Maternal benefits and risks of trial of labor versus elective repeat caesarean delivery in women with a previous caesarean delivery;Bénéfices et risques maternels de la tentative de voie basse comparée à la césarienne programmée en cas d'antécédent de césarienne

Journal de Gynecologie Obstetrique et Biologie de la Reproduction

Volumn 41, Issue 8, 2012, Pages 708-726

  Beucher, G ^a   Dolley, P ^a   Levy Thissier S ^a   Florian, A ^a   Dreyfus, M ^a  

^a CAEN UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL   (France)

Author keywords

Elective repeat caesarean delivery; Maternal morbidity; Previous caesarean; Trial of labor; Vaginal birth after caesarean delivery

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; BLADDER; BLEEDING; BLOOD TRANSFUSION; CESAREAN SECTION; ELECTIVE SURGERY; ENDOMETRITIS; FEVER; HEALTH HAZARD; HUMAN; HYSTERECTOMY; LABOR; MATERNAL MORBIDITY; MATERNAL MORTALITY; MATERNAL WELFARE; OBESITY; SCAR; SURGICAL INFECTION; UTERUS; UTERUS RUPTURE; VENOUS THROMBOEMBOLISM;

CESAREAN SECTION; CESAREAN SECTION, REPEAT; CICATRIX; FEMALE; HUMANS; MATERNAL MORTALITY; MORBIDITY; PREGNANCY; PREGNANCY OUTCOME; RISK ASSESSMENT; RISK FACTORS; TRIAL OF LABOR; UTERINE DISEASES; UTERINE RUPTURE; VAGINAL BIRTH AFTER CESAREAN;

EID: 84870704486     PISSN: 03682315     EISSN: 17730430     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jgyn.2012.09.028     Document Type: Article

References (84)

