Forgoing life sustaining treatments: Differences and similarities between North America and Europe

Acta Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica

Volumn 50, Issue 10, 2006, Pages 1177-1186

  Moselli, N M ^a   Debernardi, F ^a   Piovano, F ^a  

^a CANDIOLO CANCER INSTITUTE   (Italy)

Author keywords

Do not resuscitate orders; End of life decisions; Medical futility and advanced directives; Withholding withdrawal of life sustaining treatments

Indexed keywords

COMPARATIVE STUDY; CONTROLLED STUDY; DATA ANALYSIS; EUROPE; HEALTH CARE POLICY; HEALTH SURVEY; HUMAN; MEDICAL DECISION MAKING; MEDICAL STAFF; NORTH AMERICA; PATIENT ATTITUDE; PATIENT DECISION MAKING; PRACTICE GUIDELINE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; QUESTIONNAIRE; RESUSCITATION; REVIEW; TERMINAL CARE; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

CARDIOPULMONARY RESUSCITATION; CLINICAL TRIALS; CROSS-CULTURAL COMPARISON; DECISION MAKING; EUROPE; HUMANS; NORTH AMERICA; PATIENT PARTICIPATION; RESUSCITATION ORDERS; TERMINAL CARE; WITHHOLDING TREATMENT;

EID: 33750306318     PISSN: 00015172     EISSN: 13996576     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1399-6576.2006.01150.x     Document Type: Review

References (88)

