Is High Resolution Melting Analysis (HRMA) accurate for detection of human disease-associated mutations? A meta analysis

PLoS ONE

Volumn 6, Issue 12, 2011, Pages

  Li, Bing Sheng ^a,b   Wang, Xin Ying ^a,b   Ma, Feng Li ^a,b   Jiang, Bo ^a,b   Song, Xiao Xiao ^c   Xu, An Gao ^d  

^a SOUTHERN MEDICAL UNIVERSITY   (China)

^b Guangdong Provincial Key Laboratory of Gastroenterology   (China)

^c KUNMING MEDICAL UNIVERSITY   (China)

^d Huizhou First Hospital   (China)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CONFIDENCE INTERVAL; DIAGNOSTIC ACCURACY; DISEASE ASSOCIATION; DNA SEQUENCE; GENE MUTATION; HIGH RESOLUTION MELTING ANALYSIS; HUMAN; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; META ANALYSIS; MUTATIONAL ANALYSIS; NONHUMAN; REGRESSION ANALYSIS; SAMPLE SIZE; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; DISEASES; DNA DENATURATION; GENETICS; METHODOLOGY; MULTIVARIATE ANALYSIS; MUTATION; NUCLEOTIDE SEQUENCE; RISK; STATISTICAL MODEL;

DISEASE; DNA MUTATIONAL ANALYSIS; HUMANS; LIKELIHOOD FUNCTIONS; MULTIVARIATE ANALYSIS; MUTATION; NUCLEIC ACID DENATURATION; ODDS RATIO; REGRESSION ANALYSIS;

EID: 83355176473     PISSN: None     EISSN: 19326203     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0028078     Document Type: Article

References (83)

