Correlation of wear in vivo and six laboratory wear methods

Dental Materials

Volumn 28, Issue 9, 2012, Pages 961-973

  Heintze, S D ^a   Faouzi, M ^b   Rousson, V ^b   Ozcan M ^c  

^a IVOCLAR VIVADENT AG   (Liechtenstein)

^b UNIVERSITY OF LAUSANNE   (Switzerland)

^c UNIVERSITY OF ZURICH   (Switzerland)

Author keywords

Clinical; Composite; Correlation; Laboratory test method; Wear

Indexed keywords

ALABAMA; CLASS II; CLINICAL; CLINICAL TRIAL; CLINICAL WEAR; COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION; COMPOSITE RESINS; CORRELATION COEFFICIENT; DIRECT USE; FIXED EFFECTS; GENERAL PRACTITIONERS; IN-VIVO; LABORATORY METHODS; LABORATORY TEST; LINEAR MIXED MODELS; LOADING FORCE; MEAN AGES; MEDLINE; NUMBER OF CYCLES; POSTERIOR TEETH; RANDOM EFFECTS; RESIN MATERIALS; RESTORATIVE MATERIALS; TEST PARAMETERS; WEAR MEASUREMENTS;

ABRASION; COMPOSITE MATERIALS; DENTAL PROSTHESES; ENAMELS; LABORATORIES; OPTICAL CORRELATION; RESEARCH; RESINS; RESTORATION; WEAR OF MATERIALS;

MATERIALS;

RESIN;

ADULT; ARTICLE; DENTAL PROCEDURE; DENTAL RESTORATION WEAR; FEMALE; HUMAN; MALE; MATERIALS TESTING; METHODOLOGY; MIDDLE AGED; STATISTICS;

ADULT; COMPOSITE RESINS; DENTAL RESTORATION WEAR; DENTAL STRESS ANALYSIS; FEMALE; HUMANS; MALE; MATERIALS TESTING; MIDDLE AGED; STATISTICS AS TOPIC;

EID: 84864498102     PISSN: 01095641     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.dental.2012.04.006     Document Type: Article

References (62)

