Structural identifiability of systems biology models: A critical comparison of methods

PLoS ONE

Volumn 6, Issue 11, 2011, Pages

  Chis, Oana Teodora ^a   Banga, Julio R ^a   Balsa Canto, Eva ^a  

^a INSTITUTO DE INVESTIGACIONES MARINAS   (Spain)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ACCURACY; ALGORITHM; ARABIDOPSIS; ARTICLE; BIOLOGICAL MODEL; COMPUTER SIMULATION; CONTROLLED STUDY; GLYCOLYSIS; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; LINEAR SYSTEM; MATHEMATICAL COMPUTING; MATHEMATICAL MODEL; NONLINEAR SYSTEM; STOICHIOMETRY; STRUCTURE ANALYSIS; SYSTEMS BIOLOGY; COMPARATIVE STUDY; METABOLISM; METHODOLOGY;

IMMUNOGLOBULIN ENHANCER BINDING PROTEIN;

ARABIDOPSIS; GLYCOLYSIS; MODELS, BIOLOGICAL; NF-KAPPA B; NONLINEAR DYNAMICS; SYSTEMS BIOLOGY;

EID: 81555207959     PISSN: None     EISSN: 19326203     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0027755     Document Type: Article

References (59)

1. Wolkenhauer O, Ullah M, Kolch W, Cho K, (2004) Modeling and simulation of intracellular dynamics: Choosing an appropriate framework. IEEE Trans on Nanobioscience 3 (3): 200-207.
2. Janes K, Lauffenburger D, (2006) A biological approach to computational models of proteomic networks. Curr Op Chem Biol 10: 73-80.
3. Banga JR, Balsa-Canto E, (2008) Parameter estimation and optimal experimental design. Essays in Biochemistry 45: 195-210.
4. Lipniacki T, Paszek P, Brasier A, Luxon B, Kimmel M, (2004) Mathematical model of NFκB regulatory module. J Theor Biol 228: 195-215.
5. Brown K, Hill C, Calero G, Myers C, Lee K, et al. (2004) The statistical mechanics of complex signaling networks:nerve growth factor signaling. Phys Biol 1: 184-195.
6. Achard P, Schutter ED, (2006) Complex parameter landscape for a complex neuron model. PLOS Computational Biology 2: 0794-0803.
7. Piazza M, Feng X, Rabinoswitz J, Rabitz H, (2008) Diverse metabolic model parameters generate similar methionine cycle dynamics. J Theor Biol 251: 628-639.
8. Gutenkunst R, Waterfall J, Casey F, Brown K, Myers C, et al. (2007) Universally sloppy parameter sensitivities in systems biology models. Plos Comput Biol 3: 1871-1878.
9. Walter E, Pronzato L, (1997) Identification of Parametric Models from Experimental Data. Springer, Masson.
10. Balsa-Canto E, Alonso A, Banga J, (2008) Computational procedures for optimal experimental design in biological systems. IET Systems Biology 2 (4): 163-172.
11. Bandara S, Sclöder J, Eils R, Bock H, Meyer T, (2009) Optimal experimental design for parameter estimation of a cell signaling model. Plos Comput Biol 5: 1-12.
12. Kreutz C, Timmer J, (2009) Systems biology: experimental design. FEBS J 276: 923-942.
13. He F, Brown M, Yue H, (2010) Maximin and bayesian robust experimental design for measurement set selection in modelling biochemical regulatory systems. Int J Robust & Nonlinear Control 20: 1059-1078.
14. Rodriguez-Fernandez M, Egea JA, Banga J, (2006) Novel metaheuristic for parameter estimation in nonlinear dynamic biological systems. BMC Bioinformatics 7: 483.
15. Srinath S, Gunawan R, (2010) Parameter identifiability of power-law biochemical system models. J Biotechnol 149: 132-140.
16. Hengl S, Kreutz D, Timmer J, Maiwald T, (2007) Data-based identifiability analysis of non-linear dynamical models. Bioinformatics 23 (19): 2612-2618.
17. Balsa-Canto E, Alonso A, Banga J, (2010) An iterative identification procedure for dynamic modeling of biochemical networks. BMC Systems Biology 4: 11.
