Maternal Employment and Children's Achievement in Context: A Meta-Analysis of Four Decades of Research

Psychological Bulletin

Volumn 134, Issue 1, 2008, Pages 77-108

  Goldberg, Wendy A ^a   Prause, JoAnn ^a   Lucas Thompson, Rachel ^a   Himsel, Amy ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^b El Camino College   (United States)

Author keywords

achievement; grades; intelligence; maternal employment; meta analysis

Indexed keywords

ACHIEVEMENT; ADOLESCENT; AGE; ARTICLE; CHILD; CHILD BEHAVIOR; CHILD CARE; COGNITION; CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY; EDUCATIONAL STATUS; EMPLOYMENT; ETHNIC GROUP; FAMILY; FEMALE; HUMAN; INTELLIGENCE; LONGITUDINAL STUDY; MALE; META ANALYSIS; MOTHER; PHYSIOLOGY; PRESCHOOL CHILD; PSYCHOLOGICAL ASPECT; RACE; SEX DIFFERENCE; SOCIOECONOMICS; STATISTICS; TIME;

ACHIEVEMENT; ADOLESCENT; AGE FACTORS; CHILD; CHILD BEHAVIOR; CHILD CARE; CHILD, PRESCHOOL; COGNITION; CONTINENTAL POPULATION GROUPS; CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDIES; EDUCATIONAL STATUS; EMPLOYMENT; ETHNIC GROUPS; FAMILY; FEMALE; HUMANS; INTELLIGENCE; LONGITUDINAL STUDIES; MALE; MOTHERS; SEX FACTORS; SOCIOECONOMIC FACTORS; TIME FACTORS;

EID: 38549114209     PISSN: 00332909     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1037/0033-2909.134.1.77     Document Type: Article

References (125)

