Empathy decline and its reasons: A systematic review of studies with medical students and residents

Academic Medicine

Volumn 86, Issue 8, 2011, Pages 996-1009

  Neumann, Melanie ^a   Edelhäuser, Friedrich ^a   Tauschel, Diethard ^a   Fischer, Martin R ^a   Wirtz, Markus ^b   Woopen, Christiane ^c   Haramati, Aviad ^d,e   Scheffer, Christian ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF WITTEN HERDECKE   (Germany)

^b UNIVERSITY OF EDUCATION FREIBURG   (Germany)

^c UNIVERSITY OF COLOGNE   (Germany)

^d GEORGETOWN UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^e Institute for Integrative Health   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 80051548322     PISSN: 10402446     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1097/ACM.0b013e318221e615     Document Type: Review

References (115)

1. Simpson M, Buckman R, Stewart M, et al. Doctor-patient communication: The Toronto Consensus Statement. BMJ. 1991; 303:1385-1387.
2. DiBlasi Z, Harkness E, Ernst E, Georgiou A, Kleijnen J. Influence of context effects on health outcomes: A systematic review. Lancet. 2001;357:757-762. (Pubitemid 32217684)
3. Stewart MA. Effective physician-patient communication and health outcomes: A review. CMAJ. 1995;152:1423-1433.
4. Stewart M, Brown JB, Donner A, et al. The impact of patient-centered care on outcomes. J Fam Pract. 2000;49:796-804.
5. Griffin SJ, Kinmouth A, Veltman M, Grant J, Stewart M. Effect on health-related outcomes of interventions to alter the interaction between patients and practitioners: A systematic review of trials. Ann Fam Med. 2004;2:595-608. (Pubitemid 39643435)
6. Mercer SW, Reynolds WJ. Empathy and quality of care. Br J Gen Pract. 2002;52(suppl):S9-S13.
7. Squier RW. A model of empathic understanding and adherence to treatment regimens in practitioner-patient relationships. Soc Sci Med. 1990;30: 325-329.
8. Maguire P, Faulkner A, Booth K, Elliot C, Hiller V. Helping cancer patients disclose their concerns. Eur J Cancer Care. 1996;32A: 78-81.
9. Coulehan J, Platt F, Egner B, et al. "Let me see if I have this right ": Words that build empathy. Ann Intern Med. 2001;135: 221-227. (Pubitemid 32738320)
10. Beckman HB, Frankel RM. Training practitioners to communicate effectively in cancer care: It is the relationship that counts. Patient Educ Couns. 2003;50:85-89. (Pubitemid 36593246)
11. Neumann M, Wirtz M, Bollschweiler E, Warm M, Wolf J, Pfaff H. Psychometric evaluation of the German version of the "Consultation and Relational Empathy" (CARE) measure at the example of cancer patients [in German]. Psychother Psychosom Med Psychol. 2008;58:5-15. (Pubitemid 351204088)
12. Larson EB, Yao Y. Clinical empathy as emotional labor in the patient-physician relationship. JAMA. 2005;293:1100-1106. (Pubitemid 40300284)
13. Halpern J. From Detached Concern to Empathy: Humanizing Medical Practice. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press; 2001.
14. Irving P, Dickson D. Empathy: Towards a conceptual framework for health professionals. Int J Health Care Qual Assur Inc Leadersh Health Serv. 2004;17:212-220. (Pubitemid 38945672)
15. Neumann M, Wirtz M, Bollschweiler E, et al. Determinants and patient-reported longterm outcomes of physician empathy in oncology: A structural equation modelling approach. Patient Educ Couns. 2007;69: 63-75. (Pubitemid 350051675)
16. Kim SS, Kaplowitz S, Johnston MV. The effects of physician empathy on patient satisfaction and compliance. Eval Health Prof. 2004;27:237-251. (Pubitemid 39050604)
17. Price S, Mercer SW, MacPherson H. Practitioner empathy, patient enablement and health outcomes: A prospective study of acupuncture patients. Patient Educ Couns. 2006;63:239-245. (Pubitemid 44331554)
18. Roter DL, Stewart M, Putnam S, Lipkin MJ, Stiles W, Inui T. Communication patterns of primary care physicians. JAMA. 1997;277: 350-356. (Pubitemid 27045018)
19. Nightingale SD, Yarnold PR, Greenberg MS. Sympathy, empathy, and physician responses in primary care and surgical settings. J Gen Intern Med. 1991;6:420-423.
