Affective learning - a manifesto

BT Technology Journal

Volumn 22, Issue 4, 2004, Pages 253-269

  Picard, Rosalind W ^a   Papert, Seymour ^a   Bender, Walter ^b   Blumberg, Bruce ^c   Breazeal, Cynthia ^a   Cavallo, David ^a   Machover, Tod ^a   Resnick, Mitchel ^a   Roy, Deb ^a   Strohecker, Carol ^d  

^a Lab's Affective Computing grp ^*

^b MIT MEDIA LAB   (United States)

^c Media Lab

^d Media Lab Europe   (Ireland)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ANIMATION; COGNITIVE SYSTEMS; DECISION MAKING; HUMAN COMPUTER INTERACTION; INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY; INTELLIGENT CONTROL; LEARNING ALGORITHMS; LEARNING SYSTEMS; PROBLEM SOLVING; ROBOT LEARNING; SPEECH RECOGNITION; SYSTEM THEORY;

AFFECTIVE LEARNING; AFFECTIVE STATE INFORMATION; CURIOUS ROBOT; DOPAMINE SYSTEMS; EMOTION EXPRESSION RECOGNITION; EMOTION RECOGNITION; EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE; REASONING ALGORITHM;

ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE;

EID: 8644249082     PISSN: 13583948     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1023/B:BTTJ.0000047603.37042.33     Document Type: Article

References (144)

