Motivation Gains of Inferior Group Members: A Meta-Analytical Review

Journal of Personality and Social Psychology

Volumn 93, Issue 6, 2007, Pages 973-993

  Weber, Bernhard ^a   Hertel, Guido ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF WÜRZBURG   (Germany)

Author keywords

gender; K hler effect; motivation gains; social comparison; social indispensability

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; COMPETITIVE BEHAVIOR; FEMALE; GROUP PROCESS; HUMAN; MALE; MOTIVATION; SEX DIFFERENCE; SOCIAL DESIRABILITY;

COMPETITIVE BEHAVIOR; FEMALE; GROUP PROCESSES; HUMANS; MALE; MOTIVATION; SEX FACTORS; SOCIAL DESIRABILITY;

EID: 38049043382     PISSN: 00223514     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1037/0022-3514.93.6.973     Document Type: Article

References (126)

1. Aiello J.R., and Douthitt E.A. Social facilitation from Triplett to electronic performance monitoring. Group Dynamics: Theory, Research, and Practice 5 (2001) 163-180
2. Aiello J.R., and Kolb K.J. Electronic performance monitoring and social context: Impact on productivity and stress. Journal of Applied Psychology 80 (1995) 339-353
3. Aiello J.R., and Svec C.M. Computer monitoring of work performance: Social facilitation and electronic presence. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 23 (1993) 537-548
4. Allen J.A., and Hecht T.D. The "romance of teams": Toward an understanding of its psychological underpinnings and implications. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology 77 (2004) 439-461
5. Atkinson J.W., and Raynor J.O. Motivation and achievement (1974), Hemisphere, Washington, DC
6. Au W.T., Chen X.-P., and Komorita S.S. A probabilistic model of criticality in a sequential public good dilemma. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 75 (1998) 274-293
7. Bandura A. Social foundations of thought and action: A social cognitive theory (1986), Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
8. Bandura A. Self-efficacy: The exercise of control (1997), Freeman, New York
9. Baumeister R.F. Choking under pressure: Self-consciousness and paradoxical effects of incentives on skillful performance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 46 (1984) 610-620
10. Beersma B., Hollenbeck J.R., Humphrey S.E., Moon H., Conlon D.E., and Ilgen D.R. Cooperation, competition and team performance: Towards a contingency approach. Academy of Management Journal 46 (2003) 572-590
11. Brehm J.W., and Self E.A. The intensity of motivation. Annual Review of Psychology 40 (1989) 109-131
12. Broverman I., Vogel S., Broverman D., Clarkson F., and Rosenkrantz P. Sex-role stereotypes: A current appraisal. Journal of Social Issues 28 (1972) 59-78
13. Brown D.J., Ferris D.L., Heller D., and Keeping L.M. Antecedents and consequences of the frequency of upward and downward social comparisons at work. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 102 (2007) 59-75
14. Brown-Kruse J., and Hummels D. Gender effects in laboratory public goods contribution: Do individuals put their money where their mouth is?. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 22 (1993) 255-267
15. Carlson D.K., and Schmidt F.L. Impact of experimental design on effect size: Findings from research literature on training. Journal of Applied Psychology 84 (1999) 851-862
16. Carron A.V., Burke S.M., and Prapavessis H. Self-presentation and group influence. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology 16 (2004) 41-58
17. Carstensen L.L. A life-span approach to social motivation. In: Heckhausen J., and Dweck C. (Eds). Motivation and self-regulation across the life span (1998), Cambridge University Press, New York 341-364
18. Carver C.S., and Scheier M.F. On the self-regulation of behavior (1998), Cambridge University Press, New York
19. Chen G., and Kanfer R. Toward a systems theory of motivated behavior in work teams. Research in Organizational Behavior 27 (2006) 223-267
20. Cohen J. Weighted kappa: Nominal scale agreement with provision for scaled disagreement or partial credit. Psychological Bulletin 70 (1968) 213-220
21. Cohen J. Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences (1988), Erlbaum, New York
22. Collins R.L. Among the better ones: Upward assimilation in social comparison. In: Suls J., and Wheeler L. (Eds). Handbook of social comparison: Theory and research (2000), Plenum Press, New York 159-172
23. Costa P.T., Terracciano A., and McCrae R.R. Gender differences in personality traits across cultures: Robust and surprising findings. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 81 (2001) 322-331
