Evaluating collaborative fisheries management planning: A Canadian case study

Marine Policy

Volumn 32, Issue 6, 2008, Pages 867-876

  Davis, Neil A ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA   (Canada)

Author keywords

Collaborative decision making; Consensus; Fisheries management; Groundfish; Stakeholder participation

Indexed keywords

DECISION MAKING; FISHERY MANAGEMENT; LEGAL SYSTEM; PARTICIPATORY APPROACH; SECURITY; STAKEHOLDER;

CANADA; NORTH AMERICA;

EID: 50949114782     PISSN: 0308597X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.marpol.2008.01.001     Document Type: Article

References (93)

1. Cochrane K.L. Reconciling sustainability, economic efficiency, and equity in fisheries: the one that got away?. Fish and Fisheries 1 1 (2000) 3-21
2. Hernes H.K., Jentoft S., and Mikalsen K.H. Fisheries governance, social justice and participatory decision-making. In: Gray T.S. (Ed). Participation in fisheries governance (2005), Springer, Dordrecht 103-118
3. Bingham G. Resolving environmental disputes: a decade of experience (1986), The Conservation Foundation, Washington
4. Susskind L., and Cruikshank J.L. Breaking the impasse: consensual approaches to resolving public disputes (1987), Basic Books, New York
5. Wondolleck J.M., and Yaffee S.L. Making collaboration work: lessons from innovation in natural resource management (2000), Island Press, Washington
6. Sidaway R. Resolving environmental disputes: from conflict to consensus (2005), Earthscan, Sterling
7. McManus L.T., Yambao A.C., Salmo S.G., and Alino P.M. Bolinao, northern Philippines: participatory planning for coastal development. In: Buckles D. (Ed). Cultivating peace: conflict and collaboration in natural resource management (1999), International Development Research Centre, Ottawa 151-163
8. Butler M.J., Steele L.L., and Robertson R.A. Adaptive resource management in the New England groundfish fishery: implications for public participation and impact assessment. Society & Natural Resources 14 9 (2001) 791-801
9. Verheij E., Makoloweka S., and Kalombo H. Collaborative coastal management improves coral reefs and fisheries in Tanga, Tanzania. Ocean & Coastal Management 47 7/8 (2004) 309-320
10. Alpizar M.A.Q. Participation and fisheries management in Costa Rica: from theory to practice. Marine Policy 30 6 (2006) 641-650
11. da Silva P.P., and Kitts A. Collaborative fisheries management in the Northeast US: emerging initiatives and future directions. Marine Policy 30 6 (2006) 832-841
12. Baine M., Howard M., Kerr S., Edgar G., and Toral V. Coastal and marine resource management in the Galapagos Islands and the Archipelago of San Andres: issues, problems and opportunities. Ocean & Coastal Management 50 3/4 (2007) 148-173
13. Mow J.M., Taylor E., Howard M., Baine M., Connolly E., and Chiquillo M. Collaborative planning and management of the San Andres Archipelago's coastal and marine resources: a short communication on the evolution of the Seaflower marine protected area. Ocean & Coastal Management 50 3/4 (2007) 209-222
14. McCay B.J. Foxes and others in the henhouse? Environmentalists and the fishing industry in the US Regional Council System. In: Meyer R.M., Zhang C., Windsor M.L., McCay B.J., and Muth R.M. (Eds). Fisheries resource utilization and policy. Proceedings of the World Fisheries Congress, Theme 2 (1996), Science Publishers Inc., Lebanon 380-390
15. Albin C. The role of fairness in negotiation. Negotiation Journal-On the Process of Dispute Settlement 9 3 (1993) 223-244
16. Rowe G., and Frewer L.J. Public participation methods: a framework for evaluation. Science Technology & Human Values 25 1 (2000) 3-29
17. Germain R.H., Floyd D.W., and Stehman S.V. Public perceptions of the USDA Forest Service public participation process. Forest Policy and Economics 3 3/4 (2001) 113-124
18. Hunt L., and Haider W. Fair and effective decision making in forest management planning. Society & Natural Resources 14 10 (2001) 873-887
19. Smith P.D., and McDonough M.H. Beyond public participation: fairness in natural resource decision making. Society & Natural Resources 14 3 (2001) 239-249