1. S.D. Heintze How to qualify and validate wear simulation devices and methods Dental Materials 22 2006 712 734 (Pubitemid 44026526)
2. I. Krejci, T. Reich, F. Lutz, and M. Albertoni In Vitro - Testverfahren zur Evaluation dentaler Restaurationssysteme 1 Computergesteuerter Kausimulator Schweizer Monatsschrift für Zahnmedizin 100 1990 953 960
3. J.R. Condon, and J.L. Ferracane Evaluation of composite wear with a new multi-mode oral wear simulator Dental Materials 12 1996 218 226 (Pubitemid 126667321)
4. K.F. Leinfelder, and S. Suzuki In vitro wear device for determining posterior composite wear Journal of the American Dental Association 130 1999 1347 1353
5. A.J. De Gee, P. Pallav, and C.L. Davidson Effect of abrasion medium on wear of stress-bearing composites and amalgam in vitro Journal of Dental Research 65 1986 654 658 (Pubitemid 16119152)
6. ISO. Dental materials - guidance on testing of wear. Part 2: wear by two-and/or three body contact. Technical Specification. 2001; No. 14569-2.
7. U. Pallesen, and V. Qvist Clinical evaluation of three posterior composite resins: 20-year report Journal of Dental Research 84 2005 (Special Issue B): Abstract No. 145
8. J.L. Ferracane Is the wear of dental composites still a clinical concern? Is there still a need for in vitro wear simulating devices? Dental Materials 22 2006 689 692
9. W.W. Barkmeier, M.A. Latta, R.L. Erickson, and P. Lambrechts Comparison of laboratory and clinical wear rates of resin composites Quintessence International 35 2004 269 274 (Pubitemid 38365630)
10. P. Pallav, C.L. Davidson, and A.J. de Gee Wear rates of composites, an amalgam, and enamel under stress-bearing conditions Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry 59 1988 426 429
11. I. Krejci, and F. Lutz In Vitro - Testverfahren zur Evaluation dentaler Restaurationssysteme Korrelation mit In vivo - Resultaten Schweizer Monatsschrift für Zahnmedizin 100 1990 1445 1449
12. W. Finger, and J. Thiemann Correlation between in vitro and in vivo wear of posterior restorative materials Dental Materials 3 1987 280 286
13. P. Lambrechts, M. Vuylsteke, G. Vanherle, and C.L. Davidson Quantitative in vivo wear of posterior dental restorations: four-year results Journal of Dental Research 62 1985 370 Abstract No. 1759
14. K.J. Söderholm, P. Lambrechts, D. Sarrett, Y. Abe, M.C. Yang, and R. Labella Clinical wear performance of eight experimental dental composites over three years determined by two measuring methods European Journal of Oral Sciences 109 2001 273 281 (Pubitemid 33774030)
15. S.D. Heintze, G. Zappini, and V. Rousson Wear of ten dental restorative materials in five wear simulators - results of a round robin test Dental Materials 21 2005 304 317 (Pubitemid 40583938)
16. R.P. Christensen, G.J. Christensen, and V. Bangerter 3-year in vivo comparison of 7 posterior resins with silver amalgam Journal of Dental Research 66 1987 211 Abstract No. 833
17. R.P. Christensen, G.J. Christensen, and D.K. Hein 2 year clinical performance sumary on 21 direct and indirect Class 2 materials Journal of Dental Research 73 1994 180 Abstract No. 628
18. D.K. Hein, S.L. Smith, C.I. Cordner, and R.P. Christensen 1-year clinical performance of six direct Class 2 resins Journal of Dental Research 74 1995 165 Abstract No. 1225
19. S.L. Smith, D.K. Hein, T.A. Morrow, C.I. Cordner, D.R. Woods, and R.P. Christensen 2-year clinical performance of eight direct Class 2 restorative materials Journal of Dental Research 75 1996 256 Abstract No. 1907
20. S.L. Smith, D.K. Hein, T. Aina, S.H. Woolf, and R.P. Christensen 2-year clinical performance of six direct Class 2 restorative materials Journal of Dental Research 78 1999 309 Abstract No. 1632
21. D.K. Hein, J.M. Tolley, J.S. Wagstaff, and R.P. Christensen 2-year clinical performance of 6 direct Class 2 resins Journal of Dental Research 82 2003 (Special Issue A): Abstract No. 35
22. V. Bangerter, R.P. Christensen, and G.J. Christensen Method for determination of in vivo wear Journal of Dental Research 66 1987 126 Abstract No. 158
23. R. Christensen, and V. Bangerter Apparatus for automated, non-contact measurements of surface changes Journal of Dental Research 69 1990 126 Abstract No. 140
24. J.C. Russ, T.M. Hare, R.P. Christensen, and K.T. Hare SEM low magnification stereoscopic technique for mapping surface contours: application to measurement of volume differences in human teeth due to polishing Journal of Microscopy 144 1986 329 338 (Pubitemid 17229698)
25. J.-F. Roulet Degradation of dental polymers 1987 Karger Basel
26. A.J. De Gee, and P. Pallav Occlusal wear simulation with the ACTA wear machine Journal of Dentistry 22 1994 S21 S27
27. K.F. Leinfelder, R.W. Beaudreau, and R.B. Mazer An in vitro device for predicting clinical wear Quintessence International 20 1989 755 761
28. A. Mehl, W. Gloger, K.H. Kunzelmann, and R. Hickel A new optical 3-D device for the detection of wear Journal of Dental Research 76 1997 1799 1807 (Pubitemid 127732204)
29. K.-H. Kunzelmann Verschleissanalyse und - quantifizierung von Füllungsmaterialien in vivo und in vitro 1998 Shaker Verlag Aachen
30. C. Zantner, A.M. Kielbassa, P. Martus, and K.H. Kunzelmann Sliding wear of 19 commercially available composites and compomers Dental Materials 20 2004 277 285
31. I. Krejci, M. Albertoni, and F. Lutz In vitro - Testverfahren zur Evaluation dentaler Restaurationssysteme. 2. Zahnbürsten-/Zahnpastaabrasion und chemische Degradation Schweizer Monatsschrift für Zahnmedizin 100 1990 1164 1168
32. I. Krejci, T. Reich, W. Bucher, and F. Lutz Eine neue Methode für die dreidimensionale Verschleissmessung Schweizer Monatsschrift für Zahnmedizin 104 1994 160 169