24. Cross S.E., and Madson L. Models of the self: Self-construals and gender. Psychological Bulletin 122 (1997) 5-37
25. Dashiell J.F. An experimental analysis of some group effects. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 25 (1930) 190-199
26. Davis J.H. Group performance (1969), Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA
27. Diehl M., and Stroebe W. Productivity loss in brainstorming groups: Toward the solution of a riddle. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 53 (1987) 497-509
28. Doerr K.H., Mitchell T.R., Freed T., Schriesheim C.A., and Zhou X. Work flow policy and within-worker and between-workers variability in performance. Journal of Applied Psychology 89 (2004) 911-921
29. Fedor D.B., Davis W.D., Maslyn J.M., and Mathieson K. Performance improvement efforts in response to negative feedback: The roles of source power and recipient self-esteem. Journal of Management 27 (2001) 79-97
30. Feinberg J.M., and Aiello J.R. Social facilitation: A test of competing theories. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 36 (2006) 1087-1109
31. Feingold A. Gender differences in personality: A meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin 116 (1994) 429-456
32. Festinger L. Informal social communication. Psychological Review 57 (1950) 271-282
33. Festinger L. A theory of social comparison processes. Human Relations 7 (1954) 117-140
34. Geen R.G. Human motivation: A social psychological approach (1995), Brooks/Cole, Pacific Grove, CA
35. Gendolla G.H.E., and Richter M. Ego-involvement and the difficulty law of motivation: Effects on performance-related cardiovascular response. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 32 (2006) 1188-1203
36. Gilbert D.T., Giesler R.B., and Morris K.A. When comparisons arise. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 69 (1995) 227-236
37. Goffman E. The presentation of self in everyday life (1959), Doubleday, New York
38. Goffman E. Stigma: Notes on the management of spoiled identity (1963), Simon & Schuster, New York
39. Groenenboom A., Wilke H.A.M., and Wit A.P. Will we be working together again? The impact of future interdependence on group members' task motivation. European Journal of Social Psychology 31 (2001) 369-378
40. Guerin B. Social facilitation (1993), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, England
41. Harkins S. Social loafing and social facilitation. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 23 (1987) 1-18
42. Harkins S., and Petty R.E. Effects of task difficulty and task uniqueness on social loafing. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 43 (1982) 1214-1230
43. Hedges L.V. Distribution theory for Glass's estimator of effect size and related estimators. Journal of Educational Statistics 6 (1981) 107-128
44. Hedges L.V., and Olkin I. Statistical methods for meta-analysis (1985), Academic Press, San Diego, CA
45. Hertel G. Motivation gains in groups: A brief review of the state of the art. Zeitschrift für Sozialpsychologie 31 (2000) 169-175
46. Hertel G., Deter C., and Konradt U. Motivation gains in computer-mediated work groups. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 33 (2003) 2080-2105
47. Hertel G., Geister S., and Konradt U. Managing virtual teams: A review of current empirical research. Human Resource Management Review 15 (2005) 69-95
48. Hertel G., Kerr N.L., and Messé L.A. Motivation gains in performance groups: Paradigmatic and theoretical developments on the Köhler effect. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 79 (2000) 580-601
49. Hertel G., Kerr N.L., Scheffler M., Geister S., and Messé L.A. Exploring the Köhler motivation gain effect: Impression management and spontaneous goal setting. Zeitschrift für Sozialpsychologie 31 (2000) 204-220
50. Hertel G., Konradt U., and Orlikowski B. Managing distance by interdependence: Goal setting, task interdependence and team-based rewards in virtual teams. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology 13 (2004) 1-28
51. Hertel, G., Niemeyer, G., & Clauss, A. (in press). Social indispensability or social comparison: The why and when of motivation gains of inferior group members. Journal of Applied Social Psychology
52. Hoffman B.J., and Woehr D.J. A quantitative review of the relationship between person-organization fit and behavioral outcomes. Journal of Vocational Behavior 68 (2006) 389-399
53. Ingham A.G., Levinger G., Graves J., and Peckham V. The Ringelmann effect: Studies on group size and group performance. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 10 (1974) 371-384