1. Simon H A: 'Motivational and emotional controls of cognition', in Models of Thought, pp 29-38, Yale University Press, New Haven (1967).
2. Norman D A: 'Twelve issues for cognitive science', in Norman D A (Ed): 'Perspectives on cognitive science', pp 265--295, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ (1981).
3. Isen A M: 'Positive affect and decision making', in Lewis M and Haviland J (Eds): 'Handbook of emotions', Guilford, New York (2000).
4. Lane R, Reiman E M, Ahern G L, Schwartz G E and Davidson R J: 'Neuroanatomical correlates of happiness, sadness and disgust', American Journal of Psychiatry, 154, pp 926-933 (1997).
5. Damasio A R, Grabowski T J, Bechara A, Damasio H, Ponto L L B, Parvizi J and Hichwa R D: 'Subcortical and cortical brain activity during the feeling of self-generated emotions', Nature Neuroscience, 3, pp 1049-1056 (2000).
6. Ashby F G, Isen A M and Turken U: 'A neuropsychological theory of positive affect and its influence on cognition', Psychological Review, 106, No 3, pp 529-550 (1999).
7. Estrada C, Isen A M and Young M J: 'Positive affect influences creative problem solving reported source of practice satisfaction in physicians', Motivation and Emotion, 18, pp 285-299 (1994).
8. Minsky M: 'The Emotional Machine', (2003) - http://web. media. mit.edu/-minsky/
9. Bransford J D, Brown A L and Cocking R R: 'How people learn: brain, mind, experience and school', National Academy Press, Washington, DC (1999).
10. Piaget J: 'Six Etudes de Psychologie', Pub Gonthier, Paris (1971).
11. Vygotsky L: 'Thought and Language', The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA (1962).
12. Vygotsky L: 'Mind in Society: the development of the higher psychological processes', The Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA. Originally published 1930, Oxford University Press, New York (1978).
13. Darwin C: 'The Expression of Emotions in Man and Animals', The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL (reprinted in 1965) (1872).
14. James W: 'Writings 1879-1899', Chapter on Emotion, pp 350- 365, The Library of America (1992) (originally published in 1890 as Principles of Psychology, Holt, NY (1890)).
15. Kleinginna Jr, P R and Kleinginna A M: 'A categorised list of emotion definitions, with suggestions for a consensual definition', Motivation and Emotion, 5, No 4, pp 345-379 (1981).
16. Ortony A, Clore G L and Collins A: 'The Cognitive Structure of Emotions', Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1988).
17. Csikszentmihályi M: 'Flow: The Psychology of Optimal Experience', HarperCollins (1991).
18. Lepper M R and Chabay R W: 'Socialising the intelligent tutor: bringing empathy to computer tutors', in Mandl H and Lesgold A (Eds): 'Learning issues for intelligent tutoring systems', pp 242-257 (1988).
19. Mandler G: 'Mind and Body: Psychology of Emotion and Stress', W W Norton & Co, New York, NY (1984).
20. Kort B, Reilly R and Picard R W: 'An affective model of interplay between emotions and learning: reengineering educational pedagogy-building a learning companion', in Proceedings of International Conference on Advanced Learning Technologies (ICALT 2001), Madison Wisconsin (August 2001).
21. Kort B, Reilly R and Picard R W: 'External representation of learning process and domain knowledge: affective state as a determinate of its structure and function', Workshop on Artificial Intelligence in Education (AI-ED 2001), San Antonio, (May 2001).
22. Vroom V H: Work and Motivation', Wiley, New York (1964).
23. Keller J M: 'Motivational design of instruction', in Reigeluth C M (Ed): 'Instructional Design Theories and Models: an overview of their current status', Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ (1983).
24. Keller E F: 'A feeling for the organism: the life and work of Barbara McClintock', San Francisco, W H Freeman (1983).
25. Kell J M: 'Strategies for stimulating the motivation to learn', Performance and Instruction, 26, No 8, pp 362-632 (1987).
26. Keller J M: 'IMMS: instructional materials motivation survey', Florida State University (1987).
27. Ames C: 'Classrooms: goals, structures, and student motivation', Journal of Educational Psychology, 84, No 3, pp 261-271 (1992).
28. Vail P: 'Emotions: the on/off switch for learning', Modern Learning Press (1994).
29. Bandura A: 'Self-efficacy: toward a unifying theory of behaviour change', Psychological Review, 84, pp 191--215 (1977).
