Is ventilation duct cleaning useful? A review of the scientific evidence

Indoor Air

Volumn 20, Issue 6, 2010, Pages 445-457

  Zuraimi, M S ^a  

^a NATIONAL RESEARCH COUNCIL CANADA   (Canada)

Author keywords

Benefits; Duct cleaning; Indoor air quality; Performance; Review

Indexed keywords

AIR CLEANERS; AIR QUALITY; CLEANING; ENERGY UTILIZATION; HEALTH RISKS; IMPURITIES; INDOOR AIR POLLUTION; VENTILATION;

BENEFIT; BENEFIT/COST; COST SAVING; DUCT CLEANING; HEALTH BENEFITS; INDOOR AIR QUALITY; PERFORMANCE; SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE; SYSTEMS PERFORMANCE; VENTILATION SYSTEMS;

CONTAMINATION;

EID: 78349299770     PISSN: 09056947     EISSN: 16000668     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1600-0668.2010.00672.x     Document Type: Review

References (80)

1. Ahmad, I., Tansel, B. and Mitrani, J.D. (2001) Effectiveness of HVAC duct cleaning procedures in improving indoor air quality, Environ. Monit. Assess., 72, 265-276.
2. Arundel, A.V., Sterling, E.M., Biggin, J.H. and Sterling, T.D. (1986) Indirect health effects of relative humidity in indoor environments, Environ. Health Perspect., 65, 351-361.
3. Asikainen, V., Pasanen, P. and Liesivuori, J. (2003) Mineral oil residues on HVAC components: measuring methods, Build. Environ., 38, 1057.
4. Auger, M. (1994) Efficiency of Residential Duct Cleaning. Project No. 93-2-001. Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, Ottawa, Canada.
5. Bernstein, R.S., Sorenson, W.G., Garabrant, D., Reaux, C. and Treitman, R.D. (1983) Exposures to respirable, airborne Penicillium from a contaminated ventilation system: clinical, environmental and epidemiological aspects, Am. Ind. Hyg. Assoc. J., 44, 161-169.
6. Brosseau, L.M., Vesley, D., Kuehn, T.H., Melson, J. and Han, H.S. (2000a) Duct cleaning: a review of associated health effects and results of company and expert surveys, ASHRAE Trans., 106, 180-187.
7. Brosseau, L.M., Vesley, D., Kuehn, T.H., Melson, J. and Han, H.S. (2000b) Methods and criteria for cleaning contaminated ducts and air-handling equipment, ASHRAE Trans., 106, 188-189.
8. CEN. (1997) Ventilation for buildings - Ductwork - Requirements for ductwork components to facilitate maintenance of ductwork systems. European Committee for Standardization, Brussels, European Prestandard, (ENV 12097).
9. Chang, J.C.S., Foarde, K.K. and VanOsdell, D.W. (1996) Assessment of fungal (Penicillium chrysogenum) growth on three HVAC duct materials, Environ. Int., 22, 425-431.
10. Cook, T.D. and Campbell, D.T. (1979). Quasi Experimentation: Design and Analysis for Field Settings, Chicago, Rand McNally College Publishing Company.
11. Douwes, J., Van Der Sluis, B., Doekes, G., Van Leusden, F., Wijnands, L., Van Strien, R., Verhoeff, A. and Brunekreef, B. (1999) Fungal extracellular polysaccharides in house dust as a marker for exposure to fungi: relations with culturable fungi, reported home dampness, and respiratory symptoms, J. Allergy Clin. Immunol., 103, 494-500.
12. EPA. (1997) Should you have the air ducts in your home cleaned? EPA-402-K-97-002. Research Triangle Park: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Indoor Environment Division, Office of Air and Radiation.
13. EPA. (2001) Mold remediation in schools and commercial buildings. Investigating, evaluating, and remediating moisture and mold problems. EPA-402-K-01-001. Research Triangle Park: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Indoor Environment Division, Office of Air and Radiation.
14. EPA. (2006) Pesticide Registration (PR) Notice 2006-A Draft: Draft Pesticide Registration Notice Use of Antimicrobial Pesticide Products in Heating, Ventilation, Air Conditioning and Refrigeration Systems (HVAC&R). U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Pesticide Programs.
15. Ezeonu, I.M., Noble, J.A., Simmons, R.B., Price, D.L., Crow, S.A. and Ahearn, D.G. (1994) Effect of relative humidity on fungal colonization of fiberglass insulation, Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 60, 2149-2151.
16. Figley, D. (1994) Use of Biocides by Residential Duct Cleaners, Ottawa, Canada, Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation.
