Cognitive, collaborative, conceptual and creative - Four characteristics of the next generation of knowledge-based CAD systems: A study in biologically inspired design

CAD Computer Aided Design

Volumn 44, Issue 10, 2012, Pages 879-900

  Goel, Ashok K ^a,b   Vattam, Swaroop ^a   Wiltgen, Bryan ^a   Helms, Michael ^a,b  

^a School of Interactive Computing   (United States)

^b GEORGIA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY   (United States)

Author keywords

AI in design; Biologically inspired design; Biomimcry; Bionics; Collaborative design; Computer aided design; Conceptual design; Creative design; Design cognition; Knowledge based design

Indexed keywords

BIOLOGICALLY INSPIRED DESIGN; BIOMIMCRY; COLLABORATIVE DESIGN; CREATIVE DESIGN; DESIGN COGNITION;

BIOLOGICAL SYSTEMS; BIONICS; COGNITIVE SYSTEMS; CONCEPTUAL DESIGN; KNOWLEDGE BASED SYSTEMS;

COMPUTER AIDED DESIGN;

EID: 84862275281     PISSN: 00104485     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.cad.2011.03.010     Document Type: Article

References (137)

1. M. Stumptner An overview of knowledge-based configuration AI Communications 10 2 1997 111 125
2. Sussman G. Electrical design: a problem for artificial intelligence research. In: Proceedings of the 5th international joint conference on artificial intelligence. IJCAI-77. vol. 2. 1977.
3. D. McDermott Circuit design as problem solving J.C. Latombe, AI and pattern recognition CAD 1978 North-Holland 227 245
4. J. Latombe Artificial intelligence and pattern recognition in CAD, proceedings of the international federation for information processing (IFIP) working conference Grenoble, France, March 17-19 1978 North-Holland Publishing Company Amsterdam (New York)
5. J. McDermott R1: a rule-based configurer of computer systems Artificial Intelligence 19 1 1982 39 88
6. D.C. Brown, and B. Chandrasekaran Design problem solving: knowledge structures and control strategies 1989 Morgan Kaufmann San Mateo (Calif.)
7. S. Mittal, C. Dym, and M. Morjaria PRIDE: an expert system for the design of paper handling systems IEEE Computer 19 7 1986 102 114
8. Steinberg L. Design as refinement plus constraint propagation: the VEXED experience. In: Proc. national conference on AI. AAAI-87. 1987.
9. S. Marcus, J. Stout, and J. McDermott VT: an expert elevator designer that uses knowledge-based backtracking AI Magazine 9 1 1988 95 111
10. J. McDermott R1 (XCON) at age 12: lessons from an elementary school achiever Artificial Intelligence 59 1993 241 248
11. S. Finger, and J. Dixon A review of mechanical engineering design - I Research in Engineering Design 1 1 1989 51 67
12. S. Finger, and J. Dixon A review of mechanical engineering design - II Research in Engineering Design 1 2 1989 121 137
13. Christopher Tong, and Duvvuru Sriram Artificial intelligence in engineering design 1992 Academic Press San Diego (CA, USA)
14. C. Dym Engineering design: a synthesis of views 1994 Cambridge University Press
15. Katz R, Chang E, Bhateja Rajiv. Version modeling concepts for computer-aided design databases. In: Procs. ACM SIGMOD international conference on management of data. 1986. p. 379-86.
16. Eastman C, Bond A, Chase S. A data model for design dabeltabases. In: Proc. first international conference on AI in design. 1991.
17. Ahmed R, Navathe S. Version management of composite objects in CAD databases. In: Procs. ACM SIGMOD international conference on management of data. 1991. p. 218-27.
18. M. Pearce, A. Goel, J. Kolodner, C. Zimring, L. Sentosa, and R. Billington Case-based decision support: a case study in architectural design IEEE Expert 7 5 1992 14 20
19. Goel A, Kolodner J, Pearce M, Billington R, Zimring C. Towards a case-based tool for aiding conceptual design problem solving. In: Proc. third DARPA workshop on case-based reasoning. 1991.
20. M. Huhns, and E. Acosta Argo: a system for design by analogy IEEE Expert, Fall 1988 53 68
21. J. Barber, S. Bhatta, A. Goel, M. Jacobson, M. Pearce, and L. Penberthy AskJef: integration of case-based and multimedia technologies for interface design support J. Gero, Artificial intelligence in design'92 1992 Kluwer Dordrecht 457 474
22. J. Mostow, M. Barley, and T. Weinrich Automated reuse of design plans Artificial Intelligence in Engineering 4 4 1989 181 196
23. P. Pu, and M. Reschberger Assembly sequence planning using case-based reasoning techniques Knowledge-Based Systems 4 3 1991 123 130
