Introduction of genetic engineering in aquaculture: Ecological and ethical implications for science and governance

Aquaculture

Volumn 250, Issue 3-4, 2005, Pages 542-554

  Myhr, Anne Ingeborg ^a   Dalmo, Roy Ambli ^b  

^a University of Tromsö   (Norway)

^b UNIVERSITY OF TROMSØ   (Norway)

Author keywords

DNA vaccines; Ethics; Extended peer review; GM feed; Risk governance; Scientific uncertainty; Sustainable development

Indexed keywords

AQUACULTURE; CONSUMER-RESOURCE INTERACTION; ETHICS; FISHERY MANAGEMENT; FISHERY POLICY; GENETIC ENGINEERING; RISK ASSESSMENT;

EID: 28444456723     PISSN: 00448486     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.aquaculture.2004.12.032     Document Type: Review

References (100)

1. ABRAC (Agricultural Biotechnology Research Advisory Committee-U.S. Department of Agriculture) Performance standards for safely conducting research with genetically modified fish and shellfish 1995 (http://www.isb.vt.edu/ perfstands/psmain.cfm )
2. Anonymous Europeans and biotechnology in 2002. European Commission Eurobarometer 58 2003
3. A. Aumaitre, K. Aulrich, A. Chesson, G. Flachowsky, and G. Piva New feeds from genetically modified plants: substantial equivalence, nutritional equivalence, digestibility, and safety for animals and the food chain Livest. Prod. Sci. 74 2002 223 238
4. S. Bauer, C.J. Kirschning, H. Häcker, V. Redecke, S. Hausmann, S. Akira, H. Wagner, and G.B. Lipford Human TLR9 confers responsiveness to bacterial DNA via species-specific CpG motif recognition Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 98 2001 9237 9242
5. A. Bouchie DNA vaccine deployed for endangered condors Nat. Biotechnol. 21 2003 11
6. P. Boudinot, M. Blanco, P. deKinkelin, and A. Benmansour Combined DNA immunisation with the glycoprotein gene of viral hemorrhagic septicaemia virus and infectious hematopoietic necrosis virus induces double-specific protective immunity and non-specific response in rainbow trout Virology 12 1998 297 306
7. British Agriculture and Environment Biotechnology Commission Animals and biotechnology 2002 BAEBC London September
8. J.Y. Byon, T. Ohira, I. Hirono, and T. Aoki Use of cDNA microarray to study immunity against viral hemorrhagic septicemia (VHS) in Japanese flounder (Paralichthys olivaceus) following DNA vaccination Fish Shellfish Immunol. 18 2005 135 147
9. J. Cayford Breeding sanity into the GM food debate Issues Sci. Technol. 20 2004 49 56
10. S. Corbeil, S.E. LaPatra, E.D. Anderson, and G. Kurath Nanogram quantities of a DNA vaccine protect rainbow trout fry against heterologous strains of infectious hematopoietic necrosis virus Vaccine 8 2000 2817 2824
11. V.T. Covello, and M.W. Merkhofer Risk assessment methods; approaches for assessing health and environmental risks 1993 Plenum Press New York
12. R.A. Dalmo, K. Ingebrigtsen, and J. Bøgwald Non-specific defence mechanisms in fish, with particular reference to the reticuloendothelial system J. Fish Dis. 20 1997 241 273
13. K. Davies What makes genetically modified organisms so distasteful? Trends Biotechnol. 19 2001 424 427
14. J.M. Dijkstra, H. Okamoto, M. Ototake, and T. Nakanishi Luciferase expression 2 years after DNA injection in glass catfish (Kryptopterus bicirrhus) Fish Shellfish Immunol. 11 2001 199 202
15. J.L. Domingo Health risks of GM foods: many opinions but few data Science 288 2000 1748 1749
16. M. Dupuis, K. Denis-Mize, C. Woo, C. Goldbeck, M.J. Selby, M. Chen, G.R. Otten, J.B. Ulmer, J.J. Donnelly, G. Ott, and D. McDonald Distribution of DNA vaccines determines their immunogenicity after intramuscular injection in mice J. Immunol. 165 2000 2850 2858
17. R. Einspanier, A. Klotz, J. Kraft, K. Aulrich, R. Poser, F. Schwägle, B. Jahreis, and G. Flachowsky The fate of forage plant DNA in farm animals, a collaborative case-study investigating cattle and chicken fed recombinant plant material Eur. Food Res. Technol. 212 2001 129 134
