Syntactic processing in the human brain: What we know, what we don't know, and a suggestion for how to proceed

Brain and Language

Volumn 120, Issue 2, 2012, Pages 187-207

  Fedorenko, Evelina ^a   Nieto Castañón, Alfonso ^a   Kanwisher, Nancy ^a  

^a MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY   (United States)

Author keywords

Anatomical variability; FMRI; Functional localization; Functional regions of interest; Functional specificity; Syntactic processing

Indexed keywords

ANALYTIC METHOD; ANATOMICAL VARIATION; ARTICLE; BRAIN FUNCTION; BRAIN REGION; CONTROLLED STUDY; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAM; FUNCTIONAL ANATOMY; HUMAN; HUMAN EXPERIMENT; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; LANGUAGE ABILITY; LANGUAGE PROCESSING; NEUROIMAGING; NEUROPHYSIOLOGY; STEREOTAXIS; STRUCTURE ANALYSIS; TASK PERFORMANCE; WORD RECOGNITION; WORKING MEMORY;

BRAIN; BRAIN MAPPING; FUNCTIONAL LATERALITY; HUMANS; LANGUAGE; LINGUISTICS; NEUROIMAGING;

EID: 84856594319     PISSN: 0093934X     EISSN: 10902155     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.bandl.2011.01.001     Document Type: Article

References (119)

