The ambiguity of the embryo: Ethical inconsistency in the human embryonic stem cell debate

Metaphilosophy

Volumn 38, Issue 2-3, 2007, Pages 153-169

  Devolder, Katrien ^a   Harris, John ^b  

^a GHENT UNIVERSITY   (Belgium)

^b UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Embryo; Embryonic stem cells; Ethical inconsistency; Moral status; Potentiality

Indexed keywords

EID: 57149108263     PISSN: 00261068     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-9973.2007.00480.x     Document Type: Article

References (47)

1. Aristotle. 1984. De anima (bk. II, no. 1) and Metaphysics (bk. VII, no. 10). In The Complete Works of Aristotle, edited by Jonathan Barnes. Princeton: Princeton University Press
2. Boklage, Charles E. 1990. "Survival Probability of Human Conceptions from Fertilization to Term." International Journal of Fertility 35. no. 2:75-94
3. Bovens, Luc. 2006. "The Rhythm Method and Embryonic Death." Journal of Medical Ethics 32, no. 6:355-57
4. Brown, Grattan. 2005. "Philosophy and Theology." National Catholic Bioethics Quarterly 5, no. 3:599-606
5. Burley, Justine, and John Harris. 1999. "Human Cloning and Child Welfare." Journal of Medical Ethics 25, no. 2:121-26
6. Cohen, G. A. 1995. Self-Ownership, Freedom, and Equality. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
7. Devolder, Katrien. 2005a. "Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research: Why the Discarded-Created Distinction Cannot Be Based on the Potentiality Argument." Bioethics 19, no. 2:167-86
8. -. 2005b. "Creating and Sacrificing Embryos for Stem Cells." Journal of Medical Ethics 31, no. 6:366-70
9. -. 2006a. "What's in a Name? Embryos, Entities, and ANTities in the Stem Cell Debate." Journal of Medical Ethics 32. no. 1: 43-48
10. -. 2006b. "The Ethics and Regulation of Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research: A Critical Analysis of the Debate." Ph.D. dissertation, Ghent University
11. Devolder, Katrien, and John Harris. 2005. "Compromise and Moral Complicity in the Embryonic Stem Cell Debate." In Philosophical Reflections on Medical Ethics, edited by Nafsika Athanassoulis, 88-108. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan
12. Devolder, Katrien, and Julian Savulescu. 2006. "The Moral Imperative to Conduct Cloning and Stem Cell Research." Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 15, no. 1:7-21
13. Dworkin, Ronald. 1977. Taking Rights Seriously. London: Duckworth
14. -. 1994. Life's Dominion. London: HarperCollins
15. Edmonds, D. Keith, K. S. Lindsay, J. F. Miller, E. Williamson, and P. J. Wood. 1982. "Early Embryonic Mortality in Women." Fertility and Sterility 38:447-53
16. Finnis, John. 1995. "A Philosophical Case against Euthanasia." In Euthanasia Examined: Ethical Clinical and Legal Perspectives, edited by John Keown, 23-35. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
17. Gerami-Naini, B., O. V. Dovzhenko, M. Durning, F. H. Wegner, J. A. Thomson, and T. G. Golos. 2004. "Trophoblast Differentiation in Embryoid Bodies Derived from Human Embryonic Stem Cells." Endocrinology 145:1517-24
18. Green, Ronald M. 2001. The Human Embryo Research Debates. New York: Oxford University Press
19. Harris, John. 1980. The Value of Life. London: Routledge
20. -. 1983. "In Vitro Fertilisation: The Ethical Issues." Philosophical Quarterly 33, no. 132:217-38
21. -. 1992. Wonderwoman and Superman. Oxford: Oxford University Press
22. -. 1997. "Goodbye Dolly: The Ethics of Human Cloning." Journal of Medical Ethics 23, no. 6:353-60
23. -. 1998. "Rights and Reproductive Choice." In The Future of Human Reproduction: Choice and Regulation, edited by John Harris and Søren Holm, 5-37. Oxford: Oxford University Press
