Comparative histological results of different biomaterials used in sinus augmentation procedures: A human study at 6 months

Clinical Oral Implants Research

Volumn 23, Issue 12, 2012, Pages 1369-1376

  Iezzi, Giovanna ^a   Degidi, Marco ^b   Piattelli, Adriano ^a   Mangano, Carlo ^b   Scarano, Antonio ^a   Shibli, Jamil A ^c   Perrotti, Vittoria ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CHIETI   (Italy)

^b Guarulhos University ^*

^c GUARULHOS UNIVERSITY   (Brazil)

Author keywords

Anorganic bovine bone; Biphasic calcium phosphate; Calcium carbonate; Phycogene hydroxyapatite; Porcine bone; Sinus augmentation procedures

Indexed keywords

BIOMATERIAL; CALCIUM CARBONATE; CALCIUM PHOSPHATE; HYDROXYAPATITE; TITANIUM;

AGED; ANIMAL; ARTICLE; BONE PROSTHESIS; BONE REGENERATION; BONE TRANSPLANTATION; CATTLE; COMPARATIVE STUDY; FEMALE; HUMAN; MALE; METHODOLOGY; MIDDLE AGED; SINUS FLOOR AUGMENTATION; SWINE; TOOTH IMPLANT; TOOTH IMPLANTATION; TREATMENT OUTCOME; WOUND HEALING;

AGED; ANIMALS; BIOCOMPATIBLE MATERIALS; BONE REGENERATION; BONE SUBSTITUTES; BONE TRANSPLANTATION; CALCIUM CARBONATE; CALCIUM PHOSPHATES; CATTLE; DENTAL IMPLANTATION, ENDOSSEOUS; DENTAL IMPLANTS; DURAPATITE; FEMALE; HUMANS; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; SINUS FLOOR AUGMENTATION; SWINE; TITANIUM; TREATMENT OUTCOME; WOUND HEALING;

EID: 84870239425     PISSN: 09057161     EISSN: 16000501     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1600-0501.2011.02308.x     Document Type: Article

References (65)

