Arguing the value of virtual worlds: Patterns of discursive sensemaking of an innovative technology

MIS Quarterly: Management Information Systems

Volumn 35, Issue 3, 2011, Pages 685-709

  Berente, Nicholas ^a   Hansen, Sean ^b   Pike, Jacqueline C ^c   Bateman, Patrick J ^d  

^a UNIVERSITY OF GEORGIA   (United States)

^b ROCHESTER INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY   (United States)

^c DUQUESNE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^d YOUNGSTOWN STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Argument; Discourse; Organizational value; Second Life; Sensemaking; Toulmin; Virtual worlds

Indexed keywords

VIRTUAL REALITY;

ARGUMENT; DISCOURSE; ORGANIZATIONAL VALUE; SECOND LIFE; SENSEMAKING; TOULMIN; VIRTUAL WORLDS;

INTERACTIVE COMPUTER GRAPHICS;

EID: 80051730540     PISSN: 02767783     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.2307/23042804     Document Type: Article

References (114)

1. Anderson, C. 2006. "Wired Travel Guide: Second Life," WIRED Magazine (available online at http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/14.10/ sloverview.html).
2. Attewell, P. 1992. "Technology Diffusion and Organizational Learning: The Case of Business Computing," Organization Science (3:1), pp. 1-19.
3. Billig, M. 1996. Arguing and Thinking: A Rhetorical Approach to Social Psychology, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
4. Billig, M. 1997. "The Dialogic Unconscious: Psychoanalysis, Discursive Psychology and the Nature of Repression," British Journal of Social Psychology (36:2), pp. 139-159. (Pubitemid 127454325)
5. Boczkowski, P. J., and Orlikowski, W. J. 2004. "Organizational Discourse and New Media: A Practice Perspective," in The Sage Handbook of Organizational Discourse, D. Grant, C. Hardy, C. Oswick, and L. L. Putnam (eds.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, pp. 360-377.
6. Boden, D. 1994. The Business of Talk, Cambridge UK: Polity Press.
7. Boje, D. M. 1991. "The Storytelling Organization: A Study of Story Performance in an Office- Supply Firm," Administrative Science Quarterly (36:1), pp. 106-126.
8. Boland, R. J. 2001. "The Tyranny of Space in Organizational Analysis," Information and Organization (11:1), pp. 3-23.
9. Boland, R. J., and Tenkasi, R. V. 1995. "Perspective Making and Perspective Taking in Communities of Knowing," Organization Science (6:4), pp. 350-372.
10. Boland, R. J., Tenkasi, R. V., and Te'eni, D. 1994. "Designing Information Technology to Support Distributed Cognition," Organization Science (5:3), pp. 456-477.
11. Boulos, M. N. K., Hetherington, L., and Wheeler, S. 2007. "Second Life: An Overview of the Potential of 3-D Virtual Worlds in Medical and Health Education," Health Information & Libraries Journal (24:4), pp. 233-245.
12. Boyatzis, R. E. 1998. Transforming Qualitative Information: Thematic Analysis and Code Development, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
13. Brockriede, W., and Ehninger, D. 1960. "Toulmin on Argument: An Interpretation and Application," Quarterly Journal of Speech (46), pp. 44-53.
14. Bruner, J. S. 1990. Acts of Meaning, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
15. Bryant, A., Hughes, J., Myers, M. D., Trauth, E. M., and Urquhart, C. 2004. "Twenty Years of Applying Grounded Theory in Information Systems: A Coding Method, Useful Theory Generation Method, or an Orthodox Positivist Method of Data Analysis?," in Information Systems Research: Relevant Theory and Informed Practice, B. Kaplan, D. P. Truex, D. Wastell, A. T. Wood-Harper and J. I. DeGross (eds.), Norwell, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishers, pp. 649-650.
16. Chandler, A. D. 1977. The Visible Hand: The Managerial Revolution in American Business, Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press.
17. Cohen, M. D., March, J. G., and Olsen, J. P. 1972. "A Garbage Can Model of Organizational Choice," Administrative Science Quarterly, (17:1), pp. 1-25.