1. Ahmadian A, Gharizadeh B, Gustafsson AC, Sterky F, Nyren P, et al. (2000) S ingle-nucleotide polymorphism analysis by pyrosequencing. Anal Biochem 280 (1): 103-110.
2. Orita M, Iwahana H, Kanazawa H, Hayashi K, Sekiya T, (1989) Detection of polymorphisms of human DNA by gel electrophoresis as single-strand conformation polymorphisms. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 86 (8): 2766-2770.
3. Lerman LS, Silverstein K, (1987) Computational simulation of DNA melting and its application to denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis. Methods Enzymol 155: 482-501.
4. Xiao W, Oefner PJ, (2001) Denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography: A review. Hum Mutat 17 (6): 439-474.
5. Li Q, Liu Z, Monroe H, Culiat CT, (2002) Integrated platform for detection of DNA sequence variants using capillary array electrophoresis. Electrophoresis 23 (10): 1499-1511.
6. Bocker S, (2007) Simulating multiplexed SNP discovery rates using base-specific cleavage and mass spectrometry. Bioinformatics 23 (2): e5-12.
7. Wittwer CT, Herrmann MG, Gundry CN, Elenitoba-Johnson KS, (2001) Real-time multiplex PCR assays. Methods 25 (4): 430-442.
8. Wittwer CT, Herrmann MG, Moss AA, Rasmussen RP, (1997) Continuous fluorescence monitoring of rapid cycle DNA amplification. Biotechniques 22 (1): 130-131, 134-138.
9. Heid CA, Stevens J, Livak KJ, Williams PM, (1996) Real time quantitative PCR. Genome Res 6 (10): 986-994.
10. Tyagi S, Kramer FR, (1996) Molecular beacons: probes that fluoresce upon hybridization. Nat Biotechnol 14 (3): 303-308.
11. De Leeneer K, Coene I, Poppe B, De Paepe A, Claes K, (2008) Rapid and sensitive detection of BRCA1/2 mutations in a diagnostic setting: comparison of two high-resolution melting platforms. Clin Chem 54 (6): 982-989.
12. Kramer D, Thunnissen FB, Gallegos-Ruiz MI, Smit EF, Postmus PE, et al. (2009) A fast, sensitive and accurate high resolution melting (HRM) technology-based assay to screen for common K-ras mutations. Cell Oncol 31 (3): 161-167.
13. Whitehall V, Tran K, Umapathy A, Grieu F, Hewitt C, et al. (2009) A Multicenter Blinded Study to Evaluate KRAS Mutation Testing Methodologies in the Clinical Setting. J Mol Diagn 11 (6): 543-552.
14. Wittwer CT, Reed GH, Gundry CN, Vandersteen JG, Pryor RJ, (2003) High-resolution genotyping by amplicon melting analysis using LCGreen. Clin Chem 49 (6): 853-860.
15. Takano T, Ohe Y, Tsuta K, Fukui T, Sakamoto H, et al. (2007) Epidermal growth factor receptor mutation detection using high-resolution melting analysis predicts outcomes in patients with advanced non small cell lung cancer treated with gefitinib. Clin Cancer Res 13 (18): 5385-5390.
16. Fukui T, Ohe Y, Tsuta K, Furuta K, Sakamoto H, et al. (2008) Prospective study of the accuracy of EGFR mutational analysis by high-resolution melting analysis in small samples obtained from patients with non-small cell lung cancer. Clin Cancer Res 14 (15): 4751-4757.
17. Franklin WA, Haney J, Sugita M, Bemis L, Jimeno A, et al. (2010) KRAS mutation: comparison of testing methods and tissue sampling techniques in colon cancer. J Mol Diagn 12 (1): 43-50.
18. Fuster O, Barragan E, Bolufer P, Cervera J, Larrayoz MJ, et al. (2009) Rapid detection of KIT mutations in core-binding factor acute myeloid leukemia using high-resolution melting analysis. J Mol Diagn 11 (5): 458-463.
19. Willmore-Payne C, Holden JA, Tripp S, Layfield LJ, (2005) Human malignant melanoma: detection of BRAF- and c-kit-activating mutations by high-resolution amplicon melting analysis. Hum Pathol 36 (5): 486-493.
20. Pichler M, Balic M, Stadelmeyer E, Ausch C, Wild M, et al. (2009) Evaluation of high-resolution melting analysis as a diagnostic tool to detect the BRAF V600E mutation in colorectal tumors. J Mol Diagn 11 (2): 140-147.
