Faculty status for librarians in higher education

Portal

Volumn 3, Issue 3, 2003, Pages 431-445

  Hoggan, Danielle Bodrero ^a  

^a SCRIPPS RESEARCH INSTITUTE   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 13444249343     PISSN: 15312542     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1353/pla.2003.0060     Document Type: Article

References (129)

1. Blaise Cronin, "The Mother of all Myths," Library Journal 126, 3 (February 15,2001): 144.
2. Mark Y. Herring, "An Impediment to Service," Library Journal 126 (April 15,2001): 8.
3. Stephen Karetzky, "Blazing at Blaise," Library Journal 126 (April 1, 2001): 8.
4. Jane D. Schweinsburg, "20/20 Hindsight," Library Journal 126 (April 15, 2001): 8.
5. Karetzky.
6. Lisa Dunn, "Cronin is 'Mything' the Point," Library Journal 126 (May 1,2001): 8.
7. Robert Eno, "Colleagues Not in Arms," Library Journal 126 (June 1, 2001): 10.
8. Association of College and Research Libraries, Committee on the Status of Academic Librarians, "Standards for Faculty Status for College and University Librarians," American Library Association (2001). Available: [June 7, 2003].
9. Association of College and Research Libraries, Committee on the Status of Academic Librarians, "Standards for Faculty Status for College and University Librarians," American Library Association (2001). Available: [June 7, 2003]., Ibid.
10. Heartsill Young (ed.), The ALA Glossary of Library and Information Science (Chicago: American Library Association, 1983), 1.
11. Association of College and Research Libraries, Academic Status Committee, "Model Statement of Criteria and Procedures for Appointment, Promotion in Academic Rank, and Tenure for College and University Librarians," American Library Association (1987). Available: [June7,2003].
12. Association of College and Research Libraries, Academic Status Committee, "Model Statement of Criteria and Procedures for Appointment, Promotion in Academic Rank, and Tenure for College and University Librarians," American Library Association (1987). Available: [June7,2003]., Ibid., paragraph 2.
13. Association of College and Research Libraries, Board of Directors, "Statement on the Terminal Professional Degree for Academic Librarians," American Library Association (2001).., [June 7, 2003].
14. ACRL, Academic Status Committee, "Model Statement."
15. ACRL, Academic Status Committee, "Model Statement.", Ibid.
16. ACRL, Committee on the Status of Academic Librarians, "Standards for Faculty Status."
17. Shannon Cary, "Faculty Rank, Status, and Tenure for Librarians: Current Trends," College & Research Libraries News 62 (May 2001): 510-11,520.
18. Association of College and Research Libraries, "Faculty Rank, Status, and Tenure for Librarians," University of Virginia Library (1999). Available: [June 7,2003].
19. Association of College and Research Libraries, "Faculty Rank, Status, and Tenure for Librarians," University of Virginia Library (1999). Available: [June 7, 2003].,Ibid.
20. Cary.
21. Cary., Ibid., paragraph 6 and Table 1.
22. ACRL, "Faculty Rank, Status, and Tenure."
23. Cary.
24. ACRL, "Faculty Rank, Status, and Tenure."
25. Cary.
26. Cary., Ibid., paragraph 10.
27. ACRL, "Faculty Rank, Status, and Tenure."
28. ACRL, "Faculty Rank, Status, and Tenure.", Ibid.
29. ACRL, Committee on the Status of Academic Librarians, "Standards for Faculty Status."
30. Mary Biggs, "Sources of Tension and Conflict Between Librarians and Faculty Journal of Higher Education 52 (March/April 1981): 182-201.
31. Herbert S. White, "Faculty Status for Academic Librarians: The Search for the Holy Grail," Library Journal 121 (November 15, 1996): 39-40. Also: Dunn, Karetzky, and Schweinsburg.
32. W. Bede Mitchell and Mary Reichel, "Publish or Perish: A Dilemma for Academic Librarians?" College & Research Libraries 60, 3 (May 1999): 232-43.
33. Dale S. Montanelli and Patricia E Stenstrom, "The Benefits of Research for Academic Librarians and the Institutions They Serve," College & Research Libraries 47 (September 1986): 482-485.
34. David V. Loertscher, "Collaboration: A Major Key to Success," San Jose State University School of Library and Information Science Uanuary 27,2000). Available: [7, 2003].
35. Cronin.
36. Montanelli and Stenstrom.
37. Bruce R. Kingma and Gillian M. McCombs, "The Opportunity Costs of Faculty Status for Academic Librarians," College & Research Libraries 56 (May 1995): 258-264.