1. Amunts K., Schleicher A., Bürgel U., Mohlberg H., Uylings H.B., Zilles K. Broca's region revisited: Cytoarchitecture and intersubject variability. Journal of Comparative Neurology 1999, 412(2):319-341.
2. Amunts K., Willmes K. From inter-subject variability in clinical syndromes to anatomical variability. Brain and Language 2006, 96(2):147-150. (discussion 157-170).
3. Badre D., D'Esposito M. Is the rostro-caudal axis of the frontal lobe hierarchical?. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 2009, 10:659-669.
4. Badre D., Wagner A.D. Left ventrolateral prefrontal cortex and the cognitive control of memory. Neuropsychologia 2007, 45(13):2883-2901.
5. Bedny, M., Dodell-Feder, D., Pascual-Leone, A., Fedorenko, E., & Saxe, R. (in press). Language processing in the occipital cortex of congenitally blind adults. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.
6. Ben-Shachar M., Hendler T., Kahn I., Ben-Bashat D., Grodzinsky Y. The neural reality of syntactic transformations: Evidence from functional magnetic resonance imaging. Psychological Science 2003, 14(5):433-440.
7. Ben-Shachar M., Palti D., Grodzinsky Y. Neural correlates of syntactic movement: Converging evidence from two fMRI experiments. Neuroimage 2004, 21(4):1320-1336.
8. Binkofski F., Amunts K., Stephan K.M., Posse S., Schormann T., Freund H.J., et al. Broca's region subserves imagery of motion: A combined cytoarchitectonic and fMRI study. Human Brain Mapping 2000, 11(4):273-285.
9. Blumstein S.E. Reflections on the cognitive neuroscience of language. The cognitive neurosciences 2009, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA. IV ed.
10. Blumstein S.E., Myers E.B., Rissman J. The perception of voice onset time: An fMRI investigation of phonetic category structure. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2005, 17(9):1353-1366.
11. Bokde A.L., Tagamets M.A., Friedman R.B., Horwitz B. Functional interactions of the inferior frontal cortex during the processing of words and word-like stimuli. Neuron 2001, 30(2):609-617.
12. Bookheimer S.Y. Functional MRI of language: New approaches to understanding the cortical organization of semantic processing. Annual Review of Neurosciences 2002, 25:151-188.
13. Bornkessel-Schlesewsky I., Friederici A. Neuroimaging studies of sentence and discourse comprehension. The Oxford handbook of psycholinguistics 2007, 407-424. Oxford Univ Press, United Kingdom. G. Gaskell (Ed.).
14. Brodmann, K. (1909). Vergleichende lokalisationslehre der grosshirnrinde in ihren prinzipien dargestellt auf grund des zellenbaues. Barth Leipzig.
15. Buckner R.L., Raichle M.E., Petersen S.E. Dissociation of human prefrontal cortical areas across different speech production tasks and gender groups. Journal of Neurophysiology 1995, 74(5):2163-2173.
16. Burton M.W. The role of inferior frontal cortex in phonological processing. Cognitive Science 2001, 25(5):695-709.
17. Burton M.W. Understanding the role of the prefrontal cortex in phonological processing. Clinical Linguistics & Phonetics 2009, 23(3):180-195.
18. Caplan D. Functional neuroimaging studies of syntactic processing in sentence comprehension: A critical selective review. Language and Linguistics Compass 2007, 1(1-2):32-47.
19. Carpentier A., Pugh K.R., Westerveld M., Studholme C., Skrinjiar O., Thompson J.L., et al. Functional MRI of language processing: Dependence on input modality and temporal lobe epilepsy. Epilepsia 2001, 42(10):1241-1254.
20. Carramazza A., Zurif E. Dissociations of algorithmic and heuristic processes in sentence comprehension: Evidence from aphasia. Brain and Language 1976, 3:572-582.
21. Constable R.T., Pugh K.R., Berroya E., Mencl W.E., Westerveld M., Ni W., et al. Sentence complexity and input modality effects in sentence comprehension: An fMRI study. Neuroimage 2004, 22(1):11-21.
22. Cooke A., Zurif E.B., DeVita C., Alsop D., Koenig P., Detre J., et al. Neural basis for sentence comprehension: Grammatical and short-term memory components. Human Brain Mapping 2002, 15(2):80-94.
23. Costafreda S.G., Fu C.H., Lee L., Everitt B., Brammer M.J., David A.S. A systematic review and quantitative appraisal of fMRI studies of verbal fluency: Role of the left inferior frontal gyrus. Human Brain Mapping 2006, 27(10):799-810.
24. Cutting L.E., Clements A.M., Courtney S., Rimrodt S.L., Schafer J.G., Bisesi J., et al. Differential components of sentence comprehension: Beyond single word reading and memory. Neuroimage 2006, 29(2):429-438.
