Teleology then and now: The question of Kant's relevance for contemporary controversies over function in biology

Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C :Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences

Volumn 37, Issue 4, 2006, Pages 748-770

  Zammito, John ^a  

^a RICE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Biology as a 'special science'; Function; Immanuel Kant; Intrinsic purposiveness; Naturalism; Systematicity

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; BIOLOGY; ETHICAL THEORY; HISTORY; HUMAN; KNOWLEDGE; METAPHYSICS; NATURAL SCIENCE; PHILOSOPHY;

BIOLOGY; ETHICAL THEORY; HISTORY, 18TH CENTURY; HUMANS; KNOWLEDGE; METAPHYSICS; NATURAL SCIENCES; PHILOSOPHY;

EID: 33751519780     PISSN: 13698486     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.shpsc.2006.09.008     Document Type: Article

References (113)

1. Adickes E. Kant als Naturforscher (1924), de Gruyter, Berlin
2. In: Allen C., Bekoff M., and Lauder G. (Eds). Nature's purposes: Analyses of function and design in biology (1998), MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
3. Allison H. Kant's antinomy of teleological judgment. Southern Journal of Philosophy 30 Suppl. (1991) 25-42
4. Allison H. Is the Critique of judgment 'post-critical'?. In: Sedgwick S. (Ed). The reception of Kant's critical philosophy (2000), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 78-92
5. Baumanns P. Das Problem der organischen Zweckmäßigkeit (1965), Bouvier, Bonn
6. Bedau M. Can biological teleology be naturalized?. Journal of Philosophy 88 (1991) 647-655
7. Bedau M. Goal-directed systems and the good. The Monist 75 (1992) 34-51
8. Bedau M. Naturalism and teleology. In: Wagner S., and Warner R. (Eds). Naturalism: A critical appraisal (1993), University of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame 23-51
9. Beiser F. German idealism: The struggle against subjectivism, 1781-1801 (2002), Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA & London
10. Bigelow J., and Pargetter R. Functions. In: Allen C., Bekoff M., and Lauder G. (Eds). Nature's purposes: Analyses of function and design in biology (1998), MIT Press, Cambridge, MA 241-260
11. In: Buller D.J. (Ed). Function, selection and design (1999), SUNY Press, Albany
12. Butts R. Teleology and scientific method in Kant's Critique of judgment. Nous 24 (1990) 1-16
13. Christensen W. A complex systems theory of teleology. Biology and Philosophy 11 (1996) 301-320
14. Churchland P. The engine of reason, the seat of the soul: A philosophical journey into the brain (1995), MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
15. Cummins R. Functional analysis. Journal of Philosophy 72 (1975) 741-764
16. In: Cunningham A., and Jardine N. (Eds). Romanticism and the sciences (1990), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
17. In: Depew D., and Weber B. (Eds). Evolution at the crossroads: The new biology and the new philosophy of science (1985), MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
18. Dörflinger B. Das Leben theoretischer Vernunft (2000), de Gruyter, Berlin
19. Duchesneau F. Épigenèse de la raison pure et analogies biologiques. In: Duchesneau F., Lafrance G., and Piché C. (Eds). Kant actuel (2000), Bellarmin, Montreal 233-256
20. Edwards J. Spinozism, freedom, and transcendental dynamics in Kant's final system of transcendental idealism. In: Sedgwick S. (Ed). The reception of Kant's critical philosophy (2000), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 54-77
21. Flasch W. Kants Empiriologie: Naturteleologie als Wissenschaftstheorie. In: Schmid P., and Zurbuchen S. (Eds). Grenzen der kritischen Vernunft (1997), Schwabe, Berlin 273-289
22. Förster E. Is there a 'gap' in Kant's critical system?. Journal of the History of Philosophy 25 (1987) 533-555
23. Fricke C. Explaining the inexplicable: The hypotheses of the faculty of reflective judgment in Kant's third Critique. Nous 24 (1990) 45-62
24. In: Galison P., and Stump D. (Eds). The disunity of science: Boundaries, contexts, and power (1996), Stanford University Press, Stanford