17. Fitzner, K., Müller, B., Lußky, J. and Küchen, V. (2000) Final report task 2 of AIRLESS. Design, operation and maintenance criteria for air handling systems and components for better indoor air quality and lower energy consumption. Pre-Normative Research. Research funded in part by the European Commission in the framework of the Non Nuclear Energy Programme Joule III. Hermann-Rietschel-Institute for Heating and Air-Conditioning of the Technical University of Berlin (Contract JOR3- CT97-0171).
18. Foarde, K.K. and Menetrez, M.Y. (2002) Evaluating the potential efficacy of three antifungal sealants of duct liner and galvanized steel as used in HVAC systems, J. Ind. Microbiol. Biotechnol., 29, 38-43.
19. Foarde, K.K., VanOsdell, D.W. and Chang, J.C.S. (1996) Evaluation of fungal growth on fiberglass duct materials for various moisture, soil, use, and temperature conditions, Indoor Air, 6, 83-92.
20. Foarde, K.K., VanOsdell, D.W., Myers, E. and Chang, J.C.S. (1997) Investigation of contact vacuuming for remediation of fungally contaminated duct materials, Environ. Int., 23, 751-762.
21. Fortmann, R., Gentry, G., Foarde, K.K., VanOsdell, D.W. and Kulp, R.N. (1997) Results of a pilot field study to evaluate the effectiveness of cleaning residential heating and air conditioning systems and the impact on indoor air quality and system performance. EPA Contract No. 68-D4-0005, Work Assignment No. 2-030, Research Triangle Institute, US Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Research and Development, Washington D.C., USA.
22. Fransson, J.I., Ruud, S.H. and Rosell, L. (1995) Rena ventilationskanaler. SP-Rapport:38, Sveriges Provnings- och Forskningsinstitut (SP), Energiteknik/Kemisk Analys, Borås, Sweden.
23. Fugler, D. and Auger, M. (1994) A first look at the effectiveness of residential duct cleaning, JAWMA, 44, 2-16.
24. Garrison, R.A., Robertson, L.D., Koehn, R.D. and Wynn, S.R. (1993) Effect of heating-ventilation-air conditioning system sanitation on airborne fungal populations in residential environments, Ann. Allergy, 71, 548-556.
25. Godish, T. (2003) Air Quality, 4th edn, Chelsea, MI, US, Lewis publishers.
26. Gordis, L. (1996) Epidemiology, Philadelphia, W.B. Saunders Company.
27. Górny, R.L., Reponen, T., Willeke, K., Schmechel, D., Robine, E., Boissier, M. and Grinshpun, S.A. (2002) Fungal fragments as indoor air biocontaminants, Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 68, 3522-3531.
28. Groen, D. (1995) A case study in the use of mechanical insulation repair coatings, Healthy Buildings, pp. 23-24.
29. Holopainen, R., Asikainen, V., Pasanen, P. and Seppänen, O. (2002a) The field comparison of three measuring techniques for evaluation of the surface dust level in ventilation ducts, Indoor Air, 12, 47-54.
30. Holopainen, R., Tuomainen, M., Asikainen, V., Pasanen, P., Säteri, J. and Seppänen, O. (2002b) The effect of cleanliness control during installation work on the amount of accumulated dust in ducts of new HVAC installations, Indoor Air, 12, 191-197.
31. Holopainen, R., Asikainen, V., Tuomainen, M., Björkroth, M., Pasanen, P. and Seppänen, O. (2003) Effectiveness of duct cleaning methods on newly installed duct surfaces, Indoor Air, 13, 212-222.
32. Hubbard, H.F. (2006) Building Disinfection Chemistry: Heterogeneous Consumption of Gaseous Disinfecting Agents and Resulting By-product Formation. PhD thesis. The University of Texas at Austin.
33. HVCA. (2005) Guide to Good Practice: Internal Cleanliness of Ventilation Systems. (HVCA TR19). London. UK, Heating and Ventilating Contractors Association (HVCA).
34. Hyvarinen, A., Reponen, T., Husman, T., Ruuskanen, J. and Nevalainen, A. (1993) Characterizing mold problem buildings - concentrations and flora of viable fungi, Indoor Air, 3, 337-343.
35. Immonen, J., Laitinen, S., Taskinen, T., Pekkanen, J., Nevalainen, A. and Korppi, M. (2002) Mould-specific immunoglobulin G antibodies in students from moisture- and mould-damaged schools: a 3-year follow-up study, Pediatr. Allergy Immunol., 13, 125-128.
