Reflections on the legitimacy of regional environmental governance: Lessons from Australia's experiment in natural resource management

Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning

Volumn 10, Issue 1, 2008, Pages 1-30

  Wallington, Tabatha ^a   Lawrence, Geoffrey ^a   Loechel, Barton ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF QUEENSLAND   (Australia)

Author keywords

Democracy; Environmental governance; Legitimacy; Natural resource management; Regional governance

Indexed keywords

EID: 43949119383     PISSN: 1523908X     EISSN: 15227200     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/15239080701652763     Document Type: Article

References (132)

1. Abrahams, H. (2005) Devolution enhances integration, Australasian Journal of Environmental Management, 12(Supplementary issue), pp. 57-61.
2. Adams, D. (2004) Usable knowledge in public policy, Australian Journal of Public Administration, 63, pp. 29-42.
3. AFFA (Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry - Australia) (1999) Managing Natural Resources in Rural Australia for a Sustainable Future: A Discussion Paper for Developing a National Policy (Canberra: AFFA).
4. Agrawal, A. & Ribot, J. (1999) Accountability in decentralization: a framework with South Asian and West African cases, The Journal of Developing Areas, 33, pp. 473-502.
5. Amin, A. (2004) Regions unbound: towards a new politics of place, Geografiska Annaler B, 86, pp. 33-44.
6. Australian Government (2005) Intergovernmental Agreement on a National Action Plan for Salinity and Water Quality. Available at http://www.napswq.gov.au/publications/iga.html (accessed 18 April 2007).
7. Babbie, E. (1999) The Basics of Social Research (Belmont, CA: Wadsworth).
8. Bates, G. (2003) Legal perspectives, in: S. Dovers & S. Wild River (Eds) Managing Australia's Environment, pp. 255-301 (Sydney: Federation Press).
9. Beer, A., Clower, T., Haughtow, G. & Maude, A. (2005) Neoliberalism and the institutions for regional development in Australia, Geographical Research, 43, pp. 49-58.
10. Beetham, D. (1991) The Legitimation of Power (Basingstoke, Macmillan).
11. Bell, S. (2004) 'Appropriate' policy knowledge, and institutional and governance implications, Australian Journal of Public Administration, 63, pp. 22-28.
12. Bell, S. & Park, A. (2006) The problematic metagovernance of networks: water reform in New South Wales, Journal of Public Policy, 26, pp. 63-83.
13. Benhabib, S. (1996) Toward a deliberative model of democratic legitimacy, in: Benhabib, S. (Ed.) Democracy and Difference (Princeton: Princeton University Press).
14. Bogason, P. & Musso, J. A. (2005) The democratic prospects of network governance, American Review of Public Administration, 36, pp. 3-18.
15. Bogason, P (2006) Networks and bargaining in policy analysis in: G. Peters & J. Pierre (Eds) Handbook of Public Policy (London: Sage Publications).
16. Bolton, G. C. (1982) Court in power, Westerly, 27, pp. 57-64.
17. Bradsen, J. (1988) Soil Conservation Legislation in Australia. Report to the National Soil Conservation Program (Adelaide: University of Adelaide).
18. Bulkeley, H. & Mol, A. P. J. (2003) Participation and environmental governance: consensus, ambivalence and debate, Environmental Values, 12, pp. 143-154.
19. Bulkeley, H., Davies, A., Evans, B., Gibbs, D., Kern, K. & Theobald, K. (2003) Environmental governance and transnational municipal networks in Europe, Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning, 5, pp. 235-254.
20. Bulkeley, H., Watson, M., Hudson, R. & Weaver, P. (2005) Governing municipal waste: towards a new analytical framwork, Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning, 7, pp. 1-23.
21. Chambers, S. (1996) Reasonable Democracy: Jürgen Habermas and the politics of Discourse (Ithaca NY: Cornell University Press).
