Printability of calcium phosphate powders for three-dimensional printing of tissue engineering scaffolds

Acta Biomaterialia

Volumn 8, Issue 1, 2012, Pages 373-385

  Butscher, Andre ^a,b   Bohner, Marc ^a   Roth, Christian ^b   Ernstberger, Annika ^a   Heuberger, Roman ^a   Doebelin, Nicola ^a   Rudolf Von Rohr, Philipp ^b   Müller, Ralph ^b  

^a RMS Foundation   (Switzerland)

^b ETH ZURICH   (Switzerland)

Author keywords

Calcium phosphates (CaP); Powder flowability; Powder wettability; Three dimensional printing (3DP); Tissue engineering

Indexed keywords

3D PRINTERS; CALCIUM PHOSPHATE; COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH; PARTICLE SIZE; SCAFFOLDS (BIOLOGY); SURFACE ROUGHNESS; TISSUE;

CALCIUM PHOSPHATE; FLOWABILITY; POWDER BED; POWDER FLOWABILITY; POWDER PROPERTIES; POWDER WETTABILITY; THREE-DIMENSIONAL PRINTING (3DP); THREE-DIMENSIONAL-PRINTING; TISSUES ENGINEERINGS;

WETTING;

CALCIUM PHOSPHATE; TISSUE SCAFFOLD;

ACCURACY; ARTICLE; PARTICLE SIZE; POWDER; PRIORITY JOURNAL; QUALITY CONTROL; TISSUE ENGINEERING; WETTABILITY;

EID: 84855956567     PISSN: 17427061     EISSN: 18787568     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.actbio.2011.08.027     Document Type: Article

References (73)