54. Jackson J.M., and Harkins S.G. Equity in effort: An explanation of the social loafing effect. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 49 (1985) 1199-1206
55. Jackson J.M., and Williams K.D. Social loafing on difficult tasks: Working collectively can improve performance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 49 (1985) 937-942
56. Janicik, G. A. (2007). Group motivational gains in a cognitive task domain: Revisiting the Köhler effect. Manuscript submitted for publication.
57. Johnson C.S., and Stapel D.A. When different is better: Performance following upward comparison. European Journal of Social Psychology 37 (2007) 258-275
58. Jung, J. J. H., Schneider, C., & Valacich, J. S. (2005). The influence of real-time identifiability and evaluability performance feedback on group electronic brainstorming performance. Proceedings of the 38th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, January 3-6, 2005 (p. 30a). Retrieved from http://csdl2.computer.org/persagen/DLAbsToc.jsp?resourcePath=/dl/proceedings/&toc=comp/proceedings/hicss/2005/2268/01/2268toc.xml
59. Kameda T., Stasson M.F., Davis J.H., Parks C.D., and Zimmerman S.K. Social dilemmas, subgroups, and motivation loss in task-oriented groups: In search of an "optimal" team size in division of work. Social Psychology Quarterly 55 (1992) 47-56
60. Kanfer R., and Kanfer F.H. Goals and self-regulation: Applications of theory to work settings. In: Maehr M.L., and Pintrich P.R. (Eds). Advances in motivation and achievement 7 (1991), JAI Press, Greenwich, CT 287-326
61. Karau S.J., Markus M.J., and Williams K.D. On the elusive search for motivation gains in groups: Insights from the collective effort model. Zeitschrift für Sozialpsychologie 31 (2000) 179-190
62. Karau S.J., and Williams K.D. Social loafing: A meta-analytic review and theoretical integration. Interpersonal Relations and Group Processes 65 (1993) 681-706
63. Karau S.J., and Williams K.D. Understanding individual motivation in groups: The collective effort model. In: Turner M.E. (Ed). Groups at work: Advances in theory and research (2001), Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ 113-142
64. Kemmelmeier M., and Oyserman D. Self-construals and consequences of upward social comparison: The ups and downs of thinking about a successful other. European Journal of Social Psychology 31 (2001) 311-320
65. Kerr N.L. Motivation losses in task-performing groups: A social dilemma analysis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 45 (1983) 819-828
66. Kerr N.L., and Bruun S. The dispensability of member effort and group motivation losses: Free rider effects. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 44 (1983) 78-94
67. Kerr N.L., Messé L.A., Park E.S., and Sambolec E.J. Identifiability, performance feedback and the Köhler effect. Group Processes and Intergroup Relations 8 (2005) 375-390
68. Kerr N.L., Messé L.A., Seok D.-H., Sambolec E.J., Lount Jr. R.B., and Park E.S. Psychological mechanisms underlying the Köhler motivation gain. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 33 (2007) 828-841
69. Kluger A.N., and DeNisi A. The effects of feedback interventions on performance: A historical review, a meta-analysis, and a preliminary feedback intervention theory. Psychological Bulletin 119 (1996) 254-284
70. Koestner R., and McClelland D.C. The affiliation motive. In: Smith C.P. (Ed). Motivation and personality: Handbook of thematic content analysis (1992), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, England 205-210
71. Köhler O. Kraftleistungen bei Einzel- und Gruppenarbeit [Physical performance in individual and group work]. Industrielle Psychotechnik 3 (1926) 274-282
72. Köhler O. Über den Gruppenwirkungsgrad der menschlichen Körperarbeit und die Bedingung optimaler Kollektivkraftreaktion [Human physical performance in groups and conditions for optimal collective performance]. Industrielle Psychotechnik 4 (1927) 209-226
73. Latané B., Williams K., and Harkins S. Many hands make light the work: The causes and consequences of social loafing. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 37 (1979) 822-832
74. LePine J.A., and Van Dyne L. Peer responses to low performers: An attributional model of helping in the context of groups. Academy of Management Review 26 (2001) 67-84
75. Liden R.C., Wayne S.J., Jaworski R.A., and Bennett N. Social loafing: A field investigation. Journal of Management 30 (2004) 285-304
76. Locke E.A., and Latham G.P. A theory of goal setting and task performance (1990), Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