20. Levinson W, Gorawa-Bhat R, Lamb J. A study of patient cues and physician responses in primary care and surgical settings. JAMA. 2000;284:1021-1027. (Pubitemid 30659134)
21. Howie JG, Heaney DJ, Maxwell MW, Freeman GK, Rai H. Quality at general practice consultations: Cross sectional survey. BMJ. 1999;319:738-743. (Pubitemid 29431528)
22. MacPherson H, Mercer SW, Scullion T, Thomas KJ. Empathy, enablement, and outcome. J Altern Complement Med. 2003; 9:869-876.
23. Bikker AP, Mercer SW, Reilly D. A pilot prospective study on the consultation and relational empathy, patient enablement, and health changes over 12 months in patients going to the Glasgow Homoeopathic Hospital. J Altern Complement Med. 2005; 11:591-600. (Pubitemid 41279074)
24. Rakel DP, Hoeft TJ, Barrett BP, Chewning BA, Craig BM, Niu M. Practitioner empathy and the duration of the common cold. Fam Med. 2009;41:494-501.
25. Neumann M, Bensing J, Mercer SW, Ernstmann N, Pfaff H. Analyzing the "nature" and "specific effectiveness" of clinician empathy: A theoretical overview and contribution towards a theory-based research agenda. Patient Educ Couns. 2009; 74:339-346.
26. Institute of Medicine. Crossing the Quality Chasm: A New Health System for the 21st Century. Washington, DC: National Academies Press; 2001.
27. Little P, Everitt H, Williamson I, et al. Observational study of effect of patientcentredness and positive approach on outcomes of general practice consultations. BMJ. 2001;323:908-911. (Pubitemid 32980484)
28. Mechanic D, Meyer S. Concepts of trust among patients with serious illness. Soc Sci Med. 2000;51:657-668. (Pubitemid 30316320)
29. Coulter A. Patients' views of the good doctor. BMJ. 2002;325:668-669.
30. Klingenberg A, Bahrs O, Szecsenyi J. What do patients want from their GP? First results from a European study [in German]. Z Allg Med. 1996;72:180-186.
31. Wensing M, Jung HP, Olesen F, Grol R. A systematic review of the literature on patient priorities for general practice care. Part 1: Description of the research domain. Soc Sci Med. 1998;47:1573-1588. (Pubitemid 28482440)
32. West CP, Shanafelt TD. The influence of personal and environmental factors on professionalism in medical education. BMC Med Educ. 2007;7:1-9.
33. Association of American Medical Colleges. Report I: Learning objectives for medical student education-Guidelines for medical school. Acad Med. 1999;74:13-18. http://journals.lww.com/academicmedicine/Abstract/1999/01001/ Learning-objectives-for-medical-student.10.aspx. Accessed April 5, 2011.
34. Frank JR. The CanMEDS 2005 Physician Competency Framework. Better Standards. Better Physicians. Better Care. Ottawa, Ontario, Canada: Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada; 2005.
35. Working Group Under a Mandate of the Joint Commission of the Swiss Medical Schools. Swiss Catalogue of Learning Objectives for Undergraduate Medical Training. http://sclo.smifk.ch. Accessed April 5, 2011.
36. Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG, and The PRISMA Group. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. PloS Med. July 21, 2009;6:e1000097.
37. Stepien KA, Baernstein A. Educating for empathy. A review. J Gen Intern Med. 2006; 21:524-530.
38. Hemmerdinger JM, Stoddort S, Lilford RA. A systematic review of tests of empathy in medicine. BMC Med Educ. 2007;7:1-8.