36. JADCA-02. (1997) Light transmission measurement method. Research report of the Japan Air Duct Cleaners Association, Tokyo, Japan, JADCA.
37. Kanaani, H., Hargreaves, M., Ristovski, Z. and Morawska, L. (2008) Deposition rates of fungal spores in indoor environments, factors effecting them and comparison with non-biological aerosols, Atmos. Environ., 42, 7141-7154.
38. Kanaani, H., Hargreaves, M., Ristovski, Z. and Morawska, L. (2009) Fungal spore fragmentation as a function of airflow rates and fungal generation methods, Atmos. Environ., 43, 3725-3735.
39. Kolari, S., Heikkilä-Kallio, U., Luoma, M., Pasanen, P., Korhonen, P., Nykyri, E. and Reijula, K. (2005) The effect of duct cleaning on perceived work environment and symptoms of office employees in non-problem buildings, Build. Environ., 40, 1665-1671.
40. Kristensen, P. (1992) Bias from nondifferential but dependent misclassification of exposure and outcome, Epidemiology, 3, 210-215.
41. Kvasnak, W., Ahmadi, G., Bayer, R. and Gaynes, M. (1993) Experimental investigation of dust particle deposition in turbulent channel flow, J. Aerosol Sci., 24, 795-815.
42. Levetin, E. (1995) Fungi. In: Burge, H.A. (ed.) Bioaerosols, Boca Raton, Lewis Publishers, 87-120.
43. Luoma, M., Pasanen, A.-L., Pasanen, P. and Fan, Y. (1993) Duct cleaning - a literature survey, Air Infiltration Rev., 14, 1-5.
44. Mendell, M.J., Fisk, W.J., Petersen, M.R., Hines, C.J., Dong, M., Faulkner, D., Deddens, J.A., Ruder, A.M., Sullivan, D. and Boeniger, M.F. (2002) Indoor particles and symptoms among office workers: results from a double-blind cross-over study, Epidemiology, 13, 296-304.
45. Mendell, M.J., Lei-Gomez, Q., Mirer, A.G., Seppänen, O. and Brunner, G. (2008) Risk factors in heating, ventilating, and air-conditioning systems for occupant symptoms in US office buildings: the US EPA BASE study, Indoor Air, 18, 301-316.
46. Miguel, A.F., Reis, A.H. and Aydin, M. (2004) Aerosol particle deposition and distribution in bifurcating ventilation ducts, J. Hazard. Mater., 116, 249-255.
47. Miller-Leiden, S., Lobascio, C., Nazaroff, W.W. and Macher, J.M. (1996) Effectiveness of in-room air filtration and dilution ventilation for tuberculosis infection control, JAWMA, 46, 869-882.
48. Mølhave, L., Schneider, T., Kjærgaard, S.K., Larsen, L., Norn, S. and Jørgensen, O. (2000) House dust in seven Danish offices, Atmos. Environ., 34, 4767-4779.
49. Morey, P.R. (1988) Experience on the contribution of structure to environmental pollution. In: Kundisin, R.B. (ed.), Architectural Design and Indoor Microbial Pollution, New York, Oxford University Press, 40-79.
50. NADCA. (2006) Assessment, cleaning and restoration of HVAC systems (ACR 2006). NADCA National air duct cleaners association. Washington, D.C
51. NEMI. (2002) Indoor air quality (IAQ) market research. National Energy Management Institute (NEMI). Report by Management Consultants to the Construction Industry (FMI).
52. Nielsen, J.B., Valbjorn, O., Gravesen, S. and Molhave, L. (1990) Stov i ventilationsanlaeg Horsholm. Statens Byggeforskningsinstitut. 34 pp. SBI-Rapport 206.
53. Nielsen, K.F., Gravesen, S., Nielsen, P.A., Andersen, B., Thrane, U. and Frisvad, J.C. (1999) Production of mycotoxins on artificially and naturally infested building materials, Mycopathologia, 145, 43-56.
54. Nyman, E. and Sandstrom, N. (1991) Mikroorgansme i ventilations system Sweden, Byggforskningsrdet. 38 pp. R45.
55. Park, J.H., Cox-Ganser, J.M., Kreiss, K., White, S.K. and Rao, C.Y. (2008) Hydrophilic fungi and ergosterol associated with respiratory illness in a water-damaged building, Environ. Health Perspect., 116, 45-50.
56. Pasanen, P. (1998) Emissions from the Filters and Hygiene of Air Ducts in the Ventilation Systems of Office Buildings. Doctoral dissertation, Department of Environmental Sciences, University of Kuopio, Kuopio, Finland.
57. Pasanen, A.-L., Pasanen, P., Jantunen, M.J. and Kalliokoski, P. (1991) Significance of air humidity and air velocity for fungal spore release into the air, Atmos. Environ., 25, 459-462.
58. Pasanen, P., Pasanen, A.-L. and Jantunen, M.J. (1993) Water condensation promotes fungal growth in ventilation ducts, Indoor Air, 3, 106-112.