18. EU, Commission of the European Communities A strategy for the sustainable development of European aquaculture 2002 (http://europa.eu.int )
19. Expert Panel of the Royal Society of Canada Elements of precaution; recommendations for the regulation of food biotechnology in Canada 2001 (http://www.rsc.ca )
20. FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations) Genetically modified organisms and aquaculture FAO Fish. Circ. vol. 989 2003 FAO Rome
21. M. Fernandez-Alonso, A. Rocha, and J.M. Coll DNA vaccination by immersion and ultrasound to trout viral haemorrhagic septicaemia virus Vaccine 19 2001 3067 3075
22. Fisheries and Oceans Canada Biotechnology to help develop better salmon feeds 2003 (http://www.dfo-mpo.gc.ca/science.aquaculture/biotech/fact3_e.htm )
23. G.S. Foss, and S. Rogne Gene medification or genetic modification? The devil is in the details Nat. Biotechnol. 21 2003 1280 1281
24. S.O. Funtowicz, and J.R. Ravetz Uncertainty and quality in science for policy 1990 Kluwer Dordrecht, Netherlands
25. Gene Technology Act The act relating to the production and use of genetically modified organism. Act no. 38 of 2 April 1993, Oslo, Norway 1993 (http://www.bion.no )
26. E. Hallerman, and A. Kapuscinski Incorporating risk assessment and risk management into public policies on genetically modified finfish and shellfish Aquaculture 173 1995 309 318
27. E. Hallerman, D. King, and A. Kapuscinski A decision support software for safely conducting research with genetically modified fish and shellfish Aquaculture 73 1999 309 318
28. R. Hannesson Aquaculture and fisheries Mar. Policy 27 2003 169 178
29. A.G. Haslberger Codex guidelines for GM foods include the analysis of unintended effects Nat. Biotechnol. 21 2003 739 741
30. P.W. Hedrick Invasion of transgenes from salmon or other genetically modified organisms into natural populations Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 58 2001 841 844
31. J.A. Heinemann, and P.D. Roughan New hypotheses on the material nature of horizontally transferred genes Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 906 2000 169 186
32. J.A. Heinemann, and T. Traavik Problems in monitoring horizontal gene transfer in field trials of transgenic plants Nat. Biotechnol. 22 2004 1105 1109
33. J. Heppell, and H.L. Davis Application of DNA vaccine technology to aquaculture Adv. Drug Rev. 43 2000 29 43
34. C.L. Hew, and G.L. Fletcher The role of aquatic biotechnology in aquaculture Aquaculture 197 2002 191 204
35. R.A. Hiter, J.A. Foran, D.O. Carpenter, M.C. Hamilton, B.A. Knuth, and S.J. Schawn Global assessment of organic contamination in farmed salmon Science 303 2004 226 229
36. Holmenkollen guidelines for sustainable aquaculture Proceedings of the second international symposium on sustainable aquaculture, Oslo, Norway 1998 A.A. Balkema Rotterdam/Brookfield (http://www.ntva.no/rapport/aqua.htm )
37. P.T. Jystad An intrafish.com industry report on fishmeal and oil or vegetable alternatives: will high volume prediction spoil premium fish products? 2001 Intrafish, Bodø, Norway
38. P.H.M. Joosten, M.Y. Engelsma, M.D. van der Zee, and J.H.W.M. Rombout Induction of oral tolerance in carp (Cyprinus carpio L.) after feeding protein antigens Vet. Immunol. Immunopathol. 60 1997 187 196
39. E.R. Kandimalla, F.-G. Zhu, L. Bhagat, D. Yu, and S. Agrawal Toll-like receptor 9: modulation of recognition and cytokine induction by novel synthetic CpG DNAs Biochem. Soc. Trans. 31 2003 654 658
40. A.R. Kapuscinski, T. Nega, and E.M. Hallermann Adaptive biosafety assessment and management regimes for aquatic genetically modified organisms in the environment R.S.V. Pullin D.M. Bartley J. Kooimans Towards policies for conservation and sustainable use of aquatic genetic resources Conference Proceedings, 59, ICLARM (International Center for Living Aquatic Resources Management), Manila 1999 225 251
