Neural population codes

Current Opinion in Neurobiology

Volumn 13, Issue 2, 2003, Pages 238-249

  Sanger, Terence D ^a  

^a STANFORD UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

BRAIN REGION; CELL POPULATION; MATHEMATICAL COMPUTING; NERVE CELL NETWORK; NERVE CONDUCTION; POISSON DISTRIBUTION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PROBABILITY; REVIEW; SPIKE WAVE; TUNING CURVE;

EID: 0038396152     PISSN: 09594388     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0959-4388(03)00034-5     Document Type: Review

References (80)

1. Zhang K.C., Ginzburg I., McNaughton B.L., Sejnowski T.J. Interpreting neuronal population activity by reconstruction: unified framework with application to hippocampal place cells. J. Neurophysiol. 79:1998;1017-1044.
2. Eliasmith C, Anderson CH: Neural Engineering. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press; 2003.
3. Dayan P, Abbott LF: Theoretical Neuroscience. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press; 2001.
4. Rieke F, Warland D, de Ruyter van Steveninck, Bialek W: Spikes: Exploring the Neural Code. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1997.
5. Maynard E.M., Hatsopoulos N.G., Ojakangas C.L., Acuna B.D., Sanes J.N., Normann R.A., Donoghue J.P. Neuronal interactions improve cortical population coding of movement direction. J. Neurosci. 19:1999;8083-8093.
6. Fetz E.E. Neuroscience: temporal coding in neural populations? Science. 278:1997;1901-1902.
7. deCharms R.C. Information coding in the cortex by independent or coordinated populations. Proc. Natl. Acad Sci. USA. 95:1998;15166-15168.
8. Buonomano D.V., Merzenich M.M. Temporal information transformed into a spatial code by a neural network with realistic properties. Science. 267:1995;1028-1030.
9. Oram M.W., Foldiak P., Perrett D.I., Sengpiel F. The 'Ideal Homunculus': decoding neural population signals. Trends Neurosci. 21:1998;259-265.
10. Wu S., Nakahara H., Amari S. Population coding with correlation and an unfaithful model. Neural. Comput. 13:2001;775-797 The authors show that the assumption of a lack of correlation between spike generators from different cells does not lead to a significant loss of decoding accuracy under reasonable assumptions on the correlations.
11. Chawla D., Lumer E.D., Friston K.J. The relationship between synchronization among neuronal populations and their mean activity levels. Neural. Comput. 11:1999;1389-1411.
12. Panzeri S., Treves A., Schultz S., Rolls E.T. On decoding the responses of a population of neurons from short time windows. Neural. Comput. 11:1999;1553-1577.
13. Cabel D.W., Cisek P., Scott S.H. Neural activity in primary motor cortex related to mechanical loads applied to the shoulder and elbow during a postural task. J. Neurophysiol. 86:2001;2102-2108 This study provides another example of tuning curves that respond to multiple variables, and the complexity of the resulting interactions. In this case, the response to the two variables is a linear superposition of the response to each variable independently.
14. Cisek P., Kalaska J.F. Simultaneous encoding of multiple potential reach directions in dorsal premotor cortex. J. Neurophysiol. 87:2002;1149-1154 Probabilistic and Bayesian models predict that population codes can represent the simultaneous possibility of more than one value of a variable in the form of a probability distribution over x. This study provides a demonstration that cells in the dorsal premotor cortex can simultaneously represent the possibility of two different directions of movement, with subsequent selection of a single direction being made only immediately prior to movement onset. Similar findings occur in the oculomotor system.
15. Hoshi E., Shima K., Tanji J. Task-dependent selectivity of movement-related neuronal activity in the primate prefrontal cortex. J. Neurophysiol. 80:1998;3392-3397.
16. Sergio L.E., Kalaska J.F. Changes in the temporal pattern of primary motor cortex activity in a directional isometric force versus limb movement task. J. Neurophysiol. 80:1998;1577-1583.
17. Zhang J., Riehle A., Requin J., Kornblum S. Dynamics of single neuron activity in monkey primary motor cortex related to sensorimotor transformation. J. Neurosci. 17:1997;2227-2246.
18. Gandolfo F., Li C., Benda B.J., Schioppa C.P., Bizzi E. Cortical correlates of learning in monkeys adapting to a new dynamical environment. Proc. Natl. Acad Sci. USA. 97:2000;2259-2263.
19. Zemel R.S., Dayan P., Pouget A. Probabilistic interpretation of population codes. Neural. Comput. 10:1998;403-430.