1. Artzi, Z., Nemcovsky, C.E. & Dayan, D. (2002) Bovine-HA spongiosa blocks and immediate implant placement in sinus augmentation procedures. Histopathological and histomorphometric observations on different histological stainings in 10 consecutive patients. Clinical Oral Implants Research 13: 420-427.
2. Artzi, Z., Weinreb, M., Carmeli, G., Lev-Dor, R., Dard, M. & Nemcovsky, C.E. (2008) Histomorphometric assessment of bone formation in sinus augmentation utilizing a combination of autogenous and hydroxyapatite/biphasic tricalcium phosphate graft materials: at 6 and 9 months in humans. Clinical Oral Implants Research 19: 686-692.
3. Barone, A., Crespi, R., Aldini, N.N., Fini, M., Giardino, R. & Covani, U. (2005) Maxillary sinus augmentation: histologic and histomorphometric analysis. International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 20: 519-525.
4. Barone, A., Orlando, B., Tonelli, P. & Covani, U. (2011) Survival rate for implants placed in the posterior maxilla with and without sinus augmentation: a comparative cohort study. Journal of Periodontology 82: 219-226.
5. Barone, A., Ricci, M., Covani, U., Nannmark, U., Azarmehr, I. & Calvo-Guirado, J.L. (2010) Maxillary sinus augmentation using prehydrated cortico-cancellous porcine bone: histomorphometric evaluation after 6 months. Clinical Implant Dentistry & Related Research doi: 10.1111/j.1708-8208.2010.00274.x.
6. Barone, A., Santini, S., Marcaccini, S., Giacomelli, L., Gherone, E. & Covani, U. (2008) Osteotomy and membrane elevation during the maxillary sinus augmentation procedure. A comparative study: piezoelectric device vs. conventional rotative instruments. Clinical Oral Implants Research 19: 511-515.
7. Barone, A., Santini, S., Sbordone, L., Crespi, R. & Covani, U. (2006) A clinical study of the outcomes and complications associated with maxillary sinus augmentation. International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 21: 81-85.
8. Browaeys, H., Bouvry, P. & De Bruyn, H. (2007) A literature review on biomaterials in sinus augmentation procedures. Clinical Implant Dentistry & Related Research 9: 166-177.
9. Calvo-Guirado, J.L., Ramirez Fernandez, M.P., Negri, B., Delgado Riuz, R.A., Sanchez De-Val, J.E.M. & Gomez-Moreno, G. (2011) Experimental model of bone response to collagenized xenografts of porcine origin (Osteobiol® MP3): a radiological and histomorphometric study. Clinical Implant Dentistry & Related Research doi: 10.1111/j.1708-8208.2011.00337.
10. Campion, C.R., Chander, C., Buckland, T. & Hing, K. (2011) Increasing strut porosity in silicate-substituted calcium-phosphate bone graft substitutes enhances osteogenesis. Journal of biomedical materials research. Part B, Applied biomaterials 97: 245-254.
11. Cordaro, L., Bosshardt, D.D., Palattella, P., Rao, W., Serino, G. & Chiapasco, M. (2008) Maxillary sinus grafting with Bio-Oss or Straumann® BoneCeramic: histomorphometric results from a randomized controlled multicenter clinical trial. Clinical Oral Implants Research 19: 796-803.
12. Covani, U., Orlando, B., Giacomelli, L., Cornelini, R. & Barone, A. (2011) Implant survival after sinus elevation with Straumann® BoneCeramic in clinical practice: ad-interim results of a prospective study at a 15-month follow-up. Clinical Oral Implants Research 22: 481-484.
13. Daculsi, G., Laboux, O., Malard, O. & Weiss, P.B. (2003) Current state of the art of biphasic calcium phosphate bioceramics. Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine 14: 195-200.
14. Demers, C., Hamdy, C.R., Corsi, K., Chellat, F., Tabriziam, M. & Yahia, L. (2002) Natural coral exoskeleton as a bone graft substitute: a review. Bio-medical Materials and Engineering 12: 15-35.
15. Ewers, R. (2005) Maxilla sinus grafting with marine algae derived bone forming material: a clinical report of long-term results. Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery 63: 1712-1723.
16. Ewers, R., Goriwoda, W., Schopper, C., Moser, D. & Spassova, E. (2004) Histologic findings at augmented bone areas supplied with two different bone substitute materials combined with sinus floor lifting. Report of one case. Clinical Oral Implants Research 15: 96-100.
17. Frenken, J.W.F.H., Bowmann, W.F., Braven-Boer, N., Zijderveld, S.A., Sculten, E.A.J.M. & Ten Bruggenkate, C.M. (2010) The use of Straumann® BoneCeramic in a maxillary sinus floor elevation procedure: a clinical, radiological, histological and histomorphometric evaluation with a 6 month healing period. Clinical Oral Implants Research 21: 201-208.