20. Webler T. "Right" discourse in citizen participation: an evaluative yardstick. In: Renn O., Webler T., and Wiedemann P. (Eds). Fairness and competence in citizen participation: evaluating models for environmental discourse (1995), Kluwer, Dordrecht 35-86
21. Dalton T.M. Exploring participants' views of participatory coastal and marine resource management processes. Coastal Management 34 4 (2006) 351-367
22. Innes J.E., and Booher D.E. Consensus building and complex adaptive systems-a framework for evaluating collaborative planning. Journal of the American Planning Association 65 4 (1999) 412-423
23. Government of Canada. Oceans Act, 1996, Bill C 31.
24. Institute for Dispute Resolution. Independent review of improved decision making in the Pacific salmon fishery, 16 May 2001. p. 1-77.
25. Day J.C., and Gunton T.I. The theory and practice of collaborative planning in resource and environmental management. Environments 31 2 (2003) 5-20
26. Renn O., Webler T., and Wiedemann P. A need for discourse on citizen participation: objectives and structure of the book. In: Renn O., Webler T., and Wiedemann P. (Eds). Fairness and competence in citizen participation (1995), Kluwer, Dordrecht 1-16
27. Gray T.S. Theorising about participatory fisheries governance. In: Gray T.S. (Ed). Participation in fisheries governance (2005), Springer, Dordrecht 1-26
28. Wondolleck J.M., and Yaffee S.L. Collaborative ecosystem planning processes in the United States: evolution and challenges. Environments 31 2 (2003) 59-72
29. McCay B.J., and Jentoft S. From the bottom up: participatory issues in fisheries management. Society & Natural Resources 9 3 (1996) 237-250
30. Olsen M.E. Participatory pluralism (1982), Nelson-Hall, Chicago
31. Smith L.G. Public participation in policy making: the state-of-the-art in Canada. Geoforum 15 2 (1984) 253-259
32. Fiorino D.J. Citizen participation and environmental risk-a survey of institutional mechanisms. Science Technology & Human Values 15 2 (1990) 226-243
33. In: Dyer C., and McGoodwin J.R. (Eds). Folk management in the world's fisheries (1994), University of Colorado Press, Niwot
34. Fisher R., and Ury W. Getting to yes: negotiating agreement without giving in. 2nd ed. (1991), Penguin Books, Toronto
35. In: Pinkerton E. (Ed). Cooperative management of local fisheries: new directions for improved management and community development (1989), University of British Columbia Press, Vancouver
36. Jentoft S., McCay B.J., and Wilson D.C. Social theory and fisheries co-management. Marine Policy 22 4/5 (1998) 423-436
37. MacInnes D., and Davis A. Representational management or management of representation? The place of fishers in Atlantic Canadian fisheries management. In: Meyer R.M., Zhang C., Windsor M.L., McCay B.J., Hushak L.J., and Muth R.M. (Eds). Fisheries resource utilization and policy. Proceedings of the World Fisheries Congress, Theme 2 (1996), Science Publishers Inc., Lebanon 317-332
38. Pinkerton E. The contribution of watershed-based multi-party co-management agreements to dispute resolution: the Skeena Watershed Committee. Environments 23 2 (1996) 51-68
39. Mikalsen K.H., and Jentoft S. From user-groups to stakeholders? The public interest in fisheries management. Marine Policy 25 4 (2001) 281-292
40. Coffey C. What role for public participation in fisheries governance?. In: Gray T.S. (Ed). Participation in fisheries governance (2005), Springer, Dordrecht 27-44
41. Elliott G., Wiltshire B., Manan I.A., and Wismer S. Community participation in marine protected area management: Wakatobi National Park, Sulawesi, Indonesia. Coastal Management 29 4 (2001) 295-316
42. Fisheries and Oceans Canada. Pacific region-state of the fisheries, 2005.
43. Butler C. Fishing for a pension or peanuts?. Samudra 39 (2004) 8-14
44. Fisheries and Oceans Canada. Pacific region integrated fisheries management plan: groundfish, 2006.
45. Fisheries and Oceans Canada. Regional data unit statistics, 2007.
46. Pacific Fisheries Management Inc. Future direction of the commercial groundfish fisheries in British Columbia: discussion paper, June 2003.
