The role of community representatives on health service committees: Staff expectations vs. reality

Health Expectations

Volumn 14, Issue 3, 2011, Pages 272-284

  Nathan, Sally ^a   Johnston, Lynda ^b   Braithwaite, Jeffrey ^c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF NEW SOUTH WALES   (Australia)

^b Sydney South West Area Health Service ^*  (Australia)

^c UNIVERSITY OF NEW SOUTH WALES   (Australia)

Author keywords

Committees; Community participation; Community representatives; Health services; Planning

Indexed keywords

ADVISORY COMMITTEE; ARTICLE; ATTITUDE TO HEALTH; AUSTRALIA; CONSUMER; CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY; HEALTH SERVICE; HUMAN; INFORMATION PROCESSING; INTERPERSONAL COMMUNICATION; METHODOLOGY; ORGANIZATION AND MANAGEMENT; ROLE PLAYING;

ADVISORY COMMITTEES; ATTITUDE TO HEALTH; AUSTRALIA; COMMITTEE MEMBERSHIP; COMMUNICATION; CONSUMER PARTICIPATION; CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDIES; DATA COLLECTION; HEALTH SERVICES ADMINISTRATION; HUMANS; NEW SOUTH WALES; ROLE;

EID: 80051572120     PISSN: 13696513     EISSN: 13697625     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1369-7625.2010.00628.x     Document Type: Article

References (58)