41. A.R. Kapuscinski, R.M. Goodman, S.D. Hann, L.R. Jacobs, E.E. Pullins, C.S. Johnson, J.D. Kinsey, R.L. Krall, A.G.M. La Viña, M.G. Mellon, and V.W. Ruttan Making safety first a reality for biotechnology products Nat. Biotechnol. 21 2003 599 601
42. F.S.B. Kibenge, M.J.T. Kibenge, P.K. McKenna, P. Stothard, R. Marshall, R.R. Cusack, and S. McGeachy Antigenic variation among isolates of infectious salmon anaemia virus correlates with genetic variation of the viral haemagglutinin gene J. Gen. Virol. 82 2001 2869 2879
43. C.H. Kim, M.C. Johnson, J.D. Drennan, B.E. Simon, E. Thomann, and J.C. Leong DNA vaccination encoding viral glycoproteins induce non-specific immunity and Mx protein synthesis in fish J. Virol. 74 2000 7048 7054
44. N. Kobayashi, T. Kuramoto, K. Yamaoka, M. Hashida, and Y. Takakura Hepatic uptake and gene expression mechanisms following intravenous administration of plasmid DNA by conventional and hydrodynamic-based procedures J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther. 297 2001 853 860
45. H.A. Kuiper, H.P.J.M. Noteborn, E.J. Kok, and G.A. Kleter Safety aspects of novel food Food Res. Int. 35 2002 267 270
46. H.A. Kuiper, and G.A. Kleter The scientific basis for risk assessment of regulation of genetically modified foods Trends Food Sci. Technol. 14 2003 277 293
47. S. LaPatra, S. Corbeil, G.R. Jones, W.D. Shewmaker, and G. Kurath The dose-dependent effect on protection and humoral responses to a DNA vaccine against infectious hematopoietic necrosis virus (IHN) virus in subyearling rainbow trout J. Aquat. Anim. Health 12 2000 181 188
48. C.M. Lawson, W.S. Yeow, C.M. Lee, and M.W. Beilharz In vivo expression of an interferon-alpha gene by intramuscular injection of naked DNA J. Interferon Cytokine Res. 17 1997 255 261
49. M.K. Lee, S.L. Blake, J.T. Singer, and B.L. Nicholson Genomic variation of aquatic birnaviruses analyzed with restriction fragment length polymorphism Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 62 1996 2513 2520
50. J.C. Leong, and J.L. Fryer Viral vaccines for aquaculture Annu. Rev. Fish Dis. 3 1993 225 240
51. M.A. Liu Vaccine developments Nat. Med. 4 1998 515
52. N. Lorenzen, N.J. Olesen, and C. Koch Immunity to VHS virus in rainbow trout Aquaculture 172 1999 41 61
53. N. Lorenzen, E. Lorenzen, K. Einer-Jensen, J. Heppell, and H.L. Davis Genetic vaccination of rainbow trout against viral haemorrhagic septicaemia virus: small amounts of plasmid DNA protect against a heterologous serotype Virus Res. 63 1999 19 25
54. N. Lorenzen, E. Lorenzen, K. Einer-Jensen, and S. LaPatra Immunity induced shortly after DNA vaccination of rainbow trout against rhabdoviruses protects against heterologous virus but not against bacterial pathogens Dev. Comp. Immunol. 26 2001 173 179
55. H.P.S. Makkar Anti-nutritional factors in foods for livestock M. Gill E. Owen G.E. Pollot T.L.J. Lawrence Animal production in developing countries BSAP Occas. Publ. vol. 16 1993 69 85
56. D.G. Mayo, and R.D. Hollander Acceptable evidence: science and values in risk management 1991 Oxford University Press Oxford
57. A.H. Meijer, S.F. Gabby Krens, I.A. Medina Rodriquez, S. He, W. Bitter, B.E. Snaar-Jagalska, and H.P. Spaink Expression analysis of the toll-like receptor and TIR domain adaptor families of zebrafish Mol. Immunol. 40 2003 773 783
58. P. Melamed, Z. Gong, G. Fletcher, and C.L. Hew The potential impact of modern biotechnology on fish aquaculture Aquaculture 204 2002 255 269
59. K. Momma, W. Hashimoto, S. Ozawa, S. Kawai, T. Katsube, F. Takaiwa, M. Kito, S. Utsumi, and K. Murata Quality and safety evaluation of genetically engineered rice with soybean glycinin: analyses of the grain composition and digestibility of glycinin in transgenic rice Biosci. Biotechnol. Biochem. 63 1999 314 318