18. Corbin, J. M., and Strauss, A. L. 1990. "Grounded Theory Research: Procedures, Canons, and Evaluative Criteria," Qualitative Sociology (13:1), pp. 3-21.
19. Cyert, R. M., and March, J. G. 1963. A Behavioral Theory of the Firm, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
20. Czarniawska, B. 2004. "Turning to Discourse," in The Sage Hand-book of Organizational Discourse, D. Grant, C. Hardy, C. Oswick, and L. L. Putnam (eds.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, pp. 399-404.
21. Daft, R. L., Lengel, R. H., and Trevino, L. K. 1987. "Message Equivocality, Media Selection, and Manager Performance: Implications for Information Systems," MIS Quarterly (11:3), pp. 355-366
22. Davis, A., Khazanchi, D., Murphy, J., Zigurs, I., and Owens, D. 2009. "Avatars, People, and Virtual Worlds: Foundations for Research in Metaverses," Journal of the Association for Information Systems (10:2), pp. 90-117.
23. DiMaggio, P. J., and Powell, W. W. 1983. "The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Organizational Fields," American Sociological Review (48:2), pp. 147-160.
24. Dodds, A. E., Lawrence, J. A., and Valsiner, J. 1997. "The Personal and the Social: Mead's Theory of the 'Generalized Other,'" Theory & Psychology (7:4), pp. 483-503. (Pubitemid 127473550)
25. Drazin, R., Glynn, M. A., and Kazanjian, R. K. 1999. "Multilevel Theorizing About Creativity in Organizations: A Sensemaking Perspective," Academy of Management Review (24:2), pp. 286-307.
26. Edwards, D., and Potter, J. 1992. Discursive Psychology, London: Sage Publications Ltd.
27. Erickson, K., and Stull, D. 1998. Doing Team Ethnography: Warnings and Advice, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
28. Fairclough, N. 2003. Analyzing Discourse: Textual Analysis for Social Research, London: Routledge
29. Feldman, M. S., and March, J. G. 1981. "Information in Organizations as Signal and Symbol," Administrative Science Quarterly (26:2), pp. 171-186.
30. Gal, U., and Berente, N. 2008. "A Social Representations Perspective on Information Systems Implementation: Rethinking the Concept of 'Frames,'" Information Technology and People (21:2), pp. 133-154.
31. Galbraith, J. R. 1977. Organization Design, Reading, MA: Addison Wesley.
32. Galimberti, C., Ignazi, S., Vercesi, P., and Riva, G. 2001. "Communication and Cooperation in Networked Environments: An Experimental Analysis," CyberPsychology & Behavior (4:1), pp. 131-146. (Pubitemid 32289169)
33. Gartner. 2008. "Gartner Says 90 Per Cent of Corporate Virtual World Projects Fail Within 18 Months," Gartner Group, Stamford, CT (available online at http://www.gartner.com/it/page.jsp?id=670507).
34. Giddens, A. 1984. The Constitution of Society: Outline of the Theory of Structuration, Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.
35. Gioia, D. A., and Chittipeddi, K. 1991. "Sensemaking and Sensegiving in Strategic Change Initiation," Strategic Management Journal (12:6), pp. 433-448.
36. Gioia, D. A., and Thomas, J. B. 1996. "Identity, Image, and Issue Interpretation: Sensemaking During Strategic Change in Academia," Administrative Science Quarterly (41:3), pp. 370-403.
37. Glazer, B. G., and Strauss, A. L. 1967. The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research, New York: Aldine.
38. Gordon, M. E., Slade, L. A., and Schmitt, N. 1986. "The 'Science of the Sophomore' Revisited: From Conjecture to Empiricism," Academy of Management Review (11:1), pp. 191-207.
39. Granovetter, M. 1985. "Economic Action and Social Structure: The Problem of Embeddedness," American Journal of Sociology (91:3), pp. 481-510.
40. Grant, D., Hardy, C., Oswick, C., and Putnam, L. L. 2004. "Organizational Discourse: Exploring the Field," in The Sage Handbook of Organizational Discourse, D. Grant, C. Hardy, C. Oswick, and L. L. Putnam (eds.), Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, pp. 1-36.
