The irony of western ideas in a multicultural world: Russians' intellectual engagement with the "End of History" and "Clash of Civilizations"

International Studies Review

Volumn 5, Issue 1, 2003, Pages 53-76

  Tsygankov, Andrei P ^a  

^a SAN FRANCISCO STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

CULTURAL IDENTITY; MULTICULTURALISM; WESTERN WORLD;

RUSSIAN FEDERATION;

EID: 0041768041     PISSN: 15219488     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/1521-9488.501003     Document Type: Article

References (139)

1. ALIYEV, ISMAIL. (1998) Ievraziystvo kak natsionalnaya ideiya. NG-Stsenariyi, 4.
2. ALKER, HAYWARD R. (1986) Dialectical Thinking about World Order. Part I: Ten World Hypotheses That Have Made My Days. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the International Studies Association, Anaheim, CA, March.
3. ALKER, HAYWARD R., AND THOMAS J. BIERSTEKER. (1984) The Dialectics of World Order: Notes for a Future Archeologist of International Savoir Faire. International Studies Quarterly 28:121-142.
4. ALKER, HAYWARD R., THOMAS J. BIERSTEKER, AND TAKASHI INOGUCHI. (1989) From Imperial Power Balancing to People's Wars. In International/Intertextual Relations, edited by James Der-Derian and Michael J. Shapiro. New York: Lexington Books.
5. ALKER, HAYWARD R., TAHIR AMIN, THOMAS BIERSTEKER, AND TAKASHI INOGUCHI. (1998) How Should We Theorize Contemporary Macro-Encounters: In Terms of Superstates, World Orders, or Civilizations? Paper presented at the Third Pan-European International Relations Conference, SGIR-ISA, Vienna, Austria, September 16-19.
6. ANDERSON, PERRY. (1992) A Zone of Engagement. London: Verso.
7. ARAB-OGLI, EDUARD A. (1990) Yevropeiskaya tsivilizatsiya i obschechelovecheskiye tsennosti. Voprosy filosofiyi 8:10-12.
8. AUDINLI, ERSEL, AND JULIE MATHEWS. (2000) Are the Core and Periphery lrreconcilable? The Curious World of Publishing in Contemporary International Relations. International Studies Perspectives 1:289-303.
9. BARBER, BENJAMIN R. (1992) Jihad vs. McWorld. Atlantic Monthly 269(3):231-235.
10. BATALOV, EDUARD YA. (1990) Yedinstvo v mnogoobraziyi-printsip zhivogo mira. Voprosy filosofiyi 8: 13-24.
11. BATKIN, LEONID. (1988) Vozobnovleniye istoriyi. Moscow: Moskovski Rabochi.
12. BOGATUROV, ALEKSEI. (1996) Plyuralisticheskaya odnopolyarnost' i interesy Rossiyi. Svobodnaya mysl' 2:25-36.
13. BORODAI, T. (1992) Vystupleniye. Voprosy filosofiyi 6:12-13.
14. BOZEMAN, ADDA. (1984) The International Order in a Multicultural World. In The Expansion of International Society, edited by Hedley Bull and Adam Watson. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
15. BREWER, MARILYNN B., AND DONALD T. CAMPBELL. (1976) Ethnocentrism and Intergroup Attitudes: East African Evidence. New York: Wiley.
16. BROWN, MICHAEL, E., SEAN M. LYNN-JONES, AND STEPHEN E. MILLER. (1996) Debating the Democratic Peace: An International Security Reader. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
17. BRUBAKER, ROGERS. (1996) Nationalism Reframed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
18. BRZEZINSKI, ZBIGNIEW. (1989) The Grand Failure: The Birth and Death of Communism in the Twentieth Century. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.
19. BULL, HEDLEY. (1972) The Theory of International Politics, 1919-1969. In The Aberystwyth Papers: International Politics, 1919-1969, edited by Brian Porter. London: Oxford University Press.
20. BULL, HEDLEY. (1992) Martin Wight and the Theory of International Relations. In International Theory: The Three Traditions, edited by Martin Wight. New York: Holmes and Meier.
21. BULL, HEDLEY, AND ADAM WATSON. (1984) The Expansion of International Society. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