1. S.J. Hollister Porous scaffold design for tissue engineering Nat Mater 4 7 2005 518 524 (Pubitemid 40952745)
2. R. Langer, and J.P. Vacanti Tissue engineering Science 260 5110 1993 920 926 (Pubitemid 23209960)
3. B.R. Constantz, I.C. Ison, M.T. Fulmer, R.D. Poser, S.T. Smith, and M. VanWagoner Skeletal repair by in situ formation of the mineral phase of bone Science 267 5205 1995 1796 1799
4. S.V. Dorozhkin, and M. Epple Biological and medical significance of calcium phosphates Angew Chem Int Ed 41 17 2002 3130 3146 (Pubitemid 35021275)
5. W. Renooij, H.A. Hoogendoorn, W.J. Visser, R.H.F. Lentferink, M.G.J. Schmitz, and H. Vanieperen Bioresorption of ceramic strontium-85-labeled calcium-phosphate implants in dog femora - a pilot-study to quantitate bioresorption of ceramic implants of hydroxyapatite and tricalcium ortho-phosphate invivo Clin Orthop Rel Res 197 1985 272 285 (Pubitemid 15018942)
6. D.W. Hutmacher Scaffolds in tissue engineering bone and cartilage Biomaterials 21 24 2000 2529 2543
7. A. Butscher, M. Bohner, S. Hofmann, L. Gauckler, and R. Muller Structural and material approaches to bone tissue engineering in powder-based three-dimensional printing Acta Biomater 7 3 2011 907 920
8. A.K. Maier, L. Dezmirean, J. Will, and P. Greil Three-dimensional printing of flash-setting calcium aluminate cement J Mater Sci 46 9 2011 2947 2954
9. Y. Shanjani, J.N.A. De Croos, R.M. Pilliar, R.A. Kandel, and E. Toyserkani Solid freeform fabrication and characterization of porous calcium polyphosphate structures for tissue engineering purposes J Biomed Mater Res Part B 93B 2 2010 510 519
10. U. Klammert, T. Reuther, C. Jahn, B. Kraski, A.C. Kubler, and U. Gbureck Cytocompatibility of brushite and monetite cell culture scaffolds made by three-dimensional powder printing Acta Biomater 5 2 2009 727 734
11. P.H. Warnke, H. Seitz, F. Warnke, S.T. Becker, S. Sivananthan, and E. Sherry Ceramic scaffolds produced by computer-assisted 3D printing and sintering: characterization and biocompatibility investigations J Biomed Mater Res Part B 93B 1 2010 212 217
12. C.B. Williams, J.K. Cochran, and D.W. Rosen Additive manufacturing of metallic cellular materials via three-dimensional printing Int J Adv Manuf Technol 53 1-4 2011 231 239
13. W.Y. Yeong, C.K. Chua, K.F. Leong, and M. Chandrasekaran Rapid prototyping in tissue engineering: challenges and potential Trends Biotechnol 22 12 2004 643 652 (Pubitemid 39473215)
14. A. Khalyfa, S. Vogt, J. Weisser, G. Grimm, A. Rechtenbach, and W. Meyer Development of a new calcium phosphate powder-binder system for the 3D printing of patient specific implants J Mater Sci Mater Med 18 5 2007 909 916 (Pubitemid 46764024)
15. Peters F, Haenel T, Bernhardt A, Lode A, Gelinsky M, Duerr H. In vitro examination of 3D printed vs. milled scaffolds from beta-tricalcium phosphate (beta-TCP) for patient individual bone regeneration. 8th World Biomaterials Congress, Amsterdam; 2008.
16. J. Will, R. Melcher, C. Treul, N. Travitzky, U. Kneser, and E. Polykandriotis Porous ceramic bone scaffolds for vascularized bone tissue regeneration J Mater Sci - Mater Med 19 8 2008 2781 2790
17. B. Leukers, H. Gulkan, S.H. Irsen, S. Milz, C. Tille, and M. Schieker Hydroxyapatite scaffolds for bone tissue engineering made by 3D printing J Mater Sci Mater Med 16 12 2005 1121 1124 (Pubitemid 41803736)
18. V. Karageorgiou, and D. Kaplan Porosity of 3D biomaterial scaffolds and osteogenesis Biomaterials 26 27 2005 5474 5491 (Pubitemid 40592136)
19. Vacanti JP, Cima LG, Cima MJ. Vascularized tissue regeneration matrices formed by solid free form fabrication techniques. U.S. Patent No. 6,176,874 B1; 2001.
20. E. Sachs, M. Cima, P. Williams, D. Brancazio, and J. Cornie 3-Dimensional printing - rapid tooling and prototypes directly from a CAD model J Eng Ind - Trans ASME 114 4 1992 481 488 (Pubitemid 23581969)
21. I. Holme Advances in the science and technology of paints, inks and related coatings Surf Coat Int Part B - Coat Trans 89 4 2006 343 363
22. S.B. Rane, T. Seth, G.J. Phatak, D.P. Amalnerkar, and B.K. Das Influence of surfactants treatment on silver powder and its thick films Mater Lett 57 20 2003 3096 3100
