How to address the ethics of reproductive travel to developing countries: A comparison of national self-sufficiency and regulated market approaches

Developing World Bioethics

Volumn 12, Issue 1, 2012, Pages 45-54

  Crozier, G K D ^a   Martin, Dominique ^b  

^a LAURENTIAN UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^b UNIVERSITY OF MELBOURNE   (Australia)

Author keywords

Assisted reproductive technologies; Commercial surrogacy; Health care; Justice; Medical tourism; Oocyte donation

Indexed keywords

ADULT; ARTICLE; COMMERCIAL PHENOMENA; COMPARATIVE STUDY; DEVELOPED COUNTRY; DEVELOPING COUNTRY; ETHICS; FEMALE; HEALTH CARE COST; HEALTH CARE DELIVERY; HUMAN; INDIA; INFERTILITY THERAPY; INFORMED CONSENT; INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION; LEGAL ASPECT; MALE; MANAGEMENT; MEDICAL TOURISM; MOTHER; OOCYTE DONATION; POVERTY; SOCIAL JUSTICE; STANDARD; THAILAND; VULNERABLE POPULATION;

ADULT; COMMERCE; DELIVERY OF HEALTH CARE; DEVELOPED COUNTRIES; DEVELOPING COUNTRIES; FEMALE; HEALTH CARE SECTOR; HUMANS; INDIA; INFORMED CONSENT; INTERNATIONALITY; MALE; MEDICAL TOURISM; OOCYTE DONATION; POLICY MAKING; POVERTY; REPRODUCTIVE TECHNIQUES, ASSISTED; SOCIAL JUSTICE; SURROGATE MOTHERS; THAILAND; VULNERABLE POPULATIONS;

EID: 84858645997     PISSN: 14718731     EISSN: 14718847     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1471-8847.2012.00316.x     Document Type: Article

References (58)