30. Bandura A: 'Social learning theory', Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ (1977).
31. Pajares F: 'Self-efficacy beliefs in academic settings', Review of Educational Research, 66, pp 543-578 (1996).
32. Schunk D H: 'Self-efficacy and achievement behaviours', Educational Psychology Review, 1, pp 173-208 (1989).
33. Zimmerman B J: 'Self-efficacy: an essential motive to learn', Contemporary Educational Psychology, 25, pp 82-91 (2000).
34. Maehr M L: 'Meaning and motivation: toward a theory of personal investment', in Ames R and Ames C (Eds): 'Research on motivation in education', pp 39-73, Academic Press, San Diego, CA (1984).
35. Dweck C S: 'Motivational processes affecting learning', American Psychologist, 41, pp 1040-1048 (1986).
36. Amu C and Archer I 'Achievement goals in the classroom: students' learning strategies and motivation processes', Journal of Educational Psychology, 80, pp 260-267 (1988).
37. Dweck C S and Leggett E L: 'A social-cognitive approach to motivation and personality', Psychological Review, 25, pp 256-273 (1988).
38. Elliott E S and Dweck C I 'Goals: an approach to motivation and achievement', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 141 pp 5-12 (1988).
39. Matsubara Y and Nagamachi M: 'Motivation systems and motivation models for intelligent tutoring', in Frasson C (Ed): Proceedings of the Third International Conference in Intelligent Tutoring Systems, pp 139-147 (1996).
40. De Vicente A and Pain H: 'Motivation diagnosis', in Intelligent Tutoring Systems (1998).
41. Whitelock D and Scanlon E: 'Motivation, media and motion: reviewing a computer supported collaborative learning experience', in Bma P et al (Eds): 'Proceedings of the European Conference', (1996).
42. Keller J M and Keller B H: 'Motivational delivery checklist', Florida State University (1989).
43. Kagan J: Personal communication (2002).
44. Computing Research Association - http://www.cra.org/
45. Fernald A: 'Intonation and communicative intent in mother's speech to infants: Is the melody the message? Child Development, 6O, pp 1497-1510 (1989).
46. Salovey P and Mayer J D: 'Emotional intelligence', Imagination, Cognition and Personality, 9, No 3, pp 185-211 (1990).
47. Goleman D: 'Emotional Intelligence', Bantam Books, NY (1995).
48. Picard R W: 'Affective Computing', The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA (1997).
49. Scherer K R: 'Chapter 10: speech and emotional states', in Darby J K (Ed): 'Speech evaluation in psychiatry', Grune and Stratton Inc (1981).
50. Hansen J: 'Speech under stress', ICASSP'99, Pheonix, Arizona (1999).
51. Ekman P and Friesen W: 'Facial action coding system', Consulting Psychologists Press (1977).
52. Cohn J F, Zlochower A J, Lien J and Kanade T: Automated face analysis by feature point tracking has high concurrent validity with manual FACS coding', Psychophysiology, 36, pp 35-43 (1999).
53. Bartlett M S, Hager J C, Ekman P and Sejnowski T J: 'Measuring facial expressions by computer image analysis', Psychophysiology, 36, pp 253-263 (1999).
54. Donato G, Bartlett S, Hager M, Ekman J C P and Seinowski T: 'Classifying facial actions', IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 21, No 10, pp 974-989 (1999).
55. Tian Y, Kanade T and Cohn J F: 'Recognising action units for facial expression analysis', IEEE Trans Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 23, No 2 (February 2001).
56. Kapoor A and Picard R W: 'Real-time, fully automatic upper facial feature tracking', in Proceedings of the 5th International Conference on Automatic Face and Gesture Recognition 2002, Washington DC (May 2002).
57. Kapoor A and Picard R W: 'A real-time head nod and shake detector', Workshop on Perceptive User Interfaces, Orlando, FL (November 2001).
58. Mota S and Picard R W: 'Automated posture analysis for detecting learner's interest level', 1st IEEE Workshop on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition, CVPR HCI 2003 (2003).
59. Bartlett M S, Littlewort G, Braathen B, Sejnowski T J and Movellan J R: 'A prototype for automatic recognition of spontaneous facial actions', in Becker S and Obermayer K (Eds): 'Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems', The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA (2003).
60. DeSilva L C, Miyasato T and Nakatsu R: 'Facial emotion recognition using multi-model information', Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Information, Communication and Signal Processing, Singapore, pp 397-401 (1997).