24. K. Sycara, R. Guttal, J. Koning, S. Narasimhan, and D. Navinchandra CADET: a case-based synthesis tool for engineering design International Journal of Expert Systems 4 2 1991 157 188
25. K. Hua, B. Faltings, and I. Smith CADRE: case-based geometric design Artificial Intelligence in Engineering 10 2 1996 171 183
26. M. Maher, M. Balachandran, and D. Zhang Case-based reasoning in design 1995 Lawrence Erlbaum
27. D. Navinchandra Case-based reasoning in CYCLOPS, a design problem solver J. Kolodner, Proc. first DARPA workshop on case-based reasoning 1988 Morgan Kauffman 286 301
28. B. Smyth, M. Keane, and P. Cunningham Hierarchical case-based reasoning: integrating case-based and decompositional problem-solving techniques for plant-control software design IEEE Transactions on Knowledge and Data Engineering 13 5 2001 793 812
29. F. Gebhardt, A. Voß, W. Gräther, and B. Schmidt-Belz Reasoning with complex cases 1997 Kluwer Norwell (MA)
30. I. Smith, C. Lottaz, and I. Faltings Spatial composition using cases: IDIOM Lecture notes in computer science vol. 1010 1995 Springer 88 97
31. Goel A, Chandrasekaran B. Integrating case-based and model-based reasoning for design problem solving. In: Proc. AAAI-88 workshop on AI in design. 1988.
32. A. Goel, S. Bhatta, and E. Stroulia Kritik: an early case-based design system M. Maher, P. Pu, Issues and applications of case-based reasoning in design 1997 Erlbaum Mahwah (NJ) 87 132
33. F. Zhao, and M. Maher Using analogical reasoning to design buildings Engineering with Computers 4 1988 107 122
34. M. Maher, and P. Pu Issues and applications of case-based reasoning in design 1997 Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Mahwah (NJ)
35. A. Goel, and S. Craw Design, innovation and case-based reasoning Knowledge Engineering Review 20 3 2005 271 276
36. A. Goel, and S. Bhatta Use of design patterns in analogy-based design Advanced Engineering Informatics 18 2 2004 85 94
37. S. Bhatta, and A. Goel Model-based indexing and index learning in engineering design Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence 9 6 1996 601 610 special issue on Machine Learning in Engineering
38. B. Chandrasekaran Functional representations and causal processes M. Yovits, Advances in Computers 1994 73 143
39. B. Chandrasekaran Functional representation: a brief historical perespective Applied Artificial Intelligence 8 2 1994 173 197
40. J. Gero, K. Tham, and H. Lee Behavior: a link between function and structure in design D. Brown, M. Waldron, H. Yoshikawa, Intelligent computer aided design 1992 North Holland Amsterdam 193 225
41. J. Gero, and U. Kannengiesser The situated function-behavior-structure framework Design Studies 2004
42. Y. Umeda, H. Takeda, T. Tomiyama, and H. Yoshikawa Function, behavior, and structure AIENG'90 applications of AI in engineering 1990 Computational Mechanics Publications and Springer-Verlag Southernpton (Berlin) 177 193
43. Y. Umeda, M. Ishii, M. Yoshioka, Y. Shimomura, and T. Tomiyama Supporting conceptual design based on the function-behavior-state modeler (AI EDAM) Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing 10 44 1996 275 288
44. Y. Umeda, and T. Tomiyama Functional reasoning in design IEEE Expert 12 2 1997 42 48
45. A. Goel, S. Rugaber, and S. Vattam Structure, behavior and function of complex systems: the structure, behavior, function modeling language (AI EDAM) Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing 23 2009 23 35
46. A. Goel, and E. Stroulia Functional device models and model-based diagnosis in adaptive design (AI EDAM) Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing 10 1996 355 370 Special issue on Functional Representation and Reasoning
47. S. Prabhakar, and A. Goel Functional modeling for enabling adaptive design of devices for new environments Artificial Intelligence in Engineering 12 1998 417 444
48. B. Faltings, and K. Sun FAMING: supporting innovative mechanism shape design Computer Aided Design 1995
49. L. Joskowicz, and E. Sacks Computational kinematics Artificial Intelligence 51 1-3 1991
50. L. Joskowicz, E. Sacks, and V. Srinivasan Kinematics tolerance analysis Computer-Aided Design 29 1998
51. M. Gross, and E. Do Drawing on the back of an envelope: a framework for interacting with application programs by freehand drawing Computers & Graphics 24 6 2000 835 849
