'This inscrutable principle of an original organization': Epigenesis and 'looseness of fit' in Kant's philosophy of science

Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A

Volumn 34, Issue 1, 2003, Pages 73-109

  Zammito, John H ^a  

^a RICE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Blumenbach; Buchdahl; Empirical law; Epigenesis; Girtanner; Kant

Indexed keywords

EID: 0037333707     PISSN: 00393681     EISSN: 18792510     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0039-3681(02)00092-4     Document Type: Article

References (114)

1. Adickes, E. (1924). Kant als Naturforscher. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.
2. Allison, H. (1991). Kant's antinomy of teleological judgment. Southern Journal of Philosophy, 30(Supplement System and teleology in Kant's Critique of judgment), 25-42.
3. Allison, H. (1994). Causality and causal laws in Kant: A critique of Michael Friedman. In P. Parrini (Ed.), Kant and contemporary epistemology (pp. 291-308). Dordrecht: Kluwer.
4. Aulie, R. (1961). Caspar Friedrich Wolff and his 'Theoria generationis', 1759. Journal of the History of Medicine, 16, 124-144.
5. Barnaby, D. (1988). The early reception of Kant's Metaphysical foundations of natural science. In R. Woolhouse (Ed.), Metaphysics and philosophy of science in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries (pp. 281-306). Dordrecht: Kluwer.
6. Beddoes, T. (1815). Observations on the nature and cure of calculus, sea scurvy, consumption, catarrh, and fever. Together with conjectures upon several other subjects of physiology and pathology. Philadelphia: Webster.
7. Bernasconi, R. (2001a). Who invented the concept of race? Kant's role in the Enlightenment's construction of race. In R. Bernasconi (Ed.), Race (pp. 11 36). Oxford: Blackwell.
8. Bernasconi, R. (2001b). Kant and Blumenbach on the Bildungstrieb. Paper presented at the Conference of the American Society of Eighteenth-Century Studies, New Orleans, April, 2001.
9. Blumenbach, J. F. (1779). Handbuch der Naturgeschichte. Göttingen: Dieterich.
10. Blumenbach, J. F. (1781). Über den Bildungstrieb und das Zeugungsgeschäfte. Göttingen: Dieterich.
11. Blumenbach, J. F. (1785). De Nisu formativo et generationis negotio nuperae observationes. N.p.
12. Blumenbach, J. F. (1787). De nisu formativo et generationis negotio nuperae observationes. Göttingen: Dieterich.
13. Blumenbach, J. F. (1789). Über den Bildungstrieb. Göttingen: Dieterich.
14. Blumenbach, J. F. (1791). Handbuch der Naturgeschichte (4th ed.). Göttingen: Dieterich.
15. Blumenbach, J. F. (1792). An essay on generation (A. Crichton, Trans.). London: Cadell.
16. Blumenbach, J. F. (1797). Handbuch der Naturgeschichte. 5th Edition. Göttingen: Dieterich.
17. Bodemer, C. (1964). Regeneration and the decline of preformationism in eighteenth-century embryology. Bulletin of the History of Medicine, 38, 20-31.
18. Breidenbach, O. (1995). Die Geburt des Lebendigen - Embryogenese der Formen oder Embryologie der Natur? - Anmerkungen zum Bezug von Embryologie und Organismustheorien vor 1800. Biologisches Zentralblatt, 114, 191-199.
19. Buchdahl, G. (1965). Causality, causal laws and scientific theory in the philosophy of Kant. British Journal for Philosophy of Science, 16, 187-208.
20. Buchdahl, G. (1967). The relation between 'understanding' and 'reason' in the architectonic of Kant's philosophy. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 67, 209-226.
21. Buchdahl, G. (1969a). The Kantian 'dynamic of reason', with special reference to the place of causality in Kant's system. In L. W. Beck (Ed.), Kant studies today (pp. 341-374). La Salle, IL: Open Court.
22. Buchdahl, G. (1969b). Metaphysics and the philosophy of science: The classical origins: Descartes to Kant. Cambridge: MIT Press.
