The crushing truth about glass ionomer restoratives: Exposing the standard of the standard

Journal of Dentistry

Volumn 40, Issue 3, 2012, Pages 181-188

  Fleming, Garry J P ^a   Dowling, Adam H ^a   Addison, Owen ^b  

^a DUBLIN DENTAL UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL   (Ireland)

^b UNIVERSITY OF BIRMINGHAM   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Compressive fracture strength; Glass ionomer restorative; ISO 9917 1: 2003; Reliability; Validity

Indexed keywords

CHEMFLEX; FUJI IX GP FAST; GLASS IONOMER; KETAC MOLAR APLICAP; KETAC-MOLAR APLICAP;

ARTICLE; CHEMISTRY; COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH; DENTAL PROCEDURE; HUMAN; HUMIDITY; INSTRUMENTATION; MATERIALS TESTING; MECHANICAL STRESS; OBSERVER VARIATION; REPRODUCIBILITY; STANDARD; TEMPERATURE;

COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH; DENTAL STRESS ANALYSIS; GLASS IONOMER CEMENTS; HUMANS; HUMIDITY; MATERIALS TESTING; OBSERVER VARIATION; REFERENCE STANDARDS; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS; STRESS, MECHANICAL; TEMPERATURE;

EID: 84856915529     PISSN: 03005712     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jdent.2011.12.004     Document Type: Article

References (46)