39. Pedersen R. Empirical research on empathy in medicine-A critical review. Patient Educ Couns. 2009;76:307-322.
40. Kliszcz J, Hebanowski M, Rembowski J. Emotional and cognitive empathy in medical schools. Acad Med. 1998;73:541. http://journals.lww.com/ academicmedicine/Abstract/1998/05000/Emotional-and-cognitive-empathy-in-medical- schools.25. aspx. Accessed April 5, 2011. (Pubitemid 28261914)
41. Austin EJ, Evans P, Magnus B, O'Hanlon K. A preliminary study of empathy, emotional intelligence and examination performance in MBChB students. Med Educ. 2007;41: 684-689. (Pubitemid 47035421)
42. Todres M, Tsimtsiou Z, Stephenson A, Jones R. The emotional intelligence of medical students: An exploratory cross-sectional study. Med Teach. 2010;32:e42-e48.
43. Chen D, Lew R, Hershman W, Orlander J. A cross-sectional measurement of medical student empathy. J Gen Intern Med. 2007; 22:1434-1438. (Pubitemid 47476699)
44. Hojat M, Vergare MJ, Maxwell K, et al. The devil is in the third year: A longitudinal study of erosion of empathy in medical school. Acad Med. 2009;84:1182-1191. http://journals.lww.com/academicmedicine/Fulltext/2009/09000/ The-Devil-is-in-the-Third-Year-A-Longitudinal.12.aspx. Accessed April 5, 2011.
45. Hojat M, Mangione S, Nasca TJ, et al. An empirical study of decline in empathy in medical school. Med Educ. 2004;38: 934-941. (Pubitemid 39223006)
46. Newton B, Barber L, Clardy J, Cleveland E, O'Sullivan P. Is there hardening of the heart during medical school? Acad Med. 2008;83: 244-249. http://journals.lww.com/academic medicine/Fulltext/2008/03000/Is-There- Hardening-of-the-Heart-During-Medical. 6.aspx. Accessed April 5, 2011. (Pubitemid 351654279)
47. Thomas MR, Dyrbye LN, Huntington JL, et al. How do distress and well-being relate to medical student empathy? A multicenter study. J Gen Intern Med. 2007;22:177-183. (Pubitemid 47308813)
48. DiLalla LF, Hull SK. Effect of gender, age, and relevant course work on attitudes toward empathy, patient spirituality, and physician wellness. Teach Learn Med. 2004; 16:165-170. (Pubitemid 38880650)
49. Stratton TD, Saunders JA, Elam CL. Changes in medical students' emotional intelligence: An exploratory study. Teach Learn Med. 2008;20:279-284.
50. Newton BW, Savidge MA, Barber L, et al. Differences in medical students' empathy. Acad Med. 2000;75:1215. http://journals.lww.com/academicmedicine/ Fulltext/2000/12000/Differences-in-Medical-Students-Empathy. 20.aspx. Accessed April 5, 2011. (Pubitemid 32038197)
51. Bellini LM, Baime M, Shea JA. Variation of mood and empathy during internship. JAMA. 2002;287:3143-3146. (Pubitemid 34633992)
52. Bellini LM, Shea JA. Mood change and empathy decline persist during three years of internal medicine training. Acad Med. 2005; 80:164-167. http://journals.lww.com/academic medicine/Fulltext/2005/02000/Mood-Change-and- Empathy-Decline-Persist-during.13. aspx. Accessed April 5, 2011. (Pubitemid 40165714)
53. West C, Huschka M, Novotny P, et al. Association of perceived medical errors with resident distress and empathy. JAMA. 2006; 296:1071-1078. (Pubitemid 44343527)
54. West C, Huntington J, Huschka M, et al. A prospective study of the relationship between medical knowledge and professionalism among internal medicine residents. Acad Med. 2007;82:587-592. http://journals.lww.com/ academicmedicine/Fulltext/2007/06000/A-Prospective-Study-of-the-Relationship- between.11.aspx. Accessed April 5, 2011. (Pubitemid 46828208)
55. Rosen IM, Gimotty PA, Shea JA, Bellini LM. Evolution of sleep quantity, sleep deprivation, mood disturbances, empathy, and burnout among interns. Acad Med. 2006;81:82-85. http://journals.lww.com/academicmedicine/Fulltext/2006/ 01000/Evolution-of-Sleep-Quantity-Sleep-Deprivation.20.aspx. Accessed April 5, 2011. (Pubitemid 44366098)
56. Mangione S, Kane G, Caruso J, Gonnella J, Nasca T, Hojat M. Assessment of empathy in different years of internal medicine training. Med Teach. 2002;24:370-373.