20. Turner R.S., Anderson M.E. Pallidal discharge related to the kinematics of reaching movements in two dimensions. J. Neurophysiol. 77:1997;1051-1074.
21. Lewis J.E., Kristan W.B. Representation of touch location by a population of leech sensory neurons. J. Neurophysiol. 80:1998;2584-2592.
22. Eurich C.W., Wilke S.D. Multidimensional encoding strategy of spiking neurons. Neural. Comput. 12:2000;1519-1529.
23. Scott S.H., Sergio L.E., Kalaska J.F. Reaching movements with similar hand paths but different arm orientations. 2. Activity of individual cells in dorsal premotor cortex and parietal area 5. J. Neurophysiol. 78:1997;2413-2426.
24. Scott S.H., Kalaska J.F. Reaching movements with similar hand paths but different arm orientations. 1. Activity of individual cells in motor cortex. J. Neurophysiol. 77:1997;826-852.
25. Scott S.H. Population vectors and motor cortex: neural coding or epiphenomenon? Nat. Neurosci. 3:2000;307-308.
26. Steinberg O., Donchin O., Gribova A., Cardosa de Oliveira S., Bergman H., Vaadia E. Neuronal populations in primary motor cortex encode bimanual arm movements. Eur. J. Neurosci. 15:2002;1371-1380.
27. Caminiti R., Johnson P.B., Urbano A. Making arm movements within different parts of space: dynamic aspects in the primate motor cortex. J. Neurosci. 10:1990;2039-2058.
28. Ashe J. Force and the motor cortex. Behav. Brain Res. 87:1997;255-269.
29. Ajemian R., Bullock D., Grossberg S. Kinematic coordinates in which motor cortical cells encode movement direction. J. Neurophysiol. 84:2000;2191-2203.
30. Amirikian B., Georgopoulos A.P. Directional tuning profiles of motor cortical cells. Neurosci. Res. 36:2000;73-79.
31. Kakei S., Hoffman D.S., Strick P.L. Muscle and movement representations in the primary motor cortex. Science. 285:1999;2136-2139.
32. Sanger TD: A probability interpretation of neural population coding for movement. In Self-organization, Computational Maps, and Motor Control. Edited by Morasso P, Sanguineti V. North Holland: Elsevier Science; 1997:75-116.
33. Andersen R.A., Essick G.K., Siegel R.M. Encoding of spatial location by posterior parietal neurons. Science. 230:1985;456-458.
34. Schwartz A.B., Taylor D.M., Tillery S.I.H. Extraction algorithms for cortical control of arm prosthetics. Curr. Opin. Neurobiol. 11:2001;701-707.
35. Wessberg J., Stambaugh C.R., Kralik J.D., Beck P.D., Laubach M., Chapin J.K., Kim J., Biggs S.J., Srinivasan M.A., Nicolelis M.A. Real-time prediction of hand trajectory by ensembles of cortical neurons in primates. Nature. 408:2000;361-365.
36. Sanger T.D. Probability density estimation for the interpretation of neural population codes. J. Neurophysiol. 76:1996;2790-2793.
37. Sanger T.D. Probability density methods for smooth function approximation and learning in populations of tuned spiking neurons. Neural. Comput. 10:1998;1567-1586.
38. Salinas E., Abbott L.F. Vector reconstruction from firing rate. J. Comput. Neurosci. 1:1994;89-108.
39. Moran D.W., Schwartz A.B. Motor cortical activity during drawing movements: population representation during spiral tracing. J. Neurophysiol. 82:1999;2693-2704.
40. Moran D.W., Schwartz A.B. Motor cortical representation of speed and direction during reaching. J. Neurophysiol. 82:1999;2676-2692.
41. Georgopoulos A.P., Kettner R.E., Schwartz A.B. Primate motor cortex and free arm movements to visual targets in three-dimensional space II. Coding of the direction of arm movement by a neural population. J. Neurosci. 8:1988;2928-2937.
42. Schwartz A.B., Kettner R.E., Georgopoulos A.P. Primate motor cortex and free arm movements to visual targets in three-dimensional space I. Relation between single cell discharge and direction of movement. J. Neurosci. 8:1988;2913-2927.
43. Scott S.H., Gribble P.L., Graham K.M., Cabel D.W. Dissociation between hand motion and population vectors from neural activity in motor cortex. Nature. 413:2001;161-165 The population vector for cells in primary motor cortex is shown to be a poor predictor of hand movement direction due to lack of uniformity in the distribution of preferred tuning directions, as predicted by theoretical analyses [44,45].
44. Mussa-Ivaldi S. Do neurons in the motor cortex encode movement direction? An alternative hypothesis. Neurosci. Lett. 91:1988;106-111.
45. Sanger T.D. Theoretical considerations for the analysis of population coding in motor cortex. Neural. Comput. 6:1994;12-21.
46. Lin S.M., Si J., Schwartz A.B. Self-organization of firing activities in monkey's motor cortex: trajectory computation from spike signals. Neural. Comput. 9:1997;607-621.