60. W.M. Muir The threats and benefits of GM fish EMBO Rep. 5 2004 654 659
61. W.M. Muir, and R.D. Howard Possible ecological risks of transgenic organisms release when transgenes affect mating success, sexual selection and the Trojan gene hypothesis Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 96 1999 13853 13856
62. W.M. Muir, and R.D. Howard Assessment of possible ecological risks and hazards of transgenic fish with implications for other sexually reproductive organisms Transgenic Res. 11 2002 101 114
63. A.I. Myhr, and T. Traavik Genetically modified crops: precautionary science and conflicts of interests J. Agric. Environ. Ethics 16 2003 227 247
64. A.I. Myhr, and T. Traavik Sustainable development and Norwegian genetic engineering regulation: applications, impact and challenges J. Agric. Environ. Ethics 16 2003 317 335
65. R.L. Naylor, R.J. Goldburg, J.H. Primavera, N. Kautsky, M.C.M. Beverigde, J. Clay, L. Folke, J. Lubchenco, H. Mooney, and M. Yroell Effect of aquaculture on world fish supplies Nature 405 2000 1017 1024
66. T. Netherwood, S.M. Martin-Orue, A.G. O'Donnell, S. Gockling, J. Graham, J.C. Mathers, and H.J. Gilbert Assessing the survival of transgenic plant DNA in the human gastrointestinal tract Nat. Biotechnol. 22 2004 204 209
67. C. Nicoletti Unsolved mysteries of intestinal M cells Gut 47 2000 735 739
68. K.M. Nielsen, and J.P. Townsend Monitoring and modelling horizontal gene transfer Nat. Biotechnol. 22 2004 110 1114
69. NRC (National Research Council) Animal biotechnology: science based concerns 2002 National Academy Press Washington, DC
70. NRC (National Research Council) Biological confinement of genetically engineered organisms 2004 National Academy Press Washington, DC
71. Nuffield Council on Bioethics Genetically modified crops: the ethical and social issues 1999 Nuffield Council on Bioethics London http://www.nuffield. org/bioethics
72. K.E. Nusbaum, B.F. Smith, P. DeInnocentes, and R.C. Bird Protective immunity induced by DNA vaccination of channel catfish with early and late transcripts of the channel catfish herpesvirus (IHV-1) Vet. Immunol. Immunopathol. 84 2002 151 168
73. H. Ochman, J.G. Lawrence, and E.A. Grotsman Lateral gene transfer and the nature of bacterial innovation Nature 405 2000 299 304
74. Pew Initiative on Food and Biotechnology Future fish: issues in science and regulation of transgenic fish 2003 Pew Initiative on Food and Biotechnology Washington, DC
75. M. Power Lots of fish in the sea; salmon aquaculture, genomics and ethics. Electronic working paper series W. Maurice Young center for applied ethics 2003 University of British Columbia (http://www.ethics.ubc.ca )
76. I. Pryme In-vivo studies on possible health consequences of GM food and feed Nutr. Health 17 2003 1 8
77. H. Qin, Y. Dong, and A.G. von Arnim Epigenetic interactions between Arabidopsis transgenes: characterization in light of transgene integration sites Plant Mol. Biol. 52 2003 217 231
78. T. Reuter, and K. Aulrich Investigation on genetically modified maize (BT-maize) in pig nutrition: fate of feed-ingested foreign DNA in pig bodies Eur. Food Res. Technol. 216 2003 185 192
79. Romøren, K., 2003. Liposome- and chitosan-based formulations used for gene delivery to fish: -in vivo and in vitro studies of possibilities and limitations. Ph.D. dissertation, Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences, Department of Pharmaceutics. School of Pharmacy, University of Oslo, Norway, ISSN 1501-7710.
80. K. Romøren, B.J. Thu, and J. Evensen Distribution of luciferase expression after intraperitoneal administration of lipoplex to rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) fry J. Liposom. Res. 13 2003 44 55
81. G. Rowe, and L.J. Frewer Public participation methods: a framework for evaluation Sci. Technol. Human Values 25 2000 3 21
