Is it rational to assume that infants imitate rationally? a theoretical analysis and critique

Human Development

Volumn 55, Issue 3, 2012, Pages 107-121

  Paulus, Markus ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MUNICH   (Germany)

Author keywords

Action control; Action understanding; Conceptual analysis; Imitation

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; BEHAVIOR; COGNITION; HUMAN; IMITATION; INFANCY; INFANT; PERCEPTION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; THEORETICAL MODEL; THEORETICAL STUDY; THINKING;

EID: 84865386023     PISSN: 0018716X     EISSN: 14230054     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1159/000339442     Document Type: Article

References (100)

1. Adolph, K.E., & Avolio, A. (2000). Walking infants adapt locomotion to changing body dimensions. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 26, 1148-1166.
2. Adolph, K.E., & Berger, S. (2006). Motor development. In W. Damon & R. Lerner (Series Eds.), D. Kuhn & R.S. Siegler (Vol. Eds.), Handbook of child psychology. Vol. 2: Cognition, perception, and language (6th ed., pp. 161-213). New York: Wiley.
3. Adolph, K.E., & Robinson, S.R. (2008). In defense of change processes. Child Development, 79, 1648-1653.
4. Apperly, I.A., & Butterfill, S.A. (2009). Do humans have two systems to track beliefs and belief-like states? Psychological Review, 116, 953-970.
5. Baillargeon, R. (2008). Innate ideas revisited: For a principle of persistence in infants' physical reasoning. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 3, 2-13.
6. Baker, C.L., Saxe, R.R., & Tenenbaum, J.B. (2009). Action understanding as inverse planning. Cognition, 113, 329-349.
7. Baldwin, J.M. (1968). Mental development in the child and race (3rd ed.). New York: Augustus M. Kelley. (Original work published in 1906.)
8. Barresi, J., & Moore, C. (1996). Intentional relations and social understanding. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 19, 107-122.
9. Beck, S.R., Riggs, K.J., & Gorniak, S.L. (2009). Relating developments in children's counterfactual thinking and executive functions. Thinking and Reasoning, 15, 337-354.
10. Beck, S.R., Robinson, E.J., Carroll, D.J., & Apperly, I.A. (2006). Children's thinking about counterfactuals and future hypotheticals as possibilities. Child Development, 77, 413-426. (Pubitemid 43430207)
11. Bennett, M.R., & Hacker, P.M.S. (2003). Philosophical foundations of neuroscience. Malden: Blackwell.
12. Bering, J.M., & Povinelli, D.J. (2003). Comparing cognitive development. In D. Maestripieri (Ed.), Primate psychology (pp. 205-233). Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
13. Brandom, R.B. (1994). Making it explicit. Reasoning, representing, and discursive commitment . Harvard: University Press.
14. Brandom, R.B. (2009). Reason in philosophy: Animating ideas . Cambridge: Harvard Press.
15. Brownell, C.A., & Koop, C. (Eds.) (2007). Socioemotional development in the toddler years: Transitions and transformations. New York: Guilford Press.
16. Brownell, C.A., Nichols, S.R., Svetlova, M., Zerwas, S., & Ramani, G. (2010). The head bone's connected to the neck bone: When do toddlers represent their own body topography? Child Development, 81, 797-810.
17. Brownell, C.A., Zerwas, S., & Ramani, G.B. (2007). 'So big': The development of body self-awareness in toddlers. Child Development, 78, 1426-1440.
18. Buttelmann, D., Carpenter, M., Call, J., & Tomasello, M. (2007). Enculturated chimpanzees imitate rationally. Developmental Science, 10, F31-F38.
19. Buttelmann, D., Carpenter, M., Call, J., & Tomasello, M. (2008). Rational tool use and tool choice in human infants and great apes. Child Development, 79, 609-626.
20. Calvo-Merino, B., Glaser, D.E., Grèzes, J., Passingham, R.E., & Haggard, P. (2005). Action observation and acquired motor skills: An fMRI study with expert dancers. Cerebral Cortex, 15, 1243-1249. (Pubitemid 41373616)
21. Campbell, R.L., & Richie, D.M. (1983). Problems in the theory of developmental sequences: Prerequisites and precursors. Human Development, 26, 156-172.