57. Shanafelt TD, West C, Zhao X, et al. Relationship between increased personal well-being and enhanced empathy among internal medicine residents. J Gen Intern Med. 2005;20:559-564. (Pubitemid 41026237)
58. Yarascavitch C, Regehr G, Hodges B, Haas DA. Changes in dental student empathy during training. J Dent Educ. 2009;73:509-517.
59. Sherman JL, Cramer A. Measurement of changes in empathy during dental school. J Dent Educ. 2005;69:338-345.
60. Schillinger M. Learning Environment and Moral Development: How University Education Fosters Moral Judgment Competence in Brazil and Two German-Speaking Countries. Aachen, Germany: Shaker Verlag; 2006.
61. Lind G. Review and Appraisal of the Moral Judgment Test (MJT). http://www. uni-konstanz.de/ag-moral/pdf/Lind-2000-MJT-Review-and-Appraisal.pdf. Accessed April 5, 2011.
62. Branch WT. Supporting the moral development of medical students. J Gen Intern Med. 2000;15:503-509.
63. Patenaude J, Niyonsenga T, Fafard D. Changes in students' moral development during medical school: A cohort study. CMAJ. 2003;7:840-844. (Pubitemid 36433937)
64. Crandall S, Reboussin BA, Michielutte R, Anthony J, Naughton M. Medical students' attitudes toward underserved patients: A longitudinal comparison of problem-based and traditional medical curricula. Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract. 2007;12: 71-86.
65. Werner ER, Korsch BM. The vulnerability of the medical student: Posthumous presentation of L. L. Stephens' ideas. Pediatrics. 1976;57:321-328.
66. Decety J, Yang C, Cheng Y. Physicians down-regulate their pain empathy response: An event-related brain potential study. Neuroimage. 2010;50:1676-1682.
67. Cheng Y, Lin C, Liu H, et al. Expertise modulates the perception of pain in others. Curr Biol. 2007;17:1708-1713. (Pubitemid 47503814)
68. Schrauth M, Kowalski A, Weyrich P, Begenau J, Zipfel S, Nikendei C. Self-image, the real physician and the ideal physician: A comparison of medical students from 1981 and 2006 [in German]. Psychother Psychosom Med Psychol. 2009;59:446-453.
69. Shapiro J. Walking a mile in their patients' shoes: Empathy and othering in medical students' education. Philos Ethics Humanit Med. 2008;3:10.
70. Aronson E, Wilson TD, Akert RM. Social Psychology [in German]. Munich, Germany: Pearson Studium; 2004.
71. Gruehn D, Rebucal K, Diehl M, Lumley M, Labouvie-Vief G. Empathy across the adult lifespan: Longitudinal and experiencesampling findings. Emotion. 2008;8:753-765.
72. Gallese V. The roots of empathy: The shared manifold hypothesis and the neural basis of intersubjectivity. Psychopathology. 2003;36: 171-180. (Pubitemid 37176876)
73. Hojat M. Empathy in Patient Care. Antecedents, Development, Measurement and Outcomes. Berlin, Germany: Springer; 2007.
74. Bauer J. Why I Feel What You Feel. Communication and the Mystery of Mirror Neurons [in German]. Hamburg, Germany: Hoffmann und Campe; 2005.