41. Green, S. E., Li, Y., and Nohria, N. 2009. "Suspended in Self-Spun Webs of Significance: A Rhetorical Model of Institutionalization and Institutionally Embedded Agency," Academy of Management Journal (52:1), pp. 11-36.
42. Greenwood, R., Oliver, C., Shalin, K., and Suddaby, R. 2008. The Sage Handbook of Organizational Institutionalism, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
43. Gregor, S., and Benbasat, I. 1999. "Explanations from Intelligent Systems: Theoretical Foundations and Implications for Practice," MIS Quarterly (23:4), pp. 497-530.
44. Griffith, T. L. 1999. "Technology Features as Triggers for Sensemaking," Academy of Management Review (24:3), pp. 472-488.
45. Guest, G., and MacQueen, K. M. 2008. Handbook for Team-Based Qualitative Research, Lanham, MD: AltaMira Press.
46. Habermas, J. 1981. The Theory of Communicative Action, Volume One: Reason and the Rationalization of Society, Boston: Beacon Press.
47. Hansen, S., Berente, N., Pike, J., and Bateman, P. J. 2009. "Productivity and Play in Organizations: Executive Perspectives on the Real-World Organizational Value of Immersive Virtual Environments," Artifact (2:3), pp. 69-81.
48. Harry, B., Sturges, K. M., and Klingner, J. K. 2005. "Mapping the Process: An Exemplar of Process and Challenge in Grounded Theory Analysis," Educational Researcher (34:2), pp. 3-13. (Pubitemid 40447082)
49. Hemp, P. 2006. "Avatar-Based Marketing," Harvard Business Review (84:6), pp. 48-57.
50. Henrich, J., Boyd, R., Bowles, S., Camerer, C., Fehr, E., Gintis, H., and McElreath, R. 2001. "In Search of Homo Economicus: Behavioral Experiments in 15 Small-Scale Societies," American Economic Review (91:2), pp. 73-78.
51. Heracleous, L. T. 2004. "Interpretivist Approaches to Organizational Discourse," in The Sage Handbook of Organizational
52. Discourse, D. Grant, C. Hardy, C. Oswick, and L. L. Putnam (eds.), Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, pp. 175-192.
53. Heracleous, L. T., and Barrett, M. 2001. "Organizational Change as Discourse: Communicative Actions and Deep Structures in the Context of Information Technology Implementation," Academy of Management Journal (44:4), pp. 755-778.
54. Hobson, N. 2006. "Is it Time You Got a Second Life?," Strategic Communication Management (11:1), p. 3.
55. Hof, R. D. 2006. "My Virtual Life," Business Week, May 1 (available online at http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/06-18/ b3982001.htm).
56. Howcroft, D., and Hughes, J. 1999. "Grounded Theory: I Mentioned it Once But I Think I Got Away with It," in Information Systems- The Next Generation: Proceedings of the 4th UK Academy for Information Systems Conference, L. Brooks and C. Kimble (eds.), Maidenhead, UK: McGraw-Hill, pp. 129-141.
57. Huang, X., Gattiker, T. F., and Schwarz, J. L. 2008. "Can Students Pass the Test: Should We Use Student Subjects in Operations Management Research," in Proceedings of the 39th Annual Meeting of the Decision Sciences Institute, Baltimore, MD, November 22-25, pp. 4931-4936 (available online at http://www.ecisionsciences.org/Proceedings/DSI2008/docs/493-3475.pdf)
58. Ives, B., and Junglas, I. 2008. "APC Forum: Business Implications of Virtual Worlds and Serious Gaming," MIS Quarterly Executive (7:3), pp. 151-156.
59. James, W. 1987. Pragmatism, Albany, NY: Library of America.
60. Johnstone, B. 2002. Discourse Analysis, Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing.
61. Khera, I. P., and Benson, J. D. 1970. "Are Students Really Poor Substitutes for Businessmen in Behavioral Research?," Journal of Marketing Research (7:4), pp. 529-532.
62. Kim, D., and Benbasat, I. 2006. "The Effects of Trust-Assuring Arguments on Consumer Trust in Internet Stores: Application of Toulmin's Model of Argumentation," Information Systems Research (17:3), p. 286.
63. King, J. L., and Lyytinen, K. 2004. "Reach and Grasp," MIS Quarterly (28:4), pp. 539-551.
64. Kirsch, L. S. 1997. "Portfolios of Control Modes and IS Project Management," Information Systems Research (8:3), pp. 215-239.