25. Dapretto M., Bookheimer S.Y. Form and content: Dissociating syntax and semantics in sentence comprehension. Neuron 1999, 24:427-432.
26. Devlin J.T., Matthews P.M., Rushworth M.F. Semantic processing in the left inferior prefrontal cortex: A combined functional magnetic resonance imaging and transcranial magnetic stimulation study. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2003, 15(1):71-84.
27. Duncan J. An adaptive coding model of neural function in prefrontal cortex. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 2001, 2(11):820-829.
28. Duncan J. The multiple-demand (MD) system of the primate brain: Mental programs for intelligent behaviour. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2010, 14(4):172-179.
29. Eickhoff S.B., Paus T., Caspers S., Grosbras M.-H., Evans A., Zilles K., et al. Assignment of functional activations to probabilistic cytoarchitectonic areas revisited. Neuroimage 2007, 36:511-521.
30. Fadiga L., Craighero L., D'Ausilio A. Broca's area in language, action, and music. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 2009, 1169:448-458.
31. Fedorenko E., Kanwisher N. Functionally localizing language-sensitive regions in individual subjects with fMRI: A reply to Grodzinsky's critique of Fedorenko & Kanwisher (2009). Language and Linguistics Compass 2011, 5(2):78-94.
32. Fedorenko E., Hsieh P.-J., Nieto-Castanon A., Whitfield-Gabrieli S., Kanwisher N. A new method for fMRI investigations of language: Defining ROIs functionally in individual subjects. Journal of Neurophysiology 2010, 104:1177-1194.
33. Fedorenko E., Kanwisher N. Neuroimaging of language: Why hasn't a clearer picture emerged?. Language and Linguistics Compass 2009, 3(4):839-865.
34. Fiez J.A. Phonology, semantics, and the role of the left inferior prefrontal cortex. Human Brain Mapping 1997, 5(2):79-83.
35. Fischl B., Rajendran N., Busa E., Augustinack J., Hilds O., Thomas Yeo B.T., et al. Cortical folding patterns and predicting cytoarchitecture. Cerebral Cortex 2008, 18(8):1973-1980.
36. Ford M. A method for obtaining measures of local parsing complexity throughout sentences. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 1983, 22:203-218.
37. Friederici A.D., Fiebach C.J., Schlesewsky M., Bornkessel I.D., von Cramon D.Y. Processing linguistic complexity and grammaticality in the left frontal cortex. Cerebral Cortex 2006, 16(12):1709-1717.
38. Friederici A.D., Kotz S.A. The brain basis of syntactic processes: Functional imaging and lesion studies. Neuroimage 2003, 20:8-17.
39. Friederici A.D., Meyer M., von Cramon D.Y. Auditory language comprehension: An event-related fMRI study on the processing of syntactic and lexical information. Brain and Language 2000, 75(3):289-300.
40. Friederici A.D., Ruschenmeyer S.-A., Hahne A., Fiebach C.J. The role of left inferior frontal and superior temporal cortex in sentence comprehension: Localizing syntactic and semantic processes. Cerebral Cortex 2003, 13:170-177.
41. Friederici A.D., Wang Y., Herrmann C.S., Maess B., Oertel U. Localization of early syntactic processes in frontal and temporal cortical areas: A magnetoencephalographic study. Human Brain Mapping 2000, 11:1-11.
42. Gentner T.Q., Fenn K.M., Margoliash D., Nusbaum H.C. Recursive syntactic pattern learning by songbirds. Nature 2006, 440(7088):1204-1207.
43. Gibson E. Linguistic complexity: Locality of syntactic dependencies. Cognition 1998, 68:1-76.
44. Gordon P., Hendrick R., Johnson M. Memory interference during language processing. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory & Cognition 2001, 27(6):1411-1423.
45. Gough P.M., Nobre A.C., Devlin J.T. Dissociating linguistic processes in the left inferior frontal cortex with transcranial magnetic stimulation. Journal of Neuroscience 2005, 25(35):8010-8016.
46. Graves W.W., Grabowski T.J., Mehta S., Gupta P. The left posterior superior temporal gyrus participates specifically in accessing lexical phonology. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2008, 20(9):1698-1710.
47. Grewe T., Bornkessel I., Zysset S., Wiese R., von Cramon D.Y., Schlesewsky M. The emergence of the unmarked: A new perspective on the language-specific function of Broca's area. Human Brain Mapping 2005, 26(3):178-190.
48. Grodzinsky Y. The picture of the linguistic brain: How sharp can it be? Reply to Fedorenko & Kanwisher. Language and Linguistics Compass 2010, 4(8):605-622.