1. Alessandri S.M. Effects of maternal work status in single-parent families on children's perception of self and family and school achievement. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 54 (1992) 417-433
2. Anderson B., Mead N., and Sullivan S. Mothers working outside the home: What do national assessment results tell us? (1986), Educational Testing Service, Princeton, NJ
3. Armistead L., Wierson M., and Forehand R. Adolescents and maternal employment: Is it harmful for a young adolescent to have an employed mother?. Journal of Early Adolescence 10 (1990) 260-278
4. Auerbach J., Lerner Y., Barasch M., and Palti H. Maternal and environmental characteristics as predictors of child behavior problems and cognitive competence. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry 62 (1992) 409-420
5. Banducci R. The effect of mother's employment on the achievement, aspirations, and expectations of the child. Personnel & Guidance Journal 46 (1967) 263-267
6. Barnett R.C., and Rivers C. She works/he works: How two-income families are happier, healthier and better off (1998), Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
7. Baum C.L. Does early maternal employment harm child development? An analysis of the potential benefits of leave taking. Journal of Labor Economics 21 (2003) 409-448
8. Baum C.L. The long-term effects of early and recent maternal employment on a child's academic achievement. Journal of Family Issues 25 (2004) 29-60
9. Baydar N., and Brooks-Gunn J. Effects of maternal employment and child-care arrangements on preschoolers' cognitive and behavioral outcomes: Evidence from the children of the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth. Developmental Psychology 27 (1991) 932-945
10. Beyer S. Maternal employment and children's academic achievement: Parenting styles as mediating variable. Developmental Review 15 (1995) 212-253
11. Blau F.D., and Grossberg A.J. Maternal labor supply and children's cognitive development. Review of Economics and Statistics 74 (1992) 474-481
12. Bogenschneider K., and Steinberg L. Maternal employment and adolescent's academic achievement: A developmental analysis. Sociology of Education 67 (1994) 60-77
13. Borenstein M., Rothstein D., and Cohen J. Comprehensive Meta-Analysis. A computer program for research synthesis (Version 2.0) [Computer software] (2005), Biostat, Englewood, NJ
14. Bowlby J. Maternal care and mental health (Monograph Series No. 2) (1952), World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland
15. Bronfenbrenner U., and Crouter A.C. Work and family through time and space. In: Kamerman S.B., and Hayes C.D. (Eds). Families that work: Children in a changing world (1982), National Academy Press, Washington, DC 39-83
16. Brooks-Gunn J., Han W.-J., and Waldfogel J. Maternal employment and child cognitive outcomes in the first three years of life: The NICHD Study of Early Child Care. Child Development 73 (2002) 1052-1072
17. Brooks-Gunn J., Klebanov P., Smith J.R., and Lee K. Effects of combining public assistance and employment on mothers and their young children. Women & Health 32 (2001) 179-210
18. Brutsaert H. Home and school influences on academic performance: State and Catholic elementary schools in Belgium compared. Educational Review 30 (1998) 37-43
19. Burchinal L.G., and Rossman J.E. Relations among maternal employment indices and developmental characteristics of children. Marriage & Family Living 23 (1961) 334-340
20. Chase-Lansdale P.L., Mott F.L., Brooks-Gunn J., and Phillips D.A. Children of the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth: A unique research opportunity. Developmental Psychology 27 (1991) 918-931
21. Cherry F.F., and Eaton E.L. Physical and cognitive development in children of low-income mothers working in the child's early years. Child Development 48 (1977) 158-166
22. Cohen J. Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. 2nd ed. (1988), Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ
23. Coley R.L., Morris J.E., and Hernandez D. Out-of-school care and problem behavior trajectories among low-income adolescents: Individual, family, and neighborhood characteristics as added risks. Child Development 75 (2004) 948-965
24. Cooper H., and Hedges L. The handbook of research synthesis (1994), Russell Sage Foundation, New York
25. Crouter A.C., McDermid S., McHale S.M., and Perry-Jenkins M. Parental monitoring and perceptions of children's school performance and conduct in dual- and single-earner families. Developmental Psychology 26 (1990) 649-657
26. Davis J.A., Smith T.W., and Marsden D.V. General Social Surveys. 1972-1998: Cumulative codebook (1999), National Opinion Research Center, Chicago
27. Desai S., Chase-Lansdale P.L., and Michael R.T. Mother or market? Effects of maternal employment on the intellectual ability of 4-year-old children. Demography 26 (1989) 545-561
28. Duval S. The trim and fill method. In: Rothstein H., Sutton A., and Borenstein M. (Eds). Publication bias in meta-analysis: Prevention, assessment and adjustments (2005), Wiley, West Sussex, England 127-144
29. Duval S., and Tweedie R. Trim and fill: A simple funnel-plot-based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis. Biometrics 56 (2000) 455-463
30. Eagly A. Sex differences in social behavior: A social-role interpretation (1987), Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ
31. Farel A.M. Effects of preferred maternal roles, maternal employment, and sociodemographic status on school adjustment and competence. Child Development 51 (1980) 1179-1186
32. Fraiberg S. Every child's birthright: In defense of mothering (1977), Basic Books, New York
33. Gold D., and Andres D. Comparisons of adolescent children with employed and nonemployed mothers. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly 24 (1978) 243-254
34. Gold D., and Andres D. Developmental comparison between ten-year-old children with employed and nonemployed mothers. Child Development 49 (1978) 75-84
35. Gold D., and Andres D. Relations between maternal employment and development of nursery school children. Canadian Journal of Behavioral Science 10 2 (1978) 116-129
36. Gold D., Andres D., and Glorieux J. The development of Francophone nursery-school children with employed and nonemployed women. Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science 11 (1979) 169-173
37. Goldberg W.A., and Easterbrooks M.A. Maternal employment when children are toddlers and kindergartners. In: Gottfried A.E., and Gottfried A.W. (Eds). Maternal employment and children's development: Longitudinal research (1988), Plenum Press, New York 121-154
38. Goldberg W.A., Greenberger E., and Nagel S.K. Employment and achievement: Mothers' work involvement in relation to children's achievement behaviors and mothers' parenting behaviors. Child Development 67 (1996) 1512-1527
39. Gottfried A.E., and Gottfried A.W. Maternal employment and children's development: An integration of longitudinal findings with implications for social policy. In: Gottfried A.E., and Gottfried A.W. (Eds). Maternal employment and children's development: Longitudinal research (1988), Plenum Press, New York 11-58
40. Gottfried A.E., Gottfried A.W., and Bathurst K. Maternal employment, family environment, and children's development: Infancy through the school years. In: Gottfried A.E., and Gottfried A.W. (Eds). Maternal employment and children's development: Longitudinal research (1988), Plenum Press, New York 11-58
41. Gottfried A.E., Gottfried A.W., and Bathurst K. Maternal and dual-earner employment status and parenting. In: Bornstein M.H. (Ed). Handbook of parenting: Vol. 2. Biology and ecology of parenting. 2nd ed. (2002), Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ 207-229
42. Greenstein T.N. Are the "most advantaged" children truly disadvantaged by early maternal employment?. Journal of Family Issues 16 (1995) 149-169
43. Gregg P., Washbrook E., Propper C., and Burgess S. The effects of a mother's return to work decision on child development in the UK. Economic Journal 115 (2005) F48-F80
44. Gutman L.M., McLoyd V.C., and Tokoyawa T. Financial strain, neighborhood stress, parenting behaviors, and adolescent adjustment in urban African American families. Journal of Research on Adolescence 15 (2005) 425-449
45. Halpern D.F., and Riggio H.R. Changes at the intersection of work and family [Special issue]. American Behavioral Scientist 49 9 (2006)
46. Han W.J., Waldfogel J., and Brooks-Gunn J. The effects of early maternal employment on later cognitive and behavioral outcomes. Journal of Marriage and the Family 63 (2001) 336-354
47. Harvey E. Short-term and long-term effects of early parental employment on children of the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth. Developmental Psychology 35 (1999) 445-459
48. Haveman R., Wolfe B., and Spaulding J. Childhood events and circumstances influencing high school completion. Demography 28 (1991) 133-157
49. Hedges L.V., and Olkin I. Statistical methods for meta-analysis (1985), Academic Press, San Diego, CA
50. Hedges L.V., and Pigott T.D. The power of tests in meta-analysis. Psychological Methods 6 (2001) 203-217
51. Heyns B., and Catsambis S. Mother's employment and children's achievement: A critique. Sociology of Education 59 (1986) 140-151
52. Hill J.L., Waldfogel J., Brooks-Gunn J., and Han W.J. Maternal employment and child development: A fresh look using newer methods. Developmental Psychology 41 (2005) 833-850
53. Hock E., and DeMeis D. Depression in mothers of infants: The role of maternal employment. Developmental Psychology 26 (1990) 285-291
54. Hoffman L.W. Effects of maternal employment on the child. Child Development 32 (1961) 187-197
55. Hoffman L.W. Effects of maternal employment on the child: A review of the research. Developmental Psychology 10 (1974) 204-228
56. Hoffman L.W. Maternal employment: 1979. American Psychologist 34 (1979) 859-865
57. Hoffman L.W. The effects of maternal employment on the academic attitudes and performance of school-aged children. School Psychology Review 9 (1980) 319-335
58. Hoffman L.W. Maternal employment and the young child. In: Perlmutter M. (Ed). Parent-child interaction and parent-child relations in child development (1984), Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ 101-127
59. Hoffman L.W., and Youngblade L.M. Mothers at work: Effects on children's well-being (1999), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, England
60. Horwood L.J., and Fergusson D.M. A longitudinal study of maternal labour force participation and child academic achievement. Journal of Child Psychology 40 (1999) 1013-1024
61. Howes C. Relations between early child care and schooling. Developmental Psychology 24 (1988) 53-57