23. Buchdahl, G. (1970). Gravity and intelligibility: Newton to Kant. In R. E. Butts, & J. Davis (Eds.), The methodological heritage of Newton (pp. 74-102). Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
24. Buchdahl, G. (1971). The conception of lawlikeness in Kant's philosophy of science. Synthese, 23, 24-46.
25. Buchdahl, G. (1974). Transcendental reduction: A concept for the interpretation of Kant's critical method. In G. Funke (Ed.), Akten des 4. Internationalen Kant-Kongresses Mainz 6-10. April 1974 (Vol. 1, pp. 28-44). Berlin & New York: Walter de Gruyter.
26. Buchdahl, G. (1981). Reduction-realization: a key to the structure of Kant's thought. Philosophical Topics, 12, 39-98.
27. Buchdahl, G. (1984). Zum Verhältnis von allgemeiner Metaphysik der Natur und besonderer metaphysischer Naturwissenschaft bei Kant. In B. Tuschling (Ed.), Probleme der 'Kritik der reinen Vernunft' (pp. 97-142). Berlin & New York: Walter de Gruyter.
28. Buchdahl, G. (1986). Kant's 'special metaphysics' and the Metaphysical foundations of natural science. In R. E. Butts (Ed.), Kant's philosophy of physical science (pp. 121-161). Dordrecht: Reidel.
29. Butts, R. E. (1990). Teleology and scientific method in Kant's Critique of judgment. Nous, 24, 1-16.
30. Butts, R. E. (1991). Comments on Michael Friedman: 'Regulative and constitutive'. Southern Journal of Philosophy, 30(Supplement System and teleology in Kant's Critique of judgment), 103-108.
31. Dawson, V. (1991). Regeneration, parthenogenesis, and the immutable order of nature. Archives of Natural History, 18, 309-321.
32. Duchesneau, F. (1979). Haller et les théories de Buffon et C. F. Wolff sur l'épigenèse. History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences, 1, 65-100.
33. Duchesneau, F. (1985). Vitalism in late eighteenth-century physiology: The cases of Barthez, Blumenbach and John Hunter. In W. F. Bynum, & R. Porter (Eds.), William Hunter and the eighteenth-century medical world (pp. 259-295). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
34. Fambach, O, (Ed.). (1959). Der Aufstieg zur Klassik in der Kritik der Zeit. Die wesentlichen und die umstrittenen Rezensionen aus der periodischen Literatur von 1750 bis 1795, begleitet von den Stimmen der Umwelt. Ein Jahrhundert deutscher Literaturkritik (1750-1850) (Vol. 3). Berlin: Akademie.
35. Förster, E. (1987). Is there a 'gap' in Kant's critical system? Journal of the History of Philosophy, 25, 533-555.
36. Forster, G. (1786). Noch etwas über die Menschenraßen. Teutsche Merkur, 57-86, 150-166.
37. Friedman, M. (1986). The metaphysical foundations of Newtonian science. In R. E. Butts (Ed.), Kant's philosophy of physical science (pp. 25-60). Dordrecht: Reidel.
38. Friedman, M. (1990). Kant and Newton: Why gravity is essential to matter. In P. Bricker, & R. I. G. Hughes (Eds.), Philosophical perspectives on Newtonian science (pp. 185-202). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
39. Friedman, M. (1991). Regulative and constitutive. Southern Journal of Philosophy, 30(Supplement System and teleology in Kant's Critique of judgment), 73-102.
40. Friedman, M. (1992a). Causal laws and the foundations of natural science. In P. Guyer (Ed.), The Cambridge companion to Kant (pp. 161'199). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
41. Friedman, M. (1992b). Kant and the exact sciences. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
42. Gaissinovich, A. E. (1968). Le rôle du Newtonianisme dans la renaissance des idées épigénetiques en embryologie du XVIIIe siècle. In Actes du XIe Congrès International d'Histoire des Sciences (Vol. 5, pp. 105-110).