23. J.C. Lin, and C.Y. Wang Effects of surfactant treatment of silver powder on the rheology of its thick-film paste Mater Chem Phys 45 2 1996 136 144 (Pubitemid 126359131)
24. S. Hogekamp, and M. Pohl Methods for characterizing wetting and dispersing of powder Chem Ing Tech 76 4 2004 385 390
25. M. Lanzetta, and E. Sachs Improved surface finish in 3D printing using bimodal powder distribution Rapid Prototyping J 9 3 2003 157 166
26. M. Bohner, R. Luginbuhl, C. Reber, N. Doebelin, G. Baroud, and E. Conforto A physical approach to modify the hydraulic reactivity of alpha-tricalcium phosphate powder Acta Biomater 5 9 2009 3524 3535
27. Spillmann A, Sonnenfeld A, Rudolf von Rohr P. Method for the attachment of nanoparticles to substrate particles. International Patent No. WO/2007/036060; 2007.
28. A. Spillmann, A. Sonnenfeld, and P.R. von Rohr Effect of surface free energy on the flowability of lactose powder treated by PECVD Plasma Process Polym 5 8 2008 753 758
29. A. Sonnenfeld, A. Spillmann, C. Arpagaus, and P.R. von Rohr Application of plasma surface treatment to solid-state microscopic particulates Plasma Process Polym 6 3 2009 170 179
30. x structures deposited on fine powders by short plasma exposure in a plasma down stream reactor Appl Surf Sci 255 5 2008 1911 1915
31. A. Spillmann Flowability modification of lactose powder by plasma enhanced chemical vapor deposition Plasma Process Polym 4 2007 S16 S20
32. Beamson G, Briggs D. High resolution XPS of organic polymers. Chichester: Wiley; 1992.
33. D.A. Shirley High-resolution X-ray photoemission spectrum of valence bands of gold Phys Rev B 5 12 1972 4709
34. J. Rodriguez-Carvajal Recent developments of the program FULLPROF. Commission on powder diffraction (IUCr) Newsletter 26 2001 12 19
35. 2 J Solid State Chem 10 1974 232 248
36. K. Sudarsanan, and R.A. Young Significant precision in crystal structure details: holly springs hydroxyapatite Acta Crystallogr B25 1969 1534 1543
37. 7 structure Acta Crystallogr C 49 12 1993 2062 2064
38. 2 Acta Crystallogr Sect B - Struct Sci 33 13 1977 1325 1333
39. J.I. Langford, and A.J.C. Wilson Scherrer after 60 years - survey and some new results in determination of crystallite size J Appl Crystallogr 11 1978 102 113
40. DIN EN 725-8. Advanced technical ceramics - methods of test for ceramic powders - part 8: determination of tapped bulk density; 2006. http://www.beuth.de/langanzeige/DIN-EN-725-8/de/88828024.html&bcrumblevel= 4&SearchID=282576440.
41. DIN EN 725-9. Advanced technical ceramics - methods of test for ceramic powders - part 9: determination of untapped bulk density; 2006. http://www.beuth.de/langanzeige/DIN-EN-725-9/de/88827999.html&bcrumblevel= 3&SearchID=282577090.
42. D. Schulze, and A. Wittmaier Flow properties of highly dispersed powders at very small consolidation stresses Chem Eng Technol 26 2 2003 133 137 (Pubitemid 36333648)
43. D. Schulze Flowability of bulk solids - definition and measuring principles Chem Ing Tech 67 1 1995 60 68
44. Lazghab M, Saleh K, Pezron I, Guigon P, Komunjer L. Wettability assessment of finely divided solids. In: 4th French meeting on powder science and technology, Compiegne, France; 2004. p. 79-91. (Pubitemid 41435519)
45. C. Arpagaus Plasma surface modification of polymer powders in a downer reactor 2005 Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich
46. E.W. Washburn The dynamics of capillary flow Phys Rev 17 3 1921 273 283
47. K. Grundke, M. Boerner, and H.J. Jacobasch Characterization of fillers and fibers by wetting and electrokinetic measurements Colloids Surf 58 1-2 1991 47 59
48. U. Gbureck, T. Hoelzel, I. Biermann, J.E. Barralet, and L.M. Grover Preparation of tricalcium phosphate/calcium pyrophosphate structures via rapid prototyping J Mater Sci - Mater Med 19 4 2008 1559 1563
49. Melcher R. Rapid prototyping von Keramiken durch 3D-Drucken. PhD thesis. Erlangen, Germany: Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg; 2009.
50. J.F. Moulder, W.F. Stickle, P.E. Sobol, and K.D. Bomben Handbook of X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy 1995 Physical Electronics Eden Prairie, MN