1. B. Blondel, N. Lelong, M. Kermarrec, and F. Goffinet La santé périnatale en France métropolitaine de 1995 à 2010. Résultats des enquêtes nationales périnatales J Gynecol Obstet Biol Reprod 41 2012 151 166
2. National Institutes of Health National Institutes of Health consensus development conference statement. Vaginal birth after caesarean: new insights March 8-10, 2010 Obstet Gynecol 115 2010 1279 1295
3. American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists Vaginal birth after previous caesarean delivery. ACOG practice bulletin 115 Obstet Gynecol 116 2010 450 463
4. American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists Vaginal birth after previous caesarean delivery. ACOG practice bulletin 5 1999 ACOG Washington, DC
5. Blondel B, Kermarrec M. Enquête nationale périnatale 2010. Les naissances en 2010 et leur évolution depuis 2003. Rapport mai 2011. www.drees.sante.gouv.fr.
6. C. D'Ercole, F. Bretelle, L. Piéchon, R. Shojai, and L. Boubli La césarienne a-t-elle une indication en cas d'utérus cicatriciel ? J Gynecol Obstet Biol Reprod 29 2000 51 67
7. J.M. Dodd, C.A. Crowther, E. Huertas, J.M. Guise, and D. Horey Planned elective repeat caesarean section versus planned vaginal birth for women with a previous caesarean birth Cochrane Database Syst Rev 4 2004 CD004224
8. M.G. Rosen, J.C. Dickinson, and C.L. Westhoff Vaginal birth after caesarean: a meta-analysis of morbidity and mortality Obstet Gynecol 77 1991 465 470
9. E.L. Mozurkewich, and E.K. Hutton Elective repeat caesarean delivery versus trial of labor: a meta-analysis of the literature from 1989 to 1999 Am J Obstet Gynecol 183 2000 1187 1197
10. A.C. Rossi, and V. D'Addario Maternal morbidity following a trial of labor after caesarean section vs elective repeat caesarean delivery: a systematic review with meta-analysis Am J Obstet Gynecol 199 2008 224 231
11. J.M. Guise, M. Denman, C. Emeis, N. Marshall, M. Walker, and R. Fu Vaginal birth after caesarean: new insights on maternal and fetal outcomes Obstet Gynecol 115 2010 1267 1278
12. M.B. Landon, J.C. Hauth, K.J. Leveno, C.Y. Spong, S. Leindecker, and M.W. Varner Maternal and perinatal outcomes associated with a trial of labor after prior caesarean delivery N Engl J Med 351 2004 2581 2589
13. C.A. Crowther, J.M. Dodd, J.E. Hiller, R.R. Haslam, J.S. Robinson, and J.S. Robinson Planned vaginal birth or elective repeat caesarean: patient preference restricted cohort with nested randomised trial PLoS Med 9 2012 e1001192
14. N.L. Eriksen, and L. Buttino Vaginal birth after caesarean: a comparison of maternal and neonatal morbidity to elective repeat caesarean section Am J Perinatol 6 1989 375 379
15. J.P. Phelan, M.O. Ahn, F. Diaz, H.S. Brar, and M.H. Rodriguez Twice a caesarean, always a caesarean? Obstet Gynecol 73 1989 161 165
16. F.J. Roumen, A.A. Janssen, and F.P. Vrouenraets The course of delivery after previous caesarean section Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol 34 1990 15 20
17. S. Iglesias, R. Burn, and L.D. Saunders Reducing the caesarean section rate in a rural community hospital Can Med Assoc J 145 1991 1459 1464
18. C.M. Paterson, and N.J. Saunders Mode of delivery after one caesarean section: audit of current practice in a health region BMJ 303 1991 818 821
19. L. Troyer, and V.M. Parisi Obstetric parameters affecting success in a trial of labor: designation of a scoring system Obstet Gynecol 167 1992 1099 1104
20. B.D. Raynor The experience with vaginal birth after caesarean delivery in a small rural community practice Am J Obstet Gynecol 168 1993 60 62
21. M.M. Abitbol, I. Castillo, U.B. Taylor, B.L. Rochelson, S. Shmoys, and A.G. Monheit Vaginal birth after caesarean section: the patient's point of view Am Fam Physician 47 1993 129 134
22. B.L. Flamm, J.R. Goings, Y. Liu, and G. Wolde-Tsadik Elective repeat caesarean delivery versus trial of labor: a prospective multicenter trial Obstet Gynecol 83 1994 927 932
23. S. Granovsky-Grisaru, M. Shaya, and Y.Z. Diamant The management of labor in women with more than one uterine scar: is a repeat caesarean section really the only "safe" option? J Perinat Med 22 1994 13 17