82. P.H. Russell, T. Kanellos, I.D. Sylvester, K.C. Chang, and C.R. Howard Nucleic acid immunisation with a reporter gene results in antibody production in goldfish (Carassius auratus) Fish Shellfish Immunol. 8 1998 121 128
83. A. Sagar, A. Daemmrich, and M. Ashiya The tragedy of the commoners: biotechnology and its public Nat. Biotechnol. 18 2000 2 4
84. M. Sanden, I.J. Bruce, M.A. Rahman, and G. Hemre The fate of transgenic sequences present in genetically modified plant products in fish feed; investigating the survival of GM soybean DNA fragments during field trials in Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar L Aquaculture 237 2004 391 405
85. K.J. Stacey, M.J. Sweet, and D.A. Hume Macrophages ingest and are activated by bacterial DNA J. Immunol. 157 1996 2116 2122
86. Stirling, A., 1999. On science and precaution on risk management of technological risk. An ESTO project report prepared for the European Commission- JRC Institute for Prospective Technological Studies, Seville. (http://www.sussex.ac.uk/Units/gec/gecko/r9e-prc-.htm).
87. I. Strobel, S. Berchtold, A. Götze, U. Schulze, G. Schuler, and A. Steinkasserer Human dendritic cells transfected with either RNA or DNA encoding influenza matrix protein M1 differ in their ability to stimulate cytotoxic T lymphocytes Gene Ther. 7 2000 2028 2035
88. B. Tappeser, M. Jager, and C. Eckelkamp Survival, persistence, transfer: the fate of genetically modified microorganisms and recombinant DNA in different environments D.K. Letourneau B.E. Burrows Genetically engineered organisms; assessing environmental and human health effects 2002 CRC Press Boca Raton, FL 223 251
89. D. Tave Genetics for fish hatchery managers 2nd ed. 1993 Van Nostrand Reinhold New York
90. G.S. Traxler, E. Anderson, S.E. LaPatra, J. Richard, B. Shewmaker, and G. Kurath Naked DNA vaccination of Atlantic salmon, Salmon salar against IHNV Dis. Aquat. Org. 38 1999 183 190
91. T.-R. Tuominen, and M. Esmark Food for thought; the use of marine resources in fish feed. Report 02/03 2003 WWF Norway (http://www.panda.org/ downloads/marine/foodforthoug.pdf )
92. H. Verhoog The intrinsic value of animals: its implementation in governmental regulations in the Netherlands and its implications for plants D. Heaf J. Wirz Intrinsic value and integrity of plants in the context of GE Proceedings of Ifgene Workshop, Dornach, Switzerland 2001 15 18
93. T. Verri, L. Ingrosso, R. Chiloiro, A. Danieli, V. Zonno, P. Alifano, N. Romano, G. Scapigliatti, S. Vilella, and C. Storelli Assessment of DNA vaccine potential for gilthead sea bream (Sparus aurata) by intramuscular injection of a reporter gene Fish Shellfish Immunol. 15 2003 283 295
94. W.S. Wang, and B.L. Nicholson Antigenic and in vitro host range variety in populations of aquatic birnaviruses demonstrated by selection for neutralization resistance to monoclonal antibodies Zool. Stud. 35 1996 93 104
95. WCED (World Commission on Environment and Development) Our common future 1987 Oxford University Press Oxford, UK
96. B. Wynne Uncertainty and environmental learning: reconceiving science and policy in the preventive paradigm Glob. Environ. Change 2 1992 111 127
97. B. Wynne Creating public alienation: expert cultures of risk and ethics of GMOs Sci. Cult. 10 2001 445 481
98. Z.Q. Xiang, and H. Ertl Manipulation of the immune response to a plasmid-encoded viral antigen by coinoculation with plasmids expressing cytokines Immunity 2 1995 129 135
99. X. Ye, S. Al-Babili, A. Kløti, J. Zhang, P. Lucca, P. Beyer, and I. Potrykus Engineering the provitamin A (beta-carotene) biosynthetic pathway into (carotenoid-free) rice endosperm Science 287 2000 303 305
100. H. Zhao, H. Hemmi, S. Akira, S.H. Cheng, R.K. Scheule, and N.S. Yew Contribution of toll-like receptor 9 signalling to the acute inflammatory response to nonviral vectors Molec. Ther. 9 2004 241 248