22. Cheshire, L., Higgins, V. & Lawrence, G. (Eds) (2007) Rural Governance: International Perspectives (London: Routledge).
23. Cohen, J. (1989) Deliberation and democratic legitimacy, in: A. Hamlin and P. Pettit (Eds) The Good Polity (Oxford: Blackwell).
24. Commonwealth of Australia (2004) Our Vital Resources: A National Action Plan for Salinity and Water Quality (Canberra: Council of Australian Governments). Available at http://www.napswq.gov. au/publications/vital- resources.html (accessed 18 April 2007).
25. Commonwealth of Australia and State of Queensland (2004) Bilateral Agreement Between the Commonwealth of Australia and the State of Queensland to Deliver the Natural Heritage Trust. Departments of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry and the Environment and Heritage (Canberra: Australia).
26. Connelly, S., Richardson, T & Miles, T. (2006) Situated legitimacy: deliberative arenas and the new rural governance, Journal of Rural Studies, 22, pp. 267-277.
27. Contandriopoulos, D., Denis, J., Langley, A. & Valette, A. (2004) Governance structures and political processes in a public system: lessons from Quebec, Public Administration, 82, pp. 627-655.
28. Cortner, H. J. & Moote, M. A. (1999) The Politics of Ecosystem Management (Washington, DC: Island Press).
29. Cowell, R. & Flynne, A. (2006) Editorial-seven years of JEPP, Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning, 8, pp. 1-8.
30. Cowell, R. & Murdoch, J. (1999) Land use and the limits to (regional) governance: some lessons from planning for housing and minerals in England, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 23, pp. 654-669.
31. Craig, A. & Vanclay, F. (2005) Questioning the potential of deliberativeness to achieve 'acceptable' natural resource management decisions, in: J. Martin & R. Eversole (Eds) Participation and Governance in Regional Development (Aldershot, UK: Ashgate).
32. Curtis, A. (2003) The Landcare experience, in: S. Dovers and S. Wild River (Eds) Managing Australia's Environment (Sydney: Federation Press).
33. Curtis, A. & Lockwood, M. (2000) Landcare and catchment management in Australia: lessons for state-sponsored community participation, Society and Natural Resources, 13, pp. 61-73.
34. Davidson, D. J. & Frickel, S. (2004) Understanding environmental governance: a critical review, Organization & Environment, 17, pp. 471-492.
35. Davies, A. R. (2002) Power, politics and networks: shaping partnerships for sustainable communities, Area, 34, pp. 190-203.
36. Department of Environment and Heritage (DEH) (2003a) National Natural Resource Management Monitoring and Evaluation Framework (Natural Resource Management Ministerial Council). Available at http://www.nrm.gov.au/monitoring/ (accessed 18 April 2007).
37. DEH (2003b) National Framework for Natural Resource Management Standards and Targets, Endorsed by the Natural Resource Management Ministerial Council. Available at: http://www.nrm.gov.au/monitoring (accessed 18 April 2007).
38. Dovers, S. (2003) Reflecting on three decades: a synthesis, in: S. Dovers & S. Wild River (Eds) Managing Australia's Environment, pp. 515-535 (Sydney: The Federation Press).
39. Dryzek, J. (2000) Deliberative Democracy and Beyond (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
40. Dryzek, J. (2001) Legitimacy and economy in deliberative democracy, Political Theory, 29, pp. 651-669.
41. Everingham, J., Cheshire, L. & Lawrence, G. (2006) Regional renaissance? New forms of governance in nonmetropolitan Australia. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 24, 139-155.
42. Ewing, S. (2003) Catchment management arrangements, in: S. Dovers & S. Wild River (Eds) Managing Australia's Environment, pp. 393-412 (Sydney: The Federation Press).
43. Fischer, F. (2006) Participatory governance as deliberate empowerment: cultural politics and the facilitation of discursive space, American Review of Public Administration, 36, pp. 19-40.