43. Genova, A. C. (1974). Kant's epigenesis of pure reason. Kant-Studien, 65, 259-273.
44. Girtanner, C. (1791). Neue chemische Nomenklatur für die deutsche Sprache. Berlin: Unger.
45. Girtanner, C. (1795). Anfangsgründe der antiphlogistische Chemie (2nd ed.). Berlin: Unger.
46. Girtanner, C. (1796). Über das Kantische Prinzip für die Naturgeschichte. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.
47. Gregory, F. (1989). Kant's influence on natural scientists in the German Romantic period. In R. P. W. Visser, H. J. M. Bos, L. C. Palm, & H. A. M. Snelders (Eds.), New trends in the history of science (pp. 53-66). Amsterdam & Atlanta: Rodopi.
48. Guyer, P. (1990a). Kant's conception of empirical law. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 64(Supplement), 221-242.
49. Guyer, P. (1990b). Reason and reflective judgment: Kant on the significance of systematicity. Nous, 24, 17-43.
50. Haigh, E. (1976). Vitalism, the soul, and sensibility: The physiology of Théophile Bordeu. Journal of the History of Medicine, 31, 30-41.
51. Harvey, W. (1943). On generation. Ann Arbor: Edwards. First published 1651.
52. Herder, J. G. (1887). Ideen zur Philosophie der Geschichte der Menschheit. In B. Suphan (Ed.). Herders Sämtliche Werke (Vol 13). Berlin: Weidmann. First published 1784.
53. Ingensiep, H. (1994). Die biologischen Analogien und die erkenntnistheoretischen Alternativen in Kants Kritik der reinen Vernunft B § 27. Kant-Studien, 85, 381-393.
54. Jahn, I. (1995). Georg Forsters Lehrkonzeption für eine 'Allgemeine Naturgeschichte' (1786-1793) und seine Auseinandersetzung mit Caspar Friedrich Wolffs 'Epigenesis'-Theorie. Biologisches Zentralblatt, 114, 200-206.
55. Kant, I. (1763). Der einzig mögliche Beweisgrund zu einer Demonstration des Daseins Gottes. Akademie-Ausgabe (Vol. 2, pp. 63-164).
56. Kant, I. (1775/7). Von den verschiedenen Racen der Menschen. Akademie-Ausgabe (Vol. 2, pp. 427-444).
57. Kant, I. (1781/87). Kritik der reinen Vernunft (A = 1781; B = 1787). Akademie-Ausgabe (Vols. 3-4).
58. Kant, I. (1783). Prolegomena zu einer jeden künftigen Metaphysik, die als Wissenschaft wird auftreten können. Akademie-Ausgabe (Vol. 4, pp. 253-384).
59. Kant, I. (1785a). Recensionen von J. G. Herders Ideen zur Philosophie der Geschichte der Menschheit. Theil 1. 2. Akademie Ausgabe (Vol. 8, pp. 43-66).
60. Kant, I. (1785b). Bestimmung des Begriffs einer Menschenrace. Akademie-Ausgabe (Vol. 8, pp. 89-106).
61. Kant, I. (1786) Metaphysische Anfangsgründe der Naturwissenschaft. Akademie-Ausgabe (Vol. 4, pp. 465-566).
62. Kant, I. (1788). Über den Gebrauch teleologischer Principien in der Philosophie. Akademie-Ausgabe (Vol. 8, pp. 157-184).
63. Kant, I. (1790). Kritik der Urteilskraft. Akademie-Ausgabe (Vol. 5, pp. 165-486).
64. Kant, I. (1798). Anthropologie in pragmatischer Hinsicht. Akademie-Ausgabe (Vol. 7, pp. 117-334).
65. Kant, I. (1802). Physische Geographie. Akademie-Ausgabe (Vol. 9, pp. 151-436).
66. Kant, I. Briefwechsel. Akademie-Ausgabe (Vols. 10-13).
67. Kant, I. Reflexionen. Akademie-Ausgabe (Vols. 17-18).
68. Kant, I. Vorlesungen über Metaphysik. Akademie-Ausgabe (Vols. 28-29).
69. Kitcher, I. (1986). Projecting the order of nature. In R. E. Butts (Ed.). Kant's philosophy of physical science (pp. 201-235). Dordrecht: Reidel.