25. Genova A. The purposive unity of Kant's critical idealism. Idealistic Studies 5 (1975) 177-190
26. Gfeller T. Wie tragfähig ist der teleologischen Brückenschlag? Zu Kants Kritik der teleologischen Urteilskraft. Zeitschrift für philosophische Forschung 52 (1998) 215-236
27. Gilead A. Restless and impelling reason: On the architectonic of human reason according to Kant. Idealistic Studies 15 (1985) 137-150
28. Ginsborg H. Kant on aesthetic and biological purposiveness. In: Reath A., Herman B., and Korsgaard C. (Eds). Reclaiming the history of ethics (1987), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 329-360
29. Ginsborg H. Lawfulness without a law: Kant on the free play of imagination and understanding. Philosophical Topics 25 (1997) 37-81
30. Ginsborg H. Kant on understanding organisms. In: Watkins E. (Ed). Kant and the sciences (2001), Oxford University Press, Oxford 231-258
31. Ginsborg H. Two kinds of mechanical inexplicability in Kant and Aristotle. Journal of the History of Philosophy 42 (2004) 33-65
32. Gloy K. Die Naturauffassung bei Kant, Fichte und Schelling. Fichte-Studien 6 (1994) 253-275
33. In: Gloy K., and Burger P. (Eds). Die Naturphilosophie im Deutschen Idealismus (1993), Frommann-Holzboog, Bad Cannstatt
34. Godfrey-Smith P. Functions: A consensus without unity. Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 74 (1993) 196-208
35. Godfrey-Smith P. A modern history theory of functions. Nous 28 (1994) 344-362
36. Gould S.J., and Lewontin R. The spandrels of San Marco and the Panglossian paradigm: A critique of the adaptationist program. Proceedings of the Royal Society B205 (1979) 581-598
37. Gould S.J., and Vrba E. Exaptation-a missing term in the science of form. Paleobiology 8 (1982) 4-15
38. Griffiths P. The historical turn in the study of adaptation. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 47 (1996) 511-532
39. Griffiths P., and Gray R. Developmental systems and evolutionary explanation. Journal of Philosophy 91 (1994) 277-304
40. Guyer P. Reason and reflective judgment: Kant on the significance of systematicity. Nous 24 (1990) 17-43
41. Guyer P. The unity of nature and freedom: Kant's conception of the system of philosophy. In: Sedgwick S. (Ed). The reception of Kant's critical philosophy (2000), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 19-53
42. Guyer P. Organism and the unity of science. In: Watkins E. (Ed). Kant and the sciences (2001), Oxford University Press, Oxford 259-281
43. Guyer P. Kant and the systematicity of nature: Two puzzles. History of Philosophy Quarterly 20 (2003) 277-295
44. Haffner, T. (1997). Die Epigenesisanalogie in Kants Kritik der reinen Vernunft. Ph.D. thesis, Universität des Saarlands.
45. Huneman P. Métaphysique et biologie: Kant et la constitution du concept d'organisme (2002), Presses Universitaires du Septentrion, Villeneuve
46. Ingensiep H.W. Die biologische Analogien und die erkenntnistheoretische Alternativen in Kants Kritik der reinen Vernunft B §27. Kant-Studien 85 (1994) 381-393
47. Ingensiep H.W. Organismus und Leben bei Kant. In: Ingensiep H.W., Baranzke H., and Eusterschulte A. (Eds). Kant-Reader: Was kann ich wissen? Was soll ich tun? Was darf ich hoffen? (2004), Königshausen & Neumann, Würzburg 107-136
48. Kant, I. (1910-). Kants gesammelte Schriften (Königlich Preussischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, Ed.) (29 vols.). Berlin: Reimer.
49. Kant, I. (1923). Critique of pure reason (N. Kemp-Smith, Trans.). Toronto: Macmillan, 1923.
50. Kant, I. (1956). Critique of practical reason (L.W. Beck, Trans.). Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill.
51. Kant, I. (1987). Critique of judgement (W. Pluhar, Trans.). Indianapolis: Itackett.
52. Kleingeld P. The conative character of reason in Kant's philosophy. Journal of the History of Philosophy 36 (1998) 77-97
53. Krohn W., and Küppers G. Die Natürlichen Ursachen der Zwecke: Kants Ansätze zu einer Theorie der Selbstorganisation. Selbstorganisation: Jahrbuch für Komplexität in der Natur-, Sozial-, und Geisteswissenschaften 3 (1992) 31-50
54. Lagier R. Les races humaines selon Kant (2004), PUF, Paris
