Giving in early modern history: Philanthropy in Amsterdam in the Golden Age

Continuity and Change

Volumn 27, Issue 2, 2012, Pages 301-343

  Van Leeuwen, Marco H D ^a  

^a UTRECHT UNIVERSITY   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ALTRUISM; EIGHTEENTH CENTURY; SEVENTEENTH CENTURY; SOCIAL HISTORY;

AMSTERDAM [NORTH HOLLAND]; NETHERLANDS; NORTH HOLLAND;

EID: 84869161159     PISSN: 02684160     EISSN: 1469218X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1017/S0268416012000148     Document Type: Article

References (128)

1. S. Hindle, On the parish? The micro-politics of poor relief in rural England c. 1550-1750 (Oxford, 2004)
2. and S. King, Poverty and welfare in England 1700-1850. A regional perspective (Manchester, 2000).
3. See, for instance, A. E. Komter, Social solidarity and the gift (Cambridge, 2005)
4. Th. N. M. Schuyt B. Gouwenberg and R. H. F. P. Bekkers Geven in Nederland 2009 (The Hague 2009)
5. R. H. F. P. Bekkers, Giving and volunteering in the Netherlands (Utrecht, 2004)
6. P.Wiepking, For the love of mankind: a sociological study on charitable giving (Amsterdam, 2008)
7. R. Bekkers and P. Wiepking, 'A literature review of empirical studies of philanthropy: eight mechanisms that drive charitable giving', Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 40, 5 (2011), 924-73
8. M. H. D. van Leeuwen and P. Wiepking, 'National campaigns for charitable causes', Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly (forthcoming)
9. P. Wiepking and I. Maas, 'Resources that make you generous: effects of social and human resources on charitable giving', Social Forces 87 (2009), 1973-95
10. P. Wiepking and M. H. D. van Leeuwen, 'Picturing generosity: factors of success and failure of national campaigns in the Netherlands', Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly (forthcoming).
11. L. Heerma van Voss and M. H. D. van Leeuwen, 'Charity in the Dutch Republic: an introduction'. 3 O. Hufton, The poor of eighteenth-century France, 1750-1789 (Oxford, 1974), 173-4 (italics added)
12. P. Lindert, 'Poor relief before the welfare state: Britain versus the continent, 1780-1880', European Review of Economic History 2, 2 (1998), 101-40, figure 1.
13. M. H. D. van Leeuwen, 'Surviving with a little help: the importance of charity to the poor of Amsterdam 1800-50, in a comparative perspective', Social History 18, 3 (1993), 319-38.
14. C. Fairchild, Poverty and charity in Aix-en-Provence, 1649-1789 (London, 1976)
15. C. Jones, Charity and bienfaisance: the treatment of the poor in the Montpellier region 1740-1815 (Cambridge, 1982)
16. J. L. Marais, Histoire du don en France de 1800 à 1939. Dons et legs charitables, pieux et philantropiques (Rennes, 1999)
17. M. Prak, 'Goede buren en verre vrienden. De ontwikkeling van onderstand bij armoede in Den Bosch sedert de Middeleeuwen', in H. D. Flap and M. H. D. van Leeuwen eds., Op lange termijn. Verklaringen van trends in de geschiedenis van samenlevingen (Hilversum, 1994), 147-69
18. and J. Kocka and G. Lingelbach eds., Schenken, Stiften und Spenden [special issue of Geschichte und Gesellschaft 33, 1 (2007)].
19. For example, D. T. Andrew, 'On reading charity sermons: eighteenth-century Anglican solicitation and exhortation', Journal of Ecclesiastical History 43, 4 (1992), 581-91
20. R. Titmuss, The gift relationship (London, 1970); Hindle, On the parish? I. Krausman Ben-Amos, The culture of giving: informal support and gift-exchange in early modern England (Cambridge, 2008)
21. S. Cavallo, Charity and power in early modern Italy; benefactors and their motives in Turin, 1541-1789 (Cambridge, 1995)
22. Komter, Social solidarity and the gift. For the Netherlands, see inter alia A. E. Komter and C. Schuyt, 'Geschenken en relaties', Beleid en Maatschappij 20 (1993), 227-85