61. Huang T S, Chen L S and Tao H: 'Bimodal emotion recognition by man and machine', ATR Workshop on Virtual Communication Environments, Kyoto, Japan (April 1998).
62. Chen L S, Huang T S, Miyasato T and Nakatsu R: 'Multimodal human emotion/expression recognition', in Proceedings of International Conference on Automatic Face and Gesture Recognition, Nara, Japan, IEEE Computer Society (April 1998).
63. Kapoor A, Picard R W and Ivanov Y: 'Probabilistic combination of multiple modalities to detect interest', Proceedings of Int Conf on Pattern Recognition, Cambridge, England (August 2004).
64. Kapoor A, Mota S and Picard R W: 'Towards a learning companion that recognises affect', AAAI Fall Symposium 2001, North Falmouth, MA (November 2001).
65. Conati C: 'Probabilistic assessment of users' emotions in educational games', Applied Artificial Intelligence, 16, Nos 7 and 8, pp 555-575 (2002).
66. Zhou X and Conati C: 'Inferring user goals from personality and behaviour in a causal model of user affect', Intelligent User Interfaces 2003, pp 211-218 (2003).
67. Zhou X and Conati C: 'Modeling students' emotions from cognitive appraisal in educational games', Intelligent Tutoring Systems 2002, pp 944-954 (2002).
68. Sheldon-Biddle E, Malone L and McBride D: 'Objective measurement of student affect to optimise automated instruction', Proceedings of Workshop on Modelling User Attitudes and Affect, User Modeling '03 (2003).
69. Scheirer J, Fernandez R and Picard R W: 'Expression glasses: a wearable device for facial expression recognition', CHI'99 Short Papers, Pittsburgh, PA (1999).
70. Healey J and Picard R W: 'SmartCar: detecting driver stress', Proceedings of ICPR'00, Barcelona, Spain (May 2000).
71. Tekscan: 'Tekscan Body pressure measurement system user's manuar, Tekscan Inc, South Buston, MA USA (1997).
72. Reeves B and Nass C: 'The Media Equation', Center for the Study of Language and Information, Cambridge University Press (1996).
73. Picard R W and Scheirer J: 'The Galvactivator: a glove that senses and communicates skin conductivity', Proceedings from the 9th International Conference on Human-Computer Interaction, New Orleans (August 2001).
74. Dennerlein J T, Becker T, Johnson T, Reynolds C and Picard R W: 'Frustrating computer users increases exposure to physical risk factors', Proceedings of International Ergonomics Association, Seoul, Korea (2003).
75. Bechara A, Damasio H, Tranel D and Damasio A: 'Deciding advantageously before knowing the advantageous strategy', Science, 275, pp 1293-1295 (1997).
76. Hirstine W, Iversen P and Ramachandran V S: 'Autonomic responses of autistic children to people and objects', Proceedings of the Royal Society, London, B, 268, pp 1883- 1888 (April 2001).
77. La France M: 'Posture Mirroring and Rapport', in David M (Ed): 'Interaction rhythms: periodicity in communicative behaviour' Human Sciences Press, New York, NY, pp 279-298 (1982).
78. Liu K and Picard R W: 'Subtle expressivity in a robotic computer', presented at CHI 2003 Workshop on Subtle Expressiveness in Characters and Robots (2003).
79. Neisser U: 'The imitation of man by machine', Science, 39, pp 193-197 (1963).
80. Sutton R and Barto A: 'Reinforcement learning: an introduction', The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA (1998).
81. Shuttleworth S J: 'Cognition, evolution and behaviour', Oxford University Press, New York, NY (1998).
82. Gould J and Gould C: 'The animal mind', W H Freeman, New York, NY (1999).
83. Wilkes G: 'Click and treat training kit', Click and Treat Inc, Mesa, AZ (1995).
84. Marler P: 'Song learning: the interface between behaviour and neuroethology: philosophical transactions', Biological Sciences, 329, No 1253, pp 109-114 (1990).
85. Markham E: 'Constraints children place on word memirigs', Cognitive Science, 14, pp 57-77 (1990).
86. Breazeal C, Edsinger A, Fitzpatrick P and Scassellati B: 'Active vision systems for sociable robots', in Dautenhan K (Ed): 'IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man and Cybernetics', Part A, 31, No 5, pp 443-453 (2001).
87. Feinman S, Roberts D, Hseih K, Sawyer D and Swanson D: 'A critical review of social referencing in infancy', in Feinman S (Ed): 'Social referencing and the social construction of reality in infancy', pp 15-54, Plenum Press, New York (1992).