75. Decety J, Jackson PL. The functional architecture of human empathy. Behav Cogn Neurosci Rev. 2004;3:71-100.
76. Decety J, Jackson P. A social-neuroscience perspective on empathy. Curr Dir Psychol Sci. 2006;15:54-58. (Pubitemid 43748092)
77. McManus IC, Keeling A, Paice E. Stress, burnout and doctors' attitudes to work are determined by personality and learning style: A twelve-year longitudinal study of UK medical graduates. BMC Med. 2004;2:29.
78. Baron RM, Kenny DA. The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations. J Pers Soc Psychol. 1986;51:1173-1182.
79. Winseman J, Malik A, Morison J, Balkoski V. Students' views on factors affecting empathy in medical education. Acad Psychiatry. 2009;33:484-491.
80. Dillman DA, Smyth JD, Christian LM. Internet, Mail, and Mixed-Mode Surveys: The Tailored Design Method. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons; 2008.
81. Edwards PJ, Roberts IG, Clarke MJ, et al. Methods to increase response rates to postal questionnaires. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2009;1:DOI: 10.1002/14651858. MR000008.pub3.
82. McColl E, Jacoby A, Thomas L, et al. Design and use of questionnaires: A review of best practice applicable to surveys of health service staff and patients. Health Technol Assess. 2001;5:31.
83. Steins G. A diagnostic analysis of empathy and perspective taking: A validation of the relationship between both constructs and implications for measurement [in German]. Diagnostica. 1998;44:117-129.
84. Nezu AM, Nezu CM. Evidence-Based Outcome Research: A Practical Guide to Conducting Randomized Controlled Trials for Psychosocial Interventions. New York, NY: Oxford University Press; 2008.
85. Hojat M, Gonnella J, Nasca T, Mangione S, Vergare M, Magee M. Physician empathy: Definition, components, measurement, and relationship to gender and specialty. Am J Psychiatry. 2002;159:1563-1569. (Pubitemid 35006738)
86. Hojat M, Gonnella JS, Mangione S, Nasca TJ, Magee M. Physician empathy in medical education and practice: Experience with the Jefferson Scale of Physician Empathy. Semin Integr Med. 2003;1:25-41. (Pubitemid 39345208)
87. Hojat M, Mangione S, Nasca T, Gonnella J. Empathy scores in medical school and ratings of empathic behavior in residency training 3 years later. J Soc Psychol. 2005; 145:663-672. (Pubitemid 41806957)
88. Glaser KM, Markham FW, Adler HM, McManus RP, Hojat M. Relationships between scores on the Jefferson Scale of Physician Empathy, patient perceptions of physician empathy and humanistic approaches to patient care: A validity study. Med Sci Monit. 2007;13:CR291-CR294. (Pubitemid 47037668)
89. Chen DC, Pahilan ME, Orlander J. Comparing a self-administered measure of empathy with observed behavior among medical students. J Gen Intern Med. 2010; 25:200-202.
90. Kanning UP. Development and validation of a German-language version of the Interpersonal Competence Questionnaire (ICQ). Eur J Psychol Assess. 2006;22:43-51. (Pubitemid 43446188)
91. Aukes LC, Geertsma J, Cohen-Schotanus J, Zwierstra RP, Slaets J. The development of a scale to measure personal reflection in medical practice and education. Med Teach. 2007;29:177-182. (Pubitemid 47272726)
92. Baron-Cohen S, Wheelwright S, Hill J, Raste Y, Plumb I. The "Reading the Mind in the Eyes" Test revised version: A study with normal adults, and adults with Asperger syndrome or high-functioning autism. J Child Psychol Psychiatry. 2001;42: 241-251. (Pubitemid 32233124)
93. Lawrence EJ, Shaw P, Baker D, Baron-Cohen S, David A. Measuring empathy: Reliability and validity of the Empathy Quotient. Psychol Med. 2004;34:911-924.