77. Lount Jr. R.B., Messé L.A., and Kerr N.L. Trying harder for different reasons: Conjunctivity and sex composition as bases for motivation gains in performing groups. Zeitschrift für Sozialpsychologie 31 (2000) 221-230
78. Lount, R. B., Jr., Park, E. S., Seok, D.-H., Messé, L. A., & Kerr, N. (2007). Impression management concerns and group motivation gains. Manuscript submitted for publication.
79. Lount Jr. R.B., and Phillips K.W. Working harder with the out-group: The impact of social category diversity on motivation gains. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 103 (2007) 214-224
80. Major B., Testa M., and Bylsma W.H. Responses to upward and downward social comparisons: The impact of esteem-relevance and perceived control. In: Suls J., and Wills T.A. (Eds). Social comparison: Contemporary theory and research (1991), Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ 237-260
81. Markus H., and Kitayama S. Culture and the self: Implications for cognition, emotion, and motivation. Psychological Review 98 (1991) 224-253
82. Maynard D.C., and Hakel M.D. Effects of objective and subjective task complexity on performance. Human Performance 10 (1997) 303-330
83. McClelland D.C., Atkinson J.W., Clark R.A., and Lowell E.L. The achievement motive (1953), Van Nostrand, Princeton, NJ
84. Messé L.A., Hertel G., Kerr N.L., Lount Jr. R.B., and Park E.S. Knowledge of partner's ability as a moderator of group motivation gains: An exploration of the Köhler discrepancy effect. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 82 (2002) 935-946
85. Moede W. Der Wetteifer, seine Struktur und sein Ausmaβ. Ein Beitrag zur experimentellen Gruppenpsychologie [Structure and intensity of competition: A contribution to experimental group psychology]. Pädagogische Psychologie und experimentelle Pädagogik 16 (1914) 353-368
86. Munkes J., and Diehl M. Matching or competition? Performance comparison processes in an idea generation task. Group Processes and Intergroup Relations 6 (2003) 305-320
87. Mussweiler T. Comparison processes in social judgment: Mechanisms and consequences. Psychological Review 110 (2003) 472-489
88. Nowell C., and Tinkler S. The influence of gender on the provision of a public good. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 25 (1994) 25-36
89. Park, E. S., Lount, R. B., Jr., Kerr, N. L., & Messé, L. A. (2006). "Stand by your man": The influence of traditional sex-role attitudes on motivation in groups. Manuscript in preparation.
90. Paulus P.B. Group influence on individual task performance. In: Paulus P.B. (Ed). Basic group processes (1983), Springer-Verlag, New York 97-120
91. Paulus P.B., Dugosch K.L., Dzindolet M.T., Coskun H., and Putman V.L. Social and cognitive influences in group brainstorming: Predicting production gains and losses. European Review of Social Psychology 12 (2002) 299-325
92. Paulus P.B., and Dzindolet M.T. Social influence processes in group brainstorming. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 64 (1993) 575-586
93. Paulus P.B., Larey T.S., Putman V.L., Leggett K.L., and Roland E.J. Social influence processes in computer brainstorming. Basic and Applied Social Psychology 18 (1996) 3-14
94. Paulus P.B., and Nijstad B.A. Group creativity: Innovation through collaboration (2003), Oxford University Press, New York
95. Pritchard R.D., Jones S.D., Roth P.L., Stuebing K.K., and Ekeberg S.E. Effects of group feedback, goal setting, and incentives on organizational productivity. Journal of Applied Psychology 73 (1988) 337-358
96. Roy M.C., Gauvin S., and Limayem M. Electronic group brainstorming: The role of feedback on productivity. Small Group Research 27 (1996) 215-247
97. Sambolec E., Kerr N.L., and Messé L.A. The role of competitiveness at social tasks: Can indirect cues enhance performance?. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology 19 (2007) 160-172
98. Schwartz S.H., and Rubel T. Sex differences in value priorities: Cross-cultural and multimethod studies. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 89 (2005) 1010-1028
99. Seta J.J. The impact of comparison processes on coactors' task performance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 42 (1982) 281-291
100. Seta J.J., Seta C.E., and Donaldson S. The impact of comparison processes on coactors' frustration and willingness to expend effort. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 17 (1991) 560-568
101. Shepherd M.M., Briggs R.O., Reinig B.A., Yen J., and Nunamaker J.F. Invoking social comparison to improve electronic brainstorming: Beyond anonymity. Journal of Management Information Systems 12 (1996) 155-170
102. Shepperd J.A. Productivity loss in performance groups: A motivation analysis. Psychological Bulletin 113 (1993) 67-81