49. Grodzinsky Y., Friederici A.D. Neuroimaging of syntax and syntactic processing. Current Opinion in Neurobiology 2006, 16(2):240-246.
50. Grodzinsky Y., Santi A. The battle for Broca's region. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2008, 12(12):474-480.
51. Hagoort P., Baggio G., Willems R.M. Semantic unification. The new cognitive neurosciences 2009, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA. IV ed.
52. Hagoort P., Hald L., Bastiaansen M., Petersson K.M. Integration of word meaning and world knowledge in language comprehension. Science 2004, 304(5669):438-441.
53. Hagoort P., Indefrey P., Brown C., Herzog H., Steinmetz H., Seitz R.J. The neural circuitry involved in the reading of German words and pseudowords: A PET study. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 1999, 11(4):383-398.
54. Hasson U., Nusbaum H.C., Small S.L. Repetition suppression for spoken sentences and the effect of task demands. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2006, 18(12):2013-2029.
55. Heim S., Alter K., Ischebeck A.K., Amunts K., Eickhoff S.B., Mohlberg H., et al. The role of the left Brodmann's areas 44 and 45 in reading words and pseudowords. Cognitive Brain Research 2005, 25(3):982-993.
56. Heim S., Eickhoff S.B., Amunts K. Different roles of cytoarchitectonic BA 44 and BA 45 in phonological and semantic verbal fluency as revealed by dynamic causal modelling. Neuroimage 2009, 48(3):616-624.
57. Hein G., Knight R.T. Superior temporal sulcus - it's my area: Or is it?. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2008, 20(12):2125-2136.
58. Hickok G., Okada K., Serences J. Area Spt in the human planum temporale supports sensory-motor interaction for speech processing. Journal of Neurophysiology 2009, 101:2725-2732.
59. Holmes V.M., O'Regan J.K. Eye fixation patterns during the reading of relative-clause sentences. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 1981, 20(4):417-430.
60. Horwitz B., Amunts K., Bhattacharyya R., Patkin D., Jeffries K., Zilles K., et al. Activation of Broca's area during the production of spoken and signed language: A combined cytoarchitectonic mapping and PET analysis. Neuropsychologia 2003, 41(14):1868-1876.
61. Humphries C., Binder J.R., Medler D.A., Liebenthal E. Syntactic and semantic modulation of neural activity during auditory sentence comprehension. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2006, 18(4):665-679.
62. Humphries C., Binder J.R., Medler D.A., Liebenthal E. Time course of semantic processes during sentence comprehension: An fMRI study. Neuroimage 2007, 36(3):924-932.
63. Humphries C., Love T., Swinney D., Hickok G. Response of anterior temporal cortex to syntactic and prosodic manipulations during sentence processing. Human Brain Mapping 2005, 26:128-138.
64. Humphries C., Willard K., Buchsbaum B., Hickok G. Role of anterior temporal cortex in auditory sentence comprehension: An fMRI study. NeuroReport 2001, 12(8):1749-1752.
65. Indefrey P., Brown C.M., Hellwig F., Amunts K., Herzog H., Seitz R.J., et al. A neural correlate of syntactic encoding during speech production. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2001, 98(10):5933-5936.
66. Indefrey P., Levelt W.J.M. The spatial and temporal signatures of word production components. Cognition 2004, 92(1/2):101-104.
67. Iwamura Y., Tanaka M., Sakamoto M., Hikosaka O. Converging patterns of finger representation and complex response properties of neurons in area 1 of the first somatosensory cortex of the conscious monkey. Experimental Brain Research 1983, 51(3):327-337.
68. January D., Trueswell J.C., Thompson-Schill S.L. Co-Localization of stroop and syntactic ambiguity resolution in Broca's area: Implications for the neural basis of sentence processing. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2009, 21(12):2434-2444.
69. Kaan E., Swaab T.Y. The neural circuitry of syntactic comprehension. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2002, 6(8):350-356.
70. Kaminski J., Call J., Fischer J. Word learning in a domestic dog: Evidence for " fast mapping" Science 2004, 304(5677):1682-1683.
71. Kanwisher N. Functional specificity in the human brain: A window into the functional architecture of the mind. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2010, 107(25):11163-11170.