47. Koolman J, Mose B, Stanley RD, Trager D. Developing an integrated commercial groundfish strategy for British Columbia: insights gained about participatory management. In: Heifetz J, DiCosimo G, Gharrett AJ, Love MS, O'Connell VM, Stanley RD, editors. Biology, assessment, and management of north pacific rockfishes. Fairbanks: Alaska Sea Grant College Program; 2007. p. 287-300.
48. Fisheries and Oceans Canada. Archived fisheries management plans 2002-2005. Available from: 〈http://www-ops2.pac.dfo-mpo.gc.ca/xnet/content/MPLANS/archive.htm〉 [accessed 9.12.07].
49. Fisheries and Oceans Canada. A policy for selective fishing in Canada's pacific fisheries, 2001.
50. Glavin T. The conservation of marine biological diversity and species abundance on Canada's west coast: institutional impediments. Groundfish: a case study (2001), Sierra Club of British Columbia
51. Yamanaka KL, Lacko LC. Inshore rockfish stock assessment for the west coast of Canada and recommendations for management. Canadian Science Advisory Secretariat, Research Document 2001/139, 2001.
52. Fisheries and Oceans Canada. Canada's oceans strategy, 2002.
53. Parker S.J., Berkeley S.A., Golden J.T., Gunderson D.R., Heifetz J., Hixon M.A., et al. Management of Pacific rockfish. Fisheries 25 3 (2000) 22-30
54. Hannah R.W., and Matteson K.M. Behavior of nine species of Pacific rockfish after hook-and-line capture, recompression, and release. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society 136 1 (2007) 24-33
55. Fisheries and Oceans Canada. Integrated fisheries management plan: rockfish hook and line inside. Available from: 〈http://www-ops2.pac.dfo-mpo.gc.ca/xnet/content/MPLANS/archive/2002/InsideZN02pl.PDF〉; 2002 [accessed 27.08.07].
56. Diamond Management Consulting Inc. Commercial industry caucus pilot integration proposal, 2005.
57. Thibault J.W., and Walker L. Procedural justice: a psychological analysis (1975), Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc., Hillsdale
58. Leventhal G.S. What should be done with equity theory? New approaches to the study of fairness in social relationships. In: Gergen K.J., Greenberg M.S., and Willis R.H. (Eds). Social exchange: advances in theory and research (1980), Wiley, New York 27-55
59. Bellamy J.A., McDonald G.T., Syme G.J., and Butterworth J.E. Evaluating integrated resource management. Society & Natural Resources 12 4 (1999) 337-353
60. Crosby N., Kelly J.M., and Schaefer P. Citizens panels-a new approach to citizen participation. Public Administration Review 46 2 (1986) 170-178
61. Moote M.A., McClaran M.P., and Chickering D.K. Theory in practice: applying participatory democracy theory to public land planning. Environmental Management 21 6 (1997) 877-889
62. Lauber T.B., and Knuth B.A. Measuring fairness in citizen participation: a case study of moose management. Society & Natural Resources 12 1 (1999) 19-37
63. Webler T., and Tuler S. Fairness and competence in citizen participation-theoretical reflections from a case study. Administration & Society 32 5 (2000) 566-595
64. McCool S.F., and Guthrie K. Mapping the dimensions of successful public participation in messy natural resources management situations. Society & Natural Resources 14 4 (2001) 309-323
65. Leach W.D., Pelkey N.W., and Sabatier P.A. Stakeholder partnerships as collaborative policymaking: evaluation criteria applied to watershed management in California and Washington. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 21 4 (2002) 645-670
66. Halvorsen K.E. Assessing the effects of public participation. Public Administration Review 63 5 (2003) 535-543
67. Frame T.M., Gunton T., and Day J.C. The role of collaboration in environmental management: an evaluation of land and resource planning in British Columbia. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 47 1 (2004) 59-82
68. Mascarenhas M., and Scarce R. "The intention was good": legitimacy, consensus-based decision making, and the case of forest planning in British Columbia, Canada. Society & Natural Resources 17 1 (2004) 17-38