24. M.J. McMahon, E.R. Luther, W.A. Bowes Jr., and A.F. Olshan Comparison of a trial of labor with an elective second caesarean section N Engl J Med 335 1996 689 695
25. B. Hook, R. Kiwi, S.B. Amini, A. Fanaroff, and M. Hack Neonatal morbidity after elective repeat caesarean section and trial of labor Pediatrics 100 1997 348 353
26. H. Obara, H. Minakami, T. Koike, S. Takamizawa, S. Matsubara, and I. Sato Vaginal birth after caesarean delivery: results in 310 pregnancies J Obstet Gynaecol Res 24 1998 129 134
27. L.S. Swaim, C.S. Holste, and D.K. Waller Umbilical cord blood pH after prior caesarean delivery Obstet Gynecol 92 1998 390 393
28. J.C. Rageth, C. Juzi, and H. Grossenbacher Delivery after previous caesarean: a risk evaluation Obstet Gynecol 93 1999 332 337
29. C.Y. Spong, M.B. Landon, S. Gilbert, D.J. Rouse, K.J. Leveno, and M.W. Varner Risk of uterine rupture and adverse perinatal outcome at term after caesarean delivery Obstet Gynecol 110 2007 801 807
30. J.U. Hibbard, S. Gilbert, M.B. Landon, J.C. Hauth, K.J. Leveno, and C.Y. Spong Trial of labor or repeat caesarean delivery in women with morbid obesity and previous caesarean delivery Obstet Gynecol 108 2006 125 133
31. M.B. Landon, C.Y. Spong, E. Thom, J.C. Hauth, S.L. Bloom, and M.W. Varner Risk of uterine rupture with a trial of labor in women with multiple and single prior caesarean delivery Obstet Gynecol 108 2006 12 20
32. R.M. Silver, M.B. Landon, D.J. Rouse, K.J. Leveno, C.Y. Spong, and E.A. Thom Maternal morbidity associated with multiple repeat caesarean deliveries Obstet Gynecol 107 2006 1226 1232
33. J.M. Bais, D.M. van der Borden, M. Pel, G.J. Bonsel, M. Eskes, and H.J. van der Slikke Vaginal birth after caesarean section in a population with a low overall caesarean section rate Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol 96 2001 158 162
34. H. Blanchette, M. Blanchette, J. McCabe, and S. Vincent Is vaginal birth after caesarean safe? Experience at a communityhospital Am J Obstet Gynecol 184 2001 1478 1484 [discussion 1484-7]
35. J.U. Hibbard, M.A. Ismail, Y. Wang, C. Te, and T. Karrison Failed vaginal birth after a caesarean section: how risky is it? I. Maternal morbidity Am J Obstet Gynecol 184 2001 1365 1371 [discussion 1371-3]
36. W.A. Spaans, M.B. Sluijs, J. van Roosmalen, and O.P. Bleker Risk factors at caesarean section and failure of subsequent trial of labour Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol 100 2002 163 166
37. A. Kwee, M.L. Bots, G.H. Visser, and H.W. Bruinse Obstetric management and outcome of pregnancy in women with a history of caesarean section in the Netherlands Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol 132 2007 171 176
38. P.C. Tan, R.N. Subramaniam, and S.Z. Omar Labour and perinatal outcome in women at term with one previous lower-segment caesarean: a review of 1000 consecutive cases Aust N Z J Obstet Gynaecol 47 2007 31 36
39. J.M. Guise, K. Eden, C. Emeis, M.A. Denman, N. Marshall, and R. Fu Vaginal birth after caesarean: new insights. Evidence report/technology assessment No. 191. AHRQ publication No. 10-E003 2010 Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality Rockville, MD
40. G.S. Eglinton, J.P. Phelan, S. Yeh, F.P. Diaz, T.M. Wallace, and R.H. Paul Outcome of a trial of labor after prior caesarean delivery J Reprod Med 29 1984 3 8
41. K.D. Gregory, L.M. Korst, M. Fridman, I. Shihady, P. Broussard, and A. Fink Vaginal birth after caesarean: clinical risk factors associated with adverse outcome Am J Obstet Gynecol 198 2008 452.e1 452.e10
42. G. Loebel, C.M. Zelop, J.F.X. Egan, and J. Wax Maternal and neonatal morbidity after elective repeat Caesarean delivery versus a trial of labor after previous Caesarean delivery in a community teaching hospital J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med 15 2004 243 246
43. J.N. Martin Jr., B.A. Harris Jr., J.F. Huddleston, J.C. Morrison, M.G. Propst, and W.L. Wiser Vaginal delivery following previous caesarean birth Am J Obstet Gynecol 146 1983 255 263