47. Bergenheim M., RibotCiscar E., Roll J.P. Proprioceptive population coding of two-dimensional limb movements in humans: I. Muscle spindle feedback during spatially oriented movements. Exp. Brain Res. 134:2000;301-310.
48. Roll J.P., Bergenheim M., RibotCiscar E. Proprioceptive population coding of two-dimensional limb movements in humans: II. Muscle-spindle feedback during 'drawing-like' movements. Exp. Brain Res. 134:2000;311-321.
49. Rolls E.T., Treves A., Tovee M.J. The representational capacity of the distributed encoding of information provided by populations of neurons in primate temporal visual cortex. Exp. Brain Res. 114:1997;149-162.
50. Brunel N., Nadal J.P. Mutual information; Fisher information; and population coding. Neural. Comput. 10:1998;1731-1757.
51. Deneve S., Latham P.E., Pouget A. Reading population codes: a neural implementation of ideal observers. Nat. Neurosci. 2:1999;740-745.
52. Pouget A., Zhang K., Deneve S., Latham P.E. Statistically efficient estimation using population coding. Neural. Comput. 10:1998;373-401.
53. Snippe H.P. Parameter extraction from population codes: a critical assessment. Neural. Comput. 8:1996;511-529.
54. Brown E.N., Frank L.M., Tang D., Quirk M.C., Wilson M.A. A statistical paradigm for neural spike train decoding applied to position prediction from ensemble firing patterns of rat hippocampal place cells. J. Neurosci. 18:1998;7411-7425.
55. Twum-Danso N., Brockett R. Trajectory estimation from place cell data. Neural. Networks. 14:2001;835-844 This elegant mathematical analysis extends Bayesian estimation methods to time-varying systems using the theory of stochastic differential equations for diffusion processes. The solid mathematical basis provides the ability to relate estimation methods to linear techniques such as the Kalman filter, and it will provide the background for extending optimal population decoding to trajectories in time-varying systems.
56. Deneve S., Latham P.E., Pouget A. Efficient computation and cue integration with noisy population codes. Nat. Neurosci. 4:2001;826-831.
57. Shen L.M., Alexander G.E. Neural correlates of a spatial sensory-to-motor transformation in primary motor cortex. J. Neurophysiol. 77:1997;1171-1194.
58. Baraduc P., Guigon E., Burnod Y. Recoding arm position to learn visuomotor transformations. Cereb. Cortex. 11:2001;906-917 A computational neural network model is presented that combines information on current position and target of a movement by multiplying the two values together. An adaptive network then learns to take the combined population information and create a new population that represents the appropriate motor command. This is a concrete example of combining multiple input populations to produce an output population with desired behavior.
59. Burnod Y., Baraduc P., Battaglia-Mayer A., Guigon E., Koechlin E., Ferraina S., Lacquaniti F., Caminiti R. Parieto-frontal coding of reaching: an integrated framework. Exp. Brain Res. 129:1999;325-346.
60. Fukushima K., Yamanobe T., Shinmei Y., Fukushima J., Kurkin S., Peterson B.W. Coding of smooth eye movements in three-dimensional space by frontal cortex. Nature. 419:2002;157-162 The authors show that neurons in the frontal eye field respond to both lateral motion and motion in depth, thereby coding 3D movement. This is an example of coding of multiple co-ordinates by the same population, and the authors propose that it may be helpful for controlling eye movements that are related to three-dimensional movements of the hand in space.
61. Sanger T.D. Optimal hidden units for two-layer nonlinear feedforward neural networks. Int. J. Pattern Recogn. 5:1991;545-561.
62. Powell MJD: Radial basis functions for multivariable interpolation: a review. In Algorithms for Approximation. Edited by Mason JC, Cox MG. Oxford: Clarendon Press; 1987:143-167.
63. Broomhead D.S., Lowe D. Multivariable functional interpolation and adaptive networks. Complex Systems. 2:1988;321-355.
64. Klopfenstein RW, Sverdlove R: Approximation by uniformly spaced Gaussian functions. In Approximation Theory IV. Edited by Chui CK, Schumaker LL, Ward JD. New York: Academic Press; 1983:575-580.
65. Baraduc P., Guigon E. Population computation of vectorial transformations. Neural. Comput. 14:2002;845-871 This investigation of the representational capacity of populations concludes that cosine tuning is appropriate if preferred directions are nonuniformly distributed, but that other forms of tuning may be appropriate if preferred directions are uniformly distributed.