59. Pasanen, P., Pasanen, A.-L. and Kalliokoski, P. (1995) Hygienic aspects of processing oil residues in ventilation ducts, Indoor Air, 5, 62-68.
60. Pasanen, A.-L., Kujanpää, L., Pasanen, P., Kalliokoski, P. and Blomquist, G. (1997) Culturable and total fungi in dust accumulated in air ducts in single-family houses, Indoor Air, 7, 121-127.
61. Puhakka, E., Kärkkäinen, J. and Jyrkiäinen, J. (1992) Tuloilmakanaviston puhdistustyön seuranta esimerkkitapauksen avulla (Monitoring the cleaning of supply air ducts using a case study). LVIS 2000, Report 14, Espoo, pp. 82-88. (In Finnish).
62. Rylander, R. (1999) Indoor air-related effects and airborne (1→3)-beta-D-glucan, Environ. Health Perspect., 107(Suppl. 3), 501-503.
63. Schata, M., Jorde, W., Elixmann, J.H. and Linskens, H.F. (1989) Allergies to mold caused by fungal spores in air conditioning equipment, Environ Int, 15, 177-179.
64. Schleibinger, H., Laussmann, D., Bornehag, C.-G., Eis, D. and Rueden, H. (2008) Microbial volatile organic compounds in the air of moldy and mold-free indoor environments, Indoor Air, 18, 113-124.
65. Schneider, T., Kildesø, J., Petersen, O.H., Kloch, N.P. and Løbner, T. (1996) Design and calibration of a simple instrument for measuring dust on surfaces in the indoor environment, Indoor Air, 6, 204-210.
66. Schwartz, J. and Neas, L.M. (2000) Fine particles are more strongly associated than coarse particles with acute respiratory health effects in schoolchildren, Epidemiology, 11, 6-10.
67. Seppänen, O. and Fisk, W.J. (2002) Association of ventilation system type with SBS symptoms in office workers, Indoor Air, 12, 98-112.
68. Shelton, B.G., Kirkland, K.H., Flanders, W.D. and Morris, G.K. (2002) Profiles of airborne fungi in buildings and outdoor environments in the United States, Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 68, 1743-1753.
69. Sieber, W.K., Staynor, L.T., Malkin, R., Petersen, M.R., Mendell, M.J., Walligford, K.M., Crandall, M.S., Wilcox, T.G. and Reed, L. (1996) The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health Indoor Environmental Evaluation Experience. Part Three: Associations between environmental factors and self-reported health conditions, Appl. Occup. Environ. Hyg., 11, 1387-1392.
70. Sippola, M.R. and Nazaroff, W.W. (2003) Modeling particle loss in ventilation ducts, Atmos. Environ., 37, 39-40.
71. Sondossi, M. (2004) Biocides: nonpublic health, nonagricultural microbials. In: Schaechter, M. and Lederberg, J. (eds) The Desk Encyclopedia of Microbiology, Oxford, UK, Elsevier Academic Press, 147-160.
72. Szponar, B. and Larsson, L. (2000) Determination of microbial colonisation in water-damaged buildings using chemical marker analysis by gas chromatography- mass spectrometry, Indoor Air, 10, 13-18.
73. Toivola, M., Nevalainen, A. and Alm, S. (2004) Personal exposures to particles and microbes in relation to microenvironmental concentrations, Indoor Air, 14, 5.
74. Tsay, A., Roman, M.C., Chapman, E.L. and Chapman, M.D. (2000) Air duct cleaning to reduce allergen levels in the home - is it worthwhile? J. Allergy Clin. Immunol., 105, 1, Part 2, S271.
75. Wallin, O. (1991) Klimat och byggnader. Nr 1/1991. Second edition. Stockholm, Kungliga tekniska hgskolan. Intitutionen fr uppvrmnmgs- och ventilationsteknik.
76. Wan, G.H. and Li, C.S. (1999) Indoor endotoxin and glucan in association with airway inflammation and systemic symptoms, Arch. Environ. Health, 54, 172-179.
77. Weschler, C.J. (2006) Ozone's impact on public health: contributions from indoor exposures to ozone and products of ozone-initiated chemistry, Environ. Health Perspect., 114, 1489-1496.
78. Weschler, C.J. and Nazaroff, W.W. (2008) Semivolatile organic compounds in indoor environments, Atmos. Environ., 42, 9018-9040.
79. Yoshizawa, S., Ito, H., Kumagai, K., Shizawa, K., Shimizu, S., Abe, S. and Ichiki, T. (1997) Methods to Evaluate Duct Cleaning Efficiency, Tokyo, Japan, JADCA-01, Japanese Air Duct Cleaners Association.
80. Zhao, B. and Chen, J.J. (2006) Numerical analysis of particle deposition in ventilation duct, Build. Environ., 41, 710-718.