Effect of a blend of comfrey root extract (Symphytum officinale L.) and tannic acid creams in the treatment of osteoarthritis of the knee: Randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind, multiclinical trials

Journal of Chiropractic Medicine

Volumn 10, Issue 3, 2011, Pages 147-156

  Smith, Doug B ^a   Jacobson, Bert H ^a  

^a OKLAHOMA STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Botanicals; Knee pain; Osteoarthritis; Therapeutic; Topical

Indexed keywords

EID: 80052138868     PISSN: 15563707     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jcm.2011.01.003     Document Type: Article

References (52)

1. Helmick C., Felson D., Lawrence R., Gabriel S., Hirsch R., Kwoh C., et al. Estimates of the prevalence of arthritis and other rheumatic conditions in the United States. Part I. Arthritis And Rheumatism 2008, 58(1):15-25.
2. Lawrence R., Felson D., Helmick C., Arnold L., Choi H., Deyo R., et al. Estimates of the prevalence of arthritis and other rheumatic conditions in the United States. Part II. Arthritis and Rheum 2008, 58(1):26-30.
3. Dieppe P. Osteoarthritis: time to shift the paradigm. Brit Med J 1999, 1999(218):1299-1300.
4. Creamer P., Hochberg M.C. Osteoarthritis. Lancet 1997, 350:503-509.
5. Berman B.M., Singh B.B., Lao L., Langenberg P., Li H., Hadhazy V., et al. Randomized trial of acupuncture as an adjunctive therapy in osteoarthritis of the knee. J Rheumatol 1999, 38:346-354.
6. Summers M.N., Haley W.E., Reveille J.O., Alarcon G.S. Radiographic assessment and psychological variables as predictors of pain and functional impairment in osteoarthritis of the knee and hip. Arthritis Rheum 1988, 31:204-209.
7. Bradley J.D., Brandt K.D., Katz B.P., Kalasinski L.A., Ryan S.I. Comparison of an anti-inflammatory dose of ibuprofen, an analgesic dose of ibuprofen, and acetaminophen in the treatment of patients with osteoarthritis of the knee. N Engl J Med 1991, 325:87-91.
8. MacFarlane D.G., Bucklan-Wright J.C., Emery P., Fogelman I., Clark B., Lynch J. Comparison of clinical, radionuclide, and radiographic features of osteoarthritis of the hands. Annal Rheum Dis 1991, 50:623-626.
9. Yelin E., Murphy L., Cisternas M., Foreman A., Pasta D., Helmick C. Medical care expenditures and earnings losses among persons with arthritis and other rheumatic conditions in 2003, and comparisons with 1997. Arthritis Rheum 2007, 56(5):1397-1407.
10. McAlindon T.E., Felson D.T., Zhang Y., Hannan M.T., Alabadi P., Weissman B., et al. Relation of dietary intake on serum levels of vitamin D to progression in the Framingham Study. Ann Int Med 1996, 125:353-359.
11. McAlindon T.E., LaValley M.P., Gulin J.P., Felson D.T. Glucosamine and chondroitin for treatment of osteoarthritis. A systematic quality assessment and meta-analysis. J Am Med Assoc 2000, 283:1460-1475.
12. Katz J., Shah T. Persistent pain in the older adult: what should we do now in light of the 2009 American geriatrics society clinical practice guideline?. Pol Arch Med Wewn 2009, 119(12):795-800.
13. Panicker S., Borgia J., Fhied C., Mikecz K., Oegema T. Oral glucosamine modulates the response of the liver and lymphocytes of the mesenteric lymph nodes in a papain-induced model of joint damage and repair. Osteoarhr Cartil 2009, 17(8):1014-1021.
14. Samson D., Grant M., Ratko T., Bonnell C., Ziegler K., Aronson N. Treatment of primary and secondary osteoarthritis of the knee. Evid Rep Technol Assess 2007, (157):1-157.
15. Koll R, Buhr M, Dieter R, Pabst H, Predel H, Petrowicz O, et al. Efficacy and tolerance of a comfrey root extract (Extr. Rad. Symphyti) in the treatment of ankle distorsions: results of a multicenter, randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind study. Phytomedicine 2004;11(6):470-7.