18. Roper R, Saccomani M, Vicini P, (2010) Cellular signaling identifiability analysis:a case study. J Theor Biol 264: 528-537.
19. Kholodenko B, (2006) Cell-signalling dynamics in time and space. Nature Reviews, Molecular Cell Biology 7: 165-176.
20. Miao H, Xia X, Perelson A, Wu H, (2011) On identifiability of nonlinear ode models and applications in viral dynamics. SIAM Rev Soc Ind Appl Math 53 (1): 3-39.
21. Pohjanpalo H, (1978) System identifiability based on power-series expansion of solution. Math Biosci 41: 21-33.
22. Walter E, Lecourtier Y, (1982) Global approaches to identifiability testing for linear and nonlinear state space models. Mathematics and Computers in Simulation 24: 472-482.
23. Vajda S, Godfrey K, Rabitz H, (1989) Similarity transformation approach to identifiability analysis of nonlinear compartmental models. Mathematical Biosciences 93: 217-248.
24. Ljung L, Glad T, (1994) On global identifiability of arbitrary model parameterizations. Automatica 30: 265-276.
25. Bellu G, Saccomani MP, Audoly S, D'Angìo L, (2007) DAISY: A new software tool to test global identifiability of biological and physiological systems. Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine 88: 52-61.
26. Denis-Vidal L, Joly-Blanchard G, Noiret C, (2001) Some effective approaches to check the identifiability of uncontrolled nonlinear systems. Mathematics in Computers and Simulation 57: 35-44.
27. Walter E, Braems I, Jaulin L, Kieffer M, (2004) Guaranteed numerical computation as an alternative to computer algebra for testing models for identifiability. Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Academic Press124-f131.
28. Xia X, Moog CH, (2003) Identifiability of nonlinear systems with applications to hiv/aids models. IEEE Trans Aut Cont 48: 330-336.
29. Craciun G, Pantea C, (2008) Identifiability of chemical reaction networks. Journal of Mathematical Chemistry 44: 244-259.
30. Davidescu F, Jorgensen S, (2008) Structural parameter identifiability analysis for dynamic reaction networks. Chemical Engineering Science 63: 4754-4762.
31. Szederkenyi G, (2009) Comment on "Identifiability of chemical reaction networks" by G. Craciun and C. Pantea. J Math Chem 45: 1172-1174.
32. Goodwin A, Defibaugh D, Weber L, (1992) The vapor pressure of 1,1,1,2-tetrafluoroethane (r134a) and chlorodifluoromethane (r22). Int J Thermophys 13: 837.
33. Domurado M, Domurado D, Vansteenkiste S, Marre AD, ESchacht, (1995) Glucose oxidase as a tool to study in vivo the interaction of glycosylated polymers with the mannose receptor of macrophages. J Contr Rel 33: 115-123.
34. Bartl M, Kotzing M, Kaleta C, Schuster S, Li P, (2010) Just-in-time activation of a glycolysis inspired metabolic network- solution with a dynamic optimization approach. Proc 55nd International Scientific Colloquium 2010 Ilmenau, Germany.
35. Saccomani M, Audoly S, Bellu G, D'Angio L, (2010) Examples of testing global identifiability of biological and biomedical models with daisy software. Computers in Biology and Medicine 40: 402-407.
36. Locke J, Millar A, Turner M, (2005) Modelling genetic networks with noisy and varied experimental data: the circadian clock in arabidopsis thaliana. Journal of Theoretical Biology 234: 383-393.
37. Vajda S, (1984) Structural identifiability of linear, bilinear, polynomial and rational systems. Proceedings of the 9th IFAC World Congress, Budapest, Hungary.
38. Vajda S, (1987) Identifiability of polynomial systems: structural and numerical aspects. Identifiability of parametric models, Pergamon, Oxford.