22. BUZGALIN, ALEKSANDR. (2002) Russia and America: A New Twist in the Confrontation? Prism 8(3):www.jamestown.com.
23. DILIGENSKI, GERMAN G. (1991) "Konets istoriyi" ili smena tsivilizatsi? Voprosy filosofiyi 3:29-42.
24. DOYLE, MICHAEL. (1997) Ways of War and Peace: Realism, Liberalism, and Socialism. New York: W.W. Norton.
25. DUGIN, ALEKSANDR. (1991) Konservativnaya revolutsiya, 9-38. Moscow: Arktogeya.
26. DUGIN, ALEKSANDR. (1997) Osnovy Geopolitiki. Moscow: Arktogeya.
27. DUGIN, ALEKSANDR. (2002) Geopolitika terrora. Moscow: Arktogeya tsentr.
28. FEDOROV, VALERI. (2002) V peryed, k ideologiyi? Nezavisimaya gazeta, February 18.
29. FRIEDMAN, THOMAS L. (1999) The Lexus and the Olive Tree. New York: Farrar, Straus & Giroux.
30. FUKUYAMA, FRANCIS. (1989) The End of History? The National Interest 16 (Summer):3-16.
31. FUKUYAMA, FRANCIS. (1992) Capitalism and Democracy. Journal of Democracy 3(3):100-110.
32. FUKUYAMA, FRANCIS. (1993) The Modernizing Imperative: The USSR as an Ordinary Country. The National Interest 20(Spring):10-18.
33. FUKUYAMA, FRANCIS. (1995) Trust: The Social Virtue and the Creation of Prosperity. New York: Free Press.
34. FUKUYAMA, FRANCIS. (2002) Their Target: The Modern World. Newsweek, January 14. See also www.msnbc.com/news.
35. FUREDI, FRANK. (1994) The Enthronement of Low Expectations: Fukuyama's Ideological Compromise for Our Time. In Has History Ended? Fukuyama, Mars, Modernity, edited by Christopher Bertram and Andrew Chitty. London: Avebury.
36. GELLNER, ERNEST. (1983) Nations and Nationalism. Oxford: Blackwell.
37. GLAZYEV, SERGEI. (1997) Genotszid: Rossiya i novyi mirovoi poryadok. Moscow: Publisher Unknown.
38. GOLDSTEIN, JUDITH, AND ROBERT O. KEOHANE. (1993) Ideas and Foreign Policy: Beliefs, Institutions, and Political Change. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
39. HALL, JOHN. (1996) International Orders. Cambridge: Polity.
40. HARDING, SANDRA. (1998) Is Science Multicultural? Postcolonialism, Feminism, and Epistemologies. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
41. HEGEL, GEORG WILHELM FRIEDRICH. (1974) The Essential Writings. New York: Harper & Row.
42. HOFFMANN, STANLEY. (1977) An American Social Science: International Relations. Daedalus 106(3): 41-60.
43. HOLSTI, K. J. (1985) The Dividing Discipline: Hegemony and Diversity in International Theory. Boston: Unwin Hyman.
44. HUNTINGTON, SAMUEL P. (1968) Political Order in Changing Societies. New Haven: Yale University Press.
45. HUNTINGTON, SAMUEL P. (1989) No Exit: The Errors of Endism. The National Interest 17(Fall):3-11.
46. HUNTINGTON, SAMUEL P. (1991) The Third Wave: Democratization in the Late Twentieth Century. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press.
47. HUNTINGTON, SAMUEL P. (1993a) The Clash of Civilizations? Foreign Affairs 72(4):22-49.
48. HUNTINGTON, SAMUEL P. (1993b) If Not Civilizations, What? Paradigms of the Post-Cold War World. Foreign Affairs 72(6):186-189.
49. HUNTINGTON, SAMUEL P. (1996a) The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order. New York: Simon & Schuster.
50. HUNTINGTON, SAMUEL P. (1996b) The West: Unique, Not Universal. Foreign Affairs 75(6):28-46.
51. HUNTINGTON, SAMUEL P. (1997) The Erosion of American National Interests. Foreign Affairs 76(5): 29-42.
52. HUNTINGTON, SAMUEL P. (1999) A Local Front of a Global War. New York Times, December 16:A31.
53. HUNTINGTON, SAMUEL P. (2002) The Age of Muslim Wars. Newsweek, January. See also www.msnbc.com/news/672440.asp.
54. ILYIN, M. V. (1995) Vystupleniye. Polis 1:151-153.