16. Kommission E. Monographie Symphyti radix (Beinwellwurzel). Bundesanzeiger 1990, 318.
17. Schmidtke-Schrezenmeier G., Reck R., Gerster G. Behandlung der nichtaktivierten Gonarthrose. Besserung durch ein Phytotherapeutikum. Therapiewoche 1992, 42:1322-1325.
18. Barna M., Kucera A., Hladícova M., Kucera M. Wound healing effects of a Symphytum herb extract cream (Symphytum x uplandicum NYMAN): results of a randomized, controlled double-blind study. Wien Med Wochenschr 2007, 157(21-22):569-574.
19. Kucera M., Barna M., Horàcek O., Kàlal J., Kucera A., Hladìkova M. Topical Symphytum herb concentrate cream against myalgia: a randomized controlled double-blind clinical study. Adv Ther 2005, 22(6):681-692.
20. Bleakley C., McDonough S., MacAuley D. Some conservative strategies are effective when added to controlled mobilisation with external support after acute ankle sprain: a systematic review. Aust J Physiother 2008, 54(1):7-20.
21. D'Anchise R., Bulitta M., Giannetti B. Comfrey extract ointment in comparison to diclofenac gel in the treatment of acute unilateral ankle sprains (distortions). Arzneimittelforschung 2007, 57(11):712-716.
22. Predel H., Giannetti B., Koll R., Bulitta M., Staiger C. Efficacy of a comfrey root extract ointment in comparison to a diclofenac gel in the treatment of ankle distortions: results of an observer-blind, randomized, multicenter study. Phytomedicine 2005, 12(10):707-714.
23. Sakakura C., Neto R., Bellucci M., Wenzel A., Scaf G., Marcantonio E. Influence of homeopathic treatment with comfrey on bone density around titanium implants: a digital subtraction radiography study in rats. Clin Oral Implants Res 2008, 19(6):624-628.
24. Grube B., Grünwald J., Krug L., Staiger C. Efficacy of a comfrey root (Symphyti offic. adix) extract ointment in the treatment of patients with painful osteoarthritis of the knee: results of a double-blind, randomised, bicenter, placebo-controlled trial. Phytomedicine 2007, 14(1):2-10.
25. Koll R., Klingenburg S. Therapeutic characteristance and tolerance of topical comfrey preparations. Results of an observational study of patients. FortschrMed Orig 2002, 120(1):1-9.
26. Yudoh K., Nguyen V., Nakamura H., Hongo-Masuko K., Kato T., Nishioka K. Potential involvement of oxidative stress in cartilage senescence and development of osteoarthritis: oxidative stress induces chondrocyte telomere instability and downregulation of chondrocyte function. Arthritis Res Ther 2005, 7(2):R380-R391.
27. Regan E., Bowler R., Crapo J. Joint fluid antioxidants are decreased in osteoarthritic joint compared to joints with macroscopically intact cartilage and subacute injury. Osteoarthr Cartil 2008, 16(4):515-521.
28. Roman-Blas J., Contreras-Blasco M., Largo R., Alvarez-Soria M., Castañeda S., Herrero-Beaumont G. Differential effects of the antioxidant n-acetylcysteine on the production of catabolic mediators in IL-1beta-stimulated human osteoarthritic synoviocytes and chondrocytes. Eur J Pharma 2009, 623(1-3):125-131.
29. Zampieron E., Kamhi E. Alternative treatment for arthritis. J Indian Rheumatol Assoc 2004, 12:139-142.
30. Cho M., Heo Y., Park M., Oh H., Park J., Woo Y., et al. Grape seed proanthocyanidin extract (GSPE) attenuates collagen-induced arthritis. Immunol Lett 2009, 124(2):102-110.
31. Levanon D., Stein H. Quantitative analysis of chondroitin sulphate retention by tannic acid during preparation of specimens for electron microscopy. Histochemic J 1995, 27(6):457-465.
