The costs of avoiding accidents: Selective compliance and the 'Peltzman effect' in Italy

International Review of Law and Economics

Volumn 32, Issue 2, 2012, Pages 256-270

  Benedettini, Simona ^a   Nicita, Antonio ^b  

^a BOCCONI UNIVERSITY   (Italy)

^b UNIVERSITY OF SIENA   (Italy)

Author keywords

Offsetting behavior; Point record driving license; Seat belts; Traffic fatalities; Traffic law enforcement

Indexed keywords

EID: 84862165817     PISSN: 01448188     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.irle.2012.02.001     Document Type: Article

References (60)

1. Andersson H., Lundborg P. Perception of own death risk. An analysis of road-traffic and overall mortality risks. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 2007, 34:67-84.
2. Arranz J.M., Gil A.I. Traffic accidents, deaths and alcohol consumption. Applied Economics 2009, 41:2583-2595.
3. Angrist J., Pischke J. Mostly harmless econometrics 2009, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
4. Begg D., Langley J. Changes in risky driving behavior from age 21 to 26 years. Journal of Safety Research 2001, 32:491-499.
5. Benedettini, S., & Nicita, A. (2009). Deterrence, Incapacitation and Enforcement Design. Evidence from Traffic Enforcement in Italy. Working paper n. 564. University of Siena. Available at: http://www.econ-pol.unisi.it/quaderni/564.pdf.
6. Bourgeon J.M., Picard P. Point-record driving license and road safety: An economic approach. Journal of Public Economics 2007, 91:235-258.
7. Brons M., Nijkamp P., Pels E., Rietveld P. A meta-analysis of the price elasticity of gasoline demand. A SUR approach. Energy Economics 2008, 30:2105-2122.
8. Calabresi G. The costs of accidents: A legal and economic analysis 1970, Yale University Press, New Haven.
9. Calkins L.N., Zlatoper T.J. The effects of mandatory seat belt laws on motor vehicle fatalities in the United States. Social Science Quarterly 2001, 82:716-732.
10. Campbell B.J. The association between enforcement and seat belt use. Journal of Safety Research 1988, 19:159-163.
11. Carpenter C., Dobkin C. The effect of alcohol consumption on mortality: Regression discontinuity evidence from the minimum drinking age. Applied Economics 2009, 1:164-182.
12. Castillo-Manzano J.I., Castro-Nuño M., Pedregal D.J. An econometric analysis of the effects of the penalty points system driver's license in Spain. Accident Analysis and Prevention 2010, 42:1310-1319.
13. Chen W., Cooper P., Pinili P. Driver accident risk in relation to the penalty point system in British Columbia. Journal of Safety Research 1995, 26:9-18.
14. Chipman M.L., Morgan P. The role of driver demerit points and age in the prediction of motor vehicle collisions. British Journal of Preventive and Social Medicine 1975, 29:190-195.
15. Cohen A., Einav L. The effects of mandatory seat belt laws on driving behavior and traffic fatalities. Review of Economics and Statistics 2003, 85:828-843.
16. Dee T.S. Reconsidering the effects of seat belt laws and their enforcement status. Accident Analysis and Prevention 1998, 30:1-10.
17. Derrig R.A., Segui-Gomez M., Abtahi A., Liu L.L. The effect of population safety belt usage rates on motor vehicle-related fatalities. Accident Analysis and Prevention 2002, 34:101-110.
18. De Paola, M., Scoppa, V., & Falcone, M. (2010). The deterrent effects of penalty point system in driving licenses: A regression discontinuity approach. University of Calabria, Working paper No. 4, pp. 1-20.
19. Diamantopoulou, K., Cameron, M., Dyte, D., & Harrison, W. (1997). The relationship between demerit points accrual and crash involvement. Monash University Accident Research Centre: Report No. 116.
20. Dionne G., Pinquet J., Maurice M., Vanasse C. Incentive mechanisms for safe driving: A comparative analysis with dynamic data. Review of Economics and Statistics 2011, 93(1):218-227.
21. Directorate General for Energy and Transport. (2009). EU energy and transport in figures. Statistical pocketbook 2009. Available at: http://ec.europa.eu/transport/publications/statistics/doc/2009_energy_transport_figures.pdf.
22. Evans N., Graham J.D. Risk reduction or risk compensation? The case of mandatory safety-belt use laws. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 1991, 4:61-73.
23. Farchi S., Chini F., Giorgi Rossi P., Camilloni L., Borgia P., Guasticchi G. Evaluation of the health effects of the new driving penalty point system in the Lazio Region, Italy. Injury Prevention 2007, 31:60-64.
24. Fogarty J. The demand for beer, wine and spirits: A survey of the literature. Journal of Economic Surveys 2009, 23:1-51.
25. Fuller R., Gormley M., Stradling S., Broughton P., Kinnear N., O'Dolan C., Hannigan B. Impact of speed change on estimated journey time: failure of drivers to appreciate relevance of initial speed. Accident Analysis & Prevention 2009, 41:10-14.
26. Garbacz C. Estimating seat belt effectiveness with seat belt usage data from the centers for disease control. Economic Letters 1990, 34:83-88.
27. Garbacz C. More evidence on the effectiveness of seat belt laws. Applied Economics 1992, 24:313-315.
28. Garoupa N. Optimal law enforcement with dissemination of information. European Journal of Law and Economics 2001, 7:183-196.
29. Haque M.O. Evaluation of the demerit point system in deterring traffic offenses. Evaluation Review 1990, 14:22-41.
