Self-reports of pain intensity and direct observations of pain behavior: When are they correlated?

Pain

Volumn 102, Issue 1-2, 2003, Pages 109-124

  Labus, Jennifer S ^a   Keefe, Francis J ^b   Jensen, Mark P ^c,d  

^a OHIO UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b DUKE UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER   (United States)

^c UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^d UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON MEDICAL CENTER   (United States)

Author keywords

Pain behavior observation; Pain intensity self report; Validity

Indexed keywords

ADULT; ARTICLE; BEHAVIOR; CHILD; CHRONIC PAIN; CLINICAL ARTICLE; CONTROLLED STUDY; CORRELATION ANALYSIS; DATA ANALYSIS; FACIAL EXPRESSION; HUMAN; LOW BACK PAIN; MEASUREMENT; OBSERVATION; PAIN ASSESSMENT; PAIN THRESHOLD; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RIGIDITY; SELF REPORT; STATISTICAL SIGNIFICANCE; TASK PERFORMANCE; TRAINING;

EID: 0037334354     PISSN: 03043959     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/s0304-3959(02)00354-8     Document Type: Article

References (71)

1. Ahles T., Coombs D., Jensen L., Stukel T., Maurer L., Keefe F. Development of a behavioral observation technique for the assessment of pain behaviors in cancer patients. Behav Ther. 21:1990;449-460.
2. Baumstark K., Buckelew S., Sher K., Beck N., Buescher K., Hewett J., Crews T. Pain behavior predictors among fibromyalgia patients. Pain. 55:1993;339-346.
3. Beyer J., McGrath P., Berde C. Discordance between self-report and behavioral measures in children aged 3 - 7 years after surgery. J Pain Symptom Manage. 5:1990;350-356.
4. Breau L., McGrath P., Craig K., Santor D., Cassidy L., Reid G. Facial expression of children receiving immunizations: a principal components analysis of the child facial coding system. Clin J Pain. 17:2001;178-186.
5. Buckelew S., Parker J., Keefe F., Deuser W., Crews T., Conway R., Kay D., Hewett J. Self-efficacy and pain behavior among subjects with fibromyalgia. Pain. 59:1994;377-384.
6. Dirks J., Wunder J., Kinsman R., McElhinney J., Jones N. A pain rating scale and a pain behavior checklist for clinical use: development, norms, and the consistency score. Psychother Psychosom. 59:1993;41-49.
7. Feuerstein M., Greenwald M., Gamache M., Papciak A., Cook E. The Pain Behavior Scale: modification and validation for outpatient use. J Psychopathol Behav Assess. 7:1985;301-315.
8. Goodenough B., Addicoat L., Champion G., McInerney M., Young B., Juniper K., Ziegler J.B. Pain in 4 - 6-year-old children receiving intramuscular injections: a comparison of the Faces Pain Scale with other self-reported and behavioral measures. Clin J Pain. 13:1997;60-73.
9. Gramling S., Elliot T. Efficient pain assessment in clinical settings. Behav Res Ther. 30:1992;71-73.
10. Hadjistavropolous T., LaChapelle D., MacLeod F., Snider B., Craig K. Measuring movement-exacerbated pain in cognitively impaired frail elders. Clin J Pain. 16:2000;54-63.
11. Jensen I., Bradley L., Linton S. Validation of an observation method of pain assessment in non-chronic back pain. Pain. 39:1989;267-274.
12. Keefe F., Block A. Development of an observation method for assessing pain behavior in chronic low back pain patients. Behav Ther. 13:1982;363-375.
13. Keefe F., Wilkins R., Cook W. Direct observation of pain behavior in low back pain patients during physical examination. Pain. 20:1984;59-68.
14. Keefe F.J., Bradley L.A., Crisson J.E. Behavioral assessment of low back pain: identification of pain behavior subgroups. Pain. 40:1990;153-160.
15. Kleinke C., Spangler A.J. Psychometric analysis of the audiovisual taxonomy for assessing pain behavior in chronic back-pain patients. J Behav Med. 11:1987;83-93.
16. Koho P., Aho S., Watson P., Hurri H. Assessment of chronic pain behaviour: reliability of the method and its relationship with perceived disability, physical impairment and function. J Rehab Med. 33:2001;128-132.
17. LeResche L., Dworkin S. Facial expressions of pain and emotions in chronic TMD patients. Pain. 35:1988;71-78.