18. Friedmann, A., Dard, M., Kleber, B.-M., Bernimoulin, J.-P. & Bosshardt, D.D. (2009) Ridge augmentation and maxillary sinus grafting with a biphasic calcium phosphate: histologic and histomorphometric observations. Clinical Oral Implants Research 20: 708-714.
19. Froum, S.J., Wallace, S.S., Cho, S.C., Elian, N. & Tarnow, D.P. (2008) Histomorphometric comparison of a biphasic bone ceramic to anorganic bovine bone for sinus augmentation: 6-to-8-month postsurgical assessment of vital bone formation. A pilot study. International Journal of Periodontics and Restorative Dentistry 28: 273-281.
20. Galindo-Moreno, P., Avila, G., Fernandez-Barbero, J.E., Mesa, F., O'Valle-Ravassa, F. & Wang, H.L. (2008) Clinical and histologic comparison of two different composite grafts for sinus augmentation: a pilot study. Clinical Oral Implants Research 19: 755-759.
21. Galindo-Moreno, P., Moreno-Riestra, I., Avila, G., Padial-Molina, M., Paya, J.A., Wang, H.L. & O'Valle, F. (2011) Effect of anorganic bovine bone to autogenous cortical bone ratio upon bone remodeling patterns following maxillary sinus augmentation. Clinical Oral Implants Research 22: 857-864.
22. Hallman, M., Lederlund, A., Linsskog, S., Lundgren, S. & Sennerby, L. (2001) A clinical histologic study of bovine hydroxyapatite in combination with autogenous bone and fibrin glue for maxillary sinus floor augmentation. Results after 8 months of healing. Clinical Oral Implants Research 12: 135-143.
23. Hallman, M., Sennerby, L. & Lundgren, S. (2002) A clinical and histologic evaluation of implant integration in the posterior maxilla after sinus floor augmentation with autogenous bone, bovine hydroxyapatite, or 20:80 mixture. International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 17: 635-643.
24. Hammerle, C.H.F., Chiantella, G.C., Karring, T. & Lang, N.P. (1998) The effect of a deproteinized bovine bone mineral on bone regeneration around titanium dental implants. Clinical Oral Implants Research 9: 151-162.
25. Hurzeler, M.B., Quinones, C.R., Kirsch, A., Gloker, C., Schupbach, P., Strub, J.R. & Caffesse, R.G. (1997) Maxillary sinus augmentation using different grafting materials and dental implants in monkeys. Part I. Evaluation of anorganic bovine-derived bone matrix. Clinical Oral Implants Research 8: 476-486.
26. John, H.D. & Wenz, B. (2004) Histomorphometric analysis of natural bone mineral for maxillary sinus augmentation. International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 19: 199-2007.
27. Karabuda, C., Ozdemir, O., Tosun, T., Anil, A. & Olgac, V. (2001) Histological and clinical evaluation of 3 different grafting materials for sinus lifting procedure based on 8 cases. Journal of Periodontology 72: 1436-1442.
28. Kim, Y.K., Yun, P.Y., Kim, S.G. & Lim, S.C. (2009) Analysis of the healing process in sinus bone grafting using various grafting materials. Oral Surgery Oral Medicine Oral Pathology Endodontics Oral Radiology 107: 204-211.
29. Klongnoi, B., Rupprecht, S., Kessler, P., Zimmermann, R., Thorwarth, M., Pongsiri, S., Neukam, F.W., Wiltfang, J. & Schlegel, K.A. (2006) Lack of beneficial effects of platelet-rich plasma on sinus augmentation using a fluorohydroxyapatite or autogenous bone: an explorative study. Journal of Clinical Periodontology 33: 500-509.
30. Kuhl, S., Gotz, H., Hansen, T., Kreisler, M., Behneke, A., Heil, U., Duscher, H. & d'Hoedt, B. (2010) Three-dimensional analysis of bone formation after maxillary sinus augmentation by means of microcomputed tomography: a pilot study. International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 25: 930-938.
31. Lambert, F., Léonard, A., Drion, P., Source, S., Layrolle, P. & Rompen, E. (2011) Influence of space-filling materials in subantral bone augmentation: blood clot vs autogenous bone chips vs bovine hydroxyapatite. Clinical Oral Implants Research 22: 538-545.
32. Landi, L., Pretel, R.W., Hakimi, N.M. & Setayesh, R. (2000) Maxillary sinus floor elevation using a combination of DFDBA and bovine-derived porous hydroxyapatite: a preliminary histologic and histomorphometric report. International Journal of Periodontics and Restorative Dentistry 20: 575-583.