23. A. de Regt, Geld en gezin. Financiële en emotionele relaties tussen gezinsleden (Amsterdam, 1993)
24. Schuyt et al., Geven in Nederland 2009; Bekkers, Giving and volunteering; and P. Wiepking, For the love of mankind.
25. The expression 'autobiographies in miniature' is taken from S. Epstein, Wills and wealth in medieval Genoa, 1150-1250 (Cambridge, MA, 1984), 232
26. M. Vovelle, Piété baroque et déchristianisation en Provence au XVIIIe siècle: les attitudes devant la mort d'après les clauses des testaments (Paris, 1973)
27. W. K. Jordan, Philanthropy in England 1480-1660: a study of the changing pattern of English social aspirations (London, 1959)
28. and W. K. Jordan, The charities of rural England 1480-1660: the aspirations and achievements of the rural society (London, 1962)
29. W. G. Bittle and R. T. Lane, 'Inflation and philanthropy in England: a re-assessment of W. K. Jordan's data', Economic History Review 29, 2 (1976), 203-10
30. and J. F. Hadwin, 'Deflating philanthropy', Economic History Review 31 (1978), 105-17
31. Hindle, On the parish? 98-9; and Ben-Amos, Culture of giving, 113-14.
32. J.-P. Gutton, La société et les pauvres: l'example de la généralité de Lyon, 1534-1789 (Paris, 1971)
33. P. T. Hoffman, Church and community in the diocese of Lyon, 1500-1789 (New Haven and London, 1984)
34. Jones, Charity and bienfaisance; M. Dinges, Stadtarmut in Bordeaux 1525-1675 (Bonn, 1988)
35. Cavallo, Charity and power; J. Spaans, Armenzorg in Friesland 1500-1800. Publieke zorg en particuliere liefdadigheid in zes Friese steden: Leeuwarden, Bolsward, Franeker, Sneek, Dokkum en Harlingen (Hilversum, 1997)
36. I. Dos Guimarã es, Quando o Rico se Faz Pobre: Misercordias, Caridade e Poder no Imperio Portugues, 1500-1800 (Lisbon, 1997)
37. N. Z. Davis, The gift in sixteenth-century France (Oxford, 2000)
38. D. Green, 'To do the right thing: gender, wealth, inheritance and the London middle class', in A. Laurence, J. Maltby and J. Rutterford eds., Women and their money, 1700-1950: essays on women and finance (London, 2009), 133-50
39. D. Kaiser, 'Testamentary charity in early modern Russia: trends and motivations', Journal of Modern History 76, 1 (2004), 1-28.
40. Recent Dutch studies on early modern philanthropy include M. Prak, 'Armenzorg 1500-1800', in J. van Gerwen and M. H. D. van Leeuwen eds., Studies over zekerheidsarrangementen. Risico's, risicobestrijding en verzekeringen in Nederland vanaf de Middeleeuwen (Amsterdam and The Hague, 1998), 49-90
41. Spaans, Armenzorg in Friesland; S. Groenveld, J. H. H. Dekker and T. R. M. Willemse, Wezen en boefjes. Zes eeuwen zorg in wees- en kinderhuizen (Hilversum, 1997)
42. A. E. C. McCants, Civic charity in a Golden Age: orphan care in early modern Amsterdam (Urbana and Chicago, 1997)
43. A. Buursma, 'Dese bekommerlijke tijden'. Armenzorg, armen en armoede in de stad Groningen 1594-1795 (Assen, 2009)
44. E. van Nederveen Meerkerk and G. Vermeesch, 'Reforming outdoor relief. Changes in urban provisions for the poor in the Northern and Southern Low Countries (c. 1500-1800)', in M. van der Heijden, E. van Nederveen Meerkerk, G. Vermeesch and M. van der Berg eds., Public services in the Low Countries (Amsterdam, 2009), 135-54
45. C. H. Parker, The reformation of community. Social welfare and Calvinist charity in Holland, 1572-1620 (Cambridge, 1998)
46. I. van der Vlis, Leven in armoede. Delftse bedeelden in de zeventiende eeuw (Amsterdam, 2001)
47. H. van Wijngaarden, Zorg voor de kost. Armenzorg, arbeid en onderlinge hulp in Zwolle, 1650-1700 (Amsterdam, 2000).
48. M. H. D. van Leeuwen, 'Overrun by hungry hordes? Migrants' entitlements to poor relief in the Netherlands, 16th-20th centuries', in S. Hindle and A. Winter eds., Migration, settlement and belonging in Europe, 1500-2000: comparative perspective (Oxford, forthcoming)
49. H. Looijesteijn and M. H. D. van Leeuwen, 'Identity registration in the Dutch Republic', in K. Breckenridge and S. Szreter eds., Registration and recognition. Documenting the person in world history (Oxford, forthcoming), ch. 8.