21. van der Stoep N, van Paridon CD, Janssens T, Krenkova P, Stambergova A, (2009) Diagnostic guidelines for high-resolution melting curve (HRM) analysis: an interlaboratory validation of BRCA1 mutation scanning using the 96-well LightScanner. Hum Mutat 30 (6): 899-909.
22. Bastien R, Lewis TB, Hawkes JE, Quackenbush JF, Robbins TC, et al. (2008) High-throughput amplicon scanning of the TP53 gene in breast cancer using high-resolution fluorescent melting curve analyses and automatic mutation calling. Hum mutat 29 (5): 757-764.
23. Montgomery JL, Sanford LN, Wittwer CT, (2010) High-resolution DNA melting analysis in clinical research and diagnostics. Expert Rev Mol Diagn 10 (2): 219-240.
24. OECD website. Available: http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/43/6/3883978.pdf. Accessed 2011 May 10.
25. Reed GH, Kent JO, Wittwer CT, (2007) High-resolution DNA melting analysis for simple and efficient molecular diagnostics. Pharmacogenomics 89 (6): 597-608.
26. Erali M, Voelkerding KV, Wittwer CT, (2008) High resolution melting applications for clinical laboratory medicine. Exp Mol Pathol 85 (1): 50-58.
27. Taylor CF, (2009) Mutation scanning using high-resolution melting. Biochem Soc Trans 37 (2): 433-437.
28. Vossen RH, Aten E, Roos A, den Dunnen JT, (2009) High-resolution melting analysis (HRMA): more than just sequence variant screening. Hum mutat 30 (6): 860-866.
29. Wittwer CT, (2009) High-resolution DNA melting analysis: advancements and limitations. Hum mutat 30 (6): 857-869.
30. Erali M, Voelkerding KV, Wittwer CT, (2008) High resolution melting applications for clinical laboratory medicine. Exp Mol Pathol 85 (1): 50-58.
31. Whiting P, Rutjes AW, Reitsma JB, Bossuyt PM, Kleijnen J, (2003) The development of QUADAS: a tool for the quality assessment of studies of diagnostic accuracy included in systematic reviews. BMC Med Res Methodol 3 (10): 25.
32. Berlin JA, (1997) Does blinding of readers affect the results of meta-analyses? Lancet 350 (9072): 185-186.
33. Higgins JP, Thompson SG, Deeks JJ, Altman DG, (2003) Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. BMJ 327 (7414): 557-560.
34. DerSimonian R, Laird N, (1986) Meta-analysis in clinical trials. Control Clin Trials 7 (3): 177-188.
35. Lijmer JG, Bossuyt PM, Heisterkamp SH, (2002) Exploring sources of heterogeneity in systematic reviews of diagnostic tests. Stat Med 21 (11): 1525-1537.
36. Macaskill P, (2004) Empirical Bayes estimates generated in a hierarchical summary ROC analysis agreed closely with those of a full Bayesian analysis. J Clin Epidemiol 57 (9): 925-932.
37. Deeks JJ, (2001) Systematic reviews in health care: Systematic reviews of evaluations of diagnostic and screening tests. BMJ 323 (7305): 157-162.
38. Zamora J, Abraira V, Muriel A, Khan K, Coomarasamy A, (2006) Meta-DiSc: a software for meta-analysis of test accuracy data. BMC Med Res Methodol 6 (12): 31.
39. Assessing Diagnostic Technologies (1996) Technology Assessment Program Report No. 1 Boston US Dept of Veterans Affairs.
40. Willmore C, Holden JA, Zhou L, Tripp S, Wittwer CT, et al. (2004) Detection of c-kit-activating mutations in gastrointestinal stromal tumors by high-resolution amplicon melting analysis. Am J Clin Pathol 122 (2): 206-216.
41. Nomoto K, Tsuta K, Takano T, Fukui T, Fukui T, et al. (2006) Detection of EGFR mutations in archived cytologic specimens of non-small cell lung cancer using high-resolution melting analysis. Am J Clin Pathol 126 (4): 608-615.
42. Willmore-Payne C, Holden JA, Layfield LJ, (2006) Detection of epidermal growth factor receptor and human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 activating mutations in lung adenocarcinoma by high-resolution melting amplicon analysis: correlation with gene copy number, protein expression, and hormone receptor expression. Hum Pathol 37 (6): 755-763.
43. Willmore-Payne C, Holden JA, Layfield LJ, (2006) Detection of EGFR- and HER2-activating mutations in squamous cell carcinoma involving the head and neck. Mod Pathol 19 (5): 634-640.