33. Lee, J.H., Jung, U.W., Kim, C.S. & Cho, K.S. (2008) Histologic and clinical evaluation for maxillary sinus augmentation using macroporous biphasic calcium phosphate in human. Clinical Oral Implants Research 19: 767-771.
34. Lee, Y.M., Shin, S.Y., Kim, J.Y., Kye, S.B., Ku, Y. & Rhyv, I.C. (2006) Bone reaction to bovine hydroxyapatite for maxillary sinus floor augmentation: histologic results in humans. International Journal of Periodontics and Restorative Dentistry 26: 471-481.
35. Lindgren, C., Sennerby, L., Mordenfeld, A. & Hallman, M. (2009) Clinical histology of microimplants placed in two different biomaterials. International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 24: 1093-1100.
36. Mangano, C., Paino, F., D'Aquino, R., De Rosa, A., Iezzi, G., Piattelli, A., Laini, L., Mitsiadis, T., Desiderio, V., Mangano, F., Papaccio, G. & Tirino, V. (2011) Human dental pulp stem cells hook into biocoral scaffold forming an engineered biocomplex. PLoS ONE 6: e18721.
37. Mangano, C., Scarano, A., Perrotti, V., Iezzi, G. & Piattelli, A. (2007) Maxillary sinus augmentation with a porous synthetic hydroxyapatite and bovine derived hydroxyapatite: a comparative clinical and histologic study. International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 22: 980-986.
38. Mazor, Z., Horowitz, R.A., Del Corso, M., Prasad, HS., Rohrer, M.D., Dohan Ehrenfest, D.M. (2009) Sinus floor augmentation with simultaneous implant placement using Choukroun's platelet-rich fibrin as the sole grafting material: a radiologic and histologic study at 6 months. Journal of Periodontology 80: 2056-2064.
39. Nannmark, U. & Sennerby, L. (2008) The bone tissue response to prehydrated and collagenated cortico-cancellous porcine bone grafts: a study in rabbit maxillary defects. Clinical Implant Dentistry & Related Research 10: 264-270.
40. Orsini, G., Scarano, A., Piattelli, M., Piccirilli, M., Caputi, S. & Piattelli, A. (2006) Histologic and ultrastructural analysis of regenerated bone in maxillary sinu augmentation using a porcine bone-derived biomaterial. Journal of Periodontology 77: 1984-1990.
41. Pagliani, L., Andersson, P., Lanza, M., Nappo, A., Verrocchi, D., Volpe, S. & Sennerby, L.A. (2010) collagenated porcine bone substitute for augmentation at Neoss implant sites: a prospective 1-year multicenter case series study with histology. Clinical Implant Dentistry & Related Research doi: 10.1111/j.1708-8208.2010.00314.x.
42. Piattelli, M., Bavero, G.F., Scarano, A., Orsini, G. & Piattelli, A. (1999) Bone reactions to anorganic bovine bone (Bio-Oss) used in sinus lifting procedure: a histologic long-term report of 20 cases in man. International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 14: 835-840.
43. Piattelli, A., Scarano, A. & Mangano, C. (1996) Clinical and histologic aspects of biphasic calcium phosphate ceramic (BCP) used in connection with implant placement. Biomaterials 17: 1767-1770.
44. Piattelli, A., Scarano, A. & Quaranta, M. (1997) High-precision, cost-effective cutting system for producing thin sections of oral tissues containing dental implants. Biomaterials 18: 577-579.
45. Pidkonen, L., Gurbuzer, B., Kucukodaci, Z., Urhan, M., Baris, M. & Tezulas, R. (2011) Scintigraphic, histologic and histomorphometric analyses of bovine bone mineral and autogenous bone mixture in sinus floor augmentation: a randomized controlled trial - Results after 4 months of healing. Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery 69: 160-169.
46. Polyzois, I., Renvert, S., Bosshardt, D.D., Lang, N.P. & Claffey, N. (2007) Effect of Bio-Oss® on osseointegration of dental implants surrounded by circumferential bone defects of different dimensions: an experimental study in the dog. Clinical Oral Implants Research 18: 304-310.
47. Proussaefs, P., Lozada, J., Kleiman, A., Rohrer, M.D. & McMillan, D.J. (2003) The use of titanium mesh in conjuction with autogenous bone graft and inorganic bovine bone mineral (Bio-Oss) for localized alveolar ridge augmentation: a human study. International Journal of Periodontics and Restorative Dentistry 23: 185-195.
48. Ramirez Fernandez, M.P., Calvo-Guirado, J.L., Arcesio-Delgado Ruiz, R., Maté Sanchez De-Val, J.E., Ortega, V.V. & Olmes, L.M. (2011) Bone response to hydroxyapatite with open porosity of animal origin (porcine(Osteobiol® MP3) and bovine (Endobon®)): a radiological and histomorphometric study. Clinical Oral Implants Research 22: 767-773.