1. 'Reproductive travel' includes all forms of international trade in reproductive medical goods and services, including both formal cross-border care arranged by governments and informal care organized by private clinics and practitioners.
2. 2008. Surrogacy $445 Mn Business in India. Economic Times Economic Times. 25 Aug. Available at: [Accessed 11 Jan 2012]. economictimes.indiatimes.com/articleshow/3403841.cms.
3. It remains a matter of some debate whether these measures will substantively protect the interests of surrogates.
4. Iyer, M. 2008. Draft Law Tightens Surrogacy Norms [India]. Times of India 30 Sep. Available at: [Accessed 10 Jan 2011].
5. Qadeer, I. The ART of Making Babies. Indian J Medical Ethics 2010; VII(4): 209-215.
6. Waldby, C. & M. Cooper. The Biopolitics of Reproduction. Australian Feminist Studies 2008; 23(55): 57-73.
7. Whittaker, A. & A. Speier. 'Cycling Overseas': Care, Commodification, and Stratification in Cross-Border Reproductive Travel. Medical Anthropology 2010; 29(4): 363-383.
8. Barnett, A. & H. Smith. Cruel Cost of the Human Egg Trade. The Observer 30 April. Available at: [Accessed on 12 Jan 2012]. 2006.
9. Recent high-profile stories include Lisa Ling's investigation 'Wombs for rent,' which appeared on the Oprah Winfrey Show in September 2007, and Alison Motluck's 'From here to maternity,' a two-part series on the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation Radio's Ideas that originally aired in June 2009.
10. Chung, L.H. Free Trade in Human Reproductive Cells: A Solution to Procreative Tourism and the Unregulated Internet. Minn J Int Law 2006; 15: 265-270.
11. Baum, K. Golden Eggs: Toward the Rational Regulation of Oocyte Donation. BYU L Rev 2001: 107.
12. Storrow, R.F. Quests for Conception: Fertility Tourists, Globalization and Feminist Legal Theory. Hastings Law J 2006; 57: 295-330.
13. Smerdon, U.R. The Baby Market: Crossing Bodies, Crossing Borders: International Surrogacy between the United States and India. Cumb Law Rev 2009; 39: 815-819.
14. Dickenson, D. Commodification of Human Tissue: Implications for Feminist Developmental Ethics. Developing World Bioethics 2002; 2(1): 55-63.
15. Pennings, G. Reproductive Tourism as Moral Pluralism in Motion. J Medical Ethics 2002; 28(6): 337-341.
16. See, for example, the anthropological analysis of Andrea Whittaker and Amy Speier.
17. Amrita Pande 'It May Be Her Eggs But It's My Blood': Surrogates and Everyday Forms of Kinship in India. Qual Sociol 2009; 32: 379-397.
18. Pande, A. Commercial Surrogacy in India: Manufacturing a Perfect Mother-Worker. Signs 2010; 35(4): 969-992.
19. Pande, A. 'At Least I Am Not Sleeping with Anyone': Resisting the Stigma of Commercial Surrogacy in India. Feminist Studies 2010: 36(2): 292-312).
20. 'Why Is Medical Travel of Concern to Global Social Policy?' and the multidisciplinary special edition of Global Social Policy titled (Leng, C.H. & A. Whittaker (Eds.)). Global Social Policy 2010; 10: 287-433.
21. Evidence of recent interest by policy makers include the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology's (ESHRE) creation of a task force on reproductive travel.
22. Pennings, G. et al. ESHRE Task Force on Ethics and Law 15: Cross-Border Reproductive Care. Hum Reprod 2008; 23(10): 2182-2184.
23. the International Federation of Social Worker's 2008 policy on cross-border reproductive services (available at:) [Accessed 12 Jan 2012].
24. WHO's 2009 workshop on 'The Movement of Patients across International Borders,' held in Kobe, Japan.
25. Assisted Human Reproduction Canada's 'First International Forum on Cross-Border Reproductive Care,' held in Ottawa, Canada in 2009.
26. Westhead, R. 2010. Troubling Questions Surround Surrogate-Born Children in India. Star 26 Apr. Available at: [Accessed 12 Jan 2012].
27. Palattiyil, G., et al. Globalization and Cross-Border Reproductive Services: Ethical Implications of Surrogacy in India for Social Work. Int Social Work 2010; 53: 691.
28. Master, Z., et al. The Ethics of Human Embryos and Embryonic Stem Cell Research. J Stem Cells 2008; 3: 127-161.
29. Whittaker, A. 2009. A Socio-Anthropological Perspective on Reproductive Medical Travel and Associated Technologies in the Asia-Pacific. Thematic Paper. Kobe, Japan: WHO Center for Health Development. 30 Nov.
30. Parks, J.A. Care Ethics and the Global Practice of Commercial Surrogacy. Bioethics 2010; 24: 333-340.
31. Blyth, E. Fertility Patients' Experiences of Cross-Border Reproductive Tourism. Fertil Steril 2010; 94: e11-e15.
