Grains of truth or transparent blindfolds? A review of current debates in archaeological phytolith analysis

Vegetation History and Archaeobotany

Volumn 22, Issue 1, 2013, Pages 71-82

  Shillito, Lisa Marie ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF YORK   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Cereals; Maize; Microarchaeology; Morphometrics; Rice; Taphonomy

Indexed keywords

ZEA MAYS;

EID: 84870656752     PISSN: 09396314     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s00334-011-0341-z     Document Type: Review

References (118)

1. Ahn SM (2010) The emergence of rice agriculture in Korea: archaeobotanical perspectives. Archaeol Anthrop Sci 2: 89-98.
2. Albert RM, Weiner S (2001) Study of phytoliths in prehistoric ash layers using a quantitative approach. In: Meunier JD, Colin F, Faure Denard L (eds) Phytoliths: applications in earth science and human history. Aix en Provence, CEREGE, pp 251-266.
3. Albert RM, Weiner S, Bar-Yosef O, Meignen L (2000) Phytoliths in the Middle Palaeolithic deposits of Kebara cave, Mt Carmel, Israel: study of the plant materials used for fuel and other purposes. J Archaeol Sci 27: 931-947.
4. Albert RM, Shahack-Gross R, Cabanes D, Gilboa A, Lev-Yadun S, Portillo M, Sharon I, Boaretto E, Weiner S (2008) Phytolith-rich layers from the Late Bronze and Iron Ages at Tel Dor (Israel): mode of formation and archaeological significance. J Archaeol Sci 35: 57-75.
5. Albert RM, Bamford MK, Cabanes D (2009) Palaeoecological significance of palms at Olduvai Gorge, Tanzania, based on phytolith remains. Quat Int 193: 41-48.
6. Albert RM, Berna F, Goldberg P (2010) Insights on Neanderthal fire use at Kebara cave (Israel) through high resolution study of prehistoric combustion features: evidence from phytoliths and thin sections. Quat Int. doi: 10. 1016/j. quaint. 2010. 10. 016.
7. Ball TB, Gardner JS, Brotherson JD (1996) Identifying phytoliths produced by the inflorescence bracts of three species of wheat (Triticum monococcum L., T. dicoccon Schrank., and T. aestivum L.) using computer-assisted image and statistical analyses. J Archaeol Sci 23: 619-632.
8. Ball TB, Ehlers R, Standing MD (2009) Review of typologic and morphometric analysis of phytoliths produced by wheat and barley. Breed Sci 59: 505-512.
9. Bartoli F, Wilding LP (1980) Dissolution of biogenic opal as a function of its physical and chemical properties. Soil Sci Soc Am J 44: 873-878.
10. Boz B, Haddow S, Hager L, Pilloud M (2007) Human remains report Çatalhöyük. Arch Rep 2007: 180-198.
11. Bozarth SR, Guderjan TH (2004) Biosilicate analysis of residue in Maya dedicatory cache vessels from Blue Creek, Belize. J Archaeol Sci 31: 205-215.
12. Bullock P, Federoff N, Jongerius A, Stoops G, Tursina T (eds) (1985) Handbook for thin section description. WAINE Research Publications, Albrighton.
13. Cabanes D, Mallol C, Expósito I, Baena J (2010) Phytolith evidence for hearths and beds in the late Mousterian occupations of Esquilleu cave (Cantabria, Spain). J Archaeol Sci 37: 2, 947-2, 957.
14. Canti MG (1998) The micromorphological identification of faecal spherulites from archaeological and modern materials. J Archaeol Sci 25: 435-444.
15. Chen B, Jiang Q (1997) Antiquity of the earliest cultivated rice in central China and its implications. Econ Bot 51: 307-310.
16. Cid MS, Detling JK, Brizuela MA, Whicker AD (1989) Patterns in grass silicification: response to grazing history and defoliation. Oecologia 80: 268-271.
17. Cooke J, Leishman MR (2011) Is plant ecology more siliceous than we realise? Trends Plant Sci 16: 61-68.
18. Darwin C (1846) An account of the fine dust which often falls on vessels in the Atlantic Ocean. Quat J Geol Soc 2: 26-30.