55. INAYATULLAH, NAEEM, AND DAVID L BLANEY. (1996) Knowing Encounters: Beyond Parochialism in International Relations Theory. In The Return of Culture and Identity in IR Theory, edited by Yosef Lapid and Friedrich. Kratochwil. Boulder: Lynne Rienner.
56. JERVIS, ROBERT. (1976) Perception and Misperception in International Politics. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
57. JERVIS, ROBERT. (1992) Hypotheses on Misperception. In International Politics: Enduring Concepts and Contemporary Issues, edited by Robert J. Art and Robert Jervis. New York: Harper Collins.
58. KAHLER, MILES. (1993) International Relations: Still an American Social Science? In Ideas and Ideals: Essays on Politics in Honor of Stanley Hoffmann, edited by Linda B. Miller and Michael J. Smith. Boulder: Westview Press.
59. KAPLAN, MORTON. (1994) Coming Anarchy. Atlantic Monthly 273(2):44-76.
60. KARAGODIN, ANDREI. (1994) Otkroveniya mondialistov. Den' 36, September.
61. KARA-MURZA, ALEKSEI. (2001) Na perekrestke politiki i nauki. Polis 6: www.politstudies.ru/universum/esse/8kmz.html#17.
62. KASPE, SVATOSLAV. (1995) Rossiskaya tsivilizatsiya i ideiyi A. Dzh. Toynbi. Svobodnaya misl' 2:76-83.
63. KHOREV, BORIS. (1996) Rossiyu pribirayut k rukam. Moscow: Paleia.
64. KHOROS, V. G. (1995) Vystupleniye. Polis 1:123-126.
65. KHRUSTALEV, MARK A., AND MARINA M. LEBEDEVA. (1990) Vystupleniye. SshA: Ekonomika, Politika, Ideologiya 6:40-45.
66. KOJEVE, ALEXANDRE. (1969) Introduction to the Readings of Hegel. New York: Basic Books.
67. KORTUNOV, SERGEI. (1998) Imperskoye i natsionalnoye v rossiyskom soznaniyi. Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn' 5:15-27.
68. KORTUNOV, SERGEI. (2002) Stanovleniye novogo myrovogo poryadka. Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn' 6: 77-90.
69. KOVALEV, OLEG. (1997) Russian "Realism": Theory and Policy Preferences. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Delaware.
70. KRASIN, YURI A. (1990) Vzaiomodeistviye obschestvennykh system v tselostnom mire. Voprosy filosofiyi 8:3-9.
71. KRIVOKHIZHA, V. I. (1997) Rossiya v novom mire: vremya resheni. Moscow: Rossiski institut strategicheskikh issledovani.
72. KURGINYAN, SERGEI E. (1991) Tseli i tsennosti. Den' 24, November.
73. KURGINYAN, SERGEI E., B. P. AUTENSHLYUS, P. S. GONCHAROV, YU. V. GROMYKO, I. YU. SUDIYEV, AND V. S OVCHINSKI. (1990) Postperestroyka. Moscow: Politizdat.
74. LEVINE, ROBERT A. (1965) Socialization, Social Structure, and Intersocietal Images. In International Behavior: A Social-Psychological Analysis, edited by Herbert C. Kelman. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
75. LEVINE, ROBERT A., AND DONALD T. CAMPBELL. (1972) Ethnocentrism: Theories of Conflict, Ethnic Attitudes, and Group Behavior, New York: Wiley.
76. LIGHT, MARGOT. (1996) Foreign Policy Thinking. In Internal Factors in Russian Foreign Policy, edited by Neil Malcolm, Alex Pravda, Roy Allison, and Margot Light. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
77. MACFARLANE, NEIL S. (1997) Democratization, Nationalism, and Regional Security in the Southern Caucasus. Government and Opposition 10:399-420.
78. MCCONNELL, CAMPBELL P., AND STANLEY L. BRUE. (2002) Macroeconomics: Principles, Problems, and Policies. 15th edition. Boston: McGraw Hill/Irwin.
79. MEDEVOI, A. (1995) Vystupleniye. Obschestvenniye nauki i souremennost' 4:136-138.
80. MESHKOV, ALEKSEI. (2002) Aktual' niye aspekti vneshnei politiki Rossiyi. Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn' 4:3-16.
81. MIGRANYAN, ANDRANIK. (1994) Rossiya i blizhneye zarubezhiye. Nezavisimaya gazeta, January 12.
82. MILLIKEN, JENNIFER. (2001) Discourse Study: Bringing Rigor to Critical Theory. In Constructing International Relations: The Next Generation, edited by Karen M. Fierke and Knud Erik Jorgensen. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe.