44. Fitzroy Basin Association (FBA) (2003) Draft Central Queensland Strategy for Sustainability 2 (Rockhampton: FBA).
45. Fitzroy Basin Association (FBA) (2006) Fitzroy Basin Association Homepage. Available at http://www.fba.org.au (accessed 18 April 2007).
46. Goodwin, M. (1998) The governance of rural areas: some emerging research issues and agendas, Journal of Rural Studies, 14, pp. 5-12.
47. Gibbs, D., While, A. & Jonas, A. E. G. (2007) Governing nature conservation: the European Union Habitats Directive and conflict around estuary management, Environment and Planning A, 39, pp. 339-358.
48. Gray, I. & Lawrence, G. (2001) A Future for Regional Australia: Escaping Global Misfortune (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
49. Grimes, J. (1998) Introduction, in: J. Grimes, G. Lawrence & D. Stehlik (Eds) Sustainable Futures: Towards a Catchment Management Strategy for the Central Queensland Region, pp. 3-5 (Rockhampton: Institute for Sustainable Regional Development).
50. Habermas, J. (1975) Legitimation Crisis (Cambridge, MA: Beacon).
51. Handke, B. & Baldwin, M. (2003) Working with the community to develop policy and to deliver on-ground action, Canberra Bulletin of Public Administration, 108, pp. 42-44.
52. Hansen, K. (2005) Representative government and network governance - in need of 'co-governance': lessons from local decision making on public schools in Denmark, Scandinavian Political Studies, 28, pp. 219-237.
53. Head, B. (2005) Participation or co-governance? Challenges for regional natural resource management, in: J. Martin & R. Eversole (Eds) Participation and Governance in Regional Development (Aldershot: Ashgate).
54. Head, B. W. (1997) Corporatism, in: D. Woodward, A. Parkin & Summers J. (Eds) Government, Politics, Power and Policy in Australia, 6th ed. (Melbourne: Longman).
55. Head, B. & Ryan, N. (2004) Can co-governance work? Regional natural resource management in Queensland, Australia, Society and Economy, 26, pp. 361-382.
56. Humphrey, L. & Shaw, K. (2004) Regional devolution and democratic renewal: developing a radical approach to stakeholder involvement in the English regions, Environment and Planning A, 36, pp. 2183-2202.
57. Hutchcroft, P. D. (2001) Centralization and decentralization in administration and politics: assessing territorial dimensions of power and authority, Governance: An International Journal of Policy and Administration, 14, pp. 23-53.
58. Industry Commission (1998) A Full Repairing Lease: Inquiry into Ecologically Sustainable Land Management. Final Report (Melbourne: Industry Commission).
59. Jessop, B. (1995) The regulation approach, governance and post-Fordism: alternative perspectives on economic and political change? Economy and Society, 24, pp. 307-333.
60. Jessop, B. (2002) The Future of the Capitalist State (Cambridge: Polity Press).
61. Joint Steering Committee (2002) Guidelines for Developing a Regional Natural Resource Management Plan in Queensland (Australia: Queensland Government and Commonwealth of Australia).
62. Jordan, A. (2001) The European Union: an evolving system of multi-level governance . . . or government? Policy and Politics, 29, pp. 193-208.
63. Jordan, A., Wurzel, R. K. W. & Zito, R. (2003) Policy innovation or 'muddling through'? 'New' environmental policy instruments in the United Kingdom, Environmental Politics, 12, 179-200.
64. Krell-Laluhová, Z. & Schneider, S. (2004) Legitimacy and the democratic quality of the political order in Britain, Germany and Switzerland: a discourse analytical perspective. Paper presented at ECPR Joint Sessions of Workshops, April 13-18, University of Uppsala, Sweden. Available at http:// www.essex.ac.uk/ecpr/events/jointsessions/paperarchive/uppsala/ws12/ KrellLaluhovaSchnieder.pdf (accessed 25 November 2006).