1. Von Gunten CF. CPR in hospitalized patients: when is it futile? Am Fam Physician 1991; 44: 2130-4.
2. Tunstall-Pedoe H, Bailey L, Chamberlain DA, Marsden AK, Ward ME, Zideman DA. Survey of 3765 cardiopulmonary resuscitations in British hospitals (the Bresus study): methods and overall results. BMJ 1992; 304: 1347-51.
3. Choudhry NK, Choudhry S, Singer PA. CPR for patients labeled DNR: the role of the Limited Aggressive Therapy Order. Ann Intern Med 2003; 138: 65-8.
4. Ebell MH. Prearrest predictors of survival following inhospital cardiopulmonary resuscitation: a meta-analysis. J Fam Pract 1992; 34: 551-8.
5. Burns JP, Edwards J, Johnson J, Cassem NH, Truog RD. Do-not-resuscitate order after 25 years. Crit Care Med 2003; 31: 1543-50.
6. The British Medical Association. The Royal College of Nursing and The Resuscitation Council (UK). Decisions Relating to Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation. http://www.bma.org.uk/ap.nfs/AttachmentsByTitle/PDFcardioresus/$FILE/ Cardio.pdf. London, 1993.
7. Sjokvist P, Nilstun T, Svantesson M, Berggren L. Withdrawal of life support - who should decide? Differences in attitudes among the general public, nurses and physicians. Intensive Care Med, 1999; 25: 949-54.
8. Ferrand E, Lemaire F, Regnier B, Kuteifan K, Badet M, Asfar P et al. French RESSENTI Group. Discrepancies between perceptions by physicians and nursing staff of intensive care unit end-of-life decisions. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2003; 167: 1310-5.
9. Le Conte P, Baron D, Trewick D, Touzé MD, Longo C, Vial I et al. Withholding and withdrawing life-support therapy in an Emergency Department: prospective survey. Intensive Care Med 2004; 30: 2216-21.
10. Chevrolet JC. L'ordre «ne pas réanimer» en soins intensifs. Aspects éthiques et position du Conseil d'éthique clinique des hôpitaux universitaires de Genève (Suisse). [Do not resuscitate orders in intensive care units. Ethical aspects and position of the Conseil d'éthique clinique of the University hospitals of Geneva (Switzerland)]. Réanimation 2003; 12: 78-87.
11. Giannini A, Pessina A, Tacchi EM. End-of-life decisions in intensive care units: attitudes of physicians in an Italian urban setting. Intensive Care Med 2003; 29: 1902-10.
12. Haverkate I, van Delden JJ, van Nijen AB, van der Wal G. Guidelines for the use of do-not-resuscitate orders in Dutch hospitals. Crit Care Med 2000; 28: 3039-43.
13. Smedira NG, Evans BH, Grais LS, Cohen NH, Lo B, Cooke M et al. Withholding and withdrawal of life support from the critically ill. N Engl J Med 1990; 322: 309-15.
14. Jayes RL, Zimmerman JE, Wagner DP, Knaus WA. Variations in the use of DNR orders in ICUs. Findings from a national study. Chest 1996; 110: 1332-9.
15. The SUPPORT Principal Investigators. A controlled trial to improve care for seriously ill hospitalized patients. The Study to Understand Prognoses and Preferences for Outcomes and Risks of Treatments (SUPPORT). JAMA 1995; 274: 1591-8.
16. Prendergast TJ, Luce JM. Increasing incidence of withholding and withdrawal of life support from the critically ill. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1997; 155: 15-20.
17. Keenan SP, Busche KD, Chen LM, McCarthy L, Inman KJ, Sibbald WJ. A retrospective review of a large cohort of patients undergoing the process of withholding or withdrawal of life support. Crit Care Med 1997; 25: 1324-31.
18. Prendergast TJ, Claessens MT, Luce JM. A national survey of end-of-life care for critically ill patients. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1998; 158: 1163-7.
19. Cook DJ, Guyatt G, Rocker G, Sjokvist P, Weaver B, Dodek P et al. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation directives on admission to intensive-care unit: an international observational study. Lancet 2001; 358: 1941-5.
20. Keenan SP, Busche KD, Chen LM, Esmail R, Inman KJ, Sibbald WJ. Withdrawal and withholding of life support in the intensive care unit: a comparison of teaching and community hospitals. The Southwestern Ontario Critical Care Research Network. Crit Care Med 1998; 26: 245-51.
21. Cook DJ, Guyatt GH, Jaeschke R, Reeve J, Spanier A, King D et al. Determinants in Canadian health care workers of the decision to withdraw life support from the critically ill. Canadian Critical Care Trials Group. JAMA 1995; 273: 703-8.