69. Branch K.M., and Bradbury J.A. Comparison of DOE and army advisory boards: application of a conceptual framework for evaluating public participation in environmental risk decision making. Policy Studies Journal 34 4 (2006) 723-753
70. Kvale S. InterViews: an introduction to qualitative research interviewing (1996), Sage, Thousand Oaks
71. Yin R.K. Case study research: design and methods. 2nd ed. (1994), Sage, Thousand Oaks
72. Boyatzis R.E. Transforming qualitative information: thematic analysis and code development (1998), Sage, Thousand Oaks
73. Wondolleck J.M., and Ryan C.M. What hat do I wear now? An examination of agency roles in collaborative processes. Negotiation Journal-On the Process of Dispute Settlement 15 2 (1999) 117-133
74. Pinkerton E. Watershed partnerships: how much have we learned?. In: Krueger C., and Zimmerman C. (Eds). Symposium on the sustainability of the Arctic-Yukon-Kuskokwim salmon fisheries (2007), Alaska SeaGrant, Anchorage
75. Schelling T.S. The strategy of conflict (1960), Harvard University, Cambridge
76. Leach W.D., and Pelkey N.W. Making watershed partnerships work: a review of the empirical literature. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management 127 6 (2001) 378-385
77. Harter P.J. Negotiating regulations-a cure for malaise. Georgetown Law Journal 71 1 (1982) 1-118
78. Susskind L., and McMahon G. The theory and practice of negotiated rulemaking. Yale Journal on Regulation 3 1 (1985) 133-166
79. Leach W., and Sabatier P. Facilitators, coordinators and outcomes. In: O'Leary R., and Bingham L.B. (Eds). The promise and performance of environmental conflict resolution (2003), Resources for the Future, Washington, DC 148-171
80. Schuett M.A., Selin S.W., and Carr D.S. Making it work: keys to successful collaboration in natural resource management. Environmental Management 27 4 (2001) 587-593
81. Chess C., and Purcell K. Public participation and the environment: do we know what works?. Environmental Science & Technology 33 16 (1999) 2685-2692
82. Smith C.L., and Gilden J. Assets to move watershed councils from assessment to action. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 38 3 (2002) 653-663
83. Chuenpagdee R., and Jentoft S. Step zero for fisheries co-management: what precedes implementation. Marine Policy 31 6 (2007) 657-668
84. Holland D., Gudmundsson E., and Gates J. Do fishing vessel buyback programs work: a survey of the evidence. Marine Policy 23 1 (1999) 47-69
85. Scholz A., Bonzon K., Fujita R., Benjamin N., Woodling N., Black P., et al. Participatory socioeconomic analysis: drawing on fishermen's knowledge for marine protected area planning in California. Marine Policy 28 4 (2004) 335-349
86. Stump N.E., and Kriwoken L.K. Tasmanian marine protected areas: attitudes and perceptions of wild capture fishers. Ocean & Coastal Management 49 5/6 (2006) 298-307
87. Jentoft S., Mikalsen K.H., and Hernes H.K. Representation in fisheries co-management. In: Wilson D.C., Nielsen J.R., and Degnbol P. (Eds). The fisheries co-management experience: accomplishments, challenges and prospects (2003), Kluwer, Dordrecht 281-292
88. Cloutier T. Conflicts of interest on regional fishery management councils: corruption or cooperative management?. Ocean and Coastal Law Journal 2 (1996) 101-152
89. Young J.A., Smith A.P., and Muir J.F. Representing the individual fishermen: an attitudinal perspective on one PO's membership. Marine Policy 20 2 (1996) 157-169
90. In: Wilson D.C., Nielsen J.R., and Degnbol P. (Eds). The fisheries co-management experience: accomplishments, challenges, and prospects (2003), Kluwer, Boston
91. Pomeroy R., Parks J., Pollnac R., Campson T., Genio E., Marlessy C., et al. Fish wars: conflict and collaboration in fisheries management in Southeast Asia. Marine Policy 31 6 (2007) 645-656
92. Heylings P., and Bravo M. Evaluating governance: a process for understanding how co-management is functioning, and why, in the Galapagos Marine Reserve. Ocean & Coastal Management 50 3/4 (2007) 174-208
93. Pretty J. Social capital and the collective management of resources. Science 302 5652 (2003) 1912-1914