65. Lafferty, W. & Meadowcroft, J. (2000) Concluding perspectives, in: W. Lafferty & J. Meadowcroft (Eds) Implementing Sustainable Development: Strategies and Initiatives in High Consumption Societies (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
66. Lane, M. B. (2003) Participation, decentralization, and civil society: indigenous rights and democracy in environmental planning, Journal of Planning Education and Research, 22, pp. 360-372.
67. Lane, M. B. & Corbett, T. (2005) The tyranny of localism: indigenous participation in community-based environmental management, Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning, 7, pp. 141-159.
68. Lane, M. B. & Morrison, T. H. (2006) Public interest or private agenda? A meditation on the role of NGOs in environmental policy and management in Australia, Journal of Rural Studies, 22, pp. 232-242.
69. Lane, M. B., McDonald, G. T. & Morrison, T. H. (2004) Decentralisation and environmental management in Australia: a comment on the prescriptions of the Wentworth Group, Australian Geographical Studies, 42, pp. 103-115.
70. Lawrence, G. (2005) The regional approach to natural resource management in Australia: achievements and continuing concerns. Paper presented at the 11th International Symposium on Society and Resource Management, June 16-19, Ostersund, Sweden.
71. Lawrence, G. & Cheshire, L. (2004) Managing nature: the promises and problems of regional environmental governance in Australia. Plenary Address at the Ecopolitics XV Conference, Environmental Governance: Transforming Regions and Localities, November 12-14, Graduate School of the Environment, Macquarie University, Sydney.
72. Lawrence, G., Richards, C. & Cheshire, L. (2005) The environmental enigma: why do producers professing stewardship continue to practice poor natural resource management? Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, 6, pp. 1-20.
73. Leach, M., Mearns, R. & Scoones, I. (1999) Environmental entitlements: dynamics and institutions in community-based natural resource management, World Development, 27, pp. 225-247.
74. Lockie, S. (1994) Farmers and the state: local knowledge and self-help in rural environmental management, Regional Journal of Social Issues, 28, pp. 24-38.
75. Lockie, S. (1999) The state, rural environments and globalisation: 'action at a distance' via the Australian Landcare Program, Environment and Planning A, 31, pp. 597-611.
76. Lockie, S. (2000) Environmental governance and legitimation: state-community interactions and agricultural land degradation in Australia, Capitalism, Nature, Socialism, 11, pp. 41-58.
77. Lockie, S. (2004) Collective agency, non-human causality and environmental social movements: a case study of the Australian 'Landcare movement', Journal of Sociology, 40, pp. 41-58.
78. Lockie, S. (2006) Networks of agri-environmental action: temporality, spatiality and identity in agricultural environments, Sociologia Ruralis, 46, pp. 22-39.
79. Lockie, S. & Higgins, V. (2007) Roll-out neoliberalism and hybrid practices of regulation in Australian agri-environmental governance, Journal of Rural Studies, 23, pp. 1-11.
80. Lockwood, M., Curtis, A. & Davidson, J. (2005) Regional governance of natural resource management: the Australian experience. Paper presented at the International Symposium on Sustainable Resource Management, June, Östersund, Sweden.
81. Loechel, B., Lawrence, G. & Cheshire, L. (2005) Multi-sectoral collaboration in Central Queensland: bringing the state back in? Paper presented at the United National International Conference on Engaging Communities, August 14-17, Brisbane, Australia.
82. Loudon, M. (2000) Public and private: the shifting boundary, Canberra Bulletin of Public Administration, 96, pp. 9-12.
83. Macnaghten, P. & Urry, J. (1998) Contested Natures (London: Sage).
84. Majone, G. (1999) The regulatory state and its legitimacy problems, West European Politics, 22, pp. 1-24.
85. Manin, B. (1987) On legitimacy and political deliberation, Political Theory, 15, pp. 351-352.
86. Mansbridge, J. (1999) Everyday talk in the deliberative system, in: S. Macedo (Ed.) Deliberative Politics: essays on 'Democracy and Disagreement', pp. 211-239 (New York: Oxford University Press).