1. International Organization for Standardization ISO 9917-1 - dentistry - water-based cements. Part 1: powder/liquid acid-base cements 1st ed. 2003
2. A.L. Yettram, K.W. Wright, and H.M. Pickard Finite element stress analysis of the crowns of normal and restored teeth Journal of Dental Research 55 1976 1004 1011
3. S.N. White, and Z. Yu Compressive and diametral tensile strengths of current adhesive luting agents Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry 69 1993 568 572
4. B.W. Darvell Uniaxial compression tests and the validity of indirect tensile strength Journal of Materials Science 25 1990 757 780 (Pubitemid 20657986)
5. C.W. Fairhurst Compressive properties of dental gypsum Journal of Dental Research 39 1960 812 824
6. A.D. Wilson Dental cements-general. Zinc oxide dental cements. Dental cement based on ion-leachable glasses J.A. Von Fraunhofer, Scientific aspects of dental materials 1975 Butterworths London 131 221
7. B. Lawn, and R. Wilshaw Indentation fracture: principles and applications Journal of Materials Science 10 1975 1049 1081
8. B.W. Darvell Mechanical testing B.W. Darvell, Materials science for dentistry 7th ed. 2002 University of Hong Kong Hong Kong 1 35
9. J.F. McCabe, D.C. Watts, H.J. Wilson, and H.V. Worthington An investigation of test-house variability in the mechanical testing of dental materials Journal of Dentistry 18 1990 90 97
10. International Organization for Standardization ISO DP 9917 harmonization of test methods for dental cements 1987
11. W. Yang, and B.W. Darvell Failure behaviour of glass ionomer cement under Hertzian indentation Dental Materials 24 2008 1223 1229
12. W. Yang, and B.W. Darvell Hertzian load-bearing capacity of a ceramic-reinforced glass ionomer cement stored wet and dry Dental Materials 25 2009 952 955
13. G. Iazzetti, J.O. Burgess, and D. Gardiner Selected mechanical properties of fluoride-releasing restorative materials Operative Dentistry 26 2001 21 26
14. K.G. Boberick, J.I. McCool, and G.R. Baran Strength and fatigue of polyacid-modified restorative materials (compomers) Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine 13 2002 613 620 (Pubitemid 34533817)
15. M. Irie, Y. Marou, G. Nishgawa, K. Suzuki, and D.C. Watts Class I gap-formation in highly-viscous glass-ionomer restorations: delayed vs immediate polishing Operative Dentistry 33 2008 196 202
16. N. Frankel, G.J. Pearson, and R. Labella Long-term strength of aesthetic restoratives Journal of Oral Rehabilitation 25 1998 89 93 (Pubitemid 128704904)
17. V.H.W. Khouw-Liu, H.M. Anstice, and G.J. Pearson An in vitro investigation of a poly(vinyl phosphonic acid) based cement with four conventional glass-ionomer cements. Part 1. Flexural strength and fluoride release Journal of Dentistry 27 1999 351 357
18. J.A. Williams, R.W. Billington, and G.J. Pearson The effect of support system on biaxial tensile strength of a glass ionomer cement Dental Materials 18 2002 376 379 (Pubitemid 40072254)
19. A.E. Kaplan, J. Williams, R.W. Billington, M. Braden, and G.J. Pearson Effects of variation in particle size on biaxial flexural strength of two conventional glass-ionomer cements Journal of Oral Rehabilitation 31 2004 373 378 (Pubitemid 38591893)
20. A.H. Dowling, and G.J.P. Fleming Are encapsulated anterior glass-ionomer restoratives better than their hand-mixed equivalents Journal of Dentistry 37 2009 133 140
21. A.H. Dowling, and G.J.P. Fleming Is encapsulation of posterior glass-ionomer restoratives the solution to clinically induced variability introduced on mixing Dental Materials 24 2008 957 966
22. G.J.P. Fleming, A.A. Farooq, and J.E. Barralett The influence of powder/liquid mixing ratio on the performance of a range of glass-ionomer cements Biomaterials 24 2003 4173 4179 (Pubitemid 36809019)
23. G.J.P. Fleming, and D.M. Zala An assessment of encapsulated versus hand-mixed glass ionomer restoratives Operative Dentistry 28 2003 168 177 (Pubitemid 37237471)
24. G.J.P. Fleming, S.M. Kenny, and J.E. Barralet The optimisation of the initial viscosity of an encapsulated glass-ionomer filling material following different mechanical mixing regimes Journal of Dentistry 34 2006 155 163 (Pubitemid 43139013)
25. E.A. Wasson, and J.W. Nicholson Effect of operator skill in determining the physical properties of glass-ionomer cements Clinical Materials 15 1994 169 172 (Pubitemid 24127785)
26. J. Camilleri, F.E. Montesin, A.S. Juszczyk, S. Papaioannou, R.V. Curtis, and F. McDonald The constitution, physical properties and biocompatibility of modified accelerated cement Dental Materials 24 2008 341 350 (Pubitemid 351146668)
27. L.C. Pereira, M.C. Nunes, R.G. Dibb, J.W. Powers, J.F. Roulet, and M.F. Navarro Mechanical properties and bond strength of glass-ionomer cements Journal of Dentistry 4 2002 73 80 (Pubitemid 44146467)
28. S. Deb, P. Shah, B. Vazquez, and J. San Roman A novel acrylic copolymer for a poly(alkenoate) glass-ionomer cement Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine 14 2003 575 581 (Pubitemid 36851208)
29. D. Xie, W.A. Brantley, B.M. Culbertson, and G. Wang Mechanical properties and microstructures of glass-ionomer cements Dental Materials 16 2000 129 138
30. W.A.J. Higgs, P. Lucksanasombool, R.J.E.D. Higgs, and M.V. Swain Comparison of the material properties of PMMA and glass-ionomer based cements for use in orthopaedic surgery Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine 12 2001 453 460 (Pubitemid 32488122)
31. S.A. Mazzaoui, M.F. Burrow, M.J. Tyas, S.G. Dashper, D. Eakens, and E.C. Reynolds Incorporation of casein phosphopeptide-amorphous calcium phosphate into a glass-ionomer cement Journal of Dental Research 82 2003 914 918 (Pubitemid 41756874)
32. E. Bresciani, T.J.E. Barata, T.C. Fagundes, A. Adachi, M.M. Terrin, and M.F.L. Navarro Compression and diametral tensile strength of glass ionomer cements Journal of Applied Oral Science 12 2004 344 348
33. X. Xu, and J.O. Burgess Compressive strength, fluoride release and recharge of fluoride-releasing materials Biomaterials 24 2003 2451 2461 (Pubitemid 36407663)
34. Product specification for Ketac Molar Aplicap (3M ESPE, Seefeld Germany).
35. Product specification for Fuji IXGP Fast Capsule (GC Europe, Leuven, Belgium).
36. Product specification for ChemFlex in Caps (Dentsply DeTrey, Konstanz, Germany).
37. G.J.P. Fleming, P.M. Marquis, and A.C.C. Shortall The influence of clinically induced variability on the distribution of compressive fracture strengths of a hand-mixed zinc phosphate dental cement Dental Materials 15 1999 87 97 (Pubitemid 129586757)
38. G.J.P. Fleming, R.M. Shelton, G. Landini, and P.M. Marquis Encapsulated versus hand-mixed zinc phosphate dental cement Biomaterials 20 1999 2147 2153 (Pubitemid 29488663)
39. C.H. Lloyd, and L. Mitchell The fracture toughness of tooth coloured restorative materials Journal of Oral Rehabilitation 11 1984 257 272 (Pubitemid 14011942)
40. J.R. Kelly Perspectives on strength Dental Materials 11 1995 103 110
41. J.E. Ritter Predicting lifetimes of materials and material structures Dental Materials 11 1995 142 146
42. J.F. McCabe, and T.E. Carrick A statistical approach to the mechanical testing of dental materials Dental Materials 2 1986 139 142
43. O. Addison, P.M. Marquis, and G.J.P. Fleming Resin elasticity and the strengthening of all-ceramic restorations Journal of Dental Research 86 2007 519 523
44. R. Danzer A general strength distribution function for brittle materials Journal of the European Ceramic Society 10 1992 461 472 (Pubitemid 23624765)
45. A.I. Malkin, F.A. Kulikov-Kostyushko, and T.A. Shumikhin Statistical kinetics of quasi-brittle fracture Physical Chemistry 406 2006 33 37 (Pubitemid 43480461)
46. Dowling AH, Fleming GJP, Addison O. Improving the standard of the standard: a new test for consideration? Journal of Dentistry, submitted for publication.