38. Rodger C. Lewis, "Publish or Perish? Looking at Publication for Tenure from the Other Side of the Street," College & Research Libraries News 61 (August 2000): 606 08; White.
39. Richard W. Meyer, "A Measure of the Impact of Tenure," College & Research Libraries 60, 2 (March 1999): paragraph 11.
40. Richard W. Meyer, "Earnings Gains Through the Institutionalized Standard of Faculty Status," Library Administration and Management 4 (Fall 1990): 184-193.
41. ACRL, Academic Status Committee, "Model Statement," paragraph 29.
42. Cary.
43. Jean A. Major, "Mature Librarians and the University Faculty: Factors Contributing to Librarians' Acceptance as Colleagues," College & Research Libraries 54 (November 1993): 463-469.
44. Marjorie A. Benedict, "Librarians' Satisfaction With Faculty Status," College & Research Libraries 52 (November 1991): 538-548.
45. Marjorie A. Benedict, "Librarians' Satisfaction With Faculty Status," College & Research Libraries 52 (November 1991): 538-548., Ibid.,538.
46. Marjorie A. Benedict, "Librarians' Satisfaction With Faculty Status," College & Research Libraries 52 (November 1991): 538-548., Ibid.,538., Ibid.,539.
47. Bomiie Horenstein, "Job Satisfaction of Academic Librarians: An Examination of the Relationships Between Satisfaction, Faculty Status, and Participation," College & Research Libraries 54 (May 1993): 255-269.
48. Bomiie Horenstein, "Job Satisfaction of Academic Librarians: An Examination of the Relationships Between Satisfaction, Faculty Status, and Participation," College & Research Libraries 54 (May 1993): 255-269.,Ibid.,255.
49. Bomiie Horenstein, "Job Satisfaction of Academic Librarians: An Examination of the Relationships Between Satisfaction, Faculty Status, and Participation," College & Research Libraries 54 (May 1993): 255-269.,Ibid.,255., Ibid.
50. Bomiie Horenstein, "Job Satisfaction of Academic Librarians: An Examination of the Relationships Between Satisfaction, Faculty Status, and Participation," College & Research Libraries 54 (May 1993): 255-269.,Ibid.,255., Ibid., Ibid., 264.
51. Dale Susan Bengston and Dorothy Shields, "A Test of Marchant's Predictive Formulas Involving Job Satisfaction," Journal of Academic Librarianship 11 (May 1985): 88-92.
52. Horenstein.
53. Michael Koenig, Ronald Morrison, and Linda Roberts, "Faculty Status for Library Professionals: Its Effect on Job Turnover and Job Satisfaction Among University Research Library Directors," College & Research Libraries 57 (May 1996): 295-300.
54. Benedict.
55. Meyer, "A Measure of the Impact of Tenure."
56. Meyer, "A Measure of the Impact of Tenure.", Ibid., paragraph 25.
57. Meyer, "A Measure of the Impact of Tenure.", Ibid., paragraph 26.
58. Richard L. Hart, "Scholarly Publication by University Librarians: A Study at Penn State," College & Research Libraries 60 (September 1999): 454-462.
59. Richard L. Hart, "Scholarly Publication by University Librarians: A Study at Penn State," College & Research Libraries 60 (September 1999): 454-462., Ibid.
60. The core literature was defined as the list of 36 journal titles identified by John M. Budd and Charles A. Seavy ("Characteristics of Journal Authorship by Academic Librarians," College & Research Libraries 51 [September 1990]: 469), as cited in Hart.
61. Hart, paragraph 12.
62. Peter S. Fiske, Put Your Science to Work: Tue Thke-charge Career Guide for Scientists (Washington, D.C.: American Geophysical Union, 2001), 168.
63. Biggs.
64. Biggs., Ibid.
65. Lewis; White.
66. Beth J. Shapiro, "The Myths Surrounding Faculty Status for Librarians," College & Research Libraries News 54 (November 1993): 562-563.
67. Major.
68. Meyer, "A Measure of the Impact of Tenure."
69. Meyer, "A Measure of the Impact of Tenure.", Ibid.,paragraphs 6-7.
70. Mitchell and Reichel, paragraph 19 and Table 4.
71. Shapiro.
72. Lewis, paragraph 8.
73. Mitchell and Reichel, paragraph 9.
74. Tyler Goldberg and Neal D. Nixon, "Periodic Career Review for Librarians at the University of Louisville," Kentucky Libraries 65 (Winter 2001): 14-15.
75. Jeannie P. Miller and Candace R. Benefiel, "Academic Librarians and the Pursuit of Tenure: The Support Group as a Strategy for Success," College & Research Libraries 59 (May 1998): 260-65.