62. Huston A.C., and Aronson S.R. Mothers' time with infant and time in employment as predictors of mother-child relationships and children's early development. Child Development 76 (2005) 467-482
63. Hutner F.C. Mother's education and working: Effect on the school child. Journal of Psychology 82 (1972) 27-37
64. Jackson A.P. The effects of family and neighborhood characteristics on the behavioral and cognitive development of poor Black children: A longitudinal study. Journal of Community Psychology 32 (2003) 175-186
65. Jackson A.P., Brooks-Gunn J., Huang C., and Glassman M. Single mothers in low-wage jobs: Financial strain, parenting, and preschoolers' outcomes. Child Development 71 (2000) 1409-1423
66. Jackson A.P., and Schienes R. Single mothers' self-efficacy, parenting in the home environment, and children's development in a two-wave study. Social Work Research 29 (2005) 7-20
67. Jacobson K.C., and Crockett L.J. Parental monitoring and adolescent adjustment: An ecological perspective. Journal of Research on Adolescence 10 (2000) 65-97
68. Johnson D.J., Jaeger E., Randolph S.M., Cauce A.M., Ward J., and The NICHD Early Child Care Research Network. Studying the effects of early child care experiences on the development of children of color in the U.S.: Towards a more inclusive research agenda. Child Development 74 (2003) 1227-1244
69. Jones J.B., Lundsteen S.W., and Michael W.B. The relationship of the professional employment status of mothers to reading achievement of sixth-grade children. California Journal of Education Research 2 (1967) 102-108
70. Kiedel K.C. Maternal employment and ninth grade achievement in Bismarck, North Dakota. Family Coordinator 19 (1970) 95-97
71. Lanahan L., McGrath D.J., McLaughlin M., Burian-Fitzgerald M., and Salganik L. Fundamental problems in the measurement of instructional processes: Estimating reasonable effect sizes and estimating what is important to measure (2005), American Institutes for Research, Washington, DC
72. Leibowitz A. Parental inputs and children's achievement. Journal of Human Resources 12 (1977) 242-251
73. Lerner J., and Galambos N. The influences of maternal employment across life: The New York Longitudinal Study. In: Gottfried A.E., and Gottfried A.W. (Eds). Maternal employment and children's development: Longitudinal research (1988), Plenum Press, New York 59-83
74. Lipsey M.W., and Wilson D.B. Practical meta-analysis (2001), Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA
75. Lorber M. Psychophysiology of aggression, psychopathy, and conduct disorders: A meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin 130 (2004) 531-552
76. McGroder S.M., Zaslow M.J., Papillo A.R., Ahluwalia S.K., and Brooks J.L. The estimated effect of maternal employment on children under mandatory and non-mandatory employment circumstances. Community, Work, and Family 8 (2005) 331-357
77. McLoyd V.C. Employment among African American mothers in dual earner families: Antecedents and consequences for family life and child development. In: Frankel J. (Ed). The employed mother and the family context (1993), Springer, New York 180-226
78. Menaghan E.G., Kowaleski-Jones L., and Mott F.L. The intergenerational costs of parental social stressors: Academic and social difficulties in early adolescence for children of young mothers. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 38 (1997) 72-86
79. Milne A.M., Myers D.E., Rosenthal A.S., and Ginsburg A. Single parents, working mothers, and the educational achievement of school children. Sociology of Education 59 (1986) 125-139
80. Moen P. It's about time: Couples and careers (2003), Cornell University Press, New York
81. Montemayor R., and Clayton M.D. Maternal employment and adolescent development. Theory Into Practice 22 2 (1983) 112-118
82. Moorehouse M.J. Linking maternal employment patterns to mother-child activities and children's school competence. Developmental Psychology 27 (1991) 295-303
83. Muller C. Maternal employment, parental involvement, and mathematics achievement among adolescents. Journal of Marriage and the Family 57 (1995) 85-100
84. Nelson D.D. A study of school achievement among adolescent children with working and nonworking mothers. Journal of Educational Research 62 (1969) 295-303
85. NICHD Early Child Care Research Network. Early child care and children's development prior to school entry: Results from the NICHD Study of Early Child Care. American Educational Research Journal 39 (2002) 133-164
86. Nolan F.L. Effects on rural children. In: Nye F.I., and Hoffman L.W. (Eds). The employed mother in America (1963), Rand McNally, Chicago 122-124
87. Nye F.I., and Hoffman L.W. The employed mother in America (1963), Rand McNally, Chicago
88. Parcel T.L., and Menaghan E.G. Maternal working conditions and children's verbal facility: Studying the intergenerational transmission of inequality from mothers to young children. Social Psychology Quarterly 53 (1990) 132-147
89. Parcel T.L., and Menaghan E.G. Early parental work, family social capital, and early childhood outcomes. American Journal of Sociology 99 (1994) 972-1009
90. Parcel T.L., and Menaghan E.G. Parents' jobs and children's lives (1994), Aldine de Gruyter, New York
91. Parcel T.L., Nickoll R.A., and Dufur M.J. The effects of parental work and maternal nonemployment on children's reading and math achievement. Work and Occupations 23 (1996) 461-483