87. Martin, J. & Eversole, R. (2006) Organizing regionally for natural resource management in Australia: reflections on agency and government, Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning, 8, pp. 259-277.
88. Moore, S. A. (2005) Regional delivery of natural resource management in Australia: is it democratic and does it matter? in: Martin, J.& Eversole, R. (Eds) Participation and Governance in Regional Development (Aldershot: Ashgate).
89. Morrison, T. H. & Lane, M. B. (2004) The rise and rise of environmental NGOs: unforeseen risks to democratic environmental governance in Australia. Refereed paper presented to the Australasian Political Studies Association Conference, September 29-October 1, University of Adelaide.
90. Morrison, T. H., McDonald, G. T. & Lane, M. B. (2004) Integrating natural resource management for better environmental outcomes, Australian Geographer, 35, pp. 243-258.
91. Mues, C., Chapman, L. & Van Hilst, R. (1998) Landcare: Promoting Improved Land Management Practices on Australian Farms (Canberra: Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics).
92. National Natural Resource Management Taskforce (NNRMTF) (1999) Managing Natural Resources in Australia for a Sustainable Future (Canberra: Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry, Australia).
93. O'Neill, J. (2001) Representing people, representing nature, representing the world. Environment and Planning C, 19, pp. 483-500.
94. Papadakis, E. & Grant, R. (2003) The politics of 'light handed regulation': new environmental policy instruments in Australia, Environmental Politics 12, 27-49.
95. Papadopoulos, Y. (2003) Cooperative forms of governance: problems of democratic accountability in complex environments, European Journal of Political Research, 42, pp. 473-501.
96. Parkins, J. R. (2006) De-centering environmental governance: a short history and analysis of democratic processes in the forest sector of Alberta, Canada, Policy Sciences, 39, pp. 183-203.
97. Parkins, J. R. & Mitchell, R. E. (2005) Public participation as public debate: a deliberative turn in natural resource management, Society and Natural Resources, 18, pp. 529-540.
98. Parkinson, J. (2003) Legitimacy problems in deliberative democracy, Political Studies, 51, pp. 180-196.
99. Paton, S., Curtis, A., McDonald, G. & Woods, M. (2004) Regional natural resource management: is it sustainable, Australasian Journal of Environmental Management, 11, pp. 259-267.
100. Pellizzoni, L. (2003) Uncertainty and participatory democracy, Environmental Values, 12, pp. 195-224.
101. Pellizzoni, L. (2004) Responsibility and environmental governance, Environmental Politics, 13, pp. 541-565.
102. Peters, G. (2000) Governance and comparative politics, in: J. Pierre (Ed.) Debating Governance: Authority, Steering and Democracy (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
103. Peters, G. & Pierre, J. (2001) Developments in intergovernmental relations: towards multi-level governance, Policy and Politics, 29, pp. 131-135.
104. Pierre, J. & Peters, G. (2000) Governance, Politics and the State (London: MacMillan).
105. Pini, B. & Haslam McKenzie, F. (2006) Challenging local government notions of community engagement as unnecessary, unwanted and unproductive: case studies from rural Australia, Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, 8, 1, pp. 27-44.
106. Queensland Department of Natural Resources and Mines (2005) Options for Future Community Engagement in Regional Natural Resource Management (Brisbane: Queensland Government). Available at http://www.regionalnrm.qld.gov. au/options_paper/options_paper.pdf (accessed 25 November 2006).
107. Reddel, T. & Woolcock, G. (2004) From consultation to participatory governance? A critical review of citizen engagement strategies in Queensland, Australian Journal of Public Administration, 63, pp. 75-87.
108. Reeve, I. (2001) Property rights and natural resource management: tiptoeing round the slumbering dragon, in: S. Lockie & L. Bourke (Eds), Rurality Bites: The Social and Environmental Transformation of Rural Australia, pp. 257-269 (Sydney/Pluto press).