50. A. P. A. M. Spijker, 'Van Aalmoes tot sociale bijstand. Een overzicht van de ontwikkeling van de stedelijke armenzorg in Haarlem', Haerlem Jaarboek (1979), 66-98. On Alkmaar
51. C. J. van Baar and L. Noordegraaf, 'Werkschuwheid en misbruik van sociale voorzieningen? Het beleid in de Alkmaarse armenzorg 1750-1815', Alkmaarse Historische Reeks 5 (1982), 55-67. On Nijmegen
52. F. H. M. C. Adriaens, De magistraat van Nijmegen en de armenzorg (1750-1800) (Nijmegen, 1956). On Utrecht
53. P. D. 't Hart, De stad Utrecht en haar inwoners. Een onderzoek naar samenhangen tussen sociaal-economische ontwikkelingen en de demografische geschiedenis van de stad Utrecht 1771-1825 (Utrecht, 1983), 74-99. On Middelburg
54. J. L. Kool- Blokland, De zorg gewogen: zeven eeuwen godshuizen in Middelburg (Middelburg, 1990). On six Frisian cities, see Spaans, Armenzorg in Friesland. The same applies to specialist institutions such as orphanages. On Amsterdam, see McCants, Civic charity. On the Dutch Republic in general, see Groenveld et al., Wezen en boefjes, 114-30.
55. H. Nusteling, Welvaart en werkgelegenheid in Amsterdam 1540-1860 (Amsterdam, 1985), 260-1. In the same period nominal wages in the building industry rose from an index of 41 to 96, see ibid. 235-6.
56. M. H. D. van Leeuwen and J. E. Oeppen, 'Reconstructing the demographic regime of Amsterdam 1681-1920', Economic and Social History in the Netherlands 5 (1993), 61-104, especially 87; and Nusteling, Welvaart, 234.
57. J. Wagenaar, Amsterdam in zyne opkomst, aanwas, geschiedenissen, voorregten, koophandel, gebouwen, kerkenstaat, schoolen, schutterye, gilden en regeeringe, beschreeven. (Amsterdam, 1760-1767), vol. II, 149. This was also the case for the Sephardic charity (T. Levie Bernfeld, Poverty and welfare among the Portuguese Jews in early modern Amsterdam (Oxford, 2012), ch. 5, especially 147-8) as well as for the Burgher orphanage, McCants, Civic charity, ch. 7.
58. H. W. van der Hoeven, Uit de geheime notulen van de 'Eerwaarde Groote Vergadering' 1785-1815. Het beleid van de diakonie van de Hervormde kerk te Amsterdam (The Hague, 1985), 178, 184.
59. H. C. de Wolf, Geschiedenis van het R.C. Oude-Armenkantoor te Amsterdam (Hilversum, 1966), 201-6. Meischke, Het R.C. Maagdenhuis, 69-73.
60. T. Levie Bernfeld, 'Financing poor relief in the Spanish-Portuguese Jewish community in Amsterdam in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries', in J. I. Israel and Reinier Salverda eds., Dutch Jewry: its history and secular culture (Leiden, 2002), 63-102
61. Levie Bernfeld, Poverty and welfare, ch. 5, especially 138-40 and Appendix H, Figure 3, 255.
62. G. P. M. Pot, Arm Leiden. Levensstandaard, bedeling en bedeelden, 1750-1854 (Hilversum, 1994), 168-70
63. P. A. C. Douwes, Armenkerk. De hervormde diaconie te Rotterdam in de negentiende eeuw (Schiedam, 1977), 125.
64. E. van Nederveen Meerkerk and D. Teeuwen, 'Keeping up the good works: voluntary giving and the financial maintenance of charitable institutions in Dutch towns, c. 1600-1800', paper presented at the Department of Economic and Social History, Utrecht University, 15 March 2012.
65. R. Wall, 'Relations between generations in British families past and present', in C. Marsh and S. Arber eds., Families and households: divisions and change (London, 1992), 63-85
66. R. T. Vann, 'Wills and the family in an English town: Banbury 1550-1800', Journal of Family History 4, 4 (1979), 346-7, especially 352; Vovelle, Piété baroque et déchristianisation en Provence au XVIIIe siècle, 27.
67. E. van Nederveen Meerkerk in this issue of Continuity and Change, 'The will to give: charitable bequests and community building in the Dutch Republic, c.1600-1800'.