55. Lewontin R. The organism as subject and object of evolution. In: Levins R., and Lewontin R. (Eds). The dialectical biologist (1985), Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA 85-106
56. Lewens T. No end to function talk in biology. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and the Biomedical Sciences 32 (2001) 179-190
57. Lewens T. Organisms and artifacts: Design in nature and elsewhere (2004), MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
58. Lewens, T. (Forthcoming). Functions. In M. Matthen, & C. Stephens (Eds.), Handbook of the Philosophy of Science: 3: Philosophy of Biology. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
59. Lieber H.-J. Kants Philosophie des Organischen und die Biologie seiner Zeit. Philosophia Naturalis 1 (1950) 553-570
60. Locke J. Essay concerning human understanding (1998), Penguin, Harmonsworth (First published 1689)
61. Lorenz K. Kant's doctrine of the a priori in the light of contemporary biology. In: Evans R. (Ed). Konrad Lorenz: The man and his ideas (1975), Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, New York & London 181-217
62. Löw R. Philosophie des Lebendigen: der Begriff des Organischen bei Kant, sein Grund und seine Aktualität (1980), Suhrkamp, Frankfurt
63. McLaughlin P. Blumenbach und der Bildungstrieb: Zur Verhältnis von epigenetischen Embryologie und typologischen Artbegriff. Medizinhistorisches Journal 17 (1982) 357-372
64. McLaughin P. Kant's critique of teleology in biological explanation: Antinomy and teleology (1990), Mellen, Lewiston
65. McLaughlin P. What functions explain: Functional explanation and self-reproducing systems (2001), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
66. Millikan R. In defense of proper functions. Philosophy of Science 56 (1989) 288-302
67. Millikan R. White Queen psychology and other essays for Alice (1997), MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
68. Nagel E. Goal-directed processes in biology. Journal of Philosophy 74 (1977) 261-279
69. Neander K. Functions as selected effects: The conceptual analyst's defense. Philosophy of Science 58 (1991) 168-184
70. Nuyen A. The Kantian theory of metaphor. Philosophy and Rhetoric 22 (1989) 95-109
71. Philonenko A. L'antinomie du jugement téléologique chez Kant. Révue de Métaphysique et de Morale 82 (1977) 13-31
72. Putnam H. The collapse of the fact/value dichotomy and other essays (2002), Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
73. Quarfood M. Transcendental idealism and the organism: Essays on Kant (2004), Almqvist & Wiksell, Stockholm
74. Quine, W. V. (1969). Epistemology naturalized. In Quine, Ontological relativity and other essays (pp. 69-90). New York: Columbia University Press.
75. Quine W.V. On empirically equivalent systems of the world. Erkenntnis 9 (1975) 313-328
76. Rang B. Zweckmäßigkeit, Zweckursächlichkeit und Ganzheitlichkeit in der organischen Natur: Zum Problem einer teleologischen Naturauffassung in Kants Kritik der Urteilskraft. Philosophisches Jahrbuch 100 (1998) 39-71
77. Reill P.H. Vitalizing nature in the Enlightenment (2004), University of California Press, Berkeley & Los Angeles
78. In: Rescher N. (Ed). Current issues in teleology (1986), University Press of America, Lanham, New York, & London
79. Richards R. Kant and Blumenbach on the Bildungstrieb: A historical misunderstanding. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 31 (2000) 11-32
80. Richards R. The romantic conception of life: Science and philosophy in the age of Goethe (2002), University of Chicago Press, Chicago & London
81. Roe S. Matter, life, and generation: Eighteenth-century embryology and the Haller-Wolff debate (1981), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
82. Roger J. Les sciences de la vie dans la pensée française du XVIIIe siècle (1963), Colin, Paris
83. Roqué A. Self-organization: Kant's concept of teleology and modern chemistry. Review of Metaphysics 39 (1985) 107-135
84. Ruse M. Teleology: Yesterday, today, and tomorrow. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 31 (2000) 213-232
85. Schlosser G. Self-re-production and functionality: A systems-theoretical approach to teleological explanation. Synthese 116 (1998) 303-354