19. Delhon C, Alexandre A, Berger J-F, Thiebault S, Brochier J-L, Meunier J-D (2003) Phytolith assemblages as a promising tool for reconstructing Mediterranean Holocene vegetation. Quat Res 59: 48-60.
20. Doolittle WE, Frederick CD (1991) Phytoliths as indicators of prehistoric maize (Zea mays subsp. mays, Poaceae) cultivation. Plant Syst Evol 177: 175-184.
21. Elbaum R, Weiner S, Albert RM, Elbaum M (2003) Detection of burning of plant materials in the archaeological record by changes in the refractive indices of siliceous phytoliths. J Archaeol Sci 30: 217-226.
22. Emery-Barbier A, Thiébault S (2005) Preliminary conclusions on the Late Glacial vegetation in south-west Anatolia (Turkey): the complementary nature of palynological and anthracological approaches. J Archaeol Sci 32: 1, 232-1, 251.
23. Erlich H, Demadis KD, Pokrovsky OS, Koutsoukos PG (2010) Modern views on desilicification: biosilica and abiotic silica dissolution in natural and artificial environments. Chem Rev 110: 4, 656-4, 689.
24. Fairbairn A, Asouti E, Near J, Martinoli D (2002) Macrobotanical evidence for plant use at Neolithic Çatalhöyük, south-central Turkey. Veget Hist Archaeobot 11: 41-54.
25. Fishkis O, Ingwersen J, Streck T (2009) Phytolith transport in sandy sediment: experiments and modelling. Geoderma 151: 168-178.
26. Fishkis O, Ingwersen J, Lamers M, Denysenko D, Streck T (2010a) Phytolith transport in soil: a field study using fluorescent labelling. Geoderma 157: 27-36.
27. Fishkis O, Ingwersen J, Lamers M, Denysenko D, Streck T (2010b) Phytolith transport in soil: a laboratory study on intact soil cores. Eur J Soil Sci 61: 445-455.
28. France I, Duller AWG, Duller GAT, Lamb HF (2000) A new approach to automated pollen analysis. Quat Sci Rev 19: 537-546.
29. French C, Sulas F, Madella M (2009) New geoarchaeological investigations of the valley systems in the Aksum area of northern Ethiopia. Catena 78: 218-233.
30. Fuller DQ, Harvey E, Qin L (2007) Presumed domestication? Evidence for wild rice cultivation and domestication in the fifth millennium BC of the Lower Yangtze region. Antiquity 81: 316-331.
31. Fuller DQ, Sato Y-I, Castillo C, Qin L, Weisskopf AR, Kingwell-Banham EJ, Song J, Ahn S-M, van Etten J (2010) Consilience of genetics and archaeobotany in the entangled history of rice. Archaeol Anthrop Sci 2: 115-131.
32. Gé T, Courty MA, Matthews W, Wattez J (1993) Sedimentary formation processes of occupation surfaces. In: Goldberg P, Nash DT, Petraglia MD (eds) Formation processes in archaeological context. (Monographs in world archaeology 18). Prehistory Press, Madison, pp 149-163.
33. Goldberg P, Miller CE, Schiegl S, Ligouis B, Berna F, Conard NJ, Wadley L (2009) Bedding, hearths, and site maintenance in the Middle Stone Age of Sibudu Cave, KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. Archaeol Anthrop Sci 1: 95-122.
34. Grave P, Kealhofer L (1999) Assessing bioturbation in archaeological sediments using soil morphology and phytolith analysis. J Archaeol Sci 26: 1, 239-1, 248.
35. Harvey EL, Fuller DQ (2005) Investigating crop processing using phytolith analysis: the example of rice and millets. J Archaeol Sci 32: 739-752.
36. Henry AG, Brook AS, Piperno DR (2011) Microfossils in calculus demonstrate consumption of plants and cooked foods in Neanderthal diets (Shanidar III, Iraq; Spy I and II, Belgium). Proc Natl Acad Sci 108: 486-491.
37. Hillman GC (1981) Reconstructing crop husbandry practices from charred remains of crops. In: Mercer R (ed) Farming practice in British prehistory. Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh, pp 123-162.