22. Asch DA, Hansen-Flaschen J, Lanken PN. Decisions to limit or continue life-sustaining treatment by critical care physicians in the United States: conflicts between physicians' practices and patients' wishes. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1995; 151: 288-92.
23. Heffner JE, Barbieri C. End-of-life care preferences of patients enrolled in cardiovascular rehabilitation programs. Chest 2000; 117: 1474-81.
24. Mebane EW, Oman RF, Kroonen LT, Goldstein MK. The influence of physician race, age, and gender on physician attitudes toward advance care directives and preferences for end-of-life decision-making. J Am Geriatr Soc 1999; 47: 579-91.
25. Vincent JL. Forgoing life support in western European intensive care units: the results of an ethical questionnaire. Crit Care Med 1999; 27: 1626-33.
26. Ferrand E, Robert R, Ingrand P, Lemaire F. Withholding and withdrawal of life support in intensive-care units in France: a prospective survey. French LATAREA Group. Lancet 2001; 357: 9-14.
27. Pochard F, Azoulay E, Chevret S, Vinsonneau C, Grassin M, Lemaire F et al. French PROTOCETIC Group. French intensivists do not apply American recommendations regarding decisions to forgo life-sustaining therapy. Crit Care Med 2001; 29: 1887-92.
28. Sprung CL, Cohen SL, Sjokvist P, Baras M, Bulow HH, Hovilehto S et al. Ethicus Study Group. End-of-life practices in European intensive care units: the Ethicus Study. JAMA 2003; 290: 790-7.
29. Azoulay E, Pochard F, Chevret S, Adrie C, Annane D, Bleichner G et al. FAMIREA Study Group. Half the family members of intensive care unit patients do not want to share in the decision-making process: a study in 78 French intensive care units. Crit Care Med 2004; 32: 1832-8.
30. Van der Heide A, Deliens L, Faisst K, Nilstun T, Norup M, Paci E et al. EURELD consortium. End-of-life decision-making in six European countries: descriptive study. Lancet 2003; 362: 345-50.
31. Wunsch H, Harrison DA, Harvey S, Rowan K. End-of-life decisions: a cohort study of the withdrawal of all active treatment in intensive care units in the United Kingdom. Intensive Care Med 2005; 31: 823-31.
32. Fins JJ, Miller FG, Acres CA, Bacchetta MD, Huzzard LL, Rapkin BD. End-of-life decision-making in the hospital: current practice and future prospects. J Pain Symptom Manage 1999; 17: 6-15.
33. Tschann JM, Kaufman SR, Micco GP. Family involvement in end-of-life hospital care. J Am Geriatr Soc 2003; 51: 835-40.
34. Zingmond DS, Wenger NS. Regional and institutional variation in the initiation of early do-not-resuscitate orders. Arch Intern Med 2005; 165: 1705-12.
35. Wood GG, Martin E. Withholding and withdrawing life-sustaining therapy in a Canadian intensive care unit. Can J Anaesth 1995; 42: 186-91.
36. Hall RI, Rocker GM. End-of-life care in the ICU: treatments provided when life support was or was not withdrawn. Chest 2000; 118: 1424-30.
37. Cardoso T, Fonseca T, Pereira S, Lencastre L. Life-sustaining treatment decisions in Portuguese intensive care units: a national survey of intensive care physicians. Crit Care 2003; 7: R167-75.
38. Vincent JL. Ethical principles in end-of-life decisions in different European countries. Swiss Med Wkly 2004; 134: 65-8.
39. Iyilikçi L, Erbayrakatar S, Gökmen N, Ellidokuz H, Kara HC, Günerli A. Practices of anaesthesiologists with regard to withholding and withdrawal of life support from the critically ill in Turkey. Acta Anaestesiol Scand 2004; 48: 457-62.
40. Hakim RB, Teno JM, Harrell FE Jr, Knaus WA, Wenger N, Phillips RS et al. Factors associated with do-not-resuscitate orders: patients' preferences, prognoses, and physicians' judgments. SUPPORT Investigators. Study to Understand Prognoses and Preferences for Outcomes and Risks of Treatments. Ann Intern Med 1996; 125: 284-93.
41. Daly BJ, Gorecki J, Sadowski A, Rudy EB, Montenegro HD, Song R et al. Do-not-resuscitate practices in the chronically critically ill. Heart Lung 1996; 25: 310-7.
42. Sinuff T, Cook DJ, Rocker GM, Griffith LE, Walter SD, Fisher MM et al. Level of Care Study Investigators & the Canadian Critical Care Trials Group. DNR directives are established early in mechanically ventilated intensive care unit patients. Can J Anesth 2004; 51: 1034-41.