44. J.P. Phelan, S.L. Clark, F. Diaz, and R.H. Paul Vaginal birth after caesarean Am J Obstet Gynecol 157 1987 1510 1515
45. S.W. Wen, I.D. Rusen, M. Walker, R. Liston, M.S. Kramer, and T. Baskett Comparison of maternal mortality and morbidity between trial of labor and elective caesarean section among women with previous caesarean delivery Am J Obstet Gynecol 191 2004 1263 1269
46. C.M. Zelop, T.D. Shipp, J.T. Repke, A. Cohen, A.B. Caughey, and E. Lieberman Uterine rupture during induced or augmented labor in gravid women with one prior caesarean delivery Am J Obstet Gynecol 181 1999 882 886
47. A.G. Cahill, D.M. Stamilio, A.O. Odibo, J.F. Peipert, S.J. Ratcliffe, and E.J. Stevens Is vaginal birth after caesarean (VBAC) or elective repeat caesarean safer in women with a prior vaginal delivery? Am J Obstet Gynecol 195 2006 1143 1147
48. A.B. Caughey, T.D. Shipp, J.T. Repke, C.M. Zelop, A. Cohen, and E. Lieberman Rate of uterine rupture during a trial of labor in women with one or two prior caesarean deliveries Am J Obstet Gynecol 181 1999 872 876
49. R.K. Cowan, R.A. Kinch, B. Ellis, and R. Anderson Trial of labor following caesarean delivery Obstet Gynecol 83 1994 933 936
50. B.L. Flamm, L.A. Newman, S.J. Thomas, D. Fallon, and M.M. Yoshida Vaginal birth after caesarean delivery: results of a 5-year multicenter collaborative study Obstet Gynecol 76 1990 750 754
51. B.L. Flamm, O.W. Lim, C. Jones, D. Fallon, L.A. Newman, and J.K. Mantis Vaginal birth after caesarean section: results of a multicenter study Am J Obstet Gynecol 158 1988 1079 1084
52. E. Kugler, I. Shoham-Vardi, E. Burstien, M. Mazor, and R. Hershkovitz The safety of a trial of labor after caesarean section in a grand multiparous population Arch Gynecol Obstet 277 2008 339 344
53. S.P. Chauhan, E.F. Magann, C.S. Carroll, P.S. Barrilleaux, J.A. Scardo, and J.N. Martin Jr. Mode of delivery for the morbidly obese with prior caesarean delivery: vaginal versus repeat caesarean section Am J Obstet Gynecol 185 2001 349 354
54. C. Durnwald, and B. Mercer Vaginal birth after caesarean delivery: predicting success, risks of failure J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med 15 2004 388 393
55. R.S. Hansell, K.B. McMurray, and G.R. Huey Vaginal birth after two or more caesarean sections: a five-year experience Birth 17 1990 146 150
56. L.M. Harper, A.G. Cahill, D.M. Stamilio, A.O. Odibo, J.F. Peipert, and G.A. Macones Effect of gestational age at the prior caesarean delivery on maternal morbidity in subsequent VBAC attempt Am J Obstet Gynecol 200 2009 276.e1 276.e6
57. M.G. Phipps, B. Watabe, J.L. Clemons, S. Weitzen, and D.L. Myers Risk factors for bladder injury during caesarean delivery Obstet Gynecol 105 2005 156 160
58. N.E. Marshall, R. Fu, and J.M. Guise Impact of multiple caesarean deliveries on maternal morbidity: a systematic review Am J Obstet Gynecol 205 2011 262.e1 262.e8
59. S.A. Gilbert, W.A. Grobman, M.B. Landon, C.Y. Spong, D.J. Rouse, and K.L. Leveno Elective repeat caesarean delivery compared spontaneous trial of labor after a prior caesarean delivery: a propensity score analysis Am J Obstet Gynecol 206 2012 311.e11 311.e19
60. O. Parant Rupture utérine : prédiction, diagnostic et prise en charge J Gynecol Obstet Biol Reprod 2012 10.1016/j.jgyn.2012.09.036
61. K.E. Fitzpatrick, J.J. Kurinczuk, Z. Alfirevic, P. Spark, P. Brocklehurst, and M. Knight Uterine rupture by intended mode of delivery in the UK: a national case-control study PLoS Med 9 2012 e1001184
62. G. Kayem, C. Raiffort, H. Legardeur, L. Gavard, L. Mandelbrot, and G. Girard Critères d'acceptation de la voie vaginale selon les caractéristiques de la cicatrice utérine J Gynecol Obstet Biol Reprod 2012 10.1016/j.jgyn.2012.09.033
63. P. Deruelle, J. Lepage, S. Depret, and E. Clouqueur Mode de déclenchement du travail et conduite du travail en cas d'utérus cicatriciel J Gynecol Obstet Biol Reprod 2012 10.1016/j.jgyn.2012.09.030
64. A.G. Cahill, M.J. Stout, D.M. Stamilio, A.O. Odibo, J.F. Peipert, and G.A. Macones Risk factors for bladder injury in patients with a prior hysterotomy Obstet Gynecol 112 2008 116 120