44. Hung CC, Lee CN, Chang CH, Jong YJ, Chen CP, et al. (2008) Genotyping of the G1138A mutation of the FGFR3 gene in patients with achondroplasia using high-resolution melting analysis. Clin Biochem 41 (3): 162-166.
45. Liyanage KE, Hooper AJ, Defesche JC, Burnett JR, van Bockxmeer FM, (2008) High-resolution melting analysis for detection of familial ligand-defective apolipoprotein B-100 mutations. Ann Clin Biochem 45 (2): 170-176.
46. Polakova KM, Lopotova T, Klamova H, Moravcova J, (2008) High-resolution melt curve analysis: initial screening for mutations in BCR-ABL kinase domain. Leuk Res 32 (8): 1236-1243.
47. Tan AY, Westerman DA, Carney DA, Seymour JF, Juneja S, et al. (2008) Detection of NPM1 exon 12 mutations and FLT3- internal tandem duplications by high resolution melting analysis in normal karyotype acute myeloid leukemia. J Hematol Oncol 1 (29): 10.
48. Doi Y, Sasaki D, Terada C, Mori S, Tsuruda K, et al. (2009) High-resolution melting analysis for a reliable and two-step scanning of mutations in the tyrosine kinase domain of the chimerical bcr-abl gene. Int J Hematol 90 (1): 37-43.
49. Fassina A, Gazziero A, Zardo D, Corradin M, Aldighieri E, et al. (2009) Detection of EGFR and KRAS mutations on trans-thoracic needle aspiration of lung nodules by high resolution melting analysis. J Clin Pathol 62 (12): 1096-1102.
50. Gaucher C, Walrant-Debray O, Nguyen TM, Esterle L, Garabedian M, et al. (2009) PHEX analysis in 118 pedigrees reveals new genetic clues in hypophosphatemic rickets. Hum Genet 125 (4): 401-411.
51. Ma ES, Wong CL, Law FB, Chan WK, Siu D, (2009) Detection of KRAS mutations in colorectal cancer by high-resolution melting analysis. J Clin Pathol 62 (10): 886-891.
52. Rapado I, Grande S, Albizua E, Ayala R, Hernandez JA, et al. (2009) High resolution melting analysis for JAK2 Exon 14 and Exon 12 mutations: a diagnostic tool for myeloproliferative neoplasms. J Mol Diagn 11 (2): 155-161.
53. Xiao J, Bastian RW, Perlmutter JS, Racette BA, Tabbal SD, et al. (2009) High-throughput mutational analysis of TOR1A in primary dystonia. BMC Med Genet 10 (11): 24.
54. Lopez-Villar I, Ayala R, Wesselink J, Morillas JD, Lopez E, et al. (2010) Simplifying the detection of MUTYH mutations by high resolution melting analysis. BMC cancer 10 (5): 408.
55. Zhi-hong C, Ai-lin G, She-juan AN, You-wei Z, Dong MA, et al. (2010) High resolution melting analysis for the rapid and sensitive of KRAS cond 12 and 13 mutations in coloretal cancer. Chin J Lab Med 33 (3): 209-212.
56. Krypuy M, Newnham GM, Thomas DM, Conron M, Dobrovic A, (2006) High resolution melting analysis for the rapid and sensitive detection of mutations in clinical samples: KRAS codon 12 and 13 mutations in non-small cell lung cancer. BMC cancer 6 (21): 295.
57. Krypuy M, Ahmed AA, Etemadmoghadam D, Hyland SJ, Group AOCS (2007) High resolution melting for mutation scanning of TP53 exons 5-8. BMC cancer 7 (31): 168.
58. Do H, Krypuy M, Mitchell PL, Fox SB, Dobrovic A, (2008) High resolution melting analysis for rapid and sensitive EGFR and KRAS mutation detection in formalin fixed paraffin embedded biopsies. BMC cancer 8 (21): 142.
59. Simi L, Pratesi N, Vignoli M, Sestini R, Cianchi F, et al. (2008) High-resolution melting analysis for rapid detection of gene mutations in colorectal cancer. Am J Clin Pathol 130 (2): 247-253.
60. Dagar V, Chow CW, Ashley DM, Algar EM, (2009) Rapid detection of SMARCB1 sequence variation using high resolution melting. BMC cancer 9 (13): 437.
61. Fu X, Deng Y, Fan X, Luo Y, Chen D, et al. (2009) Detecting KRAS mutations in colorectal carcinoma patients with high resolution melting curve analysis. Chin Arch Gen Surg (Electronic Edition) 3 (5): 376-378.
62. Krenkova P, Norambuena P, Stambergova A, Macek M Jr, (2009) Evaluation of high-resolution melting (HRM) for mutation scanning of selected exons of the CFTR gene. Folia Biol (Praha) 55 (6): 238-242.