92. Paulson S.E. Maternal employment and adolescent achievement revisited: An ecological perspective. Family Relations 45 (1996) 201-208
93. Peisner-Feinberg E.S., Burchinal M.R., Clifford R.M., Culkin M.L., Howes C., Kagan S.L., and Yazejian N. The relation of preschool child-care quality to children's cognitive and social developmental trajectories through second grade. Child Development 72 (2001) 1534-1553
94. Perry-Jenkins M., Repetti R., and Crouter A. Work and family in the 1990s. Journal of Marriage and the Family 62 (2000) 981-998
95. Rees A.H., and Palmer F.H. Factors related to change in mental test performance. Developmental Psychology Monograph 3 2, Pt. 2 (1970) 1-57
96. Ricciuti H.N. Single parenthood and school readiness in White, Black, and Hispanic 6- and 7-year-olds. Journal of Family Psychology 13 (1999) 450-465
97. Rosenthal D.D., and Hansen J. The impact of maternal employment on children's perceptions of parents and personal development. Sex Roles 7 (1981) 593-598
98. Rosenthal R. Meta-analytic procedures for social research (1991), Sage, Newbury Park, CA
99. Rosenthal R. Writing meta-analytic reviews. Psychological Bulletin 118 (1995) 183-192
100. Rosenthal R., and DiMatteo M.R. Meta-analysis: Recent developments in quantitative methods for literature reviews. Annual Review of Psychology 52 (2001) 59-82
101. Roy P. Maternal employment and adolescent roles: Rural-urban differentials. Marriage & Family Living 23 (1961) 340-349
102. Ruhm C.J. Parental employment and child cognitive development. Journal of Human Resources 39 (2004) 155-192
103. Schachter F.F. Toddlers with employed mothers. Child Development 52 (1981) 958-964
104. Smith J.R., Brooks-Gunn J., Klebanov P.K., and Lee K. Welfare and work: Complementary strategies for low-income women?. Journal of Marriage and the Family 62 (2000) 808-821
105. Smith T.E. Gender differences in the scientific achievement of adolescents: Effects of age and parental separation. Social Forces 71 (1992) 469-484
106. Stafford F.P. Women's work, sibling competition and children's school performance. American Economic Review 77 (1987) 972-980
107. StataCorp. Stata statistical software (Version 9) [Computer software] (2005), Author, College Station, TX
108. Sterne J., Becker B., and Egger M. The funnel plot. In: Rothstein H., Sutton A., and Borenstein M. (Eds). Publication bias in meta-analysis: Prevention, assessment and adjustments (2005), Wiley, West Sussex, England 75-98
109. Sterne J., and Egger M. Regression methods to detect publication and other bias in meta-analysis. In: Rothstein H., Sutton A., and Borenstein M. (Eds). Publication bias in meta-analysis: Prevention, assessment and adjustments (2005), Wiley, West Sussex, England 99-110
110. Sterne J., Gavaghan D., and Egger M. Publication and related bias in meta-analysis: Power of statistical tests and prevalence in the literature. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 53 (2000) 1119-1129
111. Sutton A. Evidence concerning the consequences of publication and related bias. In: Rothstein H., Sutton A., and Borenstein M. (Eds). Publication bias in meta-analysis: Prevention, assessment and adjustments (2005), Wiley, West Sussex, England 175-192
112. Terrin N., Schmid C., Lau J., and Olkin I. Adjusting of publication bias in the presence of heterogeneity. Statistics in Medicine 22 (2003) 2113-2126
113. Thompson S., and Higgins J. How should meta-regression analyses be undertaken and interpreted?. Statistics in Medicine 21 (2002) 1559-1573
114. Thomson Scientific. Journal Citation Reports (2005), Author, Philadelphia
115. U.S. Census Bureau. Statistical abstracts of the United States: 2002. 122nd ed. (2002), Author, Washington, DC
116. Vandell D.L., Pierce K.M., and Dadisman K. Out-of-school settings as a developmental context for children and youth. Advances in Child Development and Behavior 33 (2005) 43-77
117. Vandell D.L., and Ramanan J. Children of the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth: Choices in after-school care and child development. Developmental Psychology 27 (1991) 637-643
118. Vandell D.L., and Ramanan J. Effects of early and recent maternal employment on children from low-income families. Child Development 63 (1992) 938-949
119. Voydanoff P. Work and family life (1987), Sage, Beverly Hills, CA
120. Waldfogel J., Han W.J., and Brooks-Gunn J. The effects of early maternal employment on child cognitive development. Demography 39 (2002) 369-392
121. Weinraub M., Jaeger E., and Hoffman L.W. Predicting infant outcome in families of employed and nonemployed mothers. In: Fox N., and Fein G.G. (Eds). Infant day care: The current debate (1990), Ablex, Westport, CT 127-144
122. Williams S.Z. The effects of maternal employment on scholastic performance of children. Journal of Home Economics 62 (1970) 609-613
123. Wolfer L.T., and Moen P. Staying in school: Maternal employment and the timing of Black and White daughters' school exit. Journal of Family Issues 17 (1996) 540-560
124. Woods M.B. The unsupervised child of the working mother. Developmental Psychology 6 (1972) 14-25
125. Youngblut J.M., Brooten D., Singer L.T., Standing T., Lee H., and Rodgers W.L. Effects of maternal employment and prematurity on child outcomes in single parent families. Nursing Research 50 (2001) 346-355