22. Carpendale, J.E.M., & Lewis, C. (2004). Constructing an understanding of the mind: The development of children's understanding of mind within social interactions. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 27, 79-150.
23. Chomsky, N. (1980). Rules and representations . New York: Columbia University Press.
24. Csibra, G., & Gergely, C. (2007). 'Obsessed with goals': Functions and mechanisms of teleological interpretation of actions in humans. Acta Psychologica, 124, 60-78. (Pubitemid 44932838)
25. Csibra, G., & Gergely, G. (2009). Natural pedagogy. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 13, 148-153.
26. Csibra, G., Gergely, G., Bíró, S., Koós, O., & Brockbank, M. (1999). Goal attribution without agency cues: The perceptions of 'pure reason' in infancy. Cognition, 72, 237-267. (Pubitemid 29462583)
27. De Bruin, L.C., & Newen, A. (2012). An association account of false belief understanding. Cognition, 123, 240-259.
28. Elsner, B. (2007). Infants' imitation of goal-directed actions: The role of movements and action effects. Acta Psychologica, 124, 44-59. (Pubitemid 44932837)
29. Ewert, O.M. (1983). Eine historische Nachbemerkung zu Neuberger, Merz und Selg: Imitation bei Neugeborenen-eine kontroverse Befundlage. Zeitschrift für Entwicklungspsychologie und Pädagogische Psychologie, 15, 277-279.
30. Gergely, G., Bekkering, H., & Kiraly, I. (2001). Rational imitation of goal-directed actions in 14-montholds. In J.D. Moore & K. Stenning (Eds.), Proceedings of Cogsci 2001 (pp. 309-315). London: LEA.
31. Gergely, G., Bekkering, H., & Kiraly, I. (2002). Rational imitation in preverbal infants. Nature, 415, 755. (Pubitemid 34150489)
32. Gergely, G., & Csibra, G. (2003). Teleological reasoning in infancy: The naïve theory of rational action. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 7, 287-292. (Pubitemid 36818921)
33. Gopnik, A., & Schulz, L. (2004). Mechanisms of theory formation in young children. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 8, 371-377. (Pubitemid 39099463)
34. Guillaume, P. (1925). L'imitation chez l'enfant . Paris: Alcan.
35. Hacker, P.M.S. (2010). Human nature: The categorical framework . Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell.
36. Haith, M.M. (1998). Who put the cog in infant cognition: Is rich interpretation too costly? Infant Behavior and Development, 21 , 167-179. (Pubitemid 128347883)
37. Hamlin, J.K., Wynn, K., & Bloom, P. (2007). Social evaluation by preverbal infants. Nature, 450, 557-559. (Pubitemid 350190246)
38. Harr, R., & Tissaw, M.A. (2005). Wittgenstein and psychology: A practical guide . Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing.
39. Heyes, C.M. (2001). Causes and consequences of imitation. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 5, 253-261.
40. Heyes, C.M. (2009). Evolution, development and intentional control of imitation. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences, 364, 2293-2298.
41. Hommel, B. (2009a). Action control according to TEC (theory of event coding). Psychological Research, 73, 512-526.
42. Hommel, B. (2009b). Conscious and unconscious control of spatial action. In W.P. Banks (Ed.), Encyclopedia of consciousness (pp. 171-181). Oxford: Elsevier.
43. Hommel, B., Müsseler, J., Aschersleben, G., & Prinz, W. (2001). The theory of event coding (TEC): A framework for perception and action planning. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 24, 849-878. (Pubitemid 34965924)
44. Jones, S.S. (2007). Imitation in infancy. The development of mimicry. Psychological Science, 18, 593-599.
45. Jones, S.S. (2009). The development of imitation in infancy. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences, 364, 2325-2335.
46. Jones, S.S., & Yoshida, H. (2011). Imitation in infancy and the acquisition of body knowledge. In V. Slaughter & C. Brownell (Eds.). Early development of body representations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
47. Kaminski, J., Nitzschner, M., Wobber, V., Tennie, C., Bräuer, J., Call, J., & Tomasello, M. (2011). Can dogs distinguish rational from irrational acts? Animal Behaviour, 81, 195-203.