72. Kanwisher N., McDermott J., Chun M.M. The fusiform face area: A module in human extrastriate cortex specialized for face perception. Journal of Neuroscience 1997, 17(11):4302-4311.
73. King J., Just M. Individual differences in syntactic processing: The role of working memory. Journal of Memory and Language 1991, 30:580-602.
74. Kriegeskorte N., Simmons W.K., Bellgowan P.S., Baker C.I. Circular analysis in systems neuroscience: The dangers of double dipping. Nature Neuroscience 2009, 12(5):535-540.
75. Lindenberg R., Fangerau H., Seitz R.J. " Broca's area" as a collective term?. Brain and Language 2007, 102(1):22-29.
76. Matelli M., Luppino G., Rizzolatti G. Architecture of superior and mesial area 6 and the adjacent cingulate cortex in the macaque monkey. Journal of Comparative Neurology 1991, 311(4):445-462.
77. Mazoyer B.M., Tzourio N., Frak V., Syrota A., Murayama N., Levrier O., et al. The cortical representation of speech. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 1993, 5:467-479.
78. Meyer M., Friederici A.D., von Cramon D.Y. Neurocognition of auditory sentence comprehension: Event related fMRI reveals sensitivity to syntactic violations and task demands. Cognitive Brain Research 2000, 9:19-33.
79. Michael E.B., Keller T.A., Carpenter P.A., Just M.A. Fmri investigation of sentence comprehension by eye and by ear: Modality fingerprints on cognitive processes. Human Brain Mapping 2001, 13(4):239-252.
80. Miller E.K., Cohen J.D. An integrative theory of prefrontal cortex function. Annual Review of Neuroscience 2001, 24:167-202.
81. Myers E.B., Blumstein S.E., Walsh E., Eliassen J. Inferior frontal regions underlie the perception of phonetic category invariance. Psychological Science 2009, 20(7):895-903.
82. Neville H.J., Bavelier D., Corina D., Rauschecker J., Karni A., Lalwani A., et al. Cerebral organization for language in deaf and hearing subjects: Biological constraints and effects of experience. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 1998, 95(3):922-929.
83. Noppeney U., Phillips J., Price C. The neural areas that control the retrieval and selection of semantics. Neuropsychologia 2004, 42:1269-1280.
84. Noppeney U., Price C.J. An fMRI study of syntactic adaptation. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2004, 16(4):702-713.
85. Novick J.M., Trueswell J.C., Thompson-Schill S.L. Cognitive control and parsing: Reexamining the role of Broca's area in sentence comprehension. Cognition Affect Behavioral Neuroscience 2005, 5(3):263-281.
86. Olson I.R., Plotzker A., Ezzyat Y. The enigmatic temporal pole: A review of findings on social and emotional processing. Brain 2007, 130(Pt 7):1718-1731.
87. Osterhout L., Allen M., McLaughlin J., Inoue K. Brain potentials elicited by prose-embedded linguistic anomalies. Memory and Cognition 2002, 30(8):1304-1312.
88. Osterhout L., Holcomb P.J. Event-related potentials and syntactic anomaly: Evidence of anomaly detection during the perception of continuous speech. Language and Cognitive Processes 1993, 8:413-438.
89. Ouattara K., Lemasson A., Zuberbühler K. Campbell's monkeys use affixation to alter call meaning. Plos One 2009, 4(11):e7808.
90. Parzen E. On estimation of a probability density function and mode. The Annals of Mathematical Statistics 1962, 33(3):1065-1076.
91. Patterson K., Nestor P.J., Rogers T.T. Where do you know what you know? The representation of semantic knowledge in the human brain. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 2007, 8(12):976-987.
92. Pepperberg I. The Alex studies: Cognitive and communicative abilities of grey parrots 2000, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
93. Petersen S.E., Fox P.T., Snyder A.Z., Raichle M.E. Activation of extrastriate and frontal cortical areas by visual words and word-like stimuli. Science 1990, 249(4972):1041-1044.
94. Plante E., Creusere M., Sabin C. Dissociating sentential prosody from sentence processing: Activation interacts with task demands. Neuroimage 2002, 17:401-410.
95. Poldrack R.A. Can cognitive processes be inferred from neuroimaging data?. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2006, 10(2):59-63.
96. Poldrack R.A., Wagner A.D., Prull M.W., Desmond J.E., Glover G.H., Gabrieli J.D. Functional specialization for semantic and phonological processing in the left inferior prefrontal cortex. Neuroimage 1999, 10(1):15-35.
97. Rademacher J., Morosan P., Schormann T., Schleicher A., Werner C., Freund H.J., et al. Probabilistic mapping and volume measurement of human primary auditory cortex. Neuroimage 2001, 13:669-683.