88. Breazeal C, Hoffman G and Lockerd A: 'Teaching and working with robots as a collaboration', in Proceedings of AAMAS 2004, Columbia NY (2004).
89. Biswas G, Katzlberger T, Bransford J, Schwartz D and TAG-V (the teachable agents group at Vanderbilt): 'Extending Intelligent Learning Environments with Teachable Agents to Enhance Learning', 10th International Conference on Al in Education: AI-ED in the wired and wireless future (Moore J D, Redfield C L and Johnson W L (Eds)), IOS Press, Amsterdam, pp 389-397 (2001).
90. Biswas G, Schwartz D, Bransford J and TAG-V (the teachable agents group at Vanderbilt): 'Technology Support for Complex Problem Solving: From SAD Environments to Al, Smart Machines in Education', in Forbus K D and Feltovich P J (Eds): 'The coming revolution in education technology', AAAI/MIT Press, Menlo Park, CA (2001).
91. Pryor K: 'Clicker Training for Dogs', Sunshine Books Inc, Waltham, MA (1999).
92. Lindsay S R: 'Applied Dog Behaviour and Training', Iowa State University Press, Ames, IA (2000).
93. Blumberg B and Downie M: 'Integrated learning for interactive synthetic characters', Transactions on Graphic, 21, No 3, Proceedings of ACM SIGGRAPH 2002 (2002).
94. Blumberg B: 'D-learning: what learning in dogs tells us about building characters that learn what they ought to learn', in Lakerneyer G and Nebel B (Eds): 'Exploring Artificial Intelligence in the New Millenium', Morgan Kaufman Publishers, San Francisco, CA (2002).
95. Lorenz K and Leyhausen P: 'Motivation of human and animal behaviour: an ethological view', Van Nostrand Reinhold Co, New York, NY (1973).
96. Panksepp J: 'Affective Neuroscience', Oxford University Press (1998).
97. Bull P E: 'Posture and Gesture', International Series in Experimental Social Physchology, Pergamon Press (1987).
98. Hatfield E, Cacioppo J and Rapson R L 'Emotional contagion', New York, Cambridge University Press (1994).
99. Burleson W, Picard R W, Perlin K and Lippincott J: 'A platform for affective agent research', in Proceedings of the AAMAS Workshop on Empathetic Agents, Columbia University, New York, NY (July 2004).
100. Wentzel K: 'Student motivation in middle school: the role of perceived pedagogical caring', Journal of Educational Psychology, 89, No 3, pp 411-419 (1997).
101. Pianta R C: 'Beyond the parent: the role of other adults in children's lives', New Directions in Child Development, 57, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco (1992).
102. Wentzel K and Asher S R: 'Academic lives of neglected, rejected, popular, and controversial children', Child Development, L6, pp 754-763 (1995).
103. Birch S H and Ladd G W: Interpersonal relationships in the school environment and children's early school adjustment: the role of teachers and peers', in Juvonen J and Wentzel K (Eds): 'Social motivation: understanding children's school adjustment', Cambridge University Press, New York (1996).
104. Bickmore T arid Picad R W~Eswblishirig ancl maintaining long- term human-computer relationships', Transactions on Computer Human Interaction, to appear (2004).
105. Csikszentmih′alyi M: 'Finding Flow: the psychology of engagement with everyday life', HarperCollins (1997).
106. Papert S: 'The Children's Machine', Basic Books (1993).
107. Kafai Y and Resnick M (Eds): 'Constructionism in practice: designing, thinking, and learning in a digital world', Mahwah, NJ, Lawrence Erlbaum (1996).
108. Brosterman N: 'Inventing Kindergarten', Harry Abrams Publishing (1997).
109. Resnick M, Berg R and Eisenberg M: 'Beyond black boxes: bringing transparency and aesthetics back to scientific investigation', Journal of the Learning Sciences, 2, No 1, pp 7- 30 (2000).
110. Lave J and Wenger E: 'Situated Learning: legitimate peripheral participation', University Press, Cambridge (1991).
111. Turkle S and Papert S: 'Epistemological pluralism', Signs, 16, No 1, pp 128-157 (1990).
112. Papert S: 'Teaching children to be mathematicians versus teaching about mathematics', International Journal of Mathematics Education in Science and Technology, 3, pp 249- 262(1972).
113. Papert S: 'Mindstorms: Children, Computers, and Powerful Ideas', Basic Books (1980).
114. Abelson H and diSessa A: 'Turtle Geometry', The MIT Press (1980).
115. Austin H: 'A computation theory of physical skill', MIT Artificial Intelligence Laboratory Note AIM-330 (1974).
116. Burton R et al: 'Skiing as a Model of Instruction', in Rogoff B and Lave J (Eds): 'Everyday Cognition: development in social context', Harvard University Press (1984).
