Are all crowds equally wise? A comparison of political election forecasts by experts and the public

Journal of Forecasting

Volumn 28, Issue 1, 2009, Pages 1-18

  Sjöberg, Lennart ^a,b  

^a STOCKHOLM SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS   (Sweden)

^b NORWEGIAN UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY   (Norway)

Author keywords

Election forecast; Experts; Opinion polls

Indexed keywords

NEWSPRINT; SURVEYS;

DAILY NEWSPAPERS; ELECTION FORECAST; EXPERT; FOUR-GROUP; INDIVIDUAL DIFFERENCES; MEDIAN ERRORS; OPINION POLLS; PARLIAMENTARY ELECTIONS; PUBLIC IS; SWEDISHS;

FORECASTING;

EID: 58149199741     PISSN: 02776693     EISSN: 1099131X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1002/for.1083     Document Type: Article

References (51)

1. Allen MJ, Yen WM. 2003. Introduction to Measurement Theory. Waveland Press: Long Grove, IL.
2. Andersson P. 2004. How well do financial experts perform? A review of empirical research on performance of analysts, day-traders, forecasters, fund managers, investors, and stockbrokers. No. EFI report 2004:9, Stockholm. School of Economics.
3. Andersson P, Edman J, Ekman M. 2005. Predicting the World Cup 2002: performance and confidence of experts and non-experts. International Journal of Forecasting 21: 565-576.
4. Andersson P, Gschwend T, Meffert MF, Schmidt C. 2006. Forecasting the outcome of a national election: the influence of expertise, information, and political preferences. Paper presented at the 2006 annual meeting of the International Communication Association.
5. Arrow KJ, Forsythe R, Gorham M, Hahn R, Hanson R, Ledyard JO et al. 2008. The promise of prediction markets. Science 320: 877-878.
6. Babad E. 1995. Can accurate knowledge reduce wishful thinking in voters' predictions of election outcomes? Journal of Psychology 129: 285-300.
7. Babad E. 1997. Wishful thinking among voters: motivational and cognitive influences. International Journal of Public Opinion Research 9: 105-125.
8. Babad E, Yacobos E. 1993. Wish and reality in voters' predictions of election outcomes. Political Psychology 14: 37-54.
9. Babad E, Hills M, Odriscoll M. 1992. Factors influencing wishful thinking and predictions of election outcomes. Basic and Applied Social Psychology 13: 461-476.
10. Benjamin DJ, Shapiro JM. 2006. The rational voter, thinly sliced: personal appeal as an election forecaster. Unpublished paper, Harvard University, April 24 2006.
11. Blaisa A, Mathieu T. 2003. How good are voters at sorting out the weakest candidate in their constituency? Electoral Studies 20: 1-7.
12. Camerer CF, Johnson ET. 1991. The process-performance paradox in expert judgment: how can experts know so much but predict so badly? In Toward a General Theory of Expertise: Prospects and Limits, Ericsson KA, Smith J (eds). Cambridge University Press: New York; 195-217.
13. Christiansen JD. 2007. Prediction markets: practical experiments in small markets and behaviours observed. Journal of Prediction Markets 1: 17-41.
14. Cialdini RB, Trost MR. 1998. Social influence: social norms, social conformity, and compliance. In Handbook of Social Psychology, Vol. II. McGraw-Hill: Boston, MA; 151-192.
15. Cohen J, Cohen P, West SG, Aiken LS. 2003. Applied Multiple Regression/Correlation Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. Erlbaum: Mahwah, NJ.
16. Dolan KA, Holbrook TM. 2001. Knowing versus caring: The role of affect and cognition in political perceptions. Political Psychology 22: 27-44.
17. Erikson RS, Wlezien C. 2006. Are political markets superior to polls as election predictors? Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Association for Public Opinion Research.
18. Granberg D, Holmberg S. 2002. A mass-elite comparison of wishful thinking. Social Science Quarterly 83: 1079-1085.
19. Gruca TS, Berg JE. 2007. Public information bias and prediction market accuracy. Journal of Prediction Markets 1: 219-231.
20. Irwin GA, Van Holsteyn JJ. 2002. According to the polls: the influence of opinion polls on expectations. Public Opinion Quarterly 66: 92-104.
21. Lawrence M, Goodwin P, O'Connor M, Onkal D. 2006. Judgmental forecasting: a review of progress over the last 25 years. International Journal of Forecasting 22: 493-518.