86. Schurz G. What is 'normal'? An evolution-theoretic foundation for normic laws and their relation to statistical normality. Philosophy of Science 68 (2001) 476-497
87. Simon J. Teleologisches Reflektieren und kausales Bestimmen. Zeitschrift für Philosophische Forschung 30 (1976) 369-388
88. Sloan P. Buffon, German biology and the historical interpretation of biological species. British Journal for the History of Science 12 (1979) 109-153
89. Sloan P. From logical universals to historical individuals: Buffon's idea of biological species. In: Fischer J.-L., and Roger J. (Eds). Histoires du concept d'espèce dans la science de la vie (1985), Singer-Polignac, Paris 101-140
90. Sloan P. The gaze of natural history. In: Fox C., Porter R., and Wokler R. (Eds). Inventing human science (1995), University of California Press, Berkeley 112-151
91. Sloan P. Preforming the categories: Kant and eighteenth-century generation theory. Journal of the History of Philosophy 40 (2002) 229-253
92. Sloan, P. (2006). Kant on the history of nature: The ambiguous heritage of the critical philosophy for natural history. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 37, this issue. doi:10.1016/j.shpsc.2006.09.003.
93. Sober E. Philosophy of biology (1993), Westview, Boulder
94. Steigerwald J. The dynamics of reason and its elusive object in Kant, Fichte and Schelling. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 34 (2003) 111-134
95. Steigerwald, J. (2006). Kant's concept of natural purpose and the reflecting power of judgment. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, this issue. doi:10.1016/j.shpsc.2006.09.006.
96. Tucker A. Our knowledge of the past: A philosophy of historiography (2004), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
97. Tuschling B. The system of transcendental idealism: Questions raised and left open in the Kritik der Urteilskraft. Southern Journal of Philosophy 30 Suppl. (1991) 109-128
98. Vartanian A. Trembley's polyp, La Mettrie and eighteenth-century French materialism. Journal of the History of Ideas 11 (1950) 259-286
99. Wachbroit R. Normality as a biological concept. Philosophy of Science 61 (1994) 579-591
100. Wagner S. Teleosemantics and the troubles of naturalism. Philosophical Studies 82 (1996) 81-110
101. In: Wagner S., and Warner R. (Eds). Naturalism: A critical appraisal (1993), University of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame
102. Walsh D. A taxonomy of functions. Canadian Journal of Philosophy 26 (1996) 493-514
103. Warnke C. 'Naturmechanismus' und 'Naturzweck': Bemerkungen zu Kants Organismus-Begriff. Deutsche Zeitschrift fur Philosophie 40 (1992) 42-52
104. Wright L. Functions. Philosophical Review 82 (1973) 139-168
105. Yovel Y. The interests of reason: From metaphysics to moral history. In: Yovel Y. (Ed). Kant's practical philosophy reconsidered (1989), Kluwer, Dordrecht 135-148
106. Zammito J. The genesis of Kant's Critique of judgment (1992), University of Chicago Press, Chicago & London
107. Zammito J. 'Method' versus 'manner'? Kant's critique of Herder's Ideen in the light of the epoch of science, 1790-1820. Herder Jahrbuch/Herder Yearbook (1998) 1-26
108. Zammito J. 'This inscrutable principle of an original organization': Epigenesis and 'looseness of fit' in Kant's philosophy of science. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 34 (2003) 73-109
109. Zammito J. A nice derangement of epistemes: Post-positivism in the study of science from Quine to Latour (2004), University of Chicago Press, Chicago and London
110. Zammito J. Reconstructing German Idealism and Romanticism: Historicism and presentism. Modern Intellectual History 1 (2004) 427-438
111. Zammito, J. (2006). Kant's early views on epigenesis: The role of Maupertuis. In J. E. Smith (Ed.), The problem of animal generation in modern philosophy (pp. 317-354). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
112. Zanetti V. Die Antinomie der teleologischen Urteilskraft. Kant-Studien 83 (1993) 341-355
113. Zumbach C. The transcendent science: Kant's conception of biological methodology (1984), Nijhoff, The Hague