38. Iriarte J (2003) Assessing the feasibility of identifying maize through the analysis of cross-shaped size and three-dimensional morphology of phytoliths in the grasslands of southeastern South America. J Archaeol Sci 30: 1, 085-1, 094.
39. Ishida S, Parker AG, Kennet D, Hodson MJ (2002) Phytolith analysis from the archaeological site of Kush, Ras al-Khaimah, United Arab Emirates. Quat Res 59: 310-321.
40. Itzstein-Davey F, Taylor D, Dodson J, Atahan P, Zheng H (2007) Wild and domesticated forms of rice (Oryza sp.) in early agriculture at Qingpu, lower Yangtze, China: evidence from phytoliths. J Archaeol Sci 34: 2, 101-2, 108.
41. Jenkins E (2009) Phytolith taphonomy: a comparison of dry ashing and acid extraction on the breakdown of conjoined phytoliths formed in Triticum durum. J Archaeol Sci 36: 2, 402-2, 407.
42. Jenkins EL, Rosen AM (2007) The phytoliths. In: Finlayson B, Mithen S (eds) The early prehistory of Wadi Faynan, southern Jordan: archaeological survey of Wadis Faynan, Ghuwayr and al-Bustan and evaluation of the Pre-Pottery Neolithic A Settlement of WF16. Oxbow Books, Oxford, pp 429-436.
43. Jenkins E, Nuimat S, Jamjoum K, Baker A, Elliott S, Underwood F (2011) Phytoliths as indicators of past water availability and palaeoeconomic practices. In: 5th Experimental archaeology conference, January 8th-9th, University of Reading.
44. Karkanas P, Esfritou N (2009) Floor sequences in Neolithic Makri, Greece: micromorphology reveals cycles of renovation. Antiquity 83: 955-967.
45. Katz O, Gilead I, Bar (Kutiel) P, Shahack-Gross R (2007) Chalcolithic agricultural life at Grar, northern Negev, Israel: dry farmed cereals and dung-fueled fires. Paléorient 33: 101-116.
46. Kaufman PB, Dayanandan P, Franklin CI, Takeoka Y (1985) Structure and function of silica bodies in the epidermal system of grass shoots. Ann Bot 55: 487-507.
47. Kellogg EA, Bircher JA (1993) Linking phylogeny and genetics: Zea mays as a tool for phylogenetic studies. Syst Biol 42: 415-439.
48. Lee Y-J, Woo J-Y (eds) (2003) Prehistoric cultivation in Asia and Sorori rice. Chungbuk National University Museum, Korea.
49. Lentfer CJ, Boyd WE, Gojak D (1997) Hope Farm Windmill: phytolith analysis of cereals in early colonial Australia. J Archaeol Sci 24: 841-856.
50. Li P, Treloar WJ, Flenley JR, Empson L (2004) Towards automation of palynology 2: the use of texture measure and neural network analysis for automated identification of optical images of pollen grains. J Quat Sci 19: 755-762.
51. MacLeod N (2005) Shape models as a basis for morphological analysis in paleobiological systematics: dicotyledenous leaf physiography. Bull Am Paleontol 369: 219-238.
52. Madella M, Jones MK, Goldberg P, Goren Y, Hovers E (2002) The exploitation of plant resources by Neanderthals in Amud cave (Israel): the evidence from phytolith studies. J Archaeol Sci 29: 703-719.
53. Madella M, Alexandre A, Ball T (2005) International code for phytolith nomenclature 1. 0. Ann Bot 96: 253-260.
54. Madella M, Jones MK, Echlin P, Powers-Jones A, Moore M (2009) Plant water availability and analytical microscopy of phytoliths: implications for ancient irrigation in arid zones. Quat Int 193: 32-40.
55. Massey FP, Hartley SE (2006) Experimental demonstration of the antiherbivore effects of silica in grasses: impacts on foliage digestibility and vole growth rates. Proc R Soc B 273: 2, 299-2, 304.
56. Massey FP, Ennos AR, Hartley SE (2007) Herbivore specific induction of silica-based plant defences. Oecologia 152: 677-683.