43. Cook D, Rocker G, Marshall J, Sjokvist P, Dodek P, Griffith L et al. Level of Care Study Investigators and the Canadian Critical Care Trials Group. Withdrawal of mechanical ventilation in anticipation of death in the intensive care unit. N Engl J Med 2003; 349: 1123-32.
44. Esteban A, Gordo F, Solsona JF, Alia I, Caballero J, Bouza C et al. Withdrawing and withholding life support in the intensive care unit: a Spanish prospective multi-centre observational study. Intensive Care Med 2001; 27: 1744-9.
45. Sjokvist P, Berggren L, Cook DJ. Attitudes of Swedish physicians and nurses towards the use of life-sustaining treatment. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 1999; 43: 167-72.
46. Nolin T, Andersson R. Withdrawal of medical treatment in the ICU. A cohort study of 318 cases during 1994-2000. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 2003; 47: 501-7.
47. Eliasson AH, Howard RS, Torrington KG, Dillard TA, Phillips YY. Do-not-resuscitate decisions in the medical ICU: comparing physician and nurse opinions. Chest 1997; 111: 1106-11.
48. Faber-Langendoen K, Lanken PN. Dying patients in the intensive care unit: forgoing treatment, maintaining care. Ann Intern Med 2000; 133: 886-93.
49. Hamel MB, Teno JM, Goldman L, Lynn J, Davis RB, Galanos AN et al. Patient age and decisions to withhold life-sustaining treatments from seriously ill, hospitalized adults. SUPPORT Investigators. Study to Understand Prognoses and Preferences for Outcomes and Risks of Treatments. Ann Intern Med 1999; 130: 116-25.
50. Skerritt U, Pitt B. 'Do not resuscitate'. How? why? and when? Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 1997; 12: 667-70.
51. Vetsch G, Uehlinger DE, Zürcher Zenklusen RM. DNR orders at a tertiary care hospital - are they appropriate? Swiss Med Wkly 2002; 132: 190-6.
52. Kelly WF, Eliasson AH, Stocker DJ, Hnatiuk OW. Do specialists differ on do-not-resuscitate decisions? Chest 2002; 121: 957-63.
53. Blackhall LJ, Frank G, Murphy ST, Michel V, Palmer JM, Azen SP. Ethnicity and attitudes towards life sustaining technology. Soc Sci Med 1999; 48: 1779-89.
54. Hopp FP, Duffy SA. Racial variations in end-of-life care. J Am Geriatr Soc 2000; 48: 658-63.
55. Shepardson LB, Gordon HS, Ibrahim SA, Harper DL, Rosenthal GE. Racial variation in the use of do-not-resuscitate orders. J Gen Intern Med 1999; 14: 15-20.
56. Johnson KS, Elbert-Avila KI, Tulsky JA. The influence of spiritual beliefs and practices on the treatment preferences of African Americans: a review of the literature. J Am Geriatr Soc 2005; 53: 711-9.
57. Pfeifer MP, Sidorov JE, Smith AC, Boero JF, Evans AT, Settle MB. The discussion of end-of-life medical care by primary care patients and physicians: a multicenter study using structured qualitative interviews. The EOL Study Group. J Gen Intern Med 1994; 9: 82-8.
58. Frank C, Heyland DK, Chen B, Farquhar D, Myers K, Iwaasa K. Determining resuscitation preferences of elderly inpatients: a review of the literature. CMAJ 2003; 169: 795-9.
59. Stolman CJ, Gregory JJ, Dunn D, Levine JL. Evaluation of patient, physician, nurse, and family attitudes toward do not resuscitate orders. Arch Intern Med 1990; 150: 653-8.
60. Gross MD. What do patients express as their preferences in advance directives? Arch Intern Med 1998; 158: 363-5.
61. Carlet J, Thijs LG, Antonelli M, Cassel J, Cox P, Hill N et al. Challenges in end-of-life care in the ICU. Statement of the 5th International Consensus Conference in Critical Care: Brussels, Belgium, April 2003. Intensive Care Med 2004; 30: 770-84.
62. Cohen S, Sprung C, Sjokvist P, Lippert A, Ricou B, Baras M et al. Communication of end-of-life decisions in European intensive care units. Intensive Care Med 2005; 31: 1215-21.
63. Morgan R, King D, Prajapati C, Rowe J. Views of elderly patients and their relatives on cardiopulmonary resuscitation. BMJ 1994; 308: 1677-8.
64. Vincent JL. Information in the ICU: are we being honest with our patients? The results of a European questionnaire. Intensive Care Med 1998; 24: 1251-6.
65. Hildén HM, Louhiala P, Palo J. End of life decisions: attitudes of Finnish physicians. J Med Ethics 2004; 30: 362-5.
66. Lofmark R, Nilstun T. Do-not-resuscitate orders - should the patient be informed? J Intern Med 1997; 241: 421-5.