66. Sanger T.D. A tree-structured algorithm for reducing computation in networks with separable basis functions. Neural. Comput. 3:1991;67-78.
67. Sanger T.D. A tree-structured adaptive network for function approximation in high dimensional spaces. IEEE Trans. Neural Networks. 2:1991;285-293.
68. Sanger TD, Sutton R, Matheus C: Iterative construction of sparse polynomial approximations. In Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems. Moody JE, Hanson SJ, Lippmann RP. San Mateo: Morgan Kaufmann; 1992.
69. Pouget A., Deneve S., Ducom J.-C. Narrow versus wide tuning curves: what's best for a population code? Neural. Comput. 11:1999;85-90.
70. Zhang K., Sejnowski T. Neuronal tuning: to sharpen or broaden? Neural. Comput. 11:1999;75-84.
71. Carreira-Perpinan M.A., Goodhill G.J. Are visual cortex maps optimized for coverage? Neural. Comput. 14:2002;1545-1560 It has been proposed that a population can be considered optimal for coding a particular representation if any small change in the population would worsen the quality of the coding. The authors argue that such methods do not provide adequate evidence for optimality of a population.
72. Reina G.A., Moran D.W., Schwartz A.B. On the relationship between joint angular velocity and motor cortical discharge during reaching. J. Neurophysiol. 85:2001;2576-2589 This paper follows in the long tradition of using linear correlation based methods in an attempt to determine which of several co-ordinate systems is most closely related to a neural representation. The authors compare whether joint angles or hand positions in 3D space are better linear predictors of cell firing in motor cortex, and whether population vectors based on joint angles or hand positions are better predictors of the actual motion trajectories. They found that both coordinate systems were well correlated, but the joint angles that were more closely linked to hand position were better predictors of cell firing than those that were less linked to hand position. Although this might seem to imply that the motor cortical representation has been optimized for representing hand position, it is difficult to draw such conclusions from a purely linear analysis unless we assume that the brain itself is limited to linear analytic techniques. A Bayesian or information-theoretic analysis might well lead to very different conclusions.
73. Crammond D.J., Kalaska J.F. Prior information in motor and premotor cortex: activity during the delay period and effect on pre-movement activity. J. Neurophysiol. 84:2000;986-1005.
74. Gomez J.E., Fu Q., Flament D., Ebner T.J. Representation of accuracy in the dorsal premotor cortex. Eur. J. Neurosci. 12:2000;3748-3760.
75. Wu S., Amari S., Nakahara H. Population coding and decoding in a neural field: a computational study. Neural. Comput. 14:2002;999-1026 This study investigates the effect on Fisher information of introducing local correlations into the spike generators of a population of cells. The information increases both for very low and very high correlations. The authors point out some pitfalls of using maximum-likelihood estimators in this type of population.
76. Abbott L.F., Dayan P. The effect of correlated variability on the accuracy of a population code. Neural. Comput. 11:1999;91-101.
77. Wilke S.D., Eurich C.W. Representational accuracy of stochastic neural populations. Neural. Comput. 14:2002;155-189 The authors investigate the effect of the dimensionality of the input data x on the Fisher information for populations that have Poisson-type noise, additive noise, or local correlations in spike generators. Additive noise has lower reconstruction error for high input dimensionality, but it leads to worse reconstruction for large populations when there are local correlations. They derive the important result that populations with highly varied tuning curves may have better representational properties than populations in which all tuning curves share a similar shape.
78. Poliakov A.V., Schieber M.H. Limited functional grouping of neurons in the motor cortex hand area during individuated finger movements: a cluster analysis. J. Neurophysiol. 82:1999;3488-3505.
79. Hubel D.H., Wiesel T.N. Functional architecture of the macaque monkey visual cortex. Proc. R Soc. Lond. Ser. B. 198:1977;1-59.
80. Todorov E. Cosine tuning minimizes motor errors. Neural. Comput. 14:2002;1233-1260 This is one of a series of papers in which the authors examine the role of signal-dependent noise and predict that the properties of tuning curves may be determined by an attempt to minimize the effects of noise.