39. Margaria G, Riccomagno E, Chappell M, Wynn H, (2001) Differential algebra methods for the study of the structural identifiability of rational function state-space models in the biosciences. Mathematical Biosciences 174: 1-26.
40. Chappel M, Godfrey K, Vajda S, (1990) Global identifiability of the parameters of nonlinear systems with specific input: A comparison of methods. Mathematical Biosciences 102: 41-73.
41. Wu H, Zhu H, Miao H, Perelson AS, (2008) Parameter identifiability and estimation of hiv/aids dynamic models. Bulletin of Mathematical Biology 70 (3): 785-799.
42. Walter E, Pronzato L, (1996) On the identifiability and distinguishability of nonlinear parametric models. Math Comput Simulat 42: 125-26.
43. Denis-Vidal L, Joly-Blanchard G, (1996) Identifiability of some nonlinear kinetics. Proceedings of the Third Workshop on Modelling of Chemical Reaction Systems, Heidelberg.
44. Vajda S, Rabitz H, (1989) Isomorphism approach to global identifiability of nonlinear systems. IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control 34: 220-223.
45. Peeters R, Hanzon B, (2005) Identifiability of homogeneous systems using the state isomorphism approach. Automatica 41: 513-529.
46. Denis-Vidal L, Joly-Blanchard G, (2000) An easy to check criterion for (un)identifiability of uncontrolled systems and its applications. IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control 45: 768-771.
47. Ollivier F, (1990) Le probleme de l'identifiabilite structurelle globale: etude theorique, methodes effectives et bornes de complexite. Paris, France These de Doctorat en Science, Ecole Polytechnique.
48. Buchberger B, (1976) A theoretical basis for the reduction of polynomials to canonical forms. ACM SIGSAM Bulletin 10 (3): 19-29.
49. Ritt J, (1950) Differential algebra. New York AMS Colloquium Publications.
50. Kolchin E, (1973) Differential algebra and algebraic groups,. New York Academic Press.
51. Brendel M, Bonvin D, Marquardt W, (2006) Incremental identification of kinetic models for homogeneous reactions systems. Chemical Engineering Science 61: 5404-5420.
52. Chis O, Banga J, Balsa-Canto E, (2011) GenSSI: a software toolbox for structural identifiability analysis of biological models. Bioinformatics doi:10.1093/bioinformatics/btr431.
53. Goodwin B, (1965) Oscillatory behavior in enzymatic control processes. Advances in Enzyme Regulation 3: 425-428.
54. Verdiere N, Denis-Vidal L, Joly-Blanchard G, Domurado D, (2005) Identifiability and estimation of pharmacokinetic parameters for the ligands of the macroohagemannose receptor. Int J Appl Math Comput Sci 15: 517-526.
55. Chapman MJ, Godfrey K, Chappell MJ, Evans ND, (2003) Structural identifiability of non-linear systems using linear/non-linear splitting. Control 76: 209-216.
56. Szederkenyi G, Banga J, Alonso A, (2011) Inference of complex biological networks: distinguishability issues and optimization-based solutions. BMC Systems Biology in press.
57. Lee E, Boone D, Chai S, Libby S, Chien M, et al. (2000) Failure to regulate TNF-induced NF-κB and cell death responses in A20-deficient mice. Science 289: 2350-2354.
58. Hoffmann A, Levchenko A, Scott M, Baltimore D, (2002) The IkB-NF-kB signaling module: temporal control and selective gene activation. Science 298: 1241-1245.
59. Saccomani M, Audoly S, D'Angio L, (2003) Parameter identifiability of nonlinear systems: the role of initial conditions. Chemical Engineering Science 39: 619-632.