65. C. Deneux-Tharaux Utérus cicatriciel : aspects épidémiologiques J Gynecol Obstet Biol Reprod 2012 10.1016/j.jgyn.2012.09.022
66. H.E. Richter, C.G. Brumfield, S.P. Cliver, K.L. Burgio, C.L. Neely, and R.E. Varner Risk factors associated with anal sphincter tear: a comparison of primiparous patients, vaginal births after caesarean deliveries, and patients with previous vaginal delivery Am J Obstet Gynecol 187 2002 1194 1198
67. M.E. Hannah, H. Whyte, and W.J. Hannah Maternal outcomes at 2 years after planned caesarean section versus planned vaginal birth for breech presentation at term: the International Randomized Term Breech Trial Am J Obstet Gynecol 191 2004 917 927
68. E.C. Almeida, A.A. Nogueira, F.J. Candido dos Reis, and J.C. Rosa e Silva Caesarean section as a cause of chronic pelvic pain Int J Gynecol Obstet 79 2002 101 104
69. D.J. Murphy, G.M. Stirrat, J. Heron, and ALSPAC Study Team The relationship between caesarean section and subfertility in a population based sample of 14,541 pregnancies Hum Reprod 17 2002 1914 1917
70. A. Shorten, and B. Shorten The importance of mode of birth after previous caesarean: success, satisfaction and postnatal health J Midwifery Womens Health 57 2012 126 132
71. E.A.S. Clark, and R.M. Silver Long-term maternal morbidity associated with repeat caesarean delivery Am J Obstet Gynecol 205 2011 S2 S10
72. A.B. Caughey, T.D. Shipp, J.T. Repke, C. Zelop, A. Cohen, and E. Lieherman Trial of labor after caesarean delivery: the effect of previous vaginal delivery Am J Obstet Gynecol 179 1998 938 941
73. I. Hendler, and E. Bujold Effect of prior vaginal delivery or prior vaginal birth after caesarean delivery on obstetric outcomes in women undergoing trial of labor Obstet Gynecol 104 2004 273 277
74. B.M. Mercer, S. Gilbert, M.B. Landon, C.Y. Spong, K.J. Leveno, and D. Rouse Labor outcomes with increasing with number of prior vaginal births after caesarean delivery Obstet Gynecol 111 2008 285 291
75. O. Erez, L. Novack, V. Kleitman-Meir, D. Dukler, I. Rez-Weiss, and F. Gotsch Remote prognosis after primary caesarean delivery: the association of VBACs and recurrent caesarean deliveries with maternal morbidity Int J Women Health 4 2012 93 107
76. D.D. Mankuta, M.M. Leshno, M.M. Menasche, and M.M. Brezis Vaginal birth after caesarean section: trial of labor or repeat caesarean section? A decision analysis Am J Obstet Gynecol 189 2003 714 719
77. E. Paré, J.N. Quinones, and G.A. Macones Vaginal birth after caesarean section versus elective repeat caesarean section: assessment of maternal downstream health outcomes BJOG 113 2006 75 85
78. O. Sadan, M. Leshno, A. Gottreich, A. Golan, and S. Lurie Once a caesarean always a caesarean? A computer-assisted decision analysis Arch Gynecol Obstet 276 2007 517 521
79. W.A. Grobman, Y. Lai, M.B. Landon, C.Y. Spong, K.J. Leveno, and D.J. Rouse Can a prediction model for vaginal birth after caesarean also predict the probability of morbidity related to a trial of labor? Am J Obstet Gynecol 200 2009 56.e1 56.e6
80. S.L. Clark, J.R. Scott, T.F. Porter, D.A. Schlappy, V. McClellan, and D.A. Burton Is vaginal birth after caesarean less expensive than repeat caesarean delivery? Am J Obstet Gynecol 182 2000 599 602
81. S. Tahseen, and M. Griffiths Vaginal birth after two caesarean sections (VBAC-2)-a systematic review with meta-analysis of success rate and adverse outcomes of VBAC-2 versus VBAC-1 and repeat (third) caesarean sections BJOG 117 2010 5 19
82. A.G. Cahill, M. Tuuli, A.O. Odibo, D.M. Stamilio, and G.A. Macones Vaginal birth after caesarean for women with three or more prior caesareans: assessing safety and success BJOG 117 2010 422 428
83. Haute Autorité de santé Indications de la césarienne programmée à terme 2012 http://www.has-sante.fr/publications
84. D. Gallot, A. Delabaere, F. Desvignes, C. Vago, M. Accoceberry, and D. Lémery Quelles sont les recommandations d'organisation et d'information en cas de proposition de tentative de voie basse pour utérus cicatriciel ? J Gynecol Obstet Biol Reprod 2012 10.1016/j.jgyn.2012.09.031