49. Ripamonti, U. (1991) The morphogenesis of bone in replicas of porous hydroxyapatite obtained from conversion of calcium carbonate exoskeletons of coral. The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery 73A: 692-703.
50. Ripamonti, U., Richter, P.W., Nilen, R.W.N. & Renton, L. (2008) The induction of bone formation by smart biphasic hydroxyapatite tricalcium phosphate biomimetic matrices in the non-human primate Papio Ursinus. Journal of Cellular and Molecular Medicine 12: 1-15.
51. Sartori, S., Silvestri, M., Forni, F., Icaro Cornaglia, A., Tepei, P. & Cattaneo, V. (2003) Ten-year follow-up in a maxillary sinus augmentation using anorganic bovine bone (Bio-Oss). A case report with histomorphometric evaluation. Clinical Oral Implants Research 14: 369-372.
52. Scarano, A., Degidi, M., Iezzi, G., Pecora, G., Piattelli, A., Orsini, G., Caputi, S., Perrotti, V., Mangano, C. & Piattelli, A. (2006) Maxillary sinus augmentation with different biomaterials. A comparative histologic and histomorphometric study in man. Implant Dentistry 15: 197-207.
53. Schopper, C., Moser, D., Sabbas, A., Lagogiannis, G., Spassova, E., Konig, F., Donath, K. & Ewers, R. (2003) The Fluorohydroxyapatite (FHA) FRIOS® ALGIPORE® is a suitable material for the reconstruction of severely atrophic human maxillae. Clinical Oral Implants Research 14: 743-749.
54. Simunek, A., Cierny, M., Kopecka, D., Kohout, A., Bukac, J. & Vahalova, D. (2005) The sinus lift with phycogenic bone substitute. A histomorphometric study. Clinical Oral Implants Research 16: 342-348.
55. Soardi, C.M., Spinato, S., Zaffe, D. & Wang, H.L. (2011) Atrophic maxillary floor augmentation by mineralized human bone allografts in sinuses of different size: an histologic and histomorphometric analysis. Clinical Oral Implants Research 22: 560-566.
56. Stavropoulos, A., Kostopoulos, L., Nyengaard, J.R. & Karring, T. (2003) Deproteinized bovine bone (Bio-Oss®) and bioactive glass (Biogran®) arrest bone formation when used as an adjunct to guided tissue regeneration (GTR). Journal of Clinical Periodontology 30: 636.
57. Tadjoedin, E.S., de Lange, G.L., Bronckers, A.L.J.J., Lyaruu, D.M. & Burger, E.H. (2003) Deproteinized cancellous bovine bone (Bio-Oss®) as bone substitute for sinus floor elevation. A retrospective, histomorphometrical study of five cases. Journal of Clinical Periodontology 30: 261-270.
58. Traini, T., Degidi, M., Sammons, R., Stanley, P. & Piattelli, A. (2008) Histological and elemental microanalytical study of anorganic bovine bone substitution following sinus floor augmentation in humans. Journal of Periodontology 79: 1232-1240.
59. Traini, T., Valentini, P., Iezzi, G. & Piattelli, A. (2007) Histological and histomorphometrical evaluation of anorganic bovine bone retrieved 9 years after a sinus augmentation procedure. Journal of Periodontology 78: 955-961.
60. Valentini, P., Abensur, D., Densari, D., Graziani, J.N. & Hammerle, C.H.F. (1998) Histological evaluations of Bio-Oss® in a 2-stage sinus floor elevation and implantation procedure. A human case report. Clinical Oral Implants Research 9: 59-64.
61. Valentini, P., Abensur, D., Wenz, B., Peetz, M. & Schenk, R. (2000) Sinus grafting with porous bone mineral (Bio-Oss®) for implant placement: a 5 year study on 15 patients. International Journal of Periodontics and Restorative Dentistry 20: 245-253.
62. Wallace, S.S. & Froum, S.J. (2003) Effect of maxillary sinus augmentation on the survival of endosseous dental implants. A systematic review. Annals of Periodontology 8: 328-343.
63. Wikesjo, U.M., Lim, W.H., Razi, S.S., Sigurdsson, T.J., Tatakis, D.N. & Hardwick, W.R. (2003) Periodontal repair in dogs: a bioabsorbable calcium carbonate coral implant enhances space provision for alveolar bone regeneration in conjunction with guided tissue regeneration. Journal of Periodontology 74: 957-964.
64. Yamanichi, N., Itose, T., Neiva, R. & Wang, H.L. (2008) Long-term evaluation of implant survival in augmented sinuses: a case series. International Journal of Periodontics and Restorative Dentistry 28: 163-169.
65. Yildirim, M., Spiekermann, H., Biesterfeld, S. & Edelhoff, D. (2000) Maxillary sinus augmentation using xenogenic bone substitute material Bio-Oss in combination with venous blood. A histologic and histomorphometric study in humans. Clinical Oral Implants Research 11: 217-229.