70. Kitcher, I. (1993). Knowledge, society, and history. Canadian Journal of Philosophy, 23, 155-178.
71. Kitcher, I. (1994). The unity of science and the unity of nature. In P. Parrini (Ed.). Kant and contemporary epistemology (pp. 253-272.). Dordrecht: Kluwer.
72. Kitcher, P. (1983). Kant's philosophy of science. Midwest Studies in Philosophy, 8, 387-407.
73. Körner, S. (1955). Kant. Harmonsworth: Penguin.
74. Kuhn, T. (1970). The structure of scientific revolutions (2nd ed.). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
75. Larson, J. (1979). Vital forces: regulative principles or causal agents? Isis, 70, 235-249.
76. Larson, J. (1994). Interpreting nature: The science of living form from Linnaeus to Kant. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
77. Lenoir, T. (1980). Kant, Blumenbach, and vital materialism in German biology. Isis, 71, 77-108.
78. Lenoir, T. (1981a). The Göttingen school and the development of transcendental Naturphilosophie in the Romantic Era. Studies in History of Biology, 5, 111-205.
79. Lenoir, T. (1981b). Teleology without regrets. The transformation of physiology in Germany 1790-1847. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 12, 293-354.
80. Lenoir, T. (1988). Kant, Von Baer, and causal-historical thinking in biology. Poetics Today, 9, 103-115.
81. McLaughlin, P. (1982). Blumenbach und der Bildungstrieb: Zum Verhältnis von epigenetischer Embryologie und typologischem Artbegriff. Medizinhistorisches Journal, 17, 357-372.
82. McLaughlin, P. (1990). Kant's critique of teleology in biological explanation: Antinomy and teleology. Lewiston: Mellen.
83. Mocek, R. (1995). Caspar Friedrich Wolffs Epigenesis - Konzept - ein Problem im Wandel der Zeit. Biologisches Zentralblatt, 114, 179-190.
84. Morrison, M. (1989). Methodological rules in Kant's philosophy of science. Kant-Studien, 92, 155-172.
85. Müller-Sievers, H. (1993). Epigenesis: Naturphilosophie im Sprachdenken Wilhelm von Humboldts. Paderborn: Schöningh.
86. Müller-Sievers, H. (1997). Self-generation: Biology, philosophy and literature around 1800. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
87. Okruhlik, K. (1983). Kant on the foundations of science. In W. Shea (Ed.), Nature mathematicized (pp. 251-268). Dordrecht: Reidel.
88. Querner, H. (1990). Christoph Girtanner und die Anwendung des Kantischen Prinzips in der Bestimmung des Menschen. In G. Mann, & F. Dumont (Eds.), Die Natur des Menschen: Probleme der Physischen Anthropologie und Rassenkunde (1750-1850) (pp. 123-136). Stuttgart: G. Fischer.
89. Reill, P. H. (1989). Anti-mechanism, vitalism and their political implications in late Enlightened scientific thought. Francia, 16, 195-212.
90. Reill, P. H. (1992). Between mechanism and hermeticism: Nature and science in the late Enlightenment. In R. Vierhaus (Ed.), Frühe Neuzeit - Frühe Moderne? (pp. 393-421). Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.
91. Reill, P. H. (1998). Analogy, comparison, and active living forces: Late Enlightenment responses to the skeptical critique of causal analysis. In J. van der Zande, & R. Popkin (Eds.), The skeptical tradition around 1800 (pp. 203-211). Dordrecht: Kluwer.
92. Rescher, N. (2001). Cognitive pragmatism. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
93. Rheinberger, H.-J. (1981). Über Formen und Gründe der Historisierung biologischer Modelle von Ordnung und Organisation am Ausgang des 18. Jahrhunderts. In M. Hahn, & H.-J. Sandkühler (Eds.), Gesellschaftliche Bewegung und Naturprozeß (pp. 71-81). Cologne: Paul-Rugenstein.
