A meta-analysis of percutaneous compression plate versus sliding hip screw for the management of intertrochanteric fractures of the hip

Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery

Volumn 72, Issue 5, 2012, Pages 1435-1443

  Cheng, Tao ^a   Zhang, Guo You ^b   Liu, Tao ^c   Zhang, Xian Long ^a  

^a SHANGHAI JIAO TONG UNIVERSITY   (China)

^b WENZHOU MEDICAL UNIVERSITY   (China)

^c SOOCHOW UNIVERSITY   (China)

Author keywords

Dynamic hip screw; Hip fracture; Minimally invasive surgery; PCCP; Percutaneous compression plate; Systematic review

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; BLOOD TRANSFUSION; BONE PLATE; BONE SCREW; CEREBROVASCULAR ACCIDENT; CHEST INFECTION; DEEP VEIN THROMBOSIS; FEMUR INTERTROCHANTERIC FRACTURE; FRACTURE NONUNION; GASTROINTESTINAL HEMORRHAGE; HOSPITALIZATION; HUMAN; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; KIDNEY INFECTION; LUNG EMBOLISM; META ANALYSIS; OPERATION DURATION; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PERCUTANEOUS COMPRESSION PLATE; POSTOPERATIVE HEMORRHAGE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REOPERATION; SLIDING HIP SCREW; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; WOUND INFECTION;

BONE PLATES; BONE SCREWS; FRACTURE FIXATION, INTERNAL; HIP FRACTURES; HUMANS; PROSTHESIS DESIGN;

EID: 84864532135     PISSN: 21630755     EISSN: 21630763     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1097/TA.0b013e318247252a     Document Type: Article

References (69)