68. A. T. van Deursen, Een dorp in de polder. Graft in de zeventiende eeuw (Amsterdam, 1994), 184.
69. See also B. Diefendorf, From penitence to charity: pious women and the Catholic reformation in Paris (New York, 2004), 241-51
70. E. Rapley, The Dévots. Women and church in seventeenth-century France (Montreal, 1990), 20
71. Hoffman, Church and community, 171-84; P. T. Hoffman, 'Wills and statistics : Tobit analysis and the counter Reformation in Lyon', Journal of Interdisciplinary History 14, 2 (1984), 813-34
72. Leslie McGranahan, 'The widow's offering: inheritance, family structure, and the charitable gifts of women', Explorations in Economic History 46, 3 (2009), 356-67
73. R. B. Evenhuis, Ook dat was Amsterdam. De kerk der late hervorming in de achttiende eeuw (Amsterdam, 1974), 125.
74. J. de Vries and A. van der Woude, The first modern economy: success, failure, and perseverance of the Dutch economy, 1500-1815 (Cambridge, 1997), 567.
75. The same holds true for testators to the Sephardic charity, Levie Bernfeld, Poverty and welfare, ch. 5, 155-7 and especially Appendix I, 246-7, tables 21 and 22.
76. T. Adams, 'The provision of work as assistance and correction in France, 1534-1848', in D. T. Critchlow and C. Parker eds., Always with us: a history of private charity and public welfare (Lanham, 1998), 55-76 and especially 61
77. J. P. Gutton, 'Pour l'histoire d'un elite ', 7-18 in J. P. Gutton ed., Les administrateursdes hòpitaux dans la France d'Ancien Régime (Lyon, 1997)
78. D. Hickey, 'Les méchanisms de la strá tegie sociale. Bienfaiteurs et administrateurs des hò pitaux locaux en France au XVIIe et XVIIIe siè cles ', in Gutton, Les administrateurs, 19-41
79. M. H. D. van Leeuwen, The logic of charity: Amsterdam 1800-1850 (Aldershot and New York, 2000), 54-67; Cavallo, Charity and power, 149-51.
80. T. C. M. H. van Rijckevorsel, Geschiedenis van het R.C. Maagdenhuis te Amsterdam 1570-1887 (Amsterdam, 1887), 78-9, 95, 104, 125, 132, 136-41, 155-62, 173, 181-6.
81. A. Komter and C. Schuyt, 'Wegen van wederkerigheid: geefrelaties tussen ouders en kinderen', in C. Brinkgreve ed., Overdragen en eigenmaken. Over sociale erfenissen (Groningen, 1994), 16-36, especially 30
82. T. Levie Bernfeld, 'Caridade escapas da morte', Dutch-Jewish History 3 (1993), 179-204
83. Levie Bernfeld, Poverty and welfare, ch. 6, especially 173.
84. H. A. Hö weler, 'Jakob Muhl en de liefdadigheid (1785-1786)', Documentatieblad Werkgroep Achttiende Eeuw 39 (1978), 1-9.
85. see also Levie Bernfeld, Poverty and welfare, ch. 4, Especially 116 and n. 374 (gift of Josua de Prado to Joseph Levi) and ch. 6, especially n. 170, 424-5.
86. ACA, PA 440, nos 255/86 and 256/102, 1736; Levie Bernfeld, 'Caridade escapa da morte', 185.
87. Evenhuis, Ook dat was Amsterdam, 125-6
88. As did the rabbi, Levie Bernfeld, Poverty and welfare, ch. 5, especially 73-5.
89. S. Groenveld, ' '''Geef van uw haaf een milde gaaf ons arme weesen''. De zorg voor wezen tot 1800 als onderdeel van de armenzorg', in S. Groenveld and J. Th. Balk eds., Daar de orangie-appel in de gevel staat:. in en om het weeshuis der doopsgezinde collegianten 1675-1975 (Amsterdam, 1975), 37.
90. J. C. Breen, 'Collecten te Amsterdam in de achtiende eeuw', Jaarboek Amstellodamum (1907), 129-52, here 131-2.
91. Evenhuis, Ook dat was Amsterdam, 124.
92. De Wolf, Geschiedenis van het R.C. Oude-Armenkantoor te Amsterdam, 39 for 1638 and 1640.
93. C. Lesger and M. H. D. van Leeuwen, 'Residential segregation from the sixteenth to the nineteenth century: evidence from the Netherlands', Journal of Interdisciplinary History 42, 3 (2011), 333-69.