33. R. Hickel, J.F. Roulet, S. Bayne, S.D. Heintze, I.A. Mjör, and M. Peters Recommendations for conducting controlled clinical studies of dental restorative materials (Science Committee Project 2/98 - FDI World Dental Federation) Journal of Adhesive Dentistry 9 Suppl 1 2007 121 147
34. D.F. Taylor, S.C. Bayne, J.R. Sturdevant, and A.D. Wilder Comparison of direct and indirect methods for analyzing wear of posterior composite restorations Dental Materials 5 1989 157 160
35. K.F. Leinfelder, D.F. Taylor, W.W. Barkmeier, and A.J. Goldberg Quantitative wear measurement of posterior composite resins Dental Materials 2 1986 198 201
36. J.P. Moffa, and A.A. Lugassy Calibration of evaluators utilizing the M-L occlusal loss scale Journal of Dental Research 65 1986 302 Abstract No. 1197
37. R.W. Bryant Comparison of three standards for quantifying occlusal loss of composite restorations Dental Materials 6 1990 60 62
38. R. Perry, G. Kugel, K.H. Kunzelmann, H.P. Flessa, and D. Estafan Composite restoration wear analysis: conventional methods vs. three-dimensional laser digitizer Journal of the American Dental Association 131 2000 1472 1477
39. F. Lutz, R.W. Phillips, J.F. Roulet, and J.C. Setcos In vivo and in vitro wear of potential posterior composites Journal of Dental Research 63 1984 914 920
40. C. Meier, and F. Lutz Komposits kontra Amalgam: Vergleichende Verschleissfestigkeitsmessungen in vivo: 1-Jahres-Resultate SSO: Schweizerische Monatsschrift für Zahnheilkunde 89 1979 203 212
41. C.P. Turssi, J.L. Ferracane, and K. Vogel Filler features and their effects on wear and degree of conversion of particulate dental resin composites Biomaterials 26 2005 4932 4937 (Pubitemid 40354225)
42. P. Pallav, A.J. de Gee, A. Werner, and C.L. Davidson Influence of shearing action of food on contact stress and subsequent wear of stress-bearing composites Journal of Dental Research 72 1993 56 61
43. X. Hu, A.C. Shortall, and P.M. Marquis Wear of three dental composites under different testing conditions Journal of Oral Rehabilitation 29 2002 756 764 (Pubitemid 41697872)
44. S. Suzuki Does the wear resistance of packable composite equal that of dental amalgam? Journal of Esthetic and Restorative Dentistry 16 2004 355 365 discussion; 365-7 (Pubitemid 40115732)
45. S. Suzuki, E. Nagai, Y. Taira, and Y. Minesaki In vitro wear of indirect composite restoratives Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry 88 2002 431 436 (Pubitemid 40433844)
46. W.W. Barkmeier, M.A. Latta, R.L. Erickson, T.M. Wilwerding, and B.G. Simister Evaluation of a generalized wear model for composite Journal of Dental Research 81 2002 (Special Issue A): Abstract No. 3844
47. W.W. Barkmeier, M.A. Latta, R.L. Erickson, and T.M. Wilwerding Simulated wear rates of resin composites and clinical relationships Journal of Dental Research 85 Special Issue A 2006 Abstract No. 393
48. S. Suzuki, and K.F. Leinfelder Effect of organic peroxide additives on wear resistance of composite resin Compendium of Continuing Education in Dentistry 18 1997 1006 1011
49. S. Suzuki, A. Kobashigawa, and K.F. Leinfelder In vitro wear of direct and indirect nanhybrid composites Journal of Dental Research 84 Special Issue A 2005 Abstract No. 3089
50. S. Suzuki Simulated enamel wear during occlusal contact American Journal of Dentistry 17 2004 373 377
51. M.A. Latta, W.W. Barkmeier, and C.M. Murdock Localized wear of newer-generation composite resins Journal of Dental Research 82 Special Issue B 2003 Abstract No. 1291
52. S.D. Heintze, A. Cavalleri, M. Forjanic, G. Zellweger, and V. Rousson A comparison of three different methods for the quantification of the in vitro wear of dental materials Dental Materials 22 2006 1051 1062 (Pubitemid 44479793)
53. C. Zantner, A.M. Kielbassa, P. Martus, and K.H. Kunzelmann Wear of aluminum oxide antagonists by commercially available composites and compomers American Journal of Dentistry 17 2004 285 290 (Pubitemid 41310002)
54. J.R. Condon, and J.L. Ferracane Factors effecting dental composite wear in vitro Journal of Biomedical Materials Research 38 1997 303 313 (Pubitemid 27514870)
55. J.L. Ferracane, K.K. Choi, and J.R. Condon In vitro wear of packable dental composites Compendium of Continuing Education in Dentistry. Supplement 1999 S60 S66
56. R.S. Freiberg, and J.L. Ferracane Evaluation of cure, properties and wear resistance of Artglass dental composite American Journal of Dentistry 11 1998 214 218 (Pubitemid 128505205)
57. N.L. Clelland, M.P. Pagnotto, R.E. Kerby, and R.R. Seghi Relative wear of flowable and highly filled composite Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry 93 2005 153 157 (Pubitemid 40170085)
58. N.L. Clelland, S.C. Villarroel, L.A. Knobloch, and R.R. Seghi Simulated oral wear of packable composites Operative Dentistry 28 2003 830 837 (Pubitemid 37456969)
59. G.M. Correr, R.C. Alonso, S. Consani, R.M. Puppin-Rontani, and J.L. Ferracane In vitro wear of primary and permanent enamel. Simultaneous erosion and abrasion American Journal of Dentistry 20 2007 394 399
60. S.D. Heintze, A. Cavalleri, G. Zellweger, and J.L. Ferracane Influence of the antagonist material on the wear of different composites in two different wear simulators Dental Materials 22 2006 166 175 (Pubitemid 43061315)
61. M. Besek, T. Windeler, P.R. Schmidlin, J. Schug, and N.T. Göhring Verschleiss Zahnfarbene adhäsive Füllungen im Seitenzahnbereich 2004 Eigenverlag PPK Zurich p. 221-30
62. T.N. Göhring, M.J. Besek, and P.R. Schmidlin Attritional wear and abrasive surface alterations of composite resin materials in vitro Journal of Dentistry 30 2002 119 127 (Pubitemid 40433452)