18. LeResche L., Dworkin S., Wilson L., Ehrlich K. Effect of temporomandibular disorder pain duration on facial expressions and verbal report of pain. Pain. 51:1992;289-295.
19. Lindstrom I., Ohlund C., Nachemson A. Physical performance, pain, pain behavior and subjective disability in patients with subacute low back pain. Scand J Rehab Med. 27:1995;153-160.
20. Manne S., Jacobsen P., Redd W. Assessment of acute pediatric pain: do child self-report and nurse ratings measure the same phenomenon? Pain. 48:1992;45-52.
21. McDaniel L., Anderson K., Bradley L., Young L., Turner R., Agudelo C., Keefe F. Development of an observation method for assessing pain behavior in rheumatoid arthritis patients. Pain. 24:1986;165-184.
22. Ohlund C., Lindstrom I., Arekoug B., Eek C., Peterson L., Nachemson A. Pain behavior in industrial subacute low back pain. Part I. Reliability: concurrent and predictive validity of pain behavior assessments. Pain. 58:1994;201-209.
23. Parker J., Charles C., Smarr K., McClure K., Stucky-Ropp R., Anderson S., Walker S. Relationship of pain behavior to disease activity and health status in rheumatoid arthritis. Arthritis Care Res. 6:1993;71-77.
24. Prkachin K., Mercer S. Pain expression in patients with shoulder pathology: validity, properties and relationship to sickness impact. Pain. 39:1989;257-265.
25. Prkachin K., Berzins S., Mercer S. Encoding and decoding of pain expressions: a judgement study. Pain. 58:1994;253-258.
26. Prkachin K, Schultz I, Berkowitz J, Hughes E, Hunt D. Assessing pain behaviour in real time: concurrent validity and examiner sensitivity, submitted for publication, 2002.
27. Richards J., Nepomuceno C., Riles M., Suer Z. Assessing pain behavior: the UAB Pain Behavior Scale. Pain. 14:1982;393-398.
28. Romano J., Syrjala K., Levy R., Turner J., Evans P., Keefe F. Overt pain behaviors: relationship to patient functioning and treatment outcome. Behav Ther. 19:1988;191-201.
29. Romano J., Turner J., Friedman L., Bulcroft R., Jensen M., Hops H. Observational assessment of chronic pain: patient-spouse behavioral interactions. Behav Ther. 22:1991;549-567.
30. Teskee K., Daut R., Cleeland C. Relationships between nurses' observations and patients' self-reports of pain. Pain. 16:1983;289-296.
31. Turk D.C., Wack J.T., Kerns R.D. An empirical evaluation of the 'pain behavior' construct. J Behav Med. 8:1985;119-130.
32. Tyler D., Tu A., Douthit J., Chapman C. Toward validation of pain measurement tools for children: a pilot study. Pain. 52:1983;301-309.
33. Wilkie D., Keefe F., Dodd M., Copp L. Behavior of patients with lung cancer: description and associations with oncologic and pain variables. Pain. 51:1992;231-240.
34. Ahles T.A., Ruckdeschel J.C., Blanchard J.B. Cancer-related pain - assessment with visual analogue scales. J Psychosom Res. 28:1984;121-124.
35. Begg C. Publication bias. Cooper H., Hedges L. The handbook of research synthesis. 1994;399-410 Russell Sage, New York.
36. Bornstein R. Criterion validity of objective and projective dependency tests: a meta-analytic assessment of behavioral prediction. Psychol Assess. 11:1999;48-57.
37. Chung J.W., Wong T.K., Yang J.C. A preliminary report on the Chinese Cancer Pain Assessment Tool (CCPAT): reliability and validity. Acta Anaesthesiol Sin. 39:2001;33-40.
38. Cinciripini P.M., Floreen A. An evaluation of a behavioral program for chronic pain. J Beh Med. 5:1982;375-379.
39. Cohen J. Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. 1988;Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, NJ.
40. Craig K., Prkachin K., Grunau R. The facial expression of pain. Turk D., Melzack R. Handbook of pain assessment. 1992;257-276 Guilford, New York.
41. Follick M., Ahern D., Aberger E. Development of an audiovisual taxonomy of pain behavior: reliability and discriminate validity. Health Psychol. 4:1985;555-568.
42. Fordyce W. Behavioral methods for chronic pain and illness. 1976;The C.V. Mosby Company, St. Louis, MO.
43. Friedman L. Estimators of random Effects Variance Components in Meta-analysis. J Ed Behav Stat. 25(1):2000;1-12.
44. Greenhouse J., Iyengar S. Sensitivity analysis and diagnostics. Cooper H., Hedges L. The handbook of research synthesis. 1994;383-398 Russell Sage, New York.