94. Fairchild, Poverty and Charity in Aix-en-Provence, 538.
95. Meischke, Het R.C. Maagdenhuis, 2, and Rijckevorsel, Geschiedenis van het R.C. Maagdenhuis te Amsterdam, 76, 79-80
96. C. Commelin, Beschrijving van Amsterdam (Amsterdam, 1693), 529. In seventeenth-century Graft, it was a regular practice to donate a percentage of the profits earned on a successful sea journey to poor relief. See van Deursen, Een dorp in de polder, 186.
97. Levie Bernfeld, Poverty and welfare, ch. 6, especially 159-69.
98. Andrew, 'On reading charity sermons' ; Fairchild, Poverty and charity in Aixen- Provence, 25-6
99. S. Lloyd, 'Pleasing spectacles and elegant dinners: conviviality, benevolence and charity anniversaries in eighteenth century London', Journal of British Studies 41, 1 (2002), 23-57.
100. Italics in the original. These are references to 2 Cor. 9: 6 and Ps. 37: 26.
101. Italics in the original. The reference is to Ps. 112: 9.
102. C. van der Vijver, Geschiedkundige beschrijving der stad Amsterdam (Amsterdam, 1844-1848), 41. 76 Wagenaar, Amsterdam in zyne opkomst, vol. II, 342.
103. Fairchild, Poverty and charity in Aix-en-Provence, 27; see also 54-8.
104. Norberg, Rich and poor in Grenoble, 301-3.
105. Quoted in Andrew, 'On reading charity sermons', 587.
106. Quoted in Richard L. Greaves, Society and religion in Elizabethan England (Minneapolis, 1981), 559.
107. J. Chiffoleau, La comptabilité de l'au-delà. Les hommes, la mort et la religion dans la région d'Avignon à la fin du moyen age (Rome, 1980)
108. J. T. Rosenthal, The purchase of paradise: gift giving and the aristocracy, 1307-1485 (London, 1972).
109. Mol, 'Friezen en het hiernamaals ', 28-9.
110. van Leeuwen, The logic of charity, 87-8.
111. Quoted in Vovelle, Piété baroque et dé christianisation en Provence au XVIIIe siècle, 75.
112. E. Meulemand, 'Goede werken', in F. W. Grosheide and G. P. van Itterson eds., Christelijke encyclopedie. Vol. III (Kampen, 1958), 271-3. See also Matt. 7: 16-21.
113. Greaves, Society and religion in Elizabethan England, 557
114. I. Archer, 'The charity of early modern Londoners ', Transactions of the Royal Historical Society 12 (2002), 223-44.
115. G. Oorthuys, De leer der praedestinatie (Wageningen, 1931), 40-56 and 87-8.
116. Greaves, Society and religion in Elizabethan England, 561. For the complicated discourses that then arose, see Ben-Amos, Culture of giving, ch. 7, especially 267 and 273.
117. P. W. Hansen, 'Miraklernes tid. Almiassekultur og gavegiving i Oplysningstidens Kobehaven', in P. Henningsen ed., Miraklernes tid og andre fortoellinger om livet I 1700-tallets Kobenhaven (Copenhagen, 2008), 5-62
118. B. J. Kaplan, Calvinists and libertines: confession and community in Utrecht, 1578-1620 (Oxford, 1995), 291-2
119. S. Marshall, The Dutch gentry 1500-1650: family, faith, and fortune (New York, 1987)
120. Groenveld, ''Geef', 38-9.
121. Quoted in J. Romein and A. Romein, Erflaters van onze beschaving, Zeventiende eeuw (Amsterdam, 1938), 121-2.
122. Quoted in Hö weler, 'Jakob Muhl en de liefdadigheid', 3.
123. S. D. Muller, Charity in the Dutch Republic: pictures of rich and poor for charitable institutions (Ann Arbor, 1985).
124. L. Lees, The solidarity of strangers. The English poor laws and the people, 1700-1948 (Cambridge, 1998)
125. K. A. Lynch, Individuals, families and communities in Europe, 1200-1800. The urban foundations of western society (Cambridge, 2003). For similar arguments on contributing to charity among Sephardic Jews, see Levie Bernfeld, Poverty and welfare, ch. 6, especially 175-8
126. H. C. de Wolf, De kerk en het Maagdenhuis. Vier episoden uit de geschiedenis van katholiek Amsterdam (Utrecht and Antwerp, 1970), 98; McCants, Civic charity.
127. M. Prak, Republikeinse veelvoud, democratisch enkelvoud (Nijmegen, 1999).
128. M. H. D. van Leeuwen, 'Guilds and middleclass welfare 1550-1800: provisions for burial, sickness, old age, and widowhood', Economic History Review 65, 1 (2012), 61-90.