1. Rosengren BE, Ahlborg HG, Gärdsell P, et al. Bone mineral density and incidence of hip fracture in Swedish urban and rural women 1987-2002. Acta Orthop. 2010;81:453-459.
2. van Zeeland ML, Genovesi IP, Mulder JW, Strating PR, Glas AS, Engel AF. POSSUM predicts hospital mortality and long-term survival in patients with hip fractures. J Trauma. 2011;70:E67-E72.
3. Cooper C, Campion G, Melton LJ III. Hip fractures in the elderly: a world-wide projection. Osteoporos Int. 1992;2:285-289.
4. Palm H, Lysén C, Krasheninnikoff M, Holck K, Jacobsen S, Gebuhr P. Intramedullary nailing appears to be superior in pertrochanteric hip fractures with a detached greater trochanter: 311 consecutive patients followed for 1 year. Acta Orthop. 2011;82:166-170.
5. Gullberg B, Johnell O, Kanis JA. World-wide projections for hip fracture. Osteoporos Int. 1997;7:407-413.
6. Johnell O. The socioeconomic burden of fractures: Today and in the 21st century. Am J Med. 1997;103:20S-25S.
7. Johnell O, Kanis JA. An estimate of the worldwide prevalence and disability associated with osteoporotic fractures. Osteoporos Int. 2006; 17:1726-1733.
8. Alobaid A, Harvey EJ, Elder GM, Lander P, Guy P, Reindl R. Minimally invasive dynamic hip screw: Prospective randomized trial of two techniques of insertion of a standard dynamic fixation device. J Orthop Trauma. 2004;18:207-212.
9. Smith EB, Parvizi J, Purtill JJ. Delayed surgery for patients with femur and hip fractures-risk of deep venous thrombosis. J Trauma. 2011;70: E113-E116.
10. Gardenbroek TJ, Segers MJ, Simmermacher RK, Hammacher ER. The proximal femur nail antirotation: An identifiable improvement in the treatment of unstable pertrochanteric fractures? J Trauma. 2011;71: 169-174.
11. Rogmark C, Spetz CL, Garellick G. More intramedullary nails and arthroplasties for treatment of hip fractures in Sweden. Acta Orthop. 2010;81:588-592.
12. Cheng T, Zhang G, Zhang X. Minimally invasive versus conventional dynamic hip screw fixation in elderly patients with intertrochanteric fractures: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Surg Innov. 2011;18: 99-105.
13. Hu F, Jiang C, Shen J, Tang P, Wang Y. Preoperative predictors for mortality following hip fracture surgery: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Injury. In press.
14. Kuzyk PR, Guy P, Kreder HJ, Zdero R, McKee MD, Schemitsch EH. Minimally invasive hip fracture surgery: Are outcomes better? J Orthop Trauma. 2009;23:447-453.
15. Kristensen MT, Foss NB, Ekdahl C, Kehlet H. Prefracture functional level evaluated by the New Mobility Score predicts in-hospital outcome after hip fracture surgery. Acta Orthop. 2010;81:296-302.
16. Butler M, Forte ML, Joglekar SB, Swiontkowski MF, Kane RL. Evidence summary: Systematic review of surgical treatments for geriatric hip fractures. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2011;93:1104-1115.
17. Gao AG, Cheng L, Yuan P. Percutaneous compression plate versus dynamic hip screw in treatment of elderly patients with intertrochanteric hip fractures [in Chinese]. China J Orthop Trauma. 2011;13:29-32.
18. Bhandari M, Schemitsch E, Jönsson A, Zlowodzki M, Haidukewych GJ. Gamma nails revisited: Gamma nails versus compression hip screws in the management of intertrochanteric fractures of the hip: a metaanalysis. J Orthop Trauma. 2009;23:460-464.
19. Lee PC, Hsieh PH, Chou YC, Wu CC, Chen WJ. Dynamic hip screws for unstable intertrochanteric fractures in elderly patients- encouraging results with a cement augmentation technique. J Trauma. 2010;68:954-964.
20. Yang E, Qureshi S, Trokhan S, Joseph D. Gotfried percutaneous compression plating compared with sliding hip screw fixation of intertrochanteric hip fractures: a prospective randomized study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2011;93:942-947.
21. Lee YS, Huang HL, Lo TY, Huang CR. Dynamic hip screw in the treatment of intertrochanteric fractures: A comparison of two fixation methods. Int Orthop. 2007;31:683-688.
22. Wang JP, Yang TF, Kong QQ, et al. Minimally invasive technique versus conventional technique of dynamic hip screws for intertrochanteric femoral fractures. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 2010;130:613-620.
23. Wong TC, Chiu Y, Tsang WL, Leung WY, Yeung SH. A double-blind, prospective, randomised, controlled clinical trial of minimally invasive dynamic hip screw fixation of intertrochanteric fractures. Injury. 2009; 40:422-427.