1. Bastian H. Speaking up for ourselves. The evolution of consumer advocacy in health care. International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care, 1998; 14: 3-23.
2. Charles C, DeMaio S. Lay participation in health care decision making: a conceptual framework. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 1993; 18: 881-904.
3. Crawford MJ, Rutter D, Manley C et al. Systematic review of involving patients in the planning and development of health care. BMJ, 2002; 325: 1263.
4. Entwistle VA. Public involvement in health service governance and development: questions of potential for influence. Health Expectations, 2009; 12: 1-3.
5. Florin D, Dixon J. Public involvement in health care. BMJ, 2004; 328: 159-161.
6. Fudge N, Wolfe CDA, McKevitt C. Assessing the promise of user involvement in health service development: ethnographic study. BMJ, 2008; 336: 313-317.
7. Pickard S, Marshall M, Rogers A et al. User involvement in clinical governance. Health Expectations, 2002; 5: 187-198.
8. Salter B. Patients and doctors: reformulating the UK health policy community? Social Science & Medicine, 2003; 57: 927-936.
9. CFC. Improving Health Services through Consumer Participation: A Resource Guide for Organisations. Consumer Focus Collaboration. Department of Public Health at Flinders University, Australia, 2000.
10. Butler A. Consumer Participation in Australian Primary Health Care: A Literature Review. Canberra: National Resource Centre for Consumer Participation in Health, 2002.
11. Draper M. Involving Consumers in Improving Hospital Care: Lessons from Australian Hospitals. Canberra: Commonwealth Department of Health and Family Services, 1997.
12. Forster R, Gabe J. Voice or choice? Patient and public involvement in the National Health Service in England under New Labour. International Journal of Health Services, 2008; 38: 333-356.
13. Daykin N, Evans D, Petsoulas C, Sayers A. Evaluating the impact of patient and public involvement initiatives on UK health services: a systematic review. Evidence and Policy, 2007; 3: 47-65.
14. Jewkes R, Murcott A. Community representatives: representing the "community"? Social Science & Medicine, 1998; 46: 843-858.
15. Learmonth M, Martin GP, Warwick P. Ordinary and effective: the Catch-22 in managing the public voice in health care? Health Expectations, 2009; 12: 106-115.
16. Rutter D, Manley C, Weaver T, Crawford MJ, Fulop N. Patients or partners? Case studies of user involvement in the planning and delivery of adult mental health services in London. Social Science and Medicine, 2004; 58: 1973-1984.
17. Kidd S, Kenny A, Endacott R. Consumer advocate and clinician perceptions of consumer participation in two rural mental health services. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing, 2007; 16: 214-222.
18. Nathan S. Consumer participation: the challenges to achieving influence and equity. Australian Journal of Primary Health, 2004; 10: 15-20.
19. Perkins D, Senior K, Owen A. Mere tokenism or best practice: The Illawarra Division of General Practice Consumer Consultative Committee. Australian Journal of Primary Health Interchange, 2002; 8: 81-87.
20. Church J, Saunders D, Wanke M, Pong R, Spooner C, Dorgan M. Citizen participation in health decision-making: past experience and future prospects. Journal of Public Health Policy, 2002; 23: 12-32.
21. Tritter JQ, McCallum A. The snakes and ladders of user involvement: moving beyond Arnstein. Health Policy, 2006; 76: 156-168.
22. Carr BJ. Making the best of consumer participation. Journal of Quality in Clinical Practice, 2001; 21: 37-39.
23. Medicare Australia. About Medicare Australia, 2009. Available from:, accessed 29 April 2009.
24. NRCCPH. Feedback, Participation and Consumer Diversity: A Literature Review. Canberra: NRCCPH, 2000.
25. Pickin C, Popay J, Staley K, Bruce N, Jones C, Gowman N. Developing a model to enhance the capacity of statutory organisations to engage with lay communities. Journal of Health Services & Research Policy, 2002; 7: 34-42.
26. Putland C, Baum F, MacDougall C. How can health bureaucracies consult effectively about their policies and practices? Some lessons from an Australian study. Health Promotion International, 1997; 12: 299-309.
27. al-Mazroa Y, al-Shammari S. Community participation and attitudes of decision-makers towards community involvement in health development in Saudi Arabia. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 1991; 69: 43-50.
28. Milewa T. User participation in service planning. A qualitative approach to gauging the impact of managerial attitudes. Journal of Management in Medicine, 1997; 11: 238-245.
29. Monahan A, Stewart DE. The role of lay panelists on grant review panels. Chronic Diseases in Canada, 2003; 24: 70-74.
30. Nathan S, Harris E, Kemp L, Harris-Roxas B. Health service staff attitudes to community representatives on committees. Journal of Health Organisation and Management, 2006; 20: 1477-7266.
31. Bryant J, Saxton M, Madden A, Bath N, Robinson S. Consumers' and providers' perspectives about consumer participation in drug treatment services: is there support to do more? What are the obstacles? Drug and Alcohol Review, 2008; 27: 138-144.
32. McCann TV, Baird J, Clark E, Lu S. Mental health professionals' attitudes towards consumer participation in inpatient units. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 2008; 15: 10-16.
33. Hogg C, Williamson C. Whose interests do lay people represent? Towards an understanding of the role of lay people as members of committees. Health Expectations, 2001; 4: 2-9.
34. Gorsky M. Community involvement in hospital governance in Britain: evidence from before the National Health Service. International Journal of Health Services, 2008; 38: 751-771.
35. Hogg CNL. Patient and public involvement: what next for the NHS? Health Expectations, 2007; 10: 129-138.
36. Health Issues Centre. Participate in Health. Victoria: Health Issues Centre, 2009. Available from:, accessed 29 April 2009.
37. Gregory J. Consumer Engagement in Australian Health Policy Australian Institute of Health Policy Studies, 2008. Available from:, accessed 9 February 2010.
38. Australian Council on Healthcare Standards. National Report on Health Services Accreditation 2003-2006. Sydney: Australian Council on Healthcare Standards, 2007.
39. Johnson A, Silburn K. Community and consumer participation in Australian health services: an overview of organisational commitment and participation processes. Australian Health Review, 2000; 23: 113-121.
40. Sydney South West Area Health Service. Sydney South West Area Health Service Statutory Annual Report 2006/07: Sydney South West Area Health Service, 2007 Contract No.: April 29 2009.
41. Sydney South West Area Health Service. Community Participation Framework. Liverpool, NSW: Sydney South West Area Health Service, 2006. Available from:, accessed 15 May 2009.
42. NSW Health. Health Councils in Rural NSW, Phase One evaluation, March-August 1999. Sydney: NSW Health, 2000.
43. SPSS. SPSS Statistics Version 17 for Windows. Chicago: SPSS Inc, 2009.
44. Litva A, Canvin K, Shepherd M, Jacoby A, Gabbay M. Lay perceptions of the desired role and type of user involvement in clinical governance. Health Expectations, 2009; 12: 81-91.
45. Crawford M, Rutter D. Are the views of members of mental health user groups representative of those of 'ordinary' patients? A cross-sectional survey of service users and providers. Journal of Mental Health, 2004; 13: 561-568.
46. Sitzia J, Cotterell P, Richardson A. Interprofessional collaboration with service users in the development of cancer services: The Cancer Partnership Project. Journal of Interprofessional Care, 2006; 20: 60-74.
47. Williamson C. The rise of doctor-patient working groups. BMJ, 1998; 317: 1374-1377.
48. Quennell P. Getting their say, or getting their way? Has participation strengthened the patient "voice" in the National Institute for Clinical Excellence? Journal of Management in Medicine, 2001; 15: 202-219.
49. van Wersch A, Eccles M. Involvement of consumers in the development of evidence based clinical guidelines: practical experiences from the North of England evidence based guideline development programme. Quality in Health Care, 2001; 10: 10-16.
50. Arnstein SR. Ladder of citizen participation. AIP Journal, 1969; 216-224.
51. Nilsen ES, Myrhaug HT, Johansen M, Oliver S, Oxman AD. Methods of consumer involvement in developing healthcare policy, research, clinical practice guidelines and patient information material Cochrane Consumers and Communication Group Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 1, 2009.
52. Labonte R. Participation in health promotion: the 'Hardware' and the 'Software'. In: Labonte R (ed.) Power, Participation and Partnerships for Health Promotion. Victoria, Australia: Victorian Health Promotion Foundation, 1997: 27-41.
53. Labonte R. Mutual accountability in partnerships: health agencies and community groups. Promotion et Education, 1999; 6: 3-8, 36.
54. Williamson C. Reflections on health care consumerism: insights from feminism. Health Expectations, 1999; 2: 150-158.
55. Williamson C. The challenge of lay partnerships: it provides a different view of the world. BMJ, 1999; 319: 721-722.
56. Pitkin HF. The Concept of Representation. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1967.
57. Contandriopoulos D. A sociological perspective on public participation in health care. Social Science & Medicine, 2004; 58: 321-330.
58. Brooks F. Nursing and public participation in health: an ethnographic study of a patient council. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 2008; 45: 3-13.