98. Rodd J.M., Davis M.H., Johnsrude I.S. The neural mechanisms of speech comprehension: fMRI studies of semantic ambiguity. Cerebral Cortex 2005, 15(8):1261-1269.
99. Rogalsky C., Hickok G. Selective attention to semantic and syntactic features modulates sentence processing networks in anterior temporal cortex. Cerebral Cortex 2009, 19:786-796.
100. Rozzi S., Ferrari P.F., Bonini L., Rizzolatti G., Fogassi L. Functional organization of inferior parietal lobule convexity in the macaque monkey: Electrophysiological characterization of motor, sensory and mirror responses and their correlation with cytoarchitectonic areas. European Journal of Neuroscience 2008, 28(8):1569-1588.
101. Santi A., Grodzinsky Y. Working memory and syntax interact in Broca's area. Neuroimage 2007, 37(1):8-17.
102. Savage-Rumbaugh E.S., Murphy J., Sevcik R.A., Brakke K.E., Williams S.L., Rumbaugh D.M., et al. Language comprehension in ape and child. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development 1993, 101:252.
103. Saxe R., Brett M., Kanwisher N. Divide and conquer: A defense of functional localizers. Neuroimage 2006, 30(4):1088-1096. (discussion 1097-1099)_.
104. Saxe R., Kanwisher N. People thinking about thinking people. The role of the temporo-parietal junction in " theory of mind" Neuroimage 2003, 19(4):1835-1842.
105. Schlesewsky M., Bornkessel I. On incremental interpretation: Degrees of meaning accessed during sentence comprehension. Lingua 2004, 114(9-10):1213-1234.
106. Schnur T.T., Schwartz M.F., Kimberg D.Y., Hirshorn E., Coslett H.B., Thompson-Schill S.L. Localizing interference during naming: Convergent neuroimaging and neuropsychological evidence for the function of Broca's area. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2009, 106(1):322-327.
107. Schormann T., Zilles K. Three-dimensional linear and nonlinear transformations: An integration of light microscopical and MRI data. Human Brain Mapping 1998, 6(5-6):339-347.
108. Snyder H.R., Feigenson K., Thompson-Schill S.L. Prefrontal cortical response to conflict during semantic and phonological tasks. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2007, 19(5):761-775.
109. Stromswold K., Caplan D., Alpert N., Rauch S. Localization of syntactic comprehension by positron emission tomography. Brain and Language 1996, 52:452-473.
110. Thompson-Schill S.L. Dissecting the language organ: A new look at the role of Broca's area in language processing. Twenty-First Century Psycholinguistics: Four Cornerstones 2005, 173-189.
111. Tootell R.B.H., Reppas J.B., Dale A.M., Look R.B., Sereno M.I., Brady T.J., et al. Functional MRI evidence for a visual motion after effect in human cortical area MT/V5. Nature 1995, 375:139-141.
112. Vandenberghe R., Nobre A.C., Price C.J. The response of left temporal cortex to sentences. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2002, 14(4):550-560.
113. Vigneau M., Beaucousin V., Hervé P.Y., Duffau H., Crivello F., Houdé O., et al. Meta-analyzing left hemisphere language areas: Phonology, semantics, and sentence processing. Neuroimage 2006, 30(4):1414-1432.
114. Vul, E., & Kanwisher, N. (2009). Begging the question: The non-independence error in fMRI data analysis. In S. Hanson & M. Bunzl (Eds.), Foundations and Philosophy for Neuroimaging (pp.71-91).
115. Westbury C., Zatorre R.J., Evans A.C. Quantifying variability in the planum temporale: A probability map. Cerebral Cortex 1999, 9:392-405.
116. Willems R.M., Hagoort P. Broca's region: Battles are not won by ignoring half of the facts. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2009, 13(3):101. (author reply 102).
117. Wright P., Randall B., Marslen-Wilson W.D., Tyler L. Dissociating linguistic and task-related activity in the left inferior frontal gyrus. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2010, 23(2):404-413.
118. Zilles K., Schleicher A., Langemann C., Amunts K., Morosan P., Palomero-Gallagher N., et al. Quantitative analysis of sulci in the human cerebral cortex: Development, regional heterogeneity, gender difference, asymmetry, intersubject variability and cortical architecture. Human Brain Mapping 1997, 5(4):218-221.
119. Zilles K., Schleicher A., Palomero-Gallagher N., Amunts K. Quantitative analysis of cyto- and receptor architecture of the human brain. Brain Mapping: The Methods 2002, 2.