83. MIRSKI, GEORGI. (1994) "Stolknoveniye tsivilizatsi?" -debat na Zapade. Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhdunarodniye otnosheniya 11:65-73.
84. MITROFANOV, ALEKSEI V. (1997) Shagi novoi geopolitiki. Moscow: Publisher Unknown.
85. MURAVCHIK, JOSHUA. (1992) Exporting Democracy: Fulfilling America's Destiny. Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute.
86. NEUMANN, IVER B. (1996) Russia and the Idea of Europe: A Study in Identity and International Relations. London: Routledge.
87. O'HAGAN, JACINTA. (2000) Clash of Civilizations? In Contesting Images of World Politics,. edited by Greg Fry and Jacinta O'Hagan. London: Macmillan Press.
88. OPELLO, WALTER C., JR., AND STEPHEN J. ROSCOW. (1999) The Nation-State and Global Order. Boulder: Lynne Rienner.
89. OREN, IDO. (1996) The Subjectivity of the "Democratic Peace." In Debating the Democratic Peace, edited by Michael, E. Brown, Sean M. Lynn-Jones, and Stephen E. Miller. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
90. PANARIN, ALEKSANDR. (1998) Revansh istoriyi. Moscow: Logos.
91. PATOMAKI, HEIKKI, AND CHRISTER PURSIAINEN. (1999) Western Models and the Russian Idea: Beyond "Inside/Outside" in Discourses on Civil Society. Millennium 28:53-77.
92. PLATTNER, MARC C. (1988) Democracy Outwits the Pessimists. Wall Street Journal, October 12.
93. POSEN, BARRY R. (1993) The Security Dilemma and Ethnic Conflict. Survival 35:27-47.
94. POZDNYAKOV, EL'GIZ A. (1989a) Mirovoi sotsial'nyi progress: mify i real'nost'. Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhhdunarodniye otnosheniya 11:56-62.
95. POZDNYAKOV, EL'GIZ A. (1989b) Natsional'noye i internatsional'noye vo vneshnei politike. Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhhdunarodniye otnosheniya 5:3-13.
96. POZDNYAKOV, EL'GIZ A. (1989c) Vneshniaya i vnutreniaya politika: Paradoks vzaimosvyazi. Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhhdunarodniye otnosheniya 10:41-52.
97. POZDNYAKOV, EL'GIZ A. (1990) Formatsionnyi i tsivilizatsionnyi podkhody i mezhdunarodniye otnosheniya. In SSSR v mirovom soobschestve, edited by Nodar A. Simoniya. Moscow: Progress.
98. PROKHANOV, ALEKSANDR, AND SHAMIL' SULTANOV. (1991) Izmenit'sia, chtoby vizhit.' Den' 6, March.
99. PUTIN, VLADIMIR V. (2001) Speech to the German Parliament, September 25. Available at www.kremlin.ru.
100. PUTIN, VLADIMIR V. (2002) Poslaniye Prezidenta Rossiyskoi Federatsiyi V. V. Putina Federal'nomu Sobraniyu Rossiyskoi Federatsiyi. Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn' 5:3-10.
101. RAJAEE, FARHANG. (2000) Globalization on Trial: The Human Condition and the Information Civilization. Ottawa: KumarianPress.
102. RASHKOWSKI, YE. (1995) Vystupleniye. Polis 1:131-134.
103. RUBENSTEIN, RICHARD E., AND JARLE CROCKER. (1994) Challenging Huntington. Foreign Policy 9(Fall):113-128.
104. RUGGIE, JOHN G. (1998) What Makes the World Hang Together: Neo-Utilitarianism and the Social Constructivist Challenge. International Organization 52:855-885.
105. SAMUILOV, SERGEI M. (1995) Neizbezhno li stolknoveniye tsyvilizatsi? SShA: Ekonomika, Politika, Ideologiya 1:57-66, 2:52-62.
106. SERGOUNIN, ALEXANDER A. (2000) Russian Post-Communist Foreign Policy Thinking at the Cross-Roads: Changing Paradigms. Journal of International Relations and Development 3:216-255.
107. SETON-WATSON, HUGH. (1977) Nations and States. Boulder: Westview Press.
108. SHAKHNAZAROV, GEORGI. (1998) Miroporyadok tsivilizatsi? Pro et Contra 3(4):148-149.
109. SHESTOPAL, ALEKSEI. (1995) Vystupleniye. Obschestvenniye nauki i sovremennost' 4:133-134.
110. SHLAPENTOKH, VLADIMIR. (1998) "Old," "New," and "Post" Liberal Attitudes Towards the West: From Love to Hate. Communist and Post-Communist Studies 31(3):199-216.
