenschappen en de naturlijke omgeving. De Lage Landen in comparatief perspectief, c. 1000-c. 1800. Jaarboek voor Ecologishe Geschiedenis, H. Greef and M. 't Hart (eds), Academia Press, Gent.
99. Soens, T. 2006b. Polders zonder poldermodel? Een onderzoek naar de rol van inspraak en overleg in de waterstaat van de laatmiddeleeuwse Vlaamse kustvlakte (1250-1600). Tijdschrift voor Sociale en Economische Geschiedenis 4: 3-36.
100. Soens, T. 2011. Floods and Money: Funding Drainage and Flood Control in Coastal Flanders from the Thirteenth to the Sixteenth Centuries. Continuity and Change 26(3):333-365.
101. Sommé, M. 1990. Réglements, délits et organisation des ventes dans la forêt de Nieppe (début XIVe siècle-début XVIe siècle). Revue du Nord 72:511-531.
102. Squatriti, P., ed. 2000. Working with Water in Medieval Europe. Technology and Resource-Use. Leiden.
103. Stol, T. 1991. Meentgronden in de Gelderse Vallei; in het bijzonder de Bennekommer meent. Eemvallei / Stichting Veldecologie Midden-Nederland, 1(1):64-74.
104. Tagliapietra, C. 2011. Charters, Partnerships and Natural Resources: Two Cases of Endogenous Regulation in Italy. Economic Affairs 31(2):30-35.
105. Thoen, E. 1997. The birth of 'Flemish husbandry': Agricultural technology in medieval Flanders. In Medieval farming and technology: The impact of agricultural change in Northwest Europe, ed. J. Langdon. Leiden.
106. Thoen, E. 2001. A commercial survival economy in evolution. The Flemish countryside and the transition to capitalism (Middle Ages-19th Century). In Peasants into farmers? The transformation of rural economy and society in the Low Countries (Middle Ages-19th Century) in light of the Brenner Debate, eds. P. Hoppenbrouwers and J. L. van Zanden. Turnhout.
107. Thoen, E. and E. Vanhaute. 1999. The Flemish husbandry at the edge: The farming system on small holdings in the middle of the nineteenth century. In Land productivity and agro-systems in the North Sea area (Middle Ages-20th Century). Elements for comparison, eds. B. van Bavel and E. Thoen. Turnhout.
108. Totman, C. 1985. The Origins of Japan's Modern Forests: The Case of Akita. Honolulu.
109. Totman, C. 1998. The Green Archipelago: Forestry in Pre-Industrial Japan. Athens [Ohio].
110. Tukker, A. 2010. Sanctionering en controle als sleutel tot overleving; gemene gronden in Gelderland en Overijssel van de vijftiende tot de achttiende eeuw. Leidschrift Historisch Tijdschrift 25(2):115-130.
111. van Bavel, B. 1999. Transitie en continuiteit: de bezitsverhoudingen en de plattelands-economie in het westelijke gedeelte van het Gelderse rivierengebied, ca. 1300-ca. 1570. Hilversum.
112. van Bavel, B. 2001. Land, Lease and Agriculture. The Transition of the Rural Economy in the Dutch River Area (Fourteenth-Sixteenth Centuries). Past and Present 172:3-43.
113. van Bavel, B. 2003. Early Proto-Industrialization in the Low Countries? The Importance and Nature of Non-Agricultural Activities on the Countryside in Flanders and Holland. Revue Belge de Philologie et d'Histoire 81(4):1109-1165.
114. van Bavel, B. 2010. Manors and Markets: Economy and Society in the Low Countries, 500-1600. Oxford.
115. van Dam, P. 2001. Sinking Peat Bogs: Environmental Change in Holland, 1350-1550. Environmental History 6(1):32-45.
116. van Dam, P. 2009. Water en land. Bijdragen en Mededelingen Betreffende de Geschiedenis der Nederlanden 124:459-466.
117. van der Linden, H. 1956. De cope: bijdrage tot de rechtgeschiedenis van de openlegging der Hollands-Utrechtse laagvlakte. Assen.
118. van der Linden, H. 1982. Het platteland in het Noordwesten met de nadruk op de occupatie circa 1000-1300. Algemene Geschiedenis der Nederlanden 2:48-82.
119. van Tielhof, M. 2009. Op zoek naar het poldermodel in de waterstaatsgeschiedenis. Tijdschrift voor Geschiedenis 122:149-161.
120. van Zanden, J. L. 1991. Arbeid tijdens het handelskapitalisme. Opkomst en neergang van de Hollandse economie, 1350-1850. Bergen.
121. van Zanden, J. L. 1999. The Paradox of the Marks. The Exploitation of the Commons in the Eastern Netherlands, 1250-1850. Agricultural History Review 47(2):125-145.
122. th century) in light of the Brenner debate, eds. P. Hoppenbrouwers and J. L. van Zanden. Turnhout.
123. Vardi, L. 1993. Contruing the Harvest: Gleaners, Farmers, and Officials in Early Modern France. American Historical Review 98(5):1424-1447.
124. Vivier, N. 1998. Propriété collective et identité communale: les biens communaux en France, 1750-1914. Paris.
125. Waley, D. 1988. The Italian city-republics. New York.
126. Wolf, A. and T. Engelen. 2008. Fertility and Fertility Control in Pre-revolutionary China. Journal of Interdisciplinary History 38:345-376.
127. Wunder, H. 1986. Die bäuerliche Gemeinde in Deutschland. Göttingen.
128. Zagnoni, R. 2007. Comunità e beni comuni nella montagna fra Bologna e Pistoia nel medioevo. In Comunità e beni comuni dal medioevo ad oggi. Pistoia.
129. Zuijderduijn, J. 2009. Medieval Capital Markets: Markets for Rents Between State Formation and Private Investment in Holland (1300-1550). Leiden.