51. L. Korner, A. Sonnenfeld, R. Heuberger, J.H. Waller, Y. Leterrier, and J.A.E. Manson Oxygen permeation, mechanical and structural properties of multilayer diffusion barrier coatings on polypropylene J Phys D-Appl Phys 43 2010 (11)
52. M. Nebelung, and B. Lang Flowability of ceramic bulk materials part 2: interaction of primary particle properties and flowability CFI - Ceram For Int 86 4 2009 E35 E38
53. M. Nebelung, and B. Lang Flowability of ceramic bulk materials part 1: methods CFI - Ceram For Int 86 3 2009 E35 E40
54. Schulze D. Pulver und Schüttgüter, Fließeigenschaften und Handhabung. Berlin/Heidelberg: Springer; 2009.
55. C. Roth, Z. Kuensch, A. Sonnenfeld, and P.R. von Rohr Plasma surface modification of powders for pharmaceutical applications Surf Coat Technol 205 2011 597 600
56. I. Zimmermann, M. Eber, and K. Meyer Nanomaterials as flow regulators in dry powders Z Phys Chem - Int J Res Phys Chem Chem Phys 218 1 2004 51 102 (Pubitemid 38270960)
57. A. Kwade, A. Schulze, and J. Schwedes Auslegung von Silos: Unmittelbare Messung des Horizontallastverhältnisses Beton-und Stahlbetonbau 89 1994 58 63 117-119
58. ISO 6186. Plastics - determination of pourability. http://www.iso.org/ iso/iso-catalogue/catalogue-tc/catalogue-detail.htm?csnumber=25202.
59. ISO 4324. Surface active agents - powders and granules - measurement of the angle of repose. http://www.iso.org/iso/iso-catalogue/catalogue-tc/ catalogue-detail.htm?csnumber=10196.
60. Shanjani Y, Toyserkani E, Wei C, ASME. Modeling and characterization of biomaterials spreading properties in powder-based rapid prototyping techniques. In: ASME international mechanical engineering congress and exposition, Seattle, WA; 2007. p. 135-43. (Pubitemid 351725382)
61. B.R. Utela, D. Storti, R.L. Anderson, and M. Ganter Development process for custom three-dimensional printing (3DP) material systems J Manuf Sci Eng - Trans ASME 132 1 2010 9
62. A. Curodeau, E. Sachs, and S. Caldarise Design and fabrication of cast orthopedic implants with freeform surface textures from 3-D printed ceramic shell J Biomed Mater Res 53 5 2000 525 535
63. Cima M, Sachs EM, Fan T, Bredt JF, Michaels SP, Khanuja S, et al. Three-Dimensional Printing Techniques. U.S. Patent No. 5,387,380; 1995.
64. S. Palzer, C. Hiebl, K. Sommer, and H. Lechner Influence of roughness of a solid surface on the angle of contact Chem Ing Tech 73 8 2001 1032 1038
65. D.M. Spori, T. Drobek, S. Zurcher, M. Ochsner, C. Sprecher, and A. Muehlebach Beyond the lotus effect: Roughness, influences on wetting over a wide surface-energy range Langmuir 24 10 2008 5411 5417
66. T. Fan Droplet-powder impact interaction in three dimensional printing 1995 Massachusetts Institute of Technology Cambridge, MA
67. E.E.A. Sachs Three dimensional printing: the physics and implications of additive manufacturing CIRP Ann 42 1993 257 260
68. C.L. Camire, P. Nevsten, L. Lidgren, and I. McCarthy The effect of crystallinity on strength development of alpha-TCP bone substitutes J Biomed Mater Res Part B 79B 1 2006 159 165 (Pubitemid 44478867)
69. K. Igawa, M. Mochizuki, O. Sugimori, K. Shimizu, K. Yamazawa, and H. Kawaguchi Tailor-made tricalcium phosphate bone implant directly fabricated by a three-dimensional ink-jet printer J Artif Organs 9 4 2006 234 240 (Pubitemid 44954313)
70. H. Saijo, K. Igawa, Y. Kanno, Y. Mori, K. Kondo, and K. Shimizu Maxillofacial reconstruction using custom-made artificial bones fabricated by inkjet printing technology J Artif Organs 12 3 2009 200 205
71. H. Seitz, U. Deisinger, B. Leukers, R. Detsch, and G. Ziegler Different calcium phosphate granules for 3-D printing of bone tissue engineering scaffolds Adv Eng Mater 11 5 2009 B41 B46
72. Sharif H, Shanjani Y, Vlasea M, Toyserkani E, ASME. On the bio-mechanical properties of a dual-porous osteochondral scaffold. In: ASME international mechanical engineering congress and exposition, Am Soc Mech Eng, Boston, MA; 2008. p. 17-24.
73. Y. Shanjani, and E. Toyserkani On mechanical properties of SFF-made calcium polyphosphate bio-structures 2010 CRC Press, Taylor & Francis Group Boca Raton