94. Eva K, Lingard L. What's next? A guiding question for educators engaged in educational research. Med Educ. 2008;42: 752-754. (Pubitemid 352019176)
95. Becker H, Sands D. The relationship of empathy to clinical experience among male and female nursing students. J Nurs Educ. 1988;27:198-203.
96. Fields SK, Hojat M, Gonnella J, Mangione S, Kane G, Magee M. Comparisons of nurses and physicians on an operational measure of empathy. Eval Health Prof. 2004;27:80-94. (Pubitemid 38168773)
97. Hojat M, Fields SK, Gonnella JS. Empathy: An NP/MD comparison. Nurse Pract. 2003; 28:45-47.
98. Konrath S, O'Brien E, Hsing C. Changes in dispositional empathy in American college students over time: A meta-analysis. Pers Soc Psychol Rev. 2011;15:180-198.
99. Shapiro SL, Schwartz G, Bonner G. Effects of mindfulness-based stress reduction on medical and premedical students. J Behav Med. 1998;21:581-599. (Pubitemid 29024650)
100. Shapiro SL, Astin JA, Bishop SR, Cordova M. Mindfulness-based stress reduction for health care professionals: Results from a randomized trial. Int J Stress Manag. 2005; 13:164-176. (Pubitemid 40855671)
101. Epstein RM. Mindful practice. JAMA. 1999; 282:833-839. (Pubitemid 29408934)
102. Connelly JE. Narrative possibilities: Using mindfulness in clinical practice. Perspect Biol Med. 2005;48:84-94.
103. Rosenzweig S, Reibel DK, Greeson JM, Brainard GC. Mindfulness-based stress reduction lowers psychological distress in medical students. Teach Learn Med. 2003; 15:88-92. (Pubitemid 37026171)
104. Lovas JG, Lovas DA, Lovas PM. Mindfulness and professionalism in medicine. J Dent Educ. 2008;72:998-1009.
105. Beddoe A, Murphy S. Does mindfulness decrease stress and foster empathy among nursing students? J Nurs Educ. 2004;43: 305-312. (Pubitemid 40313507)
106. Krasner M, Epstein R, Beckman H, et al. Association of an educational program in mindful communication with burnout, empathy, and attitudes among primary care physicians. JAMA. 2009;302:1284-1293.
107. Hassed C, de Lisle S, Sullivan G, Pier C. Enhancing the health of medical students' outcomes of an integrated mindfulness and lifestyle program. Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract. 2009;14:387-398.
108. Grepmair L, Mitterlehner F, Loew T, Bachler E, Rother W, Nickel M. Promoting mindfulness in psychotherapists in training influences the treatment results of their patients: A randomized, double-blind, controlled study. Psychother Psychosom. 2007;76:332-338. (Pubitemid 47530548)
109. Irving JA, Dobkin PL, Park J. Cultivating mindfulness in health care professionals: A review of empirical studies of mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR). Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2009;15:61-66.
110. Young B, Salmon P. Core assumptions and research opportunities in clinical communication. Patient Educ Couns. 2005; 58:225-234. (Pubitemid 41196693)
111. Novack DH, Suchman AL, Clark W, Epstein R. Calibrating the physician. Personal awareness and effective patient care. JAMA. 1997;278:502-509. (Pubitemid 27344005)
112. Novack DH, Epstein RM, Paulsen RH. Toward creating physician-healers: Fostering medical students' self-awareness, personal growth, and well-being. Acad Med. 1999;74:516-520. http://journals.lww.com/academicmedicine/Abstract/ 1999/05000/Toward-creating-physician-healers-fostering.17.aspx. Accessed April 5, 2011. (Pubitemid 29240982)
113. Balint M. The Doctor, His Patient and the Disease [in German]. Stuttgart, Germany: Klett-Cotta; 2001.
114. Brock C, Salinsky JV. Empathy: An essential skill for understanding the physician-patient relationship in clinical practice. Fam Med. 1993;25:245-248. (Pubitemid 23131561)
115. Spencer J. Decline in empathy in medical education: How can we stop the rot? Med Educ. 2004;38:916-920.