67. Covinsky KE, Fuller JD, Yaffe K, Johnston CB, Hamel MB, Lynn J et al. Communication and decision-making in seriously ill patients: findings of the SUPPORT project. The Study to Understand Prognoses and Preferences for Outcomes and Risks of Treatments. J Am Geriatr Soc 2000; 48 (Suppl. 5): S187-93.
68. Fischer GS, Tulsky JA, Rose MR, Siminoff LA, Arnold RM. Patient knowledge and physician predictions of treatment preferences after discussion of advance directives. J Gen Intern Med 1998; 13: 447-54.
69. Marbella AM, Desbiens NA, Mueller-Rizner N, Layde PM. Surrogates' agreement with patients' resuscitation preferences: effect of age, relationship, and SUPPORT intervention. Study to understand prognoses and preferences for outcomes and risks of treatment. J Crit Care 1998; 13: 140-5.
70. Wenger NS, Phillips RS, Teno JM, Oye RK, Dawson NV, Liu H et al. Physician understanding of patient resuscitation preferences: insights and clinical implications. J Am Geriatr Soc 2000; 48 (Suppl. 5): S44-51.
71. Puchalski CM, Zhong Z, Jacobs MM, Fox E, Harrold J, Galanos A et al. Patients who want their family and physician to make resuscitation decisions for them: observations from SUPPORT and HELP. Study to Understand Prognoses and Preferences for Outcomes and Risks of Treatments. Hospitalized Elderly Longitudinal Project. J Am Geriatr Soc 2000; 48 (Suppl. 5): S84-90.
72. Sehgal A, Galbraith A, Chesney M, Schoenfeld P, Charles G, Lo B. How strictly do dialysis patients want their advance directives followed? JAMA 1992; 267: 59-63.
73. Teno JM, Clarridge BR, Casey V, Welch LC, Wetle T, Shield R et al. Family perspective on end-of-life care at the last place of care. JAMA 2004; 291: 88-93.
74. Lofmark R, Nilstun T. Informing patients and relatives about do-not-resuscitate decisions. Attitudes of cardiologists and nurses in Sweden. J Intern Med 1998; 243: 191-5.
75. Gajewska K, Schroeder M, De Marre F, Vincent JL. Analysis of terminal events in 109 successive deaths in a Belgian intensive care unit. Intensive Care Med 2004; 30: 1224-7.
76. Tallgren M, Klepstad P, Petersson J, Skram U, Hynninen M. Ethical issues in intensive care - a survey among Scandinavian intensivists. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 2005; 49: 1092-100.
77. Vincent JL. European attitudes towards ethical problems in intensive care medicine: results of an ethical questionnaire. Intensive Care Med 1990; 16: 256-64.
78. Hofmann JC, Wenger NS, Davis RB, Teno J, Connors AF, Desbiens N et al. Patient preferences for communication with physicians about end-of-life decisions. SUPPORT Investigators. Study to Understand Prognoses and Preferences for Outcomes and Risks of Treatments. Ann Intern Med 1997; 127: 1-12.
79. Fried TR, Bradley EH, O'Leary J. Prognosis communication in serious illness: perceptions of older patients, caregivers, and clinicians. J Am Geriatr Soc 2003; 51: 1398-403.
80. Bruera E, Neumann CM, Mazzocato C, Stiefel F, Sala R. Attitudes and beliefs of palliative care physicians regarding communication with terminally ill cancer patients. Palliat Med 2000; 14: 287-98.
81. Azoulay E, Pochard F, Kentish-Barnes N, Chevret S, Aboab J, Adrie C et al. Risk of post-traumatic stress symptoms in family members of intensive care unit patients. Am J Respir Crit Care Med, 2005; 171: 987-94.
82. Svantesson M, Sjokvist P, Thorsen H. End-of-life decisions in Swedish ICUs. How do physicians from the admitting department reason? Intensive Crit Care Nurs 2003; 19: 241-51.
83. Benbenishty J, Dekeyser Ganz F, Lippert A, Bulow HH, Wennberg E, Henderson B et al. Nurse involvement in end-of-life decision making: the ETHICUS Study. Intensive Care Med 2006; 31: 129-32.
84. Melltorp G, Nilstun T. The difference between withholding and withdrawing life-sustaining treatment. Intensive Care Med 1997; 23: 1264-7.
85. Sprung CL, Eidelman LA, Pizov R, Fisher CJ, Ziegler E, Sadoff JC et al. Influence of alterations in forgoing life-sustaining treatment practices on a clinical sepsis trial. Crit Care Med 1997; 25: 383-7.
86. White DB, Curtis JR. Care near the end-of-life in critically ill patients: a North American perspective. Curr Opin Crit Care, 2005; 11: 610-5.
87. Fassier T, Lautrette A, Ciroldi M, Azoulay E. Care at the end of life in critically ill patients: the European perspective. Curr Opin Crit Care 2005; 11: 616-23.
88. Levin PD, Sprung CL. Cultural differences at the end of life. Crit Care Med 2003; 31 (Suppl. 5): S354-6.