111. SIMONIYA, NODAR. (1994) Budet li sledushchaya voina stolknoveniyem tsivilizatsi? Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhdunarodniye otnosheniya 11:76-80.
112. SOGRIN, VLADIMIR. (1996) Zapadnyi liberalizm i rossiyskiye reformy. Svobodnaya misl' 1:32-43.
113. SOROKIN, KONSTANTIN E. (1996) Geopolitika sovremennosti i geostrategiya Rossiyi. Moscow: ROSSPEN.
114. STANKEVICH, SERGEI. (1994) Toward a New "National Idea." In Rethinking Russia's National Interests, edited by Stephen Sestanovich. Washington, DC: Center for International and Strategic Studies.
115. "STOLKNOVENIYE TSIVILIZATSI" PERSPEKTIVY I ALTERNATIVY. (1995) Obschestvenniye nauki i sovremennost' 4:131-142.
116. STRATEGIYA DYLA ROSSIYI. (1992) Nezavisimaya gazeta, August 19.
117. STRATEGIYA DYLA ROSSIYI-2 (1994) Nezavisimaya gazeta, May 27.
118. STRATEGIYA DYLA ROSSIYI: POVESTKA DYLA PREZIDENTA-2000. (2000) Moscow: Sovet po vneshnei i oboronnoi politike, www.svop.edu.
119. TAYLOR, PETER J. (1996) The Way the Modern World Works: World Hegemony to World Impasse. New York: Wiley.
120. TRETYAKOV, VITALI. (2002) Pragmatizm vneshnei politiki Putina. Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn' 5:3-10.
121. "TSIVILIZATSIONNAYA MODEL" MEZHDUNARODNYKH OTNOSHENI I EYE IMPLIKATSIYI. (1995) Polis 1: 121-165.
122. TSYGANKOV, ANDREI P. (1997) From Liberal Internationalism to Revolutionary Expansionism: The Foreign Policy Discourse of Contemporary Russia. Mershon International Studies Review 41:247-268.
123. TSYGANKOV, ANDREI P. (Forthcoming) Whose World Order? Russia's Perception of American Ideas After the Cold War. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press.
124. TSYMBURSKI, VADIM. (1995) Vystupleniye. Polis 1:134-141.
125. TSYMBURSKI, VADIM. (1997) Narodi mezhdu tsivilizatsiyami. Pro et Contra 2(3):154-184.
126. TSYMBURSKI, VADIM. (2001) Eto tvoi posledni geokul'turnyi vybor, Rossiya. Polis: www.politstudies.ru/universum/esse/8kmz.htm#17.
127. URBAN, JOAN BARTH, AND VALERI D. SOLOVEI. (1997) Russia's Communists at the Crossroads. Boulder: Westview Press.
128. UTKIN, ANATOLI. (1997) Konflikt tsivilizatsi? Novaya Rossiya 2:28-34.
129. VAN DER DENNEN, JOHAN M. G. (1987) Ethnocentrism and In-Group/Out-Group Differentiation: A Review and Interpretation of the Literature. In The Sociobiology of Ethnocentrism: Evolutionary Dimensions of Xenophobia, Discrimination, Racism and Nationalism, edited by Vernon Reynolds, Vincent Falgar, and Ian Vine. London: Croom Helm.
130. WAEVER, OLE. (1998) The Sociology of a Not So International Discipline: American and European Developments in International Relations. International Organization 52:687-727.
131. WIARDA, HOWARD J. (1981) The Ethnocentrism of the Social Sciences: Implications for Research and Policy. Review of Politics 43(2):163-197.
132. WIGHT, MARTIN. (1992) International Theory: The Three Traditions. New York: Holmes & Meier.
133. YAVLINSKI, GRIGORI. (2002) Dver'v Yevropu nahoditsya v Vashingtone. Obschaya gazeta, May 16, www.og.ru.
134. YEE, ALBERT S. (1996) The Casual Effects of ideas on Policies. International Organization 50:69-108.
135. ZAMOSHKIN, YURI A. (1990) "Konets istoriyi": ideologizm i realizm. Voprosy filosofiyi 3:148-155.
136. ZLOBIN, N. V. (1995) Vystupleniye. Obschestvenniye nauki i sovremennost' 4:131-133.
137. ZYUGANOV, GENNADI A. (1995) Rossiya i sovremennyi mir. Moscow: Informatsionno-izdatel'skoye agentstvo "Obozrevatel."
138. ZYUGANOV, GENNADI A. (1998) Geografiya pobedi. Moscow: Publisher Unknown.
139. ZYUGANOV, GENNADI A. (2001) Politichecki doklad Sovyeta SKP-KPSS XXXII syezdu. www.kprf.ru/tribuna/dokladckpkhcc.html.