52. P. Yaner, and A. Goel Visual analogy: viewing retrieval and mapping as constraint satisfaction Journal of Applied Intelligence 25 1 2006 91 105
53. T. Stahovich Artificial intelligence for design E.K. Antonsson, J. Cagan, Formal engineering design synthesis 2001 Cambridge University Press 228 269
54. T. Tomiyama Intelligent computer-aided design systems: past 20 years and future 20 years? (AI EDAM) Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing 21 1 2007 27 29
55. S. Szykman, C. Bochenek, J. Racz, J. Senfaute, and R. Sriram Design repositories: engineering design's new knowledge base IEEE Intelligent Systems 15 3 2000 48 55
56. S. Szykman, R. Sriram, and W. Regli The role of knowledge in next-generation product development systems ASME Transactions, the Journal of Computing and Information Science in Engineering 1 1 2001 3 11
57. Y. Kitamura, T. Sano, K. Namba, and R. Mizoguchi A functional concept ontology and its application to automatic identification of functional structures Advanced Engineering Informatics 2002
58. Y. Kitamura, M. Kashiwase, M. Fuse, and R. Mizoguchi Deployment of an ontological framework for functional design knowledge Advanced Engineering Informatics 18 2 2004
59. Murdock J, Szykman S, Sriram R. An information modeling framework to support design databases and repositories. In: Proc ASME design engineering technical conference. 1997.
60. J. Hirtz, R.B. Stone, D.A. McAdams, S. Szykman, and K.L. Wood A functional basis for engineering design: reconciling and evolving previous efforts Research in Engineering Design 13 2002 65 82 1728-33
61. L. Anthony, W. Regli, J. John, and S. Lombeyda An approach to capturing structure, behavior, and function of artifacts in computer-aided design Journal of Computing and Information Science in Engineering 1 2 2001 186 193
62. T. Stahovich, R. Davis, and H. Shrobe Generating multiple new designs from a sketch Artificial Intelligence 104 1-2 1998 211 264
63. P. Yaner, and A. Goel From design drawings to structural models by compositional analogy (AI EDAM) Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing 22 2 2008 117 128 Special issue on Multimodal Design
64. Jim Davies, Ashok Goel, and Nancy Nersessian A computational model of visual analogies in design Journal of Cognitive Systems Research 10 2009 204 215 special issue on Analogies - Integrating Cognitive Abilities
65. T. Arciszewski, E. Bloedorn, R. Michalski, M. Mustafa, and J. Wnek Machine learning of design rules: methodology and case study Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering, ASCE 8 3 1994 286 308
66. S. Bhatta, and A. Goel Discovery of physical principles from design experiences (AI EDAM) Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing 8 2 1994 113 123 Special issue on Machine Learning in Design
67. S. Sim, and A. Duffy A foundation for machine learning in design (AI EDAM) Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing 12 2 1998 193 209
68. S. Sim, and A. Duffy Evolving a model of learning in design Research in Engineering Design 15 1 2004 40 61
69. T. Stahovich LearnIT: an instance-based approach learning and reusing design strategis Journal of Mechanical Design, ASME 122 2000 149 156
70. N. Cross, H. Christiaans, and K. Dorst Analysing design activity 1996 Wiley Chichester
71. B. Christensen, and C. Schunn The relationship of analogical distance to analogical function and preinventive structure: the case of engineering design Memory and Cognition 35 1 2008 29 38
72. C. Eastman, W. Newstetter, and M. McCracken Design knowing and learning: cognition in design education 2001
73. W. Visser Two functions of analogical reasoning in design: a cognitive-psychology approach Design Studies 17 1996 417 434
74. S. Ahmed, K. Wallace, and L. Blessing Understanding the differences between how novice and experienced designers approach design tasks Research in Engineering Design 14 1 2002 1 11
75. O. Akin, C. Akin, and U. Athavankar Mental imagery as a design tool Cybernetics and Systems 28 1 1996 25 42 1997. Frames of reference in architectural design: analysing the hyperacclamation (A-h-a-!) Design Studies, 17 (4): 341-361
76. N. Bonnardel Towards understanding and supporting creativity: analogies in a constrained cognitive environment Knowledge-Based Systems 2000 505 513
77. H. Casakin, and G. Goldschmidt Expertise and the use of visual analogy: implications for design education Design Studies 20 2 1999 153 175