109. Rhodes, R. A. W. (1996) The new governance: governing without government, Political Studies, XLIV, pp. 652-667.
110. Rhodes, R. A. W. (1997) Understanding Governance: Policy Networks, Governance, Reflexivity and Accountability (Buckingham, Philadelphia: Open University Press).
111. Ribot, J. C. (2002) Democratic Decentralisation of Natural Resources: Institutionalizing Popular Participation (Washington, DC; World Resources Institute).
112. Scharpf, F. W. (1994) Games real actors could play: positive and negative coordination in embedded negotiations, Journal of Theoretical Politics, 6, pp. 27-53.
113. Shortall, S. (2004) Social or economic goals, civic inclusion or exclusion? An analysis of rural development theory and practice, Sociologia Ruralis, 44, pp. 109-123.
114. Skelcher, C., Mathur, N. & Smith, M. (2005) The public governance of collaborative spaces: discourse, design and democracy, Public Administration, 83, pp. 573-596.
115. Sørensen, E. & Torfing, J. (2005) The democratic anchorage of governance networks, Scandinavian Political Studies, 28, pp.195-218.
116. Stanley, K. G., Marsden, T. K. & Milbourne, P. (2005) Governance, rurality, and nature: exploring emerging discourses of state forestry in Britain, Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 23, pp. 679-695.
117. Steering Committee (2000) Steering Committee Report to Australian Governments on the Public Response to 'Managing Natural Resources in Rural Australia for a Sustainable Future: A Discussion Paper for Developing a National Policy (Canberra: Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry, Australia).
118. Stoker, G. (1998) Governance as theory: five propositions, International Science Journal, 155, pp. 17-28.
119. Stoker, G. (2000) The challenge of governance. Paper to Conference in Danish Association of Political Science, October, Hindsgavl Solt.
120. Stoker, G. (2006) Public value management: a new narrative for networked governance? American Review of Public Administration, 36, pp. 41-57.
121. Tendler, J. (1997) Good Government in the Tropics (Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press).
122. Vanclay, F. & Lawrence, G. (1995) The Environmental Imperative: Eco-Social Concerns for Australian Agriculture (Rockhampton, Australia: CQU Press).
123. Walls, J., O'Riordan, T., Horlick-Jones, T. & Niewöhner, J. (2005) The meta-governance of risk and new technologies: GM crops and mobile phones, Journal of Risk Research, 8, pp. 635-661.
124. Warren, M. E. (1996) Deliberative democracy and authority, American Political Science Review, 90, pp. 46-60.
125. Watson, C. (1992) An ecologically unsustainable agriculture, in: Lawrence, G. Vanclay, F. & Furze, B. (Eds) Agriculture, Environment and Society: Contemporary Issues for Australia, pp. 19-32 (Melbourne: Macmillan).
126. Weber, M. (1919) Politik als Beruf, in:Winckelmann, J. (Ed) Gesammelte politische Schriften, pp. 505-560 (Tubingen: Mohr).
127. Weiss, L. (1998) The Myth of the Powerless State (Cambridge: Polity Press).
128. Whelan, J. & Oliver, P. (2004) Regional community-based planning: the challenge of participatory environmental governance. paper presented at the Tenth International Sustainable Development Conference, March, Manchester, UK.
129. Whelan, J. & Oliver, P. (2005) The Place, Limits and Practice of Collaboration: lessons from case studies in community participation in natural resource management. Technical Report 56 (Queensland: Cooperative Research Centre for Coastal Zone, Estuary and Waterway Management).
130. Whitehead, M. (2003) 'In the shadow of hierarchy': meta-governance, policy reform and urban regeneration in the West Midlands, Area, 35, pp. 6-14.
131. Wondelleck, J. M. & Yaffee, S. L. (2000) Making Collaboration Work: Lessons from Innovation in Natural Resource Management (Washington, DC: Island Press).
132. Young, I. M. (2000) Inclusion and Democracy (Oxford: Oxford University Press).