65. Klein, H. K., and Hirschheim, R. 2001. "Choosing between Competing Design Ideals in Information Systems Development," Information Systems Frontiers (3:1), pp. 75-90.
66. Kling, R. 1980. "Social Analyses of Computing: Theoretical Perspectives in Recent Empirical Research," ACM Computing Surveys (12:1), pp. 61-110.
67. Kock, C. 2006. "Multiple Warrants in Practical Reasoning," in Arguing on the Toulmin Model: New Essays in Argument Analysis and Evaluation, D. Hitchcock and B. Verheij (eds.), Heidelberg: Springer, pp. 247-259.
68. Lawrence, P. R., and Lorsch, J. W. 1967. Organization and Environment: Managing Differentiation and Integration, Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
69. Latour, B. 1996. Aramis, or the Love of Technology, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
70. Layder, D. 1998. Sociological Practice: Linking Theory and Research, London: Sage Publications Ltd.
71. Louis, M. R. 1980. "Surprise and Sense Making: What Newcomers Experience in Entering Unfamiliar Organizational Settings," Administrative Science Quarterly (25:2), pp. 226-251.
72. Lyytinen, K., and Rose, G. M. 2003. "The Disruptive Nature of Information Technology Innovations: The Case of Internet Computing in Systems Development Organizations," MIS Quarterly (27:4), pp. 557-596.
73. Maitlis, S. 2005. "The Social Processes of Organizational Sensemaking," Academy of Management Journal (48:1), pp. 21-49. (Pubitemid 40366664)
74. March, J. G., and Olsen, J. P. 2004. "The Logic of Appropriateness," ARENA Working Papers, WP 04/09, Centre for European Studies, University of Oslo (available online at http://www.arena.uio.no/ publications/wp04-9.pdf).
75. th International Conference on Information Systems, Montreal, Canada, December 9-12.
76. Meyer, J., and Rowan, B. 1997. "Institutionalized Organizations: Formal Structure as Myth and Ceremony," The American Journal of Sociology (83:2), pp. 340-363.
77. Morse, J. M. 2007. "Sampling in Grounded Theory," in The Sage Handbook of Grounded Theory, A. Bryant and K. Charmaz (eds.), London: Sage Publications, Ltd. pp. 229-244.
78. Moscovici, S. 1984. "The Phenomenon of Social Representations," in Social Representations, R. M. Farr and S. Moscovici (eds.), Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, pp. 3-69.
79. Nickerson, R. S. 1998. "Confirmation Bias: A Ubiquitous Phenomenon in Many Guises," Review of General Psychology (2:2), pp. 175-220. (Pubitemid 128549158)
80. Noam, E. M. 2007. "The Dismal Economics of Virtual Worlds," The DATA BASE for Advances in Information Systems (38:4), pp. 106-109.
81. Nord, W. R., and Connell, A. F. 1993. "From Quicksand to Crossroads: An Agnostic Perspective on Conversation," Organization Science (4:1), pp. 108-120.
82. Orlikowski, W. J. 1992. "The Duality of Technology: Rethinking the Concept of Technology in Organizations," Organization Science (2:3), pp. 398-427.
83. Orlikowski, W. J., and Gash, D. 1994. "Technology Frames: Making Sense of Information Technology in Organizations," ACM Transactions on Information Systems (12:2), pp. 174-207.
84. Pentland, B. T. 1999. "Building Process Theory with Narrative: From Description to Explanation," Academy of Management Review (24:4), pp. 711-724.
85. Phillips, N., Lawrence, T. B., and Hardy, C. 2004. "Discourse and Institutions," Academy of Management Review (29:4), pp. 635-652.
86. Pinch, T., and Bijker, W. 1987. "The Social Construction of Facts and Artifacts," in The Social Construction of Technological Systems: New Directions in the Sociology and History of Technology, W. E. Bijker, T. P. Hughes, and T. J. Pinch (eds.), Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, pp. 17-50.
87. Potter, J., and Edwards, D. 2001. "Discursive Social Psychology," in The New Handbook of Language and Social Psychology, W. P. Robinson and H. Giles (eds.), New York: John Wiley & Sons, pp. 103-118.