32. Amanlou M., Dadkhah F., Salehnia A., Farsam H., Dehpour A. An anti-inflammatory and anti-nociceptive effects of hydroalcoholic extract of Satureja khuzistanica Jamzad extract. J Pharm Pharm Sci 2005, 8(1):102-106.
33. Shin H., Hwang H., Kang K., Lee B. An antioxidative and antiinflammatory agent for potential treatment of osteoarthritis from Ecklonia cava. Arch Pharm Res 2006, 29(2):165-171.
34. Weyers W., Brodbeck R. Skin absorption of volatile oils. Pharmacokinetics. Pharmazie Unserer Zeit 1989, 18:82-86.
35. Singh H.P., MIttal S., Kaur S., Batish D.R., Kohil R.K. Characterization and antioxidant activity of essential oils from fresh and decaying leaves of Eucalyptus tereticornis. Am J Phys Med Rehabil 1991, 70(1):29-33.
36. Altman R.D. Criteria for classification of clinical osteoarthritis. J Rheumatol 1991, 18:10-12.
37. Altman R., Asch E., Bloch D., Bole G., Borenstein D., Brandt K., et al. Development of criteria for the classification and reporting of osteoarthritis. Classification of osteoarthritis of the knee. Arthritis Rheum 1989, 29:1039-1049.
38. Roos E.M., Klässbo M., Lohmander L.S. WOMAC osteoarthritis index. Reliability, validity, and responsiveness in patients with arthroscopically assessed osteoarthritis. Western Ontario and MacMaster Universities. Scand J Rheumatol 1999, 28(4):210-215.
39. Rayburn K., Fleischbein E., Song J., Allen B., Kundert M., Leiter C., et al. Stinging nettle cream for osteoarthritis. Alt Ther Health Med 2009, 15:60-61.
40. Gregory P.J., Sperry M., Wilson A.F. Dietary supplements for osteoarthritis. Am Fam Physician 2008, 77:177-184.
41. Chrubasik J.E., Roufogalis B.D., Chrubasik S. Evidence of effectiveness of herbal antiinflammatory drugs in the treatment of painful osteoarthritis and chronic low back pain. Phytotherapy Res 2007, 7:675-683.
42. Tschaikin Extrakt aus Symphytum officinale. Wirksamkeit und veträglichkeit bie topisher anwendung. Naturheilpraxis 2004, 57:576-578.
43. Klingenburg S. Wärmendes Topikum mit Symphytum officinale. Erfahrungsheilkunde 2004, 6:350-354.
44. Doherty M., Dieppe P. The "placebo" response in osteoarthritis and its implications for clinical practice. Osteoarthritis Cartilage 2009, 17:1255-1262.
45. Schwetschenau P., Ramirez A., Johnston J., Wiggs C., Martins A. Double-blind evaluation of intradiscal chymopapain for herniated lumbar discs. Early results. J Neurosurgery 1976, 45(6):622-627.
46. Boureau F., Leizorovicz A., Caulin F. The placebo effect in bone metastatic pain. Presse Médicale (Paris, France: 1983) 1988, 17(21):1063-1066.
47. Zhang W., Robertson J., Jones A.C., Dieppe P.A., Doherty M. The placebo effect and its determinants in osteoarthritis: meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. Ann Rheum Dis 2008, 67:1716-1723.
48. Grace D., Rogers J., Skeith K., Anderson K. Topical diclofenac versus placebo: a double blind, randomized clinical trial in patients with osteoarthritis of the knee. J Rheumatol 1999, 26:2659-2663.
49. Tubach F., Ravaud P., Baron G., Falissard B., Logeart I., Bellamy N., et al. Evaluation of clinically relevant changes in patient reported outcomes in knee and hip osteoarthritis: the minimal clinically important improvement. Ann Rheum Dis 2005, 64(1):29-33.
50. Bookman A.A.M., Williams S.A., Shainhouse J.Z. Effect of topical diclofenac solution for relieving symptoms of primary osteoarthritis of the knee: a randomized controlled trial. Can Med Assoc J 2004, 171:333-338.
51. Magnusson B.M., Walters K.A., Roberts M.S. Veterinary drug delivery: potential for skin penetration enhancement. Adv Drug Deliv Rev 2001, 50:205-227.
52. Morganti P., Ruocco E., Wolf R., Ruocco V. Percutaneous absorption and delivery systems. Clin Derm 2001, 19:489-501.