24. -. 1999. "The Concept of the Person and the Value of Life." Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 9, no. 4:293-308
25. -. 2002. "The Use of Human Embryonic Stem Cells in Research and Therapy." In A Companion to Genetics: Philosophy and the Genetic Revolution, edited by Justine C. Burley and John Harris, 158-75. Oxford: Blackwell
26. -. 2003a. "Stem Cells, Sex and Procreation." Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 12, no. 4:353-72
27. -. 2003b. "Pro-Life Is Anti-Life: The Problematic Claims of Pro-Life Positions in Ethics." In Scratching the Surface of Bioethics, edited by Matti Hayry and Tuija Takala, 99-109. Amsterdam: Rodopi
28. -. 2004. On Cloning. London: Routledge
29. -. 2005a. "Global Norms, Informed Consensus and Objectivity in Bioethics." Paper presented at the Symposium on Global Bioethics, Dartmouth College (16-18 October)
30. -. 2005b. "Scientific Research Is a Moral Duty." Journal of Medical Ethics 31, no. 4:242-48
31. Harris, John, and Søren Holm. 2003. "Abortion." In The Oxford Handbook of Practical Ethics, edited by Lafollette Hugh, 112-36. Oxford: Oxford University Press
32. Hertig, Arthur T., and John Rock. 1973. "Searching for Early Fertilised Human Ova." Gynecaelogical Investigation 4:121-39
33. Adams, Eleanor C., Arthur T. Hertig, and John Rock. 1956. "A Description of 34 Human Ova within the First 17 Days of Development." American Journal of Anatomy 98:435-93
34. Kaczor, Christopher. 2005. "Could Artificial Wombs End the Abortion Debate?" National Catholic Bioethics Quarterly 5. no. 2 (Summer): 283-301
35. Klimanskaya, Irina Y., S. Chung, S. Becker, J. Lu, and R. Lanza. 2006. "Human Embryonic Stem Cell Lines Derived from Single Blastomeres." Nature 444, no. 7118:481-85
36. Leridon, Henri. 1977. Human Fertility: The Basic Components. Chicago: University of Chicago Press
37. Li, X., W. Wei, J. Yong, Q. Jia, Y. Yu, and K. Di. 2005a. "The Genetic Heterozygosity and Fitness of Tetraploid Embryos and Embryonic Stem Cells Are Crucial Parameters Influencing Survival of Mice Derived from Embryonic Stem Cells by Tetraploid Embryo Aggregation." Reproduction 130:53-59
38. Li, X., Y. Yu, W. Wei, J. Yong, J. Yang, J. You, X. Xiong, T. Qing, and H. Deng. 2005b. "Simple and Efficient Production of Mice Derived from Embryonic Stem Cells Aggregated with Tetraploid Embryos." Molecular Reproduction and Development 71:154-58
39. Macklon, N. S., J. P. Geraedts, and B. C. Fauser. 2002. "Conception to Ongoing Pregnancy: The 'Black Box' of Early Pregnancy Loss." Human Reproduction Update 8, no. 4:333-43
40. Nagy, A., E. Gocza, E. M. Diaz, V. R. Prideaux, E. Ivanyi, M. Markkula, and J. Rossant. 1990. "Embryonic Stem Cells Alone Are Able to Support Fetal Development in the Mouse." Development 110:815-21
41. Nagy, A., J. Rossant, R. Nagy, W. Abramow-Newerly, and J. C. Roder. 1993. "Derivation of Completely Cell Culture-Derived Mice from Early-Passage Embryonic Stem Cells." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 90:8424-28
42. Persson, Ingmar. 2003. "Two Claims about Potential Human Beings." Bioethics 17, nos. 5-6:503-16
43. Raz, Joseph. 1986. The Morality of Freedom. Oxford: Clarendon Press
44. Roberts, C. J., and C. R. Lowe. 1975. "Where Have All the Conceptions Gone?" Lancet 305, no. 7905:498-99
45. Steiner, Hillel. 1994. An Essay on Rights. Oxford: Blackwell
46. Sumner, L. W. 1987. The Moral Foundation of Rights. Oxford: Clarendon Press
47. Wood, Carl. 2001. "Embryo Splitting: A Role in Infertility?" Reproduction, Fertilility and Development 13, no. 1:91-93