24. Yang E, DeLaMora S. Minimally invasive treatment of intertrochanteric hip fractures with the Gotfried percutaneous compression plate. Orthopedics. 2008;31:29-36.
25. Xu YZ, Geng DC, Mao HQ, Zhu XS, Yang HL. A comparison of the proximal femoral nail antirotation device and dynamic hip screw in the treatment of unstable pertrochanteric fracture. J Int Med Res. 2010;38: 1266-1275.
26. Akinci O, Akalin Y, Reisoǧlu A, Kayali C. Comparison of long-term results of dynamic hip screw and AO 130 degrees blade plate in adult trochanteric region fractures. Acta Orthop Traumatol Turc. 2010;44: 443-451.
27. Verettas DA, Ifantidis P, Chatzipapas CN, et al. Systematic effects of surgical treatment of hip fractures: Gliding screw-plating vs intramedullary nailing. Injury. 2010;41:279-284.
28. Haentjens P, Magaziner J, Colón-Emeric CS, et al. Meta-analysis: Excess mortality after hip fracture among older women and men. Ann Intern Med. 2010;152:380-390.
29. Jamal Sepah Y, Umer M, Khan A, Ullah Khan Niazi A. Functional outcome, mortality and in-hospital complications of operative treatment in elderly patients with hip fractures in the developing world. Int Orthop. 2010;34:431-435.
30. Johansen A, Mansor M, Beck S, Mahoney H, Thomas S. Outcome following hip fracture: Post-discharge residence and long-term mortality. Age Ageing. 2010;39:653-656.
31. Janzing HM, Houben BJ, Brandt SE, et al. The Gotfried PerCutaneous Compression Plate versus the Dynamic Hip Screw in the treatment of pertrochanteric hip fractures: Minimal invasive treatment reduces operative time and postoperative pain. J Trauma. 2002;52:293-298.
32. Russell TA, Sanders R. Pertrochanteric hip fractures: time for change. J Orthop Trauma. 2011;25:189-190.
33. Gotfried Y. Percutaneous compression plating of intertrochanteric hip fractures. J Orthop Trauma. 2000;14:490-495.
34. Gotfried Y. Percutaneous compression plating for intertrochanteric hip fractures: treatment rationale. Orthopedics. 2002;25:647-652.
35. Gotfried Y, Cohen B, Rotem A. Biomechanical evaluation of the percutaneous compression plating system for hip fractures. J Orthop Trauma. 2002;16:644-650.
36. Panesar SS, Mirza S, Bharadwaj G, Woolf V, Ravikumar R, Athanasiou T. The percutaneous compression plate versus the dynamic hip screw: A meta-analysis. Acta Orthop Belg. 2008;74:38-48.
37. Gotfried Y. The lateral trochanteric wall: a key element in the reconstruction of unstable pertrochanteric hip fractures. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2004;425:82-86.
38. Gotfried Y. Integrity of the lateral femoral wall in intertrochanteric hip fractures: An important predictor of a reoperation. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2007;89:2552-2553.
39. Bensafi H, Laffosse JM, Giordano G, Dao C, Chiron P, Puget J. The percutaneous compression plate (PCCP) in the treatment of trochanteric hip fractures in elderly patients. Acta Orthop Belg. 2006;72:314-319.
40. Krischak GD, Augat P, Beck A, et al. Biomechanical comparison of two side plate fixation techniques in an unstable intertrochanteric osteotomy model: Sliding Hip Screw and Percutaneous Compression Plate. Clin Biomech (Bristol, Avon). 2007;22:1112-1118.
41. Ropars M, Mitton D, Skalli W. Minimally invasive screw plates for surgery of unstable intertrochanteric femoral fractures: a biomechanical comparative study. Clin Biomech (Bristol, Avon). 2008;23:1012-1017.
42. Brandt E, Verdonschot N, van Vugt A, van Kampen A. Biomechanical analysis of the percutaneous compression plate and sliding hip screw in intracapsular hip fractures: experimental assessment using synthetic and cadaver bones. Injury. 2006;37:979-983.
43. Varela-Egocheaga JR, Iglesias-Colao R, Suárez-Suárez MA, Fernández-Villán M, González-Sastre V, Murcia-Mazón A. Minimally invasive osteosynthesis in stable trochanteric fractures: A comparative study between Gotfried percutaneous compression plate and Gamma 3 intramedullary nail. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 2009;129:1401-1407.
44. Laufer Y, Lahav M, Lenger R, Sprecher E. Functional recovery following pertrochanteric hip fractures fixated with the Dynamic Hip Screw vs. the Percutaneous Compression Plate. ScientificWorldJournal. 2005;5: 221-229.
45. Peyser A, Weil YA, Brocke L, et al. A prospective, randomised study comparing the percutaneous compression plate and the compression hip screw for the treatment of intertrochanteric fractures of the hip. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 2007;89:1210-1217.