78. N. Cross The nature and nurture of design ability Design Studies 11 3 1990 127 140
79. J. Gero, and T. McNeil An approach to the analysis of design protocols Design Studies 19 1 1998 21 61
80. V. Goel, and J. Grafman The role of the right prefrontal cortex in ill-structured problem solving Cognitive Neuropsychology 17 5 2000 415 436
81. V. Goel, and P. Pirolli The structure of design problem spaces Cognitive Science 16 1992 395 429
82. G. Goldschmidt On visual design thinking: the vis. kids of architecture Design Studies 15 2 1994 158 174
83. D. Jansson, and S. Smith Design fixation Design Studies 12 1 1991 3 11
84. J. Moss, K. Kotovsky, and J. Cagan Expertise differences in the mental representation of mechanical devices in engineering design Cognitive Science 2005
85. R. Oxman Design by re-representation: a model of visual reasoning in design Design Studies 18 4 1997 329 347
86. J. Shah, N. Vargas-Hernandez, and S. Smith Metrics for measuring ideation effectiveness Design Studies 24 2 2003 111 134
87. S. Smith, T. Ward, and J. Schumacher Constraining effects of examples in creative generation tasks Memory and Cognition 21 6 1993 837 845
88. M. Suwa, T. Purcell, and J. Gero Macroscopic analysis of design processes based on a scheme for coding designers' cognitive actions Design Studies 19 4 1998 455 483
89. M. Suwa, and B. Tversky What do architects and students perceive in their design sketches? A protocol analysis Design Studies 18 4 1997 385 403
90. W. Visser More or less following a plan during design: opportunistic deviations in specification International Journal of Man-Machine Studies 33 3 1990 247 278
91. L. Bucciarelli Designing engineers 1994 MIT Press
92. L. Bucciareilli An ethnographic perespective on engineering design Design Studies 9 3 1988 159 168
93. M. Cutkosky, R. Engelmore, R. Fikes, T. Gruber, M. Genesereth, W. Mark, J. Tenenbaum, and J. Weber PACT: an experiment in integrating concurrent engineering systems IEEE Computer 26 1 1993 28 37
94. E. Edmonds, L. Candy, R. Jones, and B. Soufi Support for collaborative design: agents and emergence Communications of the ACM 37 1994 41 47
95. G. Fischer, J. Grudin, A. Lemke, R. McCall, J. Ostwald, and B. Reeves Supporting indirect collaborative design with integrated knowledge-based design environments Human-Computer Interactions 7 1992 281 314
96. G. Fischer, and J. Ostwald Knowledge management - problems, promises, realities, and challenges IEEE Intelligent Systems 2001 60 72
97. D. Sriram Distributed and integrated collaborative engineering design 2002 Sarven Publishers
98. E. Subrahmanian, I. Monarch, S. Konda, H. Granger, M. Collins, R. Milliken, and A. Westerberg Boundary objects and prototypes at the interfaces of engineering design Computer Supported Cooperative Work (CSCW) 12 2 2003 185 203
99. T. Kvan Collaborative design: what is it? Automation in Construction 9 4 2000 409 415
100. E. McDonough, K. Kahn, and G. Barczak An investigation of the use of global, virtual and colocated new product development teams Journal of Product Innovation Management 18 2 2001
101. G. Pahl, and W. Beitz K. Wallace, Engineering design: a systematic approach 2nd ed. 1996 Springer [English edition]
102. M. French Conceptual design for engineers 3rd ed. 1999 Springer-Verlag
103. S. Sim, and A. Duffy Towards an ontology of generic engineering design activities Research in Engineering Design 2003
104. J. Shah, S. Kulkarni, and N. Vargas-Hernandez Evaluating the effectiveness of idea generation techniques in design: metrics and experimental methodology ASME Transactions, Journal of Mechanical Design 122 4 2000 377 384
105. S. Finger, and J. Dixon A review of research in mechanical engineering design. Part 1: descriptive, prescriptive and computer-based models of design processes. Representations, analysis, and design for the life cycle Research in Engineering Design 1 1989 51 67
106. R. Welch, and J. Dixon Guiding conceptual design through behavioral reasoning Research in Engineering Design 6 1994 169 188
107. S. Gorti, and R. Sriram From symbol to form: a framework for conceptual design Computer Aided Design 23 11 1996 853 870
108. A. Goel Design, analogy, and creativity IEEE Expert 12 3 1997 62 70
109. J. Benyus Biomimicry: innovation inspired by nature 1997 William Morrow New York
110. J. Vincent, and D. Mann Systematic transfer from biology to engineering Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 360 2002 159 173
