Comparing and evaluating alternative (in vitro) tests on their ability to predict the Draize maximum average score

Toxicology in Vitro

Volumn 13, Issue 1, 1999, Pages 45-72

  Lordo, R A ^a   Feder, P I ^a   Gettings, S D ^b  

^a BATTELLE MEMORIAL INSTITUTE   (United States)

^b and Fragrance Association   (United States)

Author keywords

Alternatives; Draize eye irritation test; In vitro; Interval widths; Maximum average score (MAS); Prediction intervals; Regression analyses; Statistical analyses; Validation; Variability

Indexed keywords

COSMETIC;

ANIMAL EXPERIMENT; ARTICLE; DIAGNOSTIC VALUE; EYE IRRITATION; EYE TOXICITY; NONHUMAN; SCORING SYSTEM; STATISTICAL ANALYSIS; TETRAHYMENA;

EID: 0033068088     PISSN: 08872333     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0887-2333(98)00062-9     Document Type: Article

References (21)

1. Balls M., Blaauboer B., Brusick D., Frazier J., Lamb D., Pemberton M., Reinhardt C., Roberfroid M., Rosenkranz H., Schmid B., Spielmann H., Stammati A-L., Walum E. Report and recommendations of the CAAT/ERGATT workshop on the validation of toxicity test procedures. ATLA. 18:1990;313-337.
2. Balls M., Blaauboer B., Fentem J. H., Bruner L., Combes R. D., Ekwall B., Fielder R. J., Guillouzo A., Lewis R. W., Lovell D. P., Reinhardt C. A., Repetto G., Sladowski D., Spielmann H., Zucco F. Practical aspects of the validation of toxicity test procedures. The report and recommendations of ECVAM Workshop 5. ATLA. 23:1995;129-147.
3. Balls M., Botham P. A., Bruner L. H., Spielmann H. The EC/HO international validation study on alternatives to the Draize eye irritation test. Toxicology in Vitro. 9:1995;871-929.
4. Bruner L., Carr G., Chamberlain M., Curren R. No prediction model, no validation study. ATLA. 24:1996;139-142.
5. Bruner L. H., Carr G. J., Chamberlain M., Curren R. D. Validation of alternative methods for toxicity testing. Toxicology in Vitro. 10:1996;479-501.
6. Curren R. D., Southee J. A., Spielmann H., Liebsch M., Fentem J. H., Balls M. The role of prevalidation in the development, validation, and acceptance of alternative methods. ATLA. 23:1995;211-217.
7. Draize J. H., Woodard G., Calvery H. O. Methods for the study of irritation and toxicity of substances applied topically to the skin and mucous membranes. Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics. 82:1944;377-390.
8. ECETOC (1992) Eye Irritation: Reference Chemicals Data Bank. Technical Report No. 48. European Chemical Industry Ecology and Toxicology Centre, Brussels.
9. Feder P. I., Lordo R. A., DiPasquale L. C., Bagley D., Chudkowski M., Demetrulias J., Hintze K. L., Marenus K. D., Pape W. J. W., Roddy M. T., Schnetzinger R., Silber P. M., Teal J. J., Weise S. L., Gettings S. D. The CTFA Evaluation of Alternatives Program: An evaluation of potential in vitro alternatives to the Draize Primary Eye Irritation Test. (Phase I) Hydroalcoholic formulations; (Part 1) Statistical methods. In Vitro Toxicology. 4:1991;231-246.
10. Feder P., Carr G., Holzhutter H. G., Lovell D., Springer J. Statistical planning and analysis considerations in the evaluation of in vitro alternatives to whole animal use for eye irritation testing. Food and Chemical Toxicology. 35:1997;167-174.
11. Frazier J. M. (1990) OECD Environmental Monograph 36. Scientific Criteria for Validation of In Vitro Toxicity Tests. OECD, Paris.
12. Gettings S. D., McEwen G. N. Jr. Development of Potential Alternatives to the Draize Eye Test: The CTFA Evaluation of Alternatives Program. ATLA. 17:1990;317-324.
13. Gettings S. D., DiPasquale L. C., Bagley D. M., Casterton P. L., Chudkowski M., Curren R. D., Demetrulias J. L., Feder P. I., Galli C. L., Gay R., Glaza S. M., Hintze K. L., Janus J., Kurtz P. J., Lordo R. A., Marenus K. D., Moral J., Muscatiello M. J., Pape W. J. W., Renskers K. J., Roddy M. T., Rozen M. G. The CTFA Evaluation of Alternatives Program: An evaluation of potential in vitro alternatives to the Draize Primary eye irritation test. (Phase II). Oil/water emulsions. Food and Chemical Toxicology. 32:1994;943-976.
14. Gettings S. D., Lordo R. A., Hintze K. L., Bagley D. M., Casterton P. L., Chudkowski M., Curren R. D., Demetrulias J. L., DiPasquale L. C., Earl L. K., Feder P. I., Galli C. L., Gay R., Glaza S. M., Gordon V. C., Janus J., Kurtz P. J., Marenus K. D., Moral J., Pape W. J. W., Renskers K. J., Rheins L. A., Roddy M. T., Rozen M. G., Tedeschi J. P., Zyracki J. The CTFA Evaluation of Alternatives Program: An evaluation of potential in vitro alternatives to the Draize primary eye irritation test. (Phase III). Surfactant-based formulations. Food and Chemical Toxicology. 34:1996;79-117.
15. Gettings S. D., Teal J. J., Bagley D. M., Demetrulias J. L., DiPasquale L. C., Hintze K. L., Rozen M. G., Weise S. L., Chudkowski M., Marenus K. D., Pape J. W., Roddy M. T., Schnetzinger R., Silber P. M., Glaza S. M., Kurtz P. J. The CTFA Evaluation of Alternatives Program: An evaluation of in vitro alternatives to the Draize Primary eye irritation test. (Phase I). Hydro-alcoholic Formulations; (Part 2) Data analysis and biological significance. In Vitro Toxicology. 4:1991;247-288.
16. Holzhutter H. G., Archer G., Dami N., Lovell D. P., Saltelli A., Sjostrom M. Recommendations for the application of biostatistical methods during the development and validation of alternative toxicological methods: ECVAM Biostatistics Task Force Report 1. ATLA. 24:1996;530-551.
17. Holzhutter H. G., Spielmann H. The use of prediction models in validation studies: what should they predict? ATLA. 24:1996;881-884.
18. Kay J. H., Calandra J. C. Interpretation of eye irritation tests. Journal of the Society of Cosmetic Chemists. 12:1962;281-289.
19. Lordo R. A., Feder P. I. and Gettings S. D. (1995) Statistical design and analysis considerations in evaluating in vitro alternatives to the Draize primary eye irritation test. In Proceedings of the Biopharmaceutical Section of the American Statistical Association, pp. 108-113. American Statistical Association, Alexandria, VA.
20. Lovell D. P. Principal component analysis of Draize eye irritation tissue scores from 72 samples of 55 chemicals in the ECETOC data bank. Toxicology in Vitro. 10:1996;609-618.
21. NIEHS (1997) Validation and Regulatory Acceptance of Toxicological Test Methods. A Report of the ad hoc Interagency Coordinating Committee on the Validation of Alternative Methods. NIH Publication No: 97-3981, U.S. Dept. Health and Human Services, National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, Research Triangle Park, NC.