88. Powell, W., and DiMaggio, P. 1991. The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
89. Ramiller, N. 2001. "The 'Textual Attitude' and New Technology," Information and Organization (11:2), pp. 129-156. (Pubitemid 33632560)
90. Richards, J. 2008. "McKinsey: Ignore Second Life at Your Peril," Times Online, April 23 (available online at http://technology. timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/tech-and-web/article3803056.ece).
91. Ricoeur, P. 1981. Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences: Essays on Language, Action, and Interpretation (J. B. Thompson, trans.), Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
92. Rogers, E. M. 1995. The Diffusion of Innovations, New York: The Free Press.
93. Rose, F. 2007. "How Madison Avenue Is Wasting Millions on a Deserted Second Life," WIRED Magazine (15.08), July 24 (available online at http://www.wired.com/techbiz/media/magazine/15-08/ff-sheep).
94. Rosenberg, N. 1994. Exploring the Black Box: Technology, Economics, and History, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
95. Sairamesh, J., Lee, A., and Anania, L. 2004. "Information Cities," Communications of the ACM (47:2), pp. 29-31.
96. Saldana, J. 2009. The Coding Manual for Qualitative Researchers, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
97. Simon, H. A. 1956. Administrative Behavior, New York: Macmillan.
98. Starbuck, W. H., and Milliken, F. J. 1988. "Executives' Perceptual Filters: What They Notice and How They Make Sense," in The Executive Effect: Concepts and Methods for Studying Top Managers, D. Hambrick (ed.), Greenwich, CT: JAI Press, pp. 35-65.
99. Strauss, A. L., and Corbin, J. M. 1998. Basics of Qualitative Research: Techniques and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
100. Swanson, E. B. 1994. "Information Systems Innovation among Organizations," Management Science (40:9), pp. 1069-1092.
101. Swanson, E. B., and Ramiller, N. C. 1997. "The Organizing Vision in Information Systems Innovation," Organization Science (8:5), pp. 458-475.
102. Swanson, E. B., and Ramiller, N. C. 2004. "Innovating Mindfullly with Information Technology," MIS Quarterly (28:4), pp. 553-583.
103. Taylor, J. R., and Van Every, E. J. 2000. The Emergent Organization: Communication as Its Site and Surface, Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
104. Toulmin, S. E. 2003. The Uses of Argument, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
105. Urquhart, C. 2001. "An Encounter with Grounded Theory: Tackling the Practical and Philosophical Issues," in Qualitative Research in IS: Issues and Trends, E. Trauth (ed.). Hershey, PA: Idea Group Publishing, pp. 104-140.
106. Uzzi, B. 1997. "Social Structure and Competition in Interfirm Networks: The Paradox of Embeddedness," Administrative Science Quarterly (42:1), pp. 35-67. (Pubitemid 127172358)
107. Weick, K. 1979. The Social Psychology of Organizing, Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
108. Weick, K. 1990. "Technology as Equivoque: Sensemaking in New Technologies," in Technology and Organizations, P. S. Goodman and L. Sproull (eds.), San Francisco, CA: Jossey Bass.
109. Weick, K. 1995. Sensemaking in Organizations, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
110. Weick, K., Sutcliffe, K. M., and Obstfeld, D. 2005. "Organizing and the Process of Sensemaking," Organization Science (16:4), pp. 409-421. (Pubitemid 43057590)
111. Westley, F. R. 1990. "Middle Managers and Strategy: Microdynamics of Inclusion," Strategic Management Journal (11:5), pp. 337-351.
112. Whitton, M. C. 2003. "Making Virtual Environments Compelling," Communications of the ACM (46:7), pp. 40-46.
113. Yates, J. 1989. Control through Communication: The Rise of System in American Management, Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
114. Ye, R., and Johnson, P. E. 1995. "The Impact of Explanation Facilities on User Acceptance of Expert Systems Advice," MIS Quarterly (19:2), pp. 157-172.