30. Harre N., Brandt T., Dawe M. The development of risky driving in adolescence. Journal of Safety Research 2000, 31:185-194.
31. Houston D.J., Richardson L.E., Neeley G.W. Legislating traffic safety: A pooled time series analysis. Social Science Quarterly 1995, 76:328-345.
32. Hussain O.T., Nayyar M.S., Brady F.A., Beirne J.C., Stassen L.F.A. Speeding and maxillofacial injuries: Impact of the introduction of penalty points for speeding offences. British Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery 2006, 44:15-19.
33. Italian Institute of Statistics (ISTAT). (2009). Incidenti Stradali. Tavole di dati. Available at: http://www.istat.it/it/archivio/44757.
34. Kirk A., Stamatiadis N. Crash rates and traffic maneuvers of younger drivers. Journal of the Transportation Research Board 2001, 1779:68-74.
35. Lam L.T. Factors associated with young drivers' car crash injury: Comparisons among learner, provisional, and full licensees. Accident Analysis & Prevention 2003, 35:913-920.
36. Lawpoolsri S., Jingyi L., Braver E.R. Do speeding tickets reduce the likelihood of receiving subsequent speeding tickets? A longitudinal study of speeding violators in Maryland. Traffic Injury Prevention 2007, 8:26-34.
37. Masten S.V., Hagge V.A. Evaluation of California's graduated driver licensing program. Journal of Safety Research 2004, 35:523-535.
38. Nyborg K., Telle K. The role of warnings in regulation: Keeping control with less punishment. Journal of Public Economics 2004, 88:2801-2816.
39. Paleti R., Eluru N., Baht C.R. Examining the influence of aggressive driving behavior on driver injury severity in traffic crashes. Accident Analysis & Prevention 2010, 42:1839-1854.
40. Papaioannou, P., Mintsis, G., Taxiltaris, Ch., & Basbas, S. (2002). Enforcement and traffic accidents: recent experience from Greece. Publication at 15th International Co-operation on Theories and Concepts in Traffic Safety Workshop. Brno, Czech Republic.
41. Peer E. Speeding and the time-saving bias: How drivers' estimations of time saved in higher speed affects their choice of speed. Accident Analysis & Prevention 2010, 42:1978-1982.
42. Peltzman S. The effects of automobile safety regulation. Journal of Political Economy 1975, 83:677-725.
43. Poli de Figueiredo L.F., Rasslan S., Bruscagin V., Cruz R., Rocha e Silva M. Increases in fines and driver licence withdrawal have effectively reduced immediate deaths from trauma on Brazilian roads: First-year report on the new traffic code. Injury 2001, 32:91-94.
44. Polinsky A.M., Rubinfeld D.L. A model of optimal fines for repeat offenders. Journal of Public Economics 1991, 46:291-306.
45. Polinsky A.M., Shavell S. On offense history and the theory of deterrence. International Review of Law and Economics 1998, 18:305-324.
46. Redelmeier D.A., Tibshirani R.J., Evans L. Traffic - law enforcement and risk of death from motor - vehicle crashes: case - crossover study. Lancet. 2003, 361:2177-2182.
47. Risa A.E. Adverse incentives from improved technology: Traffic safety regulation in Norway. Southern Economic Journal 1994, 60:844-857.
48. Ruhm C.J. Are recessions good for your health?. Quarterly Journal of Economics 2000, 115:617-650.
49. Sen A. An empirical test of the offset hypothesis. Journal of Law and Economics 2001, 44:481-510.
50. Sen A., Mizzen B. Estimating the impact of seat belt use on traffic fatalities: Empirical evidence from Canada. Canadian Public Policy 2007, 33:315-335.
51. Stuckler D., Basu S., Suhrcke M., Coutts A., McKee M. The public health effect of economic crises and alternative policy responses in Europe: An empirical analysis. Lancet 2009, 374:1-11.
52. Tasca L. A review of the literature on aggressive driving research. Paper presented at the aggressive driving issues conference 2000, Available at:. http://www.aggressive.drivers.com/papers/tasca/tasca-paper.html.
53. Tarko P.A. Modeling drivers' speed selection as a trade-off behavior. Accident Analysis & Prevention 2009, 41:608-616.
54. Tay R. General and specific deterrent effects of traffic enforcement: Do we have to catch offenders to reduce crashes. Journal of Transport Economics and Policy 2005, 39:209-223.
55. Vaa, T. (2000). Effects of police enforcement measures on accidents and levels of injury. Oslo Institute for Economics of Transport: Working paper No. SM/1104/2000.
56. World Health Organization Global status report on road safety: Time for action 2009, World Health Organization, Geneva, Available at:. http://www.who.int/violence_injury_prevention/road_safety_status/2009.
57. Young D.J., Likens T.W. Alcohol regulation and auto fatalities. International Review of Law and Economics 2000, 20:107-126.
58. Zaal, D. (1994). Traffic law enforcement: A literature review. Monash University. Report No. 53.
59. Zambon F., Fedeli U., Milan G., Brocco S., Marchesan M., Cinquetti S. Sustainability of the effects of the demerit points system on seat belt use: A regionwide before-and-after observational study in Italy. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 2008, 61:877-881.
60. Zambon F., Fedeli U., Visentin C., Marchesan M., Avossa F., Brocco S., Spolaore P. Evidence - based policy on road safety: the effect of the demerit points system on seat belt use and health outcomes. Accident Analysis and Prevention 2007, 40:231-237.