46. Peyser A, Weil Y, Brocke L, Manor O, Mosheiff R, Liebergall M. Percutaneous compression plating versus compression hip screw fixation for the treatment of intertrochanteric hip fractures. Injury. 2005;36: 1343-1349.
47. Knobe M, Münker R, Sellei RM, et al. Unstable pertrochanteric femur fractures. Failure rate, lag screw sliding and outcome with extra-and intramedullary devices (PCCP, DHS and PFN) [in German]. Z Orthop Unfall. 2009;147:306-313.
48. Knobe M, Münker R, Schmidt-Rohlfing B, Sellei RM, Schubert H, Erli HJ. Surgical outcome in pertrochanteric femur fracture: the impact of osteoporosis. Comparison between DHS and percutaneous compression plate [in German]. Z Orthop Unfall. 2008;146:44-51.
49. Brandt SE, Lefever S, Janzing HM, Broos PL, Pilot P, Houben BJ. Percutaneous compression plating (PCCP) versus the dynamic hip screw for pertrochanteric hip fractures: preliminary results. Injury. 2002;33: 413-418.
50. Giancola R, Antonini G, Delle Rose G, Crippa C. Percutaneous compression plating versus gamma nail for the treatment of pertrochanteric hip fractures. Strategies Trauma Limb Reconstr. 2008;3:9-14.
51. Egger M, Smith GD, Phillips AN. Meta-analysis: Principles and procedures. BMJ 1997;315:1533-1537.
52. Egger M, Smith GD. Meta-analysis: Potentials and promise. BMJ 1997;315:1371-1374.
53. Cook DJ, Mulrow CD, Haynes RB. Systematic reviews: Synthesis of best evidence for clinical decisions. Ann Intern Med. 1997;126:376-380.
54. Bero LA, Jadad AR. How consumers and policymakers can use systematic reviews for decision making. Ann Intern Med. 1997;127:37-42.
55. Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG; PRISMA Group. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. J Clin Epidemiol. 2009;62:1006-1012.
56. Coleman BD, Khan KM, Maffulli N, Cook JL, Wark JD. Studies of surgical outcome after patellar tendinopathy: Clinical significance of methodological deficiencies and guidelines for future studies. Victorian Institute of Sport Tendon Study Group. Scand J Med Sci Sports. 2000;10:2-11.
57. Tallon C, Coleman BD, Khan KM, Maffulli N. Outcome of surgery for chronic Achilles tendinopathy. A critical review. Am J Sports Med. 2001;29:315-320.
58. Wright JG, Swiontkowski MF, Heckman JD. Introducing levels of evidence to the journal. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2003;85:1-3.
59. Kosygan KP, Mohan R, Newman RJ. The Gotfried percutaneous compression plate compared with the conventional classic hip screw for the fixation of intertrochanteric fractures of the hip. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 2002;84:19-22.
60. Romero JM, Díaz RA, Oropeza YM. Dynamic hip screw vs. percutaneous compression plate for trochanteric fractures [in Spanish]. Acta Ortop Mex. 2008;22:115-119.
61. Wang YB, Zhou ZM, Zhang HL, Yin XJ, Gu JY, Zhang YQ. Mechanical characteristics of three metal extramedullary implants for elderly intertrochanteric fractures [in Chinese]. J Clin Rehabil Tissue Eng Res. 2010;14:9849-9852.
62. Zhang B, Wu HF, Liu DS, Wang SH, Tao C. Interfixation with percutaneous compression plating in treatment of elderly patients with trochanteric hip fracture: an analysis of clinical outcomes [in Chinese]. Acad J 2nd Mil Med Univ. 2009;30:1437-1439.
63. Zeng W, Liu BL, Gao X, Ma QL, Hu BC, Chen TX. Dynamic hip screw versus percutaneous compression plate in the treatment of intertrochanteric fractures [in Chinese]. Chin J Bone Joint Injury. 2010;25:531-532.
64. Jensen JS, Michaelsen M. Trochanteric femoral fractures treated with McLaughlin osteosynthesis. Acta Orthop Scand. 1975;46:795-803.
65. Marsh JL, Slongo TF, Agel J, et al. Fracture and dislocation classification compendium-2007: Orthopaedic Trauma Association Classification, Database and Outcomes Committee. J Orthop Trauma. 2007; 21(suppl 10):S1-S133.
66. Langford J, Pillai G, Ugliailoro AD, Yang E. Perioperative lateral trochanteric wall fractures: sliding hip screw versus percutaneous compression plate for intertrochanteric hip fractures. J Orthop Trauma. 2011;25:191-195.
67. Leslie WD, Metge CJ, Azimaee M, et al. Direct costs of fractures in Canada and trends 1996-2006: a population-based cost-of-illness analysis. J Bone Miner Res. 2011;26:2419-2429.
68. Egger M, Smith GD, Sterne JA. Uses and abuses of meta-analysis. Clin Med. 2001;1:478-484.
69. Rosenthal R, DiMatteo MR. Meta-analysis: Recent developments in quantitative methods for literature reviews. Annu Rev Psychol. 2001;52: 59-82.