117. O'Modhrain S: 'Playing by feel: incorporating haptic feedback into computer-based musical instruments', unpublished PhD Dissertation, Stanford University (2000).
118. Sloane N J A and Wyner A D (Eds): 'Claude Elwood Shannon: Collected Papers', Piscataway, NJ, IEEE Press (1940/1993).
119. Strohecker C: 'Why knot?, unpublished doctoral dissertation, MIT Media Laboratory, Cambridge, MA (1991).
120. Strohecker C: 'Learning about topology and learning about learning', Proceedings A the Second International Conference on the Learning Sciences, Association for the Advancement of Computing in Education (1996).
121. Strohecker C: 'Understanding topological relationships through comparisons of similar knots', AI&Society: Learning with Artifacts, 10, pp 58-69 (1996).
122. Strohecker Q 'Cognitive zoom: from object to path and back again', Spatial Cognition II, pp 1-15 (2000).
123. Cavallo D, Blikstein P, Sipitakiat, Basu A, Camargo A, de Deus Lopes R and Cavallo A: 'The city that we want: generative themes, constructionist technologies and school/social change', in Proceedings of IEEE Technology and Education in Developing Countries 2004, Joennsu, Finland (2004).
124. Cavallo D, Sipitakiat A, Basu A, Bryant S, Welti-Santos L, Maloney J, Chen S, Asmussen E, Solomon C and Ackermann E: 'RoBallet: exploring learning through expression in the arts through constructing in a technologically immersive environment', in Proceedings of International Conference on the Learning Sciences 2004, Los Angeles, California (2004).
125. Cavallo D, Sipitakiat A, Basu A and Bryant S: 'Opening pathways to higher education through engineering projects', in Proceedings of the American Society of Engineering Education 2004, Salt Lake City, Utah (2004).
126. Machover T: 'Toy symphony', Boosey & Hawkes, New York and London (2002/3) - http://www.toysymphony.net
127. Tomaino C: 'How music can reach the silenced brain', Cerebrum: The Dana Forum on Brain Science, 4, No 1, pp 23- 24 (2002).
128. Lim M M et al: 'Ventral striatopallidal oxytocin and vasopresson Vla receptors in the monogamous prairie vole', J Comp Neurol, 468, No 4, pp 555-570 (January 2004).
129. Barsalou L W, Niedenthal P M, Barbey A K and Ruppert J A: 'Social embodiment, in the psychology of learning and motivation: advances in research theory', Ross B H (Ed), 43, Academic Press, Elsevier Science, USA (2003).
130. Minsky M: 'The Society of Mind', Simon & Schuster, New York, NY (1985).
131. Kay A: 'Computer software', Scientific American, 251, No 3, pp 41-47 (September 1984).
132. Winnicott D W: 'Playing and reality', London, Tavistock (1971).
133. Greenberg J R and Mitchell S A: 'Object Relations in Psycho- Analytic Theory', Harvard Press (1983).
134. Resnick M: 'Thinking Like a Toe (and Other Forms of Ecological Thinking', International Journal of Computers for Mathematical Learning, 8, No 1, pp 43-62 (2003).
135. Wilenski U: 'Statistical mechanics for secondary school: The GasLab Modeling Toolkit', International Journal of Computers for Mathematical Learning, 8, No 1, pp 1-41 (2003).
136. Papert S: 'Foreword', Special Issue on Multi-Agent Programming, International Journal of Computers for Mathematical Learning, 8, No 1, (2003).
137. Resnick M: 'Turtles, Termites and Traffic Jams', The MIT Press (1994).
138. Rogoff B: 'Observing sociocultural activity on three planes: participatory appropriation, guided participation and apprencticeship', in Wertsch J V, Rio P D and Alvarez A (Eds): 'Sociocultural Studies of the Mind', Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 139-164 (1995).
139. Papert S: 'An exploration in the space of mathematics educations', International Journal of Computers for Mathematical Learning, 1, No 1, pp 95-123 (1996).
140. Cavallo D: 'Epistemology all the way down', EuroLogo 2003, Polo, Portugal (2003).
141. Cavallo D: 'Emergent design and leaning environments: building on indigenous knowledge', IBM Systems Journal, 39, Nos 3 and 4, pp 768-781 (2000).
142. Smith B, Bender W, Driscoll J, Endter I, Turpeinen M and Quan D: 'Silver stringers and junior journalists: active information producers', IBM Systems Journal, .39, Nos 3 and 4 2000.
143. Monroy-Gomez C: 'eRadio,' MIT SM Thesis (2004).
144. US Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics, The Condition of Education 2000, NCES 2000-62, US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC (2000).