76. Adakole Ochai and Peter S. Nedosa, "Publications Output of Librarians: The Search for Alternative Justification," African Journal of Library, Archives & Information Science 8 (October 1998): 89-96.
77. Ochai and Nedosa, paragraph 30.
78. Mitchell and Reichel, Table 1 and paragraph 37.
79. Elizabeth Cramer and John Boyd, "The Tenure Track and the Parent Track: A Road Guide," Wilson Library Bulletin 69 (March 1995): 41-42
80. Miller and Benefiel.
81. Karen G. Lawson and Nancy L. Peizer, "Assessing Technology-based Projects for Promotion and/or Tenure in ARL Academic Libraries," College & Research Libraries 60 (September 1999): 464-476
82. Association of College and Research Libraries Task Force on Institutional Priorities and Faculty Rewards, "Academic Librarianship and the Redefining Scholarship Project," American Library Association (March 1998). Available: [June 7,2003].
83. Pamela S. Bradigan and Carol A. Mularski, "Evaluation of Academic Librarians' Publications for Tenure and Initial Promotion," The Journal of Academic Librarianship 22 (September 1996): 360-365
84. Lawson and Pelzer.
85. Becky Culbertson, conversation with author, La Jolla, CA (March 20,2002).
86. Hart; Lewis.
87. Helen Belefant-Miller and Donald Ward King, "How, What, and Why Science Faculty Read," Science and Technology Libraries 19, 2 (2001): 105.
88. Lewis, paragraph 10.
89. Alan Edelson, "Re: Electronic Availability," paragraph 8 of message posted to Liblicense-L electronic mailing list (October 14, 1999). Available:>http://www.library.yale.edu/-llicense/ListArchives/9910/msg000l7. html< [ 7, 2003].
90. Alan Edelson, "Re: Electronic Availability," paragraph 8 of message posted to Liblicense-L electronic mailing list (October 14, 1999). Available:>http://www.library.yale.edu/-llicense/ListArchives/9910/msg000l7. html< [ 7, 2003]., Ibid.
91. Tony Ferguson, "Re: Electronic Availability," message posted to Liblicense-L electronic mailing list (October 5, 1999). Available: [ 7,20031.
92. Shapiro, 562.
93. Hart.
94. Cramer and Boyd.
95. Cramer and Boyd., Ibid., paragraph 2.
96. Cramer and Boyd., Ibid., paragraph 2., Ibid., paragraph 10.
97. Cramer and Boyd., Ibid., paragraph 2., Ibid., paragraph 10., Ibid., paragraphs 13-14.
98. Benedict; Horenstein; Mitchell and Reichel.
99. Biggs, 195.
100. Cary.
101. Benedict; Koenig, Morrison, and Roberts.
102. Benedict, 542, 545,547.
103. Hart, paragraph 10.
104. Anita M. Ferris, "Tales from the Tenure Track: A Cataloger's Ultimate Experience," published on LlScareer.com: The Library and Information Science Professional's Career Development Center (April 2002). Available: [ 7, 2003].
105. Cronin; Herring; arid Donald E. Riggs, "Faculty Status for Librarians: Force-Fitting into an inappropriate Mold or Not?" College & Research Libraries 60 (July 1999): 305-06.
106. Meyer, "Earnings Gains."
107. Meyer, "Earnings Gains.", Ibid., 191-192.
108. Mitchell and Reichel, paragraph 19, and also Table 4.
109. Biggs; Lewis; Meyer, "A Measure of the Impact of Tenure;" White.
110. Biggs, 196.
111. Dunn; Karetzky; Lewis; Meyer, "A Measure of the Impact of Tenure;" Schweinsburg; White.
112. Richard W. Meyer, "Librarian Salaries: Paid What We're Worth?" College & Research Libraries News 51 (June 1990): 508.
113. Richard W. Meyer, "Librarian Salaries: Paid What We're Worth?" College & Research Libraries News 51 (June 1990): 508., Ibid., 509.
114. Richard W. Meyer, "Librarian Salaries: Paid What We're Worth?" College & Research Libraries News 51 (June 1990): 508., Ibid., 509., Ibid., 508.
115. Richard W. Meyer, "Librarian Salaries: Paid What We're Worth?" College & Research Libraries News 51 (June 1990): 508., Ibid., 509., Ibid., 508., Ibid., 509.
116. Kingma and McCombs.
117. Kingma and McCombs., Ibid., 259.
118. Kingma and McCombs., Ibid., 259., Ibid., 258-259
119. Meyer, "Earnings Gains."
120. Kingma and McCombs.
121. Ross Johnson, "Faculty Status for Academic Librarians: What do 'Nonteachirig Faculty' Teach?" Tennessee Librarian 49 (Summer 1997): 8-9; Lewis.
122. Lewis, paragraph 14.
123. Meyer, "Paid What We're Worth," 508.
124. Biggs, 197.
125. President and Fellows of Harvard College, "Professional Staff," Handbook for Librarians & Professi nal and Administrative Staff in the Harvard University Library (December 15, 1998): paragraph 1. Available: [June 7,2003].
126. Culbertson.
127. Culbertson., Ibid.
128. Meyer, "Earnings Gains;" Shapiro.
129. Meyer, "Paid What We're Worth," 509.