111. Y. Bar-Cohen Biomimetics: biologically inspired technologies 2006 Taylor & Francis
112. J. Yen, and M. Weissburg Perspectives on biologically inspired design: introduction to the collected contributions Journal of Bioinspiration and Biomimetics 2 2007
113. Srinivasarao M, Padilla L. Biologically inspired design: color on wings. In: Proc. materials research society symposium. Spring. vol. 479. 1997.
114. S. Nakrani, and C. Tovey On honey bees and dynamic server allocation in internet hosting centers Adaptive Behavior 12 2004 223 240
115. R. Bonser, and J. Vincent Technology trajectories, innovation, and the growth of biomimetics Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part C (Journal of Mechanical Engineering Science) 2007 1177 1180
116. M. Helms, S. Vattam, and A. Goel Biologically inspired design: process and products Design Studies 30 5 2009 606 622
117. S. Vattam, M. Helms, and A. Goel A content account of creative analogies in biologically inspired design AI for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing 24 2010 467 481 Special issue on Biologically Inspired Design
118. T. Mak, and L. Shu Using descriptions of biological phenomena for idea generation Research in Engineering Design 19 1 2008 21 28
119. J.S. Linsey, K.L. Wood, and A.B. Markman Modality and representation in analogy (AI EDAM) Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing 22 2008 85 100
120. K. Dunbar How scientists really reason: scientific reasoning in real-world laboratories R.J. Sternberg, J. Davidson, Mechanisms of insight 1995 MIT Press Cambridge (MA) 365 395
121. K. Dunbar The analogical paradox D. Gentner, K.J. Holyoak, B.N. Kokinov, The analogical mind: perspectives from cognitive science 2001 MIT Press
122. C. Kruger, and N. Cross Solution-driven vs. problem-driven design: strategies and outcomes Design Studies 27 5 2006 527 548
123. N.J. Nersessian How do scientists think? capturing the dynamics of conceptual change in science R.N. Giere, Cognitive models of science 1992 University of Minnesota Press Minneapolis (MN) 3 45
124. N.J. Nersessian Model-based reasoning in conceptual change L. Magnani, N.J. Nersessian, P. Thagard, Model-based reasoning in scientific discovery 1999 Kluwer Academic, Plenum Publishers New York 5 22
125. Wills L, Kolodner J. Towards more creative case-based design systems. In: Procs. twelveth national conference of the American association for artificial intelligence. 1994. p. 50-5.
126. L. Wills, and J. Kolodner Explaining serendipitous recognition in design Proc. 16th cognitive science conference 1994 Lawrence Erlbaum 940 945
127. A. Goel, A. Gomez, N. Grue, M. Murdock, M. Recker, and T. Govindaraj Explanatory interface in interactive design environments J. Gero, F. Sudweeks, Proc. fourth international conference on AI in design Palo Alto, June 1996 1996 Kluwer Academic Press Boston (MA) 1 20
128. M. Erden, H. Komoto, T. van Beek, V. D'Amelio, E. Echavarria, and T. Tomiyama A review of function modeling: approaches and applications (AI EDAM) Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing 22 2 2008 147 169
129. Google scholar. http://scholar.google.com.
130. Encyclopedia of life. http://www.eol.org.
131. Web of science. http://wokinfo.com/.
132. Biomimicry Institute. Ask nature - the biomimicty design portal. 2008. http://www.asknature.org.
133. A. Chakrabarti, P. Sarkar, B. Leelavathamma, and B. Nataraju A functional representation for aiding biomimetic and artificial inspiration of new ideas (AI EDAM) Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing 19 2005 113 132
134. P. Sarkar, and A. Chakrabarti The effect of representation of triggers on design outcomes (AI EDAM) Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing 22 02 2008 101 116
135. I. Chiu, and L. Shu Biomimetic design through natural language analysis to facilitate cross-domain analysis (AI EDAM) Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing 21 2007 45 59
136. Shu L, Stone R, McAdams D, Greer J. Integrating function-based and biomimetic design for automatic concept generation. In: Proc. international conference on engineering design. ICED'07. 2007.
137. R. Nagel, P. Midha, A. Tinsley, R. Stone, D. McAdams, and L. Shu Exploring the use of functional models in biomimetic concept design Journal of Mechanical Design, ASME 130 2 2008