22. Leigh A, Wolfers J. 2006. Competing approaches to forecasting elections: economic models, opinion polling and prediction markets. Economic Record 82: 325-340.
23. Lemert JB. 1986. Picking the winners: politician vs voter predictions of two controversial ballot measures. Public Opinion Quarterly 50: 208-221.
24. Lewis-Beck MS, Skalaban A. 1989. Citizen forecasting: can voters see into the future? British Journal of Political Science 19: 146-153.
25. Lewis-Beck MS, Tien C. 1999. Voters as forecasters: a micromodel of election prediction. International Journal of Forecasting 15: 175-184.
26. Lowenthal D, Loewenstein G. 2001. Can voters predict changes in their own attitudes? Political Psychology 22: 65-87.
27. Mehrabian A. 1998. Effects of poll reports on voter preferences. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 28: 2119-2130.
28. Petersson O, Holmberg S. 2006. Svenska partibarometrar. En dokumentation. SNS: Stockholm.
29. Ray R. 2006. Prediction markets and the financial 'wisdom of crowds'. Journal of Behavioral Finance 7: 2-4.
30. Rhode PW, Strumpf KS. 2004. Historical presidential betting markets. Journal of Economic Perspectives 18: 127-141.
31. Schaffer LM, Schneider G. 2005. The predictive quality of political stock exchanges and polls. Politische Vierteljahresschrift 46: 674.
32. Shanteau J, Weiss DJ, Thomas R, Pounds J. 2002. Performance-based assessment of expertise: how can you tell if someone is an expert? European Journal of Operations Research 136: 253-263.
33. Sjöberg L. 1997. Valet till EU-parlamentet 1995. En socialpsykologisk studie. [The election to the EU Parliament in 1995. A social psychological study.] Styrelsen för psykologiskt försvar, Stockholm.
34. Sjöberg L. 2002. The allegedly simple structure of experts' risk perception: an urban legend in risk research. Science Technology and Human Values 27: 443-459.
35. Sjöberg L. 2004. Asking questions about risk and worry: dilemmas of the pollsters. Journal of Risk Research 7: 671-674.
36. Sjöberg L. 2005. The perceived risk of terrorism.. Risk Management 7: 43-61.
37. Sjöberg L. 2006. Opinion och attityder till förvaring av använt kärnbränsle. [Opinion and attitudes to a repository for spent nuclear fuel.] Research Report No. R-06-97. Svensk Kärnbrä nslehantering AB, Stockholm.
38. Sjöberg L. 2007a. Emotions and risk perception. Risk Management 9: 222-237.
39. Sjöberg L. 2007b. The distortion of beliefs in the face of uncertainty. International Journal of Management and Decision Making 8: 1-29.
40. Sjöberg L, Drottz-Sjöberg B-M. 2008a. Risk perception by politicians and the public. Energy and Environment 19: 455-483.
41. Sjöberg L, Drottz-Sjöberg B-M. 2008b. Attitudes towards nuclear waste and siting policy: experts and the public. In Nuclear Waste Research: Siting, Technology and Treatment, Lattefer AP (ed.). Nova: New York (in press).
42. Sunstein CR. 2005. Group judgments: statistical means, deliberation, and information markets. New York University Law Review 80: 962-1049.
43. Sunstein CR. 2006. Infotopia: How Many Minds Produce Knowledge. Oxford University Press: New York.
44. Surowiecki J. 2004. The Wisdom of Crowds: Why the Many Are Smarter than the Few and How Collective Wisdom Shapes Business, Economies, Societies and Nations. Doubleday: New York.
45. Tetlock PE. 1999. Theory-driven reasoning about plausible pasts and probable futures in world politics: are we prisoners of our preconceptions? American Journal of Political Science 43: 335-366.
46. Tetlock PE. 2005. Expert Political Judgment: How Good Is It? How Can We Know? Princeton University Press: Princeton, N.J.
47. Törngren B, Montgomery H. 2004. Worse than chance? Performance and confidence among professionals and laypeople in the stock market. Journal of Behavioral Finance 5: 148-153.
48. Tversky A, Kahneman D. 1974. Judgment under uncertainty: heuristics and biases. Science 185: 1124-1131.
49. Tziralis G, Tatsiopoulos I. 2007. Prediction markets: an extended literature review. Journal of Prediction Markets 1:75-91.
50. Wolfers J, Leigh A. 2002. Three tools for forecasting federal elections: lessons from 2001. Australian Journal of Political Science 37: 223-240.
51. Wolfers J, Zitzewitz E. 2004. Prediction markets. Journal of Economic Perspectives 18: 107-126.