103. Shepperd J.A., and Taylor K.M. Social loafing and expectancy-value theory. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 25 (1999) 1147-1158
104. Stanne M.B., Johnson D.W., and Johnson R.T. Does competition enhance or inhibit motor performance: A meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin 125 (1999) 133-154
105. Steel P.D., and Kammeyer-Mueller J.D. Comparing meta-analytic moderator estimation techniques under realistic conditions. Journal of Applied Psychology 87 (2002) 96-111
106. Steiner I.D. Group process and productivity (1972), Academic Press, New York
107. Stroebe W., Diehl M., and Abakoumkin G. Social compensation and the Köhler effect: Toward a theoretical explanation of motivation gains in group productivity. In: Witte E., and Davis J. (Eds). Understanding group behavior: Vol. 2. Small group processes and interpersonal relations (1996), Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ 37-65
108. Suh E.J., Moskowitz D.S., Fournier M.A., and Zuroff D.C. Gender and relationships: Influences on agentic and communal behaviors. Personal Relationships 11 (2004) 41-59
109. Szymanski K., and Harkins S.G. Social loafing and self-evaluation with a social standard. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 53 (1987) 891-897
110. Tedeschi J.T., and Rosenfeld P. Impression management theory and the forced compliance situation. In: Tedeschi J.T. (Ed). Impression management theory and social psychology research (1981), Academic Press, New York 147-177
111. Tedeschi J.T., Schlenker B.R., and Bonoma T.V. Cognitive dissonance: Private ratiocination or public spectacle?. American Psychologist 26 (1971) 685-695
112. Vancouver J.B., Rubin B., and Kerr N.L. Sex composition of groups and member motivation: III. Motivational losses at a feminine task. Basic and Applied Social Psychology 12 (1991) 133-144
113. Van Lange P.A.M., Otten W., De Bruin E.M.N., and Joireman J.A. Development of prosocial, individualistic, and competitive orientations: Theory and preliminary evidence. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 73 (1997) 733-746
114. Wageman R. The meaning of interdependence. In: Turner M.E. (Ed). Groups at work: Advances in theory and research (2001), Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ 197-218
115. Waszak, A., & Hertel, G. (2003, March). Affektive Einfluesse auf den "Koehler Motivation Gain Effect" [Affective influences on the "Koehler motivation gain effect"]. Paper presented at the Tagung experimentell arbeitender Psychologen (TeaP), Kiel, Germany.
116. Weber, B., & Hertel, G. (2006, September). Motivation gains in groups: The interaction of personal and situational variables. Oral presentation at the congress of the German Association for Psychology, Nuremberg, Germany.
117. Weber, B., Wittchen, M., Grosch-Kumbier, S., Hoch, J., Haider, J., & Hertel, G. (2006, July). Motivation gains of stronger team members: Showing off or slowing down? Poster session presented at the general meeting of the European Association of Experimental Social Psychology, Würzburg, Germany.
118. Weber, B., Wittchen, M., & Hertel, G. (2007). Gendered ways to engender motivation gains in groups. Manuscript submitted for publication.
119. Williams, K. D. (2006, May). Motivation gains: Gut-level reactions. In N. L. Kerr & G. Hertel (Chairs), Motivation gains of inferior group members. Symposium conducted at the annual meeting of the Midwestern Psychological Association, Chicago, IL.
120. Williams K.D., Harkins S.G., and Latané B. Identifiability as a deterrent to social loafing: Two cheering experiments. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 40 (1981) 303-311
121. Williams K.D., and Karau S.J. Social loafing and social compensation: The effects of expectations of co-worker performance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 61 (1991) 570-581
122. Wills T.A., and Suls J. Commentary: Neo-social comparison theory and beyond. In: Suls J., and Wills T.A. (Eds). Social comparison: Contemporary theory and research (1991), Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ 395-411
123. Wittchen, M., Schlereth, D., & Hertel, G. (in press). Indispensability effects in a sequential task: Motivation gains during anonymous cooperation on the Internet. International Journal of Internet Science
124. Witte E.H. Köhler rediscovered: The anti-Ringelmann effect. European Journal of Social Psychology 19 (1989) 147-154
125. Wood W. Meta-analytic review of sex differences in group performance. Psychological Bulletin 102 (1987) 53-71
126. Zajonc R.B. Social facilitation. Science 149 (1965, July 16) 269-274