48. Kiraly, I. (2009). The effect of the model's presence and of negative evidence on infants' selective imitation. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 102, 14-25.
49. Klossek, U.M.H., Russell, J., & Dickinson, T. (2008). The control of instrumental action following outcome devaluation in young children. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 137, 39-51.
50. Kovács, Á.M., Téglás, E., & Endress, A.D. (2010). The social sense: Susceptibly to others' beliefs in human infants and adults. Science, 330, 1830-1834.
51. Knudsen, B., & Liszkowski, U. (2012). Eighteen-and 24-month-old infants correct others in anticipation of action mistakes. Developmental Science, 15, 113-122.
52. Kuhlmeier, V.A., Wynn, K., & Bloom, P. (2003). Attribution of dispositional states by 12-month-olds. Psychological Science, 14 , 402-408. (Pubitemid 37282802)
53. Kuhn, T.S. (1962). The structure of scientific revolutions . Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
54. Luo, Y. (2010). Do 8-month-old infants consider situational constraints when interpreting others' gaze as goal-directed action? Infancy, 15, 392-419.
55. Luo, Y., & Baillargeon, R. (2010). Toward a mentalistic account of early psychological reasoning. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 19, 301-307.
56. Markman, E.M. (1990). Constraints children place on word meaning. Cognitive Science, 14, 57-77.
57. Meltzoff, A.N., & Moore, M.K. (1977). Imitation of facial and manual gestures by human neonates. Science, 198, 75-78. (Pubitemid 8196230)
58. Meltzoff, A.N., & Moore, M.K. (1997). Explaining facial imitation: A theoretical model. Early Development and Parenting, 6, 179-192. (Pubitemid 127527083)
59. Moore, C. (2006). The development of commonsense psychology. Mahwah: LEA.
60. Moore, C., Mealiea, J., Garon, N., & Povinelli, D. (2007). The development of body self-awareness. Infancy, 11, 157-174. (Pubitemid 46901822)
61. Müller, U., & Giesbrecht, G. (2008). Methodological and epistemological issues in the interpretation of infant cognitive development. Child Development, 79, 1654-1658.
62. Nachev, P., & Hacker, P.M.S. (2010). Covert cognition in the persistent vegetative state. Current Opinion in Neurobiology, 91, 68-75.
63. Nelson, C.A. (2001). The development and neural bases of face recognition. Infant and Child Development, 10, 3-18.
64. Nielsen, M. (2006). Copying actions and copying outcomes: Social learning through the second year. Developmental Psychology, 42, 555-565. (Pubitemid 44178809)
65. Onishi, K.H., & Baillargeon, R. (2005). Do 15-month-old infants understand false beliefs? Science, 308, 255-258. (Pubitemid 40558861)
66. Overton, W.F. (1998). Developmental psychology: Philosophy, concepts, and methodology. In W. Damon (Series Ed.) & R.M. Lerner (Vol. Ed.), Handbook of child psychology. Vol. 1: Theoretical models of human development (5th ed., pp. 107-188). New York: Wiley.
67. Paulus, M. (2011). Imitation in infancy: Conceptual considerations. Theory & Psychology, 21, 849-856.
68. Paulus, M., Hunnius, S., van Wijngaarden, C., Vrins, S., van Rooij, I., & Bekkering, H. (2011a). The role of frequency information and teleological reasoning in infants' and adults' action prediction. Developmental Psychology, 47, 976-983.
69. Paulus, M., Hunnius, S., Vissers, M., & Bekkering, H. (2011b). Imitation in infancy: Rational or motor resonance? Child Development, 82, 1047-1057.
70. Paulus, M., Hunnius, S., Vissers, M., & Bekkering, H. (2011c). Bridging the gap between the other and me: The functional role of motor resonance and action effects in infants' imitation. Developmental Science, 14, 901-910.
71. Paulus, M., & Moore, C. (2011). Whom to ask for help? Children's developing understanding of other people's action capabilities. Experimental Brain Research, 211, 593-600.
72. Perner, J., & Ruffman, T. (2005). Psychology. Infants' insight into the mind: how deep? Science, 308, 214-216.
73. Perner, J., Sprung, M., & Steinkogler, B. (2004). Counterfactual conditionals and false belief: A developmental dissociation. Journal of Cognition and Development, 19, 179-201. (Pubitemid 38561961)
74. Piaget, J. (1954). The construction of reality in the child . New York: Basic Books.