63. Lu Y, Li Z, Liu Q, Feng W, Wei XU, et al. (2010) Detecting the TGFA Gene Taq I Mutation with High Resolution Melting Method. Journal of China Medical University 39 (4): 281-282, 285.
64. Olsen RK, Dobrowolski SF, Kjeldsen M, Hougaard D, Simonsen H, et al. (2010) High-resolution melting analysis, a simple and effective method for reliable mutation scanning and frequency studies in the ACADVL gene. J Inherit Metab Dis 33 (3): 247-260.
65. van ER, van PM, Chhatta AR, Gupta N, Vossen RH, et al. (2010) Sensitive and specific KRAS somatic mutation analysis on whole-genome amplified DNA from archival tissues. J Mol Diagn 12 (1): 27-34.
66. Lijmer JG, Mol BW, Heisterkamp S, Bonsel GJ, Prins MH, et al. (1999) Empirical evidence of design-related bias in studies of diagnostic tests. JAMA 282 (11): 1061-1066.
67. Rutter CM, Gatsonis CA, (2001) A hierarchical regression approach to meta-analysis of diagnostic test accuracy evaluations. Stat Med 20 (19): 2865-2884.
68. Herrmann MG, Durtschi JD, Bromley LK, Wittwer CT, Voelkerding KV, (2006) Amplicon DNA melting analysis for mutation scanning and genotyping: cross-platform comparison of instruments and dyes. Clin Chem 52 (3): 494-503.
69. Herrmann MG, Durtschi JD, Bromley LK, Wittwer CT, Voelkerding KV, (2007) Instrument comparison for heterozygote scanning of single and double heterozygotes: a correction and extension of Herrmann et al., Clin Chem 2006;52:494-503. Clin Chem 53 (1): 150-152.
70. Herrmann MG, Durtschi JD, Wittwer CT, Voelkerding KV, (2007) Expanded instrument comparison of amplicon DNA melting analysis for mutation scanning and genotyping. Clin Chem 53 (8): 1544-1548.
71. Ugo V, Tondeur S, Menot ML, Bonnin N, Le GG, et al. (2010) Interlaboratory development and validation of a HRM method applied to the detection of JAK2 exon 12 mutations in polycythemia vera patients. PLoS One 5 (1): e88-93.
72. Farrar JS, Reed GH, Wittwer CT, eds. (2009) High resolution melting curve analysis for molecular diagnositics Burlington Elsevier.
73. Sackett DL, Haynes RB, Guyatt GH, Tugwell P, (1992) Clinical epidemiology, a basic science for clinical medicine Boston Little Brown.
74. Obuchowski NA, Graham RJ, Baker ME, Powell KA, (2001) Ten criteria for effective screening: their application to multislice CT screening for pulmonary and colorectal cancers. AJR Am J Roentgenol 176 (6): 1357-1362.
75. Straus SE, Richardson WS, Glasziou P, Haynes RB, eds. (2005) Evidence-based medicine: how to practice and teach EBM New York Elsevier/Churchill Livingstone.
76. Provaznikova D, (2008) High-resolution melting analysis for detection of MYH9 mutations. Platelets 19 (6): 471-475.
77. Ririe KM, Rasmussen RP, Wittwer CT, (1997) Product differentiation by analysis of DNA melting curves during the polymerase chain reaction. Anal Biochem 245 (2): 154-160.
78. Liew M, Pryor R, Palais R, Meadows C, Erali M, et al. (2004) Genotyping of single-nucleotide polymorphisms by high-resolution melting of small amplicons. Clin Chem 50 (7): 1156-1164.
79. Reed GH, Wittwer CT, (2004) Sensitivity and specificity of single-nucleotide polymorphism scanning by high-resolution melting analysis. Clin Chem 50 (10): 1748-1754.
80. Rees WA, Yager TD, Korte J, von HPH, (1993) Betaine can eliminate the base pair composition dependence of DNA melting. Biochemistry 32 (1): 137-144.
81. von AN, Oellerich M, Schutz E, (2001) Limitations of genotyping based on amplicon melting temperature. Clin Chem 47 (7): 1331-1332.
82. Reed GH, (2004) Sensitivity and specificity of single-nucleotide polymorphism scanning by high-resolution melting analysis. Clinical Chemistry 50 (10): 1748-1754.
83. Song F, Khan KS, Dinnes J, Sutton AJ, (2002) Asymmetric funnel plots and publication bias in meta-analyses of diagnostic accuracy. Clinical Chemistry 31 (1): 88-95.