57. Matthews W (2005) Micromorphological and microstratigraphic traces of uses and concepts of space. In: Hodder I (ed) Inhabiting Çatalhöyük: reports from the 1995-1999 seasons. McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research, Cambridge/BIAA, pp 355-399.
58. Matthews W (2010) Geoarchaeology and taphonomy of plant remains and micromorphological residues in early urban environments in the ancient near east. Quat Int 214: 98-113.
59. Matthews W, French CAI (2005) Domestic space at Saar: the microstratigraphic evidence. In: Killick R, Moon J (eds) The early Dilmun settlement at Saar. London-Bahrain Archaeological Expedition. (Saar Excavation Report 3) Archaeology International Ltd, Ludlow, pp 325-337.
60. Matthews W, Postgate JN, with Payne S, Charles MP and Dobney K (1994) The imprint of living in an early Mesopotamian city: questions and answers. In: Luff R, Rowley-Conwy P (eds) Whither environmental archaeology? (Oxbow Monograph 36), Oxbow Books, Oxford, pp 171-212.
61. Matthews W, French CIA, Lawrence T, Cutler DF, Jones MK (1997) Microstratigraphic traces of site formation processes and human activities. World Archaeol 29: 281-308.
62. Matthews R, Mohammadifar Y, Matthews W, Motarjem A (2010) Investigating the Early Neolithic of western Iran: the Central Zagros Archaeological Project (CZAP). Antiquity 84: 323 project gallery. http://www. antiquity. ac. uk/projgall/matthews323/.
63. McNaughton SJ, Tarrants JL, McNaughton MM, Davis RD (1985) Silica as a defence against herbivory and a growth promoter in African grasses. Ecology 66: 528-535.
64. Mithen S, Jenkins E, Jamjoum K, Nuimat S, Nortcliff S, Finlayson BL (2008) Experimental crop growing in Jordan to develop a methodology for the identification of ancient crop irrigation. World Archaeol 40: 7-25.
65. Nesbitt M (1993) Archaeobotanical evidence for early Dilmun diet at Saar, Bahrain. Arab Archaeol Epigr 4: 20-47.
66. Ollendorf AL (1987) Archaeological Implications of a phytolith study at Tel Miqne (Ekron), Israel. J Field Archaeol 14: 453-463.
67. Osterrieth M, Madella M, Zurro D, Alvarez MF (2009) Taphonomical aspects of silica phytoliths in the loess sediments of the Argentinean Pampas. Quat Int 193: 70-79.
68. Parker AS, Lohse CM, Leibovich BC, Cheville JC, Sheinin YM, Kwon ED (2008) Comparison of digital image analysis versus visual assessment to assess surviving expression as an independent predictor of survival for patients with clear cell renal cell carcinoma. Human Pathol 39: 1, 176-1, 184.
69. Parr JF (2006) Effect of fire on phytolith coloration. Geoarchaeology 21(2): 171-185.
70. Pearsall DM (1978) Phytolith analysis of archaeological soils: evidence for maize cultivation in formative Ecuador. Science 199: 177-178.
71. Pearsall DM, Piperno DR, Dinan EH, Umlauf M, Zhao Z, Bentfer RA Jr (1995) Distinguishing rice (Oryza sativa poaceae) from wild Oryza species through phytolith analysis: results of preliminary research. Econ Bot 49: 183-196.
72. Pearsall DM, Chandler-Ezell K, Chandler-Ezell A (2003) Identifying maize in neotropical sediments and soils using cob phytoliths. J Archaeol Sci 30: 611-627.
73. Pearsall DM, Chandler-Ezell K, Zeidler JA (2004) Maize in ancient Ecuador: results of residue analysis of stone tools from the Real Alto site. J Archaeol Sci 31: 423-442.
74. Piperno DR (1984) A comparison and differentiation of phytoliths from maize and wild grasses: use of morphological criteria. Am Antiq 49: 361-383.
75. Piperno DR (1985) Phytolith taphonomy and distributions in archaeological sediments from Panama. J Archaeol Sci 12: 247-269.