75. Piaget, J. (1962). Play, dreams and imitation in childhood. New York: Norton.
76. Povinelli, D.J., Bering, J.M., & Giambrone, S. (2000). Towards a science of other minds: Escaping the argument by analogy. Cognitive Science, 24, 509-541.
77. Povinelli, D.J., & Giambrone, S. (1999). Inferring other minds: Failure of the argument by analogy. Philosophical Topics, 27, 167-201.
78. Preyer, W. (1980). Die Seele des Kindes. Beobachtungen über die geistige Entwicklung des Menschen in den ersten Lebensjahren (3rd ed.). Leipzig: Grieben.
79. Rafetseder, E., Cristi-Vargas, R., & Perner, J. (2010). Counterfactual reasoning: Developing a sense of 'nearest possible world'. Child Development, 81, 376-389.
80. Rakoczy, H. (2008). Pretence as individual and collective intentionality. Mind and Language, 23, 499-517.
81. Rakoczy, H. (2012). Do infants have a theory of mind? British Journal of Developmental Psychology, 30, 59-74.
82. Range, F., Virnayi, Z., & Huber, L. (2007). Selective imitation in domestic dogs. Current Biology, 17, 868-872. (Pubitemid 46702669)
83. Ray, E., & Heyes, C.M. (2011). Imitation in infancy: The wealth of the stimulus. Developmental Science, 14, 92-105.
84. Ridderinkhof, K.R., Forstmann, B.U., Wylie, S.A., Burle, B., & van den Wildenberg, W.P. M. (2011). Neurocognitive mechanisms of action control: Resisting the call of the Sirens. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Cognitive Science, 2, 174-192.
85. Ridderinkhof, K.R., van den Wildenberg, W.P.M., Segalowitz, S.J., & Carter, C.S. (2004). Neurocognitive mechanisms of cognitive control: The role of prefrontal cortex in action selection, response inhibition, performance monitoring, and reward-based learning. Brain and Cognition, 56, 129-140. (Pubitemid 39423876)
86. Ryle, G. (1949). The concept of mind . Chicago: University Press.
87. Schwier, C., van Maanen, C., Carpenter, M., & Tomasello, M. (2006). Rational imitation in 12-monthold infants . Infancy, 10, 303-311.
88. Siegal, M., & Varley, R. (2008). If we could talk to the animals. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 31, 146-147. (Pubitemid 351689837)
89. Sodian, B. (2011). Theory of mind in infancy. Child Development Perspectives, 5, 39-43.
90. Thoermer, C., Sodian, B., Vuori, M., Perst, H., & Kristen, S. (2012). Continuity from an implicit to an explicit understanding of false belief from infancy to preschool age. British Journal of Developmental Psychology, 30, 172-187.
91. Tissaw, M.A. (2007). Making sense of neonatal imitation. Theory & Psychology, 17, 217-242.
92. Tomasello, M., Carpenter, M., Call, J., Behne, T., & Moll, H. (2005). Understanding and sharing intentions: The origins of cultural cognition. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 28, 675-691. (Pubitemid 43372568)
93. van Geert, P. (2004). Dynamic modeling of cognitive development. Time, situatedness and variability. In A. Demetriou & A. Raftopoulos (Eds.), Emergence and transformation in the mind: Modeling and measuring cognitive change (pp. 354-378). Mawah: Erlbaum.
94. van Quine, W. (1960). Word and object . Harvard: MIT Press.
95. Verschoor, S.A., Weidema, M., Biro, S., & Hommel, B. (2010). Where do action goals come from? Evidence for spontaneous action-effect binding in infants. Frontiers in Psychology, 1, 201.
96. Vonk, J., & Subiaul, F. (2009). Do chimpanzees know what others can and cannot do? Reasoning about 'capability'. Animal Cognition, 12, 267-286.
97. Wittgenstein, L. (1953). Philosophical investigations . Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
98. Zelazo, P.D., Carlson, S.M., & Kesek, A. (2008). Development of executive function in childhood. In C.A. Nelson & M. Luciana (Eds.), Handbook of developmental cognitive neuroscience (2nd ed., pp. 553-574). Cambridge: MIT Press.
99. Zelazo, P.D., Müller, U., Frye, D., & Marcovitch, S. (2003). The development of executive function in early childhood. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development, 68, Serial No. 274.
100. Zmyj, N., Daum, M.M., & Aschersleben, G. (2009). The development of rational imitation in 9-and 12-month-old infants. Infancy, 14, 131-141.