45. Hadjistavropolous T., Craig K.D. A theoretical framework for understanding self-report and observational measures of pain: a communications model. Behav Res Ther. 40:2002;551-570.
46. Hedges L. Fixed effects models. Cooper H., Hedges L. The handbook of research synthesis. 1994;285-299 Russell Sage, New York.
47. Hedges L., Olkin I. Statistical methods for meta-analysis. 1985;Academic Press, Orlando, FL.
48. Hedges L., Vevea J.L. Fixed- and random-effects models in meta-analysis. Psychol Methods. 3:1998;486-504.
49. Hunter J., Schmidt F. Fixed effects versus random effects meta-analysis models: implications for cumulative research knowledge. Int J Selec Assess. 8:2000;275-292.
50. Jensen M.P., Karoly P. Self-report scales and procedures for assessing pain in adults. Turk D.C., Melzack R. Handbook of pain assessment. 1992;131-135 Guildford Press, New York.
51. Jensen M., Karoly P., Braver S. The measurement of clinical pain intensity: a comparison of six methods. Pain. 27:1986;117-126.
52. Keefe F. Behavioral measurement of pain. Chapman C., Loeser J. Issues in ain measurement. 1989;405-424 Raven, New York.
53. Keefe F., Block A. Development of an observation method for assessing pain behavior in chronic low back pain patients. Behav Ther. 13:1982;363-375.
54. Keefe F., Dunsmore J. Pain behavior: concepts and controversies. Am Pain Soc J. 1992;92-100.
55. Kremer E.F., Atkinson J.H. Jr, Ignlezi R.J. Measurement of pain: patient preference does not confound measurement. Pain. 10:1981;241-248.
56. Kremer E.F., Atkinson J.H. Jr, Ignelzi R.J. Pain measurement: the affective dimensional measure of the McGill Pain Questionnaire with a cancer pain population. Pain. 12:1982;153-163.
57. Lefebvre J.C., Keefe F.J. Memory for pain: the relationship of catastrophizing to the recall of daily rheumatoid arthritis pain. Clin J Pain. 18:2002;56-63.
58. Martinussen M., Bjornstad J. Meta-analysis calculations based on independent and non-independent cases. Educ Psychol Meas. 59:1999;928-950.
59. Paice J., Cohen F. Validity of a verbally administered numeric rating scale to measure cancer pain intensity. Cancer Nurs. 20:1997;88-93.
60. Petitti D. Approaches to heterogeneity in meta-analysis. Stat Med. 20:2001;3625-3633.
61. Richards J., Nepomuceno C., Riles M., Suer Z. Assessing pain behavior: The UAB Pain Behavior Scale. Pain. 9:1982;393-398.
62. Romano J., Turner J., Friedman L., Bulcroft R., Jensen M., Hops H. Observational assessment of chronic pain: patient-spouse behavioral interactions. Behav Ther. 22:1991;549-567.
63. Rosenthal R. Parametric measures of effect size. Cooper H., Hedges L. The handbook of research synthesis. 1994;231-244 Russell Sage, New York.
64. Sanders S. Automated versus self-monitoring of 'up-time' I chronic low-back pain patients: a comparative study. Pain. 15:1983;399-405.
65. Sanders M., Morrison M., Rebgetz M., Bor W., Dadds M., Shepherd R. Behavioural treatment of childhood recurrent abdominal pain: relationships between pain, children's psychological characteristics and family functioning. Behav Change. 7:1990;16-24.
66. Shadish W., Haddock C. Combining estimates of effect size. Cooper H., Hedges L. The handbook of research synthesis. 1994;261-281 Russell Sage, New York.
67. Strube M. Combining and comparing significance levels from non-independent hypothesis tests. Psychol Bull. 97:1985;334-341.
68. Tracz S., Elmore P., Pohlmann J. Correlational meta-analysis: Independent and non-independent cases. Educ Psychol Meas. 52:1992;879-888.
69. Vlaeyen J., Pernot D., Kole-Snijders M., Schuerman J., Van Eek H., Groenman N. Assessment of the components of observed chronic pain behavior: the Checklist for Interpersonal Pain Behavior (CHIP). Pain. 43:1990;337-347.
70. Wilkie D., Lovejoy N., Dodd M., Tesler M. Cancer pain intensity measurement: concurrent validity of three tools - Finger dynamometer. Pain Intensity Number Scale, Visual Analogue Scale. Hosp J. 6:1990;1-13.
71. Wilkie D.J., Keefe F.J., Dodd M.J., Copp L.A. Behavior of patients with lung cancer: description and associations with oncologic and pain variables. Pain. 51:1992;231-240.