94. Rheinberger, H.-J. (1986). Aspekte des Bedeutungswandels im Begriff organismischer Ähnlichkeit vom 18. zum 19. Jahrhundert. History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences, 8, 237-250.
95. Riedel, M. (1980). Historizismus und Kritizismus: Kants Streit mit G. Forster und J. G. Herder. In B. Fabian, & W. Schmidt-Biggemann (Eds.), Deutschlands kulturelle Entfaltung (pp. 31-48). Munich: Kraus.
96. Roe, S. (1979). Rationalism and embryology: Caspar Friedrich Wolff's theory of epigenesis. Journal of the History of Biology, 12, 1-43.
97. Roger, J. (1968). Leibniz et les sciences de la vie. Studia Leibnitiana. Supplementa, 2, 209-219.
98. Sloan, J. (1979). Buffon, German biology, and the historical interpretation of biological species. British Journal for the History of Science, 12, 109-153.
99. Sloan, J. (2001). Kant and epigenetic embryology: The implications for his post-1790 philosophy. Paper presented at the Conference of the American Society of Eighteenth-Century Studies, New Orleans, April, 2001.
100. Sloan, P. (1973). The idea of racial degeneracy in Buffon's Histoire naturelle. In H. Pagliaro (Ed.). Racism in the eighteenth century (pp. 293-321). Cleveland/London: Case Western Reserve University Press (= Studies in Eighteenth-Century Culture, 3).
101. Sloan, P. (2002). Preforming the categories: Kant and eighteenth-century generation theory. Journal of the History of Philosophy, 2, 229-253.
102. Stawson, P. (1966). The bounds of sense. London: Methuen.
103. Tuschling, B. (1991). The system of transcendental idealism: Questions raised and left open in the Kritik der Urteilskraft. Southern Journal of Philosophy, 30(Supplement System and teleology in Kant's Critique of judgment), 109-128.
104. Wegelin, C. (1957). Dr. Med. Christoph Girtanner (1760-1800). Gesnerus, 14, 141-163.
105. Williams, L. P. (1973). Kant, Naturphilosophie and scientific method. In R. Giere, & R. Westfall (Eds.), Foundations of scientific method: The nineteenth century (pp. 3-22). Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
106. Wolff, C. F. (1966). Theorie von der Generation. Reprint Stuttgart: G. Fischer. First published 1764.
107. Wubnig, J. (1968/69). The epigenesis of pure reason. Kant-Studien, 60, 147-152.
108. Zammito, J. (1992). The genesis of Kant's Critique of judgment. Chicago/London: University of Chicago Press.
109. Zammito, J. (1998). 'Method' versus 'manner'? Kant's critique of Herder's Ideen in the light of the epoch of science, 1790-1820. In H. Adler, & W. Koepke (Eds.), Herder-Jahrbuch/Herder Yearbook 1998 (pp. 1-26). Stuttgart: Metzler.
110. Zammito, J. (2001a). Epigenesis: Concept and metaphor in Herder's Ideen. In R. Otto, & J. Zammito (Eds.), Vom Selbstdenken: Aufklärung und Aufklärungskritik in Johann Gottfried Herders 'Ideen zur Philosophie der Geschichte der Menschheit' (pp. 131-145). Heidelberg: Synchron.
111. Zammito, J. (2001b). Policing polygeneticism in Germany, 1775: (Kames,) Kant and Blumenbach. Paper presented at the Conference on the 'German invention of race', Harvard University, May 2001.
112. Zöller, G. (1989). From innate to a priori: Kant's radical transformation of a Cartesian-Leibnizian legacy. Monist, 72, 222-235.
113. Zöller, G. (1988). Kant on the generation of metaphysical knowledge. In H. Oberer, & G. Seel (Eds.), Kant: Analysen - Probleme - Kritik (pp. 71-90). Würzburg: Königshausen & Neumann.
114. Zumbach, C. (1984). The transcendent science: Kant's conception of biological methodology. The Hague: Nijhoff.