32. For example, the pursuit of national self-sufficiency in blood has been advocated by the World Health Organization since the 1970s (Keown, J. The Gift of Blood in Europe: An Ethical Defence of EC Directive 89/381. J Med Ethics 1997; 23: 96-100.
33. And is now promoted as goal with respect to human organs for transplantation (World Health Organization. 2008 WHO Guiding Principles on Human Cell, Tissue and Organ Transplantation (Updated Edition). Geneva: World Health Organization; Steering Committee of the Istanbul Summit. Organ Trafficking and Transplant Tourism and Commercialism: The Declaration of Istanbul. Lancet 2008; 372: 5-6.
34. Pennings, G. Gamete Donation in a System of Need-Adjusted Reciprocity. Hum Reprod 2005; 20: 2990-2993.
35. To illustrate, an organ exchange program might, for example, arrange for Patient A's relative to donate a kidney to Patient B in exchange for donation of a kidney from Patient B's relative to Patient A in order to overcome immunological incompatibilities. Gametes might likewise be exchanged to overcome social or genetic barriers to donation by relatives.
36. Pennings, G. Legal Harmonization and Reproductive Tourism in Europe. Hum Reprod 2004; 19: 2689-2694.
37. Hunter, D. & S. Oultram. The Challenge of Sperm Ships: The Need for the Global Regulation of Medical Technology. J Medical Ethics 2008; 34: 552-556.
38. Black, J.J. Egg Donation: Issues & Concerns. MCN Am J Maternal/Child Nurs 2010; 35: 132-137.
39. Terman, S. Marketing Motherhood: Rights and Responsibilities of Egg Donors in Assisted Reproductive Technology Agreements. Northwestern J L Soc Pol 2008; 3: 167-185.
40. Inhorn, M.C. & P. Patrizio. Rethinking Reproductive 'Tourism' as Reproductive 'Exile. Fertil Steril 2009; 92(3): 904-906.
41. Steiner, P. Gifts of Blood and Organs: The Market in 'Fictitious' Commodities. Revue Française de Sociologie 2003; 44: 147-162.
42. Chugh, K.S. & V. Jha. Commerce in Transplantation in Third World Countries. Kidney Int 1996; 49: 1181.
43. Naqvi, S.A., et al. A Socioeconomic Survey of Kidney Vendors in Pakistan. Transpl Int 2007; 20: 934-939.
44. Bailey, A. Reconceiving Surrogacy: Towards a Reproductive Justice Account of Surrogacy Work in India. Hypatia. Published online 9 Feb 2011.
45. Hochschild, A. 2009. Childbirth at the Global Crossroads. American Prospect 5 Oct. Available at: [Accessed 10 Jan 2011].
46. UNICEF (United Nations Children's Fund). 2006. The State of the World's Children Women and Children: The Double Dividend of Gender Equality. New York, NY: UNICEF: 47.2007.
47. Waldby, C. Reproductive Work in Embryonic Stem Cell Research. New Genetics and Society 2008; 27: 19-31.
48. Widdows, H. Border Disputes across Bodies: Exploitation in Trafficking for Prostitution and Egg Sale for Stem Cell Research. Int J Feminist Bioethics 2009; 2: 5-24.
49. Darnovsky, M. 2010. Egg Raffles and Shadow Markets: The Fertility Industry Goes Global - and Skirts Laws. Biopolitical Times. 23 Mar. Available at: [Accessed 10 Jan 2011.
50. Martin, D. Medical Travel and the Sale of Human Biological Materials: Suggestions for Ethical Policy Development. Global Social Policy 2010; 10: 377-395.
51. Matt Zwolinski provides a similar argument regarding low-wage labour. He argues that the moral significance of a sweat-shop labourer's consent need not be undermined by lack of voluntariness, exploitation, or constraints on independence.
52. Zwolinski, M. Sweatshops, Choice, and Exploitation. Bus Ethics Q 2007; 17: 689-727.
53. Bakdash, T. & N. Scheper-Hughes. Is It Ethical for Patients with Renal Disease to Purchase Kidneys from the World's Poor? PLoS Med 2006; 3: e349. Available at: [Accessed 10 Jan 2011].
54. Veatch, R.M. Why Liberals Should Accept Financial Incentives for Organ Procurement. Kennedy Inst Ethic J 2003; 13: 19-36: 32.
55. Anderson, E. 1993. Value in Ethics and Economics. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press: 189.
56. Thompson, J.E.B. Poverty, Development, and Women: Why Should We Care? J Obstet Gynecol Neonatal Nurs 2007; 36: 523-530.
57. Baruah, B. Monitoring Progress towards Gender-Equitable Poverty Alleviation. Progress Development Studies 2009; 9: 171.
58. The ESHRE's code of practice for cross border reproductive care is a move in this direction: Shenfield, F. et al. ESHRE's Good Practice Guide for Cross-Border Reproductive Care for Canters and Practitioners. Hum Reprod; First published online: April 19.2011.