76. Piperno DR (1988) Phytolith analysis: an archaeological and geological perspective. Academic Press, New York.
77. Piperno DR (1991) The status of phytolith analysis in the American tropics. J World Prehist 5: 155-191.
78. Piperno DR (1998) Paleoethnobotany in the Neotropics from microfossils: new insights into ancient plant use and agricultural origins in the tropical forest. J World Prehist 12: 394-449.
79. Piperno DR (2003) A few kernels short of a cob: on the Staller and Thompson late entry scenario for the introduction of maize into northern South America. J Archaeol Sci 30: 83-826.
80. Piperno DR (2006) Phytoliths: a comprehensive guide for archaeologists and paleoecologists. AltaMira Press, Lanham.
81. Piperno DR (2009) Identifying crop plants with phytoliths (and starch grains) in Central and South America: a review and an update of the evidence. Quat Int 193: 146-159.
82. Piperno DR, Ranere AJ, Holst I, Iriarte I, Dickau R (2009) Starch grain and phytolith evidence for early ninth millennium b. p. maize from the Central Balsas River Valley, Mexico. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 106: 5, 019-5, 024.
83. Portillo M, Albert RM, Henry DO (2009) Domestic activities and spatial distribution in Ain Abu Nukhayla (Wadi Rum, Southern Jordan): the use of phytoliths and spherulites studies. Quat Int 193: 174-183.
84. Reynolds OL, Keeping MG, Meyer JH (2009) Silicon-augmented resistance of plants to herbivorous insects: a review. Ann Appl Biol 155: 171-186.
85. Roberts N, Rosen A (2009) Diversity and complexity in early farming communities of Southwest Asia: new insights into the economic and environmental basis of Neolithic Çatalhöyük. Current Anthrop 50: 393-402.
86. Rosen AM (1992) Preliminary identification of silica skeletons from Near Eastern archaeological sites: an anatomical approach. In: Rapp GJ, Mulholland SC (eds) Phytolith systematics: emerging issues. Plenum Press, New York/London, pp 129-147.
87. Rosen AM (2005) Phytolith indicators of plant and land use at Çatalhöyük. In: Hodder I (ed) Inhabiting Çatalhöyük: reports from the 1995-1999 seasons. McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research/BIAA, Cambridge.
88. Rosen AM, Weiner S (1994) Identifying ancient irrigation: a new method using opaline phytoliths from emmer wheat. J Archaeol Sci 21: 125-132.
89. Rovner I (1971) Potential of opal phytoliths for use in paleoecological reconstruction. Quat Res 1: 343-359.
90. Rovner I (2004) On transparent blindfolds. Comments on identifying maize in Neotropical sediments and soils using cob phytoliths. J Archaeol Sci 31: 815-819.
91. Russ JC, Rovner I (1989) Stereological identification of opal phytolith populations from wild and cultivated Zea maize. Am Antiq 54: 784-792.
92. Ryan P (2011) Plants as material culture in the Near Eastern Neolithic: perspectives from the silica skeleton artifactual remains at Çatalhöyük. J Anthropol Archaeol 30: 292-305.
93. Sanson GD, Kerr SA, Gross KA (2007) Do silica phytoliths really wear mammalian teeth? J Archaeol Sci 34: 526-531.
94. Shahack-Gross R, Finkelstein I (2008) Subsistence practices in an arid environment: a geoarchaeological investigation in an Iron Age site, the Negev Highlands, Israel. J Archaeol Sci 35: 965-982.
95. Shahack-Gross R, Albert RM, Gilboa A, Nagar-Hilman O, Sharon I, Weiner S (2005) Geoarchaeology in an urban context: the uses of space in a Phoenician monumental building at Tel Dor (Israel). J Archaeol Sci 32: 1, 417-1, 431.
96. Shillito L-M (2011a) Taphonomic observations of archaeological wheat phytoliths from Neolithic Çatalhöyük, Turkey, and the use of conjoined phytolith size as an indicator of water availability. Archaeometry 53: 631-641.
97. Shillito L-M (2011b) Simultaneous thin section and phytolith observations of finely stratified deposits from Neolithic Çatalhöyük, Turkey: implications for paleoeconomy and Early Holocene paleoenvironment. J Quat Sci 26: 576-588.
98. Shillito L-M, Matthews W, Almond MJ (2008) Investigating midden formation processes and cultural activities at Neolithic Çatalhöyük, Turkey. Antiquity 82: 317 project gallery. http://antiquity. ac. uk/projgall/shillito/index. html.
99. Shillito L-M, Matthews W, Bull ID, Almond MJ (2011) The microstratigraphy of middens: capturing daily routine in rubbish at Neolithic Çatalhöyük. Turk Antiquity 85(329): 1024-1038.
100. Staller JE (2003) An examination of the palaeobotanical and chronological evidence for an early introduction of maize (Zea mays L.) into South America: a response to Pearsall. J Archaeol Sci 30: 373-380.
101. Staller JE, Thompson RJ (2002) A multidisciplinary approach to understanding the initial introduction of maize into coastal Ecuador. J Archaeol Sci 29: 33-50.
102. Stillman EC, Flenley JR (1996) The needs and prospects for automation in palynology. Quat Sci Rev 15: 1-5.
103. Strömberg CAE (2009) Methodological concerns for analysis of phytolith assemblages: Does count size matter? Quat Int 193: 124-140.
104. Tsartsidou G, Lev-Yadun S, Albert RM, Rosen A, Efstratiou N, Weiner S (2007) The phytolith archaeological record: strengths and weaknesses evaluated based on a quantitative modern reference collection from Greece. J Archaeol Sci 34: 1, 262-1, 275.
105. Tubb HJ, Hodson MJ, Hodson JC (1993) The inflorescence papillae of the Triticeae: a new tool for archaeological and taxonomic research. Ann Bot 73: 537-545.
106. Twiss PC (1992) Predicted world distribution of C3 and C4 grass phytoliths. In: Mulholland SC, Rapp GJ (eds) Phytolith systematics-emerging issues. Plenum, New York, pp 113-129.
107. Valamoti SM (2006) Detecting seasonal movement from animal dung: an investigation in Neolithic northern Greece. Antiquity 81: 1, 053-1, 064.
108. van der Veen M (2007) Formation processes of desiccated and carbonized plant remains-the identification of routine practice. J Archaeol Sci 34: 968-990.
109. Wallis LA (2001) Environmental history of northwest Australia based on phytolith analysis at Carpenter's Gap 1. Quat Int 83-85: 103-117.
110. Weiner S (2010) Microarchaeology: beyond the visible archaeological record. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
111. Wilson J, Hardy K, Allen R, Copeland L, Wrangham R, Collins M (2010) Automated classification of starch granules using supervised pattern recognition of morphological properties. J Archaeol Sci 37: 594-604.
112. Winter-Livneh R, Svoray T, Gilead I (2010) Settlement patterns, social complexity and agricultural strategies during the Chalcolithic period in the northern Negev, Israel. J Archaeol Sci 37: 284-294.
113. Zhang Y, Fountain DW, Hodgson RM, Flenley JR, Gunetileke S (2004) Towards automation of palynology 3: pollen pattern recognition using Gabor transforms and digital moments. J Quat Sci 19: 736-768.
114. Zhao Z (2010) New data and new issues for the study of origin of rice agriculture in China. Archaeol Anthropol Sci 2: 99-105.
115. Zhao Z, Pearsall DM, Bentfer RA Jr, Piperno DM (1998) Distinguishing rice (Oryza sativa, Poaceae) from Oryza species through phytolith analysis, II finalised method. Econ Bot 52: 134-145.
116. Zheng Y, Dong Y, Matsui A, Udatsu T, Fujiwara H (2003) Molecular genetic basis of determining subspecies of ancient rice using the shape of phytoliths. J Archaeol Sci 30: 1, 215-1, 221.
117. Zucol AF, Brea M, Scopel A (2005) First record of fossil wood and phytolith assemblages of the Late Pleistocene in el Palmar National Park (Argentina). J S Am Earth Sci 20: 33-43.
118. Zurro D, Madella M, Briz I, Vila A (2009) Variability of the phytolith record in fisher-hunter-gatherer sites: an example from the Yamana society (Beagle Channel, Tierra del Fuego, Argentina). Quat Int 193: 184-191.